Matthew 6:4
That thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father which seeth in secret himself shall reward thee openly.
Translations
That your alms may be in secret: and your Father which sees in secret himself shall reward you openly.
That thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father which seeth in secret himself shall reward thee openly.
that thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father which seeth in secret himself shall reward thee openly.
That thy alms may be in secret; and thy Father who seeth in secret, himself will reward thee openly.
that thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father which seeth in secret shall recompense thee.
that thine alms may be in secret: and thy Father who seeth in secret shall recompense thee.
that thy kindness may be in secret, and thy Father who is seeing in secret Himself shall reward thee manifestly.
so that thine alms may be in secret, and thy Father who sees in secret will render [ it] to thee.
that thine alms may be in secret,—and, thy Father, who seeth in secret, will give it back to thee.
so that your giving may be in secret. And your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will reward you.
so that your giving may be in secret. And your Father, who sees what is done in secret, will Himself reward you openly.
so that your merciful deeds may be in secret, then your Father who sees in secret will reward you openly.
So that your giving may be in secret; and your Father, who sees in secret, will give you your reward.
That thine almes may be in secret, and thy Father that seeth in secret, hee will rewarde thee openly.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
That thy alms may be in secret, and thy Father who seeth in secret will repay thee.
Cross-references
- Matthew 6:18
That thou appear not unto men to fast, but unto thy Father which is in secret: and thy Father, which seeth in secret, shall reward thee openly.
Fasting is practiced in secret, with reward from God openly.
- Mark 12:43-44
And he called unto him his disciples, and saith unto them, Verily I say unto you, That this poor widow hath cast more in, than all they which have cast into the treasury:
The widow’s small offering is valued above larger gifts.
- Matthew 5
And seeing the multitudes, he went up into a mountain: and when he was set, his disciples came unto him:
Both texts are part of Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount.
- Matthew 23:5
But all their works they do for to be seen of men: they make broad their phylacteries, and enlarge the borders of their garments,
Secret service contrasts with works done to be seen.
- Ecclesiastes 12:14
For God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil.
God judges secret deeds, whether good or evil.
- 2 Corinthians 9:6-8
But this I say, He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully.
Generous giving is joined with God’s abundant provision.
- Luke 21:1-4
And he looked up, and saw the rich men casting their gifts into the treasury.
The widow’s gift shows that inward devotion outweighs the amount.
- Luke 18:9-14
And he spake this parable unto certain which trusted in themselves that they were righteous, and despised others:
Both contrast humble devotion with religion displayed for others.
- Proverbs 11:25
The liberal soul shall be made fat: and he that watereth shall be watered also himself.
Generous giving is met with increase and blessing.
- Matthew 6:19-21
Lay not up for yourselves treasures upon earth, where moth and rust doth corrupt, and where thieves break through and steal:
Giving in secret is connected with laying up treasure in heaven.
- Luke 16:15
And he said unto them, Ye are they which justify yourselves before men; but God knoweth your hearts: for that which is highly esteemed among men is abomination in the sight of God.
What people esteem highly may be abomination to God.
- Luke 12:2-3
For there is nothing covered, that shall not be revealed; neither hid, that shall not be known.
What is concealed will be revealed and spoken openly.
- Psalms 51:6
Behold, thou desirest truth in the inward parts: and in the hidden part thou shalt make me to know wisdom.
Inward truth is joined to God seeing in secret.
- Luke 14:13-14
But when thou makest a feast, call the poor, the maimed, the lame, the blind:
Promises recompense for generosity to those unable to repay.
- 1 Corinthians 4:5
Therefore judge nothing before the time, until the Lord come, who both will bring to light the hidden things of darkness, and will make manifest the counsels of the hearts: and then shall every man have praise of God.
God brings hidden things to light.
- Matthew 25:34-40
Then shall the King say unto them on his right hand, Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world:
Service to those in need is recognized and rewarded by God.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
38 sources
Alms are to be given sincerely, quietly and privately for the benefit of the suffering poor, not to attract attention, praise or honor or to create an outward appearance of goodness.DA 312.1–2DA 298BS 8.2–3 Charitable actions may be made known when the purpose is to encourage others to give and to glorify God, but they must never be displayed for self-glory or to advertise generosity.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 God sees the motives behind acts of giving and judges them even when people praise those acts, so good deeds done to win human approval receive no reward from Him and have only that praise as their reward.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 18822SP 12.1–13.1GW 275.3 Acceptable giving comes from pity, love, compassion, a kind heart and wholehearted devotion for those who suffer, offered for God's glory with pure motive in penitence and humility.ST Apr 7, 1909BS 8.2–3 The Father who sees what is done in secret rewards it openly, and God Himself is the great reward as givers grow in His character and become like Him, with character softened, refined and ennobled into the image of Jesus.ST Apr 7, 1909DA 312.1–2ST Apr 7, 1909DA 298
Sermon Setting and Background
The saying was uttered on a mountain before a large gathering, given especially to the disciples while the multitudes also listened.DA 298.1DA 298.2–3 Those hearers included people from Galilee and many other regions, and many among them were ignorant and in error.DA 298.1DA 298.2–3
It belongs to the Sermon on the Mount, which presents truth from God spoken with Christ's own authority in terms simple enough for a child to understand without being misled.FE 309.1STE 10.1 That sermon teaches the far-reaching principles of God's law, that the state of the heart regulates life and character and that meeting the claims of the law requires having its spirit in the heart.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34 It corrects a false picture of God and reveals Him as a compassionate, loving Father, and the Father who sees in secret reflects that paternal care.FE 309.1
The saying shows the heavenly Father's requirement that His people walk in the light He gives them.ST Mar 26, 1896 That requirement is always reasonable and just and accepts nothing less than perfect obedience to His commandments.ST Mar 26, 1896 Failure to walk in the light God had given was separating the Jewish people from God.ST Mar 26, 1896 Darkness comes upon those who refuse that light in the same proportion as the light has been permitted to shine upon their pathway.ST Mar 26, 1896
At Christ's first coming the Jewish nation did the opposite, giving alms to be seen of men.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872 This open display belonged to proud boasting of righteousness, together with making broad their phylacteries and uttering long prayers in the marketplaces to be seen of men, an outward show without inward piety done from love of worldly honor and exaltation and desire to impress others with importance, zeal and devotion to religious duties.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872 Their religion was formal, consisting of ordinances and purifications, rites and ceremonies, and was not heartfelt, yet they made their religious profession very prominent.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2 While making this display their hearts were hard, unmerciful and corrupt, lacking personal piety and virtuous character.RH Dec 17, 1872 They ground the faces of the poor and took advantage of them in every way possible, exacting heavy sums and taxes from the conscientious, the poor, the widow and fatherless for the treasury, devouring widows' houses, and robbing God by appropriating the offerings of the people to themselves.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872
Secret Giving Explained
Alms are to be given sincerely, quietly and privately for the benefit of the suffering poor, not to attract attention or to win public notice, praise or honor for oneself.DA 312.1–2DA 298BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 18821T 194.1 Deeds of charity done quietly for God's glory are seen by the Father who sees in secret and rewards openly, while good deeds done to win human approval receive no reward from Him and have only that praise as their reward.DA 312.1–2DA 298BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 18821T 194.1 Almsgiving done to win notice is only an outward show of goodness and does not show true mercy or devotion, for true religious character is not measured by public display.DA 312.1–2BS 8.2–32SP 12.1–13.1 Charity given without seeking a name glorifies God and is noticed in heaven, and secret acts of kindness toward a poor brother bind hearts together.DA 312.1–2BS 8.2–31T 194.1 Benevolence takes its noblest form when offered with pure motive in penitence and humility, and sincere service rendered through grace forms the character, restores its original loveliness, imparts Christ's attributes, gives heaven's peace and joy in blessing others, and fits for trusted service.DA 312.1–2BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882
The command does not require every good deed to be hidden so that little is done.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 Charitable actions may be made known or seen when the purpose is to encourage others to give and to glorify God and to testify to genuine faith, but they must not be displayed for self-glory or to advertise generosity and win reputation.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 What is condemned is charity performed for display and reputation, making the giver the center of attention instead of recognizing that good works come through the Holy Spirit.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 Giving for admiration may even be funded by exploiting the poor.1T 193.1–2
Christ's quiet works of mercy without self-exaltation exemplify this unassuming service, shunning human praise.BS 13.12SP 30.3–31.1 In contrast, the chief priests, scribes, elders and religious leaders made charitable acts conspicuous and gave publicly to draw attention to themselves and trumpet their deeds for effect.BS 13.12SP 30.3–31.1 Keeping the command in Christian work means self is kept out of view and Christ is exemplified.6T 472.1Lt 52, 1886, par. 3 Making self the center, the alpha and omega, and bringing self to the front in conversation, preaching and all efforts, talking of self and past deeds, magnifying good things done, and covering mistakes and undone duties with excuses while keeping Jesus in the background breaks its command.6T 472.1Lt 52, 1886, par. 3
Motive and Divine Seeing
The Father looks past outward appearance to the motive that prompted every act of giving, judging it even when human voices praise it.GW 275.3 Deeds that seem virtuous may spring from selfishness or hypocrisy, and His judgment of each act turns on the motive behind it.GW 275.3
Alms are acceptable when they flow from pity, love and compassion for those who suffer, from a kind heart and wholehearted devotion rather than from a wish to display good deeds.ST Apr 7, 1909 They are to be offered for God's glory with pure motive, in penitence and humility, and benevolence in this noblest form is what makes the act acceptable to Him.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882 Sincere love without show, not desire for praise, is the true motive in service.ST Apr 7, 1909
Good deeds done to win people's praise and human approval receive no reward from the Father, for display, praise and honor from men cannot earn His recognition.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882 Those who give for admiration receive that praise as their only reward, while secret acts of kindness for one in need are acceptable to God and will be rewarded by Him.BS 8.2–3ST Nov 25, 18861T 193.1–2 True religious character is not measured by public display, and outward show of goodness to win notice is not true mercy or devotion.2SP 12.1–13.1 Public display meant to advertise generosity is condemned, in contrast to humble giving to advance God's cause, for good works may be seen when their purpose is to glorify God and testify to genuine faith.1T 193.1–2 Giving for reputation may even be funded by exploiting the poor.1T 193.1–2
God regards with approval the hidden efforts of humble believers, knowing their quiet victories over temptation and their acts of kindness even when others do not notice them.ST Sep 21, 1882 He sees all that is done and said in secret and will bring hidden things to light, with works leading to justification or to condemnation.Ms 60, 1890, par. 11
Father's Open Reward
The Father who sees what is done in secret rewards it openly, and every good work done without show is met with His open reward.ST Apr 7, 1909DA 2982SP 204.1Lt 170, 1899, par. 20 Charity is not to be displayed for self-glory, human praise or honor, and kindness done for reputation and display stands condemned, for true godliness does not seek to make the giver the center of attention but to glorify God.ST Apr 7, 1909 This does not require kindness to be hidden in every case, for generosity may be spoken of and charitable actions may be made known when the purpose is to encourage others to give.ST Apr 7, 1909 Good works done in this spirit are recognized as coming through the Holy Spirit, and those who handle the Word and seek to advance His cause are called to truth in the inward parts, carefully considering plans, signing no agreement that dishonors God, and keeping out threads of selfishness.ST Apr 7, 1909Lt 170, 1899, par. 20
Service is to be given for its own sake and not from desire for reward, yet secret kindness does not go unrewarded.ST Apr 7, 1909 The reward is not to be the giver's motive, even while God faithfully sees charitable acts done without show and rewards them openly.ST Apr 7, 1909 God Himself is the great reward, received and enjoyed as the soul becomes like Him in character.ST Apr 7, 1909 When people give themselves and their gifts to God in service to others, God gives Himself to them, and they receive rich blessing as they become channels of blessing to others, with spiritual blessing and growth like a stream that nourishes the land through which it flows.ST Apr 7, 1909
The open reward is assimilation to the image of Jesus by looking away from self to Him, burying self-exaltation out of sight and making Christ a daily companion.DA 312.1–2Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33 Character is then softened, refined, ennobled and given fragrance like lilies and pinks, restored to its original loveliness and imparting Christ's attributes so that God's image shines in the life and the soul is made ready for the heavenly kingdom.DA 312.1–2Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33 Wholehearted service as a follower of Christ draws the heart into close sympathy with God, and God's Spirit brings forth the soul's sacred harmonies in response to the divine touch. Those who walk and work with God have heaven's peace, begin to experience His kingdom, find joy in blessing others, and are accepted and trusted for His service.DA 312.1–2 Even humble deeds that receive no praise here develop unselfish, ennobling character, draw the giver closer to God, are recognized in heaven, and are a sign of union with Christ.DA 312.1–2 To live with Christ is to stand in open view of the unseen world of heavenly intelligences where nothing is hidden, and they care for the soul with the exact remedy needed, never with flattery or human exaltation.Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33
God knows all self-denial and every sacrifice and the spirit and motive prompting action, including His tried servants accepting a self-sacrificing lower wage to advance soul-saving work.Ms 12, 1913, par. 161MR 84.1–85.1 Those who come into right relationship with God in this self-denial are seen by Him and rewarded openly not with money but with living success and victory wherever they go, victory after victory.Ms 12, 1913, par. 161MR 84.1–85.1 His open reward is blessing on labor, turning matters in favor when least expected, opening doors, and sending angels to help in hard places.Ms 12, 1913, par. 161MR 84.1–85.1 Reaching after higher and still higher wages places them where they no longer stand on vantage ground.Ms 12, 1913, par. 161MR 84.1–85.1 In the same way, kindness and material help given to support those bearing testimony, done without public recognition, are faithfully recorded and will not go unrewarded.SG2 68.1 Loving care and travel assistance given despite reproach for such support, as in the case of the Nichols family, are seen by God without seeking recognition and will be openly rewarded.LS 228.1
God who sees in secret will openly reward those who have declared the truth in His name.ST Feb 6, 1896 Ministers who are giving the last message of mercy to the world, presenting the truth in sincerity and relying upon God for strength, need never fear their efforts are in vain.ST Feb 6, 1896 Although no human eye can see the flight of the arrow of truth and no human ear hears the cry of the wounded soul, the truth silently cuts its way to the heart and God speaks to the soul.ST Feb 6, 1896 In the day of final account God's minister will stand with the trophies of redeeming grace to give honor unto Christ, to whom honor is due.ST Feb 6, 1896
Daily Life Application
Matthew 6:4 holds lessons still not fully learned, teaching that every gift comes from God and is to be recognized as coming from Him, and that gratitude for His goodness filling the heart brings a heavenly atmosphere around the soul.STB 823.2–3 It calls for ordering life by the truth of God found in His word, studying the Scriptures diligently not as a make-believe story but as the truth of the living God.STB 823.2–3 Studied in this way Scripture becomes the foundation of faith and the assurance of hope of eternal life in the kingdom of heaven.STB 823.2–3
Its teaching directs the heart toward contentment and submission to the Holy Spirit, being content to serve where God has placed them and seeking His approval rather than seeking recognition or pushing others aside for personal plans.AFUP 13.3 Its teaching on self-denial calls for using entrusted means for God's work rather than for self-interest, giving to those in need secretly with the Father who sees in secret rewarding openly.AFUP 13.3Lt 104, 1907, par. 7–8 Because God sees in secret and rewards every good work openly, those handling the Word and seeking to advance His cause must have truth in the inward parts, carefully considering plans, signing no agreement that dishonors God, and keeping out threads of selfishness.Lt 170, 1899, par. 20 The same truth that God sees what is done in secret applies to secret confession to God, laying bare plans, faults and sins before Him and putting wrongs right before it is too late.Lt 13, 1895, par. 20–22
The open reward comes to the one who buries self-exaltation out of sight and makes Christ a daily companion.Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33 To live with Christ is to stand in open view of the unseen world of heavenly intelligences where nothing is hidden, and they care for the soul with the exact remedy needed, never with flattery or human exaltation.Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33 That reward is assimilation to the image of Jesus by looking away from self to Him, with character softened, refined, ennobled, given fragrance like lilies and pinks, and made ready for the heavenly kingdom.Lt 46, 1900, par. 31–33 Keeping the verse means self must not be the center, the alpha and omega; talking of self and what was done in the past, magnifying good things done, covering mistakes and undone duties with excuses, and in conversation, preaching and all efforts bringing self to the front, exalting self and keeping Jesus in the background breaks its command.Lt 52, 1886, par. 3 Such self-conceit and self-love grieve the Spirit and cause Him to depart, bar the way to usefulness, and leave only a past experience with no Christ for today, so keeping the verse requires being a converted person with the transforming grace of Christ and a fresh daily experience of what Jesus is doing now, for unless converted even one called good, liberal and kindhearted will never see the King of heaven.Lt 52, 1886, par. 3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
104 sources
Alms to the needy are to be given quietly and without display, not done before others to be seen and praised by them.ST May 3, 1899RH Apr 16, 1901ST May 12, 1881ST May 24, 1905 What gives the gift its worth is the inward motive, sincere love and compassion for God's glory and the good of others rather than vanity and desire for human honor.ST Apr 7, 1909ST Sep 21, 1882RH May 7, 1861ST Oct 25, 1883RH Jun 30, 1874 The Father sees what is done in secret, with its motive and spirit, and He will reward it openly in His own time and at the judgment.ST Dec 5, 1878ST Dec 5, 1878RH Sep 10, 1857ST Dec 14, 1904RH Aug 21, 1860 Letting good works be known is not forbidden when the aim is to encourage others, provoke liberality, and lead them to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897RH Aug 10, 1916RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 The verse concerns motive and manner rather than forbidding organized giving and public support of gospel work, though those who held the stricter view taught that it prohibits public collections and requires the gift to be set aside privately at home.RH Jun 9, 1859RH Jun 24, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852RH Apr 22, 1858
Wording And Setting
That thine alms may be in secret belongs to the Sermon on the Mount, Christ's great discourse and fullest verbal declaration of the principles underlying God's law and of God's spiritual kingdom and the true motive in service.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Apr 9, 1896ST Nov 21, 1900 It was first spoken to a cosmopolitan gathering centuries ago and remains applicable to all time with the same spirit and life, a word of faith and devotion rather than mere outward morality that takes hold of the inner being and calls to belief and consecration.ST May 13, 1897 Its riches are not to be read with profit at one sitting but to be meditated on over time, deeply religious in type and illustration, and its words laden with spiritual life are understood more deeply in their original setting among the disciples.ST May 17, 1905ST May 13, 1897 It was given nearly fifteen centuries after the law was proclaimed at Sinai, presenting righteousness as God-like character and showing how the law's principles are to be lived, given by simple declaration before kingdom truths were enforced more strongly by parables.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Sep 22, 1909
The Sermon does not contrast Christ's teaching with the Ten Commandments but vindicates them, reproducing them with spiritual expansion.RH Jul 26, 1870ST Nov 25, 1889 With Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 13 it gives a full-length portrait of a Bible Christian, setting the high standard of doing what the Bible requires, avoiding what it forbids, and accepting what it promises by following Christ, to be followed now in order to stand acquitted when small and great stand before God to be judged by the Bible.RH Jan 21, 1875 It teaches the spirit of Christ as meekness, as truly a fruit of the Spirit as faith or love and essential to spiritual attainment and true Christian experience, so that lack of meekness in anger, retaliation, harshness, rigidity, and biting sarcasm is sin from remaining carnality blurring the whole character and destroying usefulness.ST Apr 6, 1882 It is the opposite of the law of the market and commercialism, the ideal the world hungers for and the law needed for economic problems, and taken as a whole its principles cannot be lived while deliberately going to war to hunt and kill fellow human beings.RH Jul 24, 1900ST Jun 6, 1900
It reveals the heavenly Father's requirement that His people walk in the light He gives them, a requirement always reasonable and just that accepts nothing less than perfect obedience to His commandments.ST Mar 26, 1896 Failure to walk in given light separates people from God, and darkness comes upon those who refuse that light in the same proportion as the light has been permitted to shine upon their pathway, as it did to the Jewish people.ST Mar 26, 1896 In the wording itself, the word openly is absent from many ancient manuscripts, versions, and early Christian writers.ST May 19, 1881 Acts of charity also transfer perishable possessions to heaven, where they are secure from decay and theft.ST May 19, 1881
The verse stands among directions about giving alms delivered before the pattern prayer.RH Jan 8, 1861 Its place shows that preparation for prayer includes living in ways one can rightly ask God to bless and resisting the temptations one asks not to be led into.RH Jan 8, 1861 It belongs to private worship and private religious duty before God alone, not to public worship which God has also instituted as another thing altogether, so it gives no testimony against vocal prayer in the public congregation.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 16, 1857RH Jan 31, 1871 Giving to the needy is a private duty to be done quietly and without show in secret before God alone, not done before men to be seen of them as from spiritual pride and a vainglorious spirit to gain applause for great piety.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871 Those who give to be observed gain only the empty applause of men and have no other reward, while those who give in secret are rewarded openly by the Father who sees in secret.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 16, 1857RH Jan 31, 1871 Public acts of worship can be driven by improper or mixed motives which God judges, while secret devotion is less exposed to those motives, yet private devotion is not a substitute for public worship since each has its proper place and use.RH Apr 16, 1857
Secret Giving Required
Alms for the needy are to be given in secret in a quiet, unostentatious manner without display, not done before men to be seen of them or for public notice, human praise, thanks, favor, fame, or reputation.ST May 3, 1899RH Apr 16, 1901RH Sep 2, 1851ST Nov 5, 1894 The wrong condemned is giving in order to be seen, not giving publicly in itself, and public giving is not made more valuable by being public. Giving for recognition, favor, or fame is hypocrisy that brings only human approval and is displeasing to God, while the Father sees what is done in secret and rewards it openly.ST May 3, 1899RH Apr 16, 1901ST Nov 5, 1894
Secrecy is to be so strict that others and even self do not dwell on the deed, pictured as the hand itself unaware of the gift.ST May 27, 1897ST May 12, 1881 True labors of love are done without thinking of the matter afterward, the giver forgets the gift and leaves all reward to God.ST May 27, 1897 The humble forget their good deeds, while those who remember them and claim credit for them are rejected.RH Sep 18, 1855 Doing good quietly without noise or show and without boasting also provides occasion to examine feeling and discern grace.ST May 24, 1905RH Sep 2, 1858RH Feb 21, 1871
Publicity that cannot be avoided does not make a gift showy when the giver would gladly have kept it private, for quiet charity is distinct from ostentatious giving meant to win attention.ST Dec 5, 1878 A kindness seen by others and moving them to help was not performed for effect when it was not meant to impress and no observer was present to be influenced, but was done for the poor person's good.ST Dec 8, 1881
On one understanding, the verse prohibits public contributions and passing a collection publicly, requiring setting aside the gift privately at home.RH Jun 24, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852RH Sep 20, 1853 Paul's direction to set money aside individually in 1 Corinthians 16:1-2 is presented as consistent with it and not contradicting Jesus, being the humble and secret method of giving Paul enjoined.RH Jun 24, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852RH Sep 20, 1853
On the other understanding, the verse does not forbid organized giving to support those who preach the gospel or giving both publicly and privately as Jesus did.RH Jun 9, 1859 Secret giving must not be used as an excuse to give little or nothing or to ignore calls for help, for it concerns motive and manner, not an excuse.RH Jun 9, 1859RH Apr 22, 1858
Almsgiving remains a binding duty together with prayer and fasting.RH May 15, 1855 Christ reproves the manner of hypocrites who do these things to appear unto men and points out the right way in secret toward the Father, and the same principle of secret sincerity applies to prayer and fasting.RH May 15, 1855RH Apr 14, 1863 The promise supports sincere religious practice rather than discouraging almsgiving, and almsgiving and fasting can be perverted when used as outward display of religion rather than practiced from right motives.ST Dec 3, 1896RH Apr 14, 1863 The same seeing in secret belongs to private devotion away from the world to read the word, examine the heart, confess sin, and seek grace through Christ, including secret prayer for others instead of fault-finding, praying in secret for anyone who seems wrong or troublesome when there is no way to speak to them and no right to speak against them, and secret prayer in which God enlightens the darkened mind about duty.RH Sep 18, 1856RH Jan 6, 1874RH Jun 22, 1916
Motive And Human Praise
The verse warns against the vainglorious spirit of the Pharisees who broadened their phylacteries and loved chief seats and titles and did alms before men from spiritual pride to gain applause for great piety.RH Sep 27, 1870RH Aug 8, 1865 At Christ's first advent the chief priests, scribes, elders and priesthood did this very thing, loving worldly honor and exaltation and wanting to give impressions of their importance, zeal and devotion to religious duties, while their hearts were hard, unmerciful and corrupt, lacking personal piety and virtuous character.RH Dec 17, 1872 They exacted heavy sums and taxes from the conscientious, the poor, the widow and fatherless for the Lord's treasury, devoured widows' houses, and robbed God by appropriating the offerings of the people to themselves.RH Dec 17, 1872 Doing good through strife or vainglory to be counted religious is selfish hypocrisy even when the outward act is right.RH Sep 27, 1870RH Aug 8, 1865 Christ's own example of doing charity without seeking public attention stands against such conspicuous religious leaders who drew attention to themselves, and His secrecy about His healings likewise showed He was not seeking popularity or drawing attention to Himself.ST Nov 5, 1912
What matters is motive and inward spirit, not the act alone, for obedience done for self-glory is not truly good.RH Sep 23, 1858ST Aug 5, 1875 Acceptable service must come from sincere love, compassion, cheerfulness, and devotion for God's glory and the good of His cause and the salvation of others, recognizing good works come through the Holy Spirit, rather than to win approval, preserve a name, advance selfish interests, or bring praise to self.ST Apr 7, 1909ST Sep 21, 1882ST Jan 22, 1902RH Sep 23, 1858ST Aug 5, 1875 God sees the secret motives behind actions and values work according to the motive that prompts it, and the pure motive makes the act acceptable.ST Sep 21, 1882ST Aug 5, 1875 When good deeds are done to win human approval they receive no reward from the Father, but gifts given for the good accomplished are recorded in heaven.ST Sep 21, 1882ST Jan 22, 1902
Giving for recognition, gratitude, or applause brings only empty human honor and a temporary earthly unrighteous reward, not the Father's reward.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Jan 22, 1902ST Oct 25, 1883RH Jun 30, 1874RH Mar 27, 1900 To labor in the service of mankind with gratitude or applause in view is merely courting the triumphs of vanity, and benevolence of that kind must necessarily die.RH Jun 30, 1874 Vanity poisons the motive so that even when others receive benefit from the deed the vain doer loses the reward.RH May 7, 1861 Unless repented such hypocrisy brings greater damnation and rejection when those who prophesied and cast out devils and did many wonderful works hear depart from me ye that work iniquity.RH Sep 27, 1870 True goodness shines brightest when unseen by people, and secret acts of kindness for someone in need are acceptable to God and will be rewarded by Him.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Oct 25, 1883
Ostentatious display has no place in the Christian standard but stands rebuked by Scripture.ST Oct 29, 1902 Compulsory observance of religious rites and public exhibition of so-called national Christianity, including enforced Sunday observance by fines and imprisonment, is display Christianity that comes short of the Christian standard.ST Oct 29, 1902 Its effectual public demonstration is love one to another.ST Oct 29, 1902 Charity is not the gold or silver or copper given to a beggar by the wayside but the motive behind the gift, and giving to be seen of men is not charity.ST Nov 6, 1901 Those who publish their benevolence to the whole world act as modern Pharisees, doing more scientifically what the Pharisee did when he sounded a trumpet on the street corner, such as secretly owning and operating a big city daily, and charity that longs to publish itself ceases to be charity.RH Jul 10, 1856ST Nov 6, 1901
A gift gained through unrighteous business practices is no proof of Christian benevolence, and honoring such a donor as an example while ignoring those practices misrepresents the ethics of Jesus. Giving to prominent charities does not prove genuine love for others when a person remains selfish and harsh toward the poor and needy in ordinary dealings.RH Jul 21, 1863 Charity should be proportioned to means, with an open hand joined to a closed mouth. Giving should be in secret without thirst for thanks or public acknowledgment, because receiving charity is bitter eating to the recipient, and giving discreetly without thirst for thanks also blesses the giver by keeping the heart open.ST Sep 3, 1896ST Feb 14, 1884 Secret kindnesses done to mankind are beautiful, and to be invisibly good is godlike, set against secret injuries which are detestable and being invisibly evil which is diabolical.RH Mar 31, 1874 The greatest pleasure is to do a good action by stealth and have it found out by accident.RH Aug 1, 1871
Father's Open Reward
The Father sees what is done in secret, action and motive together with thoughts, words, ways and worth, and He will reward it openly in His own time.ST Dec 5, 1878ST Dec 5, 1878ST Nov 24, 1887RH Sep 1, 1904 Work done for God that is reported and tabulated to win human praise, when it is full of self, is rejected, while little everyday acts done in secret and thought unworthy of notice are seen by Him and counted worthy of record in the scrolls of heaven.RH Sep 10, 1857ST May 6, 1897 Publicly announcing benefactions or praising donors to foster vanity makes charity a show, and seeking praise from people instead forfeits the reward from the Father and harms character and brings reproach on religion.ST Dec 5, 1878ST Dec 5, 1878
Secret acts of kindness, self-sacrifice and humble service, unseen, misunderstood, overlooked or forgotten by people, are not lost, for they are seen, remembered, marked and kept in God's book.RH Apr 23, 1901ST Nov 1, 1899ST Dec 26, 1892 Holy deeds done unseen are known to Him in both action and motive, and hidden faith, trust, love and duty grow beneath the surface into beauty and bear fruit.ST Jul 18, 1878ST Oct 9, 1879 They live on and keep growing like a tree when other things decay, and what was hidden will be revealed and brought to light in the life to come when the Master lifts the leaves.ST Jul 18, 1878ST Nov 1, 1899
Acts done in secret for God's glory will be remembered and rewarded openly on the day of judgment and in the final record.ST Dec 14, 1904RH Aug 21, 1860 Quiet victories over temptation and acts of kindness known only to Him receive His approval, even when others do not notice them, so good works need not be publicized.ST Sep 21, 1882ST Dec 14, 1904 Generous acts and kind words done in unselfish love, though hidden from people, are known to God and will be revealed.ST Dec 14, 1904
The reward is not to be the giver's motive and is not sought in this life but hereafter, for to seek name or place or recognition in this world is to seek earthly reward.RH Dec 17, 1901ST Sep 29, 1909 His reward includes Himself, received and enjoyed as the giver becomes more like Him in character, with spiritual blessing and growth like a stream nourishing the land.RH Dec 17, 1901 Secret generosity forms unselfishness and draws people closer to God, and He recognizes such service by grace, not as a wage owed for works, while living in Christ and disregarding self with all its interests to give life unselfishly for others corrects all wrong motives.RH Dec 17, 1901ST Sep 29, 1909
The amount does not give charity its value but the spirit does, for worth is measured by inward spirit — love, cheerfulness, devotion and whole-hearted devotion — not by size.ST Apr 1, 1897ST Oct 7, 1875 God can regard a small gift from the heart as greater than large gifts for show, making it precious and a treasure for a soul starved in darkness, as with the widow's two mites.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Apr 1, 1897ST Oct 7, 1875 Yet pride may also lead one to hide a small gift, so secrecy alone does not prove humility.ST Apr 1, 1897
The verse comforts the lonely and oppressed, for God sees what is done or endured in secret, hears sighs and sees tears hidden from others, knows every grief, and pities those who fear Him as a father pities his children.RH Mar 31, 1859ST Oct 30, 1879 Lonely believers are not unseen or forgotten but are pitied and remembered, and He will give open reward to those who endure.RH Mar 31, 1859ST Oct 30, 1879 Even when friends and companions turn against them and fathers and mothers forsake them, the Lord will take them up and they have no cause to fear.ST Oct 30, 1879
The same seeing and rewarding applies to faithful laborers in obscurity, ordinary duties and small acts, encouraging faithful service even when laborers and their work remain unnoticed by others.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 11, 1884 God's approval is enough and He is with them in their labor, so they should care more about working faithfully and gaining His approval than about who sees their work or how visible its results are, including ministers presenting the last message of mercy whose arrow of truth silently cuts to the heart and who will stand with trophies of grace.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 11, 1884 Humble and quiet service done all day long without fame or visible result leaves nothing to show at set of sun yet is not lost, because the Father ever watches the work done, keeps records of all that is forgotten, and judges with true judgment, while an angel writes beautiful deeds in a volume of gold, covering womanly deeds and trifles of presence, wielding unmeasured unknown power wherever presence goes, rejoicing with those who rejoice, weeping with the sad, strengthening the weak, seeking a poor wanderer straying in sin, aiding the poor, giving the rest of the home to the weary, and giving blessings freely to all who come.ST Nov 5, 1885 Giving a friendless girl a home and a chance to earn her support may cost more than hiring sewing done in the cheapest way, but the extra cost can be counted as a gift to her, and human reproach or lack of thanks does not erase His notice or reward for even small acts done in secret.ST Jul 7, 1887ST Jul 1, 1875 Relieving a brother's need close at hand is pleasing to God just as giving to people far away is, while giving for distant causes because they attract publicity brings applause from people rather than the Father's reward.RH Oct 15, 1861
Acts of charity also transfer perishable possessions to heaven, where they are secure from decay and theft.ST May 19, 1881 The word openly is absent from many ancient manuscripts, versions and early Christian writers, yet the promise of the Father who sees in secret as the one who rewards remains.ST May 19, 1881
Noble deeds are quiet and hidden because Christian life and action draw power from an inward unseen source.ST Mar 29, 1899 Doing good quietly without noise or show provides occasion to examine feelings and discern grace, overcomes wrong ways, prepares for salvation at Jesus' coming, and in victory over pride is content to be unknown rather than drawing attention or yearning for commendation.ST Mar 29, 1899RH May 18, 1911 A person's unseen good works should not be judged by what the church can see or record, for charitable work may be hidden from other people yet seen by God.RH Apr 3, 1900
Reporting And Daily Application
Not every good deed must be hidden, and letting good works be known and reported is not forbidden when the purpose is to encourage others, to teach how to work successfully, to provoke liberality, to imbue others with the same spirit, and to lead them to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 1909RH Aug 10, 1916RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 What matters is motive, since doing good to gain praise brings only its own reward and not the Father's, and genuine godliness never seeks display but brings glory to Him through whose grace and power the work is wrought.RH Aug 10, 1916RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Every good work is accomplished through the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit is given to glorify not the receiver but the Giver.ST Apr 7, 1909RH Nov 5, 1914 Those who desire words of praise and flattery and feed upon them are Christians in name only.RH Nov 5, 1914
The command not to let the left hand know what the right hand does rebuked doing charity to receive the glory of men, and it does not apply to those who have the cause of God at heart and humbly use means to advance it.RH Nov 5, 1914 Reporting both orally in the churches and in writing for the papers is desired, and refusal to report on the ground of this verse is against His regard.RH Nov 5, 1914 With many who plead the verse the left hand does not know what the right hand does because the right hand does nothing worthy of notice.RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Reporting is right only on proper occasions when the Lord alone is magnified by telling what great things He has done, not by vain self-confident boasting of what I have done or what we have done.ST May 27, 1897 Human reports of what is great and praiseworthy may be of least account in God's eyes, while things unworthy of notice may be great in His sight, and true labors of love are done without thinking of the matter afterward, leaving all reward to God.ST May 27, 1897
Recording gifts for contemporaries and generations to come in order to win admiration is forbidden, as is heading subscription lists with the largest and most influential giver to stir others through appeal to love of approval.ST Sep 3, 1896 Parading the result before the public through the press, through reported and preserved statistics, and through gossip is likewise forbidden, for alms must be as unseen by men as if cast into the sea while seen by God who will reward.ST Sep 3, 1896 The verse bids believers to seek the true riches laid up in store for the righteous rather than the riches of this world, which never advance knowledge of God or Christian experience.RH Jan 6, 1910 It points to Christ's holy, self-denying example, for He owned nothing in this world though the world was His, and calls believers to study that example and to cooperate, trust, and deny self.RH Jan 6, 1910
Quiet charity is illustrated by privately helping a poor laborer, whose unexpected gift relieves his family and prompts thanks to God, and by an anonymous $25,000 gift to a hospital given without seeking public notice.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Feb 19, 1880 The same principle applies to poor women who give and serve others without drawing attention to their generosity or seeking recognition, for acts of charity should be done without seeking notice or praise.ST Jul 21, 1898 Giving publicly at donation parties to attract attention or please people is the opposite of giving in secret without public notice or boasting.RH Feb 2, 1860 In the home under the golden rule, generous acts and kind words done in unselfish love may be hidden from people yet are known to God and will be revealed in the final record.ST Dec 14, 1904
Sources