Ecclesiastes 3:19
For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yea, they have all one breath; so that a man hath no preeminence above a beast: for all is vanity.
Translations
For that which befalls the sons of men befalls beasts; even one thing befalls them: as the one dies, so dies the other; yes, they have all one breath; so that a man has no preeminence above a beast: for all is vanity.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yea, they have all one breath; so that a man hath no preeminence above a beast: for all is vanity.
For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yes, they have all one breath; so that a man hath no pre-eminence above a beast: for all is vanity.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yea, they have all one breath; and man hath no preeminence above the beasts: for all is vanity.
For an event [is to] the sons of man, and an event [is to] the beasts, even one event [is] to them; as the death of this, so [is] the death of that; and one spirit [is] to all, and the advantage of man above the beast is nothing, for the whole [is] vanity.
For what befalleth the children of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other, and they have all one breath; and man hath no pre-eminence above the beast: for all is vanity.
For, as regardeth the destiny of the sons of men and the destiny of beasts, one fate, have they, as dieth the one, so, dieth the other, and, one spirit, have they all,—and, the pre-eminence of man over beast, is nothing, for, all, were vanity:
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For the fates of both men and beasts are the same: As one dies, so dies the other— they all have the same breath. Man has no advantage over the animals, since everything is futile.
For that which happens to the sons of men happens to animals. Even one thing happens to them. As the one dies, so the other dies. Yes, they have all one breath; and man has no advantage over the animals, for all is vanity.
Because the fate of the sons of men and the fate of the beasts is the same. As is the death of one so is the death of the other, and all have one spirit. Man is not higher than the beasts; because all is to no purpose.
For the condition of the children of men, and the condition of beasts are euen as one condition vnto them. As the one dyeth, so dyeth the other: for they haue all one breath, and there is no excellency of man aboue ye beast: for all is vanitie.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Therefore the death of man, and of beasts is one, and the condition of them both is equal: as man dieth, so they also die: all things breathe alike, and man hath nothing more than beast: all things are subject to vanity.
Cross-references 20 of 33
- Genesis 2:7
And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.
Both humans and animals live by the breath of life.
- Genesis 7:21-22
And all flesh died that moved upon the earth, both of fowl, and of cattle, and of beast, and of every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth, and every man:
Humans and animals share the breath of life, and both die when it is gone.
- Ecclesiastes 12:7
Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was: and the spirit shall return unto God who gave it.
The same word describes breath returning to God at death.
- Psalms 104:29
Thou hidest thy face, they are troubled: thou takest away their breath, they die, and return to their dust.
Both texts connect living creatures’ death with God withdrawing their breath.
- Psalms 146:4
His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
Both describe breath departing and thoughts perishing at death.
- Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
Both teach that the dead know nothing.
- Genesis 3:19
In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.
Both describe human death as a return to dust.
- Genesis 7:15
And they went in unto Noah into the ark, two and two of all flesh, wherein is the breath of life.
Humans and beasts alike have the breath of life.
- Job 34:14-15
If he set his heart upon man, if he gather unto himself his spirit and his breath;
When God gathers spirit and breath, all flesh perishes.
- Job 12:10
In whose hand is the soul of every living thing, and the breath of all mankind.
God holds the life and breath of every living creature.
- Job 27:3
All the while my breath is in me, and the spirit of God is in my nostrils;
Both describe human life as breath or spirit within the nostrils.
- Isaiah 2:22
Cease ye from man, whose breath is in his nostrils: for wherein is he to be accounted of?
Human breath underscores the frailty and mortality of life.
- Psalms 49:12
Nevertheless man being in honour abideth not: he is like the beasts that perish.
Compares human mortality with the fate of beasts.
- Genesis 6:17
And, behold, I, even I, do bring a flood of waters upon the earth, to destroy all flesh, wherein is the breath of life, from under heaven; and every thing that is in the earth shall die.
Both texts speak of the same breath of life in humans and other living creatures.
- Psalms 49:14
Like sheep they are laid in the grave; death shall feed on them; and the upright shall have dominion over them in the morning; and their beauty shall consume in the grave from their dwelling.
Both describe humans dying like animals.
- Hebrews 9:27
And as it is appointed unto men once to die, but after this the judgment:
Connects death with facing judgment.
- Genesis 1:30
And to every beast of the earth, and to every fowl of the air, and to every thing that creepeth upon the earth, wherein there is life, I have given every green herb for meat: and it was so.
Both texts describe humans and animals as sharing life.
- Job 17:16
They shall go down to the bars of the pit, when our rest together is in the dust.
People go down to the pit and rest in the dust.
- Romans 8:20
For the creature was made subject to vanity, not willingly, but by reason of him who hath subjected the same in hope,
Man’s sin subjected creation to vanity and death.
- Ezekiel 37:5-6
Thus saith the Lord GOD unto these bones; Behold, I will cause breath to enter into you, and ye shall live:
The same Hebrew word is rendered “breath.”
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
2 sources
To die like a beast is to die believing that death ends existence and expecting no life beyond the grave.Ms 5, 1873, par. 311MR 120.4 Holding that expectation leaves the dying without comfort and without hope at death.Ms 5, 1873, par. 311MR 120.4 By contrast, Christian hope looks beyond the grave to life again, with brightness beyond death.Ms 5, 1873, par. 311MR 120.4 Even with that hopeless expectation, the one who dies must still meet God, who is just.Ms 5, 1873, par. 311MR 120.4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
61 sources
What happens to people in death happens to animals in the same way, for as one dies so dies the other because all share one breath, leaving humans with no advantage over beasts in dying and both returning to dust.RH Jul 28, 1863RH Feb 9, 1864 That shared breath is the life-principle lent by God to animate the body, the same air and life common to every kind according to its nature, not a separate conscious person or portion of His essence.ST Mar 29, 1905RH Feb 10, 1859 Death is therefore the end of conscious life, with the dead knowing nothing, thinking nothing, and receiving neither reward nor punishment until the resurrection.ST Oct 11, 1905ST Dec 9, 1913 Having this breath does not make either people or beasts immortal, since what would prove an undying soul in man would prove it in beasts as well.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Aug 13, 1874ST Aug 29, 1878ST Feb 20, 1893 Human superiority lies not in death but in life and in the resurrection, for without being made alive again people would remain extinct like beasts, while eternal life is altogether different from this common mortal life and is given only through faith in Christ.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jan 28, 1903ST Oct 9, 1879RH Apr 8, 1858
Breath and Wording
They have all one breath, the Hebrew ruach, meaning breath or spirit and also wind.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Feb 9, 1864RH Jun 8, 1916RH Feb 15, 1870 The same word applies to humans and to beasts, rendered breath in the statement that they have all one breath and spirit in the question about the spirit going upward or downward, and it should be rendered consistently.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Feb 9, 1864RH Jun 8, 1916RH Sep 19, 1854 The sameness affirmed is sameness of event and manner in death, that as the one dies so dies the other because they share one breath of life, the same breath breathed into Adam that every beast possesses, so that in ceasing to live man has no preeminence above a beast.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Feb 9, 1864RH Sep 19, 1854RH Feb 15, 1870 That likeness concerns earthly life and the condition in death, with both returning to dust and going to one place, not reasoning abilities, organization, or future prospects if righteous, and it stands against the pagan belief that human spirits ascend to the gods while animal spirits descend to the earth.ST Aug 29, 1878
Those who read the word for breath as nephesh take it to mean life, creature, or animal life, not never-ending existence.ST Jun 28, 1899 On that reading the shared breath gives no basis for an immortal soul, since it denotes life or existence and does not make animals immortal.ST Jun 28, 1899 The same original word appears as breath or spirit in Ecclesiastes 12:7 and Psalm 104:29, where it is better rendered spirit here, though sharing a word does not force exactly the same sense in every context.RH Sep 2, 1873
The breath is the life-principle lent by God to animate the body, literal air and life common to every kind according to its nature.ST Mar 29, 1905ST Nov 1, 1877RH Nov 11, 1858RH Aug 5, 1862 It is not a portion of God's essence nor a separate conscious person, but the life-giving power and influence by which creatures are animated; when God takes it back they cease to exist.ST Nov 1, 1877RH Nov 11, 1858RH Aug 5, 1862 Soul, spirit, breath, and life denote this animating principle interchangeably, and at death each part returns to its source, the body to dust and the breath to God who gave it.RH Feb 10, 1859ST Nov 1, 1877
The declaration is the word of God and Bible truth spoken as moved by the Holy Ghost, not a mere human sentiment recorded in Scripture.RH Apr 12, 1860 It therefore raises why God would have withheld from Solomon and his people all evidence of the soul's immortality if it were true.RH Jan 16, 1866
Common Death Shared
What befalls people befalls beasts in the same manner, for as the one dies so dies the other because all have one breath, and in ceasing to live humans have no preeminence above a beast, with one as much dead as the other.RH Jul 28, 1863RH Feb 9, 1864RH Jan 16, 1866ST Dec 19, 1916 Life is a power lent by God, and when it is laid down the living being returns to the common origin from which it came.RH Jan 16, 1866 The death of man is the same as the death of the beast, caused by taking away the breath, not by the separation of a deathless soul from the body.RH Jan 16, 1866RH Oct 2, 1855RH Aug 12, 1862 If a person continued to live in heaven or hell immediately after death, the same would have to be implied for animals, and without a resurrection man would remain eternally dead.RH Jul 28, 1863ST Dec 19, 1916 The spirit is called God's because He imparts it, and its return to God means death, not a return to conscious happiness with Him, with the same vital spirit meant here as in the question about the human spirit going upward and the beast's going downward, not a conscious immortal person, so that what follows about rejoicing in labor follows from their likeness in the points compared.RH Jan 16, 1866RH Aug 12, 1862
Both go to one place, for all are of the dust and all turn to dust again, to the grave, and neither wealth nor honor can exempt a person from this return.RH Jul 28, 1863ST Oct 11, 1905ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jan 28, 1903 The spirit that leaves at death returns to God just as it was when He gave it, no more conscious than before birth, as with Adam before the breath of life entered his nostrils, so that living in the mortal body for a few years adds no consciousness to it. Whatever leaves the dead body, whether called spirit or breath, cannot love or hate or envy, cannot praise God or even remember Him, and has no knowledge or wisdom but remains silent, which shows people do not receive their reward or punishment at death.ST Oct 11, 1905 Man dies exactly as the beast dies, with no exemption for the spirit, for man and beast have all one breath which is the spirit, and the spirit is purely human and shares the sentence of death pronounced on the whole sinning man, with no known different upward way for the spirit of man after death.RH Aug 12, 1862
God manifests the estate of men to show they are beasts in respect to death, and the statement that all is vanity is explained by this shared fate of death.ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 20, 1864 Human life and pursuits apart from God are vain and ultimately useless, and all creatures depend on God for life.ST Sep 15, 1909RH Jan 6, 1903 The breath is not a separate immortal person nor an intelligent entity or separate personality, but the life God gives, and when it is taken away the living die.RH Sep 20, 1864ST May 15, 1907
Limits of Likeness
Man is a beast in one respect only, not in every respect, for the likeness concerns the experience of death and the sharing of one breath.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 9, 1879RH Sep 8, 1859RH Nov 22, 1853 In dying there is no preeminence of man above beast, since as the one dies so dies the other by the taking away of the breath, both returning to dust and going to one place.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 9, 1879RH Sep 8, 1859RH Nov 22, 1853 The difference between humans and beasts belongs to life, not to death, and does not establish that the breath is immortal or that conscious existence continues after death.ST Oct 9, 1879RH Sep 8, 1859ST Sep 15, 1881 That shared condition in earthly life and death leaves untouched reasoning abilities, organization, and future prospects if righteous, and stands against the heathen notion of different destinies with human spirits ascending to the gods while animal spirits descend.RH Sep 8, 1859RH Nov 22, 1853ST Sep 15, 1881
In life humans are superior through higher intellectual faculties, reasoning powers, organization, moral nature, and understanding.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 23, 1884ST Aug 27, 1894RH Sep 8, 1859ST Sep 15, 1881 Unlike beasts they can recognize and love what is right, and understanding makes a distinction between them.ST Oct 23, 1884RH Sep 8, 1859ST Sep 15, 1881 Life comes from the same source but is organized differently in humans and animals, each living thing having the portion of life suited to its purpose and position.ST Mar 19, 1896ST Apr 15, 1889 The way life was given to man may give him greater dignity and superiority, yet it does not make his existence longer, and having the breath of life does not make either man or beast immortal.ST Aug 27, 1894ST Apr 15, 1889
The likeness does not cover the promise set before man to encourage him to seek God, for humans have the hope of resurrection and the promised gift of immortality through Jesus Christ the Life-giver at the last trumpet, while beasts do not.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 23, 1884ST Oct 9, 1879ST Aug 27, 1894 Only men who believe and obey the gospel escape the common natural fate, since the way of salvation was devised for man while beasts remain attached to the sin-cursed world to be destroyed with it.ST Jan 28, 1903 Those who live without regard to the future and choose to be as natural brute beasts deny the Lord that bought them and face destruction with the beasts, ending forever like beasts that perish in the second death.ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jan 28, 1903RH Nov 22, 1853
Unconscious State of Dead
Death is the end of life rather than a state of conscious existence, for what befalls people in death befalls animals, as the one dies so dies the other and all go to one place, of dust and turning to dust again.ST Oct 11, 1905ST Dec 9, 1913ST Mar 11, 1908ST Jun 1, 1915 In ceasing to live humans have no preeminence over beasts in the manner of dying, with one as much dead as the other.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Feb 10, 1881 The dead know nothing and are without knowledge or thought, receiving no reward or punishment at death.ST Oct 11, 1905ST Dec 9, 1913ST Feb 10, 1881 They have no concern about what takes place on earth or in heaven.ST Apr 11, 1900
The spirit or breath that leaves at death returns to God just as it was when He gave it, no more conscious than before birth, as with Adam before the breath of life entered his nostrils. Living in the mortal body for a few years adds no consciousness to the spirit, and the breath that returns to God is life, not an intelligent entity that remains conscious after death nor a separate conscious being surviving apart from the body.ST Mar 11, 1908ST Jan 2, 1912 Whatever leaves the dead body, whether called spirit or breath, cannot love or hate or envy, cannot praise God or even remember Him, and has no knowledge or wisdom but remains silent until the resurrection. Consciousness, memory, and the powers of the living organism perish with it, and soul means the life that departs at death and can be restored rather than an entity living independently.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Jan 2, 1912 Both humans and animals yield up their lives, which return to God the Fountain of life.ST Feb 10, 1898
Because both die, share one breath, and return to dust to the grave, there is no basis for thinking a person continues to live consciously after death in heaven or hell immediately after death, since that would imply the same fate for animals.RH Jul 28, 1863RH May 15, 1866ST Jun 1, 1915 The claim that people are unlike beasts that die, that the body is merely a temporary shell from which an immortal self rises, is rejected.ST Aug 13, 1874ST Aug 13, 1874 The spirit is purely human and shares the sentence of death pronounced on the whole sinning man, with the offending part not spared, and no different upward way for the spirit of man after death is known.RH Aug 12, 1862 The dead are unintelligent and cannot act as ministering or guardian spirits, or communicate by rapping, writing, speaking, or singing.RH Aug 7, 1855 The sayings that the soul never dies and that the dead live and roam as gods while bodies lie in the ground are exposed as lies.RH Aug 7, 1855
Mortality Denies Immortality
Human beings, like animals, are mortal and have no life in themselves.ST Feb 20, 1893RH Aug 7, 1916RH Sep 20, 1864RH Apr 15, 1858 In present bodily life humans and animals share the same breath and both die, and in this respect humans have no preeminence over beasts.ST Feb 20, 1893RH Aug 7, 1916RH Sep 20, 1864ST Nov 24, 1909 Human life, like animal life, depends absolutely on breath that God gives, and when it is taken away the living creature dies.RH Aug 7, 1916RH Sep 20, 1864RH Apr 15, 1858ST Nov 24, 1909 Having that breath does not mean that either possesses an immortal entity separate from the body, so having breath does not make either immortal.ST Feb 20, 1893RH Aug 7, 1916RH Apr 15, 1858ST Nov 24, 1909 The verse concerns this present life and does not deny that humans may receive future, unending life, but emphasizes that people depend absolutely on God for any future life and do not possess life independently of him.RH Aug 7, 1916 The breath is not a separate, immortal person but the life-principle lent by God to animate the body, and the statement that all is vanity is explained by this shared fate of death.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Apr 15, 1858
The shared breath proves humans have no distinct immortal life-principle giving preeminence, for what would make humans immortal would make beasts immortal.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Aug 13, 1874ST Aug 29, 1878RH Sep 5, 1854RH Apr 15, 1858 If human death meant an immortal soul separates from a mortal body, the same would have to be true of animals, since as the one dies so dies the other.ST Aug 13, 1874ST Aug 29, 1878RH Sep 5, 1854 Mention of a beast's spirit does not prove that humans have an immortal soul, since both die and all return to dust.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Aug 29, 1878RH Feb 10, 1859 Seeing, hearing, feeling, thought, or immateriality does not prove an immortal soul, since animals share them, and man in death is all soul dying, not a deathless soul separating.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Aug 13, 1874ST Aug 29, 1878 That breath is the spirit God gave at creation and that returns to God at death, not an immaterial soul that lives separate from the body, and its return to God means death, not a return to conscious happiness with God.RH Jan 16, 1866RH Feb 10, 1859 In that sense man has no spirit more than snakes and hogs, and the claim that the body is merely a temporary shell from which an immortal self rises is rejected.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Aug 13, 1874
The verse contrasts with the pagan and heathen belief that human spirits ascend to the gods while animal spirits descend to the earth.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Oct 12, 1904RH Nov 22, 1853 All go to one place, all are of the dust and all turn to dust again, with no exemption for the spirit and no different upward way known for the spirit of man after death.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Oct 12, 1904RH Nov 22, 1853 The following question of who has seen the human spirit going upward and the beast's going downward calls for any proof to the contrary and is a triumphant challenge that such a different destiny cannot be established.RH Jan 16, 1866ST Oct 12, 1904RH Nov 22, 1853 It denies the heathen philosophy of the immortality of the soul and of different destinies for the spirits of men and beasts, rather than proving it.ST Oct 12, 1904RH Nov 22, 1853 The likeness concerns earthly life and condition in death, not reasoning abilities, organization, or future prospects if righteous, and the spirit shares the sentence of death pronounced on the whole sinning man, with the offending part not spared.RH Aug 12, 1862
Resurrection and Future Hope
In death there is no preeminence of man above beast, for as the one dies so dies the other and one is as much dead as the other when death has passed, since all have one breath and both return to the dust from which humanity was made.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Oct 9, 1879RH Apr 8, 1858RH Sep 26, 1854 So far as ceasing to live is concerned there is nothing more in man that lives after death than there is in a beast, and without a resurrection man would remain eternally dead and extinct in that condition.ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 26, 1854ST Jun 25, 1896 The difference between humans and beasts belongs to life, not to death, and the verse does not make the breath or spirit immortal nor continue conscious existence after death.ST Oct 9, 1879 Man's preeminence is therefore in the resurrection, not in death, and a resurrection as a recreation is necessary for any future life, with human hope depending on Jesus the Life-giver.ST Oct 9, 1879RH Apr 8, 1858ST Jun 25, 1896 This shared mortality is set in contrast with Christ's promise to give believers eternal life and raise them from the dead.ST Mar 14, 1911
The common mortal life given in common to Adam and to the beasts is altogether different from the eternal life promised to the sons of God who have accepted Christ by faith.ST Mar 14, 1911ST May 14, 1896ST Mar 18, 1903 Fallen, unbelieving man of himself has no preeminence above a beast as regards future life, having only the animal life in which both die alike with one breath and return to dust.ST Jan 28, 1903ST May 14, 1896ST Mar 18, 1903 When connection with God was broken eternal life was cut off from the world and every law through which life comes was perverted, so man now receives only a perverted, temporary life from vegetable and animal, water, air, and sunshine, all existing under perverted law ending in disease, decay, and death, exactly as the lower creatures do, living only because God in mercy prolongs life while alienated from the life of God through ignorance and hardness of heart.ST Mar 18, 1903 Man was created of the dust of the earth, forfeited the life God gave by sin, dies, and returns to dust, and Adam in his sinless condition had opportunity to go on to immortality, for had there been no sin there would have been no death for man or beast.ST May 14, 1896ST Jun 25, 1896
The likeness concerns death and the elements of earthly formation, not capacities during life, for humans have a moral nature and can recognize and love what is right, unlike beasts, with each having the portion suited to its purpose though life comes from the same source.ST Oct 23, 1884 The difference is not in natural life but in redemption, for the way of salvation was devised for man while beasts remain irrevocably attached to the sin-cursed world to be destroyed with it, and humans have the hope of resurrection but beasts do not.ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jan 28, 1903 Only men who believe and obey the Gospel escape the common natural fate, while those who live without regard to the future and choose to be as natural brute beasts deny the Lord that bought them and take the consequence of destruction with the beasts.ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jan 28, 1903 Those so perishing face the second death, when their existence will end forever like that of beasts that perish, whereas beasts die but once and the sinner dies the second death.ST Oct 23, 1884 A well-grounded hope in the resurrection therefore calls for seeking what is above.ST Oct 23, 1884
In respect to mortal life wealth or honor cannot exempt a person from this death, and human life and pursuits apart from God are vain and ultimately useless.RH Jan 31, 1865ST Sep 15, 1909 All creatures depend on God for life, and the question is raised whether the cause of creatures' death is also true of humans.RH Jan 6, 1903 Without the promise of Christ's return, people would have no hope beyond that shared death and common oblivion.RH Jan 5, 1911 That hopeless end is feared as dying like an animal and never living again.ST Sep 17, 1912 The same comparison has been echoed to deny resurrection and a life to come and to urge eating, drinking, and present life, while the promise of His coming gives hope of eternal consciousness in God's kingdom.ST Sep 11, 1893RH Jan 5, 1911
Sources