Matthew 2:17
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying,
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremy the prophet, saying,
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremie the prophet, saying,
Webster Bible, Revised Version, Young's Literal Translation
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremiah the prophet, saying,
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken through Jeremiah the prophet, saying,
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken through Jeremias the prophet, saying,
Then was fulfilled, that which was spoken through Jeremiah the prophet, saying:
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then what was spoken through the prophet Jeremiah was fulfilled:
Then that which was spoken by Jeremiah the prophet was fulfilled, saying,
Then the word of Jeremiah the prophet came true,
Then was that fulfilled which is spoken by the Prophet Ieremias, saying,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Then was fulfilled that which was spoken by Jeremias the prophet, saying:
Cross-references
- Jeremiah 31:15
Thus saith the LORD; A voice was heard in Ramah, lamentation, and bitter weeping; Rahel weeping for her children refused to be comforted for her children, because they were not.
Rachel’s lament over her children is applied to the grief over Bethlehem’s slain children.
- Jeremiah 31:16-17
Thus saith the LORD; Refrain thy voice from weeping, and thine eyes from tears: for thy work shall be rewarded, saith the LORD; and they shall come again from the land of the enemy.
Promises the slain children will return from the land of the enemy, comforting their mothers.
- Hosea 11:1
When Israel was a child, then I loved him, and called my son out of Egypt.
Israel’s call out of Egypt is fulfilled in Christ’s call out of Egypt.
- Genesis 35:18-20
And it came to pass, as her soul was in departing, (for she died) that she called his name Ben-oni: but his father called him Benjamin.
Identifies Rachel and records her death and burial.
- Luke 2:39
And when they had performed all things according to the law of the Lord, they returned into Galilee, to their own city Nazareth.
Luke’s brief account omits the intervening flight and return.
- Matthew 2:21-23
And he arose, and took the young child and his mother, and came into the land of Israel.
Describes the return from Egypt and the family’s move to Nazareth.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
8 sources
Then was fulfilled marks the killing of the innocent children in Bethlehem and its surrounding region as the fulfillment of what Jeremiah the prophet had spoken.1RED 21.2RH Dec 24, 1872DA 65.42SP 26.2–28.21RED 22.2 Herod sent soldiers to kill children two years old and younger.1RED 21.2 He acted to assert his power over the Jews and to murder the infant prince he feared, hoping to destroy the king of Israel.1RED 21.2 The prophecy fulfilled was Jeremiah's vision given about six hundred years earlier of Rachel weeping for her children, picturing the lamentation, mourning and grief over their deaths.RH Dec 24, 1872DA 65.41RED 22.2ST Jun 23, 1887LC1 22.2 That sorrow was heard at Ramah, where mothers grieved their lost children and could not be comforted because they were gone.2SP 26.2–28.2LC1 22.2
The calamity followed the Jews' false teaching that Christ would rule an earthly empire in earthly glory.1RED 22.2LC1 22.2 Their pride, hostility and false presentation of Christ and his mission stirred Herod's envy and hatred.RH Dec 24, 18721RED 22.2LC1 22.2 It was permitted to humble the nation, and it filled their homes with mourning.RH Dec 24, 18721RED 22.2 The planners did not destroy the infant Christ.1RED 22.2 The slaughter was one of the last cruel acts of Herod's reign, and soon afterward Herod died a fearful death, unable to resist a power greater than his own.1RED 22.2DA 66.1
The memory of Herod seeking to kill Jesus as an infant added to Joseph and Mary's sad and fearful anxiety for his safety when they turned back to Jerusalem sorrowing to seek him after losing him for a day on the return from Jerusalem.
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
77 sources
Then was fulfilled marks Herod's killing of the male children two years old and under in Bethlehem and its region as the fulfillment of Jeremiah 31:15 of Rachel mourning for her children and refusing comfort because they are gone.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Jan 11, 1899RH Oct 19, 1869RH Apr 17, 1855ST Jan 11, 1899
The slaughter was Satan's assault through pagan Rome acting through Herod to destroy the infant King to keep his own kingdom, yet Jesus escaped to Egypt beyond Herod's reach because God's purpose cannot be overthrown.ST Sep 17, 1894ST Jul 13, 1915ST Dec 13, 1883RH Jan 22, 1901
Rachel's weeping nearly two thousand years after her decease and entrance into sheol was not literal tears in death but a figurative personification of bitter grief, which proves the dead in sheol are unconscious.RH Mar 28, 1865RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877ST Jun 23, 1881
The words they are not mean the children were dead, and the promise that they shall come again from the land of the enemy means they will be brought back from death and the grave by resurrection, for Heaven is no enemy.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Feb 24, 1881ST Aug 28, 1884ST Aug 14, 1879
They died innocent because mortality was inherited from Adam and not for sins committed, so their resurrection through the Saviour is unconditional and proves that little children who die will be saved to meet their parents in glad reunion when Christ comes.RH Sep 28, 1911ST May 6, 1886ST Jan 22, 1880ST Jul 9, 1894
Text and Historical Setting
Then was fulfilled introduces the scripture carried out by Herod's decree to kill the children in Bethlehem, identifying the words as spoken by Jeremy the prophet and connecting the historical killing with the prophetic words about Rachel mourning quoted next.ST Jan 11, 1899ST Jul 9, 1894ST Nov 15, 1910ST Feb 15, 1899ST Aug 30, 1905 The formula marks the slaughter of the innocents and the mothers' grief over the murdered children as the fulfillment of Jeremiah's prophecy, even showing that this terrible event in Jesus' history carried out what the prophets had foretold.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Nov 15, 1910ST Feb 15, 1899ST Aug 30, 1905ST Nov 15, 1910 Jeremiah the prophet named here prophesied in the days of Josiah, contemporary with Zephaniah and close to the time of Habakkuk.ST Aug 6, 1912
The verse belongs to events soon after Jesus was presented in the temple under the law and immediately before Joseph fled with him to Egypt, falling chronologically in the middle of Luke 2:39.ST Jul 2, 1894ST Jun 5, 1879RH Jun 16, 1874 Scripture here places widely separated events close together while omitting intervening events, since Luke's return to Nazareth passes over the visit of the wise men, the sojourn in Egypt, and the return after Herod's death before the settlement in Nazareth.ST Jun 5, 1879RH Dec 22, 1868RH Jun 16, 1874 After all things required by the law when Jesus was forty days old, the family returned to Bethlehem and were there found by the wise men, then at God's warning Joseph fled into Egypt and stayed till Herod's death, then returning out of Egypt he was afraid to stop in Bethlehem and so retired to his old home in Nazareth.RH Dec 22, 1868RH Jun 16, 1874
The wise men found the family in a house in Bethlehem when Jesus was at least forty days old and possibly older, though the precise age cannot be determined.ST Feb 2, 1915 His birth shortly before Herod's death, which historical dating fixes in the latter part of 4 B.C., helps establish when he was born. That night of horror at Bethlehem came about twelve years before the boy Jesus discoursed in the temple at Jerusalem, and brought death and lasting ruin to Bethlehem families.ST May 31, 1910
The event marked is Herod's killing of the male children two years old and under in Bethlehem and its vicinity and surrounding region, probably fewer than two hundred.RH Oct 19, 1869RH Aug 11, 1853ST Apr 26, 1910 Soldiers under the king's command entered the town at night searching for the child regarded as a rival king, falling suddenly upon the village and its environs to destroy one child, slaughtering many innocents in order to get rid of one innocent though holding no ill will against Bethlehem's infants themselves.ST Sep 11, 1884 The slaughter brought bloodshed and cries from those who witnessed it, with mothers crying out and weeping over dead bodies while little ones were killed. The mothers' cries over their slain children rose from the hills of Judah in the anguish Jeremiah described, bringing grief to parents, desolation to the town, and deep sorrow over an act of senseless cruelty in sharp contrast to the purpose of love associated with Christ's coming.ST May 8, 1907RH Dec 18, 1913ST Feb 17, 1904 Angels are pictured weeping over the scene, with one mother escaping with her baby and one infant saved from the sword, while women were left childless and families suffered lasting ruin.ST May 31, 1910
The massacre occurred shortly before Herod's death, when he believed the child born in Bethlehem had perished with the other children.ST Apr 19, 1910 His reputation for such killing of children was not undeserved.RH Feb 21, 1871 The absence of other known testimony does not make Matthew's account unauthentic, since one declaration of Inspiration is sufficient, while even Celsus took notice of the Gospel history.RH Jul 10, 1860RH Sep 11, 1860 The slain infants were not the 144,000.RH Oct 19, 1869
The calamity was permitted to humble the Jewish nation because of its pride and wickedness, and God would have protected them from their enemies had they been faithful.RH Dec 24, 1872ST Dec 2, 1880 Their pride and false claims about Christ's earthly kingdom had stirred Herod's envy and hatred, for Herod feared the child would become king and sought to kill Jesus because of a false picture of a Messiah coming in earthly grandeur rather than humility and poverty.RH Dec 24, 1872ST May 8, 1907 The Jews misread prophecy, expecting the Messiah to take David's throne by force and restore political liberty and privileges, while Herod and the religious leaders expected Christ to reign as a temporal ruler though the chief priests and scribes professed to understand the prophecies about his appearing.ST Jun 16, 1887ST Jun 16, 1887
Prophecy Fulfilled Literally
Matthew 2:17 marks Herod's killing of the male children two years old and under in Bethlehem and its surrounding region, and the weeping and great mourning in Ramah at the loss of children, as the fulfillment of Jeremiah's prophecy in Jeremiah 31:15 of Rachel mourning for her children and refusing comfort because they are gone.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Jan 11, 1899RH Aug 11, 1853RH Sep 9, 1902 Mothers mourned and would not be comforted because their children were gone when Herod had the infants slain while seeking to destroy the infant Jesus.ST Jan 11, 1899RH Apr 17, 1855RH Aug 11, 1853RH Sep 9, 1902 The prophecy's past-tense wording did not confine it to Jeremiah's own time but applied to an event more than six hundred years later, as Matthew's explanation makes clear.ST Jan 2, 1879 It was fulfilled literally as a sign at Christ's first advent.ST Jan 2, 1879RH Aug 11, 1853
Even this terrible event belongs to the prophetic record concerning Jesus and evidences his Messiahship.ST Jan 23, 1912RH Nov 8, 1906ST Aug 30, 1905 The slaughter of the children in and around Bethlehem fulfilled a specific prophecy spoken by the prophet, so that even this event in Jesus' history carried out what the prophets had foretold.ST Jan 23, 1912RH Nov 8, 1906ST Aug 30, 1905 Human opposition to God's purpose could unwittingly bring prophecy to pass.ST Jan 23, 1912
The prophecy has a double application to Israel's captivity and restoration as well as to the children.ST Aug 28, 1884 Like the captive Israelites taken into an enemy's land, the children were taken into death, which is an enemy's power under the devil.ST Aug 28, 1884 The promise that they will come again and return to their own land therefore fits both Israel's return from captivity and the children's restoration from death.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Aug 28, 1884 The children were innocent sufferers because Christ was in the world.ST Jul 9, 1894
Christ Attacked Yet Preserved
Herod sought to destroy the infant King to preserve his own kingdom, enraged by the possibility of a rival and fearing the child would become king.ST Jul 13, 1915ST Feb 2, 1915ST May 8, 1907 The announcement that the King of the Jews was born troubled Herod and Jerusalem together and led to the decree against children two years old and under, following alarm at the report that the Messiah had been born King of the Jews as expected by many across the East on the basis of Jewish prophecy.RH Jan 8, 1857RH Feb 11, 1915 He acted on a false picture of the Messiah given by the Jewish rulers, looking for one who would come in earthly grandeur rather than in humility and poverty.ST May 8, 1907 At that time he was king of Judea under Roman rule and sought to destroy Jesus as a rival king, amid the removal of Judea's kingly power by pagan Rome.
The attempt on Christ soon after His birth was the beginning of Satan's assault against Him, and the empire through which Satan ruled stood behind the threat to His life.ST Dec 13, 1883RH Jan 22, 1901 It is symbolized by the great red dragon standing ready to devour the man-child as soon as He was born, and the man-child is Jesus Christ, for to no other do the words apply that her child was caught up unto God and to His throne.ST Dec 22, 1881 That dragon is pagan Rome before the church obtained supremacy, not the later papal power, and Rome acted through Herod as its representative.ST Dec 22, 1881 Herod as Rome's subject-king ordered the slaughter of the little children in an attempt to kill the infant Jesus, and the Roman governor sought His life.ST Dec 13, 1883ST Mar 5, 1912
Jesus was carried safely to Egypt beyond Herod's reach, and He escaped Herod's sword as the promised Messiah.ST Jul 13, 1915ST May 8, 1907 The attempt through pagan Rome under Herod to destroy the Christ-child failed, and the child remained the Hope of the race.ST Jun 27, 1911 That attempt to destroy the infant Saviour and thereby defeat the plan of salvation failed because God's purpose could not be overthrown.ST Jan 20, 1914 All the world may plot against the purposes of God but cannot defeat them, and just as the Lord cared for the infant Jesus and protected Him from all danger, so He will protect everyone who makes Christ his refuge.ST Sep 17, 1894
His preservation parallels that of Cyrus as a child when his grandfather ordered his death.ST Oct 6, 1914 The memory of Herod's terrible massacre of innocent children in hope of destroying the King of Israel later added to Joseph and Mary's fearful anxiety when, after losing Jesus for a day on the return from Jerusalem, they turned back sad and fearful to seek Him sorrowing in Jerusalem.
Dead Unconscious Not Weeping
Rachel had been dead and in sheol for long ages, nearly two thousand years, when her posterity were slaughtered, so her weeping for them was not literal tears shed in death but a figurative personification of bitter grief over the murdered children.RH Mar 28, 1865RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877ST Jun 23, 1881RH Sep 3, 1872 The figure pictures her breaking forth into lamentation and bitter weeping and refusing to be comforted because her children are not, with the Lord answering her to refrain her voice from weeping and her eyes from tears because her work shall be rewarded.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 23, 1881
The device is the same as dead kings overthrown by the king of Babylon rising from thrones in sheol to mock him, and slaughtered soldiers in the nether parts of the earth speaking to Pharaoh and being comforted or ashamed, which are not literal conversation, comfort, or shame among the dead.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 23, 1881 The verse therefore proves the dead in sheol are unconscious and shows the conversation between Dives and Lazarus in hades is figurative rather than literal.ST Jun 23, 1881
Children Raised From Enemy
The words they are not mean the children were dead, and the promise joined to them that they shall come again from the land of the enemy and return to their own border means they will be brought back from death by resurrection.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Aug 14, 1879ST Feb 11, 1886ST Apr 3, 1884 The mourning over the infants Herod killed, all under two years of age, fulfilled Jeremiah's prophecy of Rachel weeping, and the promise that her children would come again from the enemy's land gives hope that children who die will be restored.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Feb 11, 1886RH Sep 18, 1856 Death is an enemy whose dominion they will leave, and though cut off by death they will return through resurrection to their own border.ST Aug 14, 1879ST Feb 11, 1886ST Apr 3, 1884
Death is that enemy, and the grave is that land.RH Aug 4, 1874ST Feb 11, 1875ST Apr 3, 1884 Heaven is no enemy to children and is not the land of the enemy, so the children did not go at death to Heaven to be happy with angels in the presence of God but went into the land of the enemy, to the dead, to remain till Jesus comes to awake them, when death the last enemy shall be destroyed.ST Feb 24, 1881ST Aug 28, 1884RH Apr 14, 1874RH Jul 29, 1875 Herod's act placed those children under the dominion of an enemy, and the promise means they will be raised from death by resurrection, not that death is a friend or that the slain infants passed at once into the highest happiness.ST Aug 28, 1884RH Aug 4, 1874ST Feb 11, 1875 Until then they are in the grave and do not go to heaven at death, and even these innocent victims must wait in death until the final victory over death and the grave, for they are not already alive in heaven.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Sep 29, 1859ST Aug 20, 1896
They die because they inherited mortality from Adam, not because of sins they committed.ST May 6, 1886 Since they have committed no sin they cannot be condemned, and their resurrection is unconditional and comes through the Saviour, whose blood purchased them unto eternal life as redeemed people.ST May 6, 1886 The verse therefore proves that little children who die will be saved in the resurrection, with no exception stated even for children of unconverted parents.
This is the plainest text on the future life of infants.RH Jul 29, 1875 Its comfort to weeping mothers depends on parents meeting, knowing, and clasping their children again, rewarded at the resurrection morning when Christ comes, with hope in their end.RH Sep 28, 1911ST Jan 22, 1880RH Jul 29, 1875 The promise that those who mourn will be comforted and will return from the land of the enemy is applied to bereaved families as hope that death will not prevent a glad reunion when Jesus comes, when the dead will be restored and return to their own land and the mourners' work will be rewarded.RH Sep 28, 1911ST Jan 22, 1880ST Jul 9, 1894RH Sep 29, 1859 The children were innocent sufferers because Christ was in the world, martyred with their mothers weeping over their dead bodies, blessed martyrs in the cause of Christ.ST Feb 24, 1881RH Apr 14, 1874ST Jul 9, 1894ST Jul 22, 1897
Scripture Connections and Lessons
The verse belongs to the account showing that the Messiah went down into Egypt and was called out from there in fulfillment of Hosea 11:1.RH Nov 18, 1862 It stands with Matthew's birth record supporting that Jesus was born as a Jew, descended from David according to the flesh, so that rejecting that birth account would require treating it and related Scriptures as interpolations.ST Sep 29, 1909
Herod wanted to murder the infant Saviour singly and held no ill will against the infants of Bethlehem, yet he ordered a body of soldiers to fall suddenly upon the village and its environs and slay all the male infants, slaughtering many innocents in order to get rid of one innocent.ST Sep 11, 1884 Those who attack the Sabbath singly and then attack the whole decalogue in order to get rid of the Sabbath imitate Herod, not Jesus.ST Sep 11, 1884 Just as Christ escaped Herod's wholesale slaughter, the Sabbath will escape attempts to abolish the law associated with it.ST Oct 6, 1887
Herod's awful crime in slaying the innocent little ones of Bethlehem, terrible as it was, does not compare with the evil wrought upon infants by so-called soothing sirups whose essential ingredient is opium.ST Apr 9, 1912 Those sirups soothe the restless babe not by removing pain or healing disease but by deadening the nerves and benumbing the delicate nerve-cells of the brain into an unnatural stupor that always causes serious injury.ST Apr 9, 1912
The massacre of freedmen in Texas is likened to this Massacre of the Innocents because it involves the killing of innocent victims and the grief of their families, in connection with Jeremiah's prophecy of Rachel weeping for her children.RH Feb 19, 1867 Even when Herod lives and Jesus dies, violence against Jesus and the suffering of the innocent cannot destroy the truth.ST Jul 2, 1896
Sources