Psalms 146:4
His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
Translations
His breath goes forth, he returns to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
King James Version, Webster Bible, Revised Version
His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his thoughts perish.
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, American Standard Version
His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth;
In that very day his thoughts perish.His spirit goeth forth, he returneth to his earth, In that day have his thoughts perished.
His breath goeth forth, he returneth to his earth; in that very day his purposes perish.
His spirit, goeth forth, he returneth to his ground, In that very day, his thoughts perish.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
When his spirit departs, he returns to the ground;
on that very day his plans perish.His spirit departs, and he returns to the earth.
In that very day, his thoughts perish.Man's breath goes out, he is turned back again to dust; in that day all his purposes come to an end.
His breath departeth, and he returneth to his earth: then his thoughtes perish.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
His spirit shall go forth, and he shall return into his earth: in that day all their thoughts shall perish.
Pictures

Cross-references 20 of 69
- Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
Both describe the dead as knowing nothing.
- Psalms 115:17
The dead praise not the LORD, neither any that go down into silence.
The dead go down into silence and do not praise the Lord.
- Ecclesiastes 9:10
Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.
Both describe the dead as having no knowledge or activity in the grave.
- Psalms 6:5
For in death there is no remembrance of thee: in the grave who shall give thee thanks?
Both describe death as a state without conscious remembrance of God.
- Job 14:21
His sons come to honour, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them.
The dead do not know what happens to their children.
- Job 14:12
So man lieth down, and riseth not: till the heavens be no more, they shall not awake, nor be raised out of their sleep.
The dead sleep and do not awake until the appointed resurrection.
- Isaiah 38:18-19
For the grave cannot praise thee, death can not celebrate thee: they that go down into the pit cannot hope for thy truth.
Contrasts the dead, who cannot praise God, with the living who praise him.
- Genesis 2:7
And the LORD God formed man of the dust of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.
Creation joins dust and God-given breath to make a living being; death reverses this process.
- Ecclesiastes 9:6
Also their love, and their hatred, and their envy, is now perished; neither have they any more a portion for ever in any thing that is done under the sun.
The dead’s thoughts and emotions have perished, and they no longer share in earthly affairs.
- Ecclesiastes 12:7
Then shall the dust return to the earth as it was: and the spirit shall return unto God who gave it.
Both describe the body returning to earth and the spirit returning to God at death.
- Acts 2:34
For David is not ascended into the heavens: but he saith himself, The LORD said unto my Lord, Sit thou on my right hand,
Peter says David is dead and buried, and has not ascended to heaven.
- Genesis 3:19
In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.
Both describe death as the person returning to the earth and dust.
- Ecclesiastes 3:19-20
For that which befalleth the sons of men befalleth beasts; even one thing befalleth them: as the one dieth, so dieth the other; yea, they have all one breath; so that a man hath no preeminence above a beast: for all is vanity.
Humans and animals share one breath, die, and return to dust.
- 1 Corinthians 15:18
Then they also which are fallen asleep in Christ are perished.
Without resurrection, those who died in Christ have perished.
- John 5:28-29
Marvel not at this: for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice,
The dead remain in their graves until Christ calls them forth at the resurrection.
- Psalms 88:10-12
Wilt thou shew wonders to the dead? shall the dead arise and praise thee? Selah.
Describes the grave as a place where the dead do not act or praise.
- 1 Timothy 6:16
Who only hath immortality, dwelling in the light which no man can approach unto; whom no man hath seen, nor can see: to whom be honour and power everlasting. Amen.
God alone possesses immortality, while human thoughts perish at death.
- Job 17:13-16
If I wait, the grave is mine house: I have made my bed in the darkness.
Describes the grave as darkness, corruption, and rest in the dust.
- Acts 2:29
Men and brethren, let me freely speak unto you of the patriarch David, that he is both dead and buried, and his sepulchre is with us unto this day.
Peter says David is dead and buried, not ascended to heaven.
- Daniel 12:2
And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.
The dead sleep in the dust until they awake.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
19 sources
At death a person's breath goes forth, he returns to his earth, and in that very day his thoughts perish.FE 222.24SP 364.3–365.2GC 545.2–546.1 The dead are unconscious and know nothing, having no thought or part in anything done under the sun, but sleep and rest in the grave until the resurrection instead of receiving reward or punishment at once.4SP 364.3–365.2GC 545.2–546.1GC88 545.2–547.1ST Apr 16, 18854SP 369.1 For the righteous that sleep passes as a moment, and when God raises them their thoughts resume where they stopped as they awake to immortality.ST Apr 16, 18854SP 369.1 All claimed communion with the dead is therefore impossible and pretended, and this truth closes the door against turning to familiar spirits and wizards.PP 685.3RH Sep 11, 1916ST Dec 8, 1909 Princes and sons of men are themselves mortal with breath in their nostrils and cannot save, so they are an unreliable basis for dependence.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–11 Happiness belongs to the one whose help and hope are in the Lord, the God of Jacob who made heaven and earth and reigns forever, so every plan must be taken to Him for counsel and wisdom in trust, with no man standing as a god to another.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–1118MR 226.1–2Ms 101, 1906, par. 45
Death Ends Conscious Thought
When a person dies his breath goes forth, he returns to his earth, and in that very day his thoughts perish.FE 222.24SP 364.3–365.2GC 545.2–546.1GC88 545.2–547.1PP 685.3 Mortal life ends when the breath leaves the body, the body returns to the earth, and consciousness and knowledge do not continue after death.FE 222.24SP 364.3–365.2GC 545.2–546.1GC88 545.2–547.1STE 186.3 Human beings therefore cannot be trusted as a lasting source of help or hope, and happiness belongs to those who trust in the Lord.FE 222.2STE 186.3
The dead are unconscious and know nothing, with no awareness of what happens among the living on earth.4SP 364.3–365.2GC 545.2–546.1GC88 545.2–547.1PP 685.3ST Apr 16, 1885 They have no consciousness of earthly events and no part in anything done under the sun, including the joys or sorrows of those they loved.GC 545.2–546.1PP 685.3GC88 556.1RH Sep 11, 1916ST Dec 8, 1909 They are not engaged in thought, praise, or other activity.GC 545.2–546.1GC88 545.2–547.1 In the grave a person has no power to think and choose good or evil, and can choose neither good nor evil.COL 269.3Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36
The dead sleep and rest in the grave until the resurrection, rather than receiving reward or punishment immediately at death.GC88 545.2–547.1ST Apr 16, 18854SP 369.1GC 549.3 The righteous do not receive their reward at death but rest unconscious, knowing nothing of what is done on earth.ST Apr 16, 18854SP 369.1 For the righteous the time in death passes like a moment.4SP 369.1 When God raises them and wakens them at His call, their thoughts resume where they stopped as they awaken to immortality, with the first glad thought turning to victory over death.ST Apr 16, 18854SP 369.1
Character formed in lifetime remains fixed, so when God's voice wakens the dead he comes from the grave with the same appetites, passions, likes and dislikes he cherished while living.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36 A great gulf is fixed between him and the righteous, because God works no miracle to re-create one who would not be re-created when every opportunity and facility was given him.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36 All claimed communion with the dead is pretended and impossible, contradicting the claim that the dead can communicate with the living.PP 685.3RH Sep 11, 1916ST Dec 8, 1909 This truth was given to close the door effectually against necromancy by expressly forbidding engaging in it in any manner, forbidding turning to familiar spirits and wizards, with warning that He would set His face against anyone who does so and cut him off from among His people.PP 685.3
Trust God, Not Mortals
Princes and the sons of men are mortal, with breath in the nostrils, and when that breath goes forth they return to their earth and in that very day their thoughts perish.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–1118MR 226.1–2STE 186.3 They cannot save a soul nor give the lasting help that the Lord God of Israel gives, so they are an unreliable and changeable basis for dependence.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–11STE 186.3Ms 101, 1906, par. 45 Trust is therefore not to be put in man, for there is no help in princes nor in the son of man.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–11STE 186.3Ms 101, 1906, par. 45
Happiness belongs to the one whose help and hope are in the Lord, the God of Jacob, who is a sure help in contrast to human rulers who cannot be trusted as a lasting source of help.FE 222.2Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 51, 1893, par. 9–11STE 186.3 He is the one who made heaven and earth, who keeps truth forever, who executes judgment for the oppressed and gives food to the hungry.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11 He looses the prisoners, opens the eyes of the blind, raises up those who are bowed down, and loves the righteous.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11 He preserves the strangers and relieves the fatherless and the widow, but turns the way of the wicked upside down, and He reigns forever.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11
Men are therefore to act under God's supervision and accept His standard of holiness and justice, which keeps them from unprincipled actions.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–1118MR 226.1–2 All decisions and plans are to be taken to Him for approval and counsel, submitting to His supervision and standard rather than relying on mortal human beings.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–1118MR 226.1–2 No man is to stand as a god to another, and people must never look to fellow men to know duty.Ms 101, 1906, par. 45 Instead they must go to the Lord for counsel, pray to Him for wisdom with heart and mind and soul, and trust that He will graciously help in extremity.Ms 51, 1895, par. 10–11Ms 101, 1906, par. 45
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
161 sources
His breath leaves him and he returns to dust, and in that very day thinking itself ceases, for thoughts mean reasoning and the operations of the mind and perish means the power to think is lost and destroyed.RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 19, 1864ST Sep 25, 1893 The whole intelligent person dies and is unmade, not merely the body, and lies unconscious knowing nothing, without active thought, feeling, praise or part in what is done among the living.ST Feb 28, 1911ST Jun 1, 1915ST May 2, 1878ST Jun 26, 1884RH Oct 31, 1865 The breath is the life-principle God gave to make dust a living thinking being, and at death it returns to God who gave it under His keeping to be restored in the resurrection, not as a separate conscious being that continues to think.ST Sep 25, 1893RH Oct 2, 1855RH Apr 29, 1909ST Oct 23, 1893 Mortal princes and all human helpers are frail and dying, so when their thoughts and plans fail that same day they can no longer protect or save, and trust belongs in God alone who made all things and keeps truth forever.RH Feb 11, 1915RH Nov 21, 1907ST Feb 13, 1893ST Dec 19, 1892ST May 10, 1905 The dead therefore sleep in silence and darkness without reward, suffering, communication or help from prayers and masses, awaiting being awakened and made conscious again only when Christ calls them at His coming and the resurrection.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Feb 12, 1894ST Sep 15, 1881RH Oct 31, 1865ST Dec 17, 1896
Words and Context
In this verse “thoughts” means thinking itself — the operations of the mind, reasoning, consideration and the power to counsel — not merely purposes or plans.RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jun 26, 1900 Purposes or plans may still be carried out after a person’s death, or may perish while the person is still alive, but thinking ceases in that very day when breath goes out and the person returns to earth.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885ST Oct 2, 1879 To perish is for the power to think to cease and be lost and destroyed, not for past thoughts to be erased and not for thoughts to pass out of the body as continuing conscious thoughts.RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885ST Sep 25, 1893 The mind’s ability to reason and give counsel is gone, the person is left without power of thought, and no conscious intelligent part escapes death.RH Jan 19, 1864ST Nov 5, 1885RH Jan 19, 1864RH Jun 26, 1900ST Oct 2, 1879
“Thoughts” in this broad sense embraces mind, intelligence, plans, memory and affections.RH Sep 26, 1854RH Jul 29, 1875RH Sep 13, 1864RH Aug 12, 1862ST Feb 6, 1907 Thought belongs to the mind, so when thought ends the thinking intelligent person no longer exists as a conscious being, and the mind and spirit share the body’s fate.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Sep 13, 1864RH Aug 12, 1862 Plans and designs end at death and may remain unfulfilled, showing that human life and human purposes are finite and temporary.RH Sep 26, 1854RH Sep 13, 1864ST Feb 6, 1907RH Apr 18, 1871 The dead therefore have no conscious thoughts or intelligence, no mental activity or memory, and have forgotten what they knew.RH Sep 26, 1854ST Feb 6, 1907RH Apr 18, 1871
The breath or spirit that goes forth is the air breathed, the breath of life and life-principle that God gave to make the formed person a living thinking being.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Jan 6, 1904RH Sep 5, 1854ST Oct 18, 1905 It is shared with other living creatures and belongs alike to righteous and unrighteous, belonging to God who gave it.ST Jan 6, 1904RH Sep 5, 1854 At death it leaves, the living union of body and breath is dissolved, and it returns to God who gave it as life kept by Him to be bestowed again.ST Sep 25, 1893ST Jan 6, 1904RH Sep 5, 1854 What returns to God is life, not a separate conscious rational being continuing to think or to enjoy God’s presence.ST Sep 25, 1893ST Jan 6, 1904
Returning to earth means returning to dust, reversing the making of a living person from dust and breath.RH Oct 2, 1855 It is a return to the unconscious condition before life began, when there was no power of thought.ST Nov 5, 1885ST Nov 5, 1885 In that condition there is no ability to praise, and without a resurrection the person would remain there forever.ST Nov 5, 1885ST Nov 5, 1885RH Oct 2, 1855
This dying is mortal life in a world under the curse of sin, where death entered after God’s law was broken and humanity lost access to the tree of life.RH Nov 21, 1865 Brief youth is like a flower that blooms and is cut down, and loved ones who die are mourned as those whose breath has left and whose thoughts have perished that day.RH Nov 21, 1865 Adam’s descendants inherit his mortal nature and undergo death as the penalty for Adamic transgression.RH Oct 31, 1854
The statement is inspired testimony and positive proof about the state of the dead.ST Oct 16, 1884RH Apr 12, 1860 It is a direct factual declaration that when breath goes out and the person returns to earth consciousness ceases, not merely language describing appearances.ST Oct 16, 1884RH Apr 12, 1860
How Death Ends Life
Death undoes the making of a living person from dust and breath, for breath leaves, dust and breath are separated, and the living soul is disorganized, dissolved and unmade so that the living, thinking being ceases to live and think.ST Nov 30, 1882RH Sep 5, 1854ST May 29, 1884ST Oct 28, 1913 The spirit returning to God is the breath of life He gave to make dust alive, not a conscious, intelligent entity surviving apart from the body.RH Sep 5, 1854ST Oct 28, 1913 Thought depends on the living body, so when breath leaves the body and the person returns to earth, mind ceases to act as the body begins to dissolve and that very day thoughts perish.ST Nov 30, 1882ST Apr 23, 1885ST May 29, 1884 Without Jesus and the resurrection this loss would be final, and the person awaits resurrection until life is given again.ST Nov 30, 1882RH Sep 5, 1854
The verse speaks of the person himself, not merely the body, for thoughts belong to mind and spirit as well as body, so mind and spirit share the body's fate.ST Feb 28, 1911ST Jun 1, 1915ST May 2, 1878 The breath from God enables a person to live and think, and when it departs the person no longer lives or thinks, which describes death as the end of conscious, responsible thought.ST Jun 1, 1915RH Jul 28, 1863ST Jul 1, 1889 The whole responsible, intelligent person dies and is unbuilt, ceases to exist and to think consciously, and does not continue as a separate living immaterial person within the body.ST Feb 28, 1911RH Jul 28, 1863RH Feb 10, 1859 Death ends not only the body's functions but also mind and rational powers, and is not a conscious transition into another state nor continued conscious existence in heaven or hell.ST Feb 28, 1911ST May 2, 1878RH Feb 10, 1859ST Jul 1, 1889 Lazarus's return to life illustrates restoration through resurrection, not recall from heaven or Paradise.ST Feb 28, 1911
A person thinks through the brain as the bodily organ of thought, and thought, mind, consciousness, reason, sense and spiritual emotions depend on the living organized body, senses and bodily sustenance.RH Nov 12, 1861ST Oct 7, 1913 When death stops the brain, senses and organs from acting, thought and consciousness stop as well, lie dormant, and do not continue apart from the body.RH Nov 12, 1861ST Jan 18, 1883 The separation of the parts does not leave one part conscious, for their union is necessary for thought, and thinking stops until the resurrection reunites the parts.RH Dec 23, 1862ST Oct 7, 1913 The soul is inactive without the body, like fork tines separated from their handle, since the human organism of soul and body is needed for thought and service to God.RH Dec 23, 1862RH Feb 19, 1867 The dead therefore remain unconscious until they wake in the resurrection, when mind resumes from the person's last thoughts in life, rather than continuing to think as immortal souls.RH Nov 12, 1861
Death is complete cessation and extinction of vital processes, life, being and conscious mental activity, a state of silence, inactivity and complete unconsciousness and the absence of life.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Nov 24, 1874ST Dec 9, 1913 Thinking is evidence of life, so its cessation shows the dead are not conscious.ST Dec 9, 1913ST Feb 10, 1887 Death is real rather than a state in which the person remains conscious and cannot die, and it does not intensify or accelerate thought but ends conscious mental activity until the resurrection.ST Feb 10, 1887ST Sep 21, 1876 It is not merely separation from God, nor everlasting life in torment, endless remorse, or transition into greater activity and knowledge, and without a resurrection it would be an eternal sleep.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Nov 18, 1903ST Sep 21, 1876 The verse therefore supports the teaching that the sinner ultimately perishes through cessation of life rather than endless life in hell.RH Nov 24, 1874ST Nov 18, 1903
Breath is a temporary, perishable principle of life, the life God gave to animate the body, not a separate conscious entity that returns to God nor an essentially immortal part.ST Nov 1, 1883ST Mar 29, 1905ST Jun 22, 1915 When the body dissolves life returns to its source under God's control, to be bestowed and reunited with the body in the resurrection, in which alone the dead live again.RH Apr 29, 1909ST Mar 29, 1905ST Jun 22, 1915 Human beings do not possess natural or inherent immortality in themselves, for immortality belongs to God and distinguishes Him from humanity.ST Oct 23, 1893ST Nov 3, 1909ST Mar 29, 1905 A person cannot remain consciously alive without the elements that compose him, and death is the departure of life, not continued conscious existence in another condition.RH Apr 29, 1909ST Nov 1, 1883 Without the resurrection death would be an eternal sleep of oblivion, but future life comes when immortality is bestowed and life returns to the person's form and all who have died must awake to life through it.RH Apr 29, 1909ST Oct 23, 1893ST Nov 3, 1909
Unconscious Sleep Until Resurrection
When breath goes out the person returns to earth, and in that very day thoughts perish, so the dead are unconscious and know nothing, with no active conscious thought, awareness, or mental activity and no power of mind exercised, like those asleep.ST Jun 26, 1884RH Oct 31, 1865ST Dec 17, 1896RH Feb 24, 1859ST Apr 23, 1885 Thought is not made clearer or more active by death, and the dead are not aware of events in the world.ST Jun 26, 1884 Thought depends on the living body, so when breath leaves the mind ceases to act as the body begins to dissolve.ST Apr 23, 1885 Death is therefore not a continued life of happiness or misery, and the dead cannot praise or glorify their Maker but await the resurrection.ST Dec 17, 1896 For the same reason the dead have no knowledge with which to communicate through spirits claiming to be them.RH Feb 24, 1859
Death is a dreamless, silent sleep of inactivity and darkness, without work, wisdom, experiences to remember, awareness of time, distress, waiting, or gloom.RH Aug 27, 1872ST Feb 21, 1878ST Feb 15, 1899RH Aug 22, 1912RH May 16, 1907 The dead remain in the grave and in sheol, in the land of forgetfulness, in rest undisturbed by cares until called and awakened.RH Aug 27, 1872ST Feb 21, 1878 They are entirely unconscious, silent, and inactive while they remain in the grave, awaiting resurrection.ST Feb 21, 1878 They are unaware of what is happening anywhere and remain in the grave until the Son of God calls them from death.ST Feb 15, 1899 The interval passes as a moment or unmeasured blank, with no knowledge or conscious activity in sheol.RH Aug 27, 1872
This unconscious condition is the common lot of all mankind who die, righteous and wicked alike.ST Aug 27, 1894RH Oct 8, 1857ST Aug 2, 1910RH Jan 7, 1902 The breath, or spirit, that returns to God belongs to both the righteous and the unrighteous, so the condition is not limited to one group.ST Aug 27, 1894 It applies to all who die, including Paul, until the resurrection, with no continued thinking or remembering.RH Oct 8, 1857 Lazarus and the rich man therefore are not consciously thinking while dead.ST Aug 2, 1910
The dead remain unconscious, silent, inactive and asleep without knowledge unless and until raised, and they need a resurrection to live again.RH Oct 31, 1865ST Dec 17, 1896RH Mar 16, 1916ST Oct 28, 1875RH Apr 16, 1901 They know nothing until the last trumpet.ST Aug 27, 1894 They remain asleep in the dust until God awakens them at Christ's coming with His voice and the trumpet on the great resurrection day, the last day.RH Oct 31, 1865ST Aug 27, 1894RH Mar 16, 1916 Their hope is in being raised from the sleep of death and in being awakened.ST Dec 17, 1896RH May 16, 1907 They remain in that state until their reward comes.RH Apr 16, 1901
Loss of thought at death is illustrated by a living man who lost all thought and awareness, showing that complete death brings the same insensibility with no continuance of thought and awareness after death.RH Feb 4, 1858 During eighteen days of unconsciousness after a severe injury there was no awareness or thought, illustrating that the dead do not continue to think and that immortality is not possessed apart from Christ.RH Aug 19, 1858 A captain's fifteen months of unconsciousness illustrates how thought and awareness cease when the brain is not functioning rather than continuing in a higher sphere of life.RH Feb 5, 1861 Death ends not only the body's functions but also the mind and rational powers, so that the person, not merely the body, is dead.ST Feb 28, 1911 Lazarus's return to life illustrates that the dead are restored through resurrection, not by being recalled from heaven or Paradise.ST Feb 28, 1911
The Dead Know Nothing
The dead possess no conscious knowledge, thought, wisdom, activity or feeling, for when breath leaves and the body returns to earth the person's thoughts perish that same day.RH Feb 4, 1858RH Mar 27, 1856ST Nov 18, 1886RH Oct 3, 1871CO 95.3 Thought and awareness do not continue apart from the body, and the dead do not live on consciously in heaven but lie in silence and inactivity.RH Mar 27, 1856ST Nov 18, 1886RH Oct 3, 1871CO 95.3ST Sep 11, 1884 They are not clearer or more active in thought after death, and the loss of vitality in the brain marks the end of conscious thought.ST Jun 26, 1884ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 30, 1882 Death is the opposite and cessation of conscious life, an unconscious sleep without awareness or activity.ST Nov 18, 1886CO 95.3ST Sep 11, 1884
The dead do not know, work, remember, love, hate, envy, listen, carry on plans, retain knowledge and wisdom, or offer praise.ST Apr 16, 1912ST Jul 29, 1875ST Sep 19, 1911ST Aug 18, 1881RH Jan 5, 1860 In harmony with Ecclesiastes, there is no work, planning, knowledge or wisdom in sheol, the grave.ST Apr 16, 1912ST Jul 29, 1875ST Aug 18, 1881 Love, hatred, envy, joy and sorrow cease, with no consciousness of truth or error.ST Nov 5, 1885ST Apr 16, 1912RH Jan 5, 1860 Thoughts means thoughts themselves, not merely plans or purposes, so the dead do not continue thinking.ST Nov 5, 1885ST Apr 16, 1912ST Jul 29, 1875
The dead cannot praise, remember, thank, celebrate, or consciously worship and glorify their Maker.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Oct 9, 1884ST Nov 24, 1887ST Mar 6, 1907 Hades and sheol are darkness, silence and forgetfulness without knowledge or instruction.ST Jul 29, 1875ST Sep 19, 1911ST Aug 18, 1881 Praise belongs to the living and lasts only while a person lives, with hope beyond death placed in awakening to see God at the resurrection.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Oct 9, 1884ST Nov 24, 1887ST Dec 2, 1886 The time to turn to God, receive forgiveness and praise Him is therefore while alive.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Dec 2, 1886
The dead have no part in what is done under the sun and know nothing of what happens among the living.ST Jun 26, 1884ST Apr 19, 1877RH Feb 18, 1915ST Feb 24, 1887ST Nov 24, 1887 They do not observe, watch, hear or perceive the living, take no part in earthly affairs, or continue earthly work.ST Jun 26, 1884ST Apr 19, 1877RH Feb 18, 1915ST Feb 24, 1887 They do not know or hear what is said about them, the honor or disgrace of loved ones, what happens to their children, or what happens anywhere between death and the general resurrection.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Feb 18, 1915ST Feb 24, 1887 Thought belongs to the mind, so its end means the thinking, intelligent person no longer exists and denies inherent immortality or conscious life after death.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Feb 18, 1915
Since knowledge is exercised through physical senses and conscious faculties, death leaves no thought or knowledge.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 30, 1882RH Dec 22, 1868 The dead therefore cannot suffer, feel pain, see sorrow, or experience feeling or emotion.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 30, 1882 The interval until resurrection is an unconscious sleep with no awareness of time, gloom or distress.ST Jun 8, 1904ST Mar 30, 1882RH Dec 22, 1868
The dead are not conscious or acting as ministering angels.ST Jul 26, 1883ST Jul 28, 1898ST Dec 10, 1912 There are no disembodied souls suffering in another place.ST Jul 28, 1898ST Dec 10, 1912 The dead are not conscious participants in the affairs of the living, including sacrifices offered for them, and future life depends on relation to the Lord Jesus Christ.ST Jul 26, 1883ST Jul 28, 1898ST Dec 10, 1912
No Help Probation or Reward Yet
No lasting help, power or salvation can be expected from human rulers, princes, powers and all human beings, for they are mortal, frail and dying, and when breath leaves and a person returns to earth plans, thoughts, wisdom and power fail that same day.RH Feb 11, 1915RH Nov 21, 1907ST Feb 13, 1893ST Nov 10, 1909ST Jan 3, 1905 A dead ruler can protect no more than the poorest person, earthly leaders cannot be trusted as lasting help because their hopes and plans end with death, and all human paths humble or royal end in the grave where lasting relief from dangers and oppression cannot be guaranteed.RH Feb 11, 1915RH Nov 21, 1907ST Feb 13, 1893ST Nov 10, 1909RH Jun 26, 1900 The reason people cannot ultimately help those who trust in them is that they are subject to death, when the breath of life leaves, the body returns to the earth, and the mind's power to think and reason ceases.RH Feb 11, 1915RH Nov 21, 1907RH Jun 26, 1900 Human beings therefore cannot be relied on as lasting help and cannot serve as a source of help or a basis for trust, for the dead cannot be a source of help or hope.RH Feb 11, 1915RH Nov 21, 1907ST Jan 3, 1905
Mortal human support with its limited power behind human words stands in contrast to trust in God, whose truth endures, whose word is backed by omnipotent power, who made all things and keeps truth forever, helps the oppressed and needy, and in whom alone life is found.ST Dec 19, 1892ST Oct 20, 1898ST Dec 19, 1892ST Oct 10, 1906RH Apr 22, 1858 Human life and human purposes are finite and temporary, earthly people and their purposes pass away when breath departs and the body returns to earth and plans and thoughts perish that very day, so trust belongs in the Lord rather than in mortal people.ST Dec 19, 1892ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 20, 1898ST Dec 19, 1892ST Oct 10, 1906 The appeal not to trust human rulers underscores that earthly people cannot give lasting help, for when a person's breath leaves the person returns to the earth and that very day his thoughts perish.ST May 10, 1905ST Oct 10, 1906RH Apr 22, 1858
The dead cannot hear prayers or petitions, intercede for the living, or help, heal or save them, for at death breath departs, the body returns to earth, and thoughts cease that same day leaving no knowledge or activity and no part in what happens in the world between death and the general resurrection.ST Nov 28, 1906RH Jan 14, 1915RH Feb 18, 1915RH Oct 28, 1915ST Aug 2, 1910 Trust is not to be placed in Abraham, Mary, saints, angels or any deceased person for salvation, saints who have not been raised from the dead do not receive petitions, and trust in their relics is useless.ST Nov 28, 1906RH Feb 18, 1915RH Oct 28, 1915ST Aug 2, 1910 The dead are unconscious in the grave, not living on elsewhere, know nothing, and their hope of life is in the resurrection.ST Nov 28, 1906RH Jan 14, 1915RH Oct 28, 1915 The dead are not conscious participants in an ongoing state of purification.RH Jan 14, 1915RH Nov 9, 1911
The dead cannot hear a message, accept the Gospel, repent, receive a reward at death, take any action, speak or perform actions as preachers or hearers, for when breath leaves the body and the person returns to earth thoughts perish that same day and the mind lies dormant in the grave until the resurrection.RH Aug 7, 1855ST Mar 6, 1907RH Dec 16, 1862ST May 13, 1903 Therefore the Gospel was preached to people while alive, not while dead, and was not preached to people while they were dead but while they were alive.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Apr 23, 1896 Baptism for the dead has no living respondent because the dead are thoughtless and cannot act as preachers or respond as hearers.ST May 13, 1903 Conscious probation beginning with awareness of right and wrong cannot continue after consciousness ends, a person's record stands closed at death until records are examined and sentence rendered at judgment, and the life lived determines eternal life or total annihilation.RH Dec 16, 1862ST Apr 23, 1896 The dead cannot think or experience a reward because they are incapable of appreciating, receiving, enjoying, or suffering it, and the time to turn to God, receive forgiveness, and praise Him is while one is alive.RH Aug 7, 1855ST Mar 6, 1907
The dead have no experience of reward, happiness, misery or final punishment between death and resurrection, for when breath leaves the body and the person returns to earth thoughts perish that same day and the dead are unconscious in the grave without knowledge.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Feb 12, 1894ST Dec 17, 1896ST May 24, 1883RH May 15, 1866 They do not immediately go to heaven to receive reward, crowns or endless joy, do not live on consciously in heaven, hell, an intermediate waiting state or ongoing purification, are not conscious or continuing their thoughts in heaven, and death is not a continued life of happiness or misery but a waiting for the resurrection.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Feb 12, 1894ST Dec 17, 1896ST May 24, 1883RH May 15, 1866 They do not receive their final punishment at death, do not remember God or praise Him, cannot think or experience a reward being incapable of appreciating it, and are not receiving reward until judgment.ST Feb 12, 1894ST Sep 15, 1881RH Aug 7, 1855 The faithful rest awaiting Christ's coming, awakening and reward at the resurrection and judgment, as David had not ascended to heaven but slept in death expecting to awake at the resurrection of the just.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Sep 15, 1881ST Dec 17, 1896
The dead cannot be relieved of pain or advanced in happiness by prayers or masses, for when breath goes out and they return to earth their thoughts cease and they are not conscious.RH Jan 14, 1915RH Feb 18, 1915RH Nov 9, 1911RH Oct 28, 1915ST Sep 2, 1889 Paying for masses intended to help souls in purgatory does not accomplish that purpose but supports the priests, and the dead cannot be helped into heaven by masses, purgatory or work done for them, being unconscious and unable to be helped into heaven by masses or by a purgatory.RH Jan 14, 1915RH Feb 18, 1915ST Sep 2, 1889 Saints who have not been raised do not receive petitions and cannot hear prayers or intercede for the living.ST Nov 28, 1906RH Feb 18, 1915
Death ends conscious life until the resurrection, when a person dies his thoughts perish and he knows nothing.ST Nov 16, 1876 A person can kill another and shorten his days but cannot prevent rising again or put a final end to life, while God can raise the wicked and then destroy both soul and body, ending life with no redemption.ST Nov 16, 1876
No Messages From the Dead
When breath goes out and a person returns to earth, thoughts perish that very day, leaving the dead unconscious with no conscious knowledge with which to appear or communicate RH Oct 10, 1912ST Jan 17, 1906ST May 27, 1880ST Dec 8, 1909. They cannot communicate with the living, speak or converse with them, return as spirits or ghosts, be called back, or be brought back to speak and act through familiar spirits RH Oct 10, 1912ST Jan 17, 1906ST May 27, 1880ST Jul 17, 1901. Watchfulness and preparation cease at death, and life beyond the grave comes only through Christ with hope resting on the resurrection RH Oct 10, 1912ST Dec 8, 1909ST Jul 17, 1901. This perishing of thought is set against spirit communications offered as evidence that the dead are conscious, rejecting them as proof ST Jan 17, 1906ST Dec 8, 1909.
The dead have no conscious knowledge of earthly affairs and take no part in them, so they cannot observe the living, appear to them, or communicate messages to them RH Aug 28, 1853ST Mar 4, 1886ST Jul 30, 1912ST Dec 5, 1916ST Feb 20, 1893. Claims that they speak through Spiritualism and séances, through spirits claiming to be them, through departed friends and saints, or through manifestations, do not come from the dead themselves RH Aug 28, 1853ST Jul 30, 1912ST Dec 5, 1916ST Feb 20, 1893RH Dec 17, 1908. Such claims do not come from God's angels either, and those raised from the dead had no experiences of conscious existence to report RH Aug 28, 1853ST Mar 4, 1886ST Jul 30, 1912. The verse thus denies that the dead continue living as conscious disembodied beings and rejects the idea that death is merely transition to a conscious higher sphere ST Mar 4, 1886ST Jul 30, 1912ST Dec 5, 1916ST Feb 20, 1893RH Dec 17, 1908.
Apparent messages, spirit communications and spiritistic manifestations are false, lying deceptions carried out by Satan and his angels in the guise of the deceased, identified as deceptive spirits of the devil ST Jan 10, 1900ST Feb 6, 1893ST Mar 11, 1880ST Feb 9, 1915ST Jan 10, 1900. They therefore cannot communicate true information from the spirit world, for the dead are not the spirits communicating with the living ST Jan 10, 1900ST Feb 6, 1893ST Feb 9, 1915ST Jan 10, 1900. This truth guards people against deception by spirits impersonating the dead, including false assurance about what happens to their children ST Jan 10, 1900ST Feb 6, 1893RH Oct 27, 1910. The Bible's denial of natural immortality would settle Spiritualism by ruling out such communication ST Jan 10, 1900ST Mar 11, 1880RH Oct 27, 1910.
Since the dead have no conscious thoughts with which to appear or communicate, Moses could not have appeared alive with Christ at the transfiguration unless specially raised from the dead RH Aug 28, 1853ST Mar 4, 1886ST Jul 30, 1912ST Dec 5, 1916ST Feb 20, 1893. Communication with Samuel at Endor would likewise require his resurrection, for Samuel could not have returned from death to speak with Saul while thoughts had perished RH Aug 28, 1853ST Mar 4, 1886ST Jul 30, 1912RH Dec 17, 1908. The dead are not conscious spirits whom the living can call back, and the same perishing of thought denies continuance as a separate living immaterial person within the body ST Dec 5, 1916ST Feb 20, 1893RH Dec 17, 1908.
The same perishing rules out transmigration of a dead person's soul into an animal to live there ST Jul 22, 1897ST May 26, 1909ST Jun 3, 1913ST Feb 26, 1894ST Jun 20, 1900. It rules out return as ghosts, remaining as aware spirits watching over and caring for the living, and death as continued life in a higher sphere as conscious spirits who can think, feel lonely, gain greater knowledge or communicate ST May 26, 1909ST Jun 3, 1913ST Feb 26, 1894ST Jun 20, 1900ST Apr 14, 1898. The dead do not know what happens among the living, do not observe them, and do not gain greater knowledge but remain in profound, unconscious sleep in the grave until God awakens them at the resurrection on the last day ST Jul 22, 1897ST May 26, 1909ST Jun 3, 1913ST Jun 20, 1900ST Apr 14, 1898.
Mortality Resurrection and Examples
Fallen humanity is mortal and dying, depending entirely on God for any future life, for when breath leaves the body returns to earth and thoughts perish that same day.ST Feb 15, 1899RH Mar 4, 1862RH Apr 2, 1857 Human beings in the present condition do not possess inherent immortality or an essentially immortal part that remains consciously alive after death, and thought belonging to mind shows the thinking intelligent person no longer exists as such.RH Jul 29, 1875RH Nov 7, 1865 The breath or spirit is the life imparted with breath, shared with other living creatures and with righteous and unrighteous alike, not an immortal soul continuing conscious existence, and immortality as an attribute of God alone must be sought and received through Jesus Christ.ST Feb 15, 1899RH Apr 2, 1857RH Nov 7, 1865
The verse is plain declaration rather than inferred conclusion that the dead are unconscious, denying a separate conscious soul living on after the body dies and a separate living immaterial person within the body.RH Sep 13, 1864ST May 23, 1878RH Oct 23, 1860 Thoughts and affections may not undergo physical decay, yet they do not continue after the person who thinks and feels has died, so there is no continuance of existence after death or pre-existence and no support for the claim that the soul is immortal and cannot die.RH Sep 13, 1864ST Nov 24, 1887 Because thought is a function of the brain belonging to the body, there is no conscious existence apart from the body and no immortal life apart from Christ, and immortality is God's gift received by faith by the faithful at Christ's second coming and the resurrection of the just, not possessed apart from Christ.ST May 23, 1878RH Oct 23, 1860
The hope taught is not continued awareness after death but release from death through resurrection by Jesus the Life-giver, in which alone the dead live again.ST Nov 30, 1882RH Aug 7, 1916RH Apr 11, 1912 Death reverses the making of man, dust and breath being separated so the living thinking being ceases to live and think, ending body functions and also mind and rational powers so the person, not merely the body, is dead.ST Feb 28, 1911ST Nov 30, 1882 Without Jesus and the resurrection the loss would be final, human life ending at the grave in eternal sleep of oblivion, but the dead rest awaiting being made alive again when life is restored and the separated parts are reunited, whose union is necessary for thought.ST Nov 30, 1882RH Dec 23, 1862 Then the mind resumes from the person's last thoughts in life, each receiving the outcome fitting character formed in life, and to be alive to God means He will bring them back.
Immortality and conscious life are received at the resurrection of the just, when Christ comes again and the Son of God calls them from death and God restores and gives life again.RH Jun 8, 1869RH Jul 9, 1867ST Feb 15, 1899 Death is a state without conscious thought, not a conscious soul's departure to heaven or hell or to an intermediate waiting state, and there is no future life apart from resurrection.RH Jun 8, 1869RH Jul 9, 1867 The dead do not continue consciously praising God, do not go immediately to heaven or hell, remain asleep in the grave unaware of what is happening anywhere until their reward comes, and the righteous become conscious after the resurrection, not while dead, awakening to see God and to know as they are known.ST Dec 19, 1916RH Apr 16, 1901ST Feb 15, 1899
Death as sleep until resurrection explains how people self-deceived in life can still expect salvation when they rise for judgment rather than having already experienced hell and learned their fate.ST Sep 15, 1881 David had not ascended to heaven but slept in death, remained dead and asleep without remembrance, love, hatred or envy and without conscious praise, looking forward to being satisfied when awaking and to God redeeming him from the grave.RH Jan 5, 1860ST Sep 15, 1881ST Jan 24, 1884RH Feb 14, 1865 He expected to awake at the resurrection of the just.ST Sep 15, 1881
Lazarus illustrates the verse, for while dead he had no experiences to remember, like dreamless sleep in darkness and silence until called back from the tomb, a return to life not a report from conscious existence in heaven or Paradise.ST Feb 28, 1911ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jan 3, 1911 The breath returning to the girl is her life restored by Jesus when breath or life given by God returns to His keeping and thoughts that ceased that day are restored.ST Feb 6, 1896 Solomon's own wisdom ended with his thoughts at death, although the wisdom he had communicated to others survived him.ST Nov 13, 1884
The appearance of Moses long after his death proves he had been raised from the dead, for the dead know nothing and sleep unconsciously in the grave and cannot converse with the living unless raised.ST Oct 29, 1885ST Jan 20, 1887 He appeared at the transfiguration as a man who had died and been raised to life, not as a living soul thinking apart from the body, not as an angel, and not as the spirit of a dead man.ST Jan 20, 1887
Because death ends a person's thoughts and takes the breath and is described as sleep, praise of God belongs to the living and lasts only while a person lives, for the dead cannot praise or glorify their Maker, remember, or know.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Oct 9, 1884ST Dec 2, 1886 The mind lies dormant in the grave until the resurrection and the dead cannot hear or accept the Gospel, so life should be filled with good thoughts and deeds before that sleep comes, and the time to turn to God, receive forgiveness and praise Him is while alive.ST Nov 24, 1887ST Mar 6, 1907
Sources