Romans 14:23
And he that doubteth is damned if he eat, because he eateth not of faith: for whatsoever is not of faith is sin.
Translations
And he that doubts is damned if he eat, because he eats not of faith: for whatever is not of faith is sin.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And he that doubteth is damned if he eat, because he eateth not of faith: for whatsoever is not of faith is sin.
And he that doubteth is damned if he eateth, because he eateth not from faith: for whatever is not from faith is sin.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
But he that doubteth is condemned if he eat, because he eateth not of faith; and whatsoever is not of faith is sin.
and he who is making a difference, if he may eat, hath been condemned, because [it is] not of faith; and all that [is] not of faith is sin.
But he that doubts, if he eat, is condemned; because [ it is] not of faith; but whatever [ is] not of faith is sin.
But, he that is in doubt, if he eat, hath condemned himself,—because, [it was] not of faith, and, everything which is not of faith, is sin.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
But the one who has doubts is condemned if he eats, because his eating is not from faith; and everything that is not from faith is sin.
But he who doubts is condemned if he eats, because it isn’ t of faith; and whatever is not of faith is sin.
But he who is in doubt is judged if he takes food, because he does it not in faith; and whatever is not of faith is sin.
For he that doubteth, is condemned if he eate, because he eateth not of faith: and whatsoeuer is not of faith, is sinne.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
But he that discerneth, if he eat, is condemned; because not of faith. For all that is not of faith is sin.
Cross-references 20 of 36
- Hebrews 11:6
But without faith it is impossible to please him: for he that cometh to God must believe that he is, and that he is a rewarder of them that diligently seek him.
Both teach that faith is necessary to please God.
- Romans 14:5-6
One man esteemeth one day above another: another esteemeth every day alike. Let every man be fully persuaded in his own mind.
Each person should be fully persuaded and regard days unto the Lord.
- Romans 10:17
So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God.
Faith comes by hearing God’s word.
- 1 John 3:4
Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.
Defines sin as transgression of God’s law.
- Galatians 5:6
For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love.
Faith works through love.
- James 1:6-8
But let him ask in faith, nothing wavering. For he that wavereth is like a wave of the sea driven with the wind and tossed.
Both warn that acting without faith or conviction is wavering and double-minded.
- Romans 14:13
Let us not therefore judge one another any more: but judge this rather, that no man put a stumblingblock or an occasion to fall in his brother’s way.
Believers should not judge one another or put a stumbling block in a brother’s way.
- Habakkuk 2:4
Behold, his soul which is lifted up is not upright in him: but the just shall live by his faith.
Both affirm that the just live by faith.
- 1 Corinthians 8:7-13
Howbeit there is not in every man that knowledge: for some with conscience of the idol unto this hour eat it as a thing offered unto an idol; and their conscience being weak is defiled.
Eating against conscience and exercising liberty can harm a weak believer.
- Romans 14:2-3
For one believeth that he may eat all things: another, who is weak, eateth herbs.
Discusses differing convictions about eating and warns against judging fellow Christians.
- Colossians 2:14-17
Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross;
Links food and feast-day observances to ordinances removed at the cross.
- Romans 3:22
Even the righteousness of God which is by faith of Jesus Christ unto all and upon all them that believe: for there is no difference:
Identifies God’s righteousness as received through faith in Jesus Christ.
- Hebrews 10:38
Now the just shall live by faith: but if any man draw back, my soul shall have no pleasure in him.
Both connect living by faith with the consequences of acting without faith.
- Hebrews 11:1
Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Defines faith as assurance concerning what is hoped for and unseen.
- Genesis 15:6
And he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness.
Abraham’s belief in God was counted as righteousness.
- 1 Corinthians 11:29
For he that eateth and drinketh unworthily, eateth and drinketh damnation to himself, not discerning the Lord’s body.
Both warn that eating without faith brings condemnation.
- Acts 15:9
And put no difference between us and them, purifying their hearts by faith.
Both affirm that hearts are purified by faith, not by disputed food practices.
- Matthew 9:29
Then touched he their eyes, saying, According to your faith be it unto you.
Faith is named as the measure for receiving blessing.
- John 6:29
Jesus answered and said unto them, This is the work of God, that ye believe on him whom he hath sent.
Believing in Christ is God's work, and whatever is not of faith is sin.
- Galatians 3:14
That the blessing of Abraham might come on the Gentiles through Jesus Christ; that we might receive the promise of the Spirit through faith.
Both texts connect receiving the promised Spirit with faith.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
13 sources
Whatever is done without faith is sin, so to act while doubting that the act is right is to do wrong.GC 435.2–436.111MR 289.2–3Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5 Keeping God's law and rendering Him obedience and worship is acceptable only when done in faith, for without faith it is impossible to please Him.GC 435.2–436.1GC88 436.1GC88 436.2 The faith required works by love and purifies the heart, showing itself in humility, patience, forbearance, peace, joy, and willing obedience.11MR 289.2–3Lt 4, 1889, par. 52–54 That faith is not a feeling or mere agreement with doctrine, but living trust in God's word and promises, holding to His mercy even in darkness as a child depends on a parent.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5MYP 198.15T 437.2 For this reason to act against conscience is sin, and to pray or ask of God without trusting His pledged word dishonors Him.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Ms 29, 1889, par. 1–24SP 133.2–3
Faith Makes Obedience Acceptable
To act while doubting is to do wrong, for whatever is not done in faith is sin.GC 435.2–436.111MR 289.2–3Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5Lt 4, 1889, par. 52–54GC88 436.1 Keeping God's law requires faith, for without faith it is impossible to please God.GC 435.2–436.1GC88 435.2 Obedience and worship that pleases God require faith, so keeping the commandments without faith cannot please Him.GC 435.2–436.1GC88 436.1GC88 436.2
Faith is necessary to receive and follow light, and resisting faith in Christ cannot please God.Lt 4, 1889, par. 52–54 Faith is essential for preparation for judgment, when God's law is the standard by which character is judged.GC88 435.2 The faith called for works by love and purifies and cleanses the heart, showing itself in humility, patience, forbearance, long-suffering, peace, joy, and willing obedience.11MR 289.2–3Lt 4, 1889, par. 52–54
Faith is more than agreeing with doctrines, for it works through love and purifies the soul.5T 437.2 Humility, meekness, and obedience are not faith itself but its fruit.5T 437.2 Acting against conscience is sin, so a person must not act contrary to conscience but stand by the word of God when convinced by Scripture or clear reason.4SP 133.2–3
Living by Faith Daily
To ask God for anything without faith is sin, for whatever is not of faith is sin, and if such a faithless request were answered the one who asked would neither recognize the answer nor appreciate the blessing.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5 Prayer offered without faith dishonors God, for though He has pledged His word, failure to trust Him to fulfill it separates the doubter from Him.Ms 29, 1889, par. 1–2 A cold attitude toward Him in prayer makes the one who prays a source of darkness to the world rather than light.Ms 29, 1889, par. 1–2
Faith is not a particular feeling, and assurance of being His children does not rest on emotion but on God's word.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5 Living, active faith trusts His promises and depends on Him as a child depends on a parent.Ms 32, 1889, par. 1–5 It means trusting His word rather than accepting suggestions to distrust the Father, holding fast to trust through spiritual darkness with the eye fixed on His mercy.MYP 198.1 Such refusal of doubt brings deeper experience and supplies the evidence needed for peace and confidence.MYP 198.1
When the evidence makes the right course clear, to continue in doubt is sin, for the one who acts without faith does wrong.Lt 119, 1894, par. 4–6 True faith rests not on human approval but on the Lord, leading the believer to surrender personal reservations and let God work through whomever He chooses.Lt 119, 1894, par. 4–6 The declaration that whatsoever is not of faith is sin is God's voice to those engaged in health reform, to be studied carefully and made a guide in future labors.Lt 82, 1899, par. 8–9 Together with presenting the body a living sacrifice, it calls for simple, healthful lives of self-denial and self-sacrifice.Lt 82, 1899, par. 8–9
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
140 sources
He who doubts whether eating is right yet eats is condemned, because he does not eat from faith, and whatever is not from faith is sin.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Sep 4, 1893 The setting is division between Jewish and Gentile believers over ceremonial foods and observance of feast, fast and other ceremonial days, which were not essential to religion and were to be met with mutual forbearance without despising or judging.ST Nov 11, 1930RH Apr 20, 1876 Faith here means full, free conviction based on all attainable light and resting on God's Word rather than opinion, feeling, custom or another's example, so each must be fully persuaded in his own mind and act from personal faith before God.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jan 23, 1907RH Feb 13, 1872ST Oct 30, 1907 That rule has no bearing on the weekly Sabbath of the fourth commandment or any moral commandment, gives no liberty to break God's commandments, and cannot make a merely sincere belief right when it rejects sufficient evidence from God.ST Jul 15, 1889RH Mar 29, 1864RH Sep 12, 1865ST Jul 29, 1880 True faith turns the soul to Christ to receive His righteousness, power and living presence, works through love, and cannot be produced or directed by civil law or compulsion, so to force a religious act in which one has no faith is to force him to sin.ST Jul 3, 1893ST Apr 30, 1894RH Sep 14, 1911RH Nov 9, 1911ST Aug 13, 1896
Words and Original Setting
The word rendered damned means condemned or blameworthy, not necessarily destined for hell.ST Jul 15, 1889 One who eats while conscientiously doubting whether it is right incurs guilt, because the act is not done with clear conviction and not of faith.ST Jul 15, 1889RH Apr 20, 1876 Believing an act is right does not make it right, for people can act conscientiously or ignorantly and still be guilty, yet doing what one believes may be wrong is sinful and conscience condemns it.ST Jul 15, 1889
The doubting and eating concern a believer who thinks the Levitical distinction between foods may still bind Christians and whether eating foods forbidden by the ceremonial law is lawful.ST Jul 15, 1889RH Apr 20, 1876 The disputed foods are associated with Passover observances and with meats and ceremonial feast-day sabbaths, not with the continuing moral law or the Lord's Sabbath.RH Oct 7, 1851 Eating meat offered to idols is to be avoided because it could draw converts back into idolatry, cause a weak believer to stumble, or hinder others who might otherwise be won from idolatry.ST Feb 22, 1883
The chapter belongs to teaching against judging or despising fellow believers over disputed matters of food and sacred days, where each stands or falls to his own Lord.ST Aug 11, 1909 It addresses disagreements among Jewish and Gentile Christians, including converts from the circumcision still holding Jewish views of eating and feast-days, over feast, fast, and other ceremonial days connected with the Jewish ritual system.RH Apr 20, 1876RH Apr 21, 1851RH Mar 29, 1864 Such customs and scrupulous practices were not essential to religion and are treated as matters of indifference when not made a means of justification or a reason to reject Christ's sacrifice, and believers on either side could act with honest desire to honor God.ST Nov 11, 1930RH Apr 20, 1876RH Mar 29, 1864 The instruction is to treat those weak in faith as brothers, to allow each to act with sincere conviction before the Lord, to avoid judging or discouraging them, and to show mutual forbearance and preserve fellowship and peace and unity without judging or despising, while avoiding examples that could lead a weaker believer to stumble, so that all is done unto edifying.ST Nov 11, 1930RH Apr 20, 1876ST Aug 11, 1909 Those who ate were not to despise those who did not eat and those who did not eat were not to judge those who ate, because God had received them, and errors were borne with for a time to gain access to the Jews, even as Timothy was circumcised and as circumcision and uncircumcision were counted nothing while keeping the commandments of God was counted something.RH Apr 21, 1851 That situation of division does not now exist, so the chapter does not directly apply to the church today in the same way.RH Apr 21, 1851
The letter was written in the same year Paul visited Troas. The chapter does not identify the disputed day that some in Rome observed or explain their disagreement, and its placement beside discussions of food and herbs does not by itself show that the disagreement concerned the Sabbath.RH Jan 13, 1852 Its topic is meats and kindred ceremonial observances, not the moral law or the Sabbath or the fourth commandment, and it does not abrogate the Sabbath. God would not abolish the Sabbath without explicit language, so the verse cannot prove a change of the Sabbath without thorough testing, and to make it refer to the Sabbath would contradict the testimony of James and Paul's own affirmation in the same epistle of the perpetuity of the law.
No distinction between clean and unclean meats is now recognized.RH May 25, 1876RH Jan 20, 1853 The meat distinction in Ezekiel's sanctuary vision therefore belongs to the Mosaic dispensation and shows that vision would have been fulfilled then had the twelve tribes of Israel accepted it.RH Jan 20, 1853
Conscience and Faith Rule
To eat or to act at all while doubting whether it is right brings condemnation, because the act is not of faith, and whatsoever is not of faith is sin.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Sep 4, 1893ST Oct 8, 1912 To act against conscience is to act without faith, and no one should act contrary to what he conscientiously believes to be right.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Oct 8, 1912ST Dec 30, 1913 Faith rests on God's Word rather than personal opinion, and the call is not to judge one another but to serve God faithfully and put no stumbling block before fellow believers.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Oct 8, 1912 To fail to live by faith is to miss God's mark, so even conduct that appears morally ordinary still falls short when it is disobedience to God.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Oct 8, 1912 When doubt remains about whether something is lawful, the safe course is to avoid it, for violating conscience leads toward destruction of the soul.ST Dec 30, 1913ST Dec 11, 1893ST Dec 6, 1883
Guilt attaches to doing what one believes is wrong, or without settled conviction that it is lawful, even if the act is not sinful in itself, because acting against conscience reveals an intention to sin.ST Oct 19, 1888ST Sep 24, 1912 Food may be harmless in itself, yet it becomes unclean and sinful to the person who eats believing it wrong and without faith, while circumstances such as necessity to sustain life may change the decision.ST Sep 24, 1912ST Dec 29, 1909ST Aug 26, 1913ST Apr 22, 1897 The one who does not know or understand the issue answers to God and is not to be judged by another, for the concern is faithful conscience before God rather than imposing petty rules or condemning others over food.ST Dec 29, 1909 Personal freedom must not be used to pressure another to act against conscience, but love calls for self-restraint for a brother's sake.ST Dec 29, 1909 Faith rests on God's word, and conscience is to follow it and use God's food-giving blessings to His glory, with motive deciding the question in doubtful cases such as eating rabbits.ST Sep 24, 1912ST Aug 26, 1913ST Apr 22, 1897
Believing an act is right does not make it right, for people can act conscientiously or ignorantly and still be guilty.ST Jul 15, 1889RH Sep 12, 1865RH Sep 12, 1865 Faith is firm belief in what God has declared, and God gives sufficient evidence for faith and holds men responsible to believe Him, so sincere conviction that rejects that evidence does not make disobedience acceptable.ST Jul 15, 1889RH Sep 12, 1865RH Sep 12, 1865 Unbelief despises God and brings His wrath, with the second death as its stated penalty, and Paul's former opposition to Jesus was not genuine faith but responsible ignorant unbelief.RH Sep 12, 1865RH Sep 12, 1865 Even where conscience is the highest guide a person knows, to act against it is sin, and if that conscience directs toward a cruel or false religious rite the need is the light of the gospel.ST Jul 15, 1889ST Feb 20, 1907ST Feb 20, 1907
Faith means full, free conviction based on all attainable information, evidence, and light, and the question is not merely whether an act can be proved wrong but whether one is clearly convinced it is right.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jan 23, 1907ST Feb 20, 1907 It rests on God's Word as the basis for every act of Christian life, rather than feelings, convenience, human customs, personal opinion, inclination, or another's example, and whatever is not in harmony with that Word is sin.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Feb 20, 1907RH Dec 9, 1915ST Sep 25, 1901 Acting from inclination or human custom instead of the Word is presumption leading to disobedience and death, while faith leads to obedience and everlasting life.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Sep 25, 1901 As Daniel had no faith in Nebuchadnezzar's golden image because it was not according to God's Word, so to bow would have broken God's law and been sin, while refusal broke only the king's command, which was crime but not sin, and honored the law of the Most High.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Sep 25, 1901 Conscience must be regulated by that Word, conduct must follow inward conviction rather than mere outward compliance, and each must live up to the light available.ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jan 23, 1907ST Feb 20, 1907
Each person must be fully persuaded in his own mind and act from personal conviction and faith before God, not merely follow another's conscience.ST Jan 23, 1907RH Feb 13, 1872ST Oct 30, 1907RH May 7, 1867RH Nov 17, 1904 Faith cannot be exercised on another's behalf, so without personal living faith worship cannot please God and salvation is not received.ST Jan 23, 1907ST Oct 30, 1907RH Nov 17, 1904 Where Scripture gives no direct order, as with raising swine to sell, no one's conscience is to be bound by others.ST Jan 23, 1907RH Feb 13, 1872RH May 7, 1867 The same personal rule governs matters of liberty and disputed observances such as Jewish holy days, without making the Sabbath God set apart equivalent to those days, and no public official can supply faith on behalf of the people.ST Jan 23, 1907RH May 7, 1867RH Nov 17, 1904
When there is doubt whether something is right, the rule is to do nothing while doubting.ST Dec 30, 1913ST Dec 11, 1893ST Dec 6, 1883ST May 13, 1889 The practical test is whether it can be done in Jesus' name with an honest request for God's blessing, and if blessing cannot be asked it is wrong and must be left alone.ST Dec 6, 1883ST May 13, 1889RH Feb 24, 1863 That settling of doubt is done by going alone to kneel and ask God's blessing on the thing in question.ST Dec 6, 1883RH Feb 24, 1863 Acting against conscience in this way is sin because it is not done in faith, and violating conscience can dull or sear it until yielding becomes easier and at last nothing is recognized as sinful.ST Dec 30, 1913ST Dec 11, 1893ST Dec 5, 1892
Nature of Saving Faith
Faith turns the soul to Christ and receives His righteousness and power, making the believer complete in Him, and it trusts what is not yet seen as Abraham trusted the promise before he had a son and David trusted his kingship while hunted as an outlaw.ST Apr 30, 1894RH Sep 14, 1911 It receives Christ as personal Saviour, confessing one's own sins and accepting Him in living faith as the One who cleanses from sin and keeps from sinning, and it cannot be exercised on another's behalf.ST Oct 30, 1907 It receives His living presence through the Holy Spirit, trusts His Word, love and promises, and shapes everything done for God's glory.ST Apr 30, 1894ST Oct 31, 1900 It gives Christ the praise for good by recognizing that good is done only by His power and influence, while those moved to philanthropic acts without faith fail to recognize Him and take praise to themselves.ST Jul 3, 1893 God must be glorified in everything to teach the universe that there is no goodness apart from Christ by whom all things were created, for even the covering cherub depended on his Creator for goodness, brightness and power and destroyed himself by taking credit for what he was.ST Jul 3, 1893 Since angels and the unfallen intelligences of other worlds receive and retain goodness only through the power and influence of their Creator and have not sinned because they have always believed God, it is folly for sinful men to suppose they can accomplish good by themselves.ST Jul 3, 1893ST Jun 20, 1900
All human efforts to keep God's law by one's own power, no matter how earnest and sincere, without trust in Christ result only in imperfection and sin.ST Dec 15, 1898 Righteousness unto salvation comes only by believing with the heart through the grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, not by outward circumcision or any self-made righteousness that trusts in the flesh. A fallen person cannot offer works as merit or ground of salvation, because even good works are spoiled by sin and need forgiveness, and works performed before Christ's grace and the Spirit's inspiration do not please God because they do not spring from faith in Jesus Christ and cannot make people worthy to receive grace.RH Dec 2, 1858ST May 14, 1894 Seeking salvation through one's own works rather than depending on God for righteousness and the power to receive it replaces righteousness with sin, puts man in God's place, and leads to death instead of life.RH Aug 28, 1900 Faith does not free anyone from keeping the law but only from its transgression, and the law can be kept by faith alone, for Israel was at fault not for pursuing the law of righteousness but for pursuing it by works instead of by faith and therefore failed to attain it, because evil cannot produce good.ST Jul 16, 1896 Saving faith submits to and trusts God's undeserved mercy in Christ without relying on works for acceptance, and this faith is living and produces works, so a faith that produces none is dead and no true faith, while good works remain most necessary as the result of keeping the law by faith.ST Jul 16, 1896RH Dec 2, 1858
A work is acceptable only when done through love for God and love for man, which is possible only by faith that works through love and by help that comes through faith.ST Aug 13, 1896 God accepts nothing that does not proceed from supreme love to Him and equal love to fellow men, meaning all mankind and not merely one's own circle, and from faith, and whatever does not proceed from love and faith is sin.RH Aug 25, 1868 Works done without that faith necessarily savor of self and are marked by selfishness, which is heinous sin, so no one can merit pardon, justification and salvation by personal works, whether moral or remedial works God commands such as prayer, baptism and the Lord's supper, and still less by works God never commanded which spring from wisdom exalted above God's wisdom.ST Aug 13, 1896 Obedience is genuine only when it springs from trust in God, while outward compliance driven by self-interest or one's own judgment is not true obedience and can be idolatrous, and even benevolent acts are sinful when their chief motive is gaining a good name or advancing selfish interests.ST Jan 26, 1915 Works not prompted by faith are unworthy because their motive is impure, and although people may not see the distinction between works prompted by faith and works driven by other motives, God sees it and will bring it to light.RH Oct 26, 1869 A morality moved only by partial justice to one's own circle, by payment of debt or mutual insurance, or by desire to honor an institution and each other, does not meet the measure because it lacks the pure motives of universal benevolence and faith that make action acceptable to God.RH Aug 25, 1868
Unbelief is the root principle behind sin in all its forms, for without faith what remains is sin, and what may look harmless or attractive does not cease to be dangerous because it is approached without faith.RH Jan 7, 1915 To lack faith is to be under sin, and being kept under the law before faith comes is identical with being shut up under sin, because those shut up under sin are those who are not of faith, so those who are under the law are those who are transgressing the law.ST Feb 22, 1899 Those without faith are therefore in sin and, as sinners, are under the law and condemned by it.ST Jan 6, 1904 Whatever is not done from faith is missing the mark of God's glory, and through lack of faith people are not saved from their own sinful works, come short of His glory, and come short of entering into God's rest.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Jul 15, 1897 God's rest found in the seventh day is righteousness by faith, entered by believing on Him whom God sent and resting in a completed work already wrought out in Jesus Christ, just as the works were finished from the foundation of the world.ST Jul 15, 1897 Even the least unbelief, if cherished, makes the soul guilty and brings great darkness and discouragement.RH May 8, 1900
Doubting God's Word and goodness breaks His law, because doubt claims a higher knowledge than God.ST Jan 27, 1898 Questioning His Word pulls down His character and lifts the doubter above Him as judge, and setting human judgment against God's mind and will is rebellion against His rule, putting another in God's place and breaking His law against that.ST Jan 27, 1898 The measure of faith is the childlike simplicity with which a person yields his own judgment to the stated mind and will of the One who is over all.ST Jan 27, 1898 Acting without faith transgresses God's law even when no outward act expressly forbidden by the law has occurred.ST Nov 25, 1908 Merely saying Lord or asking for help does not ensure salvation, for the heart must feel its need and trust God's power and willingness to help, with faith working in the person and moving God's arm in response, and asking while not believing the requested help will be given misrepresents God and takes His name in vain.ST Nov 25, 1908
Faith rests on God's Word rather than feelings, convenience or human customs, and leads to obedience and everlasting life, while acting instead from inclination or human custom is presumption which leads to disobedience and death.RH Dec 9, 1915 Beginning theology with doubt is sin, because theology is the knowledge of God and His relation to the universe, and since whoever comes to Him must believe that He exists and rewards those who diligently seek Him, an educational method that makes doubt the guide to knowledge and requires doubting God is directly opposite to God's stated way.RH Jun 26, 1900 What is not done in faith is sin, so sin is unreasonable and the person without faith is unreasonable and wicked, and whether a person is truly reasonable depends on the heart and not merely the intellect, for foolishness comes from a depraved, deceived heart even when intellectual abilities are strong.ST Nov 5, 1896 Worry, struggle, striving and effort to be good and to make oneself perfect by the flesh instead of believing God is not of faith and is therefore sin, for sin is unbelief and doubting God.RH Mar 26, 1901 Believing, childlike faith that rests in God, receives Christ as sanctification and sanctifier, receives the Spirit of truth, and lets God keep from all sin and work in to will and to do is of faith and is not sin.RH Mar 26, 1901
Righteousness comes by faith, so a person without faith has no righteousness, and circumcision without faith is therefore only an outward sham, not a condition of salvation.ST Dec 5, 1892 Keeping God's commandments without faith in Jesus is impossible, because whatever is not of faith is sin.ST Aug 24, 1888 Faith in Christ brings Christ into the heart and life and produces obedience to God's law, while obedience offered as something to add to faith reveals trust in self-righteousness rather than Christ's righteousness.ST Dec 5, 1892 Anything in human life that does not come from faith is sin, because the law of God is against nothing but sin and is against everything that is not the fruit of the Spirit of God, so what is not the fruit of the Spirit is sin stated in another way.RH Oct 2, 1900 Faithlessness means refusing to trust God's promise, and the law was given because of such transgression to expose sin and testify against sinners until the promised Seed has fully come into the inheritance, for the law is not a means of gaining that inheritance but reveals God's righteousness and the need for His promise to work righteousness within.ST Oct 17, 1900 Since the everlasting gospel, Christ dwelling in the heart, God manifest in the flesh, the righteousness of God and true worship are all only by faith, the third angel's message is all of faith and therefore righteousness by faith.RH Jan 9, 1900
Sabbath and God's Law
The chapter deals with disputes over foods and plural days belonging to the Jewish ritual system, including meats, idol offerings, Passover foods, feast days and fast days, and annual ceremonial sabbaths and festival days, not with the weekly Sabbath of the fourth commandment or any moral commandment.RH Mar 29, 1864ST Jul 29, 1880RH Aug 19, 1851RH Aug 19, 1851RH Aug 5, 1852 It does not mention the Sabbath, the seventh day, or the first day, and its placement beside food and herbs does not by itself show any disagreement about the Sabbath.ST Jul 29, 1880RH Aug 19, 1851 Its rule is mutual forbearance between Jewish and Gentile converts without despising or judging, so that all is done unto edifying and not made a means of justification or a reason to reject Christ's sacrifice.RH Mar 29, 1864RH Aug 19, 1851RH Aug 19, 1851 To make the verse refer to the Sabbath would contradict James and Paul's own affirmation in the same epistle of the perpetuity of the law, and God would not abolish the Sabbath without explicit language, so the verse cannot prove a change without thorough testing. No distinction between clean and unclean meats is now recognized by some who hold this teaching, so that a meat distinction belonging to the Mosaic dispensation would have been fulfilled had Israel accepted it.
The chapter does not plainly teach abolition of the Lord's Sabbath and cannot serve as direct proof it was done away.RH Apr 21, 1851RH Jun 24, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852 It gives no liberty to treat the fourth commandment as optional or indifferent or to keep the Sabbath merely as a matter of weak faith, and the same keeping cannot be both indifferent and dangerous bondage.RH Jun 24, 1852RH Feb 3, 1852 Christians should be fully assured in their own minds about days they regard unto the Lord and should not judge one another over them, yet this does not make every day alike or excuse neglecting what God's word requires. The lesson of forbearance about Jewish views of eating and feast-days still held by some converts from the circumcision applied directly to divisions that troubled the apostolic church, teaching those who ate not to despise those who did not eat and those who did not eat not to judge those who ate, because God had received them.RH Apr 21, 1851 That situation of division does not now exist in the same form, so the chapter does not directly apply to the church today in that setting, and Paul bore with those errors for a time to gain access to the Jews, even having Timothy circumcised and becoming all things to all men to save some, while holding that circumcision and uncircumcision are nothing and keeping the commandments of God is something.RH Apr 21, 1851
Whatsoever is not of faith is sin, and this gives no one license to commit sin, to break God's commandments, to turn from what the Lord has instructed, to excuse what appetite suggests or the devil tempts to do, or to set himself up as judge in God's place.ST Feb 11, 1913 Every man must act as God has taught and instructed him, living and dying unto the Lord, looking with charity on practices of others that differ, doing everything not to cause another to fall, while even the strictest in self-discipline does not sit in judgment on others.ST Feb 11, 1913 Every moral question is left to individual choice in the sense that each person must be fully persuaded in his own mind, because to practice a duty such as Sabbath-keeping while doubting avails nothing, since such service is not from choice or love but the service of a slave to fear.ST May 21, 1902 The chapter does not tell a man what he should do morally about eating or Sabbath-keeping but tells him what he should not do, namely judge his neighbor, since God's Word will judge him in the last day; yet freedom does not remove harvest, for choosing to disobey God's Word reaps the wages of sin which is death, and choosing unwholesome food reaps disease, while choosing in harmony with God's Word gives righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Ghost.ST May 21, 1902
Keeping the seventh-day Sabbath holy is not mere outward rest or a work of law but requires living faith in Christ bringing pardon for past sins and sanctification of soul and body, with abstaining from worldly business, words, and thoughts in communion with God.ST Jan 11, 1877ST Oct 4, 1905RH Nov 15, 1870 Without that faith Sabbath observance is only pretence, and even outward rest without faith is sin because it misses the mark.ST Jan 11, 1877RH Nov 15, 1870ST Feb 20, 1901 Keeping holy what God made holy is not a matter of right but of power, and without faith a man cannot do what he would; only one in whom God's presence dwells can by grace keep it holy through obedience in Christ Jesus rather than mere sacrifice.ST Feb 20, 1901 Because Scripture teaches the seventh day as the day God sanctified, faithful obedience keeps that specific day and brings the worshiper into spiritual accord with God and His rest, resting on faith in His Word and not merely on choosing a day.ST Oct 4, 1905 Proper Sabbath-keeping must therefore come from faith, which the state cannot create or enforce, so religious faith and practice must be matters of conscience, not civil compulsion.RH Dec 14, 1905
Observing or not observing a day is in itself left to individual conscience before God, but failing to follow what conscience teaches about a day is sin.ST Apr 17, 1893RH Mar 28, 1871RH Mar 18, 1875 Conduct must follow inward conviction rather than mere outward compliance, so obedience imposed without winning the heart to truth would be superficial and religious observance should not be compelled.RH Mar 27, 1900 One who doubts that keeping the first day is right is condemned if he keeps it, and either keeping the first day or the seventh day without following Christ and the Bible rather than custom, the multitude, or human tradition is wrong.RH Mar 28, 1871 Those whose conscience teaches them to keep the seventh day would sin if they did not keep it.RH Mar 18, 1875 Each person should therefore be free to keep Sunday according to conscience rather than be compelled by law, since a person sins by acting while doubtful because the act does not come from faith.ST Apr 17, 1893ST Mar 31, 1887
Faith can rest only on what God has commanded in His Word, so what is not in His Word cannot be done in faith and to do it is sin.ST Sep 25, 1901 Sunday is only a human ordinance, never commanded by God and not part of His Word, so it cannot be kept in faith, and keeping it as a religious duty is sin.ST Sep 25, 1901
Forbearance Toward Brethren
The verse belongs to Paul's lesson against judging or despising fellow believers over disputed eating and observances, for each stands or falls to his own Lord and gives account of himself to God.ST Oct 8, 1912ST Nov 11, 1930ST Aug 11, 1909ST Feb 11, 1913 Differences over eating and over esteeming days kept unto the Lord with thanksgiving do not justify condemning one another, but call for charity toward differing practices and care that personal conduct can stand acquitted before Christ's judgment seat where men are judged by God's law.ST Jul 12, 1910ST Aug 11, 1909ST Feb 11, 1913 Acting while doubting is condemned because it is not done in faith, and whatever is not of faith is sin as missing God's mark even when the conduct appears morally ordinary.ST Jul 12, 1910ST Oct 8, 1912ST Aug 11, 1909 Faith in God is essential and leads to implicit obedience reaching the individual heart, yet it gives no license to commit sin, to break God's commandments, to turn from instruction, to excuse appetite or temptation, or to sit as judge in God's place.ST Jul 12, 1910ST Oct 8, 1912ST Feb 11, 1913 Every person must act as God has taught, living and dying unto the Lord, serving God faithfully and avoiding placing a stumbling-block or occasion of falling in a brother's way.ST Oct 8, 1912ST Nov 11, 1930ST Feb 11, 1913
Believers must not use liberty as license to lust but limit it out of love, following what makes for peace and builds up another.ST Feb 13, 1896ST Feb 4, 1903 Even what is right for a person must be held as faith before God and not used if it will cause a weak brother to stumble, be offended, or be made weak, and the one who does not condemn himself in what he allows is happy.ST Feb 13, 1896 Those who have knowledge that an idol is nothing must still abstain for the sake of weak recent converts from heathenism, lest with weak consciences they be defiled and caused to stumble and perish, as taught also in 1 Corinthians 8:1-13 and decided in the conference at Jerusalem for practical questions then troubling Corinth and now troubling followers of Christ.ST Feb 13, 1896ST Jul 29, 1897ST Feb 4, 1903 The same teaching makes Romans 14:1-23 a lesson in Christian self-control and temperance in eating and drinking, living not to self but for others.ST Jul 29, 1897ST Feb 4, 1903 The kingdom of God is not food and drink but righteousness and peace and joy in the Holy Spirit, and serving Christ in these things is acceptable to God and approved by men, so diet is not to be treated as a burden or as a way to become righteous but chosen for what is best to God's glory.ST Feb 13, 1896ST Aug 10, 1915
Eating or abstaining from a particular food does not save anyone, for salvation is through Christ and not by human rules.ST Jul 29, 1913 One who belongs to Christ will seek to obey God and eat and drink to glorify Him, but obedience follows connection with Christ rather than creating it.ST Jul 29, 1913
Faith Against Compulsion
Religion is a personal relation of faith and obedience to God that must be voluntary, springing from the heart and performed in love to please and honor Him.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Apr 16, 1894ST Aug 17, 1915ST Jun 18, 1912ST Dec 12, 1916 Faith is the mainspring of obedience, and because it is voluntary it cannot be produced, directed, or controlled by civil law or compulsion.ST Apr 16, 1894ST Aug 17, 1915ST Jun 18, 1912ST Dec 12, 1916RH Sep 3, 1903 Anything not done from faith is sin, so outward observance of a religious institution by one who has no faith in it or believes it to be wrong is hollow mockery that cannot be acceptable to God.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Apr 16, 1894RH Sep 3, 1903 Observance motivated by self-interest, human approval, or pressure gives allegiance to the human power or influence that secured it rather than to God, and enforced conformity produces only hypocritical worship.ST Apr 16, 1894RH Sep 3, 1903 To compel men and women against their convictions of right and duty to render such outward service robs them of their dearest and most sacred rights and invades conscience.RH Feb 8, 1912
Whatsoever is of the Word of God is of faith, because faith comes by the Word of God, and without faith it is impossible to please God.ST Oct 18, 1899 Religion is due solely to God as the duty owed to the Creator and the manner of discharging it, closing the teaching of Romans 13 and 14 on the separation of what is due to God from what is due to the powers that be.ST Oct 18, 1899 Therefore for the powers that be, or any men through the powers that be, to require anything due to God subverts faith and requires men to sin, so that any connection between religion and the State is sin, whose greatest example is the man of sin.ST Oct 18, 1899 To love the Lord with all heart, soul, strength, and mind and neighbor as self, keeping the first two of all the commandments, is complete separation from sin and is the basis and surety of the separation of religion and the State.ST Oct 18, 1899
To constrain Christians to do what they believe unjust, or to compel a religious act in which they have no faith, is to force them to sin, and those who force them incur a terrible responsibility.RH Nov 9, 1911ST Sep 13, 1910RH Nov 28, 1907ST Dec 12, 1911 Eating while doubting condemns because it is not of faith, and practicing a religious rite one does not believe in brings condemnation before God even when civil or church authorities pressure it.ST Nov 7, 1895RH Nov 28, 1907 Compelling someone to observe a day as the Sabbath when that person does not believe it is the Sabbath therefore compels that person to sin and violates conscience.RH Nov 9, 1911ST Sep 13, 1910ST Dec 12, 1911 Such compulsion is unchristian, violates the Golden Rule since no one would wish to be forced to observe a day against his own views and wishes, and renders to civil government what belongs to God alone.ST Dec 12, 1911 Making religious tests and threatening temporal punishment for noncompliance with religious customs only makes men hypocrites, never converts, because it forces outward compliance without inward faith.ST Nov 7, 1895
Difficult matters of religion must be handled not with the sword but with the sure Word of God, leading people by that Word to acknowledge what is good, and if all Christians and all men in authority understood this truth and acted upon it, there would never again be religious persecution. Governments may require obedience in civil matters but have no right to control religious belief or practice, for religious belief and practice must arise from personal faith for which each person is accountable to God, not to civil rulers.ST Mar 19, 1894ST Jun 18, 1912 Civil government therefore has no right to legislate or enforce religious observance such as a day of rest or baptism.RH Feb 8, 1912 Christian institutions such as the memorial of Christ's resurrection, the Sabbath, and the memorials of Christ's death belong to the church alone and must never be enforced upon unbelievers, since God's ordinances are designed to be an expression of faith and observance without faith is sin.RH Apr 3, 1900 God does not want unbelievers to observe His ordinances, and to force an ungodly man to keep them compels him to act the hypocrite.RH Apr 3, 1900 One person cannot believe or act for another before God, and a public official cannot supply faith on behalf of the people, as in thanksgiving proclamations and national religion.RH Nov 17, 1904
Understanding and putting God's principles of government into practice requires faith in God and His Word.RH Feb 18, 1902 God's government seeks obedience through love and for the governed person's good, unlike worldly rule driven by ambition or the assertion of power.RH Feb 18, 1902 Those who follow God trust His leading even when they cannot understand it, and parents and teachers need that same faith as they learn and apply biblical principles in governing children and pupils.RH Feb 18, 1902
Everyday Obedience Tests
Whether eating flesh is right must be decided by individual conscience acting in faith to glorify God, without condemning fellow believers who eat or who refrain.RH Oct 6, 1904ST Sep 24, 1912 One who discerns and puts a difference between meats, who has come to see that some meats are unfit, is condemned if he eats against that discernment and light, because he eats not of faith and acts without settled conviction that the act honors God.RH Mar 12, 1867RH Oct 6, 1904RH Mar 12, 1867ST Sep 24, 1912ST Dec 5, 1895 Willing, selfish, determined indulgence in what God's Word has declared unclean cannot be done with belief that it will bring glory to God, and to eat in that unbelieving state is sin, while eating from necessity when no other food is available to sustain life does not bring condemnation.ST Sep 24, 1912ST Dec 5, 1895 The original diet and the manna excluded flesh, and much flesh food now corrupts the body, dulls spiritual responsiveness and calls for stimulation, yet there are times and places where flesh is the best food to be had, as with Noah after the flood, Elijah fed bread and flesh in famine, and Jesus eating fish, so eating flesh in faith that it glorifies God is permitted while a vegetarian diet free from corrupted flesh foods is better for making the natural man more spiritual. Each must act according to the light that all of inspiration together gives about food and give the reasons of faith for discerning between meats, acting from personal conviction before God rather than imitating another, and since wholesome food for one may harm another changes should be careful without extremes or pressure and differences of conviction are no ground for persecution.RH Mar 12, 1867RH Oct 6, 1904
Eating and drinking and all healthful living must be of faith to the glory of God, for what is done without faith is sin.RH Jul 15, 1902 God has a standard for food and drink rooted in His moral law, where what destroys the body violates His law and what builds it up accords with it, and the right relation to that standard is to receive its principles into the heart in love.RH Jul 15, 1902 Seeking health by human works and effort, from duty or from a merely scientific standpoint that leaves God out, even while following right principles, is sin.RH Jul 15, 1902 The faithful way is to trust God to change the heart and the perverted appetite, to take away cravings for strong drink and lust for flesh and desire for evil things and put love for the wholesome and pure in their place.RH Jul 15, 1902
Whatever is doubtful is dangerous and must be left alone, for to act while doubting brings condemnation.ST Oct 30, 1884RH Apr 25, 1912ST Jan 4, 1905 In amusements and recreations any activity about which conscience raises a question is wrong for that person while the question remains and must be crossed off the list of possible recreations, keeping on the safe side of certainty and never skating on thin ice when strong ice is available.ST Oct 30, 1884RH Apr 25, 1912ST Jan 4, 1905RH Mar 12, 1914ST Jun 23, 1881 Even after the doubt is later removed it should still stay crossed off for at least six months, because enough amusements free from doubt remain and safety lies only on certain, strong ground.ST Oct 30, 1884RH Apr 25, 1912 The Master should be given the benefit of the doubt by staying away from the doubtful choice, and choices should be tested by whether they benefit rather than injure oneself or one's neighbor, with a clear conscience and God's approval necessary in choosing recreation.ST Jan 4, 1905RH Mar 12, 1914ST Jun 23, 1881
Asking God for blessings without believing they will be received is sinful, for whatever is not done in faith is sin, and doubt must be resisted by firmly believing God's promise while patiently waiting for it to be fulfilled through Christ's merits and sufficient saving and sustaining grace.RH Jul 23, 1857 Prayer of faith trusts Christ's command and promise, while recognizing that God may withhold a requested thing or answer in an unexpected way because His wisdom and glory are greater than the petitioner's wishes, yet believers are still to trust that He hears and will provide what is best and most needed.ST Aug 21, 1884 Faith must rest on God's Word, so praying for or expecting something one has no warrant to seek or expect is not prayer in faith; faith trusts God to meet ordinary needs through His providence, but when only a miracle can bring deliverance it trusts His power rather than doubting His promise.RH Jun 12, 1855
Baptism in the absence of faith cannot please God, since an act done without faith is sin.RH Mar 28, 1871 One who doubts whether infant baptism is right is condemned if he practices it, because acting without faith while doubting whether an act is right is sin.RH Mar 28, 1871
Bringing the full tithe, not merely part of it, must be an experience of faith, and faith opens the way for God's promised blessing. Raising money for church debts, church building or repairing, Sabbath schools, missionary enterprises, the minister's salary, relieving the poor, or any benevolent operation by feasts, soirees, fancy fairs, picnics, concerts, exhibitions, donation, tea or strawberry parties, sleigh rides, oyster suppers, weddings, and other excitements to inflame the passions, excite appetite, and produce fun and vulgar merriment is sin, because it is not done in a sober, rational, gospel way from faith but by worldly policy, foolish talking and jesting, feasting and frolicking, putting money getting above gospel and soul saving in friendship with the world which is enmity with God.RH Jul 26, 1864
Preaching sacred truths without believing them is sinful and cannot advance God's righteousness, and if acting against faith or conscience is sin in ordinary actions it applies especially to preaching, so a preacher who does not truly believe Christ's deity, the Bible's authority, or the need for regeneration dishonors those truths by proclaiming them without faith.ST Mar 19, 1885 A religious system that relies on visible images and representations because it cannot perceive the invisible shows lack of true faith and is therefore sinful, and the same judgment applies to professed Protestantism when it compromises with or supports that system, for what is not of faith is not from God but belongs to the world, follows its ways, and twists God's way by demanding that God accept worship shaped by the world.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Nov 19, 1896 Faith itself works the works of God in the believer, and like a living tree bearing fruit living faith necessarily produces works, while faith without works is dead and works not produced by faith are sinful, not a substitute for living faith.ST Oct 15, 1896
Sinful actions include not only outward wrongdoing but also words, thoughts, attitudes, and conduct toward others, for anything done without faith is sin.ST Jun 26, 1893 Whatever is not done from faith is sin, so even an apparently small or harmless act becomes accountable as sin when faith is lacking, and no sin is little in God's sight, since doing evil means stepping out from under the cross which marks separation from the world and calls for sacrifice.ST May 13, 1875RH Dec 18, 1860ST Nov 16, 1876 In even the smallest acts of life, worship, and service what is done must spring from faith, for praise without faith is valueless; faith is active, involving the will's movement toward God and readiness to do what God asks.RH Feb 27, 1900 Ordinary worldly labor and daily toil give eternal life in the performance of the act itself only when done in the same faith and hope as any religious duty, for the glory of God, to lighten others' load and bring others to Christ.ST Apr 9, 1896
In training children acting without faith is sin, so a parent must place confidence in the child and let him know good results are expected, and they will come, for a child who has his parent's confidence and knows only good is expected from him will respect himself and his parent, will dread to disappoint that trust, and will gain mastery over wrong.RH Dec 10, 1901 Conduct must follow inward conviction rather than mere outward compliance, so obedience imposed without winning the child's heart to truth would be superficial, and religious observance should not be compelled.RH Mar 27, 1900 In matters such as health and dress reform a person should follow what they believe is light from Heaven, and if they do not believe they should live only according to the faith they have rather than acting beyond it.RH Apr 26, 1870 Spending time and resources to perpetuate a worldly holiday custom cannot be justified by sentimental claims about family ties or friendship when the custom is not grounded in faith.ST Dec 17, 1894 God accepts nothing that does not proceed from supreme love to Him and equal love to fellow men and from faith, meaning all mankind and not merely one's own group, so a morality moved only by partial justice to one's own circle, by payment of debt or mutual insurance, or by desire to honor an institution and each other lacks the pure motives of universal benevolence and faith that make action acceptable.RH Aug 25, 1868 Beginning theology with doubt as guide is sin, because theology is the knowledge of God and His relation to the universe and whoever comes to Him must believe that He exists and rewards those who diligently seek Him, so an educational method requiring doubting God is directly opposite to God's stated way.RH Jun 26, 1900
Religious service performed without faith is sin, however careful, impressive, or valuable it may appear.ST Nov 1, 1899 Cain's offering lacked blood and therefore did not express faith in the coming Saviour whose blood would be shed for humanity's salvation, while Abel's unblemished animal offering followed God's appointed pattern and showed faith in the Redeemer; Cain could have obtained an animal from Abel, as God's words about a sin-offering at the door indicated, and without faith his offering was a hollow act and an offense against God.ST Nov 1, 1899 When people lose faith their actions are sinful, as shown when the Israelites worshiped the brazen serpent without faith.ST Jun 3, 1889
Sources