Matthew 27:47
Some of them that stood there, when they heard that, said, This man calleth for Elias.
Translations
Some of them that stood there, when they heard that, said, This man calls for Elias.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Some of them that stood there, when they heard that, said, This man calleth for Elias.
Some of them that stood there, when they heard that, said, This man calleth for Elijah.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And some of them that stood there, when they heard it, said, This man calleth Elijah.
And certain of those standing there having heard, said — 'Elijah he doth call;'
And some of those who stood there, when they heard [ it], said, This [ man] calls for Elias.
Now certain of them who were there standing, when they heard, began to say—This man, calleth, Elijah.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
When some of those standing there heard this, they said, “ He is calling Elijah.”
Some of them who stood there, when they heard it, said, “ This man is calling Elijah.”
And some of those who were near by, hearing it, said, This man is crying to Elijah.
And some of them that stoode there, when they heard it, said, This man calleth Elias.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And some that stood there and heard, said: This man calleth Elias.
Pictures



Cross-references
- Mark 15:35-36
And some of them that stood by, when they heard it, said, Behold, he calleth Elias.
Bystanders mistake Jesus’ cry for a call to Elijah and expect Elijah to come.
- Psalms 22:1
My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me? why art thou so far from helping me, and from the words of my roaring?
Jesus’ cry of being forsaken echoes the psalm’s opening words.
- Luke 23:44-46
And it was about the sixth hour, and there was a darkness over all the earth until the ninth hour.
Both recount the darkness, Jesus’ final cry, and his death.
- Mark 15:34
And at the ninth hour Jesus cried with a loud voice, saying, Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani? which is, being interpreted, My God, my God, why hast thou forsaken me?
Mark records the same cry from the cross.
- John 19:16-30
Then delivered he him therefore unto them to be crucified. And they took Jesus, and led him away.
parallel account of same suffering
- Luke 23:35-36
And the people stood beholding. And the rulers also with them derided him, saying, He saved others; let him save himself, if he be Christ, the chosen of God.
Rulers and soldiers mock Jesus at the cross.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
19 sources
This man calls for Elijah was the mistaken hearing of bystanders who took his cry to God from the cross for a call for that prophet, Elias being the Greek form of Elijah.Ms 29, 1909, par. 18DA 741DA 741.3Lt 1a, 1861, par. 2–5ST Aug 1, 1878 He hung on the cross in agony while darkness covered the earth and the sun hid its light, dying as that darkness passed away amid signs in nature with the earth quaking and rocks torn.EW 148.1Lt 1a, 1861, par. 2–5ST Aug 1, 1878Ms 39, 1898, par. 21–22ST Apr 15, 1897 The priests and rulers seized on the misunderstanding to mock him with contempt in his dying suffering, refusing him final relief and telling the crowd to leave him alone to see whether Elijah would come to save him.Lt 230, 1907, par. 12–16Ms 45, 1897, par. 16–17DA 754.3ST Jan 27, 1914GC88 666.2–667.2 His endurance under that derision and injustice stands as the example of faith holding firm against human power, teaching self-sacrifice, patience under affliction, and solemn consecration to God.ED 254.2–3ST Jul 7, 1898Ms 80, 1886, par. 3–5GW92 360.3
Misheard Cry at Calvary
Elias is the Greek form of Elijah, and some of those standing by the cross misheard or misunderstood Jesus' cry to God as a call for that prophet.Ms 29, 1909, par. 18DA 741DA 741.3Lt 9a, 1891, par. 21–22 They thought He was calling for Elias while He was dying.Ms 29, 1909, par. 18DA 741.3Lt 9a, 1891, par. 21–22
The saying belongs to the crucifixion, when He hung on the cross in agony while the sun hid its light and darkness covered the earth, and He died as that darkness passed away.Lt 1a, 1861, par. 2–5ST Aug 1, 1878ST Apr 15, 1897 People standing nearby mistook His cry as a call for Elijah while He endured mockery and suffering on the cross.Lt 1a, 1861, par. 2–5ST Apr 15, 1897
It follows the laying on His bruised and bleeding shoulders of the cross prepared for Barabbas, to be suffered with two companions of Barabbas who were to die at the same time with Him.DA 741.4–742.1 He was too weak to carry it, having taken neither food nor drink since the Passover supper, having agonized in Gethsemane, having endured betrayal and seen His disciples forsake Him and flee, having been taken to Annas, then to Caiaphas, then to Pilate, then to Herod, then again to Pilate, having passed from insult to insult and mockery to mockery and been twice tortured by the scourge through the night, yet having spoken no word but that which tended to glorify God and having borne Himself with firmness and dignity, until He fell fainting beneath the burden.DA 741.4–742.1 The crowd that followed from the judgment-hall to Calvary saw His weak and staggering steps without compassion and taunted Him for being unable to carry the heavy cross, and when laid on Him again He fell again so His persecutors saw He could carry it no farther.DA 741.4–742.1 The Jews themselves could not bear the humiliating load because defilement would prevent keeping the Passover, and none even of the mob would stoop to bear it.DA 741.4–742.1
It shows Christ approaching the cross and descending into humiliation in the hands of wicked men with His own nation clamoring for His blood, crowned with thorns by Herod and his soldiers, clad in the purple robe, bowed before and struck with the reed placed in His hand, scourged as the worst of criminals, rejected when the murderous Barabbas was chosen in His place, and lifted up dying as a malefactor.ST Jul 7, 1898 He was the one in whom the disciples centered their hopes of eternal life and whom they thought would take His place on David's throne, and seeing Him so gave them cause to mourn and fast, tried their faith, and caused their hope and courage to fail.ST Jul 7, 1898 It belongs to the climax of His suffering when He was in the hands of the cruel mob, crowned with thorns, treated with derision and insult and mockery, and stretched upon Calvary's cross as a malefactor.Ms 80, 1886, par. 3–5 His followers watching saw Him whom they had believed would deliver Israel dying as a criminal, so their hopes died and their agony at that critical moment was beyond measure.Ms 80, 1886, par. 3–5
His death was accompanied by heaven's presence and by signs in nature and surrounding events: darkness covered the earth for three hours, the earth quaked and shook, and rocks were split and torn.EW 148.1Ms 39, 1898, par. 21–22 His loud cry as He died troubled His enemies and made His murderers tremble.EW 148.1 The disciples, whose hopes of His reigning as a temporal king died with Him, were left sorrowful and afraid.EW 148.1
Mockery and Faithful Endurance
Those standing near the cross treated his cry to God as a call for Elijah, and the priests and rulers seized on that misrepresentation to mock him with contempt.Ms 45, 1897, par. 16–17 That mockery belonged to the final scenes at the cross, where the crowd derided him in his dying agony.Ms 45, 1897, par. 16–17GC88 666.2–667.2
The priests mocked him in his agony with bitter contempt and scorn after the darkness lifted and he revived to a sense of physical suffering and thirst.DA 754.3 Then a Roman soldier, pitying his parched lips, offered him vinegar on a hyssop stalk.DA 754.3 His cry of abandonment, Eloi, Eloi, lama sabachthani, was misinterpreted as a call for Elias.DA 754.3 While darkness had covered the earth they had been filled with fear, and as their terror abated the dread returned that he might yet escape them.DA 754.3 So they refused the last opportunity to relieve his sufferings and said to leave him alone to see whether Elias would come to save him.DA 754.3
The priests and others misunderstood his cry to God as a call for Elijah, mocked him by saying he was calling for Elijah, and told the onlookers to wait and watch to see whether Elijah would come to save him.Lt 230, 1907, par. 12–16ST Jan 27, 1914 In doing so they refused him his final opportunity for relief.Lt 230, 1907, par. 12–16ST Jan 27, 1914
On the cross he stood against the Jewish priests and rulers who used the Roman governor to carry out their will, and his endurance stands as faith holding firm against human power and injustice.ED 254.2–3 His agony on the cross teaches self-sacrifice, patience under affliction, and solemn consecration to God.ED 254.2–3GW92 360.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
52 sources
Some standing near the cross heard His cry to His Father and mistook it for a call for Elijah, for Elias is the Greek form of Elijah.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Sep 11, 1866RH Jul 19, 1864RH Jan 11, 1915 They mocked Him for calling for Elijah and challenged Him to wait to see whether Elijah would come to rescue Him, and then one gave Him vinegar before He cried again and gave up His spirit.ST Jan 27, 1914ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jan 24, 1911RH Mar 24, 1863 This belonged to His death on Friday about the ninth hour, at three in the afternoon of the Passover, after the darkness from noon until three had ended and at the time of the evening sacrifice.ST Jul 25, 1878RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 7, 1851ST Jun 7, 1899ST Jun 20, 1911 His anguished cry of forsakenness was uttered while crushed beneath the sin of the world to redeem the ruined race, revealing the dreadful evil of sin and the withdrawal of His Father's favor against sin.RH Feb 1, 1870RH May 27, 1873RH Feb 21, 1865RH Mar 25, 1873 Though apparently forsaken, He rested by faith in His Father's character and prior acceptance and was victor, showing that His affliction did not mean the Father had ceased to love Him.RH Jan 14, 1904RH Mar 21, 1912ST Oct 7, 1897
Hour Darkness and Death
This saying belongs to the account of Jesus' death on Friday at about the ninth hour, three o'clock in the afternoon of the Passover.RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 7, 1851RH Sep 5, 1865 It stands after His declaration, It is finished, and His death marks the completion of the atonement.RH Aug 15, 1854RH Apr 7, 1851 The crucifixion and its hour in the afternoon of the Passover are expressly mentioned also in the Babylonian Talmud, a Jewish record kept by bitter enemies who freely admitted His miracle-working power while ascribing it to magic and to clandestinely acquiring the pronunciation of the ineffable name of God.RH Sep 5, 1865
That death took place after the ninth hour, when the darkness had ended, and between the two evenings, at the time of the Passover sacrifice.ST Jun 20, 1911 Supernatural darkness covered the earth from noon until three o'clock, shortly before He cried out and died.ST Jul 25, 1878ST Aug 1, 1878ST Sep 12, 1900 He died as that darkness passed away, with the land covered in darkness as He cried aloud before dying.ST Aug 1, 1878ST Jun 7, 1899 The final scene moves from the darkness over the cross to His final declarations and death, as people watched Him suffer and heard His words.ST Jul 25, 1878
His death was accompanied by cosmic signs, for the sun hid its face, the earth shook, the rocks were rent, the tombs gave up their dead and graves were opened.ST Apr 3, 1893ST Jun 30, 1909 Jewish leaders witnessed the tragedy, including the darkness and earthquake, and heard the Roman soldiers declare that He was the Son of God.ST Jul 8, 1913 It was an awful, gloomy midday when light was darkened and day was turned to night as He hung and died for sinners.RH Aug 5, 1873 That darkness came with no eclipse, like that of May 19, 1780.RH Aug 5, 1873
The cry is placed amid the darkness and suffering of His death and is given as Eloi Lami Sabachthani.RH Nov 6, 1860 It belongs to the last act of His humiliation, in which He bore the sin of the world and remained to the end a forgiving, saving friend, pitying His persecutors, praying for His executioners, and saving a condemned criminal.ST Jun 9, 1898 It belongs to the description of Calvary's awful agony and to the passion of the Son of God in His trial and crucifixion.ST Sep 3, 1912ST Mar 6, 1879 That trial and crucifixion at Calvary was a scene of cruel mockery and terrible suffering.ST Feb 16, 1882
Misheard Cry for Elijah
Elias is the Greek form of Elijah.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jan 11, 1915
Some of those standing near Jesus heard His cry from the cross to God and misunderstood it as a call for Elias or Elijah.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Sep 11, 1866RH Jul 19, 1864RH Apr 21, 1863RH Aug 26, 1875
This belongs to the account of His suffering and death at Calvary on the cross, in Satan's final attempt to destroy Him when the Roman governor Pilate authorized the crucifixion and He was buried in a tomb sealed with the Roman seal.RH Sep 11, 1866RH Jul 19, 1864ST Oct 25, 1905
Bystanders used the misunderstanding to taunt Him, demanding that Elijah come to deliver Him.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jan 24, 1911
They mistook His cry of anguish as a call for Elijah while He endured mockery and suffering hanging on the cross.ST Apr 15, 1897ST Jan 24, 1911
The priests and others misunderstood His cry to God as a call for Elijah, mocked Him by saying He was calling for Elijah, refused His final opportunity for relief, and told onlookers to wait and see whether Elijah would come to save Him.ST Jan 27, 1914
After some mistook His cry for a call to Elias, another person gave Him vinegar to drink, before He cried again and yielded up His spirit.RH Mar 24, 1863
Suffering Borne for Sinners
On the tree at Calvary He fainted and was crushed beneath the load of sin after His wounding at Pilate's bar, uttering His cry of forsakenness to redeem the ruined race.RH May 27, 1873 He bore the sin of the world with the sin of the world upon Him, mocked and crucified.RH Feb 21, 1865 He ascended Calvary carrying human guilt amid a jeering multitude, spilling His precious blood and expiring in quivering agony as the Lamb of God for sinners, whom guilty sinners crucified.RH Mar 25, 1873RH Feb 6, 1879
His anguished cry of being forsaken evidences suffering endured for humanity, including the withdrawal of His Father's smiles and wrath against sin.RH Feb 1, 1870 That suffering gives the clearest discovery of the dreadful evil and exceeding sinfulness of sin.RH Feb 1, 1870RH May 27, 1873 His cry of desolation rent the earth and hid the sky and was part of sufferings not yet measured, wrought by the sins and guilt of sinners.ST Oct 22, 1885 To the end He remained a forgiving, saving friend, pitying His persecutors, praying for His executioners, and saving a condemned criminal.ST Jun 9, 1898
At the ninth hour the outer darkness lifted from the people but still enveloped the Saviour as a symbol of the agony and horror weighing on His heart.RH Jan 14, 1904 No eye could pierce the gloom around the cross and none could penetrate the deeper gloom enshrouding His soul, while the vengeance of heaven appeared to fall on Him for claiming to be the Son of God.RH Jan 14, 1904 The voices then expressed the belief that the bolts of God's wrath were hurled at Him, and many who believed on Him heard His despairing cry and lost hope, asking in what His followers could trust if God had forsaken Jesus.RH Jan 14, 1904 He had drained the last dregs in the cup of human woe and was apparently forsaken of God, yet acquainted with His Father's character, justice, mercy and great love, He relied on the evidence of His Father's acceptance heretofore given, rested by faith in Him whom it had ever been His joy to obey, committed Himself in submission to God until the sense of loss was withdrawn, and by faith was victor.RH Jan 14, 1904
His affliction, like Job's, did not mean God had ceased to love Him or had forsaken Him, the Father being moved against His beloved Son without cause.RH Mar 21, 1912 God's love for Him then was no less than when the voice declared This is my beloved Son at the Jordan and on the holy mount, and no less than in the wilderness of temptation, in Gethsemane, or amid the enshrouding darkness of Calvary when His visage was marred more than any man, and Jesus' own love did not lessen in that suffering.ST Oct 7, 1897 Love abides above changing feeling and exuberant joy as an eternal, abiding, life-giving principle.ST Oct 7, 1897 He approached the cross descending into humiliation, in the hands of wicked men with His own nation clamoring for His blood, crowned with thorns, clad in the purple robe, bowed before and struck with the reed placed in His hand, scourged as the worst of criminals, rejected when the murderous Barabbas was chosen in His place, and lifted up dying as a malefactor, though the disciples centered in Him their hopes of eternal life and thought He would take His place on David's throne.ST Jul 7, 1898
History Prophecy and Witness
The saying about calling for Elias belongs to the crucifixion, which is his death as the great sacrifice for human sin and the Messiah cut off in the middle of the seventieth week. It belongs to the history of his trial and execution and burial, told with minute accuracy in its allusions to customs, opinions, political events and other circumstances of that time.RH Feb 11, 1862 That surrounding narrative — being brought to Pontius Pilate as governor of Judea whose sentence was necessary, derision before execution, scourging before crucifixion, the written accusation in three languages affixed to the cross, bearing the cross, and giving up the body for burial at the request of friends — is circumstantial and consistent throughout with the known manners and institutions of that period.RH Feb 11, 1862 The details come not forced or fetched but accidentally in slight and distant allusion in the natural progress of the narrative, which shows truth and not a fabricated story artfully blending truth with falsehood.RH Feb 11, 1862
The principal transaction of the crucifixion took place in the afternoon of the Passover at three o'clock, and that crucifixion and the hour of the day are expressly mentioned in the Babylonian Talmud.RH Sep 5, 1865 That Talmud is a Jewish record kept by the most acrimonious enemies Christianity ever had, who freely admitted his power of performing miracles while ascribing it to magic and to clandestinely acquiring the pronunciation of the ineffable name of God.RH Sep 5, 1865 Jewish leaders witnessed the tragedy, including the darkness and earthquake, and heard the Roman soldiers declare that Jesus was the Son of God.ST Jul 8, 1913 People at the cross had joined in mocking Jesus, but the darkness later stirred their consciences so that they recognized they had done wrong, rejected the priests' false accusations, and became convinced that Jesus was no pretender, and some later became converts when Peter preached at Pentecost.ST Jul 25, 1878
The crucifixion is one time when the majority was wrong in religion, for from Enoch till now majorities have generally if not always been wrong.RH Sep 10, 1872 The side the crowd took against Christ therefore proves that sincerity, majority, and antiquity are no test of truth.RH Sep 10, 1872 The last act on Calvary came amid the jeers of throats that had once praised him, in the relentless persecution of the Harmless One in Galilee and Judah's streets, when the fiend turned Judea's heart against her Lord and taught her that act.ST Mar 11, 1903 That act sealed the doom of evil and its king and forever showed what cherished thoughts of self produce even in one endowed with glory, beauty, and wisdom and familiar with the love and peace of heaven.ST Mar 11, 1903 Countless millions peopling circling orbs watch these problems worked out on earth and trace the fruits of evil from the first fratricide through its lurid history of tears and blood to this deed.ST Mar 11, 1903 Seeing a cherub thus transformed into a malignant fiend warring against his God inspires dread of evil and causes loathing and fear of transgressing the perfect law of love even by a thought, while time's record places eternal safeguards against experiment and hearts redeemed from sin or proof against its wiles find age by age new beauties in him whose law is freedom, love, and perfect bliss.ST Mar 11, 1903
The scene belongs to the first advent, when the disciples expected him to take the kingdom and to be crowned king of Israel, but he instead went to the cross and was buried and died on Calvary in painful reversal of their hopes.ST Aug 13, 1902ST Jul 27, 1882 After escorting him in triumph into Jerusalem only a few days earlier they saw their Master put to death and felt bitter disappointment, yet they were blessed by receiving the truths he had taught.ST Jul 27, 1882RH Jul 6, 1869ST Mar 24, 1887 Seeing him so — in the hands of wicked men with his own nation clamoring for his blood, crowned with thorns, clad in the purple robe, bowed before and struck with the reed placed in his hand, scourged as the worst of criminals, rejected when the murderous Barabbas was chosen in his place, and lifted up dying as a malefactor, though in him they centered their hopes of eternal life and thought he would take his place on David's throne — gave the disciples cause to mourn and fast, tried their faith, and caused their hope and courage to fail.ST Jul 7, 1898 His suffering at Calvary shows the dark and painful experiences through which God's purposes are worked out, and his earthly mission was successful even when it appeared to end in defeat at the tomb.ST Aug 22, 1900ST Feb 4, 1913 It belongs to Satan's final attempt to destroy him, in which the Roman governor Pilate authorized the crucifixion and he was buried in a tomb sealed with the Roman seal.ST Oct 25, 1905
Example and Present Application
The reading of the account of Christ's sufferings at the crucifixion can help subdue pride and discontent.ST Apr 17, 1879 On the cross His conduct presents an example of calm self-possession under suffering, showing that Christian repose is not inaction but a steady mind sustained by faith in God and confidence in His promises.ST Jul 29, 1886 There on the cross all sorrows met amid torture and mockery, and the cry that bystanders took as a call for Elias was a cry of desolation that rent the earth and hid the sky.ST Oct 22, 1885 It was part of sufferings not yet measured, wrought by the sins and guilt of sinners, and telling these woes one by one lets sinners feel the bitter throes of grief that sin brings and learn how vast His love is that counts their guilt overpast to win and keep them at last.ST Oct 22, 1885
He ascended Calvary carrying human guilt amid a jeering multitude while His precious blood was spilled, crying to God of being forsaken and expiring in quivering agony as the Lamb of God for sinners.RH Mar 25, 1873 His crucifixion was an awful gloomy day at noon when light was darkened and day was turned to night while He hung upon the cross and died for poor sinners, a darkness like that of May 19, 1780 that came with no eclipse.RH Aug 5, 1873 This suffering requires sinners to deny appetite, vanity and pride, crucify tinsel, forsake idols, and obey God.RH Mar 25, 1873 It calls sinners to believe the awful truths of God's pure word and receive grace from Christ.RH Aug 5, 1873
On the cross He cried out in the bitterness of His soul, and His anguish pictures the fear and trembling of God's remnant people for their safety in the time of the pouring out of the seven last plagues.RH Apr 3, 1866 Like Israel pressed by the Egyptians at the Red Sea they will cry out in bitterness in Jacob's trouble before deliverance comes.RH Apr 3, 1866 Facing Calvary, He is the Pilot who also faced Gethsemane and the prison house and the tomb and came forth a conqueror from it all.RH Feb 4, 1915 That same conquering Pilot is on board today not as a passenger but as the pilot with His hand on the helm to carry the ship through dangerous seas to the land of promise.RH Feb 4, 1915
Sources