AdventAI

Mark 12:20

Now there were seven brethren: and the first took a wife, and dying left no seed.

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

2 sources

The verse belongs to the question put to Jesus about the resurrection, in which seven brothers are presented as successively taking the same woman as wife.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–63SP 48.2–3 The case is framed as an application of Moses' direction that a surviving brother should take his dead brother's wife and raise up offspring to him.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 The purpose was to entangle Jesus in His words, unsettle the minds of hearers, and pour ridicule upon that provision of Moses' law so as to bring all the Mosaic institutions into contempt.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6

By setting forth the seven brothers and the one wife the objectors intended to make bodily resurrection look absurd.3SP 48.2–3 The men who brought the case denied any resurrection and denied future rewards and punishments, exalting instead their own skeptical, atheistical sophistries and speculative ideas.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 Their reasoning rested on a false foundation, springing from ignorance of the true teachings of the Word of God and of the power of God.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 It mistakenly took for granted that risen existence would carry on the same earthly propensities and relationships, with marriage and ordinary life continuing exactly as before death.3SP 48.2–3

Sources

  1. Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904) — Ms 28, 1904 Ellen G. White, written March 11, 1904
  2. 3SP 48.2–3 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — JESUS AND THE PHARISEES. Ellen G. White, 1878

Pioneers and periodicals

14 sources

The verse opens a hypothetical case in which seven brothers in turn take the same wife, beginning with the first who marries and dies without leaving a child.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899 It was put forward by Sadducees who held to Moses yet denied that the dead will be raised, to make the resurrection look absurd by asking whose wife she would be.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910ST Mar 3, 1909 The answer given is that those raised to the future life do not marry or die but are like angels and sons of God, and the resurrection itself is proved from Moses.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902 The issue at stake is whether there will be a resurrection, not the condition of the dead between death and resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902RH Apr 5, 1860 The passage does not teach that the dead are already alive as conscious immortal souls with no need of resurrection, for that would empty the argument of its force.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859

Context and Wording

The verse begins the Sadducees' hypothetical case of seven brothers in which the first took a wife and dying left no child or seed, with the others successively marrying the same woman and each dying.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910 The first case is that of the eldest brother, who married a woman and then died without children.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899 After his death the wife passed to the next brother under the stated custom and law of levirate marriage.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 25, 1899

The case was asked by the Sadducees, who professed belief in the writings of Moses and yet denied the resurrection of the dead, teaching that a person dies and so remains for all time to come.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 In that denial they would withhold any future existence from good and bad alike and regard the dead as unconscious.RH Jun 12, 1856 The example sets up their question about whose wife the woman would be in the resurrection and about marriage in the resurrection.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854

The question was designed as a trap and a hypothetical challenge to make the resurrection appear absurd by raising a dispute over whom she would belong to after the resurrection.RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910 Those trying to trap him in this way with their teaching were defeated.RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910ST Mar 3, 1909 Mark's account, like Matthew's, does not use Luke's word worthy, and that difference in wording does not make Luke's statement incorrect, since all three accounts are inspired.RH Mar 10, 1868

Resurrection and State of Dead

Jesus answers that those who are raised to that world and the future state neither marry nor are given in marriage nor die, but are like the angels and are sons of God.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Mar 18, 1902 The whole exchange belongs to an argument whose purpose is to prove that the dead will be raised, correcting the Sadducees' error and publicly refuting and reproving their denial of the resurrection and of any future life, through which future life is made possible.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860 He corrects that error by declaring that there will be a resurrection and proving it from Moses.RH Jun 12, 1856

The dispute is about denial of the resurrection, not about views of the state of the dead.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902RH Apr 5, 1860 The question concerned whose wife the woman would be after the resurrection, not an intermediate state or how immortal souls would live in it.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902RH Apr 5, 1860 The passage does not teach that the dead are already alive as immortal souls or are conscious now with no need of a resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859 To conclude that would make the resurrection unnecessary, distort Christ's argument, and fail to answer the Sadducees.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859

While correcting the error about the resurrection, the passage leaves the view of death as unconsciousness uncorrected.RH Jun 12, 1856 Doubts about the resurrection of the kind raised by this argument can weaken confidence in the gospel and lead toward unbelief.RH May 26, 1859

Sources

  1. ST Feb 6, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 6 — THE GOD OF THE LIVING Pittenger, February 6, 1901
  2. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  3. ST Oct 25, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 43 — LESSON VI.—SABBATH, NOVEMBER 11, 1899 October 25, 1899
  4. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  5. RH Mar 18, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 11 — An Artful Question Well Answered March 18, 1902
  6. ST Oct 25, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 42 — Shiloh: the Man of Sorrows October 25, 1910
  7. ST Mar 3, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 9 — Our Bible Band March 3, 1909
  8. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  9. RH Jun 12, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 7 — THE FIRST AND NINETEENTH CENTURIES June 12, 1856
  10. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  11. RH Apr 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 20 — SADDUCEEISM Fifth-Day, April 5, 1860
  12. RH Sep 8, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 16 — OR, AN INQUIRY INTO THE PRESENT CONSTITUTION AND FUTURE CONDITION OF MAN.^[^*] Editor, September 8, 1859
  13. RH Mar 10, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 13 — DISCUSSION WITH ELD. JOHNSON, Dudley Marvin Canright, March 10, 1868
  14. RH May 26, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 1 — A POPULAR ERROR Fifth-Day, May 26, 1859

Cross-references

  1. Matthew 22:23-33

    The same day came to him the Sadducees, which say that there is no resurrection, and asked him,

    Matthew records the Sadducees’ question about the seven brothers and Jesus’ reply about resurrection.

  2. Luke 20:27-36

    Then came to him certain of the Sadducees, which deny that there is any resurrection; and they asked him,

    Jesus answers the Sadducees’ question about seven brothers and marriage after resurrection.

  3. Deuteronomy 25:5-6

    If brethren dwell together, and one of them die, and have no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger: her husband’s brother shall go in unto her, and take her to him to wife, and perform the duty of an husband’s brother unto her.

    The law requires a deceased man’s brother to raise offspring for him.

  4. Exodus 3:6

    Moreover he said, I am the God of thy father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. And Moses hid his face; for he was afraid to look upon God.

    God’s words to Moses about the patriarchs support the resurrection.

  5. Mark 12:25-27

    For when they shall rise from the dead, they neither marry, nor are given in marriage; but are as the angels which are in heaven.

    Jesus refutes the Sadducees’ denial of resurrection and teaches future life.

  6. Luke 20:35

    But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:

    Jesus likewise describes the resurrection as a future event.

  7. Matthew 22:29

    Jesus answered and said unto them, Ye do err, not knowing the scriptures, nor the power of God.

    Christ's answer exposes their error about the resurrection through ignorance of Scripture.