AdventAI

Mark 12:19

Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    Master, Moses wrote to us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

  • King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Webster Bible

    Master, Moses wrote to us, If a man's brother shall die, and leave his wife, and leave no children, that his brother should take his wife, and raise seed to his brother.

  • Revised Version

    Master, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave a wife behind him, and leave no child, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • American Standard Version

    Teacher, Moses wrote unto us, If a man’s brother die, and leave a wife behind him, and leave no child, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    'Teacher, Moses wrote to us, that if any one's brother may die, and may leave a wife, and may leave no children, that his brother may take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

  • Darby Translation

    Teacher, Moses wrote to us that if any one's brother die, and leave a wife behind, and leave no children, that his brother shall take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    Teacher! Moses, wrote for us, that—If one’s brother die, and leave behind a wife, and leave no child, that his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    “ Teacher, Moses wrote for us that if a man’s brother dies and leaves a wife but no children, the man is to marry his brother’s widow and raise up offspring for him.

  • World English Bible

    “ Teacher, Moses wrote to us, ‘ If a man’s brother dies and leaves a wife behind him, and leaves no children, that his brother should take his wife and raise up offspring for his brother.’

  • Bible in Basic English

    Master, in the law Moses says, If a man's brother comes to his end, and has a wife still living and no child, it is right for his brother to take his wife, and get a family for his brother.

  • Geneva Bible

    Master, Moses wrote vnto vs, If any mans brother die, and leaue his wife, and leaue no children, that his brother should take his wife, and rayse vp seede vnto his brother.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Master, Moses wrote unto us, that if any man’s brother die, and leave his wife behind him, and leave no children, his brother should take his wife, and raise up seed to his brother.

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

4 sources

Moses' law required that when a man died leaving a widow but no children, his surviving brother was to marry her and raise up offspring to preserve the dead brother's line.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–63SP 48.2–3 The Sadducees took up that requirement and built it into a hypothetical case in their attempt to entangle Christ.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Their question was meant to make the bodily resurrection look absurd and to hold it up to ridicule, and at the same time to discredit the Mosaic institutions themselves.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–63SP 48.2–3

Their reasoning assumed that marriage and earthly relationships as known here would continue unchanged after the resurrection.3SP 48.2–3 Their argument therefore rested on a false foundation, because they understood neither the Scriptures nor the power of God.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 Christ's answer to their questions cut through the trap and brought clear truth to the people who heard.Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 This encounter stands among His illustrations and warnings about rejecting the Son of God, which apply to people in every age: unless sinners repent, the doom foreshadowed will be theirs.DA 600.3

Sources

  1. Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904) — Ms 28, 1904 Ellen G. White, written March 11, 1904
  2. 3SP 48.2–3 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — JESUS AND THE PHARISEES. Ellen G. White, 1878
  3. Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 71, 1897 Ellen G. White, written July 11, 1897
  4. DA 600.3 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER SIXTY-FIVE. Ellen G. White, 1898

Pioneers and periodicals

17 sources

The verse records the Sadducees appealing to the written law of Moses that when a man dies leaving a widow but no children, his brother should marry her and raise up children for the dead brother.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jan 24, 1900 The law they cite is that of Deuteronomy 25:5, not Leviticus 18:16 or 20:21, so marriage to a deceased brother's wife is not forbidden, while taking a brother's wife while he is living is adultery.ST Jan 2, 1893 The speakers deny the resurrection and any future life, holding that the dead remain unconscious and dead for all time, and they press a hypothetical case of seven brothers successively marrying the same childless woman to ask whose wife she will be in the resurrection, hoping to overthrow that doctrine and trap Christ.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 The dispute is about whether the dead will ever be raised to life again, not about immortal souls living consciously between death and the resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 Christ answers that they err because they know neither the Scriptures, which teach that the dead will live again, nor the power of God to make alive all who are in their graves, nor the nature of that future state where they neither marry nor are given in marriage; His proof from Moses establishes a future resurrection, not that the dead are alive now.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902RH Sep 8, 1859

The Law and Its Setting

Mark 12:19 records the Sadducees' appeal to what Moses wrote, that if a man's brother dies and leaves his wife behind him with no children, his brother should take the widow and raise up offspring for his dead brother.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jan 24, 1900ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854 It presents this command as part of Moses' written law requiring the marriage and the raising of descendants for the deceased brother.ST Feb 3, 1914ST Jan 24, 1900ST Oct 25, 1910 The law so cited is that of Deuteronomy 25:5, not Leviticus 18:16 or 20:21.ST Jan 2, 1893 Marriage to a deceased brother's wife is therefore not contrary to Scripture, and where the brother did not die childless it remains the privilege of the widow and her former husband's brother to marry if they choose.ST Jan 2, 1893 The Levitical prohibitions forbid gross indulgence of lust and illegal marriage to a brother's wife while her husband is still living, which is adultery, while making it a duty to take her in the childless case.ST Jan 2, 1893

The words are spoken by the Sadducees, who professed belief in the writings of Moses and yet denied the resurrection of the dead.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 They withheld a future state of existence from all, good or bad, regarding man in death as unconscious.RH Jun 12, 1856 They taught that when a person dies he remains dead for all time to come.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 They used this rule as the basis for a hypothetical challenge to Christ's teaching that the dead will be raised.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1910RH Mar 18, 1902 The case involved seven brothers who successively married the same childless woman, all dead with the woman dead also and the case closed till the next world.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1910RH Mar 18, 1902

They asked whose wife she will be after the dead are raised, thinking this question about a future event would overthrow the resurrection and trap Jesus.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Oct 25, 1910RH Mar 18, 1902 The issue was whether the dead would ever be raised, which Christ affirmed and the Sadducees denied, though both accepted Moses.RH Mar 18, 1902 The verse belongs to the same discussion of the resurrection found in Matthew and Luke.RH Mar 10, 1868 Mark, like Matthew, does not repeat Luke's statement that some will be counted worthy of the resurrection, but that omission does not make Luke's statement incorrect, because Matthew, Mark, and Luke all wrote under God's inspiration.RH Mar 10, 1868

Resurrection, Not Immortal Souls

The dispute is about life after the resurrection and whether the dead will ever be raised, not about whether immortal souls exist between death and resurrection or how souls would live in an intermediate spirit world.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 The Sadducees cited Moses’ law that a man should marry his deceased brother’s childless widow and raise offspring for him, then set forth seven brothers who successively married the same woman, to challenge Christ’s teaching about the resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 Their question whose wife she will be after the dead are raised concerns marriage in the resurrection, not the condition of disembodied souls, and the case is closed till the next world because all are dead, including the woman.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 It does not prove that the dead are already immortal or alive.RH Dec 12, 1854

Christ’s reply corrects the erroneous denial of the resurrection by declaring that there will be a resurrection and proving it from the writings of Moses.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902 His proof cannot mean that all the dead are already alive, since that would leave no need for a resurrection, for the resurrection at issue is a future event, not one already occurred.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859 It proves a future resurrection, not a conscious intermediate state, and does not teach that the dead are now in conscious existence.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902 Their error was withholding a future state of existence from all, good or bad, while regarding man in death as unconscious, and Jesus left that view of unconsciousness uncorrected while refuting the denial itself.RH Jun 12, 1856

He answered that they erred because they knew neither the Scriptures, which teach that the dead will live again, nor the power of God, who is able to make alive again all who have gone into their graves.RH Mar 18, 1902 They also did not know the nature and condition of that future state where they neither marry nor are given in marriage, so that earthly marriage arrangements do not decide relations there.RH Mar 18, 1902 God is not the God of those irrecoverably and eternally dead but of the living, those who will live again.RH Mar 18, 1902 In this dispute Jesus reproved the Sadducees for denying the resurrection and future life, not for their views about the state of the dead.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860

The answer cannot rightly be used afterward to argue from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob that the dead live now as immortal souls, since that conclusion ignores the object of Jesus’ argument.RH Dec 12, 1854 The Sadducees’ argument is an argument against the resurrection, and doubts about the resurrection can weaken confidence in the gospel and lead to unbelief.RH May 26, 1859 The question belongs to the attempt by Jesus’ enemies to trap Him with their questions, in which they were defeated.ST Mar 3, 1909

Sources

  1. ST Feb 3, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 4 — SYSTEMATIC BIBLE STUDY February 3, 1914
  2. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  3. ST Jan 24, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 4 — WHO WROTE THE PENTATEUCH? Abbie C. Morrow, January 24, 1900
  4. ST Jan 2, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 9 — 70. TAKING ONE'S BROTHER'S WIFE. LEV. 18:16; 20:21 Editor, Monday, January 2, 1893
  5. ST Oct 25, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 43 — LESSON VI.—SABBATH, NOVEMBER 11, 1899 October 25, 1899
  6. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  7. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  8. RH Jun 12, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 7 — THE FIRST AND NINETEENTH CENTURIES June 12, 1856
  9. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  10. RH Mar 18, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 11 — An Artful Question Well Answered March 18, 1902
  11. RH Sep 8, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 16 — OR, AN INQUIRY INTO THE PRESENT CONSTITUTION AND FUTURE CONDITION OF MAN.^[^*] Editor, September 8, 1859
  12. ST Oct 25, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 42 — Shiloh: the Man of Sorrows October 25, 1910
  13. RH Mar 10, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 13 — DISCUSSION WITH ELD. JOHNSON, Dudley Marvin Canright, March 10, 1868
  14. RH Apr 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 20 — SADDUCEEISM Fifth-Day, April 5, 1860
  15. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  16. RH May 26, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 1 — A POPULAR ERROR Fifth-Day, May 26, 1859
  17. ST Mar 3, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 9 — Our Bible Band March 3, 1909

Cross-references

  1. Matthew 22:24

    Saying, Master, Moses said, If a man die, having no children, his brother shall marry his wife, and raise up seed unto his brother.

    Matthew records the same law cited in the Sadducees’ question.

  2. Deuteronomy 25:5-6

    If brethren dwell together, and one of them die, and have no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger: her husband’s brother shall go in unto her, and take her to him to wife, and perform the duty of an husband’s brother unto her.

    Sets out the Mosaic law about a brother marrying his childless brother’s widow.

  3. Luke 20:27-38

    Then came to him certain of the Sadducees, which deny that there is any resurrection; and they asked him,

    Luke records the same question about levirate marriage and Jesus’ reply concerning resurrection.

  4. Mark 12:23-27

    In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.

    Jesus answers the Sadducees’ marriage objection and establishes the resurrection.

  5. Luke 20:27

    Then came to him certain of the Sadducees, which deny that there is any resurrection; and they asked him,

    Luke records the parallel Sadducee question about Moses’ law.

  6. Leviticus 18:16

    Thou shalt not uncover the nakedness of thy brother’s wife: it is thy brother’s nakedness.

    distinguished as forbidding a living brother's wife

  7. Matthew 19:7

    They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?

    The Pharisees attribute a law from Deuteronomy to Moses.

  8. Matthew 22:29

    Jesus answered and said unto them, Ye do err, not knowing the scriptures, nor the power of God.

    Christ charges the Sadducees with misunderstanding Scripture and God’s power.

  9. Romans 7:2-3

    For the woman which hath an husband is bound by the law to her husband so long as he liveth; but if the husband be dead, she is loosed from the law of her husband.

    A widow is free from the marriage bond after her husband dies.

  10. 1 Corinthians 7:39

    The wife is bound by the law as long as her husband liveth; but if her husband be dead, she is at liberty to be married to whom she will; only in the Lord.

    A widow is free to marry after her husband dies.

  11. Leviticus 20:21

    And if a man shall take his brother’s wife, it is an unclean thing: he hath uncovered his brother’s nakedness; they shall be childless.

    Marriage to a brother’s wife is condemned while the brother is alive.

  12. Mark 12:26

    And as touching the dead, that they rise: have ye not read in the book of Moses, how in the bush God spake unto him, saying, I am the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob?

    Jesus cites Moses in the Sadducees’ discussion of resurrection.

  13. Luke 20:35

    But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:

    Jesus describes the resurrection as a future event.

  14. Mark 6:18

    For John had said unto Herod, It is not lawful for thee to have thy brother’s wife.

    Herod took his living brother’s wife, unlike the levirate marriage described.

  15. Acts 26:8

    Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you, that God should raise the dead?

    The passage echoes its question about whether God can raise the dead.