Galatians 4:21
Tell me, ye that desire to be under the law, do ye not hear the law?
Translations
Tell me, you that desire to be under the law, do you not hear the law?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Tell me, ye that desire to be under the law, do ye not hear the law?
Tell me, ye who are willing to be under law, the law do ye not hear?
Tell me, ye who are desirous of being under law, do ye not listen to the law?
Tell me! ye who, under law, are wishing to be: The law, do ye not hear?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Tell me, you who want to be under the law, do you not understand what the law says?
Tell me, you that desire to be under the law, don’ t you listen to the law?
Say, you whose desire it is to be under the law, do you not give ear to the law?
Tell me, ye that will be vnder the Law, doe ye not heare the Lawe?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Tell me, you that desire to be under the law, have you not read the law?
Cross-references 20 of 67
- Genesis 16:1-4
Now Sarai Abram’s wife bare him no children: and she had an handmaid, an Egyptian, whose name was Hagar.
Hagar bears Abraham’s son through a human arrangement, becoming the bondwoman in Paul’s allegory.
- Genesis 21:1-10
And the LORD visited Sarah as he had said, and the LORD did unto Sarah as he had spoken.
Isaac’s birth and Ishmael’s expulsion illustrate the contrast between the sons and covenants.
- Romans 3:19
Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law: that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God.
The law speaks to those under it and leaves all guilty before God.
- Isaiah 54:1
Sing, O barren, thou that didst not bear; break forth into singing, and cry aloud, thou that didst not travail with child: for more are the children of the desolate than the children of the married wife, saith the LORD.
The barren woman’s promised children illustrate the free Jerusalem’s many children.
- Galatians 5:1
Stand fast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage.
Calls believers to stand in Christ’s liberty rather than return to bondage.
- Hebrews 8:10
For this is the covenant that I will make with the house of Israel after those days, saith the Lord; I will put my laws into their mind, and write them in their hearts: and I will be to them a God, and they shall be to me a people:
God promises to write his law in the hearts of the new-covenant people.
- Romans 6:14
For sin shall not have dominion over you: for ye are not under the law, but under grace.
Both use “under the law” to describe the state contrasted with grace.
- Galatians 5:18
But if ye be led of the Spirit, ye are not under the law.
Both texts use “under the law” for the same condition.
- Galatians 4:4-5
But when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law,
Christ was born under the law to redeem those under it.
- Exodus 19:3-8
And Moses went up unto God, and the LORD called unto him out of the mountain, saying, Thus shalt thou say to the house of Jacob, and tell the children of Israel;
Records the covenant made at Sinai.
- Galatians 3:23
But before faith came, we were kept under the law, shut up unto the faith which should afterwards be revealed.
Both describe being shut up under the law before faith was revealed.
- Romans 8:7
Because the carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be.
The carnal mind is hostile to God and cannot submit to his law.
- Genesis 21:10
Wherefore she said unto Abraham, Cast out this bondwoman and her son: for the son of this bondwoman shall not be heir with my son, even with Isaac.
Hagar and her son are cast out, matching the bondwoman and son in the allegory.
- Genesis 17:19-21
And God said, Sarah thy wife shall bear thee a son indeed; and thou shalt call his name Isaac: and I will establish my covenant with him for an everlasting covenant, and with his seed after him.
God promises Sarah’s son Isaac and establishes the covenant with him.
- 1 Corinthians 9:20
And unto the Jews I became as a Jew, that I might gain the Jews; to them that are under the law, as under the law, that I might gain them that are under the law;
Both texts refer to being under the law.
- Galatians 4:26
But Jerusalem which is above is free, which is the mother of us all.
Describes believers as children of God through faith.
- Genesis 16:15
And Hagar bare Abram a son: and Abram called his son’s name, which Hagar bare, Ishmael.
Hagar’s son Ishmael is the bondwoman’s child in Paul’s illustration.
- Genesis 15:2-6
And Abram said, Lord GOD, what wilt thou give me, seeing I go childless, and the steward of my house is this Eliezer of Damascus?
Abraham first proposes a human heir, then believes God’s promise of offspring.
- Exodus 24:3-8
And Moses came and told the people all the words of the LORD, and all the judgments: and all the people answered with one voice, and said, All the words which the LORD hath said will we do.
covenant ratified with blood
- Galatians 4:30
Nevertheless what saith the scripture? Cast out the bondwoman and her son: for the son of the bondwoman shall not be heir with the son of the freewoman.
Hagar cast out means Sinai set aside
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
1 source
Beginning with this appeal, the passage running through verse 31 sheds clear and convincing light upon the covenants, which every candid and unprejudiced mind receives.Lt 59, 1890, par. 18–19 Its true meaning stands against attempts to make it teach a different position on the covenants.Lt 59, 1890, par. 18–19 Such attempts twist Scripture in the same way Christ's words were twisted, by spying upon Him, misrepeating and misinterpreting what He said, raising false issues, and clouding minds in order to deceive the people.Lt 59, 1890, par. 18–19 Turning away from this plain light comes from fear of being compelled to accept what the teaching on the law in Galatians requires.Lt 59, 1890, par. 18–19 Only truly converted minds are prepared to receive light either to establish or to refute a position taken upon it.Lt 59, 1890, par. 18–19
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
78 sources
Paul's question calls those who want to be under the law to listen to what the law itself says, introducing the history of Abraham's two sons as an allegory of the two covenants.RH Jul 24, 1900RH May 29, 1900RH Jul 3, 1900RH Feb 7, 1854 Hagar the bondwoman stands for the covenant from Mount Sinai that brings children into bondage, while Sarah the freewoman stands for the covenant of promise that brings freedom and corresponds to the Jerusalem above.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Mar 19, 1912ST Nov 21, 1900 To be under the law is to be shut up under its condemnation as a transgressor and to seek justification by works, which is bondage to sin and the flesh that cannot keep the promise.RH Jul 18, 1854ST Nov 21, 1911ST Jan 30, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901 The old covenant rests on human promises and efforts that fail, while the new and everlasting covenant rests on God's promises in Jesus Christ and makes free through faith by His work in the heart.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Mar 1, 1905ST Sep 28, 1915 Those who trust in Jesus are therefore justified by faith as children of the freewoman, freed from condemnation to meet the law's just demands, and called to stand fast in the liberty Christ gives.RH Jul 31, 1900ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 28, 1868ST Jun 17, 1886
Setting and Wording
Paul's letter was addressed to the Christians in Galatia, a comparatively small district of Asia Minor called the Gaul of the East.ST Nov 22, 1910 The church there was founded by Paul in A.D. 52 for a mixture of Christians largely composed of Gauls, who had dwelt in that section from about the third century before Christ and were subjugated by the Romans in B.C. 189, and who, living in a great highway of commerce, had become mixed with Greeks and Romans and to some extent with Hebrews.ST Nov 22, 1910 The phrase under the law renders the Greek hupo nomon, literally under law, meaning under, inferior to, beneath, in subjection to, distinct from en to nomo meaning in or within the law and from ennomos meaning within law.ST Jan 30, 1901
The question is addressed to people who desire to be under the law and asks whether they hear the law, and its full force depends on the Galatians' particular danger, the rest of the chapter, and the two covenants. The churches of Galatia had been troubled by judaizing teachers who did not understand that justification is obtained wholly through Christ without the law.RH Jul 18, 1854 That desire to be under the law does not prove those addressed were Jews or Jewish converts, nor that Judaism was the only error endangering them.RH Jul 18, 1854 On the understanding held by some, the law desired here means the moral law, the ten commandments, of which the epistle treats.RH Jul 18, 1854 In its setting the call for those who want to be under the law to listen to what the law itself teaches introduces an argument about the two covenants, which was applied to the Sabbath question and challenged some Adventists who heard it.RH May 17, 1864
In both halves of the verse the law means the Sinai covenant itself, so those desiring to be under the Sinai covenant are told to hear what the Sinai covenant says.RH Feb 7, 1854 That hearing introduces the allegory of Abraham's two sons as the two covenants.RH Feb 7, 1854
Two Covenants Illustrated
Tell me, you who desire to be under law, do you not hear what the law itself teaches, for the history that follows of Abraham having two sons, one by an enslaved woman and one by a free woman, one born after the flesh and one through promise, is an allegory of the two covenants present already in Abraham's household.RH Jul 24, 1900RH May 29, 1900RH Jul 3, 1900ST Mar 15, 1899ST Apr 11, 1900 The question introduces the appeal to understand the law through this contrast, calling hearers to attend to Scripture's own witness that God's children are born through promise and not by human effort.RH Jul 3, 1900ST Mar 15, 1899ST Apr 11, 1900RH Jun 5, 1900 What the law says is that story of Hagar in Abraham's household, which is the story of the Sinai covenant.RH Jun 5, 1900
Hagar the bondwoman is the covenant from Mount Sinai, called Mount Sinai in Arabia, which genders to bondage and produces children into bondage.ST Nov 21, 1900ST Apr 11, 1900RH Jun 5, 1900 She answers to and corresponds to the Jerusalem that now is of that time, ancient Jerusalem, the earthly Jerusalem, which is in bondage with her children, and stands for the old covenant.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Nov 21, 1900ST Apr 11, 1900 Those under that covenant are represented by Hagar and Ishmael with earthly Jerusalem, in bondage and after the flesh.ST Jun 3, 1886 That Sinai covenant was faulty because it rested primarily on the people's promises to obey, with God's promised blessings conditional on their doing what they had pledged.
Sarah the freewoman is the free covenant of promise and God's order, and she corresponds to the Jerusalem above which is free and is the mother of the free.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Mar 19, 1912ST Nov 21, 1900ST Apr 11, 1900 That mother is the heavenly Jerusalem and New Jerusalem, the mother of the children of promise and of faith, in contrast to earthly Jerusalem and its children in bondage.ST Mar 19, 1912RH Nov 13, 1856 The children of the freewoman are heirs, unlike the children of the bondwoman, and those who are free are represented by Sarah and Isaac with the Jerusalem above.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Apr 11, 1900 Those saved through Jesus Christ by faith are free children of promise like Isaac, and freedom in Christ is better than the apparent power of sin's bondage.ST Mar 19, 1912
Ishmael, born through Hagar by human effort, human schemes and unbelief in God's promise, represents reliance on the flesh and on people's promises and works to gain righteousness and the inheritance.RH Jul 24, 1900ST Jul 29, 1913ST Mar 1, 1905ST Sep 28, 1915RH Jun 12, 1900 Isaac, born through Sarah by God's promise and power, represents the Spirit's work and the children of promise who are free.RH Jul 24, 1900ST Jul 29, 1913ST Mar 1, 1905ST Sep 28, 1915 Descent from Abraham in the flesh does not by itself make someone an heir of the promise, but the children of the promise are counted as Abraham's seed.ST Mar 22, 1899 As Hagar's son was born through human effort and distrust of God's promise, so this covenant represents people relying on their own efforts to gain God's righteousness, a reliance that comes from forsaking God's prior covenant promise confirmed in Christ.RH Jun 12, 1900
The old covenant rests on human promises and efforts to save oneself, and like Abraham's plan to have a child through Hagar it follows the flesh and leads to bondage and failure because human beings cannot produce righteousness by their own strength and lack power to keep their promise.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Mar 1, 1905ST Sep 28, 1915 The new, everlasting covenant rests on God's promises in Jesus Christ and brings freedom through faith in Christ by God's power and work in the heart.RH Jul 24, 1900ST Jul 29, 1913ST Mar 1, 1905ST Sep 28, 1915 The weight of teaching holds that the first or old covenant is not the Ten Commandments themselves but the promise of obedience to God's voice made at Sinai in Exodus 19:5-8 before the people had heard His voice in Exodus 20:2-17, then confirmed after hearing it and ratified with blood upon book and people in Exodus 24:3-8, while the Ten were only heard spoken at the dedication, were not then in written form to be sprinkled, were written by God at least eighty days later and never dedicated with blood, so they were no part of it except as its basis; as a means of salvation this Horeb covenant of mutual national promises resting on human effort made through fear brings bondage and leaves men under condemnation as sinners, while God's law commanded to all is not itself the covenant.RH Jun 26, 1900ST May 21, 1896 Those who held otherwise taught that this Sinai covenant bringing bondage was the Ten Commandments made with Israel at Horeb, and therefore was not in force before it was made.RH Mar 1, 1864
Abraham's attempt to obtain the promised heir through Hagar was a human arrangement made in unbelief, while Isaac came through Sarah according to God's promise and power, so the promised seed and blessing do not come through fleshly schemes.RH Jun 12, 1900ST Apr 11, 1900 God gave Israel at Sinai a full and fair opportunity to try to fulfill all righteousness, thinking themselves able while knowing only birth of flesh and minding flesh, and within forty days they demonstrated utter inability and fell into deeper bondage than ever.ST Oct 22, 1896 That experience was meant to make them willing to be delivered by God from bondage of sin to liberty of righteousness by His own power through His own word in His own promise as Abraham was delivered, to be justified by faith instead of works, children of promise instead of children of flesh, born again of the Spirit, saved by the new and everlasting covenant in which God puts His laws into mind and heart, makes them His people, is merciful to unrighteousness and remembers sins no more, with no if depending on what man does but only on what God does unto all and upon all them that believe.ST Oct 22, 1896
Relying on human effort to secure God's promise produces bondage, while salvation comes by God's grace and power.ST Dec 12, 1906 Hagar represents the old-covenant principle of salvation by works, and her children represent bondage to sin; this principle existed before the covenant was formally made with Israel and continues whenever people try to save themselves by works or enforce human creeds instead of God's living Word.ST Dec 12, 1906 Like Ishmael, those under Sinai rely on the flesh and expect to fulfill God's promise through human effort, but the flesh is hostile to God and cannot submit to His law, so those born only of flesh cannot produce the righteousness required for Abraham's inheritance.RH Jun 19, 1900
The full pattern is bondage and freedom, Mount Sinai and present Jerusalem in bondage, the Jerusalem above free, the children of promise persecuted by those born after the flesh, the command to cast out the bondwoman and her son because her son shall not be heir with the freewoman's son, and the call for believers as children of the free to stand fast in the liberty Christ gives.RH Jul 31, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900 By birth all are in bondage to the principles of the world in enmity against God, and deliverance comes by believing and accepting the Spirit through Christ, putting on Christ and obtaining His freedom; those who believe are children of the freewoman with heavenly Jerusalem above as mother, the city Abraham looked to.ST Dec 19, 1900 The old covenant originates from below, from man, and could only bring bondage, while the new proceeds from above, from God's promise; to obtain freedom the bondwoman and her son must first be cast out, and the bondage to be cast out is bondage to self-effort under the old covenant.ST Dec 19, 1900 There is comfort in the command to cast out, because it removes bondage forever, and the old-covenant principle of self-reliance, self-made righteousness and bondage to sin and works of law must be cast out and repudiated so the new covenant of Christ, God's righteousness and liberty of righteousness by faith can hold its place and show its saving power, since the barren has many more children than she which has a husband.ST Dec 19, 1900RH Jul 31, 1900
Meaning of Under Law
To be under the law is to be in a state of sin and consequently held under its sentence of death and condemnation as a violator, shut up and not at liberty, confined by a law that has no power to pardon, with escape from guilt and coming wrath only through faith in Jesus Christ.ST Jan 30, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901ST Sep 16, 1886 Those who desire this condition do not knowingly desire condemnation or death itself but desire what brings that condition, loving sin and pleasure and the flesh without recognizing that its end is death, and so in loving what brings death they in effect love and choose death and condemnation.ST Jan 30, 1901ST Apr 17, 1901ST Sep 16, 1886ST Mar 15, 1899 The law's message must therefore be heard, because people may knowingly choose this deadly bondage while wrongly thinking their way is right, in love with their bonds.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Mar 15, 1899 Being under the law means being under its condemnation, not merely being within its jurisdiction or having a duty to obey it.ST Feb 20, 1912ST May 31, 1910ST Apr 17, 1901 Those who accept God's pardoning grace are no longer condemned, since grace forgives sin and frees from sin's dominion in order to write God's law in the heart and bring harmony with it, not to permit sin.ST Feb 20, 1912
The phrase is used in a twofold cause-effect sense, first being subject to the law's demands under obligation to obey, and second, resulting from disobedience because men have not obeyed, being under its resultant condemnation as worthy of death, since sin is transgression of the law and death is sin's wages.ST Oct 7, 1930 Christians remain under the law in the first sense of obligation to obey, as Christ Himself was, but are redeemed from under it in the second sense of condemnation.ST Oct 7, 1930 In this light under the law can mean being subject to the law and under obligation to keep it, contrasted with being without law, so its sense depends on context and does not always mean guilty and condemned.RH Mar 4, 1873RH Mar 4, 1873 The Galatians addressed were Gentile believers whose desire was framed by concern with the law and with the Jewish days.RH Mar 4, 1873
Under the law also means subject to the rites and ceremonies of the former law dispensation, the ceremonial system added when God renewed His covenant with Israel at Sinai that pointed to Christ and was taken out of the way at the cross, not exposure to the penalty of the Ten Commandments.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Oct 8, 1857RH Apr 29, 1862RH Oct 28, 1858 The question makes sense on that reading because people would not desire to be under the moral law if that meant condemnation, but they could desire to return to ceremonial practices, especially circumcision, having been deceived into thinking them required and desiring to do what was right.RH Oct 8, 1857 They sought to obey that ceremonial law in order to obtain justification for past transgressions of the Ten Commandments.RH Apr 29, 1862 The law identified with the covenants in the following verses is thus the ceremonial law that governed the old covenant.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Oct 28, 1858
Being under the law describes people who look to the law for justification and are judged by its standard, with the moral law speaking to those under it to expose sin, stop every mouth and make guilty before God, so that to be under the law is to be transgressing the law.RH Jul 18, 1854ST Nov 21, 1911RH Jul 18, 1854 The churches of Galatia had been troubled by judaizing teachers who taught that salvation is in human doing and human works and that man must do something to save himself, not understanding that justification is obtained wholly through Christ without the law.ST Nov 21, 1911RH Jul 18, 1854 The answer is salvation, justification and keeping through faith in Jesus Christ with emphasis upon Christ, saved by faith, justified by faith, kept by faith, with peace for those walking in Christ who is the personified law.ST Nov 21, 1911 That desire to be under the moral law, the ten commandments of which the epistle treats, does not prove those addressed were Jews or Jewish converts, nor that Judaism was the only error endangering them.RH Jul 18, 1854
The desire to be under the law is the desire to be under the Mosaic law, the body written by Moses and placed beside the ark, not the moral law spoken by God, engraved on stone and placed in the ark. That law is the law of commandments contained in ordinances, the law of enmity that was contrary to men and was taken out of the way at the cross, including circumcision. To put oneself under it by keeping it is to return to weak and beggarly elements and to take a yoke that cannot be borne, where the atonement of Christ profits nothing. Keeping the seventh-day Sabbath of the fourth commandment is not being under the law in this sense, because that Sabbath belongs to the holy moral law by which sin is known.
Bondage Freedom and Justification
Galatians 4:21 belongs to the argument that the law condemns sinners and thereby shows their need of the gospel.ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 28, 1868ST Jun 17, 1886 Those who try to justify themselves by their own works are in bondage like Hagar's children, while those who trust in Jesus for justification are children of the free woman.ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 28, 1868 The law's condemnation exposes sin, stops every excuse, and leads sinners to Christ, where they are justified by faith and freed from condemnation.ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 28, 1868ST Jun 17, 1886 That freedom is redemption from under the law in the sense of being freed from its condemnation, and through that faith believers are enabled to meet the law's just demands.ST Jun 19, 1907ST Jun 17, 1886 In Christ they do not return to a yoke of bondage but are free and bear the fruits of the Spirit, which agree with God's holy law.ST Jun 19, 1907RH Jul 28, 1868
The law justly condemns transgressors and leaves them without defense, so it cannot be their ground of salvation.RH Feb 1851 This bondage comes from sin and transgression, not from God's law.RH Feb 1851ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 Freedom in Christ is therefore freedom from sin, not abolition of the law or liberty to violate it.RH Feb 1851ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 Hagar represents present Jerusalem and bondage under the first covenant, while Sarah represents the free Jerusalem above and the children of the new covenant, the mothers of the two families being the two Jerusalems and the two covenants being shown by Abraham's relation to the two women.RH Feb 1851ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 The children of old Jerusalem are Abraham's natural descendants, while the children of Jerusalem above are his children by faith and obedience.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873
To be not under the law but under grace is to be pardoned through faith and repentance.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883 Heirship is under the new covenant, not under the old, giving deliverance from sin and condemnation through the blood of Christ without permission to violate God's law.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 The design of the new covenant is to rescue from the condemnation of the law until God's law is made part of the being, written in mind and heart, and its righteousness fulfilled in the life.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 Old Jerusalem with its sanctuary, ark, and priesthood has passed away, but Jerusalem above remains the mother, and in its sanctuary are the High Priest with His atoning blood and the ark containing the law that the new covenant writes in hearts.ST Mar 6, 1879
Seeking justification by law-keeping in order to earn life is bondage and self-righteousness, while salvation comes through God's promise in Christ received by faith.ST Apr 11, 1900 Obedience does not earn life or salvation; it follows from already having them through Christ. The contrast between bondage under the law and freedom in God does not set freedom against obedience, for the child of the free woman obeys through faith and a regenerated heart.ST Apr 11, 1900 God works within to shape both desire and action, making the believer a new creation in Christ, cherishing and keeping the law and brought into harmony with it by the Spirit.ST Apr 11, 1900
To desire to be under the law is to desire to remain in sin and out of harmony with the law. All who love sin and self hate God, and all who hate God's ways love death; no one knowingly desires condemnation for itself, but desiring what brings that condition always leads to condemnation and being cast out of God's kingdom. Seeking by one's own works to do God's will without God's power and promise and law in the heart cannot keep His law and brings deeper bondage to sin.ST Nov 21, 1900 Seeking another means of justification repudiates Christ and turns people back toward the idolatry from which they were converted, so that being children of the first covenant, being under the law, living after the flesh, and being in bondage describe the same condition of violating God's law and lacking freedom.ST Sep 15, 1909 The law apart from Christ speaks death and cannot give righteousness or inheritance, as its giving at Sinai with thunder, lightning, fire, and earthquake made clear that works of the law bring condemnation rather than righteousness.ST Nov 21, 1900 Righteousness and inheritance come by God's promise, and those who rely on their own works are thereby driven back to God's promise, while the new covenant writes the law in the heart so that those who keep it walk at liberty.ST Nov 21, 1900
Covenant and Law Identity
In what follows the law denotes the ceremonial system and the old covenant rather than the Ten Commandments, with those who sought it looking for justification and remission through ceremonies, sacrifices, priests and earthly Jerusalem in contrast to the freedom of the heavenly Jerusalem and the new covenant through which sinners obtain mercy for breaking the enduring Ten Commandments.RH Apr 29, 1862RHRH Mar 1, 1864 The account of Abraham's two sons is an allegory of two covenants in which Hagar and Ishmael stand for the covenant from Sinai and bondage and Sarah and Isaac for the free promised people and the Jerusalem above, a covenantal contrast distinct from the Ten Commandments which contain no account of Abraham's family and no reference to old Jerusalem and could be kept anywhere.RH Apr 29, 1862RHRH Mar 1, 1864 Bondage there is bondage to sin and carnal ordinances, not to God's moral law, while the law of sacrifices and offerings stands apart as a shadow of good things to come and the commandments remain in force.RHRH Mar 1, 1864RH Dec 1850
Hagar and Sarah are not the law and the gospel but old Jerusalem and Jerusalem above, for the mothers of the two families are the two Jerusalems and the two covenants are shown by Abraham's relations to them.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 The children of old Jerusalem are Abraham's natural descendants, while the children of Jerusalem above are his children by faith and obedience, receiving heirship under the new covenant rather than the old.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 The bondage of old Jerusalem came not from God's law but from sin, and the freedom of the heavenly Jerusalem is not liberty to violate God's law but freedom from sin through pardon by faith and repentance.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873 That new covenant delivers from sin and condemnation through Christ's blood, rescues from condemnation until God's law is made part of the being and its righteousness fulfilled in life, and writes the law in the heart, while old Jerusalem with its sanctuary, ark and priesthood has passed away and in the sanctuary above remain the High Priest with atoning blood and the ark containing the law.ST Mar 6, 1879ST Apr 5, 1883RH Oct 21, 1873
The Sinai covenant gendering to bondage was faulty because it rested primarily on the people's promises, with God's blessings conditional on their doing what they pledged.RH Jun 26, 1900ST May 21, 1896 It was a mutual national covenant of promises whose basis was the Ten Commandments spoken in God's voice, entered through fear when Israel said all the Lord has said will we do, and ratified with blood upon book and people in Exodus 24:3-8 after the promise in Exodus 19:5-8 and the hearing of Exodus 20:2-17.RH Jun 26, 1900ST May 21, 1896 The Ten themselves were only heard spoken when the covenant was dedicated with blood, were not then in Israel's possession in written form to be sprinkled, were written by God on stone and given to Moses in the mount at least eighty days after ratification, and were never dedicated with blood, so they were no part of the first covenant except as its basis to which it related.RH Jun 26, 1900ST May 21, 1896 As a means of salvation that Horeb covenant brings bondage because it rested on human effort and promise and attempted to keep the law from without and failed, leaving Israel under the law condemned as sinners, yet the law itself was not the covenant.ST May 21, 1896
Those who held that the Sinai covenant bringing bondage was the Ten Commandments made with Israel at Horeb concluded therefore it was not in force before it was made with Israel.RH Mar 1, 1864 That use of the passage to argue the Ten Commandments as old covenant were abolished is rejected, since those making it still require nine commandments and thereby leave most of their system with Hagar.RH Sep 10, 1872RH Aug 7, 1860 The verse teaches no abolition of the whole law of God, for what was fulfilled, taken out of the way and nailed to the cross was the ceremonial law of types and shadows pointing to Christ which received its full accomplishment in Him and has no significance this side of the cross, while all ten words remain, including prohibitions of other gods, graven images, vain use of the divine name, killing, adultery, stealing, false witness and coveting, with honor to parents and remembrance of the Sabbath day.RH Jun 17, 1862 To cast out the bondwoman is to cast out the condemned unforgiven condition of promising at Sinai to keep God's law and then coming under its condemnation by breaking it, not to cast out the fourth commandment, for the freewoman is the New Jerusalem and her children are free because they keep the same law with it written on hearts, the old covenant being unable to forgive sins so that without the new no sinner could be saved, and those loving God's law find it a law of liberty.RH Jun 17, 1862
The bondage contrasted with liberty is bondage to sin rather than subjection to the Levitical law, and the redemption in chapter 4 is redemption from the curse of the moral law treated in chapter 3, so liberty in Christ is freedom from sin.RH Jul 25, 1854 Israel's sacrificial teaching originally meant to point to salvation through Christ became a fleshly system and yoke of bondage when people trusted in works of law for righteousness, turning a plan for salvation into a persecuting religion.ST Jun 23, 1914 The allegory teaches two covenants or dispensations, the typical and antitypical systems, and literal Israel and true Israel represented by Jews and Gentiles in two periods of God's work.ST Jan 24, 1900 Paul's reading of Sarah as promise, Jerusalem, gospel and liberty and Hagar as Sinai, law and bondage is an authentic Spirit-given explanation of Scripture's fuller meaning as God's counsel develops, agreeing with Hebrews about the law and covenants.RH Sep 28, 1905RH May 6, 1862
Heirs Persecution and Application
The account sets forth only two covenants, two Jerusalems and two peoples, those born after the flesh who belong to earthly Jerusalem and are in bondage to sin under the law and its curse under sentence to be cast out, and children of promise who belong to Jerusalem above and are free.RH Jan 15, 1901RH Dec 27, 1853 The children of promise are free because they know the truth which makes them free, so that sin does not rule over them, being justified by God on the principle of the new covenant by grace through faith and made heirs to Jerusalem above and to all the promises which belong only to those who believe.RH Jan 15, 1901RH Dec 27, 1853 The curse belonging to those under the law cannot be transferred to the children of promise, nor the promise belonging to believers to those under the law, whether carnal Jew or wicked Gentile, for to give the promises to carnal Jews would rebuild the middle wall of partition between Jew and Gentile which God has thrown down and would make faith void and the promise of none effect.RH Dec 27, 1853
Descent from Abraham in the flesh does not by itself make an heir, for Ishmael was born through Hagar the slave woman while Isaac was born through Sarah by God's promise, and the children of the promise are counted as Abraham's seed.ST Mar 22, 1899 Jerusalem and its children, though descended from Jacob and bearing God's name, can therefore be rejected rather than remain God's people.RH Jan 26, 1860 Believers in Christ as Isaac was are children of promise and children of freedom, brought forth by God's power through faith in Christ resting on God's promises, in contrast to Ishmael representing bondage born of human effort and reliance on own works without power to keep what was promised.ST Sep 28, 1915 Like Isaac they may be persecuted by those who follow human schemes, for as then he born after the flesh persecuted him born after the Spirit even so it is now.ST Sep 28, 1915RH Jul 31, 1900 The law itself presents these two states of bondage and freedom, Mount Sinai and present Jerusalem standing for bondage and Jerusalem above standing for freedom, with deliverance from bondage to the principles of the world which stands in enmity against God coming by believing and accepting the Spirit through Christ, putting on Christ and obtaining His freedom and coming to the heavenly Jerusalem above as mother, the city Abraham looked to.RH Jul 31, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900 To obtain that freedom the bondwoman and her son must be cast out, since the son of the bondwoman shall not be heir with the son of the freewoman, and the bondage to be cast out is bondage to self-effort under the old covenant originating from below, from man, which could only bring bondage, while the new covenant proceeds from above, from God's promise.ST Dec 19, 1900 There is comfort in the command to cast out, because it removes that bondage forever, and the old self-reliant principle of self-made righteousness and bondage to sin and works of law must be cast out and repudiated so the new covenant of Christ and God's righteousness and liberty of righteousness by faith can hold its proper place and show its saving power, leading to the exhortation to stand fast as children of the free in the liberty Christ gives and not be entangled again.RH Jul 31, 1900ST Dec 19, 1900RH Jul 31, 1900
The new-covenant city has many more children than the old-covenant city, as written of the barren, and these children are the redeemed immortal people who give the city its glory like fine clothing.RH Dec 23, 1862 Jerusalem above as mother has Christ her husband who may fittingly be called father because He gives everlasting life, while the children of the bondwoman are not His children and do not receive that life.RH Nov 3, 1863 God's children are born free at the resurrection entering the kingdom with eternal life, connected to the promise of this future birth and not merely to conversion in this life.RH Mar 20, 1856 Isaiah's words Thy Maker is thine husband refer to the New Jerusalem, which is identified as free and mother of all with Christ as everlasting Father and the subjects of the first resurrection as children brought forth by birth at the resurrection of the just, proving the bride in the marriage of the Lamb is the city, the New Jerusalem, not the church itself as bride nor the union of believers with their Lord which has existed since Adam.RH Jan 31, 1871
The rebuke calls those desiring to be under the law to hear what the law itself says, to see that the covenant from Mount Sinai genders to bondage and like Hagar has been cast out, so that desiring to be under that law is out of keeping with the dispensation under which Christians live and presses standing fast in liberty and not being entangled again with the yoke of bondage.RH Feb 4, 1873 It speaks only to transgressors under condemnation, not to keepers of the Sabbath, the Creator's holy rest day containing Christ's rest and pledge of eternal rest.ST Jan 23, 1901 Those who did not desire to be under the law yielded to its holy claims, acknowledged sin, counted themselves dead in Christ and accepted Christ's perfect life of harmony with the law as their own, and by His obedience were made righteous, so that the law under whose condemnation they formerly were now stands as blessed witness of the effectiveness of righteousness by faith, no longer over them but with them and in them because Christ is in them.ST Jan 23, 1901 The charge that keeping the seventh day places people under bondage of the law and makes them fallen from grace conflicts with the claim still requiring a Sabbath to be kept.RH Aug 4, 1853 The contrast between being under a covenant of works and under a covenant of grace is illustrated by ministers and their followers as under a covenant of works versus Anne Hutchinson and her followers as under a covenant of grace.ST May 21, 1912
Sources