Matthew 22:21
They say unto him, Cæsar’s. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.
They say unto him, Cæsar’s. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Sabbath and Sunday Legislation
The seventh-day Sabbath as the Lord's holy day belongs entirely to God, bearing His authority, image, superscription and mark as holiness to the Lord identifying Him as Creator, and with baptism and the Lord's Supper it lies outside state authority to impose, regulate, interfere with or prohibit, so that when the state interferes the church has right and duty to protest while religious bodies must likewise remain within their proper sphere.ST Jul 3, 1907RH Oct 20, 1904ST Jan 30, 1907ST Dec 12, 1911ST Sep 13, 1905 What belongs to Caesar is to be rendered to Caesar and what belongs to God to God, church and state occupying different realms in God's plan to be kept forever separate, and civil laws designed to enforce Sunday observance violate this command since Sunday observance is a religious institution belonging to God not to Caesar, with compulsory Sunday legislation by Congress or state legislatures opposing true Christianity.ST Jul 3, 1907ST Sep 13, 1905RH Oct 10, 1912 Reverence for the Sabbath therefore belongs to God not the state and should be rendered to Him, requiring people to observe a sabbath regardless of faith makes them render to Caesar what belongs to God, and religious duties are not to be enforced by worldly power or legislation.RH Oct 20, 1904ST Dec 12, 1911ST Sep 13, 1905
Because God blessed and sanctified the seventh day for holy use after resting on it at creation, the Sabbath belongs particularly to God and should be spent to His glory as a delight holy to the Lord and honorable, turning from own pleasures on that day.RH Aug 11, 1859RH Dec 24, 1861RH Mar 21, 1865 God created the world and gave life and breath and all things, so every faculty of mind, every power of being, all strength and all time belong of right to the Creator, yet in benevolence He gave six days for secular wants to be rightly employed in secular affairs while reserving the seventh in memory of His own rest for holy worship when He could rightly claim all seven.RH Dec 24, 1861RH Mar 21, 1865ST Sep 16, 1880 The fourth commandment therefore does not require giving God something of one's own but requires not taking for self what God has reserved, and to observe the seventh-day Sabbath is to render to God what is His while to appropriate that day to self is to rob God.RH Dec 24, 1861RH Mar 21, 1865RH May 9, 1854 That thing which is God's is not man's day but God's day, claimed from beginning to end of the world, made holy and set apart for His service as long as sun and moon and heaven and earth endure, to be kept holy now today by spending it in worship of Him who gives life and breath and every day lived, a present urgent moral obligation.RH Aug 11, 1859RH May 9, 1854ST Sep 16, 1880
The duty to esteem the Sabbath above other days and observe it is due solely to God not to the state or to other people, each person to be fully persuaded in his own mind and answerable to God personally rather than to civil authorities, so that one failing to honor it is accountable to God alone.ST Oct 18, 1899RH Feb 2, 1860RH Feb 2, 1860 When government or people use it to require observance of a day they join what belongs to God with what belongs to Caesar and unite religion and state.ST Oct 18, 1899 In this application Sabbath-keepers should not resume worldly business until sure it has ended, closing the Sabbath with evening family worship to honor what is God's and guard against carelessness and against secular work encroaching on its beginning or close.RH Feb 2, 1860RH Feb 2, 1860
Sunday-keeping is neither a civil duty nor something God commands, so neither Caesar nor God authorizes anyone to require it.ST Oct 27, 1914ST Aug 31, 1888ST Jan 22, 1894 Civil government cannot rightly demand what a person is responsible to God alone for, because human life and its use are God's endowment which government cannot give or preserve, so it has no just right to divide a person's time into required working or resting hours.ST Oct 27, 1914 Ordinary Sunday labor restrictions were held by some to fall within secular administration's authority on the ground that ordinary work on Sunday is not itself a religious act and therefore not worship or religious exercise.ST Jan 22, 1894
The Sabbath in its true sense is strictly religious and belongs wholly to God so it can only be rendered to Him and cannot be touched by human legislation, while civil Sunday laws break this division by forcing on people a day bearing only the image and superscription of human government like the penny shown to Christ and not the mark of God who made the Sabbath.RH Dec 22, 1910 No state law can change Sunday's character or make it holy, and state legislation on conscience overthrows religious liberty; what is needed is not state power but the gospel's transforming power to make people new and lead them to keep the law God Himself wrote. The claim that a state-enforced rest day is only civil, giving more even privilege for voluntary worship and quiet devotion, is false because the Lord's day itself is a religious observance, so enforcing its rest enforces religion, compelling all to rest to give ministers opportunity to convince the idle confuses the two realms and gives the church help from the state for her ends.RH Dec 22, 1910
A state's claim that a day is the Lord's day does not make that day God's Sabbath, and Sabbath rest belongs to God because it meets spiritual not physical human needs over which civil government has no rightful authority.ST May 19, 1914AS Sep 25, 1889ST Mar 19, 1894 Even if Sunday were the day that ought to be kept sacred it would still be owed to God and not to civil government, because every person gives account of himself to God, and the state may allow rest or not but must not impose religious duties or penalties since Sabbath-keeping cannot be made genuine by civil force because the state cannot discern the heart's motives.ST May 19, 1914ST May 28, 1912AS Sep 25, 1889 If the Sabbath is the Lord's day its observance is owed to God not the state and should be encouraged through persuasion, education and love with equal rights for different days, for people owe God what He requires with free conscience and human authority must not compel religious belief or worship.ST May 28, 1912AS Oct 9, 1889ST Nov 28, 1911 Sunday legislation is therefore religious legislation favoring Sunday observers while burdening people who worship on another day or do not worship and violating their God-given liberty, and to forbid work on the first day after a person has rested on the seventh is religious persecution and invasion of inherent rights.ST May 19, 1914ST May 28, 1912
Matters civil relating to duty to fellow men and to the state may be regulated by civil governments, but matters lying between soul and God are outside their authority, including even duties between man and man when prescribed by God, because God's prescriptions are spiritual and civil governments cannot enforce spiritual law and have no right even to attempt it.ST Jan 23, 1907ST Oct 23, 1893RH Oct 8, 1908 Governments may forbid murder, theft, adultery and injury to reputation not because God commands it nor as standing in God's place but as absolute necessity for safety of the state and protection of subjects, needed even in a government of infidels, while Sabbath observance bearing His image and superscription as holiness to the Lord pertains to motives which no civil power can compel to keep holy.ST Oct 23, 1893 Any earthly attempt to enforce God's commands is folly bringing contempt and weakness on government, persecution on the sincerest opposers, and insult to God, and requiring civil authority to enforce religious observance sets aside the Christian principle of separation for a pagan principle since divinely commanded observance rests on divine law not civil support.ST Oct 23, 1893RH Oct 8, 1908 The principle also applies to the Sabbath because God gave it, it bears His authority and belongs to Him rather than to Caesar, and the verse is thus the basis for opposing Sunday laws by asking whether Sunday belongs to Caesar or God and by opposing making business rights depend on Sunday observance.RH Oct 10, 1912ST Mar 28, 1906ST Jan 23, 1907
Image and superscription decide whose a coin is and whether it is genuine and current in that kingdom, so Sunday bearing not God's image and superscription is not current coin in heaven but counterfeit, and calling it the Sabbath of the Lord cannot make it genuine any more than calling a lie truth or black white can change them.ST Oct 29, 1896ST Aug 20, 1912ST May 30, 1895 The seventh-day Sabbath bears God's image and superscription proving it the genuine holy weekly day while the first-day sabbath is counterfeit, and whether the first-day sabbath is of God or man is tested by God's sanctification and command with a man-made day bearing humanity's image and a humanly chosen day-line unable to make the divine creation appointment inconsistent.RH Oct 31, 1871ST May 30, 1895ST Dec 17, 1902 A counterfeit bill does not become genuine by passing through a thousand good honest hands nor the genuine less genuine for lack of recognition, and good men keeping Sunday ignorantly believing it taught of God are accepted in spite of error because hearts are right to lead to greater light, but sincerity no more makes the coin better than innocently passing a counterfeit note makes the note good.ST Oct 29, 1896ST Aug 20, 1912ST May 30, 1895
Civil legislation has its own sphere and cannot strengthen God, support His law or decide worship, so putting God and the Sabbath into the Constitution, legislating Sunday in place of the Lord's Sabbath and calling the first day, the heathen sun's day, the Sabbath substitutes a human institution for God's ordained Sabbath, teaches commandments of men, places man above God and pretends to work for God while deceiving men with world and souls at stake.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Nov 12, 1894ST Oct 15, 1894 Forcing people to give civil power what belongs to God puts state above God, puts Caesar in God's place and makes Caesar a god, and Sunday legislation superintended by clergy does this by rejecting God's commandments and substituting Babylonian Sunday for Jehovah's Sabbath, which is enforced Baal worship preventing the loyal from giving Creator and Redeemer desired obedience.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Nov 12, 1894 The Sunday holiday as Rome's special protege belongs to Rome to be rendered in Rome's own way.ST Oct 15, 1894
Like the Lord's Supper and baptism the Sabbath rests on a religious rather than civil basis, so Sunday laws prescribing religious observance and making otherwise legitimate work a crime cross the distinction between civil and religious duties.RH Oct 8, 1908ST Jul 4, 1899 Human government can never enforce God's Word, law or Sabbath but only a man's idea of what God requires, so religious teachers must not be trusted with Caesar's power to enforce Sabbath observance, a dangerous power once used to hold Jesus ought to die for not keeping the Sabbath as they kept it and now to hold those keeping the same Sabbath Jesus kept ought to die for not keeping a day Jesus never observed.ST Jul 4, 1899
There are two separate spheres of what belongs to Caesar and what belongs to God, with overt acts between man and man belonging to Caesar regulated by civil law as crime, while relations between man and his God belong to God alone and do not come within civil law at all.ST Nov 5, 1894RH May 14, 1901 The Sabbath belongs unto God, bears His image and superscription, cannot be kept holy unto man and has nothing to do with man's relation to fellow man, so no man has right to forbid or force another's observance and there would be no Sabbath law where this distinction was believed and practiced.ST Nov 5, 1894 Civil government should receive what properly belongs to it while God governs the moral kingdom belonging to Him, the state remaining within its legitimate role rather than coercing conscience, the Sabbath as God's gift kept as delight, and imposing a spurious worship day violates this distinction.ST Nov 5, 1894RH May 14, 1901
The Sabbath belongs to the Lord not to any one nation, is for humanity honoring the Creator, and must be rendered to God as His due giving others what is rightfully theirs and God what is rightfully His.RH Oct 16, 1856
Property Tithes and Offerings
God has a prior and first claim on property as the author of existence and giver of power to get wealth, so holders are stewards answerable to him for its use, bought by redemption to dedicate themselves and all they have to advance his cause.RH Aug 13, 1872RH Feb 25, 1904RH Sep 25, 1856 Every dollar is a trust bearing his image and superscription, and the world's goods are lent by the Lord to be used faithfully in his work, while taxes are owed to earthly governments in return for protection of persons, lives and property.RH Aug 13, 1872RH Jun 30, 1859ST Jul 25, 1911 What he has reserved as his own, the Sabbath and one tenth of what is received, must be honored with unreserved surrender of self including the body, with one tenth of income as the minimum sacred portion and many called to give more.RH Feb 25, 1904RH Mar 16, 1916 Faithful giving of what is due to God includes tithes and offerings, and withholding payment for work or goods received in support of his cause fails that stewardship.RH Sep 25, 1856
Paying tribute to Caesar recognized his authority, and by comparison paying tithe recognizes God's interest in every dollar received.RH Oct 19, 1916 What belongs to God must be rendered by planning for the Lord first and giving him the best strength and first fruits of labor, thought at the week's beginning, not putting self first and leaving him the remainder.RH Apr 16, 1867RH Feb 19, 1867 To put personal interests first and leave God whatever remains robs him of what is due, and systematic benevolence pledges are to be met as conscience before personal interests as owed to God and not merely to men.RH Apr 16, 1867RH Feb 19, 1867
What belongs to God includes wealth to be used for his glory and to do good, and those prospered must honor him with offerings in proportion to blessings in self-sacrifice and gratitude.ST Mar 22, 1883ST Aug 8, 1878RH Jul 27, 1876 Those who withhold rob God, lose the increase they could have gained, and fail to lay up treasure in heaven, and when possessions and worldly business absorb affections and devotion and religious privileges are neglected they fail to render what is his.ST Mar 22, 1883ST Aug 8, 1878RH Jul 27, 1876 Property must not be valued above God, people or heavenly things but gained honestly and temperately and used for real needs, help and truth, and using it for temporal and spiritual good shows love while gaining and using at cost of health and happiness for no real need shows excessive love of property.RH Jun 13, 1865RH Apr 30, 1867 Offerings do not enrich God but serve the giver's own good, and gold and silver offered with humble grateful obedient love show that all one has and is belongs to God, for obedience is better than sacrifice and an offering without pure love is unacceptable.ST Jun 11, 1894 Using wealth to save others gives back his own and adds to heavenly treasure, while turning blessings to curse by neglect of devotion withholds his due.ST Jun 11, 1894ST Aug 8, 1878RH Apr 30, 1867
Earthly blessings and possessions test whether people honor God's claims and obey truth rather than use worldly interests as excuse to withhold what belongs to him.ST Apr 22, 1875 Money bearing Caesar's stamp can become greed when hoarded for earthly wealth, turning what is owed to Caesar into selfishness and sacrificing moral and spiritual good.ST Nov 17, 1898
Caesar's claims are to be met but do not take precedence over God's, so being in debt does not excuse withholding a suitable offering including the tithe, and God's claims including tithe are not to be set aside until every other claim is paid.RH Jun 2, 1868ST Nov 11, 1880 A debt to others does not cancel what is owed to God, for the tithe belongs to God not the giver and must be paid promptly rather than used for another purpose.RH Mar 13, 1879 Paying Caesar first does not excuse withholding a tithe already promised, for vows to God must be fulfilled.RH Jan 19, 1869 Caesar has claim to taxes and self and family have needs, but God has a separate claim to what is vowed and pledged, and both must be paid without one robbing the other.RH Jul 23, 1872 Using all for self, family finery, taxes and self while leaving God only a promise, on the excuse that charity begins at home and taxes come first, withholds his due so he cannot safely bless, and debtors should account debts and give a proportion of the remainder, since providing for children does not cancel prior sacred tithes.RH Jun 2, 1868RH Jul 23, 1872
What belongs to God includes vows, pledges and freewill offerings set by property and prosperity, to be done diligently, punctually and liberally.RH Apr 16, 1872RH Jul 16, 1872 God's claims are as just as Caesar's, so pledged contributions should be paid promptly preferably monthly as Caesar's claims are met, for paper pledges are not funds until paid, and meeting systematic benevolence pledges on time renders God his own while failure robs him.RH Sep 4, 1866RH Jun 20, 1871 Withholding or postponing tithes and solemn pledges is robbing God, excused only by utter inability to pay promptly.ST Jan 29, 1880 Honesty, liberality and promptness with men leads to honesty with God, while putting personal wants first leaves inability to give God his due by spending trusted money selfishly instead of letting it work in his cause, which will be demanded with usury.RH Jun 20, 1871 Paying taxes does not fulfill duty to God, and systematic benevolence is the orderly way to give, with God first and served supremely and first.RH Jun 9, 1859RH Jun 20, 1871
Rendering God his own requires more than thanks, requiring tithes, offerings, self-denial and missions in prayer and giving especially as earthly powers pass.ST Apr 24, 1879 Withholding or turning from commands grieves the Spirit, weakens faith and harms witness, while remembering missions fulfills duty.RH Sep 8, 1863 The tithe is God's due on income reckoned after deducting expenses of acquiring it apart from own labor but without deducting family living expenses so all stand equally, and the safest rule is to give God all his own as one would want reversed. Doing so enters partnership with God not as commercial investment bringing no special credit since only duty, yet by grace bringing all promises, showing God's plan better than human substitutes. Church giving must be free-will tithe of increase willingly given not assessed from Caesar's tax books, with a loyal heart glad to give and feeling deprived when unable.RH Jan 29, 1861ST May 22, 1907 A wife may tithe her own funds but not her husband's household funds against his will to avoid strife since he is chiefly responsible and unwilling giving is not required, and pledges leaving families without necessities are not required.RH Jan 1, 1875ST May 22, 1907
Christ was willing to give Caesar whatever was due, but the nearby fish-coin account concerned temple service not Roman government and does not show he used miracle to ease a personal civil-tax obligation.ST Mar 26, 1896 Those concerned for God's things can trust him to care for them and theirs.ST Nov 13, 1893 Paying public taxes does not prevent supporting religious schools by private subscription.ST Jul 12, 1905
Conflict Obedience and Persecution
Support and obedience owed to civil authority are due only so long as its claims do not conflict with duty to God, while God's claims are always to be answered with obedience.ST Apr 25, 1878ST Jun 29, 1882RH Sep 16, 1909 Those living under the protection of the governing power are to render to that power the support it claims, remaining peaceably subject to the laws of the land, for the coin's image and inscription identify what belongs to the governing power.ST Apr 25, 1878ST Jun 29, 1882 Caesar's authority does not extend to what belongs to God, and when a ruler claims what is God's that authority must be resisted, with supreme obedience given to God.RH Sep 16, 1909ST Jan 2, 1907 When a law conflicts with duty to God the Christian's purpose is to obey God rather than men even at cost of martyrdom, yet without rebelling against civil government, continuing duty without resistance even if that obedience incidentally means disobeying the government, and taking that stand with courtesy and respect.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Aug 13, 1912
Civil rulers may govern temporal affairs but must not take God's place over conscience, worship and the personal relation to God, for duty to God has prior and supreme claim.RH Feb 3, 1910RH Feb 1, 1906ST Jan 2, 1907 No ruler, state, church authority or human demand may receive what belongs to God, and civil commands that usurp His authority over worship must not be obeyed but met with loyalty to God.RH Feb 1, 1906RH Jul 14, 1904RH Mar 2, 1916 State intrusion on the personal relationship between a person and God usurps divine prerogatives and trespasses on holy ground.RH Feb 3, 1910 The Sabbath belongs to God and not to Caesar, so a demand to keep a humanly appointed day cannot override the duty to obey God, and refusing such a demand does not forfeit the right to government protection.RH Mar 13, 1900 Human law requiring Sunday observance conflicts with the command to keep the seventh-day Sabbath, and the conflict is a test of loyalty in which God is to receive obedience and honor above every earthly power.ST Jun 4, 1894
What belongs to Caesar is tribute, honor, respect and obedience to ordinances of men necessary for protection in the enjoyment of equal natural rights, to be rendered not for fear of punishment but for the Lord's sake, and in that sphere the Christian will have no conflict with government.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Dec 3, 1896 What belongs to God is conscience and obedience in matters of conscience, which must be rendered to God, so when governments require disobedience to God they must not be obeyed in those matters.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Dec 3, 1896ST Jan 23, 1901 This is shown by God's deliverance of Daniel from the lions' den, the three Hebrews from the fiery furnace, and Peter and John and Paul and Silas from prison where they were placed for disobeying human enactments.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Dec 3, 1896 Subjection to earthly powers must never conflict with subjection to God, and when civil requirements interfere with duty to God, God's authority takes precedence even at cost of martyrdom, though disobedience to the state in that conflict is no wrong against the ruler when it violates no proper civil duty.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Dec 21, 1888ST Jan 23, 1901
Early Christians followed the distinction by meeting civil obligations but refusing to recognize the state's authority over religious duty or to worship the emperor and pagan gods, and their obedience to God therefore brought them into conflict with officials and exposed them to persecution. When the principle is ignored, rulers and religious authorities use coercion and persecution to demand religious conformity. Christians belong to a kingdom which is in but not of the world, for which no earthly potentate has right to legislate and for which Christ alone is king, acknowledging no allegiance except to Him and regarding human laws as extraneous foreign statutes imposed from without.ST May 22, 1901 They yield ready obedience to every just requirement that does not conflict with the higher law and the rights of conscience, but assume the right to judge for themselves whether any law may be conscientiously obeyed, and refuse conflicting laws even in face of torture and death.ST May 22, 1901 Even the service they render to Caesar is not from fear of civil wrath but from conscience toward God, because after conversion the individual is the Lord's free man and no longer Caesar's slave.ST May 22, 1901
Caesar's civil authority and God's authority have distinct bounds, and explaining where Caesar's authority ends and God's begins is necessary to preach the third angel's message.RH Nov 28, 1907 Rejecting the principle and allowing religious legislation opens the way to persecution, for the state is forbidden to take control of religious duties.ST Jul 19, 1905 Legislating religious duties such as Sabbath observance puts the state in God's place, and coercion in religious and moral questions leads to persecution, as shown by the persecutions of the Dark Ages and by Sunday laws. Church and state must remain separate, and joining them darkens the world, as the Dark Ages give evidence of the danger of that union.ST Jul 16, 1902
Giving civil rulers what belongs to them and giving God what belongs to Him continues because Christ did not come to take civil rule in this present evil world.ST Jan 21, 1903 Until the gospel completes its mission He occupies only a throne of grace, ministering His own blood as priest for remission of sins, and cannot yet sit upon David's throne, with the divided duty lasting until the kingdoms of this world become the Lord's at the sounding of the seventh angel when the mystery of God is finished.ST Jan 21, 1903 Obedience to human laws prepares and disciplines for obedience to God's laws and is a mature fruit of that obedience, while revolt against human law belongs to a wider rejection of law beginning in denial and defiance of God.ST Dec 15, 1887 Christians are not to act as censors over Caesar's acts, though they may regret his failure to assure an oppressed people of their freedom.ST Feb 15, 1899
Church Mission Without Politics
The verse lays down a broad principle for every age and people that people have duties both of a spiritual and of a civic nature, forever severing church and state as each independent and coordinate and supreme in its own sphere.RH Jul 25, 1912RH Apr 10, 1900ST Nov 27, 1901 The church, whatever its name, is to give itself to spiritual concerns with hands clean and clear of civic activity in its own behalf, and in America no church is to dominate the state and none is to be hindered in its spiritual activity.RH Jul 25, 1912ST Mar 27, 1907 Religion is to have nothing to do with the state and the state is to have nothing to do with religion, the state remaining neutral with no hand turning in favor of any particular religion and the name of no religion given precedence over any other.RH Jul 25, 1912RH Apr 10, 1900 Civil laws that are clearly civil apply equally to everyone while people remain free to follow religious conscience, and when the state stops legislating for religion and the church stops seeking state power to enforce its rules, each can receive what is properly due to it.ST Mar 27, 1907ST Feb 21, 1911ST Dec 14, 1915 The kingdom of Christ cannot be advanced by civil force, and using civil law to enforce religious views violates the principle and threatens liberty, persecution and return toward Dark Ages conditions, since religious devotion is a person's relation to God not something the state can command or secure.ST Feb 21, 1911ST Dec 14, 1915ST Oct 10, 1906 The church has no divine authority to interfere in civil affairs, and using government power to advance the church contradicts the teaching.ST Dec 14, 1915ST Nov 27, 1901
The religion of Christ does not seek aid from Caesar financially or otherwise, but divides what belongs to Caesar from what belongs to God and leaves the church to work without help from civil government.RH Mar 23, 1905ST Dec 23, 1903ST Mar 3, 1890 Its force is shown by the first century when Christianity made its most decisive progress while not only unaided but bitterly opposed by civil government, and by the opposite course in later years when church members sought and obtained state aid with the result of the Dark Ages.ST Dec 23, 1903ST Nov 12, 1894 Christ sought no government aid to spread his teaching and affirmed liberty to teach religion contrary to state law, and Christians need not oppose government in order to keep that separation.RH Mar 23, 1905ST Mar 3, 1890 The gospel is to be taught through persuasion, for Christ's authority and the power imparted through His Spirit are sufficient for the church's work, and seeking state power denies that sufficiency.ST Oct 10, 1906ST Jun 15, 1904 Church-state alliances can corrupt the plan of salvation and harm both church and state, and forcing people to propagate religion departs from Jesus' plan.ST Oct 10, 1906RH Nov 27, 1913 The kingdom is advanced by slow hand-to-hand saving of men one by one and by producing Christian manhood as the source of all genuine reformation, not by planning on a larger scale, striking for high places, capturing king and court or Congress and cabinet, gathering youth into a political party against corruption, or repeating the mistake of Rome and the Middle Ages when whole nations were converted by converting their kings.ST Nov 12, 1894ST Jun 15, 1904
Civil government and the church have distinct spheres and each must leave the other's province alone.RH Oct 5, 1911ST Jun 15, 1904 The church may act as a body of citizens on a weekday, but it has no right to use its worship service or its institutional authority to direct the government, just as government has no right to direct the church.RH Oct 5, 1911ST Jul 29, 1897 Civil government has legitimate work of restraining wrongdoing and jurisdiction over public acts to protect rights, but it cannot make the world Christian and must not be used to enforce duty to God, worship or belief.ST Jun 15, 1904 Christianity governs through love that regenerates the soul and brings love and peace because affection and will cannot be ordered from without, while Christ's rule concerns the heart and depends on willing loyalty with love rather than force.ST Jun 15, 1904 Those who desire conversion of the world must leave civil power to its own sphere and work for and with Christ through persuasion and self-spending effort constrained by love alone, and churchmen should not meddle in secular government but attend to living and preaching the gospel lest seeking influence cause spiritual loss.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Feb 28, 1911
The saying stands beside the teaching that His kingdom is not a worldly kingdom maintained by fighting, showing His kingdom is not advanced by fighting.ST Jun 11, 1912ST Jul 4, 1899 Jesus acknowledged Rome by directing people to give Caesar what belonged to Caesar while reserving to God what belonged to God, and did not seek political reform by repealing laws or imposing punishments, for His work was to regenerate people and lead them to God.ST Mar 11, 1913ST Apr 25, 1900 His work was to save sinners, not to regulate civil affairs or reform governments through political action, and He refused to endorse popular political ambitions or make religion a tool of political government, setting this principle for all time.ST Apr 25, 1900ST Jun 30, 1898 The verse is the only recorded statement made with reference to the Roman Empire, spoken while the greatest despotism ever known ruled the habitable globe, which was left alone apart from commanding this rendering, showing He was not a reformer in the usual sense nor engaged in repealing bad laws nor providing punishments for violators of good ones.ST Mar 11, 1913ST Mar 4, 1913 He left inheritance division to civil courts and instructed followers to respect Caesar's claims without interfering in politics, living the distinction without force to compel or protect His work even when opposed, showing the gospel is not spread or defended by the sword.ST Apr 25, 1900ST Jun 30, 1898
Representatives of Christ can render to government what belongs to it and to God what belongs to God without conflict by having nothing to do with earthly politics because Christ never had.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Aug 20, 1894 His kingdom is not of this world to govern by force but is from above and requires only obedience of loving choice, with no policy or politics but ruled by love, with no law except love and no force except love.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Aug 20, 1894 This love is of universal application with no law against its exercise, its length and breadth and height and depth infinitely greater than all worldly policy, and the work of the church is by precept and practice to manifest it toward all of every nation, kindred, tongue and people as the sum of preaching the gospel to every creature.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Aug 20, 1894 Following Christ and the apostles who never sought state aid to enforce moral sentiment or doctrine, never tried to reform politics by political action, never sought office for themselves or friends, but only did good and preached Christ, Christians obey God rather than men if Caesar demands more than his due and patiently bear consequences.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Aug 20, 1894
Caesar represents human government operating by force and sword, a temporary necessity because sin makes people resist God's law and violate one another's rights.ST Mar 29, 1905 Civil government maintains order while redemption gathers those willing to return to God's government of love, but the state is not the end or goal of redemption.ST Mar 29, 1905 Christian duty does not make national or political causes the same as God's cause, and civil and religious concerns are not to be collapsed into one.RH Dec 1, 1910 When the church dominates the state, people are led to render to Caesar what belongs to God.RH Dec 1, 1910ST Mar 29, 1905
The distinction supports keeping church and state entirely separate including in education.RH Mar 16, 1905RH Mar 2, 1905 Civil government should not enforce religious observances such as Sunday rest, since people owe civil obedience within rightful civil authority while religious duties belong to God.RH Mar 30, 1905 To say good citizenship rests on morality based on belief in God and therefore the state must teach it in schools makes religion the foundation of the state and support of religion the first duty of rulers, which is union of church and state abandoned at America's founding for a new order in which the state does not incorporate religious teaching.RH Mar 30, 1905RH Apr 13, 1905 The light on church-state relation must be set before the public when public schools are proposed as channels for religious instruction, before bishops, college presidents, ministers, laymen and boards of education, and the question is whether Bible reading, religious instruction or worship in public schools attacks separation dear to the American people.RH Mar 2, 1905RH Apr 13, 1905
The principle protects individual freedom in faith and rejects regulating religion by corporate body, monarch or state, and changing the Constitution to give government power over religion opposes the teaching.AS Aug 14, 1889ST Aug 6, 1894 It was eventually to be expressed in a nation's government after individuals had received and acted on it, and is the scriptural basis for separation not merely toleration or concession.ST Nov 8, 1905 A government respecting this separation is in that respect in harmony with Christian principles, so the United States when its constitutional separation is followed represents the Christian ideal, founded on this governmental principle in contrast to colonial governments at enmity with it, with no religious test and no establishment law as triumph of Christianity and true Protestantism following justification by faith and equality of believers.AS Aug 14, 1889ST Jun 25, 1894 Temporal things are left to temporal power while faith, conscience, reason and soul are withheld from federal invasion, a rule upheld in the gospel's infancy, lost when Christianity was adopted by the Roman chief and bound in unholy connection with the state, and accepted again when the Federal Constitution withheld power to invade reason, conscience and soul.ST Nov 8, 1905ST Aug 6, 1894 Scripture foretells when this nation will abandon it, and turning to Caesar by religious legislation in the National Reform movement for Christian citizenship leaves God's territory, darkens the world and divides civil from Christian citizenship.AS Aug 14, 1889
Constantine's union of imperial rule with religious authority changed Christianity's direction and made the distinction no longer operative in practice as Rome became temporal and political power.ST Jul 19, 1905RH Feb 7, 1907 After his adoption of Christianity and role at Nice, church and state became confused and the church took temporal power with the distinction treated as having no application.ST Jul 19, 1905RH Feb 7, 1907 Christ's recognition of Roman authority through Pilate was misapplied by claiming it established the church's authority as Rome's successor.ST Jul 19, 1905ST Mar 2, 1904 Caesar's authority does not make the state a proper teacher of God's religion, for the only religion Caesar can teach is his own, and state theology has provided basis for persecution.ST Mar 2, 1904RH Mar 9, 1905
Giving God what belongs to God includes, in the teaching of those who held it, amending the National Constitution so the nation acknowledges Christ as Ruler and Head and ordains union in His name and glory.ST Aug 18, 1887RH Aug 25, 1904 Against this, recognizing God in the Constitution need not blend church and state or endorse a sect, the verse does not authorize Congress to set a national religious standard or compel belief, and difficulty in deciding claims does not make the church final authority over state or conscience.RH Feb 18, 1909RH Apr 13, 1905RH Jul 9, 1908 The saying is cited for separate civil and spiritual spheres with temporal authority supreme in temporal matters and the church claiming no jurisdiction there, though claims to correct rulers for sinful use of power are also described, and petitions presented as a church movement are distinguished from action as citizens.RH May 23, 1865RH Apr 13, 1905RH Jul 9, 1908
The state has a place but must not take God's place or receive worship, for treating the state represented by its flag as substitute for Deity confuses religion and government toward paganism.RH Mar 30, 1905AS May 29, 1889 Placing In God We Trust on coinage wrongly mixes devotion with a civil instrument, like fourth-century coins bearing Christ's name on one side and the sun-god's image on the other.RH Dec 12, 1907RH Mar 30, 1905 When a nation orders public observance of religious festivals it unites church and state and gives homage through civil authority, violating separation.RH Apr 21, 1903RH Apr 21, 1903 A proclamation requiring or recommending worship improperly uses Caesar's authority to demand what only God may require, and supervision of practice with ministers taking oaths like civil officers mingles sacred and secular against gospel principles.AS May 29, 1889RH Sep 24, 1908
Civil power must not be used to compel observance or enforce reforms, for God requires supreme allegiance to His Word and loyalty to Christ.ST Feb 14, 1906RH Dec 1, 1910 Remaining faithful even when professed churches seek state support is required, and failure is betrayal of Christ.ST Feb 14, 1906RH Dec 1, 1910
Sources