Acts 20:7
And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, ready to depart on the morrow; and continued his speech until midnight.
And upon the first day of the week, when the disciples came together to break bread, Paul preached unto them, ready to depart on the morrow; and continued his speech until midnight.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Claims for Sunday Sacredness
Acts 20:7 is one of three texts appealed to as scriptural evidence for a divinely authorized change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day, with the apostles understood to have practiced the change because they met on that day, establishing precedent by delegated authority to be kept to the end, though the verse itself contains neither the word Sabbath nor any synonymous term, asserts nothing that the first day is holier than any other day, shows no regular habit of holding meetings on that day, says nothing about keeping a day holy in honor of the resurrection, gives no reason for the meeting, and does not command Sunday observance or establish Sunday as Sabbath.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Aug 26, 1862RH Feb 25, 1862ST Jul 18, 1878
Denying that change is treated as heinous sin contrary to God's word, yet the account of disciples breaking bread with Paul preaching until midnight and until daybreak before departing the next day, with interruptions to raise the young man, is not accepted as proof that Sunday is the Sabbath.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Aug 26, 1862RH Aug 5, 1851
The gathering at Troas is presented as positive proof of solemn religious service for celebrating the Eucharist, for preaching and communicating, with Paul deferring his journey till the following day in respect to the day, showing Sunday set apart by the apostles as the Christian Sabbath instead of the seventh as a standing memorial of Christ's birth and resurrection and the descent of the Holy Ghost, for remembering redemption and consecrating the day to the Son.RH Oct 10, 1871RH Apr 24, 1900ST Feb 17, 1890RH Aug 21, 1855
The first day is identified by its scriptural name first day of the week as the Lord's day, a day of worship distinct from the Sabbath as a day of rest, sacred to God and commemorative of finished redemption, while Sunday as a name is rejected as heathen adopted through Popery, and the verse is cited as support for calling the first day the Lord's Day and Christian Sabbath.RH Nov 27, 1913RH Mar 20, 1855
Paul had stayed seven days at Troas and thus had observed the Sabbath before this meeting, and the first-day gathering to break bread and hear Paul preach until midnight before departure is presented as evidence of an established custom of meeting on the first day for communion after resting and worshiping on the Sabbath, as a regular public Christian worship service with teaching, fellowship and prayer.RH Aug 19, 1858RH Apr 9, 1861
The same gathering, including Corinth meetings after departure from the synagogue, is used to argue that the apostles regularly met for worship on the first day and that the Sabbath had therefore been changed, proving Sunday observance from soon after the resurrection onward, with disciples beginning to meet on that day immediately or very soon after the resurrection and continuing to this day, though the account does not establish the first day as Sabbath or change by divine authority.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Aug 26, 1862ST Sep 3, 1912
The first day is presented as a stated fixed day, the definite article before first day taken to show regular observance and not merely one particular first day, supporting recurring Christian practice in which weekly communion and weekly observance belong together.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jun 24, 1873
Paul, Luke and companions were together at Troas for a week, yet communion was held on Sunday not on the Sabbath, with companions leaving after communion and before preaching while Paul remained to give more time together before departing the next morning, taken to show the first day was the Lord's day and the regular day for the Supper; the seven-day stay and departure are part of the argument that disciples kept the first day as regular meeting day rather than the seventh, though the final meeting marking the close of a week of labor does not establish regular custom.RH Jun 24, 1873
The verse is taken to identify the first day as the time Christians came together in the church to observe the Supper, so the meeting was not casual but regular practice making the day sacred, with gathering and worship presented as stated acts making the day sacred to those acts.RH Jul 8, 1873ST Oct 9, 1884RH May 20, 1873
Breaking bread is identified with observing the Supper as an act of worship on that day, including both Paul's companions and the Troas disciples with Paul preaching before leaving next day, and the Supper is treated as the weekly memory ordinance placed at regular intervals so that no Christian need go beyond seven days without remembrance that Jesus died according to the Scriptures, the resurrection day of every week to be regarded with its ordinance if possible.RH Jun 17, 1873ST Sep 4, 1901RH Nov 28, 1871
The Troas assembly in A.D. 60 is presented as the earliest indication of Sunday specially observed in place of the Sabbath, cited as evidence but not as divine command, the change introduced gradually and silently through example rather than express precept, treating the day as holy time arising through example.ST Apr 6, 1882ST Feb 24, 1887ST Mar 24, 1881RH Jan 31, 1856
The same gradual silent introduction by example is described as a spurious human adulteration and usurping rite crept after apostolic times claiming divine rank, to be put away for the unchanged seventh-day Sabbath, with no foundation in God's Word and never commanded, and the verse is cited as evidence that apostles made the first day after the Sabbath holy without Christ's command.RH Aug 21, 1855ST Jun 27, 1900
The change is said to have begun through opposition to Judaism rather than divine command, and the meeting was cited as Christ changing the Sabbath by meeting with disciples, with disciples appointing no other meeting on their own.ST Mar 24, 1881RH Dec 6, 1870
The first day is presented as appointed by the Lord for meeting, prayer, reading, exhortation, teaching, giving to the poor and breaking bread, but not as Sabbath or day of rest, keeping the appointment connected with receiving Israel's heritage without making seventh-day observance a requirement for justification.RH Oct 27, 1859
The apostles' example of setting apart one day in seven is presented as evidence that the Sabbath is of divine origin and remains binding, and the first-day assembly for worship may support treating the first day as sacred, even as an additional sacred day, without making the seventh less sacred or replaced.RH Jul 7, 1859ST Nov 13, 1879
Paul's preaching at Troas when disciples came together to break bread proves he held meetings on the first day and is taken to show God sanctioned keeping it though with no precept commanding it, claimed as apostolic preference by inference though not explicitly calling it Sabbath.RH Feb 18, 1858RH Mar 17, 1853RH Jan 2, 1866
The account is treated as supposed evidence of something tending to sanctify the first day alongside New Testament evidence for Sabbath observance, and the first-day meeting is used as argument that the first day had become the Sabbath though it does not itself establish it.RH Apr 11, 1907ST Jun 8, 1882
The verse shows apostolic use belonging to the change from seventh to first, giving no express command or precept enjoining the change, while the Old Testament Sabbath law was never repealed but still binding and now applied to the first day.ST Jan 6, 1887
The change is presented as introduced by Christ and apostles with full divine approval, the clear example and approbation supplying the divine authority needed to change a day once fixed by divine authority, supporting by resurrection that the Sabbath was changed by divine authority.RH May 8, 1856RH Jun 17, 1873
The verse is treated as example of apostles and early church observing the first day, binding as support for Sunday holy rest, carrying the force of positive precept because it benefits growth and knowledge, and as evidence first disciples worshiped and treated it holy while Sabbath reason remains divine command through all time, yet it does not establish authoritative substitution.RH May 17, 1870RH Jun 11, 1861
The same apostolic example is invoked to argue a positive command is unnecessary, and the breaking of bread on the first day is offered as apostolic example but not accepted as Sabbath evidence, giving by itself only slender precarious inference for Sunday observance not explicit institution.RH Oct 28, 1873RH Dec 24, 1872RH Apr 9, 1872
The verse is cited as evidence disciples met on the first day while the Sabbath was also observed, not establishing rest or equal authority, as practice followed alongside Jewish Sabbath observance and synagogue preaching, showing meetings before Constantine's rest laws and before the papal church began.RH Dec 1850ST Mar 17, 1887RH Apr 28, 1853RH Dec 1850
The first day is shown as a day of Christian gathering, worship and joy, not a Christian Sabbath or continuation of the Jewish Sabbath, with Paul knowing no Sabbath observance on it, presenting a Sunday morning meeting for breaking before duties while the Sabbath remained intact, belonging to gradual substitution without making rest or legal duty.RH Jul 24, 1913AUST Jun 21, 1920
The Sabbath is said to have been changed in the apostolic age by divine direction though with no recorded command, Paul teaching Jewish sabbaths not obligatory while the moral law remains, and the Holy Spirit gradually changing memorial from creation to resurrection because Christ in vain tried to correct burdensome observance counting healing or turning the sick in bed a sin, leaving what disciples could not bear for the Spirit to do gradually.RH May 8, 1856ST Mar 26, 1912
First-day meetings including Christ meeting disciples are presented as proof Sunday is Sabbath while also stating the New Testament gives no instruction changing the Sabbath, and the verse is put to fix the Christian Sabbath to the definite first day forever excluding the other five while also making Sabbath indefinite as any day after six labor days, which cannot both be true.RH Aug 2, 1870RH Feb 4, 1858
The verse is associated with Protestant belief that the first day is the Christian Sabbath, with resurrection commemoration not requiring same absolute hours in different places, with early setting apart for worship alongside Barnabas calling the eighth day joyful because Jesus rose, and with new-covenant replacement in which law was abolished yet principles carried over, as tradition accompanied by harmony and progress, without using it to establish Sunday is Sabbath.ST Apr 1, 1880RH Apr 28, 1853RH Aug 19, 1873RH Jul 28, 1859
The verse is invoked for Christians holding Sunday assemblies while the seventh-day Sabbath was not observed except synagogue preaching to Jews, challenged over whether Christ's death abolished law, with claims that God's rest was rightly called first day even from Adam so Paradise seventh appears as first, that if Jews' Sabbath were Sunday then Monday would be Christian Sabbath after a change, and that the particular day is minor so long as one day is consecrated.ST Sep 27, 1883ST Jul 19, 1883ST Apr 24, 1879
The verse is reflected in regular first-day meetings to break bread, associated with that practice rather than commanded as Sabbath, and used to support that disciples met for worship with Paul preaching as evidence the resurrection led to setting apart a worship day.ST Dec 2, 1886
No Command or Change
The day is called only plain first day of the week, with no sacred title of Sabbath, Lord's day, Christian Sabbath, holy, sanctified, rest or sacred day, standing distinct from the seventh-day Sabbath just before it, while through Acts the sacred title Sabbath belongs only to the seventh day.RH Oct 6, 1868RH Aug 22, 1854RH May 12, 1874ST Oct 17, 1878ST Feb 27, 1893
It was a particular farewell gathering to break bread before departure, not a recurring first-day meeting or Christian Sabbath, not held to keep the day holy, with its light part spent in travel toward Jerusalem.RH Oct 6, 1868
It does not say they met every first day, command rest or holiness, abolish the seventh-day Sabbath, establish custom, regular service or obligation, and it contrasts with regular Sabbath preaching and with daily breaking of bread.RH Aug 22, 1854RH May 12, 1874
It was a night meeting with many lamps at the beginning of the first day by sunset reckoning, what is now called Saturday evening, with preaching until midnight and talking until daybreak before leaving next morning, an uncommon all-night farewell because of departure and the raising of the fallen youth, not because of sacredness.RH May 12, 1874ST Oct 17, 1878ST Feb 27, 1893
An evening meeting on any weekday does not make that day holy, disciples could meet and break bread any day, no command fixes when meetings or the Supper must be held, and if assigned to the Roman evening after midnight it would fall on the second day by Jewish reckoning and give no precedent for keeping Sunday.ST Oct 17, 1878ST Feb 27, 1893
The account contains neither the word Sabbath nor any synonymous term, asserts nothing that the first day is holier than any other day, shows no regular habit of meeting that day, and says nothing about keeping a day holy in honor of the resurrection.RH Nov 1, 1853RH Nov 28, 1871ST Mar 16, 1882RH Feb 27, 1872ST Jul 18, 1878
It is one of only two New Testament mentions of the first day outside resurrection accounts, recording meeting to break bread and speaking until midnight, but not saying God sanctified the first day or replaced the Sabbath, and it has no more bearing on change of the Sabbath than on baptism.ST Mar 16, 1882RH Jun 26, 1900ST Jul 18, 1878
It is one of three main texts used with 1 Corinthians 16:1,2 and Revelation 1:10 to claim divine authority for change, yet it gives no such proof.RH Nov 1, 1853ST Jul 18, 1878
There is no express injunction, command, institution, appointment, prescription or divine authority establishing Sunday as rest, worship, sacred use or Christian Sabbath, and it gives no when, where or by whom.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Sep 17, 1874ST Sep 21, 1882ST Apr 10, 1879RH Dec 23, 1909
The phrase first day of the week means exactly that and cannot rightly be translated Sabbath, much less both Sabbath and first day in the same text, and the added title Christian Sabbath has no place in it, containing no Sabbath, no religious principle and no obligation.ST Apr 10, 1879
Without text proving institution it creates no duty of conscience and leaves observers without scriptural direction, showing use for a gathering but only as report of customary practice, not as scriptural command for obligatory observance, nor saying the day was henceforth to be worship day.RH Dec 22, 1863RH Dec 23, 1909ST Dec 1, 1881
It reports a meeting but does not command first-day worship or appoint the day as rest.ST Sep 17, 1874ST Sep 21, 1882
It gives no command, precept, example, appointment or assumption establishing first-day sacredness, rest or obligation, does not ordain always-observance, prove stated worship day, regular custom or weekly Supper, hint abstinence, command assembly, allude to resurrection commemoration, or state duty.RH Nov 29, 1853ST Aug 15, 1878RH Jun 17, 1873ST Apr 22, 1880RH Sep 29, 1863
It says not one word about Sabbath, seventh day, rest, holy time or exercises proper only to Sabbath, does not call first day Sabbath, does not prove God unsanctified the seventh or that it is no longer holy, and gives no positive command so that proof depends on inference.RH Nov 29, 1853ST Aug 15, 1878RH Jun 17, 1873
It does not make the first day holy or treat it as holy, and using it to prove requirement rests on unwarranted inference as sinking sand.RH Jun 17, 1873ST Jul 13, 1904
It does not call that day Sabbath day, ordain first-day meetings always observed, or decree abrogation of the everlasting command to keep seventh day holy, containing no precept authorizing change.ST Apr 22, 1880
It does not prove, establish or state change or transfer from seventh to first, repeal, abolition, unsanctifying seventh, or substitution; saying first day does not say seventh was changed to first and does not overturn testimony seventh day is God's Sabbath.RH Oct 6, 1868STRH Nov 15, 1853
It was an occasion connected with imminent departure with breaking as part of that gathering, placed on evening after seventh-day Sabbath with morrow as following daylight when departure and journey resumed, not proof the day became Sabbath or regular worship day.
The first day was therefore a laboring working traveling day, not a Sabbath, with preaching at night before departure next day, mentioning gathering but calling it neither Sabbath nor Lord's day and giving no indication of transfer or repeal.RH Oct 6, 1868ST Jul 22, 1908ST
It records what they did on that occasion, not replacement or abolition of Sabbath.RH Nov 15, 1853
It does not decree observance abrogates God's everlasting command, permit Saturday work, authorize changing Saturday seventh to Sunday first, or provide authority substituting Sunday.ST Apr 22, 1880RH Sep 29, 1863RH Jan 9, 1872RH Mar 4, 1875RH Sep 22, 1874
It does not call first day Sabbath or Christian Sabbath, say it was kept holy or as worship, command keeping Sunday, ordain always-observance, permit seventh-day work, or command sanctifying Sunday, leaving Sunday-keeping without scriptural authority and resting on church tradition and ordinance against plain letter of Bible.RH Jan 9, 1872RH Mar 4, 1875RH Sep 22, 1874
It is one of only eight New Testament mentions of first day and records no change from seventh to first in commemoration of resurrection.ST May 19, 1909
A bread meeting does not abrogate remembering Sabbath, and profaning Saturday still violates commandment.ST Apr 22, 1880RH Sep 29, 1863
Even a direct command to meet on first day to break bread would not affect the fourth commandment or Sabbath observance, and breaking does not abolish it.RH Nov 2, 1911RH Oct 23, 1856
With no other Scripture enjoining Sunday-keeping labor that day is not sin, there is one lawgiver only who could institute worship by command, no divine law commands Sunday observance and none forbids Sunday work, so working Sunday incurs no displeasure and where no law sin is not imputed.RH Oct 23, 1856RH Jun 26, 1900
Since believers broke bread daily they did so on seventh day as well, so breaking alone does not show abolition or replacement.RH Nov 2, 1911
By Bible reckoning evening to evening the meeting with lights was Saturday evening beginning first day ending Sunday evening, while by midnight reckoning breaking after midnight preaching and healing was Monday morning, a farewell last meeting followed Sunday morning by nearly twenty miles on foot to Assos proving no regard for day as sacred.RH Oct 23, 1856
The value of an act and of holy time cannot be determined apart from God's authority: the Sabbath made by the Son of God is of infinite value, while a day lacking divine command, blessing and sanctification has no such standing, and the verse alone neither establishes first-day Sabbath nor makes meeting make day holy.RH Nov 9, 1911
If taken as example, sailing to Assos during that same time must also be followed, and it contains no abrogation of seventh-day law and no injunction to keep first day holy or as rest.ST Dec 13, 1883
Breaking was not Sunday-only because disciples met daily for that purpose, and preaching is recorded far more often on seventh day than first.
Written about thirty years after resurrection and twenty-six years after Gospel events, it still calls the day simply first day with no sacred name such as Lord's day, proving it had not become divinely established institution then nor when John had Patmos vision.ST Jan 8, 1885RH Feb 13, 1872RH Nov 26, 1872ST Jul 11, 1878ST Jun 10, 1886
So Revelation 1:10 cannot mean first day if meaning an existing divinely established institution, early Greek Christians never called first day Sabbath, it is identified by number not sacred title contrasted with seventh called Sabbath, and it does not identify that day as Lord's day.RH Feb 13, 1872ST Jul 11, 1878ST Jun 10, 1886ST Jul 19, 1883
A marginal reference linking it to Revelation 1:10 does not establish first day is Lord's day, since Scripture nowhere says so, and it does not connect it with Christ's title as Lord of the Sabbath.ST Mar 1, 1883
It is the only religious meeting on first day in New Testament, Acts and Paul's preaching, and only text of public exercises or Supper that day, contrasted with many Sabbath meetings and eight Sabbath references with custom noted and about eighty-four Sabbaths on which Paul preached.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 8, 1880ST Mar 18, 1889ST Feb 20, 1879
The whole apostolic example for first day rests on Paul alone versus regular Sabbath preaching, with when not in original and no statement of custom, sacred title or Sabbath.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Feb 20, 1879
Only one meeting is recorded because made memorable by occurrence and healing, not because only meeting during seven days, silence not proving none, with companions sailing to Assos after Sabbath rest while Paul stayed for closing evening meeting then traveled first-day morning, directly proving that day not Sabbath.ST Jul 8, 1880ST Mar 18, 1889
The day is named only because of miracle of raising and to show treatment as common working day, with Paul speaking till daybreak then walking nineteen miles while others rowed about fifty miles around headland all Sunday daytime.ST Mar 18, 1889ST Sep 2, 1886
It has no bearing favoring sacredness but bears against it, since that day was spent in travel and labor treating it ordinary, presenting historical account not sanctification, with rest of day in labor and travel and nothing showing holiness.ST Jul 21, 1909ST Sep 6, 1910ST Oct 21, 1897ST Aug 17, 1882
Paul did not regard first day as sanctified, could not institute worship by command, and it gives Bible example of secular work while precept and example enjoin seventh-day Sabbath.ST Aug 17, 1882RH Jun 26, 1900
Though millions appeal to it as authority first day is Sabbath, that cannot sustain claim before judgment seat of Christ in presence of angels and morning stars and sons of God present when Sabbath was made and earth foundations laid, against God's imperishable testimony seventh day is Sabbath of the Lord upheld by Christ as pillar inwrought with everlasting hills.ST Jul 25, 1878
It is presented as collateral not direct evidence for Sunday sanctity, as familiar argument to set aside God's memorial, and as reason apostles met to break bread, judged unproved, inadequate, slender and precarious, not grounded in resurrection transactions, not explaining wording or describing meeting beyond day.RH Feb 28, 1856RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882ST Sep 21, 1882RH Apr 4, 1854
It must be proved from Bible Sabbath was changed or resurrection made first day rest, and it is not plain command requiring Sunday holy; examination shows Sunday position untenable and identifying first day as Christian Sabbath unscriptural.RH Aug 19, 1858RH Jun 3, 1858RH Jul 6, 1869
At most example concerns meeting and breaking, not law forbidding labor; by itself it does not establish law requiring all to worship or forbidding work, prove outsiders assembled, command resting, or show they stopped working.RH Mar 14, 1854ST Nov 22, 1883RH Dec 6, 1853ST Nov 22, 1883RH Dec 1850
So it does not establish first-day Sabbath though it supports assembly, distinguishes meeting from rest observance, early Christians also resting seventh day, while Sabbath also observed with authority not equaled.RH Mar 14, 1854RH Dec 6, 1853RH Dec 1850RH Jan 13, 1852
To establish new Sabbath it must show customary weekly assembly to commemorate resurrection by divine or apostolic precept with rest instead of seventh, which it does not, giving first day no sacred title nor calling it Sabbath.RH Dec 12, 1871
It does not show Troas church always met first day, all churches worldwide met weekly that day, Paul or all apostles commanded observance, seventh Sabbath unobserved, change to first, or primitive church laboring seventh and abstaining first as all mankind should now do.RH Dec 12, 1871
To draw universal rest-first-labor-seventh conclusions from this single meeting builds great pyramid upside down upon its point not base.RH Dec 12, 1871
The occasion is report of when Paul preached, not command to keep that day, while apostles also preached on seventh-day Sabbath.RH Jan 6, 1859
Whether Christians were commanded by apostolic practice to assemble and whether it was regular stated time for breaking are questions with no scriptural answer; report is distinct from command, fact does not by itself establish Christ commanded it or binding continuing custom, and same claim could be made of Wednesday.RH Jul 2, 1872ST Jul 8, 1897RH Mar 31, 1868RH Mar 29, 1864RH Aug 8, 1871
Considered on its own it does not prove first day is Sabbath, provides no apostolic command or example changing Sabbath from seventh, and its mention does not establish Sunday kept as Sabbath or sacred rest.RH Mar 31, 1868RH May 6, 1852ST Oct 21, 1889RH Sep 4, 1860
It is raised as possible basis for teaching Christians should meet and break bread first day, but does not affirm or establish that teaching or divinely commanded Sabbath; even if held in honor of resurrection it does not show rest-day keeping or Christian Sabbath, activities also done other days.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 25, 1873ST Feb 13, 1893ST Sep 12, 1895ST Oct 23, 1884
It gives example of first-day meeting but no direct precept commanding religious observance, seventh not first set apart for rest and worship, change gradually silently introduced by example rather than express precept.ST Sep 12, 1895
Paul in same chapter said he kept back nothing profitable and declared all God's counsel yet taught no first-day Sabbath or Lord's day; coming to tomb to prepare body shows day treated as working day, and verse does not show he taught or observed Sunday holy, holding meeting not making Sabbath or every meeting day Sabbath.ST Mar 12, 1912ST Apr 20, 1915ST Jul 24, 1893
It is cited where first day was claimed called Sabbath, which if correct would show recognition by sacred title in Acts, but given with no proof four Acts mentions call first day Sabbath or rest.RH Dec 5, 1871RH Mar 31, 1868RH May 6, 1852ST Oct 21, 1889RH Sep 4, 1860
Sabbath Remains Seventh Day
Paul's starting on his journey the next morning on the first day shows he did not regard the first day as the Sabbath, and that he honored the fourth commandment by waiting till the Sabbath was past.RH Dec 12, 1871 The meeting at Troas was not a stated daytime meeting but an unusual farewell night meeting after the close of the Sabbath, held on Saturday evening when the first day begins at sunset, with preaching first for about five hours until midnight and not about fourteen hours from Sunday morning, with breaking of bread after the sermon closed at midnight, with many lights in the upper chamber showing the whole service was in the evening, and with no daytime service followed by adjournment and then an evening service.RH Dec 12, 1871 An apostle's actions could not make the first day the seventh so as to change the commanded Sabbath.RH Mar 7, 1854 The seventh day is Saturday, kept in regular succession by Jews around the world, and the original Sabbath was known to Jesus.RH Mar 7, 1854
The day is named only as plain first day of the week as distinct from the seventh-day Sabbath just before it, giving it no sacred title and not making it the Sabbath, holy, or sacred.ST Nov 11, 1889ST Oct 22, 1894ST Nov 12, 1894 The first day is the day immediately following the Sabbath, the day before it being called the Sabbath, and neither Christ nor the apostles taught that it should be kept as sacred or regarded it as holy.ST Nov 11, 1889ST Nov 12, 1894 Sunday is the first day of the Hebrew week, while the Jewish Saturday remains the true seventh day reckoned from creation, so the verse does not show that Sunday was originally the seventh day or that time was lost. It records movement on the first day commonly called Sunday and sometimes called the Christian Sabbath, not Sabbath-keeping of that day, with Paul traveling fifty miles and his companions seventy miles by his appointment from Troas to Mitylene, then just as far on following days from Mitylene to Chios, from Chios to Samos and Trogyllium, and to Miletus about thirty miles, with Sopater, Aristarchus, Secundus, Gaius, Tychicus, Trophimus, Timothy and Luke, proving they counted the first day no more sacred than the next days, with no Sabbath observance at all.ST Dec 11, 1884 The Sabbath law pertains to the seventh day, not Sunday, and does not forbid Sunday travel.ST Dec 10, 1912
The first Christians observed the seventh-day Sabbath, which stands on the fourth commandment and the practice of Christ and his apostles, while Sunday observance stands only on tradition and church custom, and the Troas meeting on the first day to break bread with preaching continued till break of day, by modern reckoning begun Saturday evening not Sunday evening, gives no authority for Sunday observance or for holding communion on Sunday.RH Jul 12, 1906 The change from the seventh day to the first was gradually and silently introduced by example rather than by express precept, with no command to keep Sunday and no foundation in the Word of God, never commanded by the Lord of Life.ST Jun 27, 1900ST Sep 9, 1886ST Sep 12, 1895 It is a spurious human adulteration and usurping rite that crept silently into use after apostolic times claiming the rank of a divine institution, to be put away and exchanged for the genuine seventh-day Sabbath still standing unchanged in the law.ST Jun 27, 1900 Careful reading shows utter lack of divine authority for changing the Sabbath to Sunday, leaving the definite seventh-day Sabbath still binding as the sign between God and His people by which they know He is the Lord and as the seal of His law, while the first-day institution is a counterfeit mark of the man of sin who made the change.ST May 13, 1903 The verse also reveals an antidote to the mark of the beast in connection with observing God's Sabbath rather than the papal Sabbath, with the breaking at Troas on the first day understood as after sunset when Jews reckoned the day began in the evening, though by Roman reckoning a meal after midnight would fall on the second day.RH Jun 2, 1868
One instance of a church meeting on the first day after nightfall allows worship gatherings on that day, but such a gathering does not make that day the Sabbath or excuse neglecting the seventh day commanded in the fourth commandment.RH May 8, 1879 The account gives an example of meeting and breaking bread, not of resting from ordinary work or treating the day as a Sabbath, with Paul speaking till midnight before leaving the next day.RH Sep 18, 1866 The first day is treated as an ordinary common working day, distinct from the seventh-day Sabbath observed by Christ and the disciples, marked by ordinary activity including preaching and the restoration of Eutychus to life rather than holy-day observance, with no hint of labor abstinence, and Paul's preaching cited as an example of laboring on that day presenting Sunday as ordinary not sacred and not requiring rest or worship.ST Nov 8, 1905ST Feb 1, 1883ST Mar 3, 1914ST Feb 10, 1887ST Jul 17, 1907 It refers to the first day only as the first day, not calling it the Sabbath nor saying the Sabbath commandment was changed, and Scripture nowhere announces a change of the Lord's day which was the seventh day before Christ's first advent.ST Mar 12, 1885
The farewell gathering before departure does not establish the first day as a Sabbath, for while Paul held the meeting his companions traveled by boat around the peninsula toward Assos, showing customary seventh-day observance.ST Sep 26, 1911 The religious meeting was on the night corresponding to Saturday night since the day began at sunset, held because Paul was ready to leave the next day, while Luke and others sailed from Troas toward Assos and Paul set out on foot for Jerusalem on Sunday morning, and Paul delighted in God's law and kept the Sabbath.RH Oct 22, 1872 His spending the first day at Troas was not obedience to words about the Lord's day, because those words referred to the seventh-day Sabbath and were written by John decades later and could not have guided his actions.
Scripture Connections and Counts
The first day is named only eight times in the New Testament, and apart from the six mentions that refer to the same resurrection day it is named only twice, here and in the direction for laying by, while the seventh-day Sabbath is spoken of fifty-nine times as the creation memorial kept by Christ and the apostles.ST Mar 16, 1882ST Sep 16, 1913ST Mar 30, 1888RH May 1, 1900RH Jun 16, 1874 The six resurrection-day mentions belong to events about twenty-six years before this account, and this account with Paul's letters is not the only other mention, since 1 Corinthians 16:2 also names the first day.ST Sep 25, 1893ST Jul 21, 1909RH Jun 16, 1874 This meeting at Troas is distinguished from the Sabbath as a particular gathering to break bread with preaching the evening before departure, the only recorded instance in Acts of Paul preaching on that day, whereas his repeated preaching is on the seventh day.RH Jun 23, 1853ST Feb 24, 1898
The Greek mia ton sabbaton is the same as at the resurrection and in the laying by, and it means first day of the week, not the first of a new series of Sunday Sabbaths.RH Jun 21, 1864RH Aug 18, 1874RH Dec 13, 1870ST Mar 27, 1879RH Apr 11, 1871 If it began a new series at the resurrection, consistency would require another distinct series to begin here at Troas in the year 59, about twenty-eight years afterward, and yet another in 1 Corinthians 16:2, with practice commanded only for the first of those Sabbaths, which exposes the claim as false.RH Jun 21, 1864RH Aug 18, 1874ST Mar 27, 1879 The plural form does not make the first day a rest day, and the article reinforces that the first day is described in relation to the Sabbaths without being called the Sabbath, while the seventh-day Sabbath continued to be observed and called Sabbath.RH Jun 2, 1868RH Dec 13, 1870RH Apr 11, 1871 The same expression can describe each week's first day, when Christians could assess gains and set aside at home an offering for the poor at Jerusalem, and these gatherings supplied the occasion for each believer to bring to the treasury the portion set apart for benevolence.RH Jun 24, 1915RH Apr 29, 1873
Unlike the resurrection-day mentions, this verse is not evidence that the disciples honored the day in memory of the resurrection, since on the resurrection day they did not believe he had risen, and Christ is nowhere recorded as mentioning the first day.ST Apr 13, 1882RH May 1, 1900RH Jun 16, 1874 It connects the day with neither resurrection nor sanctification, and gives no regulation for observance, no work prohibition, no penalty, no blessing, and no statement of Sabbath change.ST Jul 21, 1909ST Apr 13, 1882RH Jun 16, 1874 The account records disciples coming together at Troas to break bread with Paul preaching until midnight because ready to depart on the morrow, presented as history of an ordinary day rather than proof of sanctification or stated worship.ST Jul 24, 1893RH Nov 28, 1871ST Feb 24, 1898 Raised for examination as claimed fourth-commandment-change evidence, it is questioned on regular-observance wording, Saturday-night timing, death-commemorating bread, daytime matters, and journey resumption, since it does not call the day Sabbath, ordain always-observance, permit Saturday work, command Sunday holiness, decree abrogation of the seventh day, or instruct rest from work such as fishing or hunting.ST Jul 24, 1893RH Jan 9, 1872RH Dec 24, 1867
The name Sunday does not occur in Scripture, and the first day retains the character of the wild solar holiday of pagan times with heathen name and dedication origins.RH Jun 24, 1873ST Sep 16, 1913RH Jul 8, 1875ST Apr 29, 1913 The verse identifies the first day with Sunday as distinct from the seventh day called the Sabbath, but it does not establish that Sunday was called the Lord's day by an order attributed to Sylvester, whose evidence is unreliable, and Leo I is noted as calling it Sunday or the first day, not the Lord's day.ST Mar 11, 1889ST Apr 29, 1913 The meeting to break bread and hear Paul is cited as a practice the apostles followed alongside observance of the Jewish Sabbath before Constantine's rest laws, with the first-day festival treated as distinct from the Sabbath and connected with the resurrection, not replacing the Sabbath as God's creation memorial and Decalogue command, for which no divine warrant for change is found here.RH Apr 28, 1853RH Dec 1850RH Jun 3, 1873 The account supplies precedent for a meeting continuing nearly till daybreak before journeys, as followed at Ulysses, while it is argued that if this day were actually the Jewish seventh, those calling it the first should worship on Monday instead or keep the seventh on Sunday.RH Aug 14, 1860RH Aug 4, 1853 It is relevant to the claim that early Christians set apart the first day for public worship, alongside Barnabas calling the eighth day joyful because Jesus rose, yet it records believers meeting for worship on the first day without saying they kept it as Sabbath or to commemorate the resurrection.RH Jan 6, 1874RH Jun 3, 1873
Christian Life and Practice
The gathering at Troas was a religious service with preaching when Christians came together on the first day of the week, and it supports meeting together for teaching, fellowship, breaking of bread, and prayer.ST Mar 22, 1883RH Oct 27, 1859 Continuing in speech until midnight gives warrant for holding very long meetings on extraordinary occasions, without approving such long meetings as a regular practice.ST Apr 15, 1875RH Apr 8, 1875 The address in the upper chamber was a farewell sermon whose purpose was instruction for the benefit of the hearers and for God's glory, not rhetorical display, personal glory, fame, applause, or display of eloquence.RH Feb 17, 1863STRH Oct 10, 1865ST Apr 5, 1877 Even a hearer falling asleep and falling out of the window did not interrupt the discourse, showing preaching not constrained by punctilious formality.ST Oct 8, 1885
Coming together on the evening of the first day to break bread is sweet, melting, heavenly fellowship that cheers God's scattered pilgrim strangers on earth.RH Oct 22, 1857 That breaking of bread points forward to the marriage supper of the Lamb, where the saints of all ages will eat and drink together at the Lord's table in His kingdom when the feast is fulfilled in the kingdom of God.RH Oct 22, 1857 Preparation for it now is required by putting on the wedding garment, the white linen which is the righteousness of saints.RH Oct 22, 1857 The same gathering to break bread applies to a little church gathering marked by the presence and blessing of the Holy Spirit, joyful praise, and hope of meeting Christ again.RH Nov 25, 1852
The meeting was a special occasion rather than a regular stated worship day, and its object was connected with what occurred on the sixth day rather than with commemoration of an event on the first day.RH Nov 28, 1871 It does not say that the gathering celebrated Christ's resurrection, and eating the bread and drinking the cup proclaim the Lord's death according to 1 Corinthians 11:26.ST Jan 8, 1885RH Jan 6, 1874 The believers met at night to break bread and hear Paul with speech continuing until midnight, placed after the Jewish Sabbath still observed as rest by Jews and Jewish proselytes, with the first day beginning at sunset by Jewish reckoning and the journey resumed on Sunday morning likely because the ship had remained seven days and was departing.ST Aug 19, 1875 Counting the meeting from Saturday evening does not fit the idea that it commemorated the resurrection, and how a meal after midnight on Sunday night could still fall on the first day is questioned.ST Aug 19, 1875ST Jan 8, 1885 The evening gathering after the close of the Sabbath at sunset of the seventh day resembles the supper instituted by Christ at night, and it does not abolish the original seventh-day Sabbath, give any command to substitute the first day for the seventh, or say the day was kept as a Sabbath.RH Feb 12, 1857RH Jan 6, 1874
The sermon took place between evening and midnight, the bread was broken between midnight and dawn, and then Paul traveled, so by Jewish reckoning sermon, breaking, and journey fell within the same first day, while by Roman reckoning the bread was broken on the morning of the travel day.RH Nov 29, 1853 The account is evidence that Paul performed unnecessary travel on the first day, and therefore that the first day was not the Sabbath of the fourth commandment.RH Nov 29, 1853 His meeting on that day did not make it sacred time, just as Christ's travel on a first day after His resurrection did not make that day holy.RH Apr 29, 1873 The record of disciples gathering to break bread and hear Paul preach does not state that the day is a Sabbath, give instructions to rest from work such as fishing or hunting, offer any divine or apostolic precept commanding assembly on that day, or give any hint of abstinence from labor.RH Dec 24, 1867RH Dec 12, 1871 The breaking showed the death of Christ by the breaking of His body on the cross, so the meeting commemorated the crucifixion and not the resurrection, without even alluding to any purpose to commemorate the resurrection.RH Dec 12, 1871
Sources