Acts 15:13
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Men and brethren, hearken unto me:
Translations
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Men and brothers, listen to me:
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Men and brethren, hearken unto me:
And after they held their peace, James answered, saying, Men, brethren, hearken to me.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Brethren, hearken unto me:
and after they are silent, James answered, saying, 'Men, brethren, hearken to me;
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying, Brethren, listen to me:
And, after they held their peace, James answered, saying—Brethren! hearken unto me.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
When they had finished speaking, James declared, “Brothers, listen to me!
After they were silent, James answered, “Brothers, listen to me.
And when they had come to an end, James, answering, said, My brothers, give ear to me:
And when they helde their peace, Iames answered, saying, Men and brethren, hearken vnto me.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And after they had held their peace, James answered, saying: Men, brethren, hear me.
Pictures

Cross-references 20 of 31
- Acts 15:28-29
For it seemed good to the Holy Ghost, and to us, to lay upon you no greater burden than these necessary things;
The council communicates its decision and required abstentions for Gentile believers.
- Acts 15:1-2
And certain men which came down from Judæa taught the brethren, and said, Except ye be circumcised after the manner of Moses, ye cannot be saved.
States the circumcision requirement debated at the Jerusalem conference.
- Acts 15:19-20
Wherefore my sentence is, that we trouble not them, which from among the Gentiles are turned to God:
James concludes that Gentile converts should not be burdened, while giving them specific instructions.
- Galatians 2:1-10
Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also.
James and the other leaders affirm Paul and Barnabas’s mission to the Gentiles.
- Amos 9:11-12
In that day will I raise up the tabernacle of David that is fallen, and close up the breaches thereof; and I will raise up his ruins, and I will build it as in the days of old:
Restoration of David’s fallen house accompanies Gentiles being called by God’s name.
- Acts 15:5
But there rose up certain of the sect of the Pharisees which believed, saying, That it was needful to circumcise them, and to command them to keep the law of Moses.
States the demand that Gentile believers be circumcised and keep the law of Moses.
- Acts 16:4-5
And as they went through the cities, they delivered them the decrees for to keep, that were ordained of the apostles and elders which were at Jerusalem.
The Jerusalem council’s decrees were delivered to churches, strengthening them and promoting unity.
- Galatians 2:11-14
But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
Paul confronted Peter’s conduct toward Gentile believers, which threatened unity over Jewish customs.
- Galatians 2:1-2
Then fourteen years after I went up again to Jerusalem with Barnabas, and took Titus with me also.
Paul and Barnabas confer with Jerusalem’s church leaders at the council.
- Acts 15:2
When therefore Paul and Barnabas had no small dissension and disputation with them, they determined that Paul and Barnabas, and certain other of them, should go up to Jerusalem unto the apostles and elders about this question.
The dispute prompted Paul and Barnabas to go to Jerusalem for a conference.
- Acts 10:44-48
While Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Ghost fell on all them which heard the word.
The Spirit’s gift to Gentiles confirms their acceptance.
- Acts 15:29
That ye abstain from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication: from which if ye keep yourselves, ye shall do well. Fare ye well.
The apostolic letter instructs Gentile believers to abstain from blood.
- Acts 15:6-7
And the apostles and elders came together for to consider of this matter.
The apostles and elders meet and debate the church matter.
- Acts 21:25
As touching the Gentiles which believe, we have written and concluded that they observe no such thing, save only that they keep themselves from things offered to idols, and from blood, and from strangled, and from fornication.
It restates the assembly’s decision about Gentile believers.
- Acts 15:20
But that we write unto them, that they abstain from pollutions of idols, and from fornication, and from things strangled, and from blood.
The apostles instructed Gentile believers to abstain from blood.
- Galatians 2:3-5
But neither Titus, who was with me, being a Greek, was compelled to be circumcised:
Titus remained uncircumcised at the council, defending the gospel’s freedom from pressure to observe circumcision.
- Acts 15:24
Forasmuch as we have heard, that certain which went out from us have troubled you with words, subverting your souls, saying, Ye must be circumcised, and keep the law: to whom we gave no such commandment:
The council rejects unauthorized teachers imposing circumcision and law-keeping on Gentile believers.
- Galatians 2:6
But of these who seemed to be somewhat, ( whatsoever they were, it maketh no matter to me: God accepteth no man’s person:) for they who seemed to be somewhat in conference added nothing to me:
Paul describes leaders consulting together at the conference.
- 1 Thessalonians 1:1
Paul, and Silvanus, and Timotheus, unto the church of the Thessalonians which is in God the Father and in the Lord Jesus Christ: Grace be unto you, and peace, from God our Father, and the Lord Jesus Christ.
identifies Silvanus with Silas of council
- Acts 15:22
Then pleased it the apostles and elders, with the whole church, to send chosen men of their own company to Antioch with Paul and Barnabas; namely, Judas surnamed Barsabas, and Silas, chief men among the brethren:
Records the choice of Silas to carry the council message.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
20 sources
After the others had finished speaking and fallen silent, James addressed the gathered assembly and called them to listen to him.LS 406.3–407.1AA 188.2–189.13SP 374.2 He spoke in the Jerusalem council's dispute over whether uncircumcised Gentile believers had to be circumcised and keep the ceremonial law to be saved and to be admitted to the church.LS 406.3–407.1AA 188.2–189.1ST Jun 26, 1879 Presiding over the meeting, he spoke decisively and gave the final judgment that Gentile converts turning to God should not be burdened with the ceremonial law, since God intended Gentiles to share the privileges of the Jews.3SP 374.2 That judgment was already settled and sanctioned by the Holy Spirit, who gave the apostles grace, wisdom, and enlightened judgment and showed His decision by giving the Spirit to the Gentiles, while the apostles and elders acted as counselors under His guidance rather than settling the matter by force of church authority.LS 406.3–407.1ST May 1, 1884SLP 70.1–71.13SP 372.2 The decision left Gentile believers free from circumcision while Jewish converts could continue those observances without imposing them on Gentiles, and it stands as a model of simple organization ordained for the unity and perfection of the church, bringing believers to be perfectly joined in the same mind and judgment in harmony, peace, and mutual confidence under the Holy Spirit.Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16SLP 192.3–194.1SLP 121.1–122.114MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5
James Speaks at Council
After the others had finished speaking and held their peace, James took his turn and addressed the gathered assembly, asking them to listen to him.LS 406.3–407.1AA 188.2–189.1SLP 70.1–71.18RED 34.1Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 His speaking came after the discussion had run its course, as the response to what had been said before him.LS 406.3–407.13SP 374.2SLP 70.1–71.18RED 34.1Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 It was his turn to address the assembly as it weighed its question.LS 406.3–407.1AA 188.2–189.18RED 34.1
His speech belongs to the Jerusalem council and its dispute over circumcision and the law of Moses.LS 406.3–407.1AA 188.2–189.1ST Jun 26, 1879SLP 121.1–122.13SP 372.2 The question was whether uncircumcised Gentile believers had to be circumcised and keep the ceremonial law in order to be saved.AA 188.2–189.1ST Jun 26, 1879SLP 121.1–122.13SP 372.2 It was also whether they had to observe Jewish ceremonies and customs, and whether without circumcision they should be granted admission to the church.ST Jun 26, 1879SLP 121.1–122.114MR 176.1–23SP 372.2 Apart from that brief difference over circumcision, union had prevailed among believers after the resurrection and ascension, with all of one heart and one mind.14MR 176.1–2
The background to the council was the work at Antioch in Syria, where Paul and Barnabas arrived from their mission, assembled the believers, and rehearsed how God had opened the door of faith to the Gentiles.AA 188.1 Antioch was a large and growing church, a center of missionary activity and one of the most important groups of believers, made up of many classes of people from among both Jews and Gentiles.AA 188.1 At the council Paul related his conversion and the work God had done among the Gentiles.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884 The Spirit confirmed and witnessed to his testimony, and the council set aside its prejudices, agreed with his position, and sent an address to the churches expressing that agreement.SLP 209.2–210.2ST May 1, 1884
The verse belongs to the time when Paul, at Jerusalem and at Antioch, defended Christianity against the narrow restrictions of Judaism.SLP 304.1–2
Decision, Guidance, and Unity
James presided over the meeting and, after the others had spoken, addressed it decisively with the final decision that Gentile converts turning to God should not be burdened with the ceremonial law, since it was God's intent that Gentiles should share the privileges of the Jews, a conclusion in which the Holy Spirit, the apostles, and the elders were agreed that the ceremonial law should not be imposed upon them.3SP 374.2 The council decided to leave Gentile believers free from circumcision and the ceremonial obligations, while Jewish converts might continue those observances without imposing them on the Gentiles.SLP 192.3–194.1SLP 121.1–122.1
The decision was sanctioned by the Holy Spirit and had already been settled by Him, who gave the apostles grace, wisdom, and sound and enlightened judgment to resolve the question on which the prosperity and very existence of the Christian church depended.ST May 1, 1884SLP 70.1–71.13SP 372.2 God had already shown His decision by giving the Spirit to the Gentiles, and the leaders recognized this under the Spirit's guidance with enlightened judgment.SLP 70.1–71.1 In that Jerusalem meeting the apostles and elders acted as counselors, leaving room for the Holy Spirit to judge rather than settling the disagreement by force of church authority.LS 406.3–407.1SLP 70.1–71.1
The leaders carefully considered the questions raised by the work among the Gentiles, and framed and issued recommendations and a decree concerning rites and customs including circumcision.AA 400.2–401.1ST Jun 26, 1879 In the same action they commended Barnabas and Paul as trustworthy workers, affirmed Paul's divine commission to preach to the Gentiles, and recognized him as an equal fellow-laborer and apostle, and Paul complied with the council's decisions in his work among the Gentiles.SLP 192.3–194.1AA 400.2–401.1AA 387.2–388.1 The churches generally accepted the decree that was issued.ST Jun 26, 1879SLP 70.1–71.1
Opposition did not end, for some Christians opposed it and continued to argue for the ceremonial law.ST Jun 26, 1879SLP 70.1–71.1 Some continued to use circumcision and the ceremonial law to distinguish Jews from Gentiles and to claim that Gentiles who did not observe it were farther from God, though the decision was that those observances must not be imposed on Gentile converts.SLP 121.1–122.1 False teachers ignored that decision rejecting the requirement of the ceremonial law for Gentile converts and urged the Galatian believers to keep the law.AA 383.1–2
The chapter stands as a model of simple organization ordained for the unity and perfection of the church, not as authority for leaders to command the Lord's laborers or to assume powers God has not given them.Lt 178, 1909, par. 14–16 Apart from that brief difference of understanding over circumcision and whether uncircumcised Gentiles should be granted admission to the church, union prevailed after the resurrection and ascension with believers of one heart and one mind.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 The circumcision question was soon settled through the divine illumination and sanctification of the Spirit, by which the believers were perfectly joined together in the same mind and in the same judgment in unity of understanding.14MR 176.1–2Lt 7, 1891, par. 2–5 The meeting brought critics of the methods among the Gentiles to a broader understanding of God's purpose and helped unite believers.AA 400.2–401.1 That harmony in understanding truth, unity in judgment, peace, mutual confidence, and speaking the same things is the fruit always borne under the influence of the Holy Spirit.14MR 176.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
123 sources
After all had held their peace following Peter's testimony and the report of Paul and Barnabas, James the brother of the Lord, leader of the Jerusalem church, addressed the gathered believers as men and brethren and asked them to listen as he summed up the matter with his judgment.RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 23, 1897ST Aug 30, 1883CO 30.4–31.1ST Apr 30, 1902 The meeting was the first serious internal trouble of the church, called to settle whether Gentile converts must be circumcised and keep the law of Moses to be saved.ST Mar 13, 1884CO 82.4–83.1RH Oct 26, 1911 The council decided Gentiles are saved through the grace of Jesus Christ, not by circumcision and the Mosaic ceremonial law, which was set aside except for abstaining from things offered to idols, from blood, from things strangled, and from fornication, while the Ten Commandments were not under consideration.ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 27, 1875ST Jun 3, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868 No dispute about the Sabbath was brought before it and nothing in the verse discusses or changes the Sabbath, and to argue from its silence that what was not enforced is no longer binding would permit blasphemy, murder, theft and Sabbath-breaking.RH May 27, 1875RH Mar 4, 1862ST Aug 30, 1883RH May 27, 1875ST Oct 29, 1912 James presided and gave the sentence that ended discussion while Peter was present as one apostle among fellows, showing the apostolic church had no pope and Christ alone is head of every church.ST May 18, 1904ST Jul 5, 1910RH Oct 19, 1916RH Aug 31, 1916RH Jun 13, 1871
Council Setting and Dispute
The verse marks the moment James speaks at the Jerusalem meeting called as the first serious internal trouble of the church to settle whether Gentile converts must be circumcised and keep the law of Moses to be saved.ST Mar 13, 1884CO 82.4–83.1RH Oct 26, 1911ST May 28, 1902RH May 2, 1907 It belongs to the council called to settle once for all whether Gentile believers must submit to circumcision to be saved, and to the account of the first general conference held to address whether they had to be circumcised and keep the ceremonial law of Moses.ST May 28, 1902RH May 2, 1907ST Apr 26, 1883 The question affected churches throughout the Christian community, so delegates brought it before the apostles and elders for consideration.RH May 2, 1907
The dispute arose in prosperous times at Antioch after the return of Paul and Barnabas, when men from Judea taught that church members could not be saved unless circumcised.ST Mar 13, 1884ST May 28, 1902 Paul and Barnabas strongly opposed that teaching until controversy left the church uncertain, and the growing dissension required settlement at Jerusalem.ST Mar 13, 1884ST May 28, 1902 The church decided that Paul and Barnabas with delegates should go to Jerusalem to consult the officers of that church, and Barnabas and Paul there represented the church at Antioch.ST May 28, 1902ST Jan 15, 1885 Judging Christians by human interpretations of ceremonial law and accumulated Jewish traditions was at the root of the controversy.RH Jan 2, 1900 The controversy was referred by the church at Antioch to the apostles and elders, with delegates from different churches present, and discussion was to cease until the responsible leaders reached a decision which the churches would accept.RH May 9, 1907 The matter took considerable time and labor, with delegates walking 300 miles from Antioch to Jerusalem and back, yet the time and labor were more than repaid in the restoration of harmony and the establishment of a basis of peace.ST May 28, 1902
The meeting confronts the slowness of Judean Jews to acknowledge that Gentiles stand on an equal footing with themselves under the gospel, a prejudice so strong that even Peter and Barnabas had been carried away by it.ST Mar 13, 1884 James speaks after Peter has given his testimony warning against putting upon the neck of the disciples a yoke which neither the fathers nor they were able to bear.ST Mar 13, 1884 In that testimony Peter made plain that God, who knows the hearts, gave the Holy Spirit to uncircumcised Gentiles even as to Jewish believers, putting no difference between them and purifying their hearts by faith, thereby accepting them without circumcision and revealing such rites were no longer necessary.ST May 28, 1902 His words turned the discussion against circumcision and the law of ceremonies.ST May 28, 1902 Every voice in the assembly was then hushed so Paul and Barnabas could be heard relating how wonderfully God had dealt with the Gentiles through their ministry in the conversion of the heathen.ST May 28, 1902
Representatives from the churches gathered to address a matter affecting their fellowship and faith, and delegates from Antioch and other churches gathered so the churches could deal with teachings that conflicted with the faith as believers spread across different places.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Apr 29, 1909 Judaising teachers taught that Gentile converts must keep the law of Moses in order to be saved, while Gentile converts used swine's flesh and other meats that were abomination to the Jews, and converts from the Jews still inclined to the law of Moses judged the Gentile converts and bound on them burdens which the gospel did not require.RH May 23, 1854 The conference wrote its decision to the Gentile brethren in Antioch, Syria and Cilicia to lay no greater burden than abstaining from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication, which settled the question and caused rejoicing among the churches, and swine's flesh must not be added to that forbidden list.RH May 23, 1854 This teaching insisting that Gentile Christians be circumcised and keep the law of Moses had discouraged the Gentiles, divided the church, and hindered its work until the apostles and brethren settled the question in Jerusalem.ST Dec 20, 1883 Circumcision had been a sign for God's people in its appointed time, but that time had passed with circumcision of the heart taking its place, so insisting on the former requirement brought disorder.ST Dec 20, 1883 Titus was a Greek by birth converted by Paul and the first Christian convert who was not circumcised, and Paul took him to Jerusalem to test the matter of circumcision before the council, which decided against its necessity.ST Nov 29, 1910
Verse Wording and Speaker
The verse names James as the one who answers after the others have held their peace and finished speaking. RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 23, 1897ST Aug 30, 1883ST Dec 23, 1897ST Feb 22, 1883 He addresses the gathered believers as men and brethren and asks them to listen to him. RH Nov 16, 1916ST Dec 23, 1897ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 22, 1883ST Jun 8, 1882 His judgment on what is required of Gentile converts follows in the verses that come next. ST Dec 23, 1897ST Aug 30, 1883ST Dec 23, 1897 The assembly he addresses is the Jerusalem council in its discussion of that question. RH Nov 16, 1916ST Aug 30, 1883ST Jun 8, 1882
The silence before he speaks comes after discussion and testimonies have ended. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902 It follows especially Peter's speech turning the discussion against circumcision and the law of ceremonies. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902 In that speech Peter made plain that God who knows the hearts gave the Holy Spirit to uncircumcised Gentiles even as to Jewish believers, putting no difference between them and purifying their hearts by faith. ST May 28, 1902 Every voice was thus hushed so that Paul and Barnabas could be heard relating how wonderfully God had dealt with the Gentiles through their ministry in the conversion of the heathen. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902
The meeting is a debate about church matters rather than an ordinary public worship service. RH Feb 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1861 After its discussion quieted, James summed up the matter under discussion. ST Dec 23, 1897RH Feb 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1861 As an influential pillar he joined Peter in helping Paul and Barnabas receive an impartial hearing before the whole church. RH Feb 26, 1901
The James who speaks is James the brother of the Lord, not James the brother of John who was slain by Herod. ST Apr 30, 1902ST Nov 10, 1909 He was the leader of the church in Jerusalem, the same James to whom Peter asked that news of his release from prison be carried. CO 30.4–31.1ST Apr 30, 1902ST Nov 10, 1909 He is named first among the church's pillars and served as its presiding officer in that gathering, a leadership Paul also recognized. CO 30.4–31.1ST Apr 30, 1902 He was called James the Just for his piety and was the writer of the epistle of James. ST Nov 10, 1909 He was stoned to death by order of Annas the high priest about A.D. 63. ST Nov 10, 1909
He then referred to Simeon's testimony and the prophets. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902 He affirmed that Peter's speech about God accepting the Gentiles perfectly agrees with prophecy that God will return and rebuild again the fallen tabernacle, house or family, of David and set up its ruins so the residue of men and all the Gentiles upon whom His name is called might seek the Lord. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902 He gave as his judgment that Gentile believers turning to God should not be troubled with added difficulties but only be asked by letter to abstain from things contaminated by idols, from unchastity, from flesh of strangled animals, and from blood. RH Feb 26, 1901ST May 28, 1902 The reason given is that for generations past Moses has been preached in every town and read in the synagogue every Sabbath. ST May 28, 1902
Decision on Circumcision and Law
The council that James addressed was called to decide circumcision and the law of Moses, not whether Gentiles must keep the Ten Commandments or the moral law, which were not under consideration.ST Aug 12, 1875RH May 27, 1875ST Jun 3, 1875RH Jul 2, 1861 The law set aside except for four specified requirements was the ceremonial and civil law given through Moses, not the moral law or Ten Commandments.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jun 3, 1875RH Jul 2, 1861 The dispute concerned circumcision and the ceremonial law, and the council did not repeal any of the Ten Commandments.ST Sep 9, 1880RH Jul 2, 1861
Gentiles are saved through the grace of Jesus Christ, not by taking on circumcision and the Mosaic law as conditions of justification to be saved.ST Jun 3, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868 The decision set that law aside except for four specified requirements, placing certain restrictions on Gentile converts without binding the old Levitical laws on them.ST Jun 3, 1875 Those four rules of action were given while distinguishing that requirement from the duties of Christian life, without declaring the Ten Commandments abolished.ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868
The yoke which neither the fathers nor the apostles were able to bear is not the Ten Commandments but the ceremonial requirement of circumcision and the law of Moses.RH Apr 16, 1861RH Feb 1851RH Oct 14, 1852 The Ten Commandments remain distinct from that yoke, being perfect, a delight, and kept by Christ, while circumcision is nothing compared with keeping the commandments of God.RH Apr 16, 1861ST Jul 9, 1874ST Nov 22, 1883 Imposing that ceremonial law was a burden the disciples could not bear and a threat to their spiritual well-being, a temporary burden abolished by Christ nailing its ordinances to the cross, a yoke of bondage Christians are not to be entangled with.RH Oct 14, 1852ST Jul 9, 1874 The setting aside of circumcision stands in direct contrast with the continued importance of keeping the commandments of God, decided through the Holy Spirit working in the experiences of several of the apostles with Paul present helping bring it about.RH Feb 1851ST Nov 22, 1883
The four things enjoined were to abstain from meats or things offered to idols and contaminated by idols, from blood, from things strangled, and from fornication or unchastity and sexual immorality.RH May 27, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH Apr 22, 1862ST Jan 22, 1885 They were not given as the only Christian rule of action replacing the law, and the apostles and elders distinguished the law of Moses from the law of God whose commandments remained necessary.RH May 27, 1875ST Aug 30, 1877RH Jul 21, 1868ST Feb 22, 1883 The Spirit did not impose the ceremonial law while still requiring God's commandments and holy lives, and the chapter's decision concerned a law distinct from the Ten Commandments.ST Feb 22, 1883RH Apr 22, 1862 To argue from the chapter's silence that whatever was not specifically enforced, especially the Sabbath, is not binding is an argument from silence that would also absolve honoring parents and permit blasphemy, Sabbath-breaking, murder, theft and false witness, turning gospel liberty into licentiousness and lawlessness.RH May 27, 1875RH May 27, 1875 Its silence proves nothing, since it also does not mention baptism, yet baptism remains required, and the inference that Gentiles are released is contradicted by other scriptures showing Gentiles like Jews accountable to the law.RH May 27, 1875RH Oct 21, 1873ST Sep 13, 1877RH Feb 26, 1857
The law of Moses decided against is not the Ten Commandments, for Peter calls that code by a different name than how James speaks of the Ten Commandments, circumcision belonged to that Mosaic code, and James himself upholds the Ten Commandments years afterward.RH May 26, 1863 The council still declares precepts obligatory on the Gentiles, the first and last of which are in substance the second and seventh of the Ten Commandments against idolatry and fornication, proving the authority of the Ten Commandments was not under consideration and was not set aside when Gentiles were released from the law of Moses.RH May 26, 1863 The council's decision was sanctioned by the Holy Spirit and still held good years later when Paul returned to Jerusalem, affirming that Gentile believers were to observe no such ceremonial requirement save those four abstentions.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 22, 1885 The later counsel for Paul to take the vow men and purify himself to prove he kept the law was not consistent with that decision, and the meeting's decision exposed as false the professed apostles who had taught that believers must keep the law of Moses.RH Mar 26, 1857ST Jan 22, 1885
Sabbath and Moral Law
The gathering where James spoke after the others fell silent met to decide whether Gentile believers must be circumcised, not to change or set aside the Sabbath, and no dispute about Sabbath observance was brought before it.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Oct 29, 1912 The verse itself does not discuss the Sabbath, and the chapter's incidental mention of the Sabbath does not make it one of the four requirements listed for the converts.ST Aug 30, 1883 That first general conference considered circumcision and the ceremonial law, and it records no controversy over the Sabbath.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Oct 29, 1912
Its silence about Sabbath-breaking shows no such violation had been alleged, and its decision did not abolish the fourth commandment or the rest of the moral law.ST Sep 9, 1880 The council released the Gentiles from circumcision and the law of Moses and added cautions about matters in which they were especially in danger, but it did not take up the law of God as the complete rule of moral duty or include that law in its letter.ST Nov 24, 1881 Its letter did not list every Christian duty, for the Spirit did not impose the ceremonial law on Gentile converts while they were still required to keep God's commandments and live holy lives.RH Oct 11, 1906 The omission of a commandment from the letter therefore does not prove it is no longer binding, and the omission of the Sabbath from the specific instructions does not release Christians from the seventh-day Sabbath, which is a commandment of the Lord, not of Moses.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Oct 11, 1906
James's speech refers to the Sabbath as the day when Moses is preached and read in the synagogues in every city, without its binding force being called in question.RH May 26, 1863 This proves the Sabbath question did not come before the apostles and the Gentiles were not released from the Sabbath by this assembly.RH May 26, 1863 It proves Sabbath observance continued as the weekly setting in which Gentile converts would hear Moses taught.RH May 26, 1863
The dispute itself strongly attests that the Lord's Sabbath had not been abolished or changed before the meeting, and when the assembly ended the Bible Sabbath remained sacred within the fourth commandment.RH Mar 4, 1862 The Sabbath was still rested according to the commandment after the cross, while circumcision is a yoke, a yoke of bondage Christians are not to be entangled with, so Sabbath-keeping and circumcision are not parallel cases this side of the cross. Doing away with the ceremonial law aroused long and heated controversy in the early church, while neither the Jews nor the Jewish Christians ever found fault with the rising church about the day of rest, which proves the apostolic church faithfully observed the Sabbath in the way Christ taught.ST Jun 15, 1904
The absence of any mention of a Sabbath-day change is significant, because instituting a different Sabbath would have provoked major opposition among Jewish Christians and unbelieving Jews, yet the account records no such controversy.ST Mar 11, 1897 The conference was called to consider old-dispensation rites that were not to be carried into the new, with circumcision a prominent issue in that discussion, while no controversy over changing or abolishing the Sabbath is mentioned.ST Nov 5, 1912 Although the council addressed which Jewish practices Gentile converts should follow, it did not question the sacredness of the weekly Sabbath or mention the first day of the week as a replacement.ST Oct 18, 1899 It did not alter the seventh-day Sabbath or establish Sunday as a holy day, and unlike circumcision no dispute is recorded there about changing the seventh-day Sabbath. The chapter, dated to A.D. 52 as the last mention of the apostles as a body, gives no hint that they changed the Sabbath.RH Nov 28, 1871
Prophecy of David Restored
James calls the assembly to listen and declares that God taking out of the Gentiles a people for His name fulfills all that the prophets spoke concerning the rebuilding of David's throne and kingdom, with Amos 9:11 quoted as a sample of what the prophets spoke on this point.RH Dec 24, 1903RH Jan 16, 1900 The gospel going to the Gentiles agrees with the words of the prophets.RH Jan 16, 1900
He affirms that Peter's testimony about God accepting the Gentiles perfectly agrees with prophecy that God will return and rebuild again the fallen tabernacle, house or family, of David and set up its ruins so that the residue of men, the rest of mankind, and all the Gentiles upon whom His name is called might seek after the Lord.ST May 28, 1902ST Nov 10, 1881 His ensuing words connect the preaching of the gospel to the Gentiles with the prophets' promise that God would rebuild David's fallen tabernacle so that people from among the Gentiles could seek the Lord.ST Nov 10, 1881 As his judgment he urges that Gentile believers turning to God should not be troubled with added difficulties but only be asked by letter to abstain from things contaminated by idols, from unchastity, from flesh of strangled animals, and from blood, because for generations past Moses has been preached in every town and read in the synagogue every Sabbath.ST May 28, 1902
This ingathering of a people from among the Gentiles for God's name, supported by Amos 9:11-15, is the final gathering of the subjects of God's kingdom after Israel's national probation ended.RH Feb 18, 1902 It refers to the time when the gospel shall have accomplished its work among the Gentiles under the new covenant and states the results of the new covenant.RH Feb 18, 1902RH Feb 27, 1872 The rebuilding refers to Christ's work as priest and intercessor on the Father's throne.ST Nov 10, 1881 It connects Amos's promise to rebuild David's fallen tabernacle with Christ's work in the present gospel age, especially the spread of the gospel among the Gentiles.ST Nov 10, 1881RH Jul 21, 1910
The chapter gives the gospel application of the prophecy about restoring David's kingdom, a work that begins with Christ being presented to the Jews, gathers the true seed from all nations, and ends with Christ receiving David's throne and establishing His kingdom.RH Mar 25, 1873 The prophecy of rebuilding the fallen true tabernacle of David was fulfilled in the Gentiles accepting Jesus Christ.ST Jan 29, 1902 This means the fulfillment of all promises and prophecies is in Jesus Christ and in Him alone, with no respect of persons.ST Jan 29, 1902 The only hope of the world alike for the individual Jew and the individual Gentile is to believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, for He saves Jewish sinners and sinners of all kinds, and unto them that look for Him He will appear the second time without sin unto salvation.ST Jan 29, 1902
Church Order and Unity
The moment belongs to the first general conference or council of Christian believers, held at Jerusalem after dispute arose over whether Gentile believers must be circumcised and keep the ceremonial law of Moses to be saved.CO 82.4–83.1RH May 2, 1907RH Aug 18, 1874 Apostles, elders, church delegates and representatives from Antioch and other churches gathered because teachings conflicting with the churches' faith affected churches throughout the Christian community, and leading men counseled together on general interests that no single local church could settle for all.RH May 2, 1907ST Jul 29, 1897RH Aug 18, 1874RH May 9, 1907 The apostles and elders made the decision rather than putting it to a vote of all Christians.CO 84.1–2
The matter was investigated before the church sent its decision to the Gentile believers, with the Holy Spirit's testimony accompanying the process.RH Feb 28, 1856 After discussion over whether circumcision was necessary for salvation, James joined Peter, Paul and Barnabas in giving scriptural and experiential testimony as the church sought to settle the dispute, illustrating united, orderly action with the Holy Spirit guiding judgment toward resolution. The Spirit bore witness to the word about God's work among the Gentiles, and the gathered believers set aside prejudices, agreed with Paul's position, and sent their decision to the churches.ST May 1, 1884ST Jan 15, 1885 The value of bringing different perspectives together is shown here, since no one person's judgment is perfect, and God gave His Holy Spirit to enlighten His people and help them reach sound judgments.ST Jul 26, 1883
Apostles and elders acted in that Jerusalem meeting about circumcision and the law of Moses as counselors rather than commanders, leaving room for the Holy Ghost to judge the matter.LS 406.3–407.1ST Jun 11, 1874 They acted not as rulers ordering and commanding the church and lording over God's heritage but as counselors giving room for the Holy Ghost to act as Judge.RH Dec 1, 1874 Christ by His Spirit came into that assembly where apostles, elders and all the brotherhood were in a teachable frame of mind and at once led them out of difficulties, proving at an early date the true doctrine of the leadership of Christ and the equality of the ministerial brotherhood.RH Dec 1, 1874 Church leaders thus performed their duties without taking authority from Christ or constraining conscience, settling church differences through orderly, humble counsel rather than mere authority.ST Jun 11, 1874ST Jun 25, 1874
James spoke to the gathered assembly after the dispute over circumcision had been discussed, and his remarks together with those of Peter, Paul and Barnabas helped apostles, elders and church reach a united decision with the testimony of the Holy Spirit, settling the dissension.RH May 5, 1863 He presided over the council and gave its final decision on the major question, as presiding officer and chief spokesman and named first among the church's pillars, urging that Gentile believers who had turned to God should not be troubled.RH Apr 29, 1909CO 30.4–31.1ST Jun 20, 1906 His turn came after disputing had ceased, presenting the council's final decision so that he is the most prominent figure in its deliberation, and the decision was later affirmed by the apostles, elders and whole church.ST Apr 13, 1915RH Dec 28, 1905 The council reached complete harmony under the influence of the Holy Spirit, settling the disputed question to everyone's satisfaction so that the church's spiritual effectiveness would not be impaired.RH Dec 28, 1905
The settlement reached as seeming good to the Holy Ghost and to the council brought consolation and rejoicing to the Gentile brethren in Antioch and Syria and Cilicia.RH Dec 1, 1874 The internal dispute did not produce factions or a separate church, but those involved agreed to the decision of the arbiters and it was resolved in unity and peace.ST Mar 13, 1884 The referral of the warm dispute to the brethren at Jerusalem shows that where no counsel is the people fall but in the multitude of counselors there is safety, and though the matter took considerable time and labor, with delegates walking 300 miles from Antioch to Jerusalem and back and with brethren sent from Jerusalem to confirm the decision having to return afterward, the time and labor were more than repaid in restoration of harmony and establishment of a basis of peace in the church.ST May 28, 1902 That action thwarted the enemy's purpose to permanently divide the young church and greatly encouraged all the brethren, standing as an example for all time that when the Holy Spirit is allowed to lead deliberations over disputed points, differing opinions are more happily reconciled.ST May 28, 1902
When a new emergency arises in the church it is to be met when it arises and every decision governed by Bible principles, and the action taken here gives the pattern for facing such present conditions.RH Nov 12, 1903 The church gathered in conference to consider matters of faith and practice supports recognition of Paul and Barnabas's call to gospel ministry, with the church guided by the Spirit acknowledging those whom God calls.CO 28.2–29.2 The apostles' efforts secured unity in the church through both practice and teaching, and the council's discussion and final action recognized religious liberty.RH Jan 13, 1874ST Dec 13, 1905 The Spirit of Christ does not ignore organization but works in harmony with counsel, with each heard in turn after they held their peace, and that controlling Spirit is first pure, then peaceable, gentle and easy to be entreated, full of mercy and good fruits, without partiality and without hypocrisy, bringing humility to every member, preferring one another in honor and ending strife for supremacy, because the highest calling is to be a humble child of God rather than to occupy official position.RH Jun 16, 1903
Churches truly connected to Christ recognized the council's united decisions as authoritative under the word of God, so that harmony and unity could prevail for harmonious action and cooperation among the churches.RH Apr 29, 1909 The apostles and elders framed and issued the decree, which the churches generally accepted, and controversy was set aside while church representatives awaited a decision from the responsible leaders that was to be accepted by the churches throughout the country.ST Jun 26, 1879CO 83.3 Yet some Christians opposed it and continued to argue for the ceremonial law, with some in the church resisting the decision and promoting independence and division, and a faction murmuring, finding fault, proposing new plans and trying to undermine the work of experienced teachers, such obstacles as the church would face throughout its history.ST Jun 26, 1879RH Apr 29, 1909CO 84.3 Differences settled in this way remain settled, while those disposed of by mere church authority are seldom really settled at all.RH Dec 1, 1874
The apostles settled differences of faith by collective decision under the guidance of the Holy Spirit, and their decision was correct, which does not mean any one apostle was individually infallible.RH Jun 24, 1875 They did not claim to be infallible but used enlightened judgment and followed the Holy Spirit's guidance, recognizing God's gift of the Holy Spirit to the Gentiles as evidence that God had decided the question.CO 84.1–2 Their decree was generally accepted by the churches.ST Jun 26, 1879CO 84.1–2
James Presiding Not Peter
After the others had finished speaking and held their peace, James answered and took up the discussion of the circumcision controversy at the first counsel in Jerusalem, which he presided over.ST May 18, 1904ST Jul 5, 1910ST Sep 30, 1908RH Oct 19, 1916 He spoke after the assembly had heard the dispute over whether Gentile converts had to be circumcised and keep the law of Moses to be saved, after discussion and testimony in which the apostles and elders, guided by the Holy Spirit, recognized that the ceremonial law should not be imposed on Gentile believers.RH May 9, 1907RH May 9, 1907 He testified that God intended Gentiles to share the privileges of the Jews and concluded that Gentile converts turned to God should not be burdened with the ceremonial law, his sentence that they should not be troubled being the final decision that ended the discussion, he having been chosen to decide the matter brought before the council.RH May 9, 1907RH May 9, 1907RH Aug 31, 1916 Peter was present but did not preside or give the decision, although he had been first to preach the gospel to Jews and Gentiles, and James presided and gave the council's sentence whose decision agreed with the Holy Spirit's guidance.ST May 18, 1904ST Jul 5, 1910RH May 9, 1907RH Aug 31, 1916 His role makes him the most prominent figure in the council's deliberation, while the decision was later affirmed by the apostles, elders and whole church.ST Apr 13, 1915
Peter did not call the council, preside over it, formulate its canons, or promulgate its decrees, but was present as one apostle among his fellow apostles, and it was James who answered and gave the decision.RH Jun 13, 1871 The decrees went out in the name of the apostles and elders and brethren together, for the religious question was considered by the apostles and elders together, not decided by Peter alone.RH Jun 13, 1871ST Dec 3, 1894 This proves Peter had no lordship, primacy, or papal office over the other apostles.RH Jun 13, 1871 The verse is presented as evidence that Peter did not hold authority over the other apostles, when James spoke after the others had given their accounts and rendered the decision that Gentile believers should not be troubled with circumcision but should receive certain stated requirements.ST Dec 5, 1916
His presiding in this instance refutes the doctrine that Peter was head of the church and leaves no foundation for the pretensions of popes claiming to be Peter's successors to take an authoritative position over their brethren.RH Aug 31, 1916 At that council Peter never once acted as pope or as vicar of Christ on earth, and if Peter had known himself to be supreme head of the church he would have acted as such at Jerusalem, but he did not.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Jun 13, 1871 This shows the apostolic church had no pope and never thought of one.RH Jun 13, 1871
Being chosen as presiding officer did not make James head of the general church, any more than a presiding officer or elder is head of a local church.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Apr 29, 1909 Office in the church is appointment to special service and leadership in the common work, not lordship or headship over any.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Apr 29, 1909 Christ is the head of every man and the head of every church, because he is the head of the whole church, which is his body.RH Aug 31, 1916RH Apr 29, 1909 Any preeminence there belonged to James, who took the lead in speaking rather than Peter presiding.ST Nov 4, 1930
The first council among the disciples was held in Jerusalem rather than Rome, meeting to seek God and reach a better understanding about questions on which they differed, not like councils held in later ages.ST Sep 30, 1908 James's counsel that the church followed was given in Acts 15:13-21, and Peter did not leave the church when James's advice was accepted.RH Oct 29, 1872 James, not Peter, presided over the meeting, taking the lead in speaking after others finished.ST Sep 30, 1908ST Nov 4, 1930
Dates and Related Scriptures
The Jerusalem conference belongs about A.D. 51, seventeen years after Paul's conversion in about A.D. 34.ST Dec 15, 1898ST Mar 4, 1886 It is the same visit Paul describes as going up again to Jerusalem fourteen years after his first visit, when after his first three years as a Christian in Arabia and Damascus he had stayed fifteen days living with Peter. One account dates the chapter to A.D. 52 as the last mention of the apostles as a body, and another places the council in Jerusalem in A.D. 49 or 50 when John was present before going to Asia Minor.RH Nov 28, 1871RH Nov 7, 1865 The conference and the events that led to it and followed it are the setting for Galatians 2.ST Dec 15, 1898
The record must be studied together with Galatians 2 to grasp Paul's words, because much of Galatians 2 deals with the same events, setting, and things leading to and growing out of it.ST Aug 8, 1900ST Dec 15, 1898 Galatians 2 is merely an adjunct to Acts 15, so Acts 15 must be understood and borne in mind in reading Galatians 2. The issue decided there was salvation itself: faith in the name of Christ is the only way of salvation, and the false brethren who demanded something else were denying Christ and preaching another gospel, a message of damnation with no good news in it, not the gospel of God's power to salvation.ST Aug 8, 1900
The council met to settle the question agitating the churches of Galatia whether observance of the ceremonial law is essential to salvation, giving its concurrent opinion that the churches are free from the ceremonial law.RH Sep 3, 1901 There Paul's divine commission was recognized, and he was received as a fellow laborer and given an equal position with the elders.RH Sep 3, 1901 The gospel upheld there releases Jews from their distinctive observances and admits Gentiles to equal privileges as children of Abraham.RH Sep 3, 1901
The conference was assembled to settle divisions over eating with the Gentiles and other points of the law of Moses, and its decision to the Gentile brethren in Antioch, Syria and Cilicia to lay no greater burden than abstaining from meats offered to idols, and from blood, and from things strangled, and from fornication settled the question and caused rejoicing among the churches.RH May 23, 1854 Swine's flesh must not be added to that forbidden list.RH May 23, 1854 The prohibition against eating blood remained obligatory for Gentile believers when the apostles turned to them, and the fact that the prohibition was given to Israel did not make it temporary, since it had first been given to Noah.RH Dec 31, 1861
The council urged Paul to remember the poor, and the Gentile churches' gifts to the Jerusalem church fulfilled that commitment.ST Jan 15, 1885 Its suggestion at the great conference encouraged able Gentile Christians to contribute.ST Aug 19, 1897 Silas, a leading man and prophet in the church in Jerusalem, was chosen by the apostles with Judas surnamed Barsabas to carry the message with Paul and Barnabas to Antioch and to the churches, with a letter disavowing those who troubled Gentile believers by commanding circumcision and keeping of the law.ST Mar 18, 1903RH Mar 28, 1854
Acts 15 is an example of a congregation that tested false apostles and searched out their true character.RH Jun 10, 1862 That general meeting in Jerusalem, marking the point after they had held their peace when James answered, had a cause, a work, and a result to be stated. Paul and Barnabas labored elsewhere immediately after it. The question then faced, whether a Hebrew in becoming a Christian is obliged by essential Christianity to abrogate the ritual of Mosaic Judaism with its Levitical customs and ceremonies, is the same question facing Hebrew Christians now.ST May 8, 1901 It is to be met only by the Word of God, letting Scripture have undisputed sway and doing what God says without quibble or hesitation.ST May 8, 1901
Further points
The moment belongs to the Jerusalem council called to meet a threatened schism in the early church and to restore unity.ST Feb 14, 1906 The course taken there was liberty rather than enforced uniformity.ST Feb 14, 1906 The concession made was to set aside the Sinai code in order to preserve unity.ST Feb 14, 1906
Sources