1 Corinthians 14:34
Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law.
Translations
Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted to them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience as also says the law.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Let your women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law.
Let your women keep silence in the churches; for it is not permitted to them to speak: but they are commanded to be under obedience, as also saith the law.
Let the women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but let them be in subjection, as also saith the law.
let the women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted unto them to speak; but let them be in subjection, as also saith the law.
Your women in the assemblies let them be silent, for it hath not been permitted to them to speak, but to be subject, as also the law saith;
Let [ your] women be silent in the assemblies, for it is not permitted to them to speak; but to be in subjection, as the law also says.
As for the women, in the assemblies, let them be silent, for it is not permitted them to be speaking; but let them be in submission,—even as, the law, saith.
Women are to be silent in the churches. They are not permitted to speak, but must be in submission, as the law says.
Your women are to be silent in the churches. They are not permitted to speak, but must be in submission, as the law says.
Let the wives be quiet in the assemblies, for it has not been permitted for them to be talking except in submission, as the law also says,
Let women keep quiet in the churches: for it is not right for them to be talking; but let them be under control, as it says in the law.
Let your women keepe silence in the Churches: for it is not permitted vnto them to speake: but they ought to be subiect, as also the Lawe sayth.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Let women keep silence in the churches: for it is not permitted them to speak, but to be subject, as also the law saith.
Cross-references 20 of 22
- 1 Corinthians 11:5
But every woman that prayeth or prophesieth with her head uncovered dishonoureth her head: for that is even all one as if she were shaven.
Paul’s other instruction about women praying and prophesying informs how this passage is read.
- 1 Timothy 2:11-12
Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection.
Also addresses women’s silence and conduct in church.
- Acts 21:9
And the same man had four daughters, virgins, which did prophesy.
Philip’s daughters prophesied, illustrating women’s exercise of the gift.
- Acts 2:17-18
And it shall come to pass in the last days, saith God, I will pour out of my Spirit upon all flesh: and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, and your young men shall see visions, and your old men shall dream dreams:
The Spirit’s outpouring includes daughters prophesying.
- Joel 2:28-29
And it shall come to pass afterward, that I will pour out my spirit upon all flesh; and your sons and your daughters shall prophesy, your old men shall dream dreams, your young men shall see visions:
The prophecy includes daughters and handmaids among those who receive the Spirit and prophesy.
- Genesis 3:16
Unto the woman he said, I will greatly multiply thy sorrow and thy conception; in sorrow thou shalt bring forth children; and thy desire shall be to thy husband, and he shall rule over thee.
Both describe the woman’s subjection to the man’s rule.
- 1 Timothy 2:13-14
For Adam was first formed, then Eve.
Adam’s priority in creation and Eve’s transgression are given as grounds for women’s subordinate position.
- 1 Corinthians 11:13
Judge in yourselves: is it comely that a woman pray unto God uncovered?
Both address women’s conduct when praying publicly.
- 1 Corinthians 14:26
How is it then, brethren? when ye come together, every one of you hath a psalm, hath a doctrine, hath a tongue, hath a revelation, hath an interpretation. Let all things be done unto edifying.
The meeting’s competing contributions are addressed by instructions for orderly conduct and edification.
- 1 Corinthians 14:27-30
If any man speak in an unknown tongue, let it be by two, or at the most by three, and that by course; and let one interpret.
Both regulate speaking in the assembly to prevent disorder.
- 1 Timothy 2:11
Let the woman learn in silence with all subjection.
Both instruct women to learn or keep silent with submission.
- 1 Corinthians 14:40
Let all things be done decently and in order.
Both direct orderly conduct in the church.
- 1 Corinthians 11:3
But I would have you know, that the head of every man is Christ; and the head of the woman is the man; and the head of Christ is God.
Both describe women’s subordination to men.
- Ephesians 5:22
Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as unto the Lord.
Both texts teach wives’ submission to their husbands.
- Galatians 3:28
There is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither bond nor free, there is neither male nor female: for ye are all one in Christ Jesus.
In Christ, there is neither male nor female.
- Titus 2:5
To be discreet, chaste, keepers at home, good, obedient to their own husbands, that the word of God be not blasphemed.
supports order of man first
- 1 Corinthians 11:8-9
For the man is not of the woman; but the woman of the man.
Man is placed first, and woman is created for him.
- Genesis 2:22-23
And the rib, which the LORD God had taken from man, made he a woman, and brought her unto the man.
Eve’s creation after Adam is invoked to explain women’s relation to authority.
- Colossians 3:18
Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands, as it is fit in the Lord.
Both texts teach submission as part of an ordered relationship.
- 1 Corinthians 14:1-20
Follow after charity, and desire spiritual gifts, but rather that ye may prophesy.
same chapter discussion continued
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
2 sources
The instruction about women keeping silence has been brought forward as an objection to a woman speaking publicly.Lt 17a, 1880, par. 5–6 It does not prohibit women from speaking in public.10MR 70.3Lt 17a, 1880, par. 5–6 It does not forbid women to preach to a mixed congregation in church.10MR 70.3 When the apostle's words are clearly explained, their true meaning answers the objection to women speaking in public and removes it.10MR 70.3 Women are left free to address the church with God's special power.10MR 70.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
78 sources
The silence enjoined is orderly restraint of speech in worship, not absolute or permanent speechlessness, requiring subjection under the order established in Genesis 3:16 with modesty and proper decorum.RH Jan 24, 1871RH Dec 2, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Mar 19, 1861 The speech forbidden is disorderly and insubordinate speech that usurps authority over men, such as asking troublesome questions, disputing, judging, dictating and wrangling in the meeting.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jun 26, 1866ST Jul 15, 1897ST May 30, 1878 It corrects the confusion and evils in the disorderly gatherings at Corinth, where tongues without interpretation, many speaking at once, heathen excesses and synagogue-style interruptions destroyed edification.ST Dec 19, 1900ST Nov 29, 1883ST Sep 16, 1913ST Feb 10, 1881 It does not forbid women to pray, prophesy, exhort, testify and sing when led by the Spirit modestly and in turn, agreeing with 1 Corinthians 11, Joel 2 and the service of Phebe, Priscilla and others in the gospel.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1900RH Dec 2, 1862RH Mar 19, 1861ST Aug 26, 1875 Those who held the ban to be plain and permanent teach that it is to be upheld as inspired instruction forbidding women to teach and preach in church, while the weight of teaching holds it to be local to confusing assemblies and business courts and not to be used to silence Spirit-prompted witness or to forbid voting and orderly public worship.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Dec 9, 1889ST Feb 10, 1904RH Jan 28, 1902ST Jun 17, 1875
Silence, Obedience, Law
Silence in the churches means orderly restraint of speech, not absolute or permanent speechlessness.RH Dec 2, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Oct 15, 1857ST Apr 5, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901 It regulates disorderly or insubmissive conduct rather than barring all women's speech in religious gatherings, and does not forbid women to sing, pray, exhort, prophesy, or testify of what the Lord has done.RH Dec 2, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Mar 19, 1861RH Oct 15, 1857ST Feb 27, 1901 The command addresses women who disrupt the meeting, contribute to confusion through improper talk, or take the lead over qualified brethren, especially through questions that lead to disputes.RH Dec 2, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Mar 19, 1861RH Oct 15, 1857ST Apr 5, 1899 Those who want to learn were to avoid questions that lead to disputes in the meeting and ask outside the meeting or at home, and to speak and act in ways that preserve order and promote edification, exhortation, and comfort.ST Apr 5, 1899RH Mar 19, 1861RH Oct 15, 1857ST Apr 5, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901 Its call to be under obedience means being in subjection, as the law also teaches, and the same letter's directions about how women should appear when praying and prophesying show women are not forbidden to speak in church.RH Dec 2, 1862RH Mar 19, 1861RH Oct 15, 1857ST Apr 5, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901
The speech forbidden is disorderly and insubordinate speech in public assemblies, such as asking troublesome questions, catechising the speaker, objecting, disputing, attempting to refute, altercating, wrangling, dictating, judging, and setting judgment against men.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jun 26, 1866RH Jul 16, 1901ST Aug 26, 1875 Such disruptive interlocutions, borrowed from the Jewish synagogue where ignorant and talkative hearers contended over doctrine in a liberty then allowed to men, produced confusion instead of edification.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jun 26, 1866RH Jul 16, 1901 The restriction guards against confusion and unbecoming debate and concerns irregular conduct that disrupts order and rejects the assigned order of authority, not faithful public testimony given under the Spirit's influence to strengthen, comfort, edify, and encourage the church.ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jun 26, 1866RH Jul 16, 1901ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jun 26, 1866
The forbidden speech is speech that usurps authority over men, domineers, lords it over men in church matters, claims authority not given, and acts with boldness and arrogance contrary to God's order.ST Jul 15, 1897ST May 30, 1878ST Aug 27, 1896ST May 13, 1903ST Apr 22, 1897 It forbids women from teaching and ruling in the church by usurping authority, from domineering over men, and from disputing or asserting authority over men in public assemblies or putting themselves forward immodestly.ST Jul 15, 1897ST May 30, 1878ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 27, 1896ST May 13, 1903 Women may still speak on proper occasions with assurance in Christ's name and becoming modesty, bearing modest testimony, praying, prophesying, teaching when specially led by God, and serving as gospel helpers, each serving in the sphere God assigned.ST Jul 15, 1897ST May 30, 1878ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 27, 1896ST May 13, 1903 Men and women are equal in God's sight, and the principles restraining boldness and arrogance also apply to men, whose strength likewise lies in modesty rather than ruling or instructing beyond what the Lord has given.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Aug 27, 1896ST May 13, 1903ST Apr 22, 1897
Being under obedience means being in subjection under the order established in Genesis 3:16, a relative subjection marked by modesty, humility, and proper decorum, not bondage, inequality, servility, or slavery.RH Jan 24, 1871RH Dec 2, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899ST Apr 5, 1899ST Feb 17, 1888 It reflects the subordinate position assigned to women and the order of authority between man and woman, calling for willing learning from those fitted to lead and submission to those appointed to lead, without usurping man's authority.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Apr 5, 1899ST Apr 5, 1899ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 27, 1901 It does not teach inequality or slavery for woman and must be read in harmony with the gospel principle that elevates all to equal standing, equal privileges, and equal accountability before God.ST Apr 5, 1899ST Jul 15, 1897ST Apr 5, 1899ST Feb 17, 1888 As also saith the law appeals to the Pentateuch and law of Moses as God's word, showing Paul treated it as divine authority rather than as a record to be questioned.ST Nov 1, 1905
The word let is advisory, neither mandatory nor permissive, as taught by those who hold verses 34-35 to be words spoken by objectors rather than Paul's own command.ST If the silence were a general ban on speaking in public worship, it would also forbid women to pray and to sing there, since singing is a form of speech, so allowing singing while forbidding other speech is inconsistent and gives no basis for that distinction.RH Mar 14, 1871ST Aug 17, 1876 The command for women to ask their husbands at home shows the silence cannot be a broad ban on speaking in religious meetings, for then women could simply hear there and would have no need to stay away.RH Sep 10, 1857
Corinthian Disorder Corrected
The command belongs to correction of abuses, confusion, discord and evils that had crept into the disorderly meetings at Corinth, and it stands within directions that worship in the use of spiritual gifts be conducted decently and in order.ST Dec 19, 1900ST Nov 29, 1883ST Dec 9, 1897RH Nov 8, 1906 It does not enjoin silence upon women in every proper sphere, but corrects disorderly conduct and blameworthy disorders where some assumed authority to teach and rule in ways contrary to Scripture.ST Dec 9, 1897ST Mar 5, 1896 It addresses meaningless noises and confusion rather than forbidding women to speak, pray, prophesy, bear testimony, help in the work, or proclaim truth in a womanly Christian manner when there is proper opportunity.ST Dec 19, 1900ST Mar 5, 1896
The disorder included exercising the gift of tongues without an interpreter, more than one speaking at a time, and pressing forward to offer a psalm, teaching, or revelation, with disputes over who had authority to direct the gathering and how it should be conducted.ST Sep 16, 1913ST Feb 10, 1881ST Aug 17, 1876 The silence applies to those disputes, calling for acceptance of the decision and then taking a proper part in the meeting for edification.ST Feb 10, 1881 The same abuse of gifts is found still, in pouring forth unintelligible words, importunate persuasion of everyone met, and traveling from place to place to preach by claimed special command with almost no real converts.RH Dec 17, 1908
Part of the trouble came from converts bringing heathen customs into the church and acting after the manner of heathen priestesses, with frantic actions, excitement, immodesty, and unwomanly, out-of-place use of new-found freedom.ST Jun 15, 1915ST Dec 8, 1914 This stood in contrast to respectable Jewish, Roman and Greek women who appeared veiled in public, while idolatrous priestesses devoted to abandon appeared with disheveled hair.ST Dec 8, 1914 The correction therefore calls Christian women to proper order, modesty and deportment, to teach and even preach in their proper place in winning ways without assuming undue authority over men, since women leading and men being led is incongruous and mannish women and womanish men are little help.ST Dec 8, 1914
Another part came from disruptive interlocutions borrowed from the Jewish synagogue, where ignorant and talkative hearers asked questions, catechised the speaker, objected, altercated, attempted to refute, and contended with men over doctrine.ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jul 16, 1901ST Dec 19, 1878 That liberty was then allowed to men, but it produced confusion instead of edification, and God is not the author of confusion but of peace.ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jul 16, 1901 The restriction guards against unbecoming debate and preserves fitting decorum and modest reserve, without forbidding praying or prophesying for the comfort and edification of the church.ST Dec 19, 1878RH Jul 16, 1901ST Dec 19, 1878 The question of God giving the gift of prophecy to women was not in view, and those receiving particular influence from God to teach are directed elsewhere and must obey that influence.RH Jul 16, 1901
The rebuke describes the effects of sin and social degradation among converted women who treated gatherings like heathen temples after idolatrous and wicked backgrounds, not God's original ideal for women.ST Feb 27, 1901 It rebukes what is not modest and humble and what usurps authority, and calls women to learn willingly from those fitted to lead and to submit to those appointed to lead the churches.ST Feb 27, 1901 It does not forbid women to serve, speak for God, prophesy, offer praise and prayer, talk, witness or sing, for the Spirit has rested on women in all ages for such work.ST Dec 8, 1914
Who Speaks the Ban
The demand that women keep silence in the churches is not Paul's own command but words spoken by objectors, Corinthian men whose letter he quotes only to reject.STST Jun 14, 1899ST Jun 15, 1915ST Dec 8, 1914ST Sep 16, 1913 The word let in the quotation is advisory, neither mandatory nor permissive.ST The pronouns mark the distinction, with the women addressed in the quoted suggestion and the men addressed in Paul's answer.ST Jun 14, 1899 On this understanding another explanation is also given, that verses 34-35 state an objection raised by people in the church who would control those moved by the Spirit.ST Jun 15, 1915
Paul's indignant reply in verse 36, asking whether the word of God came out from them or came unto them only, rejects the demand for silence and challenges their claim to authority over God's word.STST Jun 14, 1899ST Jun 15, 1915ST Dec 8, 1914ST Sep 16, 1913 His own teaching is to desire prophecy, not to forbid speaking in tongues, and to keep everything decently and in order without suppressing Spirit-moved testimony, praise, and instruction.STST Jun 15, 1915ST Sep 16, 1913 He would not forbid women to speak when he had just given instruction on how they should appear when praying and prophesying in public.ST Dec 8, 1914
Set beside this is the teaching that the verse means exactly what it says as Paul's inspired instruction and is to be upheld, not discarded, to be read alongside the passages about women praying or prophesying and women who prophesied.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Feb 10, 1904 Taken as plainly enjoining silence, the claim that women now have a right to speak and teach by later light sets private judgment against Paul's inspiration and asserts that the Holy Spirit later reversed what the Spirit had said through Paul.RH Jan 28, 1902
Even if the command is taken as Paul's ban on public teaching and prophesying, it was only a local and temporary rule grounded in expediency and adaptation to national and provincial conventionalities, not the permanent law of the church.RH Jul 16, 1901 It is like abstaining from meats offered to idols because weak brethren stumbled over it, though eating is not sinful in itself, and like practicing circumcision to regard conscientious scruples though it is not binding on Christians.RH Jul 16, 1901 The permanent law is given by Joel, your daughters shall prophesy, which covers fifteen hundred years of women prophesying in the Old Testament period and more widely in the Christian dispensation, recognized by Peter and Luke and by Paul himself as the custom of his day.RH Jul 16, 1901
What Women May Still Do
Women may pray, prophesy, exhort, sing, testify of what the Lord has done, and speak praise and personal experience when led by the Spirit.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1900RH Dec 2, 1862RH Jun 26, 1866RH Oct 15, 1857 Such speaking is to be done modestly, in turn, and for edification, exhortation, and comfort, avoiding unwomanly conduct and disorderly or insubmissive interruption of the meeting.RH Jan 24, 1871ST Dec 19, 1900RH Dec 2, 1862RH Jun 26, 1866RH Oct 15, 1857 The prohibition does not bar this Spirit-given speech but corrects abuses, possibly concerning business matters, and leaves no real excuse for coldness that evades the solemn duty and precious privilege of praise.ST Dec 19, 1900RH Dec 2, 1862RH Jun 26, 1866ST Dec 9, 1889 Women did prophesy, serve, help, and labor in the gospel, which necessarily involved bearing testimony to Christ, in whose communion there is neither male nor female, while God has still placed man first as the stronger vessel with women under obedience.RH Jan 24, 1871RH Dec 2, 1862ST Dec 9, 1889
Prophesying means speaking and exhorting for the comfort and edification of the church.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 26, 1875 When the whole church comes together all speak and all may prophesy, females as well as males if the Spirit directs, and that all includes the sisters equally with the brethren.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jun 3, 1873 In the same letter direction is given for how a woman should be attired while praying or prophesying in the public congregation, allotting praying and prophesying to women no less than to men.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jun 3, 1873 Women may teach and even preach or lecture in their proper place when specially moved by God and given the gift.ST Jun 15, 1915ST May 24, 1910RH Jul 30, 1861 This is to be done in sweet and blessed winning ways, without assuming undue authority over men, without boisterous, immodest, or arrogant conduct, and in subjection to those appointed to lead the churches.ST Jun 15, 1915ST May 24, 1910RH Feb 23, 1860
Men and women are equal in God's sight and in relation to God, each serving in the sphere God assigned.ST Jul 15, 1897ST May 13, 1903ST Feb 17, 1888ST Jul 29, 1889 Man is assigned a ruling position and placed first, and women are not to lord it over men in church matters, claim authority they do not have, or act domineeringly, boldly, or arrogantly.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Dec 9, 1889ST May 13, 1903ST Apr 22, 1897 A woman's strength lies in modesty, humility, faithfulness, and the power to win others, not in ruling or instructing, and these principles of avoiding boldness and arrogance also apply to men.ST May 13, 1903ST Apr 22, 1897ST Feb 17, 1888 The restriction on usurping authority concerns domestic affairs, not the exercise of spiritual gifts in church, and does not forbid women from praying, prophesying, preaching, or exhorting in public or from using gifts God gave them to advance His cause.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Feb 23, 1860
Women who want to learn were to avoid questions that lead to disputes in the meeting and ask their husbands at home or seek instruction outside the meeting.RH Jul 30, 1861ST Apr 5, 1899RH Apr 22, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Sep 10, 1857 The silence belongs to disorderly, confusing assemblies and to church courts and business meetings where members discuss matters, judge candidates, and dispute authority, not to ordinary public and social worship or to speaking about a risen or coming Saviour.RH Jul 30, 1861ST Apr 5, 1899RH Apr 22, 1862ST Apr 5, 1899RH Sep 10, 1857 Women without husbands need not know every detail of church business, which men are capable of managing.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Apr 22, 1862RH Sep 10, 1857 The verse forbids women to act as public teachers while still allowing women to prophesy, distinguishing prophecy from acting as public teachers.RH Mar 19, 1861RH Oct 15, 1857RH Mar 2, 1852
Agreement with Other Scriptures
The command must agree with chapter 11, written before it, where every woman is allowed to pray and prophesy in the church just as every man does, with direction only about covering the head and about appearance, dress, and wearing of hair.RH Mar 19, 1861RH Jul 30, 1861RH Aug 8, 1871 Prophesying means speaking and exhorting unto men for comfort, edification, and exhortation, and when the whole church is come together all speak and all may prophesy, females as well as males if the Spirit directs.RH Mar 19, 1861ST Aug 26, 1875 The silence therefore cannot forbid the very things just permitted with liberty, for praying or prophesying is not named in the ban, and to forbid it would make Paul sanction female prophesying in one place and forbid it in another.RH Mar 19, 1861RH Jul 16, 1901RH Aug 8, 1871 The question of God giving the gift of prophecy to women was not in view, and women who received particular influence from God to teach are directed in 1 Corinthians 11 and must obey that influence.RH Jul 16, 1901ST The command was given to correct some particular abuse existing in the Corinthian church, namely disruptive interlocutions that produced confusion instead of edification, such as asking questions, catechising the speaker, objecting, altercating, attempting to refute, and contending with men over doctrine.RH Mar 19, 1861RH Jul 16, 1901
The explanation that the direction about women praying or prophesying was only hypothetical, provided any such thing were allowable, while the silence then expressly forbids it, is trifling and cannot be what was meant.ST Aug 26, 1875 The silence does not cancel the promise of Joel that daughters shall prophesy, which covers fifteen hundred years of women prophesying in the Old Testament period and more widely in the Christian dispensation.RH Jul 16, 1901ST Aug 26, 1875 That promise is recognized by Peter and Luke and by Paul himself as the custom of his day, and it is not shut out from the all who speak and prophesy when the whole church is come together, since that all includes the sisters equally with the brethren.RH Jul 16, 1901ST Aug 26, 1875 To make the silence forbid such speaking would set Paul against other sacred writers and against himself, and would contradict the examples of women taking public part in the Old and New Testaments.ST Aug 26, 1875
Paul wrote the command to the Corinthians about a year before A.D. 60, yet when he came into the house of Philip the evangelist in A.D. 60 he left Philip's four daughters free to follow their calling to prophesy without rebuke or protest.ST Aug 26, 1875 Such labor in the gospel proves these women were not altogether silent in the churches, as do Phebe as servant of the church, Priscilla as helper in Christ Jesus, Tryphena and Tryphosa who labored in the Lord, Persis who labored much in the Lord, and other women who labored with Paul and are ranked with Clement and fellow-laborers whose names are in the book of life.ST Aug 26, 1875RH Dec 16, 1858ST Aug 26, 1875 Priscilla with her husband Aquila expounded unto Apollos the way of God more perfectly, and women are shown serving, teaching, prophesying, and laboring in the gospel while Paul's directions elsewhere in the same letter assume that women pray and prophesy in the congregation.RH Dec 16, 1858ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jun 26, 1866
The verse is linked with 1 Corinthians 11:5-6 on women covering their heads and their conduct in worship, is explained by 1 Timothy 2:11-12, and is to be read alongside passages about women praying or prophesying and women who prophesied.ST Feb 10, 1904ST Jun 16, 1914 Its instruction about women's speech bears on their participation and should be considered alongside 1 Timothy 2:11 and in keeping with the unity of believers in Christ, where male and female are one.RH Dec 9, 1862RH Jan 12, 1860 It stands at the close of the readings running from 1 Corinthians 10:19 through chapter 14 and belongs with chapters 12 through 14, which treat spiritual gifts and love.ST Aug 25, 1909 Taken by itself, the declaration that women should keep silent, should not speak, should be under obedience, with the law also given as support, can sound like a general ban on women speaking or participating in public worship.RH Jun 26, 1866ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 26, 1875 Read with the apostle's other instruction and the Bible's accounts of women's spiritual work, it does not prohibit all public participation by women, does not contradict what Paul says elsewhere, and gives no objection to women taking part in public worship as conducted at the present day.RH Jun 26, 1866STST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jun 26, 1866
Scope and Present Use
The instruction is local and individual, fitted to peculiar evils in Corinth and belonging to its own time, and it cannot now be fully understood in every detail, with different countries and customs calling for different application.ST Feb 17, 1888ST Jan 20, 1909RH Oct 4, 1870 It was given to correct a local irregularity there, of the same kind Timothy was to meet in his labor, and it does not forbid women to take part in praising God, to witness for God in public, or to pray, prophesy, teach and help in the gospel in a proper manner.ST Feb 17, 1888ST Jan 20, 1909RH Oct 4, 1870 It forbids immodesty and forwardness and taking work outside the proper line, since some things are unseemly for women to do as some things are unseemly for men, while any soul touched by grace may tell of it in public in a proper manner and woman is raised to rightful equality with man before God.ST Feb 17, 1888ST Jan 20, 1909
The command concerns disorderly, confusing assemblies at Corinth and proves nothing about what is proper in orderly, sober assemblies.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 17, 1876RH Mar 14, 1871 There those professing or pretending supernatural gifts, especially tongues without an interpreter, spoke more than one at a time and caused confusion, with women wrangling, yielding to pretended impulses, and becoming excited and immodest.ST Aug 17, 1876RH Mar 14, 1871 It therefore gives no objection to women taking part in public worship as conducted at the present day, to speaking for edification, exhortation and comfort, or to sharing in the all who speak and prophesy when the whole church is come together, for to make it forbid such speaking would set Paul against other sacred writers and against himself.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Aug 17, 1876RH Mar 14, 1871
The silence belongs to church courts and business meetings where members discuss matters, judge candidates, and dispute who has authority to direct the meeting, not to ordinary public and social worship or to speaking about a risen or coming Saviour.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Apr 22, 1862ST Feb 10, 1881RH Sep 10, 1857 In those deliberative meetings women were to keep order, accept the decision, ask their husbands at home about matters discussed there, and then take their proper part, since their judgment and wisdom are not especially needed there.RH Jul 30, 1861RH Apr 22, 1862ST Feb 10, 1881 It does not forbid testifying to God's goodness and encouraging others by personal experience in the assembly of the saints, for women did prophesy, serve, help and labor in the gospel, which necessarily involved bearing testimony to Christ, in whose communion there is neither male nor female.ST Dec 9, 1889ST Apr 22, 1897 The chapter describes people pressing to offer a psalm, teaching or revelation while some women claimed authority over how matters should be conducted, so the command to be under obedience concerns speaking with authority and assuming authority not given, with strength lying in modesty and the power to win others rather than in ruling or instructing.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Feb 10, 1881
Women without husbands need not know every detail of church business, which men are capable of managing, and questions about such matters may be asked at home.RH Sep 10, 1857 A sister is mistaken to open a church meeting to lead prayer when ministers are present to lead, for both cannot be impressed to lead at the same time, and lack of liberty in the prayer is evidence the impression was wrong.RH Sep 10, 1857RH Nov 13, 1860 The verse has been wrongly used to silence women who have received the Holy Spirit and wish to speak in public worship, to bind their consciences, suppress religious joy, and create a false persuasion that God disapproves of their public testimony.RH Feb 23, 1860STST Feb 24, 1881 It should not be used to silence Spirit-prompted witness, for God works through women as well as men and they should speak in lowliness and humility, nor does it deny women the privilege of speaking God's praises or exhorting sinners, and it leaves only a seeming excuse, not a real one, for coldness that evades the solemn duty and precious privilege of praise.ST Dec 9, 1889RH Feb 23, 1860STRH Dec 9, 1862
As held by a few, the verse is a positive command against women teaching and preaching that forbids giving a woman the use of a church to teach in.ST Jun 17, 1875ST Nov 26, 1896 In that line it is reflected in the rule permitting women to pray but not to teach, and it is applied so that women in Sabbath meetings generally keep silent while in social meetings they speak and testify openly.ST Jun 17, 1875ST Nov 26, 1896 The weight of teaching holds that the verse teaches modesty and proper decorum and restrains immodesty, undue forwardness, boldness and arrogance in assuming authority, principles that also apply to men.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Jul 9, 1912 It is not a prohibition on women voting.ST Jul 9, 1912
The verse belongs to Paul's reproof showing that spiritual gifts were given for the church's improvement, that the church has the duty and power to oversee and regulate their use, and that worship must be conducted decently and in order with order and quiet in public worship.RH Nov 8, 1906RH Jun 3, 1858RH Jan 10, 1871 It belongs to his directions for public audible praying in the congregation in a known tongue with understanding for edification, to be done with head uncovered when disciples are come together, not as silent secret communing nor as unknown tongues without an interpreter, so that believers and unbelievers who come to listen and learn can understand.RH Jan 31, 1871 The same abuse of gifts rebuked then is found now and is to be carefully studied, including pouring forth words unintelligible to anyone, importunate persuasion of everyone met, and women leaving home to travel from country to country to preach and visit holy places by claimed special command, with work ending in failure and almost no real converts.RH Dec 17, 1908
Sources