Luke 16:27
Then he said, I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldest send him to my father’s house:
Translations
Then he said, I pray you therefore, father, that you would send him to my father’s house:
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then he said, I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldest send him to my father’s house:
Then he said, I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldst send him to my father's house:
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said, I pray thee therefore, father, that thou wouldest send him to my father’s house;
'And he said, I pray thee, then, father, that thou mayest send him to the house of my father,
And he said, I beseech thee then, father, that thou wouldest send him to the house of my father,
But he said—I request thee then, father, that thou wouldst send him unto my father’s house,—
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
‘ Then I beg you, father,’ he said, ‘ send Lazarus to my father’s house,
“ He said, ‘ I ask you therefore, father, that you would send him to my father’s house—
And he said, Father, it is my request that you will send him to my father's house;
Then he said, I pray thee therfore, father, that thou wouldest sende him to my fathers house,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And he said: Then, father, I beseech thee, that thou wouldst send him to my father’s house, for I have five brethren,
Cross-references
- Luke 16:31
And he said unto him, If they hear not Moses and the prophets, neither will they be persuaded, though one rose from the dead.
Those who reject Scripture will not be persuaded even by a resurrection.
- Luke 16:20-21
And there was a certain beggar named Lazarus, which was laid at his gate, full of sores,
Lazarus begging at the rich man’s gate depicts severe poverty and neglect.
- Luke 16:1-13
And he said also unto his disciples, There was a certain rich man, which had a steward; and the same was accused unto him that he had wasted his goods.
The preceding parable teaches faithful use of earthly wealth and preparation for the future.
- John 12:10-11
But the chief priests consulted that they might put Lazarus also to death;
Lazarus’s raising failed to persuade Jesus’ enemies, who planned to kill him.
- Luke 16:19
There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day:
Identifies the rich man by his former purple and linen.
- Luke 15:11-32
And he said, A certain man had two sons:
The parable illustrates repentance and restoration after the preceding parables.
- Luke 16:22-23
And it came to pass, that the beggar died, and was carried by the angels into Abraham’s bosom: the rich man also died, and was buried;
The account describes Hades and Abraham’s bosom.
- John 11:43-44
And when he thus had spoken, he cried with a loud voice, Lazarus, come forth.
Lazarus’s resurrection testified, yet the Jewish leaders rejected the evidence.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
37 sources
The verse is the tormented rich man's too-late plea for Abraham to send Lazarus back to his father's house to warn his five brothers so they will not come to the same place of suffering.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4 It is made after a life spent pleasing himself and neglecting the suffering poor at his gate, with belated concern for brothers still living as he had lived.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21COL 261.21T 539.2–540.1COL 264.1 The plea rests on the claim that he had not been fairly warned and that a messenger from the dead would bring repentance.Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 The answer it receives is that Moses and the prophets give sufficient light for duty, and those who refuse that light will not be persuaded even by one rising from the dead.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4 Probation closes at death, so self-pleasing in this life fixes an impassable gulf that cannot afterward be crossed.COL 260.1ST Jun 1, 1915Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36
The Plea's Setting
The plea is the rich man's too-late request to Abraham to send Lazarus to his father's house to testify to and warn his five brothers so they will not also come to that place of torment.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4COL 264.1ST Jun 1, 1915 It is made when he is unable to help himself and at last realizes his folly in spending his life pleasing himself with no provision for eternity.COL 264.1ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 It shows belated concern for his brothers who are going on as he had gone, living to please themselves, after he had formed a selfish character by neglecting those in need.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21COL 264.1
The setting is the rich man's gate, where Lazarus in severe need, abject poverty, loathsome suffering and sores was brought to the notice of one entrusted with wealth, that he might receive help and sympathy.COL 261.21T 539.2–540.1COL 242Lt 207, 1899, par. 714MR 57.3 The rich man, clothed in purple and fine linen and faring sumptuously every day, had the means to relieve him but lived for himself and left him in need, failing to give the help he could have given and spending on self-gratification what should have been shared with the poor.COL 261.21T 539.2–540.1Lt 207, 1899, par. 714MR 57.3 The poor man is depicted as loathsome and suffering there, while in the same cities men of wealth have more than heart could wish.COL 242STMW7 56.2
In the unseen estimate Lazarus though deplorable and despised had true faith and true moral worth greatly valued by God.1T 539.2–540.1 God took him to the most exalted position among refined holy angels as an heir of God and joint-heir with Christ, while the honored ease-loving rich man had no true moral worth and his character was worthless.1T 539.2–540.1 Riches did not recommend him to God or secure favor, and he was thrust from God's presence into unutterable misery and woe.1T 539.2–540.1 This teaches not to judge or value men by wealth or by honors received from others.1T 539.2–540.1
Riches acquired by oppression, deception, overreaching, fraud or any dishonest manner are abomination in God's sight.1T 539.2–540.1 Those like the covetous Pharisees who possess riches and worldly honor while justifying themselves before men are valueless, corrupt, sinful and abominable to God and rejected by Him for lack of moral soundness, while the poor man disgusting to men is valuable to God when he possesses moral soundness and worth.1T 539.2–540.1 During sickness the rich man learned what suffering meant, but he had no knowledge of God, and after death he is portrayed as calling on Lazarus for relief, having refused from his abundance the duty to help Lazarus and lost his soul through intemperate, luxurious living.Ms 22, 1898, par. 27
Scripture's Sufficient Warning
The plea rests on the belief that a messenger returning from the dead would lead the five brothers to repent.Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 It carries the claim that he himself had not been adequately warned, blaming God as though fuller warning would have kept him from his fate.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 The answer is that men are responsible to heed the Scriptures they already have, for Moses and the prophets supply sufficient light and the needed testimony for their responsibilities.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 Those who refuse to hear that existing light will not be persuaded even by someone rising from the dead or by a miracle.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915
Figuratively the request expresses the Jewish nation's wish for further evidence despite having been sufficiently warned through Moses and the prophets.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19 Its refusal to heed that light would not be cured by a messenger raised from the dead.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19 The nation had been entrusted with sacred truth and abundant temporal and spiritual blessings and called to share God's gifts with the poor, strangers and struggling neighbors in order to bless and enlighten the world.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19COL 269.1COL 267.3 Instead it put Abraham where God should have been, relied proudly on descent from Abraham, failed to let God shape it or to reckon with eternity, used blessings selfishly, and rejected Christ whom God sent to warn it.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19COL 269.1COL 267.3 That unfaithfulness brought ruin on the nation, and such people face judgment and are found wanting.COL 269.1COL 267.3
What was predicted came to pass, for the resurrection of Lazarus did not persuade the Jewish leaders, who rejected that testimony and sought to kill him.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4 The warning would be remembered at the destruction of Jerusalem, when calamity came upon the city and starvation and suffering of every kind came upon the people.COL 269.2 Then they remembered these words and understood the parable, showing they had brought suffering upon themselves by neglect to let their God-given light shine forth to the world.COL 269.2
Probation, Stewardship, And Reversal
Eternal destiny is decided in this life while grace is offered during probation, and those who waste their opportunities in self-pleasing cut themselves off from everlasting life and by their own choice fix an impassable gulf between themselves and God, for there is no further probation after death.COL 260.1ST Jun 1, 1915 The closing history portrays the last days and the closing scenes of earth's history, in which one who neglects God and suffering people and chooses worldly pleasure and appetite instead of serving God goes to the grave with the character formed in life.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36COL 269.3 The dead cannot choose good or evil, for their thoughts perish when they die, and at the resurrection they retain the appetites and passions they cultivated.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36COL 269.3 The separation reflects the chasm formed by a life without delight in God, an impassable gulf of disobedience and wrongly formed character, for God does not remake one who refused the opportunities to be changed.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36COL 269.3
The parable contrasts the rich who do not depend on God and do not surrender their lives to Him with the poor who trust in Him and patiently endure suffering.COL 260.2–3ST Jun 1, 1915 It stands as a lasting lesson for rich and poor that their conditions are reversed after death, with the suffering believer exalted above worldly status while the tormented rich man is comforted no longer and Lazarus is comforted.COL 260.2–3STBk 158.1ST Jun 1, 1915SW 7.1 There is no sin in being rich if riches are not gained by injustice, and a rich man is not condemned for having riches.COL 266.1 Condemnation rests on him if the means, abilities and opportunities entrusted to him are spent in selfishness, lived as owner instead of steward, and used for selfish pleasure, intemperate luxurious living, extravagance and gratification rather than God's work, while the call of God and the claims of the suffering poor whose case was his responsibility are neglected.COL 266.1COL 261.4ST Jun 1, 1915Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24Ms 22, 1898, par. 27
Possessions are only lent by God, and misusing them can leave a person worse off than the poorest believer.COL 266.1ST Jun 1, 1915 Wealth cannot save when probation ends, cannot make one rich toward God or provide Christ's righteousness, cannot be taken into the next life, and hoarding treasure for self proves unfaithful stewardship.COL 266.1ST Jun 1, 1915Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24 One should lay up money beside the throne of God by using it to do good, for death cannot make poor one who devotes himself to seeking eternal riches, while faithful service and good deeds endure.COL 266.1Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24 The rich man's plea is that of one whose probation has ended in death, who in life had all that money could buy but lacked the riches that keep the account right with God.COL 267.1 At death he is commanded by irresistible power to quit the premises where he is no longer steward and is reduced to hopeless poverty and nakedness without the robe of Christ's righteousness, having brought nothing into the world and able to take nothing out, so that selfish pleasure is shown not to be happiness and he would have given all he possessed to exchange places with Lazarus.Ms 22, 1898, par. 31COL 267.1
Living for self and rejecting love expressed in care for others brings loss, and those with abundance are responsible to help people in need and will face a reckoning for their stewardship.COL 259.1–2ST Jun 25, 1894Lt 21, 1898, par. 4–5 This condemns spending on richly furnished houses, personal ornament and sensual appetites including tobacco and liquors that destroy brain power, unbalance the mind and debase the soul, turning means given to honor the Creator by blessing the world into self-gratification, dishonor to God and neglect of His heritage.STMW7 56.2 It condemns seeing the ruin Satan works in wretched fallen hopeless beings without effort in God's name to lift a standard through gifts of food, clothing and fitly spoken words as channels of the Saviour's pitying tenderness.ST Jun 6, 1900Ms 87, 1898, par. 26–29 If Dives does not heed Lazarus full of sores at his gate there is woe, for the colored people lie like Lazarus at the gate of the white race as Dives, so heavy responsibility rests on the white race to bend a portion of its energies to their moral uplifting to higher standards of education and home life.SBAWP 49.1–2 Seeking supremacy as an end and overriding justice loses what is sought and neglect brings retribution, while honestly and justly trying to uplift this people uplifts itself.SBAWP 49.1–2 The parable shows God as the foundation of faith, goodness and mercy.Ms 81, 1898, par. 28–32
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
137 sources
The verse records the rich man's plea for Abraham to send Lazarus back to his father's house to warn his five brothers so they would not come to his place of torment.RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 14, 1913ST Nov 11, 1886 The plea belongs to a made-up figurative story that borrows familiar ideas about Hades to teach moral truth, not to report actual conversations of the dead.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Oct 31, 1900ST Sep 16, 1880ST Dec 25, 1901 It gives no proof that the dead are conscious, for the dead lie in unconscious sleep with no knowledge or care for the living, and its speech is personification of what would be said if they were alive.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Oct 31, 1900ST Jul 15, 1913RH Mar 28, 1865ST Mar 30, 1882 The brothers already have sufficient warning in Moses and the prophets, and those who will not hear Scripture will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead, while the dead are not permitted to return to communicate with the living.RH May 5, 1874RH May 24, 1870ST Mar 15, 1877ST Oct 1, 1885RH May 19, 1851 The rich man stands for the Jews rich in privilege yet covetous and exclusive, Lazarus for the humble Gentiles seeking God, and the plea rebukes trust in riches and ancestry and urges faithful stewardship and compassion for the poor now because destiny is fixed in this life.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Mar 30, 1882RH Feb 8, 1912ST Apr 10, 1907ST
Words and Immediate Setting
The verse records the rich man asking Abraham to send Lazarus to his father's house to warn his five brothers so they will not come to his place of torment.RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 14, 1913ST Nov 11, 1886ST Mar 15, 1877ST Aug 25, 1881 The request begins a plea that his living family be warned about the place of torment, and it is refused because they already have the testimony of Moses and the prophets whose written testimony gives sufficient light to instruct and warn.RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 14, 1913ST Nov 11, 1886ST Mar 15, 1877ST Aug 25, 1881 The asking belongs to the parable's figurative scene and imagined conversation, not a teaching that the dead can communicate with the living or that the dead are conscious.ST Oct 14, 1913ST Nov 11, 1886ST Mar 15, 1877ST Aug 25, 1881
Dives is not the rich man's personal name but the Latin word meaning rich, or a rich man, matching the Greek word plousios used for him.RH Jan 30, 1879ST Mar 30, 1882 Calling him Dives came from the use of dives for him in Latin versions of the Scriptures and from old pictures and paintings on the subject titled in Latin Dives et Lazarus, where the first word was mistaken for the rich man's name as the last word truly is the beggar's name.RH Jan 30, 1879ST Mar 30, 1882 It would be just as proper to call him Plousios as Dives, and the parable is commonly titled Dives and Lazarus.RH Jan 30, 1879ST Mar 30, 1882
Lazarus is a typical case and typical name meaning Whom God aids, the Greek form of the Hebrew Eleazar.ST Feb 11, 1897ST Mar 24, 1909 The Lazarus in the parable is not Martha and Mary's brother and the account is not literal history about him, but belongs to the parable of the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16:19-31.ST Feb 11, 1897ST Mar 24, 1909ST Oct 3, 1878ST Nov 28, 1878 In that typical sense the rich man is a type of the Jew who felt rich in everything spiritual and counted the Gentile as the opposite, and Lazarus is a type of the Gentile hungry for the spiritual riches Christ gives.ST Mar 24, 1909 The account bears on the immortality question, whether man is immortal.ST Mar 10, 1909ST Mar 31, 1909
The conversation is set in Hades, the unseen state and place of the dead in the nether parts of the earth, the grave, the common place of the dead, and in this account hell means hades.ST Dec 4, 1884RH Dec 22, 1868RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879 Hades is described as darkness, silence, secrecy, forgetfulness and death, where there is no knowledge, remembrance, work, wisdom, device, thanksgiving, praise or activity.RH Dec 22, 1868RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879ST Jun 30, 1881 Both men are dead and represented as dead in the grave, with their thoughts perished and with no conscious activity or interest in the affairs of the living.ST Dec 4, 1884RH Dec 22, 1868ST Mar 27, 1879ST Jun 30, 1881 The dead are therefore made to speak and act as though alive according to the facts of their lives, with bodily organs like eyes, fingers and tongues, by personification representing dead men speaking as they would if alive, not by literal conversation of conscious spirits or disembodied souls.RH Dec 22, 1868RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879ST Jun 30, 1881
In the surrounding verses the word translated torment in verses 23 and 28 is basanos, whose primary sense is testing or trial with torment as a derived sense, retaining the idea of testing in this account.ST Aug 14, 1893 It is distinct from odyno, used in verses 24 and 25 for anguish or pain.ST Aug 14, 1893
The sending the rich man asks for could happen only by Lazarus himself being raised from among dead men, not by a disembodied spirit descending from heaven or returning as a conscious soul separate from the body.RH Mar 28, 1865RH Feb 2, 1864RH Mar 28, 1865RH Dec 12, 1854RH Sep 3, 1872 The request to send Lazarus, and the reply that he could make the communication only by rising from the dead, shows those conversing are personified dead men awaiting the resurrection, spoken of as alive because in the purpose of God they shall surely live again, with no interval to them between death and resurrection.RH Mar 28, 1865RH Feb 2, 1864RH Mar 28, 1865 The dead cannot return to the living to help convert the impenitent, and even resurrection would not persuade those who refuse God's word, supporting that faith rests on the word of God and that there is no opportunity for probation after death.ST Oct 1, 1894RH Mar 28, 1865RH Sep 3, 1872
Parable Literary Form
The account of the rich man and Lazarus is a parable, apologue, allegory or fable, a made-up figurative story whose impossible speech and actions teach moral truth rather than reporting literal events or actual conversations of the dead.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Dec 4, 1884ST Aug 19, 1880ST Feb 26, 1902 The request that Lazarus be sent to the father's house to warn the five brothers belongs to that figurative scene and does not teach that the dead are conscious, that man is naturally immortal, that the wicked burn forever, or that the dead can communicate with the living.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Aug 19, 1880 Both men are represented as dead and in the grave, where there is no conscious activity or interest in the affairs of the living, and in this account hell means hades, the common place of the dead.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Dec 4, 1884 Because it is a parable its imagery of people after death is to be interpreted as figurative rather than treated as literal description.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Feb 26, 1902
Christ borrows the familiar opinions of the Pharisees and rabbis about Hades to frame the story, including the gulf separating righteous and wicked, the flame and its torment, the bosom of Abraham filled with the righteous, and angels conveying souls of the good to one place and the bad to another.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Dec 25, 1901ST Sep 2, 1880 That teaching about hades was well defined and elaborately set forth long before Christ, more circumstantial and full, while He adds nothing to nor subtracts anything from its topography but takes accepted notions of His time and uses such portions as were best adapted to inculcate what He wished to teach.ST Sep 2, 1880ST Sep 2, 1880ST Sep 9, 1880 He speaks for the moment as if those notions were correct and meets hearers on their own ground as an argumentum ad hominem, without endorsing them as true, rectifying them where wrong, or deciding whether that belief was right.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Dec 25, 1901ST Sep 16, 1880ST Nov 3, 1881 Such reasoning addressed to the peculiar circumstances, character, avowed opinions and past conduct of the hearers yields a relative and particular conclusion binding on them by their own principles, honorable in conception and purpose and fully legitimate in debate to silence cavils and convince those hindered by weakness and prejudice.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Nov 3, 1881
The parable must be understood consistently as either wholly literal or wholly figurative, not partly literal and partly figurative, and interpreted in harmony with plain Scripture that the dead have no conscious existence, that thoughts perish at death, and that man returns to the condition before becoming a living soul.ST Aug 19, 1880STRH Feb 26, 1857 Taken literally in all its doctrines and details it becomes nonsense, absurd, ridiculous and cruel, for Dives and Lazarus were not real characters who actually went to the places named and those places are not matters of fact and part of the structure of the world.ST Sep 2, 1880STST Nov 3, 1881 A literal reading would require an immense dark cavern fitted up in the bowels of the earth with but one entrance and no sunlight, constructed as the grand prison-house for souls of both good and bad for the four thousand years from creation to the cross, divided by a gulf with the righteous on the more fortunate side.ST Sep 2, 1880ST Sep 2, 1880 It would place Adam, Enoch, Noah, Abraham and other faithful worthies in long ages of confinement there in continual sight of lurid flames and torment, ineffably happy yet year in and year out witnessing torture that would chill mortal sympathy, in a dismal sepulchral abode unworthy of God whose handiwork is seen among stars, sunshine, flowers, groves and vistas.ST Sep 2, 1880ST Sep 2, 1880 It would also place heaven and hell within sight and speaking distance across an impassable gulf, with the departed seeing and conversing with one another and the saved forever exposed to lost relatives, and would set immediate punishment in flames against the souls under the altar who wait long for vengeance, turning forgiveness into blood-thirsty cries.ST Nov 3, 1881ST Feb 26, 1902ST Nov 30, 1915
As figurative illustration the parable proves no doctrine about the afterlife, eternal salvation, inherent immortality, or the conscious state and care of the dead by itself, and such doctrine needs plain and express evidence.RH Sep 15, 1859RH Jan 7, 1902ST Mar 16, 1876ST Oct 1, 1894 No parable establishes doctrine but only illustrates what plain Scripture teaches, and its details should not be treated as direct statement of doctrine without explicit explanation or used as proof of consciousness.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Aug 19, 1880ST At most the plea shows what the rich man would say if he were able to speak, using a story common among the Jews, and nothing in it overthrows the Bible teaching of the unconscious state of the dead.STST Oct 1, 1894
The rich man and Lazarus is the second of the two parables in Luke 16 against covetousness, the first being the unfaithful steward, with the entire chapter directed against covetousness.ST Aug 13, 1894RH May 28, 1861ST Sep 30, 1886 The parables are to be meditated upon more than ever, without speculation, fanciful interpretation, or controversy over their meaning.ST Aug 13, 1894 Unlike the account of Noah and the flood, which is treated as true history, the rich man and Lazarus is used as parable and not as fable-turned-fact, while its teaching belongs with man's nature and destiny, the state of the dead, the end of the wicked, the hope of the gospel, and departing and being with Christ.RH May 28, 1861ST Sep 30, 1886
State of the Dead
The request to send Lazarus to the father's house to warn five brothers so they will not come to the place of torment does not prove that the dead are conscious, that man has natural immortality, or that disembodied spirits speak and act after death.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Jul 15, 1913ST Aug 19, 1880RH Dec 22, 1868ST Dec 4, 1884 It belongs to an allegory built on ideas then held by some hearers about a conscious intermediate state with punishment between death and resurrection, and whether taken as parable or as literal narration it speaks of the dead persons themselves with bodily parts and not of separate immortal souls.RH Sep 15, 1859ST Oct 31, 1900ST Jul 15, 1913ST Aug 19, 1880RH Mar 4, 1862 The eyes, fingers, tongues, seeing, remembering, devising and conversing are personification, dead men with thoughts perished made to speak and act as they would if alive and capable of thought and utterance.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881RH Mar 28, 1865 The dead are in deep sleep in Hades in the nether parts of the earth, a place of darkness, silence, forgetfulness and utter lack of knowledge, memory, wisdom, work, device, thanksgiving and praise, so they cannot see, remember, devise, converse or care for the living.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Mar 30, 1882ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881 The sending asked for could happen only by Lazarus himself being raised from among dead men awaiting the resurrection, not by a spirit descending from heaven or returning as a conscious soul, which shows those conversing are personified dead men spoken of as alive because in God's purpose they shall surely live again.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Mar 28, 1865RH Mar 28, 1865
The scene sets forth future realities as already present because certain in God's purpose, for the sake of the lesson to be conveyed.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Aug 12, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881 Lazarus comforted means comfort after the future resurrection at Christ's coming and return to receive his kingdom, and the rich man's torment means punishment after the day of judgment when cases are irrevocably fixed and the wicked suffer in the lake of fire, not bliss or torment entered immediately at death with separation of soul from body.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Mar 30, 1882ST Feb 17, 1881RH Aug 12, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858 It cannot be an event occurring immediately after death, because the dead are unconscious and unable to feel or speak, and it agrees with all testimony that judgment comes before punishment is inflicted.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Mar 30, 1882ST Jun 30, 1881 Taken literally in all details the picture would mean the wicked in torment and the righteous in bliss are conscious in separate places within sight and speech across a gulf, heaven and hell close enough for inhabitants to see and talk with one another.RH Jul 18, 1865ST Nov 16, 1876ST Nov 30, 1915ST Feb 25, 1875RH Jul 9, 1872 That would leave the anguish of the wicked in full view of the heavenly host with piercing shrieks ringing in their ears, the saved forever exposed to lost relatives and continually interrupted by their cries, and sin and suffering perpetuated forever contrary to the hope of a universe free from sin, while alongside the souls under the altar in Revelation it would have martyrs looking upon persecutors already suffering and others soon joining them, conflicting with their plea for God to judge and avenge their blood.RH Jul 18, 1865ST Nov 16, 1876ST Nov 30, 1915ST Feb 25, 1875RH Jul 9, 1872
Those who held the other view treated the account as showing departed spirits immediately conscious and existing after death, the rich man speaking after death and before the resurrection to ask for Lazarus to be sent.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Dec 16, 1858RH Mar 1, 1860ST Nov 4, 1880RH Jan 7, 1873 In that teaching the dead experience suffering or comfort as a foretaste of final reward, Hades as the abode of both righteous and wicked dead divided into Paradise and Tartarus where inhabitants know their future fate with the righteous growing in righteousness and the wicked in wickedness and hopeless despair, a familiar illustration of immortality though not establishing that good souls go directly to heaven, their state otherwise unknown and outside heaven.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Dec 16, 1858RH Mar 1, 1860ST Nov 4, 1880ST Jan 10, 1878 One treated it as fact supporting everlasting anguish.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Mar 1, 1860ST Nov 4, 1880RH Jan 7, 1873ST Jan 10, 1878 The account stands listed among objections to mortality and unconsciousness in death, as the strongest stronghold put forward as positive authority for an immaterial ever-conscious never-dying principle vaulted from heathen mythology and the speculation of Socrates and Plato into Christianity, among only two passages cited for present conscious suffering of the wicked and the one individual case considered for present punishment of the wicked.RH Aug 27, 1872RH May 5, 1874RH Dec 15, 1868RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 30, 1874 It is explained as giving no support to that doctrine, presenting serious difficulties for the view that the righteous are happy in heaven and the wicked tormented in hell immediately after death, and as fully explained by other scriptures on the place and condition of the dead.RH Aug 27, 1872RH May 5, 1874ST Jun 23, 1881RH Dec 15, 1868RH Jun 30, 1874
Sufficiency of Scripture Warning
The request to send Lazarus to the father's house to warn the five brothers is refused because the brothers already have Moses and the prophets, whose written testimony gives sufficient light to instruct and warn mankind.RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 23, 1881ST Oct 1, 1894 Men are to believe and act on the light received in God's written word rather than expect additional supernatural signs or messages from the dead.RH May 24, 1870ST Jun 23, 1881ST Oct 1, 1894 The asking and its denial belong to a personification in which dead men in hades in the nether parts of the earth are made to speak and act as though alive, not to a literal conversation of conscious spirits, since hades is darkness, silence, forgetfulness, and no knowledge, wisdom, work, or device where the dead cannot see, remember, devise, or converse.ST Oct 31, 1900RH Mar 28, 1865 The sending asked for could happen only by Lazarus himself being raised from among dead men, not by a disembodied spirit descending from heaven, which shows those conversing are personified dead men with bodily organs like eyes, fingers, and tongues awaiting the resurrection, spoken of as alive because in the purpose of God they shall surely live again.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Oct 1, 1894 Abraham cannot provide help or secure favor for the rich man because he is Abraham's literal descendant, and the warning is refused because that testimony is sufficient.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Jun 23, 1881ST Oct 1, 1894
Those who will not hear Moses and the prophets will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead, so the refusal was needless to grant and would not avail.RH May 24, 1870ST Oct 1, 1885ST Nov 14, 1900ST Feb 17, 1904RH Sep 15, 1859 Scripture is thereby set above even miraculous manifestation as evidence, standing as its own best witness rather than resting on extraordinary signs.RH May 24, 1870ST Oct 1, 1885ST Aug 24, 1904 This supports that the prophetic message of Scripture can be understood, and it rebukes all who have the Bible but remain hardened in unbelief.ST Aug 24, 1904RH Sep 15, 1859 The parable thus teaches that faith rests on the word of God, with no further probation implied in a return from the dead.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Oct 1, 1894
Even if the dead were conscious, they are not permitted to return to earth to communicate with the living, whether to instruct, converse, warn the family, or help convert the impenitent.RH May 19, 1851RH Dec 23, 1851ST Jan 20, 1887ST Oct 1, 1894 Communications claimed to be from the spirits of departed dead, whether of good men or bad men, are not from them at all but are the work of the devil, forming part of the last-day wonders and miracles by which the world is deceived.RH Dec 23, 1851 Such a return would require resurrection, and even that would not persuade those who refuse God's word.ST Oct 1, 1894 The plea gives no authority for praying to saints or to Mary, since Christ is the one Intercessor between God and humanity, and the rich man's call upon Abraham stands as the only biblical instance of prayer to a saint, made by a lost soul and denied.ST May 6, 1880ST Nov 30, 1915
Men decide their eternal destiny in this life, for character formed in life creates an impassable gulf with no crossing over and no probation after death.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Mar 30, 1882ST Nov 14, 1900ST Oct 1, 1894RH Oct 10, 1912 Death seals destiny and fixes the cases of the righteous and wicked irrevocably, so the scene belongs to the final-punishment setting after judgment and not to an event occurring immediately after death when the unconscious dead could feel or speak.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Mar 30, 1882 The living must therefore be warned now, since punishment after death does not lead to repentance, and wealth does not make a man right with God nor poverty keep him from heaven, but accountability for entrusted means, love, trust, and dependence on God decide, with personal acquaintance with Christ and a personal Saviour needed for sin.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Oct 28, 1913RH Oct 10, 1912 The rich man's plea for further evidence reflects his claim that he had not been adequately warned and lays blame on God, as though fuller warning would have kept him from his fate, yet his brothers had already received sufficient light through Moses and the prophets for responsibility, and those who reject the truth they have been given would not be persuaded even by a miracle.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915
If the rich man entered hell or purgatory before the judgment he must later be released when hades gives up its dead, which questions the idea of receiving final punishment before that time.RH Oct 31, 1865 The account of comfort and torment, if taken as the intermediate state of conscious dead who are neither happy nor miserable, conflicts with the teaching that some will be surprised by their sentence at the judgment, and if taken as what follows probation it does not prove that the dead have greater wisdom than the living.RH Sep 23, 1858 Cited as an argument for immediate consciousness after death in torment, it conflicts with a future general judgment.
Jews and Gentiles Symbolism
The rich man stands for the Jews, who were rich in law and grace and privilege yet covetous, proud, exclusive and self-righteous, trusting in noble ancestry from Abraham for salvation, while Lazarus stands for the poor and humble Gentiles, sick with sin yet seeking God and receiving grace through belief in Christ.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Apr 10, 1907ST The request to send Lazarus to the father's house belongs to that parabolic picture of the relation of Jews and Gentiles and their attitude toward God, not to a description of what happens after death.ST Mar 6, 1907STST It uses a story common among the Jews to illustrate their different attitudes toward Christ, and taken as literal fact in all details it would make God's dealings ridiculous and cruel.STST Mar 29, 1905 At most it shows what the rich man would say if he were able to speak, and no parable establishes doctrine but only illustrates what plain Scripture teaches.ST The deeper application is that Jewish national pride, exclusiveness, selfishness and contempt for the poor and for Gentiles kept the people from receiving Christ, and no sign would make up for refusal to believe God's word.ST Mar 29, 1905
The five brothers stand for people living now who lack personal acquaintance with Christ and knowledge of the future.ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915 They are directed to hear Moses and the prophets, meaning the Bible, which gives them sufficient guidance.ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915 The parable warns that the choice between eternal life and loss must be made in this life.ST Jan 26, 1915
The rich man and his five brothers together stand for the Father's house as the twelve tribes, the rich man for the Jewish nation then remaining and the five brothers for the supposed lost ten tribes, each brother standing for two tribes.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 Those tribes would hear of Christ through the apostles' preaching and could recognize the fulfillment of Moses and the prophets and believe in Jesus.ST Mar 28, 1906 The change in the men's condition stands for change of dispensations, in which the Jewish class lost much while the Gentile class gained much.RH Dec 12, 1854
The plea brings the parable back to the conditions of Jesus' own time, when Israel had Moses and the prophets but would not heed them, and the warning becomes a lesson about sin and the need for a personal Saviour.ST Oct 28, 1913ST Oct 28, 1913 One reading treats the parable as representing Israel's national death, with the rich man's request for his father's house belonging to that national figure.RH Mar 16, 1869 The request for someone to rise from the dead anticipates the raising of Lazarus and Jesus' own resurrection, which the leaders still rejected, seeking instead to kill Lazarus and to spread a false account of Jesus' resurrection.ST Oct 28, 1913
The parable is spoken in reproof of the covetous Pharisees, striking directly at that wicked root and at pride, selfishness and hard-heartedness toward kindred and family.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Feb 26, 1902 It exposes their contempt for the poor, their trust in riches, status and honor, and their trust in lineal descent from Abraham instead of accepting Christ, teaching that Abraham cannot provide help or secure favor for a literal descendant.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 29, 1905ST Oct 31, 1900 More than lineal descent is required, and the righteousness of Christ must be imputed to the one who would enter heaven.ST Oct 31, 1900 It also strikes at the Jewish belief that sickness, poverty or suffering is a sign that God has forsaken a person or is displeased with him, a belief that nurtured self-righteousness and consequent heartlessness.RH Feb 8, 1912 By employing the Pharisees' own familiar ideas about the dead for the sake of argument, Christ convicted and silenced them completely.ST Feb 26, 1902ST Sep 9, 1880
The story shows the true value of earthly riches in God's sight, that those who exalt themselves will be brought low and that wealth should be used faithfully rather than treated as life's chief end.ST Mar 30, 1882 It rejects the idea that wealth or outward condition proves righteousness or standing with God, teaching that possessions have no merit before God and that men are accountable stewards for what is entrusted to them.RH Oct 10, 1912ST Sep 9, 1880 The rich man's abundance does not prevent his condemnation while Lazarus's poverty does not prevent his salvation, so worldly prosperity is no guarantee of divine favor and poverty is not proof that a person is accursed.ST Aug 26, 1880ST Dec 4, 1884 He who received good things in this lifetime is tormented and he who received evil things is comforted, and having all one's good things in this life leaves nothing more to expect.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Dec 4, 1884
Wealth Stewardship and Application
The parable shows the true value of earthly riches in God's sight, that those who exalt themselves will be brought low and that wealth should be used faithfully to help secure eternal life rather than treated as life's chief end.ST Mar 30, 1882RH Oct 10, 1912RH Oct 10, 1912 Possessions have no merit before God, and people are accountable for how they use what is entrusted to them, recognizing God as giver and using means for others and God's cause.RH Oct 10, 1912RH Oct 10, 1912RH Feb 7, 1907 The rich man's punishment is tied to using his wealth only for his own comfort, condemning a life of luxurious self-indulgence, neglect and oppression of the poor at the gate.RH Jul 10, 1856RH Feb 7, 1907RH Jul 24, 1856 It is a mistake to trust riches as a means of grace or as help in spiritual growth, and to postpone salvation until worldly affairs are satisfactory, for God's kingdom and righteousness must be sought first.ST Aug 27, 1902RH Jul 10, 1856
Riches will not help in the judgment unless they have been used rightly and generously, and poverty does not keep anyone out of heaven.RH Aug 7, 1916RH Jun 30, 1863ST Aug 26, 1880 Earthly wealth and fine clothing cannot protect from the consequences of sin, and the evil use of riches leaves its marks when life ends.RH Aug 7, 1916RH Jun 30, 1863 The rich man was not lost merely for being rich nor Lazarus saved merely for being poor, for abundance does not prevent condemnation while poverty does not prevent salvation.RH Aug 7, 1916RH Oct 10, 1912ST Aug 26, 1880 God judges by character, trust in God and compassion: Dives is left with the self-centered life he chose, while the afflicted man who trusted God is welcomed to a new life with Him, so positions are ultimately reversed.RH Oct 10, 1912RH Jan 7, 1902ST Aug 30, 1905 The rich represent people who live for themselves and selfish gratification receiving their good things in this life, and the beggar represents those who deny self, live as Christ did, and lay hold on eternal life, valued not for possessions but for loving and depending on God.RH Oct 10, 1912RH Jan 7, 1902ST Aug 30, 1905
The rich man in torments stands as an express warning against disobedience, worldliness and postponing salvation, teaching that a life spent in pleasures and splendor of wealth brings future woe.RH Jul 10, 1856RH Jul 24, 1856RH Jul 10, 1856 Many wish to enjoy the rich man's life and then die as Lazarus did, wanting the death of the righteous after living a life of worldly ease.ST Aug 27, 1902ST Mar 10, 1881 Choices about just dealing with others now affect eternal outcome, though the question of which place to choose in the future state seems easier to answer when considering eternity than when considering this life.RH Jul 24, 1856RH Apr 4, 1871 The duty therefore is to use wealth for the poor rather than for self-indulgence, to live with heavenly affection and devotion to God, and to receive chastening because eternity depends on present choices.ST Aug 27, 1902RH Jul 24, 1856RH Apr 4, 1871
The plea to send warning to the father's house carries urgency to receive the Scriptures while there is still opportunity, since earthly wealth is powerless to provide relief in the next life.RH Apr 22, 1915ST Mar 7, 1878ST Jul 25, 1878 It is an appeal not only to the rich and selfish but to Christians to make every effort possible to save the perishing, to carry Christ's message by the living and to support the spread of the gospel rather than neglect it with tragic consequences for those who might have been reached.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Mar 7, 1878ST Jul 25, 1878 The image of Lazarus left at the gate warns against neglecting the poor while serving wealth and power, exposing earthly greed and want of charity as madness that pawns Christ, morality and hopes of heavenly life for coin of earth.ST Oct 8, 1885ST Jun 11, 1912ST Nov 17, 1898 Hearts are to be inclined to charity, showing compassion, hospitality and help to the poor in want and gloom rather than pricing crumbs to swell worth.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Jun 11, 1912ST Nov 17, 1898
The unbridgeable gulf illustrates social distance between a wealthy minister and church and a poor workingman, where the poor may feel too unwelcome and the minister too removed to reach them with sympathy.ST Oct 8, 1885ST Sep 18, 1893 Earthly wealth and social standing can make a man honored while the poor are excluded, commanding social esteem without regard to character, and a prosperous businessman can become poor in charity as wealth fosters selfishness and ease.ST Sep 18, 1893RH Apr 24, 1879 Dives stands for the rich of the twentieth century who pile up colossal fortunes into the hundreds of millions while thousands suffer for necessities of life under the very shadow of the mansion, a state that cannot go on much longer.ST Sep 18, 1893RH Apr 24, 1879ST May 20, 1908 The same luxury is repeated when great avenue palaces are nailed up while occupants go yachting to Norway and Venice and more than three hundred thousand bodies are left to swelter and three hundred thousand souls are left to starve through burning summer months within a single square mile of New York City Hall while the cool sea is only a few furlongs away and the hills of Westchester are green under a blue sky, fulfilling prophecy and showing Christ is coming.ST May 20, 1908ST Nov 29, 1899
The parable uses figurative speech like blood, trees, mountains, stones, or killed souls speaking or acting, and its request is part of that parabolic portrayal, prompting readers to ask which character they have chosen to resemble in light of the poor being rich in faith and heirs of God's kingdom.ST Aug 2, 1910ST Aug 24, 1904 The rich man had lived for himself without caring for Lazarus at his gate, connecting the whole with God's fire consuming sin and those identified with sin.ST Aug 24, 1904RH Aug 15, 1907 Temporal blessings are not an index of God's love, for neither riches nor poverty, sickness nor health, success nor failure in this life are evidences of God's care nor the measure of disapproval, and the Christian's hope does not center in material things but in the resurrection from the dead.ST Aug 2, 1910RH Aug 15, 1907 Lazarus is an example of someone deserving pity, teaching that ignorance is an infirmity of the soul and should be met with compassion just as bodily need is.ST Aug 2, 1910ST Nov 15, 1899
Sources