Isaiah 1:12
When ye come to appear before me, who hath required this at your hand, to tread my courts?
Translations
When you come to appear before me, who has required this at your hand, to tread my courts?
King James Version, Webster Bible
When ye come to appear before me, who hath required this at your hand, to tread my courts?
When ye come to appear before me,
Who hath required this at your hand, to tread my courts?Revised Version, American Standard Version
When ye come to appear before me, who hath required this at your hand, to trample my courts?
When ye come in to appear before Me, Who hath required this of your hand, To trample My courts?
When ye come to appear before me, who hath required this from your hand — to tread my courts?
When ye enter to see my face, Who hath required this at your hand trampling my courts?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
When you come to appear before Me,
who has required this of you—
this trampling of My courts?When you come to appear before me,
who has required this at your hand, to trample my courts?At whose request do you come before me, making my house unclean with your feet?
When ye come to appeare before me, who required this of your hands to tread in my courts?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
When you came to appear before me, who required these things at your hands, that you should walk in my courts?
Cross-references 20 of 28
- 1 Samuel 15:22
And Samuel said, Hath the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams.
Obedience to God matters more than offering sacrifices.
- Isaiah 1:16-17
Wash you, make you clean; put away the evil of your doings from before mine eyes; cease to do evil;
Turning from evil and practicing justice explains what God requires.
- Micah 6:6-8
Wherewith shall I come before the LORD, and bow myself before the high God? shall I come before him with burnt offerings, with calves of a year old?
Contrasts outward offerings with the justice, mercy, and humility God requires.
- Matthew 15:9
But in vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.
Jesus condemns worship made vain by human teachings replacing God’s commands.
- Jeremiah 7:4
Trust ye not in lying words, saying, The temple of the LORD, The temple of the LORD, The temple of the LORD, are these.
Both reject trust in temple ritual as a substitute for an amended life.
- Psalms 50:8-12
I will not reprove thee for thy sacrifices or thy burnt offerings, to have been continually before me.
God says he does not need offerings, since all creation belongs to him.
- Malachi 1:7-8
Ye offer polluted bread upon mine altar; and ye say, Wherein have we polluted thee? In that ye say, The table of the LORD is contemptible.
Both condemn polluted worship and defective offerings brought before God.
- Psalms 51:16-17
For thou desirest not sacrifice; else would I give it: thou delightest not in burnt offering.
God desires a broken, contrite heart rather than sacrifice alone.
- Isaiah 66:2-3
For all those things hath mine hand made, and all those things have been, saith the LORD: but to this man will I look, even to him that is poor and of a contrite spirit, and trembleth at my word.
God regards the humble who tremble at his word, not worshipers following their own devisings.
- Isaiah 29:13
Wherefore the Lord said, Forasmuch as this people draw near me with their mouth, and with their lips do honour me, but have removed their heart far from me, and their fear toward me is taught by the precept of men:
Both condemn outward worship without sincere devotion.
- Hebrews 10:1-4
For the law having a shadow of good things to come, and not the very image of the things, can never with those sacrifices which they offered year by year continually make the comers thereunto perfect.
Animal offerings cannot take away sin or replace Christ’s atonement.
- Jeremiah 6:20
To what purpose cometh there to me incense from Sheba, and the sweet cane from a far country? your burnt offerings are not acceptable, nor your sacrifices sweet unto me.
Rejects offerings unaccompanied by obedience.
- Psalms 40:6
Sacrifice and offering thou didst not desire; mine ears hast thou opened: burnt offering and sin offering hast thou not required.
God does not ultimately desire burnt and sin offerings.
- Amos 5:21-22
I hate, I despise your feast days, and I will not smell in your solemn assemblies.
God rejects offerings and assemblies detached from justice.
- Jeremiah 7:9-11
Will ye steal, murder, and commit adultery, and swear falsely, and burn incense unto Baal, and walk after other gods whom ye know not;
They used worship as a refuge while continuing in sin.
- Mark 7:7-9
Howbeit in vain do they worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.
Human religious rules and lip service are contrasted with God’s commandments.
- Isaiah 58:5-6
Is it such a fast that I have chosen? a day for a man to afflict his soul? is it to bow down his head as a bulrush, and to spread sackcloth and ashes under him? wilt thou call this a fast, and an acceptable day to the LORD?
It questions fasting that is only an outward display rather than acceptable worship.
- Proverbs 21:27
The sacrifice of the wicked is abomination: how much more, when he bringeth it with a wicked mind?
The wicked person’s sacrifice is abominable and condemned.
- Matthew 7:21-23
Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
Religious profession and works do not secure God's approval without obedience from the heart.
- Malachi 1:13-14
Ye said also, Behold, what a weariness is it! and ye have snuffed at it, saith the LORD of hosts; and ye brought that which was torn, and the lame, and the sick; thus ye brought an offering: should I accept this of your hand? saith the LORD.
Condemns bringing defective offerings to God.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
47 sources
To tread His courts is to come to appear before God in outward temple attendance and worship, which He disowns as something He never commanded or authorized when it is empty service.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915DA 589.1–590.2PK 323.2 It was spoken to apostate Judah and Jerusalem, laden with iniquity with words and deeds against the Lord, whom God calls rulers of Sodom and people of Gomorrah, and it also marks the traders and priests Christ drove from the temple and the leaders and teachers in Christ's day whose hindrances to the kingdom were of their own making.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 God does not require or accept multitude of sacrifices, burnt offerings, vain oblations, incense, new moons, sabbaths, assemblies, solemn meetings, appointed feasts, and many prayers when joined with rebellion, iniquity, and disobedience to His holy law, counting heartless, insincere, hypocritical worship as iniquity, abomination, trouble, and weariness from which He hides His eyes and will not hear.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–213SP 22.1DA 589.1–590.2 Such gifts cannot cover hands full of blood and exploitation, sacrifices without faith, contrition, humility, and repentance cannot win favor as a substitute for obedience, and worship that rejects His law for human authority, as in exalting Sunday in place of the seventh-day Sabbath, affronts Him and aids the enemy's design to break His law.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21ST Oct 20, 19143SP 22.1MH 340.2RH Jun 4, 1901 Instead He calls worshipers to wash, be clean, cease to do evil, and come with genuine repentance and a broken and contrite heart, learning to do well by seeking justice, relieving the oppressed, and caring for the fatherless and widows in a life changed by His power and conformed to His character.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–213SP 22.1DA 589.1–590.2RH Apr 24, 1913ST Mar 28, 1878 Coming to appear before Him brings accountability in the day when judgment sits and books are opened, when He will call each to answer for what was done at his hand, including harsh domineering work in His name, leading others away from obedience to His law, resisting His messengers, and carrying on ambitious enterprises and burdens of human devising that He never appointed.Lt 33, 1900, par. 3–7Ms 57, 1895, par. 1Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6RH Apr 10, 1900Ms 1, 1878, par. 35–37
Words and Ancient Setting
To tread the courts is to come to appear before God in outward temple attendance and worship, keeping up the forms of divine service with sacrifices and offerings while the life remains unchanged.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21PK 323.2RH Apr 24, 1913PK 322.2 Such coming is mere outward observance, an empty treading that is separated from obedience and just conduct and that persists in evil while neglecting the needy and oppressed.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 24, 1913PK 322.2 Its presence in God's courts does not please Him and does not make conduct acceptable, for rebellion shows that worshipful approach without obedience is to no purpose.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37PK 323.2PK 322.2
The question who required this at the hand is God's disowning of that coming, declaring He never commanded or authorized such empty service.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915DA 589.1–590.2ST Mar 28, 1878RH Feb 20, 1900 He did not require attendance in His courts with multiplied sacrifices, burnt offerings, vain oblations, incense, new moons, sabbaths, assemblies, solemn meetings, appointed feasts, and many prayers when joined with sin, hypocrisy, and bloodstained hands.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915ST Mar 28, 1878 Appearing before Him and performing religious rites while continuing in evil and refusing repentance and obedience cannot please Him, and worship He has not commanded, such as exalting a day He did not sanctify, falls under the same rebuke.DA 589.1–590.2ST Mar 28, 1878RH Feb 20, 1900DA 842.2–8
The word was spoken to apostate Judah and Jerusalem, laden with iniquity, whose words and deeds were against the Lord and whose rebellion brought ruin and ripened them for utter destruction.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915PK 323.2ST Mar 28, 1878 They are called rulers of Sodom and people of Gomorrah, claiming to be righteous and to lean upon the Lord and to be numbered among His people while transgressing His holy law and building up Zion with blood and Jerusalem with iniquity.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 The same condition delineates the traders and priests whom Christ drove from the temple courts, whose sacrifices and temple attendance were rejected when joined with rebellion.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37 It applies to the leaders and teachers of the Jewish nation in Christ's day, whose obstacles to the kingdom were of their own making through insincere and hypocritical religion and resistance to conviction.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21
Worship God Rejects
God does not require or accept the treading of His courts by those who claim righteousness while transgressing His holy law, and their multitude of sacrifices, burnt offerings, vain oblations, incense, new moons, sabbaths, assemblies, solemn meetings, appointed feasts, and many prayers with spread hands are to no purpose when joined with rebellion and iniquity.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 He disowns that mere outward coming to His temple and asks who ever commanded such empty service, counting it iniquity, abomination, trouble, and weariness.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 He hates those forms kept up while men claim to lean upon Him and to be numbered among His people yet build up Zion with blood and Jerusalem with iniquity, calling such rulers the rulers of Sodom and the people of Gomorrah.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 Worship attendance and offerings separated from obedience and just conduct are unacceptable while the needy and oppressed are neglected and evil is persisted in, for sin rather than any unwillingness on His part to forgive keeps the transgressor from receiving saving help.PK 323.1RH Apr 24, 1913 His rejection falls on ancient Judah and Jerusalem as apostate, laden with iniquity and ripe for ruin, and the same condition marked the traders and priests driven from the temple courts and the leaders and teachers whose self-made obstacles shut them from the kingdom.Ms 127, 1899, par. 32–37Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–213SP 22.1
Appearing in His courts and multiplying offerings do not please Him while worship is a heartless practice that leaves sin and evil unchanged.3SP 22.1DA 589.1–590.2PK 323.1ST Mar 28, 1878PK 322.2 Religious life that is insincere and hypocritical, resisting conviction and refusing obedience, turns religious rites into a substitute for obedience rather than its expression.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21DA 589.1–590.2ST Mar 28, 1878 He therefore hides His eyes and will not hear, treating such worship as iniquity, abomination, trouble, and weariness.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Apr 1, 1915 Multiplied animal sacrifices cannot win His favor in place of turning from evil, learning to do good, seeking justice, and caring for the oppressed, fatherless, and widows.3SP 22.1ST Mar 28, 1878 The assumption that He required those multiplied offerings is challenged, for true worship calls for repentance and obedience rather than ritual used to cover selfishness or gain.DA 589.1–590.23SP 10.1–2
Worship is unacceptable when the worshiper's hands are full of blood, and religious gifts and conduct bound up with bloodshed and guilt cannot cover exploitation or make worship pleasing.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21ST Oct 20, 1914RH Feb 20, 1900 Profession of devotion joined with disobedience leaves blood on the hands and renders sacrifices, assemblies, and prayers hypocritical.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21RH Feb 20, 1900 Gifts from the liquor traffic are condemned in particular, because wealth drawn from that trade is stained by the harm and bloodshed it causes to others.ST Oct 20, 1914MH 340.2
Sacrifices given to keep Christ's sacrifice in mind become valueless and even abomination when offered without faith, contrition, humility, and repentance.3SP 10.1–2ST Dec 11, 1893ST May 27, 1880 A broken and contrite heart is worth more to Him than many offerings made without sorrow for sin, and religious acts cannot remove guilt while the heart remains unrepentant.3SP 10.1–2ST Dec 11, 1893ST May 27, 1880 Multiplied sacrifices cannot replace obedience, and acknowledgment of sin as transgression of His law with genuine humility is required.ST Mar 28, 18783SP 10.1–2ST May 27, 1880 Outward sanctity that conceals love of sin and selfish gain is therefore rejected, for heartless ritual without humble repentance never pleased Him.3SP 22.1DA 589.1–590.2ST Dec 11, 1893
God does not require worship offered in defiance of His commands or that affronts Him by rejecting His law and substituting human authority for His word.RH Jun 4, 1901Ms 51, 1902, par. 14–1518MR 136.3 That challenge falls on those who zealously promote Sunday in place of the seventh-day Sabbath, exalting a day He did not sanctify and serving the enemy's design to break His law.RH Jun 4, 1901Ms 51, 1902, par. 14–1518MR 136.3 Treating Sunday as holy in honor of the resurrection is not commanded, for the resurrection accounts do not call it the Sabbath, the Lord's day, or a sacred day, nor say it replaces the Sabbath.DA 842.2–8 In the judgment those who oppose His government, reject His creation memorial the Sabbath, and help undermine it by replacing it will face their error and have no excuse for their part in breaking His law.Ms 51, 1902, par. 14–1518MR 136.3
Worship God Requires
Instead of empty treading of the courts, what is required is to wash, to be clean, and to cease to do evil.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–213SP 22.1ST Mar 28, 1878 Sin must be acknowledged as transgression of the law, and coming before God must be with genuine repentance rather than heartless ritual that leaves evil unchanged.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21DA 589.1–590.2ST Mar 28, 1878 Multiplied animal sacrifices cannot win favor as a substitute for obedience, for offerings made without humble repentance are not pleasing.3SP 22.1DA 589.1–590.23SP 10.1–2 Sacrifices appointed to keep Christ's sacrifice in mind become valueless and even abomination when offered without faith, contrition, and humility.DA 589.1–590.23SP 10.1–2ST Dec 11, 1893 A broken and contrite heart is worth more than many offerings.3SP 10.1–2ST Dec 11, 1893
True worship learns to do well, seeks justice, relieves the oppressed, and defends and cares for the fatherless and the widows.3SP 22.1RH Apr 24, 1913ST Mar 28, 1878 Outward attendance and offerings are unacceptable while the needy and oppressed are neglected and evil is persisted in.3SP 22.1RH Apr 24, 1913ST Mar 28, 1878 Outward sanctity that conceals love of sin must give place to devotion marked by zeal for God's glory with judgment, mercy, and faith.3SP 22.1DA 88.1 Lives unchanged by His power do not please Him, however regular the religious forms.DA 589.1–590.2DA 88.1
Religious service cannot excuse a character lacking mercy, goodness, compassion, and love, and such a character is unfit for heaven.DA 88.1Lt 45, 1894, par. 21–24 What is required is a life changed by His power and conformed to His character, not profession that acts unlike His life.DA 88.1Lt 45, 1894, par. 21–24 Even while rebuking hypocritical worship, His hand is still held out to bring Israel to self-denial and sonship if they will turn, wash, be clean, cease evil, and do well.Ms 120, 1899, par. 19–21
Accountability in Judgment
To appear before God is to stand accountable before Him, for in the great day when judgment sits and the books are opened the great Judge calls each person to answer for what was done at his hand.Ms 57, 1895, par. 1Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–65T 626.117MR 177.1 His question who required this disowns work done on human terms and by human methods and plans that violate His principles and that He has condemned, as if He had required it.Ms 57, 1895, par. 117MR 177.1 It is spoken then to those who undertook such unauthorized work, asking who authorized their actions and calling them to account for the harm done to souls.Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6RH Apr 10, 1900 Those who have caused souls to be lost will answer for the blood upon their garments.Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6RH Apr 10, 1900
The same reckoning falls on harsh, bitter, domineering work done in His name by those who think themselves Christians while lacking self-control and Christlike pity.Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6 Such workers thrust with side and shoulder and push the diseased till they are scattered, driving the weak onto Satan's battleground to be tempted and fall, treating others harshly and driving them away from the church.Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6Ms 1, 1878, par. 35–37 No self-appointed leadership authorizes that course, and its harm is answerable to God, who calls its doers to repent and who will make them see they did a work He never required.Ms 41, 1899, par. 5–6Ms 1, 1878, par. 35–37
Appearing in worship does not please Him when the worshiper leads others away from obedience to His law, undermines its commandments, and turns people from them into transgression.5T 626.1Lt 22, 1887, par. 10–11 The great Judge challenges that course and requires answer for the harm done to those led astray and for the blood of lost souls.RH Apr 10, 19005T 626.1Lt 22, 1887, par. 10–11 The question likewise warns those who approach Him while opposing His will by resisting the message and messengers sent to bring light and mercy, blocking that message, rejecting accumulated evidence, and refusing to humble themselves and repent, for they will answer to God for it.15MR 301.4–302.1 Nor does appearing before Him excuse rebellion against His government, and in the judgment those who reject His creation memorial the Sabbath, exalt another day He did not sanctify, and cooperate with the enemy to break and undermine His law will face their error with no excuse for their part.Ms 51, 1902, par. 14–1518MR 136.3
Work God Never Appointed
God asks who required work He never appointed when His people carry on ambitious, never-ending enterprises of their own devising that consume His money without producing results for His cause.Lt 33, 1900, par. 3–7Ms 57, 1895, par. 1Ms 103b, 1899, par. 13 Such work proceeds by human methods and plans He has condemned, instead of by His authority and principles, and in the great day He will call men to account for undertaking it as though He had required it.Ms 57, 1895, par. 117MR 177.1 Elaborate, expensive preparations and theatrical display do not make a meeting faithful or give strength to its message, and workers must examine whether their methods bear divine approval rather than relying on outward appearance.Lt 49, 1902, par. 17–22
He did not require workers to load themselves with a hundred responsibilities beyond what can be carried, and if the burdens crush them it is because they loaded themselves down.Lt 120, 1899, par. 15Ms 6, 1900, par. 16–19 Taking on that ambitious extra line of so-called medical missionary work endangers the general prosperity of the cause, unfits men to do thoroughly their appointed part, and leaves the special solemn testing work for this time nearly put out of work while the living oracles are made little of.Lt 120, 1899, par. 15Lt 232, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 6, 1900, par. 16–19 The chief physician under God is to carry only the responsibility appointed him for suffering humanity, and leaving the special work of standing at the post of duty in the Sanitarium to make it a memorial of truth, in order to dip deeply into slum work to lift up the most degraded, is not gathering with Christ though supposed to be.Lt 232, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 6, 1900, par. 16–19 Such unappointed expansion wears away physical, mental, and spiritual efficiency, binds up money and laborers, and spends much means unnecessarily while the appointed work is left undone.Ms 103b, 1899, par. 13Ms 6, 1900, par. 16–19
He disowns establishments created to absorb funds so largely that His warning message is hindered for want of funds to carry it to the world.Lt 185, 1900, par. 5 He rejects multiplying advantages, buildings, and enterprises in America and Battle Creek where facilities already abound, gathering workers and means from every possible resource and centralizing in selfishness while needy fields stand ready to be worked.Lt 149, 1899, par. 6–8 This includes funding projects such as the Gospel Wagon, which gives a hurtful, unsanctified, unhumble example that spoils young workers and through them spoils others, even when paid for from personal money and done in the name of medical missionary work.Lt 149, 1899, par. 6–8 He requires binding about spreading interests, doing less planning and devising for buildings in favored centers, and sharing abundant facilities and means with needy portions of the vineyard such as Australia, so that medical missionary work does not stand between Him and the work to be established there.Lt 149, 1899, par. 6–8 True, genuine medical missionary work must be carried on in a different mold in connection with the gospel in the last message of mercy to the world, with money from sanitarium funds appropriated properly and wisely instead of being spent on labor He has not told men to do.Lt 185, 1900, par. 5Lt 149, 1899, par. 6–8
Such unappointed work robs His whole vineyard to build up work in one great wicked city such as Chicago, misappropriates means that should have supplied foreign and destitute fields, replenished His treasury, translated books, and supported missionaries, and closes human senses to great need in order to create things of human devising.Lt 33, 1900, par. 3–74MR 429.3–430.1 It leaves His cause all over the world suffering for need and robs workers in new and untried fields of relief, while the Sanitarium ordained to give character to the third angel's message by its impression on the world is turned aside from that purpose.Ms 103b, 1899, par. 13Ms 6, 1900, par. 16–19 God did not require John to establish and support his own ambitious enterprises in Chicago, diverting money and talent from the appointed gospel ministry of preparing a people and proclaiming the third angel's message to work that carries another banner and deprives His cause of support.4MR 429.3–430.1
He asks who required men to take it upon themselves to be conscience for others, to decide what may be brought before His people or what His servants may do.STMW6 44.4Ms 51, 1895, par. 2–3Lt 78, 1896, par. 47 Those who assume this authority obstruct His own work, intrude on others' consciences, restrict religious liberty, and take authority over work He has not assigned them, and He will call them to account.STMW6 44.4Ms 51, 1895, par. 2–3Lt 78, 1896, par. 4718MR 223.2 The responsibility to speak His instructions specially entrusted to Moses was not delegated to them, and they have no authority to control what His servants may do or what His people may hear.Ms 51, 1895, par. 2–318MR 223.2
He will not accept missionary work from a wrong, unconverted, selfish heart still in darkness under temptation and full of sin.Lt 18a, 1891, par. 12 While a person stays in Satan's cave of darkness under the storm of temptation, He asks who can accept such work at that person's hand.Lt 18a, 1891, par. 12 To be fitted to do others good, the person must come out, fall upon the Rock and be broken, die to self, be crucified, and become free from selfishness and sin.Lt 18a, 1891, par. 12
He does not require religious effort that is excessive and harmful, such as overlong sermons that exhaust speakers and hearers, weaken the closing influence and decision, and may lead to impatience and damage the speaker's witness.Ms 1b, 1874, par. 26–28 Ministers should conserve their strength, keep their talks brief and fresh, and use varied methods and personal effort to help people reach a decision, for such overwork is not service He has asked for.Ms 1b, 1874, par. 26–28 He did not require missionaries to take on family responsibilities that add burdens and divert attention from the work He had given them, a choice presented as contrary to His counsel and will.Ms 34, 1885, par. 2–4Ms 34a, 1885, par. 4–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
109 sources
Coming to appear before God and treading His courts means coming to worship in His sanctuary with offerings and prayers, and the question challenges what authority required that worship when it is only empty approach.RH Jul 6, 1916ST Jun 2, 1914RH Jun 10, 1873ST Jun 12, 1884ST Jul 10, 1901 He rejects multiplied sacrifices, feasts, new moons, assemblies and many prayers when worshipers remain in sin and rebellion, disobey His commands and violate His moral law.ST Feb 26, 1894RH Apr 1, 1915ST May 27, 1908ST Aug 4, 1898RH Apr 3, 1900 Even forms He Himself appointed become an abomination that He hates as a weariness when hands are full of blood and hearts lack justice, mercy and truth.ST Mar 28, 1878RH Feb 20, 1900ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jun 27, 1871ST Mar 31, 1881 What He requires instead is to put away evil, learn to do well, turn from wrongdoing in willing obedience, and defend the oppressed and care for the fatherless, the widow, the poor and needy.ST May 27, 1908ST Feb 20, 1907ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jun 27, 1871RH Dec 1, 1868 Keeping the first day of the week as sacred is treading His courts without His requirement, since He never blessed, sanctified, commanded or claimed it, and no uncommanded observance can make amends for disobeying the seventh day He hallowed and commanded.ST Jul 18, 1878RH Feb 6, 1879RH Jun 16, 1874RH Oct 21, 1851ST Mar 31, 1887
Historical Setting and Audience
The utterance belongs to about 760 B.C. and concerns Judah and Jerusalem in the stormy days of Uzziah, Jotham, Ahaz and Hezekiah, kings of Judah.ST May 31, 1910 It stands among Isaiah's distinct prophecies from his period of active public ministry.RH Jul 6, 1916 It is part of the first chapter's showing of the condition of God's people and of God's plea to them to return and receive mercy and cleansing.ST May 31, 1910ST May 31, 1910
The backsliding described in Isaiah's day is a type of last-day apostasy.ST Sep 22, 1909 The times then are like the times of the last days, the sins then are similar to the sins of the last times, and the false prophets then are like the false prophets of the last days, so the warnings needed then are warnings needed now, and the same One mighty to save then is mighty to save now.ST May 31, 1910 The rebuke addresses not only the people of Isaiah's day but those of later times who bear God's name and despise and reject His law.
Israel is confronted when from the sole of the foot to the head there is no soundness, proved by desolated country and burned cities, with spiritual condition like Sodom and Gomorrah.ST May 27, 1908 Its rulers are called rulers of Sodom and its people are called people of Gomorrah.RH Apr 1, 1915 That naming shows that a professing Jewish church after apostatizing from God has become Sodom.RH Feb 20, 1855ST Jun 29, 1876
The warning belonged to the long effort to correct formalism that ended in Jerusalem's overthrow and the Babylonian captivity.RH Jul 8, 1902
Sense of the Question
To come to appear before God and to tread His courts is to come to worship, to enter His sanctuary, to attend services, and to multiply offerings and prayers.RH Jul 6, 1916ST Jun 2, 1914 Such appearing is merely treading His courts and is not what He has required when it amounts to empty approach.RH Jul 6, 1916ST Jun 2, 1914 The question of who has required this at the worshiper's hand challenges the authority for the worship offered, exposes presumption, and demands to know who authorized coming to worship and performing religious duties.RH Jun 10, 1873ST Jun 12, 1884ST Jul 10, 1901 A practice is not binding merely because people call it religious; it is binding only if God has required it.RH Jun 10, 1873RH Oct 24, 1871
Keeping His ordinances, observing His Sabbath, and offering thankful oblations as tokens of gratitude are not abolished.ST May 27, 1908 Forms that God appointed have their proper place, but God abhors them when they replace genuine devotion and obedience to justice, mercy and God.ST May 27, 1908ST Mar 31, 1881 Even divinely appointed worship becomes empty and abhorrent when separated from a faithful heart and life.ST Mar 31, 1881ST Mar 31, 1881 The rejected sabbaths are the seven annual sabbaths of Leviticus 23 and the new moons, not the weekly Sabbath.RH Apr 28, 1874 Their observance had become displeasing because of the sins of the keepers, while God's holy rest-day stands apart and remains to be kept with blessing.RH Apr 28, 1874
The passage of Isaiah 1:2-20 is also taught to condemn neglect of the Sabbath as one of the fatal sins of Israel and to utter Jehovah's condemnation against Israel. Compared with Isaiah 66:1-4 and Hosea 2:11, the prophecy teaches that certain duties once enjoined were later abrogated.ST Apr 14, 1881ST Jun 17, 1886 The question of who authorized the worship being offered applies to false worship and to duties chosen by people rather than required by God.ST Apr 14, 1881ST Jun 17, 1886
Empty Worship Rejected
Worship is empty when people remain in sin and rebellion while appearing before God, entering His courts, and multiplying religious observances, for such coming does not please Him while worshipers refuse to turn from wrongdoing.ST Feb 26, 1894ST Aug 4, 1898RH Apr 3, 1900ST Aug 7, 1893 Appearing in worship is not what He requires when it is joined to disobedience to His commands, violation of His moral law, and injustice toward others, and mere faith expressed through religious service without obedience to the moral law leaves the people disobedient.ST Feb 26, 1894RH Apr 3, 1900RH Dec 15, 1868 Religious profession in that condition is only pretense, and observance is not acceptable simply because people come to worship.RH Apr 3, 1900ST Aug 7, 1893 Although all the forms and ceremonies practiced were divinely appointed, He declares them an abomination that cannot be endured when worshipers lack justice, mercy, truth, and heart service, challenging those who put ritual before the substance of religion.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jun 27, 1871ST Mar 31, 1881 With all ceremonial exactness their hands were full of blood and they were moral lepers, whose defilement could be washed away only by living faith and submission to the promise that though sins are as scarlet they shall be as white as snow, by turning from evil to do good, defend the oppressed, and care for the fatherless and the widow.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jun 27, 1871 Forms that He appointed have their proper place, but He abhors them when they replace genuine devotion and obedience to justice, mercy, and God.ST Mar 31, 1881
Ceremonies have no saving power or virtue in themselves apart from a surrendered life turning from sin, but matter as a test and public sign of such surrender and submission to His word.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jul 25, 1854 They were reminders of sin, not a means of taking sin away or gaining acceptance, and animal sacrifices in themselves are insufficient as atonement, being useful as types pointing to Christ's sacrifice.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jul 25, 1854ST Oct 18, 1883 The oblations were meaningless, and the new moons, Sabbath-keeping, calling of assemblies, multitude of sacrifices, appointed feasts, many prayers, and spread hands He did not want, for His soul hated them as a trouble and weariness because they were full of hypocrisy and selfishness.RH Apr 1, 1915ST May 27, 1908 He will hide His eyes and not hear when worship is joined with sin, and if worshipers remain in that condition of having no soundness from sole of foot to head, like Sodom and Gomorrah proved by desolated country and burned cities, He will not hear them.RH Apr 1, 1915ST May 27, 1908 The people offered sacrifices frequently while sinning against Him, thinking He was to be appeased by sacrifices and not by repentance, and for that reason He would not accept their offerings and their treading of His courts.RH Jun 3, 1873
Outward religious observance brings condemnation rather than approval when the heart and motives are wrong, whether offered in a heartless, self-righteous spirit, pretense, hypocrisy, or hollow mockery.ST Dec 23, 1889RH Sep 23, 1858RH Aug 19, 1858 It is better to throw off the cloak of righteousness than to fill it with evil.ST May 27, 1908 People can multiply prayers and still not be heard, for prayer's quality matters more than its length, and much speaking alone does not make prayer effective.RH Jul 21, 1863 Appearing in His courts does not satisfy Him when joined to idolatry and divided affections, for outward activity with offerings, meetings, and prayers coexisted with deceit and idolatry while the people failed to practice humility, justice, love, and mercy and while faith had waned.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Feb 27, 1901 Sacrifices, offerings, assemblies, and prayers were hypocritical worship while the people continued in evil with blood on their hands, and without faith, contrition, humility, sincere repentance, and acknowledgment of sin as transgression of His law they had lost their meaning and were valueless, even an abomination.ST Mar 28, 1878RH Feb 20, 1900ST Dec 11, 1893ST May 27, 1880 The sacrifices had been given to keep Christ's sacrifice in mind, but He accepts a broken and contrite heart and humble thought, not animal offerings in its place, and calls apostate worshipers to turn from wrongdoing and practice justice, defend the oppressed, and care for the fatherless and widow rather than treat sacrifice as a substitute for obedience.ST Mar 28, 1878ST Dec 11, 1893ST May 27, 1880ST Jan 30, 1896
The sacrifices and services were meant to point to the atoning work of the coming Christ and to teach spiritual truth, but the priests failed to teach the whole law and to point to the Great Sacrifice which the typical offerings betokened, so the people lost sight of what the ceremonies signified.RH Mar 24, 1910RH Jan 12, 1911 Without understanding that purpose and without faith, sanctuary worship without Christ the reality becomes empty ceremony and mere outward organization and tradition, which instead of guarding against sin can serve as an excuse for sin and offend God.RH Jan 12, 1911RH Jul 9, 1901 Ceremonial offerings do not please God in themselves but have value only as object lessons pointing to the true sacrifice for sin, having no virtue or power in themselves, and once Christ the reality came and gave Himself the animal sacrifices and temple services had fulfilled their purpose.ST Sep 16, 1913RH Jul 9, 1901ST Jun 25, 1902 His question exposes the presumption of offering what He did not require and of substituting human traditions and self-chosen duties for His commandments, for obedience to His requirements and willingness to obey are essential, and worship cannot be made acceptable merely by setting apart special days or seasons.RH Dec 1, 1868ST May 9, 1906ST Mar 12, 1896 The people's ceremonial service had become an offense because it was not accompanied by the fruits of righteousness, since they trusted external religious acts instead of turning from sin and abandoning evil to practice justice and mercy.RH Dec 1, 1868ST Jun 25, 1902
What God Requires Instead
The question does not mean that God had cast off His people, but that He was pleading with them to put away evil, learn to do well, and come to Him to have sins washed away though they are as scarlet until they shall be as white as snow.ST May 27, 1908ST Feb 20, 1907 He calls them to turn from evil and from wrongdoing, to do good and practice justice, to defend and free the oppressed and break every yoke, and to care for the fatherless and the widow and for the poor and needy.ST Mar 28, 1878ST May 27, 1908ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jun 27, 1871 Worship attendance and ceremony, with multiplied sacrifices, offerings, and outward religious observance, is not service He accepts when separated from obedience and just conduct and when filled with hypocrisy and selfishness.RH Apr 24, 1913ST May 27, 1908ST Aug 2, 1899 If they remained in that heartless condition without repentance He would not hear them, for religious observance without practical care for others and without judgment, mercy, truth and love for God cannot please Him while worshipers persist in evil.RH Apr 24, 1913ST Mar 28, 1878ST May 27, 1908RH Jun 27, 1871ST Aug 2, 1899
Ceremonies have no saving power in themselves, but they matter as a test and public sign of a life surrendered to God and turning from sin.ST Feb 20, 1907 Willing and cheerful obedience to all He requires, with submission to His sin-condemning word rather than substitution of human traditions and self-chosen practices, is the condition for receiving His blessing.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Dec 1, 1868ST May 9, 1906RH Dec 1, 1868 Prayer and outward observances cannot make up for disobeying God and rejecting His commands, and worship offered alongside disobedience is empty and not required by Him.RH Dec 1, 1868ST May 9, 1906RH Dec 1, 1868
What He requires instead of dead formality is intelligent worship, whose only sacrifice of value is prayerful thanksgiving and praise which glorifies Him, accompanied by justice, truth and purity in the life.RH Mar 24, 1910 No outward organization and tradition can take the place of personal sanctity.RH Mar 24, 1910 He requires loving service from the heart, not slavish obedience, and not service made burdensome bondage by self-will, selfishness, unbelief and lack of love and confidence.RH Mar 26, 1861RH Mar 26, 1861RH Mar 26, 1861 Christ does not demand forced drudgery mistaken for true religion, but spontaneous, peaceful, joyful service of love, and such loving service brings freedom and ease rather than an uphill, unendurable burden.RH Mar 26, 1861RH Mar 26, 1861RH Mar 26, 1861RH Mar 26, 1861
Sabbath Sunday and Worship
Only the day God has made sacred can be desecrated, profaned, dishonored, hallowed, or kept holy, and God has hallowed only the seventh day of the seven.STSTST Jan 30, 1896 To attempt to hallow another day is will worship, worship shaped by human choice rather than God's command, and God answers it by asking who demanded it.STSTST Jan 30, 1896 Only the seventh day, which God sanctified, can be kept holy, and people cannot make a day sacred by their own choice.STST Jan 30, 1896 Worship offered in a way God has not required can be an offense rather than true service.ST
Observing the first day of the week as a sacred day is not something God has required.ST Jul 18, 1878RH Feb 6, 1879RH Jun 16, 1874ST Sep 6, 1899ST Jul 23, 1894 Keeping it as a holy day is treading God's courts without His requirement, putting Sunday-keepers under the question who hath required this at their hands because God never commanded it.RH Feb 6, 1879RH Jun 16, 1874ST Sep 6, 1899 The Sunday sabbath is not the Lord's Sabbath because Scripture does not command it.ST Sep 6, 1899 Requiring the first day of the week as of divine authority and perpetual binding obligation exposes that requirement as without any divine authority or obligation at all, since the Lord has not required it.ST Jul 23, 1894ST Jan 28, 1903
The verse asks what authority requires an act of worship and who required Sunday observance.ST Jun 4, 1874ST Sep 25, 1901ST May 13, 1889ST Jun 13, 1906 Going to church on Sunday to worship obeys no command of God.ST Jun 4, 1874ST Sep 25, 1901 Because Sunday is a human tradition rather than a day required by God, worship devoted to it is called will worship, not honor to Christ or God.ST May 13, 1889ST Jun 13, 1906 Human tradition is an unsafe guide and can make void God's commandments.ST Jun 13, 1906ST May 14, 1902 The question challenges whether God required such an observance when He sanctified the seventh day, and it is applied to the claim of setting up a different sabbath and to the substitution of human customs for divine commands without scriptural authority.ST May 14, 1902
Performing something not required cannot make amends for disobeying a duty God did require.RH Oct 21, 1851ST Mar 31, 1887RH Jun 13, 1854 Stopping work on another day does not make up for working on the seventh day.RH Oct 21, 1851RH Jun 13, 1854 Doing what God does not command is not an added duty but disobedience, just as failing to do what He commands is disobedience, so keeping both days adds a service He has not commanded.ST Mar 31, 1887 No one can fulfill the fourth commandment by giving God one day in seven without regard to the particular day, because God blessed and consecrated the seventh day, claimed it as His own holy day, and commanded it to be kept holy, while He never blessed, sanctified, claimed, or commanded Sunday.RH Oct 14, 1873 To take the seventh day for common use and offer Sunday in its place is an unauthorized substitute, like paying a lawful debt with counterfeit coin while keeping the genuine money, and Sunday as a Sabbath is a counterfeit because only the seventh day bears God's signature.RH Oct 14, 1873
Appointing a new day to commemorate redemption and discarding the Sabbath without divine direction is presumption, and the question of what God required exposes that presumption.RH Jun 2, 1859ST Oct 10, 1895 Setting apart Sunday to commemorate Christ's resurrection has no command in God's word and no indication that God's law has been changed.ST Oct 10, 1895ST Feb 13, 1901 Without an explicit divine institution or law for Sunday observance, it has no stated basis as a required positive duty, while by contrast the seventh-day Sabbath is plainly specified in the commandment and the Sabbath He did require is the Sabbath of the Lord.RH Apr 4, 1865ST Feb 13, 1901 Keeping the first day of the week to commemorate the resurrection cannot be known to please Him because God never told men to do it.RH Aug 4, 1868 Baptism is the appropriate memorial God appointed for the burial and resurrection, so introducing Sunday as another memorial is unauthorized treading that God never required.RH Aug 4, 1868
Replacing God's Sabbath with Sunday honors a human institution instead of obeying the divine commandment, an institution the Scriptures do not approve.ST Oct 2, 1893RH Jun 4, 1901ST Apr 5, 1877 Zealously promoting Sunday in place of the seventh-day Sabbath serves the enemy's design, and God challenges such substitution of human authority for His word.RH Jun 4, 1901ST Dec 9, 1897 Worship offered without His command is not acceptable service, especially when offered in violation of His express law, since Scripture commands the seventh day and gives no command for Sunday observance.ST Apr 5, 1877RH Sep 20, 1864 Replacing the seventh-day Sabbath with another day is an unauthorized change to His command, not obedience, illustrated by Nadab and Abihu's offering of unauthorized fire to show the danger of substituting human choice for God's specific instruction.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Nov 28, 1865 Elevating human institutions above God's appointments is a sign of apostasy for which God will call people to account, and disregarding His commandments puts the transgressor at risk of judgment, though those who act sincerely but ignorantly are treated differently from those who continue after receiving light.ST Apr 5, 1877ST Dec 9, 1897RH Nov 28, 1865
Worship God has not required cannot take the place of obedience to what He has commanded.ST Jan 20, 1904ST Jun 21, 1899ST Sep 14, 1882 A humanly chosen religious observance offered as a substitute for obedience does not meet God's requirement, and offering an unacceptable substitute for what His law commands cannot fulfill duty.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Jun 19, 1856 Keeping a day God never commanded is will-worship and self-righteousness, in contrast to obeying God by keeping the day He commanded.RH Dec 21, 1869 If God has abolished the Sabbath requirement, an observance He no longer wants cannot be offered to Him as a free-will service.ST Jan 20, 1904 No special blessing belongs to the first day of the week unless God has placed it there, and crediting it with His blessings makes an idol of the day, while a sacrifice that departs from His exact command is rejected and the worshiper is answerable for presuming to substitute something else.ST Jun 21, 1899RH Jun 19, 1856
God confronts people who have forsaken His law while continuing religious observances of their own devising, asking who required their inventions at their hands.RH Aug 8, 1912RH Aug 14, 1860 Sacrifices and institutions set up in disobedience are nothing in His sight, and obedience to His requirements is the essential thing.RH Aug 8, 1912 The question will be asked again of those who disobey the Sabbath command while claiming to obey it in spirit by keeping another day, for human institutions substituted for God's institutions cannot have His approval.RH Aug 8, 1912ST Dec 8, 1898 It challenges the claim that worship offered on any self-chosen day is acceptable, whether Saturday, Sunday, Monday, Friday, or any other seventh division of time as equally in accordance with God's law, since neither individuals, the church, nor the apostles have authority to sanctify another day instead.ST Mar 29, 1883ST Dec 8, 1898 Observing a substitute day that God has not blessed or sanctified does not satisfy His command to keep the seventh day holy, and requiring the first day as a Sabbath alongside God's commands treats it as an added human requirement, not a command from God.RH Oct 9, 1860
Human Customs and Daily Life
God disowns religious observances He never commanded, and confronts those who practice them with the question who required them at their hand.ST Mar 26, 1902ST Jun 10, 1908ST Mar 25, 1903 Setting apart a day to commemorate Christ's birth, crucifixion, resurrection, or ascension has no divine requirement behind it, so it cannot be claimed as a divinely appointed memorial.ST Mar 26, 1902ST Jun 10, 1908 Keeping Good Friday and Easter Sunday and abstaining from flesh meats on Good Friday more than on any other day are likewise without scriptural teaching, and men may fast from certain things on certain days but God does not require it.ST Jun 10, 1908ST Jul 22, 1908 The sacredness attached to Lent is wholly imaginary, and all the good a Christian can get from Lent can and should be gotten at all other times as well.ST Mar 25, 1903 Seeking to get in touch with historic Christianity by keeping Lent ignores God's work in the Reformation and goes back to Roman Catholicism.ST Mar 25, 1903
The true memorial of Christ's crucifixion is the Lord's Supper, and the true memorial of His resurrection is the new life begun at baptism that shows the power and righteousness manifest in His resurrection, not yearly events kept on days of the week.ST Jun 10, 1908 The fitting memorial of the resurrection is instead a godly life that shows Christ's power over sin.ST Jul 22, 1908 Introducing an uncommanded practice invites the question who required it, for religious observances rooted in human tradition do not establish true spirituality.ST Mar 12, 1896ST Jul 10, 1901 Worship cannot be made acceptable merely by setting apart special days or seasons.ST Mar 12, 1896
God does not require people to perform religious acts of their own invention such as infant baptism, where sponsors make solemn vows they cannot fulfill.ST Dec 11, 1884 The same question asks whether God required people to act in a way that obstructs worship by refusing legal arrangements for holding a church building, when that refusal lets one person take control of the building and drive the congregation out.RH Dec 6, 1864 Such a refusal is not a sacrifice God required or an honor to Him.RH Dec 6, 1864 Worship buildings should be secured properly with practical responsibility, and carrying out an act of worship in a way that endangers the congregation and the work does not honor God but sacrifices practical responsibility to a blind conscience.RH Apr 26, 1860
God has not required people to presume to act as moral governors in religious matters by imposing their interpretation of His law on others or judging their service to Him, for that authority belongs to God and not to human rulers or reformers.ST Jan 21, 1897 Human authorities have not been required to impose religious duties and judge violations by civil Sabbath laws, but in doing so take a role that belongs to God and will answer to Christ for presuming to act in spiritual matters.RH Jul 14, 1910 Coming before God in worship is unacceptable when the worshiper's gifts and conduct are bound up with bloodshed and guilt, and religious offerings cannot cover exploitation or make such worship pleasing to God.ST Oct 20, 1914 This is so in the liquor traffic, where merely entering God's courts and performing religious duties does not please Him while worshipers are implicated in wrongdoing.ST Oct 20, 1914RH Jul 10, 1913
The church fails its duty when it retains liquor sellers or users in its membership.RH Jul 10, 1913 Refusing to sell wine on Sunday is no acceptable substitute for keeping the Sabbath and refraining from producing and selling fermented wine, for appearing before God in worship cannot make up for disobedience and the Lord does not accept worship offered in place of obedience.RH Oct 5, 1905 God calls people to account for the harm they have done to souls, asking who authorized their actions, and at the judgment those who have caused souls to be lost will answer for the blood upon their garments.RH Apr 10, 1900 God does not require appearing before Him and treading His courts when Israel increases in sin while multiplying altars, increasing prayers, keeping feasts at the new moon, and making high profession. Such outward profession does not bring a nation or a person nearer to God and does not make or break true character, and where widespread dishonesty continues it is a hollow mockery like putting a religious motto on coinage.
Sources