Matthew 6:3
But when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth:
Translations
But when you do alms, let not your left hand know what your right hand does:
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
But when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doeth:
'But thou, doing kindness, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doth,
But thou, when thou doest alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand does;
But, thou, when doing an alms, let not, thy left hand, know what thy right hand is doing;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
But when you give to the needy, do not let your left hand know what your right hand is doing,
But when you do merciful deeds, don’ t let your left hand know what your right hand does,
But when you give money, let not your left hand see what your right hand does:
But when thou doest thine almes, let not thy left hand knowe what thy right hand doeth,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
But when thou dost alms, let not thy left hand know what thy right hand doth.
Cross-references
- Matthew 6:16-18
Moreover when ye fast, be not, as the hypocrites, of a sad countenance: for they disfigure their faces, that they may appear unto men to fast. Verily I say unto you, They have their reward.
Fasting, like almsgiving, can become a show of piety, while true devotion is practiced in secret.
- Luke 12:33
Sell that ye have, and give alms; provide yourselves bags which wax not old, a treasure in the heavens that faileth not, where no thief approacheth, neither moth corrupteth.
Christ commands giving alms rather than withholding them.
- Matthew 5:1-7
And seeing the multitudes, he went up into a mountain: and when he was set, his disciples came unto him:
The passage names the Sermon on the Mount, which includes Matthew 6:3.
- Luke 14:13-14
But when thou makest a feast, call the poor, the maimed, the lame, the blind:
Both commend giving to those who cannot repay.
- Matthew 23:5
But all their works they do for to be seen of men: they make broad their phylacteries, and enlarge the borders of their garments,
Both contrast almsgiving in secrecy with religious works done to be seen.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
29 sources
In the Sermon on the Mount Christ taught that giving to the needy must not be done for display or human approval, and good deeds may be seen when they lead others to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 The secrecy He calls for is so complete that the act draws no attention even in the giver's own mind, being done freely without self-display or self-congratulation.DA 298DA 298.12SP 204.1 True charity springs from pity and love for sufferers with a pure, humble motive for God's glory rather than praise or reputation, for God judges gifts by their motives and rewards what is done for Him rather than for human acclaim.1T 193.1–2BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882GW 275.3 Such secret kindness and self-sacrifice bless both giver and receiver, build unselfish character, bind hearts together, and draw hearts toward God.1T 194.1 This call to quiet giving never excuses covetousness, withholding, giving little, or neglecting the worthy poor nearby, but rebukes showy generosity while calling for humble, faithful use of means to help others and advance God's cause.1T 193.1–21T 194.1SG2 232.1ST Sep 2, 1886
Words and Historical Setting
The saying belongs to the Sermon on the Mount, where the principles and conditions of God's kingdom are taught to correct false ideas of worldly greatness.DA 299.3 It is part of that sermon’s revelation of the far-reaching, heart-level principles of God’s law, showing that the state of the heart regulates life and character and that the spirit of the law must be in the heart, so that new converts are rightly instructed in the claims of the law only when impressed with these inward principles.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34 It belongs to the pure gospel given upon the Mount that explains God’s holy law and sets the holy standard of character, requiring love to God with the whole heart and love to neighbor as God requires.Ms 26, 1899, par. 29–30 That standard forbids mingling human wisdom with the divine, confusing minds about right and holy methods in business, unjustly acquiring means at another’s expense, diverting means from the true object of foreign missions to invest them according to ambitious designs, and practicing any method to please the lust for gain and power on the principle that gain is godliness, and those who do such things prove they have not learned God’s holy law and must repent and be converted, do works worthy of the name Christian, and receive a cleansing and purging of the soul temple.Ms 26, 1899, par. 29–30 Failure to walk in the light God gives was separating the people from God, with darkness coming upon them in the same proportion as light had shone on their pathway, requiring perfect obedience to God’s commandments and faithful improvement of God-given responsibility to exhibit character and works of an elevated order in harmony with accumulated light.ST Mar 26, 1896
Its teaching stood opposed to the doctrines and practices of the self-righteous scribes and Pharisees and exposed their misrepresentation of God.FE 309.1 The same sermon revealed that failure to walk in the light given was separating the Jewish people from God.ST Mar 26, 1896
The picture of the left hand not knowing what the right hand does is not a command to keep every kind act absolutely secret.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2 It means display and human approval must not be the aim, and good works may be seen when they lead people to glorify God rather than the giver, whose grace and power make them possible.ST Apr 7, 19091T 193.1–2ST Sep 2, 1886 The Pharisees’ public display of charity sought attention and a reputation for holiness, but genuine godliness does not seek praise or flattery. The command rebukes showy almsgiving, not humble use of possessions to advance God’s cause or help others, and a person who gives nothing cannot use it as an excuse for doing little, for the issue is whether charity seeks human applause or bears the fruit of genuine faith.1T 193.1–2 It describes giving so modestly that it is not worthy of self-congratulation, and it rebukes those who use secrecy as a pretext for giving very little or withholding charitable gifts.ST Sep 2, 1886
The secrecy called for is so complete and private that the giver keeps the act from drawing attention even within personal awareness.DA 298DA 298.12SP 204.1 Giving to those in need is to be done without seeking attention or recognition, acting freely without self-display or self-congratulation.DA 298DA 298.12SP 204.1ST Sep 2, 1886
Religious leaders at the first coming broke this principle by giving alms and praying in the most public manner to appear pious, zealous, devoted and important, calling the attention of the people to themselves to be praised for devotion and piety.RH Dec 17, 1872 They gave alms to be seen of men and prayed in the marketplaces to give impressions of their importance and to make the people have exalted ideas of their religious devotion, while growing prouder and prouder and boasting of their righteousness and making religious profession very prominent.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872 Their religion was only formal, consisting of ordinances and purifications, rites and ceremonies, without heartfelt piety, for they kept the forms and ceremonies while their hearts were not in the work, lacking personal piety and virtuous character, loving the honors of the world and seeking exaltation through riches.Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872 Behind that outward semblance of goodness they concealed greed and exploitation of the poor, grinding the faces of the poor and taking advantage of them in every way possible, especially the widow and fatherless.2SP 12.1–13.11RED 12.2Ms 69, 1912, par. 24–2910MR 153.1–2RH Dec 17, 1872 They devoured widows’ houses by heavy taxes and exacted money on various pretenses for the Lord’s treasury, appropriating the offerings of the people to themselves and thus robbing God.RH Dec 17, 1872
Christ exemplified the saying by quiet, humble and disinterested works of mercy that did not exalt self and did not call attention to His goodness or seek public praise.BS 13.12SP 30.3–31.1 He lived it by shunning human praise and preferring solitude and peaceful retirement to noise and confusion, then quietly resuming His work of mercy each morning.
Selfless Giving in Practice
Charity must spring from pity and love for those who suffer, done with a pure, wholehearted and humble motive for God's glory rather than to win praise, honor, notice, or a reputation for generosity and holiness.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882Lt 52, 1886, par. 3 Magnifying one's own good deeds and bringing self to the front to attract attention and display them is contrary to this rule.Lt 52, 1886, par. 3 Good works may still be seen when they lead people to glorify God, for the question is whether charity seeks human applause or bears the fruit of genuine faith.1T 193.1–2 A pure motive sanctifies the act, and the highest religion gives benevolence without display, pleasing to God and expecting its reward from Him rather than from people.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882
God values genuine kindness and wholehearted devotion, judging charitable acts by their motives rather than their appearance before people.BS 8.2–3GW 275.3 An act praised by people may be recorded as selfish or hypocritical, while what is done for Him rather than for human acclaim He rewards.BS 8.2–3ST Sep 21, 1882GW 275.3 Secret acts of kindness and self-sacrifice bless both recipient and giver, cultivating unselfish character, binding hearts together, drawing hearts toward God, noticed in heaven and recognized as union with Christ.1T 194.1 Obedience includes not neglecting a worthy poor person close at hand, and those with means should favor the afflicted, widows and worthy poor in the prices they charge and the wages they pay.1T 194.1
The call to give in secret rebukes showy almsgiving, not the humble use of possessions to advance God's cause and help others.1T 193.1–2ST Sep 2, 1886 It does not justify neglecting the plain duty to give alms, and one who gives nothing cannot use it as an excuse for doing little.1T 193.1–2SG2 232.1 Its picture of giving so modestly as to be unworthy of self-congratulation does not excuse withholding charitable gifts, giving very little, concealing selfishness, or resisting systematic benevolence and support of God's work.SG2 232.1ST Sep 2, 18861T 192.1 The verse teaches contentment and life under the Holy Spirit's control, removing striving for place and position and reaching for honor and recognition.STB 828.2–829.1AFUP 13.3 It so shapes ambition that a person no longer elbows a fellow worker aside to make room for personal plans, but honors Christ at every step and desires most to work just where God assigns, where He can look with approval, content with that place and willing to yield the will to the Spirit.STB 828.2–829.1AFUP 13.3
Every gift received comes from God, and when this is recognized with gratitude for His goodness, a heavenly atmosphere surrounds the soul.STB 823.2–3Ms 15, 1912, par. 1–2 The verse holds lessons not yet fully learned, calling for ordering life by God's truth found in His word.STB 823.2–3 Diligent study of the Scriptures as the truth of the living God is the foundation of faith and the assurance on which hope of eternal life in the kingdom of heaven is built.STB 823.2–3 These lessons belong to the broader instruction on giving alms without seeking recognition or making a show of it.Ms 15, 1912, par. 1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
87 sources
When alms are given they are to be given quietly and privately and in secret, without noise or display or drawing attention to the act or to the generosity of the giver.ST May 3, 1899ST May 24, 1905 The left hand is not to know what the right hand does, which is to give so privately that the gift is not dwelt upon or advertised or kept track of for self-praise, but is let pass from the mind and forgotten once it is given.ST May 3, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 5, 1878 What gives the gift its value is not its size but the motive behind it, for charity must spring from pure disinterested love toward God and desire to do good for His glory rather than to win praise for self, and God who searches the heart and sees in secret will reward openly what is sincerely given in secret.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 3, 1899RH Apr 16, 1901RH Dec 24, 1872ST May 12, 1881 This does not require that every kind act always be hidden, for generous deeds may be seen and told when they are done sincerely from the heart in order to do others good and lead them to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897RH Dec 24, 1872ST Dec 9, 1880 It does forbid doing religious duties to be seen by others for esteem and applause, like the hypocrisy of the Pharisees who performed in public what should have been secret in order to gain a reputation for great piety, for deeds done to be seen bring no reward from God but only empty human praise.RH Apr 16, 1857ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871RH Apr 16, 1901
Setting and Wording
Matthew 6:3 belongs to the Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5-7, where Jesus declares the principles of His kingdom and administration and gives a verbal declaration of the underlying principles of the law.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Apr 9, 1896ST It is part of His teaching on the true motive in service, showing that righteousness is lived from unselfish motives and not for display.ST Aug 6, 1912ST Nov 21, 1900 The sermon spiritually expands the Ten Commandments, and its principles are to shape life through personal spiritual experience, with its commands belonging to the Gospel just as its promises and blessings do.ST Oct 4, 1899 What is preached there is a spiritual kingdom whose interests and principles were to be advocated and taught while a government of a different character still exists, not a policy for temporal or civil government, which was ordained only because of sin to restrain vicious conduct.ST Apr 9, 1896
The verse was given together with Christ's instructions on prayer and fasting as a continuing duty of the church, reproving the manner of hypocrites and pointing out the right way.RH May 15, 1855 Almsgiving remains binding just as prayer and fasting do, with no reason for one to cease while the others continue.RH May 15, 1855 It stands parallel to secret prayer in the closet, belonging to the private worship of God and the private duty of giving alms in a quiet and unostentatious manner, not sounding a trumpet before men.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871 That private worship is altogether distinct from the public worship God has also instituted, so the verse does not speak of public worship and does not forbid public prayer.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871 Secret almsgiving thus belongs together with secret prayer in a life that finds fault little and prays much for children and for anyone who seems wrong or troublesome.RH Jan 6, 1874
The Sermon on the Mount with Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 13 gives a full-length portrait of a Bible Christian, one who does what the Bible requires, avoids what it forbids, accepts all its promises, and looks to Christ as the perfect pattern rather than to other professors or conformity with the world.RH Jan 21, 1875 It sets a high standard that must be kept aimed at to attain any excellence in the Christian course, and living by it now is necessary to stand acquitted when all, small and great, stand before God to be judged by the Bible.RH Jan 21, 1875 Its words are spirit and life, first spoken centuries ago yet applicable to all time, to be meditated upon in the quiet hour rather than read once for profit.ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 29, 1897 They are not a mere lecture on outward morality but take hold of the inner being and unfold spiritual riches, calling to purity, simplicity, consecration, believing, and following Christ, insisting on a life of believing, consecration, and purity.ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 29, 1897
Its doctrine requires meekness as really a fruit of the Spirit as faith or love and an essential element of spiritual attainment, without which there is no true Christian experience.ST Apr 6, 1882 A harsh, retaliatory, angry spirit contradicts the sermon, and want of meekness blurs the whole character, blasts usefulness, and puts doubt about the power of grace and the reality of religion into sinners' minds.ST Apr 6, 1882 Fits of anger are not excused by impulsive nature or temperament but are sin, remaining carnality, proof of an unsanctified nature, and a disgrace to the Christian name.ST Apr 6, 1882
The image of the left hand not knowing what the right hand does expresses complete secrecy in giving, done so privately that even the giver does not dwell on it, advertise it, or keep track of it for self-praise.ST May 3, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST Aug 26, 1889 Giving to relieve distress is to be quiet, without seeking publicity, notice, praise, or recognition, without drawing attention to the gift or display of generosity, and free from desire for human recognition.ST May 3, 1899ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 5, 1878 Even the giver is to keep the deed private, letting it pass from mind and forgetting it once given, becoming a natural expression of desire to serve and please others for their good.ST Aug 26, 1889 Such sincere charity may be known only to God, who sees in secret and will reward it and reveal it at the last great day.ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 5, 1878ST Mar 8, 1910
The mention of left and right hands may be understood against the role of hand gestures in communication, since people can convey questions and remarks through hands and other movements even without speaking.ST Aug 13, 1894 In one contrast, the image of hands kept unaware of each other is set beside the work of Christ's body, whose members have no reason to keep one another unaware of their work.
Secret Giving Commanded
Almsgiving and every other charitable good are to be done quietly, privately and in secret, without noise, fuss, boasting or drawing attention either to the act or to the generosity of the giver, so privately that even the left hand does not know what the right hand is doing.ST May 3, 1899ST May 24, 1905ST Dec 5, 1878RH Sep 10, 1857 Relief of distress is to be kept completely from notice and publicity, with no display of generosity and no seeking of human credit, so that sincere charity may be known only to God, who sees in secret and will reward openly and reveal it at the last great day.ST May 3, 1899ST Dec 5, 1878RH Sep 10, 1857ST Dec 5, 1878 Publicity and desire for popular approval undermine character and bring reproach on religion, and concealing a selfless deed preserves its reward from God.RH Sep 10, 1857ST Dec 5, 1878 Doing good in secret also tests how much grace a person possesses.ST May 24, 1905
Religious duties are not to be done to be seen by others for human esteem, notice, praise, honor, popularity or applause.RH Apr 16, 1857RH Apr 16, 1901ST May 27, 1897ST May 3, 1899 That forbids sounding a trumpet, announcing gifts in the synagogue and displaying them in the streets, and all self-conscious display or concern for personal credit.ST Apr 7, 1909RH Apr 16, 1901ST May 27, 1897 The act of giving is to be private and free from desire for human recognition, not even keeping track of it for self-praise, and display must never be its aim.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897ST May 3, 1899 Work done for Christ without dwelling on its importance is precious to God, while people may value things God does not, and public giving does not make a gift greater, for the same principle applies whether giving is public or private.ST May 27, 1897
The warning is aimed at the vainglorious spirit, spiritual pride and hypocrisy of the Pharisees, and at the first advent at the chief priests, scribes and elders.RH Dec 17, 1872ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871 They obtruded upon the public gaze acts of religious worship that should have been performed in secret before God alone, doing in the most public manner what should have been secret in order to gain the applause of the multitude for great piety and a reputation for devotion.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871 They prayed in the marketplaces to give impressions of their importance and to make the people hold exalted ideas of their religious devotion, while keeping forms and ceremonies without personal piety and virtuous character, loving the honors of the world and seeking exaltation through riches.RH Dec 17, 1872 Behind that outward semblance of goodness they wronged the poor, especially the widow and fatherless, devouring widows' houses by heavy taxes and exacting money on various pretenses for the treasury, appropriating the offerings of the people to themselves and thus robbing God.RH Dec 17, 1872 Their only reward is empty human praise and empty honor gained by deceit.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1871ST May 12, 1881
That teaching corrects the idea that almsgiving is in itself meritorious before God, that alms and righteousness are the same, and that giving money to the poor secures heaven and the world to come, in a time when outward religion was performed to gain present honor and future reward.ST May 12, 1881 Desire for human esteem can mix with good works and make them unacceptable to God, who searches the heart.RH Apr 16, 1857 Pride in the deed corrupts the giver's motive and robs the giver of reward, even where others are still benefited, and a good action done without a good purpose is made sinful by that motive, so that giving to be seen and honored serves selfish ends and is not true obedience.RH May 7, 1861RH Sep 23, 1858 Alms given for praise lose their value, making the giver a beggar in alms and a Pharisee in devotion, and benevolence done with gratitude or applause in view is courting vanity and will die.RH Aug 8, 1865RH Jun 30, 1874 Giving for show springs from selfish motives and does not show God's law written in the heart, while simple unshowy giving can show that the law has not been wholly erased.
Giving is not to be done for self-serving motives, to win applause or advance one's own interests, to work for name, place or recognition, or to win favor, influence, return or advantage.RH Jul 12, 1870ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 11, 1904ST It should be for the good the gift can do, free and without thought of personal return, not a transaction in which the giver receives something in exchange, and gifts recorded in heaven are not given to be seen by people.ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 11, 1904 Giving to the needy must not be used to win public honor or to present the donor as a model of Christian benevolence, and praising a donor for generosity while knowingly ignoring unrighteous business practices gives a false picture of Christian character. Its conduct must be judged alongside the conduct by which the money was gained, and religious acts should be examined to see whether they are performed for God's glory and the furtherance of His cause.RH Aug 12, 1875
Motive Reward and Heart
What matters is the motive behind the deed, not the hiding of the deed itself.ST Apr 7, 1909RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Charity must spring from a right and benevolent and disinterested desire to do good, from pure spontaneous love toward God with cheerfulness, in humility and for God's glory, rather than to bring praise and honor to self.ST Apr 7, 1909ST Sep 21, 1882ST May 25, 1882RH Apr 16, 1901ST Apr 1, 1897 Display must not be its aim, for real godliness never prompts an effort at display, and those who desire words of praise and flattery and feed upon them are Christians in name only.ST Apr 7, 1909RH Nov 5, 1914 Generous self-sacrifice may therefore be told and good works may be seen and reported when done sincerely from the heart in order to do others good, to imbue them with the same spirit, and to lead them to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Every good work is accomplished through the Holy Spirit, and the Spirit is given to glorify not the receiver but the Giver, whose grace and power make the works possible.RH Nov 5, 1914 In family and social life this same unselfish motive appears as benevolence in small things, seeking others' happiness, forgetting self, and showing kind attention as the fruit of Christian character.ST May 25, 1882
Sincerity is the only thing that gives charity value, with the amount not essential and the spirit everything.ST May 12, 1881 God presses behind outward values and numbers and insists on the spiritual qualifications of the gift, placing it on a delicate spiritual scale that detects the thoughts and feelings of the giver.ST Apr 1, 1897RH He measures the act by the spirit that prompts it and values a gift by its heart and loving purpose rather than its size.RH Sep 18, 1855RH Mar 27, 1900RH Secret giving is more likely to be done in faith and pleases God, while humble givers may not keep count of their good works and pride makes men boast about their gifts, especially when they give much.RH Sep 18, 1855 The widow's two mites were worth more in His sight than abundant gifts given without humility, and giving from love and sacrifice is blessed by God whereas giving for human recognition earns only a human reward.RH Sep 18, 1855RH Mar 27, 1900 This corrects the teaching that almsgiving is in itself meritorious before God, that alms and righteousness are the same, and that giving money to the poor secures heaven and the world to come.ST May 12, 1881
True charity is the motive for the gift, which may or may not be present, while the gold or silver or copper given to a beggar is called charity only by metonymy.ST Nov 6, 1901 Alms done for display lack charity and are modern Pharisaism, whether by hiring a trumpeter on the street corner or by secretly owning and operating a great daily paper and publishing benevolence to the whole world.ST Nov 6, 1901 The Father who sees in secret will reward openly what is sincerely given in secret, and even a small unnoticed act of love is seen and recorded in heaven.ST May 3, 1899RH Apr 16, 1901ST Dec 14, 1904 Deeds done to be seen bring no reward from God but only empty honor from men gained by deceit, and benevolence done for applause will die.ST May 12, 1881RH Sep 18, 1855 Work done for Christ without dwelling on its importance is precious to God, while people may value things God does not.ST May 27, 1897
Doing good in secret also tests how much grace a person possesses.ST May 24, 1905 Giving quietly benefits the giver by keeping the heart open to compassion, and brings the greatest pleasure even when found out only by accident.ST Feb 14, 1884 Secret kindness done to mankind is beautiful, and to be invisibly good is godlike, as against secret injuries which are detestable and invisibly evil which is diabolical.RH Mar 31, 1874 Good alone lives on and keeps growing like a tree, so that one day the doer will see its shade.ST Jan 10, 1900 Good deeds may be hidden from men but God sees them, and angels keep a record that will be revealed, when a life of unselfishness and love will shine in its true beauty.ST Dec 14, 1904 Those who obey keep their good deeds so hidden that they themselves do not know they are serving Christ because the work looks small, yet their faces shine with the love of God without knowing it.ST Mar 25, 1897 They are the salt of the earth, unappreciated by men, doing their work quietly for God with consecration and love that only God can see and judge, and their work will stand in the day of judgment because Christ is in it, so workers must look to God and not to men.ST Mar 25, 1897
What Secrecy Permits
The verse does not forbid giving in public, for public giving does not make the gift greater and the same principle governs giving whether it is public or private. There is a time for privacy and a time for publicity, and both are required.ST Dec 9, 1880
The command about the hands does not mean acts of kindness must always be hidden, but that display must not be their aim.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897 Generous self-sacrifice may be told, and good works may be seen and reported, when done sincerely from the heart in order to do others good, to encourage others, to imbue them with the same spirit, and to lead them to glorify God rather than the giver.ST Apr 7, 1909ST May 27, 1897RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Such reporting on proper occasions gives credit to God, whose grace and power through the Holy Spirit accomplish every good work, and the Spirit is given to glorify not the receiver but the Giver.ST May 27, 1897RH Nov 5, 1914 The rebuke falls on doing alms and good works to bring praise, honor, glory, and flattery to self and on boasting about what has been done, while work done for Christ without dwelling on its importance is precious to God even when people value what God does not.ST May 27, 1897RH Dec 24, 1872RH Nov 5, 1914 Those who desire words of praise and feed upon them are Christians in name only, for real godliness never prompts an effort at display.RH Nov 5, 1914
To use the verse against orderly systematic effort is to misapply it, for its rebuke is directed at performing religious duties to be seen by others, not at recording and reporting charitable and missionary work.RH Jan 23, 1872 It does not forbid reporting work done for God by those who have the cause at heart and humbly use their means to advance it, nor pledging support, nor systematically setting aside a tithe.RH Nov 5, 1914RH Feb 19, 1861 Many who appeal to it as a reason not to report do nothing worthy of notice, and those who oppose pledging should see that their hands are doing something to advance the cause.RH Nov 5, 1914RH Feb 19, 1861
Secrecy must not become a pretext for giving very little, and the image of one hand not knowing what the other does does not excuse withholding gifts or avoiding honest examination and accounting of contributions.ST Sep 2, 1886ST Oct 21, 1875 It describes giving so modestly that it is not worthy of self-congratulation and not kept as prideful track for notice or praise.ST Sep 2, 1886ST Oct 21, 1875 Giving to support gospel ministers is a distinct duty of indebtedness that does not conflict with giving in secret.RH Jun 9, 1859 Quietly giving money, meals, lodging, and help to traveling ministers, and helping poor readers receive religious reading without charging the cost to the publisher, apply the principle of giving privately without drawing attention to the charitable act.RH Apr 25, 1854RH Apr 22, 1858
On one understanding held by some, the verse forbids public collections and requires each person to set aside the gift privately at home, to be gathered later.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Jun 24, 1852RH Sep 2, 1851RH Sep 20, 1853 This private laying aside is presented as consistent with Paul's instruction for the collection for the saints and as proving nothing for a first-day Sabbath or worship day and requiring no church meeting on the first day.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Jun 24, 1852 Setting aside privately in this way is not Pharisee-like public display, but humble unostentatious giving whose Father who sees in secret rewards openly, whereas public giving in which the left hand knows more than the right appeals to pride and boasting.RH Sep 2, 1851RH Feb 2, 1860
Church Life and Application
The verse turns life away from the riches of this world, which never advance knowledge of God or Christian experience, toward self-denial, trust, and cooperation in seeking the true riches laid up in store for the righteous.RH Jan 6, 1910 It follows the holy self-denying example of Christ, who owned nothing in this world though the world was his.RH Jan 6, 1910 His life shows the pattern, for he shunned human praise, preferred solitude and peaceful retirement to noise and confusion, and quietly resumed his work of mercy each morning from disinterested benevolence rather than to call attention to self.
In family and social life the principle appears as benevolence in small things, seeking the happiness of others, forgetting self, and showing kind attention as the fruit of Christian character.ST May 25, 1882 Charity is to be proportioned to one's means and kept private with a close mouth rather than seeking applause, lest the reward be lost. Even a small gift given quietly and discreetly from the heart, without seeking favor, fame, or praise, carries deep spiritual value and great worth.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Oct 7, 1875 Living at one's best is doing little acts of goodness as they come instead of waiting for a great opportunity, doing them in obscurity from a great motive for the glory of God to win His smile and approval and to do good to people, not for the praise of men.ST Feb 6, 1896 It is harder to plod on faithfully in obscurity than to do deeds of valor in public view, yet every hidden act receives swift recognition and ultimate reward, and this means faithfully fulfilling the duties of one's station, using the gifts of one's ministry to the uttermost, bearing chafing annoyances and trivial irritations as martyrs bore torture, finding the one noble trait in hostile people, putting the kindest construction on unkind acts and words, loving the unthankful and evil with the love of God, and being content to be a fountain in a wild valley of stones nourishing a few plants or a thirsty sheep, which done always for God's sake makes a great life.ST Feb 6, 1896
Secret charity gives hot food and drink and buys the poor's small wares and pays well for them, with sympathy, interest, kindness, and respect even to the ragged and poor, expecting no reward except the thanks of the one helped and not done for effect or to impress.ST Dec 8, 1881 Such kindness brightens a dreary place, changes faces, touches hearts, draws sudden respect, moves witnesses to repair their own negligence and also give, preaches as good as a sermon, and sends those who see it on their way better.ST Dec 8, 1881 It discreetly provides food and care while making help seem like an exchange so as not to hurt feelings.ST Apr 21, 1898 It is seen in a woman whose right hand does much good while her left hand seldom hears of it, in giving so privately that the giver does not even keep track of the good done by the other hand.ST Jan 27, 1898 It is seen in a quiet Dorcas serving people in need and refusing attention for her charity even while poor herself.ST Jul 21, 1898 It is seen in an anonymous $25,000 gift to a London hospital, and in a minister who served and spoke about religion without making his identity or calling known.ST Feb 19, 1880ST Nov 18, 1889
Work done for God is not to be reported and tabulated to gain praise from people, for work published in that way may be so full of self that God will have none of it.ST May 6, 1897 Right-hand giving is kept concealed by the left hand and left unrecorded before men, so a believer who looks inactive, uninvolved, and hypocritical for staying home from meeting and from open work can still be doing faithful unseen good that the church does not see.RH Apr 3, 1900 Little everyday acts thought unworthy of notice the Lord counts worthy of record in the scrolls of heaven.ST May 6, 1897 Good deeds may be hidden from people, but God sees them and angels keep a record that will be revealed, and a life of unselfishness and love will then shine in its true beauty, while even a small unnoticed act of love matters to God.ST Dec 14, 1904RH Mar 13, 1913
The verse belongs with the warning against religious acts performed to be seen by others, requiring sincere service rather than outward religious profession in order to escape hypocrisy and condemnation at the judgment.RH Sep 27, 1870 It belongs to the Sermon on the Mount which with Romans 12 and 1 Corinthians 13 gives a full-length portrait of a Bible Christian, one who does what the Bible requires, avoids what the Bible forbids, accepts all the Bible promises, and looks to Christ as the perfect pattern rather than to other professors or to conformity with the world.RH Jan 21, 1875 It sets a high standard that must be kept aimed at to attain any excellence in the Christian course, and living by it now is necessary to stand acquitted when all, small and great, stand before God to be judged by the Bible.RH Jan 21, 1875 Its directions for alms are among the practices of holiness that prepare for prayer, so that life is spent in pursuits one can ask God to bless and in resisting temptations one asks not to enter.RH Jan 8, 1861 Religious acts must be examined to see whether they are performed for God's glory and the furtherance of His cause rather than for human praise or selfish interests, for they can be perverted into outward performances of sanctity while the heart cherishes sin, and humility is an inward principle, not a gloomy or forbidding appearance.ST Dec 3, 1896RH Aug 12, 1875
Ostentatious display has no place in the Christian standard and stands rebuked by Scripture, for Christ forbids showing religion by outward show.ST Oct 29, 1902 This rebukes display religion including enforced Sunday observance backed by fines and imprisonment and public exhibits of so-called national Christianity to prove a Christian nation, which come short of the standard.ST Oct 29, 1902 The verse is part of the law of the mount, the truths Jesus taught and stood for and the principles and spirit of Christ upon which a true society of Jesus would be organized, containing the very ideal the world hungers for and the very law needed to apply to economic problems.RH Jul 24, 1900 A church organized otherwise has accepted the law of the market rather than the law of the mount, with commercialism dominating its organization and tyrannizing its pulpit, its Protestant churches composed for the most part of the well-to-do, seeing nothing essentially unsound or unethical in the economic system of the day, and leaving the pulpit rarely free to speak on the burning questions of the generation.RH Jul 24, 1900 The common way of giving is condemned where charities are carefully recorded in writing for the admiration of contemporaries and future generations, where long subscription lists headed by the largest and most influential giver stir others by appeal to love of approval, and where the result is paraded before the public through the press, society statistics and records, and gossip, instead of being cast away like something thrown into the sea where no one sees it, with God alone to see and reward it.ST Sep 3, 1896 The principles of the Sermon on the Mount are incompatible with deliberately going to war to kill other people.ST Jun 6, 1900
Giving to the needy is not to be used to win public honor or to present the giver as a model of Christian benevolence, and giving must be judged alongside the conduct by which the money was gained, for praising a donor while knowingly ignoring unrighteous business practices gives a false picture of Christian character. Charity should not be reserved for distant recipients because their needs bring greater publicity and praise, for giving to needs nearby and directly observed pleases God just as giving to distant causes does.RH Oct 15, 1861 Charitable aid must also avoid leaving the poor dependent rather than helping them help themselves, in contrast to charity given to be seen by others.ST Feb 24, 1898
Sources