Translations
Then said Jesus to the twelve, Will you also go away?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then said Jesus unto the twelve, Will ye also go away?
Then said Jesus to the twelve, Will ye also go away?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Jesus said therefore unto the twelve, Would ye also go away?
Jesus, therefore, said to the twelve, 'Do ye also wish to go away?'
Jesus therefore said to the twelve, Will ye also go away?
Jesus, therefore, said unto the twelve—Are, ye also, wishing to withdraw?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So Jesus asked the Twelve, “ Do you want to leave too?”
Jesus said therefore to the twelve, “ You don’ t also want to go away, do you?”
So Jesus said to the twelve, Have you a desire to go away?
Then sayde Iesus to the twelue, Will yee also goe away?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Then Jesus said to the twelve: Will you also go away?
Cross-references
- John 6:53-58
Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you.
Jesus’ teaching about eating his flesh and drinking his blood prompts disciples to leave.
- John 6:63
It is the spirit that quickeneth; the flesh profiteth nothing: the words that I speak unto you, they are spirit, and they are life.
Christ’s words are spirit and life, clarifying the spiritual meaning of his teaching.
- John 6:60
Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is an hard saying; who can hear it?
Disciples call Jesus’ teaching hard, setting up his question about whether they will leave.
- John 6:35
And Jesus said unto them, I am the bread of life: he that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth on me shall never thirst.
Jesus identifies himself as the bread of life who satisfies spiritual hunger.
- John 6:51
I am the living bread which came down from heaven: if any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever: and the bread that I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.
Christ gives himself as the living bread from heaven, bringing life to the world.
- John 6:56
He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him.
Jesus’ teaching about abiding in him prompts the disciples’ response.
- John 6:36
But I said unto you, That ye also have seen me, and believe not.
Jesus identifies disciples who see him yet do not believe.
- John 6:71
He spake of Judas Iscariot the son of Simon: for he it was that should betray him, being one of the twelve.
identifies Judas as betrayer
- John 6:26-27
Jesus answered them and said, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Ye seek me, not because ye saw the miracles, but because ye did eat of the loaves, and were filled.
Perishable food contrasts with enduring spiritual bread, explaining why Jesus’ teaching sifted the crowd.
- Exodus 16:14-15
And when the dew that lay was gone up, behold, upon the face of the wilderness there lay a small round thing, as small as the hoar frost on the ground.
Manna in the wilderness provides background for Jesus’ teaching about the bread of life.
- Psalms 78:24
And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.
Manna from heaven provides background for Jesus’ teaching about the bread of life.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
68 sources
After many followers turned back and stopped walking with him because they were offended by his hard teaching that they must eat his flesh and drink his blood to have life in him, he turned sorrowfully to the twelve to ask whether they too would leave him.DA 383.2–384.1ST May 15, 1901Lt 171, 1905, par. 9–10Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–182SP 288.2–289.1 His question puts a personal choice before them and tests whether their faith is genuine when truth is difficult to receive.DA 383.2–384.1Lt 18, 1876, par. 6–7ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18 He does not argue with those who reject him but lets the test reveal their hearts and lets them go.ST May 15, 19012SP 288.2–289.14RED 101.2–102.1 Peter answers for the twelve that they remain because they have nowhere else to go, for he alone has the words of eternal life and is the Christ, the Son of the living God.Ms 106, 1903, par. 49–50Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–236T 156.1Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17RH Sep 18, 1900 To eat and drink means to receive his words into mind and life by believing, obeying, and abiding in him, so when trials tempt believers to leave they must give Peter's answer and hold to him to the end.CH 400.4–401.1Lt 241, 1903, par. 9–10Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7Lt 23, 1890, par. 42–44Lt 17, 1897, par. 1–5
Setting and Wording
Many disciples turned back and no longer walked with him after rejecting his hard teaching and taking offense at it, and then he turned to the Twelve to ask whether they too would leave.DA 383.2–384.1ST May 15, 1901RH Sep 18, 1900Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–9 Their departure followed rejection of his truth and rebuke, and their response to his question stands in contrast to the criticism and disbelief of those who would no longer follow, with Peter answering that they had nowhere else to go because he had the words of eternal life.ST May 15, 1901RH Sep 18, 1900Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–95MR 263.1–2 The falling away came after his declaration that they must eat the flesh of the Son of man and drink his blood to have life in them, to dwell in him and he in them, to live by him, to live forever, and to be raised at the last day, which they called a hard saying.Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27Ms 47, 1886, par. 3–4 They willingly misunderstood because they missed its spiritual meaning, stumbling at what was spoken as a parable in which he represented himself under the similitude of heavenly bread, where eating and drinking means true earnest belief, receiving his word which is spirit and life so that true receivers never hunger and believers never thirst for higher food, and where all truly converted draw spiritual vitality from him as a living branch from the vine.Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7Lt 124, 1896, par. 8–11Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 Those not living by his teachings may misunderstand that spiritual meaning and turn from him when his words challenge them, while his question gave the remaining Twelve the choice to leave as well and made clear that following required receiving truth even when difficult.Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18Lt 124, 1896, par. 8–11
The account belongs with feeding the multitude, walking on the water, and teaching that he is the bread of life, after which some disciples turned away.Lt 13, 1876, par. 1–3 It stands at a turning point when many who had followed for hopes of an earthly kingdom would turn away, as his teaching ruled out worldly rewards and demanded spiritual understanding.DA 383.1 He asked with sorrow and grief, because faith in his name and mission is humanity's only hope.Lt 171, 1905, par. 9–102SP 288.2–289.14RED 101.2–102.1 His question expressed longing for fellowship and sympathy and for people to honor God's gift by believing and praising him, with yearning for his disciples to come into sacred relationship with himself and to understand him.Lt 171, 1905, par. 9–10ST Jul 15, 1897 He did not argue them back or try to prevent or stop those who rejected him, but let the test reveal their choice and let those leaving go.ST May 15, 19012SP 288.2–289.14RED 101.2–102.1DA 393.3–4
Those who left chose religious forms without the spirit of truth, revealing pride and offense at purifying truth.Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23Ms 111, 1898, par. 19–22 His plain presentation exposed questioning, resistance, and apostasy, confronting hearers until truths led them to reveal real feelings and decide for or against him.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13Ms 77, 1906, par. 6–9 The question therefore distinguished steadfast believers from half-hearted followers, since some offended by his teaching stopped identifying publicly with him, and those not wholly with him would oppose him at his trial.Ms 111, 1898, par. 19–22Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13 It brought the choice of the Twelve into view before they could mistake the meaning of the falling away, and the experience strengthened them while those who left did not return.Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23Ms 77, 1906, par. 6–9 The Twelve could not fully understand his words at the time because of moral darkness, but their understanding would become clear after his crucifixion, resurrection, and ascension, when the Holy Spirit would bring his words to remembrance and those words would sustain his followers after he no longer walked with them.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 18974RED 96.1
In the meantime he comforted them with many mansions in his Father's house and his return to receive them to himself, even while foreseeing that every beloved disciple would be severely tested in the hour of temptation.ST Jul 15, 1897 Loyalty among the Twelve did not mean all were faithful, for though he chose the Twelve, one of them is a devil, Judas Iscariot son of Simon, who would betray him.ST Apr 9, 1912Ms 106, 1903, par. 49–50Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27Ms 25, 1897, par. 23–24 The question touched the disciples' hearts except Judas, whose chief concerns were money and greatness, and the experience strengthened the Twelve except Judas.Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23Lt 171, 1905, par. 9–10 Peter's answer affirmed that they remained because he has the words of eternal life and is the Christ, yet the warning about Judas stood alongside that confession.Ms 106, 1903, par. 49–50Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27Ms 25, 1897, par. 23–24
Testing Loyalty by Choice
The question tests the commitment and loyalty of the twelve when the teaching is difficult and offensive, exposing whether their faith is genuine.ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26Ms 151, 1906, par. 16ST Nov 4, 1897 It comes after many turn away because they willingly misunderstand, and it makes clear that following requires receiving the truth even when it is hard.Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26ST Nov 4, 1897 Those who believe do not turn away but desire to remain because Jesus alone has the words of eternal life.ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Ms 151, 1906, par. 16 Their understanding will become clear after crucifixion, resurrection, and ascension, and receiving his words means studying and obeying them until they shape a Christlike character and sustain faith through trial and temptation to eternal life for those faithful to the end.ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17
It puts a personal choice before them to remain with him or go away with the others.DA 383.2–384.1Lt 18, 1876, par. 6–711MR 340.3Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30 The choice is brought into the open before they mistake the meaning of the falling away, confronting them whether they too will leave.DA 383.2–384.1Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–15Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30 Paired with Peter's answer that Christ has the words of eternal life, it serves as a text for appeal that brings serious reflection and tears.Lt 18, 1876, par. 6–7 Choosing what draws the heart from God leaves no appetite for heavenly instruction and no room for wholehearted service, so the call is for spiritual hunger for Christ.11MR 340.3
It distinguishes steadfast believers from half-hearted followers and unbelievers, separating those who believe from those who do not.Ms 111, 1898, par. 19–22Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–9 It sets the answer of the twelve against the criticism, disbelief, murmuring, mocking, insult, and offense of those who will no longer follow.Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–9Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 Some are offended by purifying truth and stop identifying publicly with him, revealing pride and showing that professed faith is tested when soul-purifying truth is presented.Ms 111, 1898, par. 19–22 His plain teaching reveals real feelings for or against him, and those not wholly with him would oppose him at his trial.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13
It confronts them with the need for conversion and a life transformed by receiving and practicing his words, with eating his flesh and drinking his blood as a real spiritual experience.Lt 146, 1900, par. 16–18FE 458.2–459.2 Those displeased by his words may turn away.FE 458.2–459.2 The experience strengthens the faithful who remain, except Judas, while those who leave do not return, having chosen religious forms without the spirit of truth.Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23 It also tests loyalty before he leaves them and prepares the remaining disciples for the trial of seeing others reject him.Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–15
Why Disciples Remain
Peter answered for the twelve that they had nowhere else to go, because Jesus alone has the words of eternal life.Ms 106, 1903, par. 49–50Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–179MR 34.3RH Sep 18, 1900 His question tested their response when His teaching was difficult and offensive, exposing whether they had genuine faith and would remain with Him, and the experience strengthened those who stayed, except Judas, while those who left did not return.Ms 71, 1896, par. 21–23Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26 Receiving His words means studying and obeying them, allowing them to shape a Christlike character and sustain faith through trials and temptation, and those faithful to the truth to the end gain eternal life.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17 Remaining rests on recognizing and believing that He is the Christ, the Son of the living God, the Son of God.6T 156.1RH Sep 18, 1900Ms 37, 1899, par. 1–2Ms 106, 1905, par. 15–26Ms 38, 1897, par. 15–17 Their faith rests on Him as the Christ whose words give eternal life, and without Him as Saviour they would be without hope.2SP 288.2–289.1
The question draws out Peter's confession of Christ's divinity in contrast with those who forsake Him, and draws out the warning that though He chose the twelve one of them is a devil, Judas Iscariot son of Simon who would betray Him.Ms 25, 1897, par. 23–24Ms 34, 1906, par. 22–23 Leaving Jesus would mean turning from His teaching of love and mercy to unbelief and the world's wickedness.2SP 288.2–289.1DA 393.5–6ST Jul 15, 1897 It would mean returning to religious teachers bound by formalism, divided by contention, and marked by self-seeking, to the formalists, scribes and Pharisees, the tradition of the elders, and lifeless formalism that teaches for doctrine the commandments of men.2SP 288.2–289.1DA 393.5–6ST Jul 15, 1897 To believe in Him is more than mere sentiment, it is living faith in a personal Saviour who can and will ransom from sin.ST Jul 15, 1897
The disciples had found greater peace and joy with Christ than before, knew Him as the Messiah and the anchor of their souls, and feared losing Him.2SP 288.2–289.1DA 393.5–6 Without a Saviour they would be without hope, adrift in fear and superstition like people adrift on a dark, stormy sea.2SP 288.2–289.1DA 393.5–6 Peter's later failure under trial shows that his confession needed to be lived out by seeking Christ's help, surrendering his own will, and revealing Christ's steadfast, self-denying character, by which Christ could have kept him loyal and resisting temptation.ST May 12, 1898
Bread of Life Teaching
John 6 presents Christ as the living bread come down from heaven, whose flesh is given for the life of the world, and whose words are spirit and life.Lt 253, 1904, par. 6–8Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28Lt 95, 1901, par. 18–19 Those who receive him have eternal life and will be raised at the last day, and though they die his life is in them, hidden with him for this life and for eternity.RH Jun 18, 1901Lt 253, 1904, par. 6–8Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28 The whole chapter is most precious and instructive yet only faintly understood, expressing what is needed for salvation and what Jesus is to each person and what advantage comes from eating his words as the great center of life.RH Jun 18, 1901Ms 68, 1897, par. 9Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15 Its teaching addresses heart and will and not understanding alone, calling for obedience to God and warning that receiving his words in faith and obedience leads to eternal life while rejecting truth for deceptive theories brings spiritual danger.Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28
The teaching about eating the flesh of the Son of man and drinking his blood was spoken as a parable in which Christ represents himself under the similitude of heavenly bread.Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 Eating and drinking means true, earnest belief in him and receiving his word, which is spirit and life.Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 All true receivers never hunger, and all who believe never thirst for higher or more satisfying food.Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27
To eat is to take the bread into the mind, to understand and practice it, to keep its precepts and make Christ's words part of daily life.CH 400.4–401.1Lt 241, 1903, par. 9–10Ms 63, 1890, par. 5–7 It is to hold to its precepts, bring its truths into daily experience, and receive and assimilate his words until they become part of the whole life.CH 400.4–401.1Lt 241, 1903, par. 9–10Ms 63, 1890, par. 5–7 All who are truly converted draw spiritual vitality from Christ in this way, as a living branch draws nourishment from the vine, dwelling in him and he in them, living by him, living forever and raised at the last day.Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7 To comprehend and appreciate the truth as it is in Jesus is to be taught daily in his school, bringing truth into daily experience.Lt 93, 1901, par. 11Ms 68, 1897, par. 19
Eating his flesh and drinking his blood means being doers of God's Word, obeying his Word, having his commandments and keeping them, and so dwelling in him and abiding in his love and staying in harmony with the Redeemer.Ms 25a, 1895, par. 27Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15Ms 47, 1886, par. 3–4 The Bible is to stand as the great educating book above all other books, showing that the way to heaven is by faith in the One whom God sent and then by working the works of God.Ms 25a, 1895, par. 27 The lesson calls for love in return for Calvary, shown by keeping his sayings.Ms 47, 1886, par. 3–4
This eating and drinking also means continual growth in grace, praying to God for this and for all other blessings, being taught daily in the school of Christ, and thereby truly knowing Christ and living as a Christian.Lt 93, 1901, par. 11Ms 68, 1897, par. 19
The sixth chapter refers especially to the spirituality of the Word, so that eating the bread of life means reading the Word of God and appropriating it as the living bread which came down from heaven, an exalted experience open to all yet understood by few.21MR 44.1–2Lt 40, 1899, par. 17–18 The living oracles are the flesh and blood of the Son of God, even though he had not yet been crucified, and his work as substitute for all sin was the only hope of ancient Israel.21MR 44.1–2Lt 40, 1899, par. 17–18 The directions given by Christ as the invisible Leader of Israel in the Old Testament Scriptures are full of richness, marrow and fatness, so that no soul who takes those words and eats them will suffer spiritual hunger.21MR 44.1–2Lt 40, 1899, par. 17–18 After God's plan was fulfilled in the death of Christ, the New Testament was written by holy men moved by the Spirit not to cast aside the Old but to reflect light back upon past ages, give meaning and significance to the whole Jewish economy, and press its plain directions for practical holiness and practical obedience into the life of everyone who claims to be a Christian.21MR 44.1–2Lt 40, 1899, par. 17–18
Call to Present Faithfulness
The whole sixth chapter, where this question stands, is to be read, studied, prayed over, brought into daily experience and made a part of life, for its instruction is the mystery of godliness.Ms 78, 1902, par. 5–7Lt 57, 1904, par. 6Lt 275, 1903, par. 9–13Ms 42, 1902, par. 6–9 Studied in this way alone it gives the knowledge that enables distinguishing the true from the false in days of peril.Lt 57, 1904, par. 6Lt 275, 1903, par. 9–13 Outward connection with a church does not save, but personal faith in a personal Saviour brings the soul into spiritual union with Christ.16MR 277.1ST Jul 15, 1897 That believing is more than mere sentiment; it is living faith in one who can and will ransom from sin.ST Jul 15, 1897
God's people must walk and work as accountable to God, depending on Him by creation and by redemption for strength, power, wisdom and guidance and not on any human being.Ms 78, 1902, par. 5–7Ms 42, 1902, par. 6–9 They are to make the Word of the living God their guide, look to Jesus Christ alone as the true Light, and receive Him by faith as sanctification, righteousness and exceeding great reward, since depending on human beings brings bondage and spiritual weakness.Ms 78, 1902, par. 5–7 The same chapter defines the righteousness of Christ that must be accepted to have on the wedding garment.Ms 13, 1899, par. 1–2 That garment is the standard of character each must reach to be counted a fit guest at the wedding, which is the marriage of humanity with divinity, and taking a firm stand requires surrendering to God what is already His, refusing to continue in sin or to measure character by human ideas, lest presumption over eternal interests result in loss of the soul.Ms 13, 1899, par. 1–2
The chapter contains the most precious and important lessons for all being educated in schools, giving an education that endures through time and eternity when its wonderful truths are brought into practical life.Ms 68, 1897, par. 9Ms 202, 1898, par. 2 It teaches what Jesus is to each person individually and what advantage comes from eating His words, realizing He Himself is the great center of life, for His words are spirit and life.Ms 68, 1897, par. 9 It is the kind of education children and youth and men and women need in order to become workers together with God, meaning youth must above all be taught the law of Jehovah and the penalty of transgression, and that God accepts the ransom made by the Saviour in behalf of each child and youth who is obedient to the law of Jehovah.Ms 202, 1898, par. 2 Bringing this exchange between Jesus and the twelve into classroom teaching in schools and institutions, recognizing Christ as the only Leader to whom people belong by creation and redemption, allows the Holy Spirit to work on minds and hearts.6T 156.1Ms 37, 1899, par. 1–2
Every worker in Christ's service should comprehend its lessons by understanding it through experience, for the evangelization of the world is Christ's work.Lt 123, 1903, par. 3 Workers must follow His example so they make no mistakes, ask and receive blessing from on high, have His guidance at every step, and move guardedly, because without Him nothing can be done.Lt 123, 1903, par. 3 Receiving Christ's words means studying and obeying them, allowing them to shape a Christlike character and sustaining faith through trials and temptation, and those who remain faithful to the truth to the end gain eternal life.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17 The chapter calls for spiritual hunger for Christ, showing that spiritual hunger and the life He gives depend on what a person chooses to receive.11MR 340.3Lt 58a, 1898, par. 17–20
Choosing what draws the heart away from God leaves no appetite for heavenly instruction and no room for wholehearted service.11MR 340.3Lt 58a, 1898, par. 17–20 Feeding the mind on things that draw it from God leaves no appetite for heavenly instruction, the choice is one of life or death, and a divided heart cannot serve God or enjoy spiritual peace, joy and hope.Lt 58a, 1898, par. 17–20 Receiving His words in faith and obedience leads to eternal life, for He is the living bread from heaven whose flesh is given for the life of the world, and His words are spirit and life.Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28 Rejecting the truth for deceptive theories, disregarding light and warning, or taking offense at truth so as to turn from the Master places people in spiritual danger, as some disciples left Jesus.Lt 263, 1903, par. 27–28Lt 43, 1898, par. 6–7
When trying circumstances tempt believers to leave, they must give Peter's answer and refuse to go away, holding to Him because He alone has the words of eternal life.Lt 23, 1890, par. 42–44Lt 17, 1897, par. 1–5 Looking to Jesus as Author and Finisher of faith and fighting lawfully for the immortal crown means refusing to make shipwreck of faith, and the faithful follower will not draw back to ruin but will follow Christ, whom to know truly is eternal life.Lt 23, 1890, par. 42–44Lt 17, 1897, par. 1–5 Christ's word of counsel or reproof recovers His disciples as often as they fall into error and peril, but every neglected counsel places the human agent in distrust and suspicion, and without thorough reform of defects of character and death to self separates farther and farther from righteousness and truth.Ms 25, 1897, par. 23–24 The question calls for love to God in return for Calvary, shown by keeping His sayings, having His commandments and keeping them, and so dwelling in Him, abiding in His love and staying in harmony with the Redeemer.Ms 47, 1886, par. 3–4
Those who urge men to put whole trust in Christ who gave His own life to save souls should not be surprised or complain when men disbelieve, murmur, are offended, insult and mock, as Jesus faced disbelief and falling away when many went back and walked no more with Him.Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 Paired with Peter's answer that He has the words of eternal life, the question presents the choice between turning away and remaining with Christ and serves as a text for appeal that brings serious reflection and tears.Lt 18, 1876, par. 6–7
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
44 sources
After many followers stopped walking with him, offended by his plain teaching about partaking of his flesh and blood, Jesus turned to the twelve to ask whether they too would leave him.ST Oct 29, 1894RH Sep 18, 1900RH Mar 16, 1869RH Dec 16, 1862ST Mar 3, 1914 His question put their choice openly before them without forcing them to stay, and it carried his sorrow and tender longing at the thought of losing those close to him.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Oct 29, 1894RH Mar 16, 1869ST Sep 1, 1881ST Jun 16, 1914 Peter answered for the twelve that there was nowhere else to go, because Jesus alone has the words of eternal life as the Christ, the Son of the living God.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Oct 29, 1894RH Sep 18, 1900RH Mar 31, 1863 Desertion by many does not change the truth, so there is no safe retreat but to abide with him and move forward, even though one of the twelve himself would prove unfaithful and betray him.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Dec 17, 1912ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Aug 26, 1873 The same question still confronts every follower tempted to exchange him for business, wealth, pleasure, or half-heartedness, calling for the answer to remain near him, cleave to him, and serve him faithfully.RH Dec 16, 1862RH Jul 10, 1860ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873
Historical Setting and Context
The question was put to the twelve after many disciples turned back and no longer walked with him, asking whether they too would leave.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Mar 16, 1869RH Dec 16, 1862ST Mar 3, 1914ST Oct 8, 1896 It came at a moment of difficult teachings, discouragement and danger, when the outlook for his cause appeared gloomy and the loyalty of the twelve was tested whether they would remain despite those trials.RH Mar 16, 1869 The wider chapter sets this crisis after Jesus fed the multitude in the wilderness, when the disciples saw no way to provide food and he took five loaves and two fish, blessed and distributed them until the food multiplied, all were filled, and twelve baskets remained over.ST Jul 26, 1905 At that miracle the people recognized God's work and called him the prophet who was to come into the world.ST Jul 26, 1905
The verse belongs to Christ's discourse after the feeding of the five thousand, in which he taught that he is the Bread of Life.ST Jun 27, 1900 That instruction was given in Capernaum, where many were too spiritually dull to understand its meaning, even though it was a great blessing and opportunity for the city. Many left because they were offended by his hard, plain and humbling teaching, especially about partaking of his flesh and blood, which they could not spiritually understand.ST Oct 29, 1894RH Sep 18, 1900ST Jul 15, 1897ST Nov 4, 1897 His heart was grieved by their murmuring and unbelief, and he looked after those leaving with pitying tenderness even as they turned away with disdain, yet he did not force the disaffected to stay or prevent them from going.ST Sep 1, 1881
Others departed with disappointed expectations and exposed motives, because his teaching separated those who sought food and political advantage from those willing to remain for spiritual truth.RH Dec 16, 1862ST Oct 8, 1896 When his words exposed their selfishness and love of the world, many who had heard his words and witnessed his works turned away.ST Sep 9, 1930
Purpose and Tone of Question
The question puts the twelve to the test, confronting them with a deliberate choice whether to remain with him when many disciples turn back and stop walking with him.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Oct 29, 1894ST May 15, 1901RH Sep 18, 1900RH Mar 16, 1869 It comes amid difficult teachings, discouragement, danger, and a gloomy outlook for his cause, calling for a decision to stay despite challenging new truth that offends those who hear it.ST Oct 29, 1894RH Sep 18, 1900RH Mar 16, 1869ST Jun 26, 1901 Their faith is tried by the departure of the others, yet it does not fail when they are brought face to face with the same alternative of leaving or abiding.ST Apr 9, 1912ST May 15, 1901ST Jun 26, 1901
He does not force the disaffected to stay nor try to prevent them from leaving, but lets the test reveal their choice.ST May 15, 1901ST Sep 1, 1881 He does not argue them back after they reject his truth and rebuke, nor does he soften his searching message or offer entertainment and a more pleasant gospel to keep the crowds.ST May 15, 1901ST Apr 2, 1894 He allows those who cannot bear the teaching to depart, and turns instead to the twelve with the open question whether they too will go.ST Sep 1, 1881ST Apr 2, 1894
The asking is full of sorrow, pitying tenderness, earnest solicitude, anguish, and human affection and longing at the thought of losing those close to him.ST Sep 1, 1881ST Jun 16, 1914ST Sep 9, 1930 His heart is grieved by murmuring and unbelief, and he looks after those leaving with pity even as they turn away with disdain, while he faces with grief the possible departure of those who have been with him and have witnessed his words and works.ST Sep 1, 1881ST Jun 16, 1914ST Sep 9, 1930 It is compassionate concern and yearning to bring those he has taught into the kingdom, not rashness or harshness, for he has led and disciplined them according to their strength, first giving instruction they could bear and then bringing them to harder truths whose rejection does not make it wrong to have taught them. When many are offended and leave, the question expresses anguish at losing their company and grief that teaching which exposed selfishness and love of the world should drive them away.ST Sep 9, 1930
The question brings the choice into the open, exposing motives, revealing character, and separating the faithful from the unfaithful.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Oct 8, 1896 It divides followers who sought food and political advantage from those willing to remain for spiritual truth, and it is spoken plainly so that who remains faithful is made manifest.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Oct 8, 1896 That separation keeps doubters from discouraging the faithful when he dies, even though one among the twelve who remains at the time has objected to the teaching, made shipwreck of faith, and will betray him.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894
It also reveals his yearning for the disciples to come into sacred relationship with himself and to understand him.ST Jul 15, 1897 To believe in him is more than mere sentiment, it is living faith in a personal Saviour who can and will ransom from sin.ST Jul 15, 1897
Answer and Reason to Stay
Peter answered for the twelve that there was nowhere else to go, because Jesus alone had the words of eternal life and they believed and were sure that He was the Christ, the Son of the living God, the Holy One of God.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Oct 29, 1894RH Sep 18, 1900ST Jun 26, 1901ST Jan 14, 1897 Enduring faith must rest on His own word, for Christ alone then and now has those words, and those who hear them receive a knowledge possessed by none others.ST Nov 5, 1912ST Jan 14, 1897 The reason to remain is that no other teacher or system can better teach the way to heaven, answer life's deepest questions, comfort in suffering, calm a guilty conscience, and sustain through death.RH Mar 31, 1863
The thought of being separated from Him brought the disciples sorrow and anxiety, for no one else could do for them what He had done.ST Sep 21, 1882 Their full understanding of His words would become clear only after His crucifixion, resurrection, and ascension, when the Holy Spirit brought them to remembrance.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 1897 He comforted them with the promise of many mansions in His Father's house and His return to receive them to Himself.ST Jul 15, 1897
Loyalty among the twelve did not mean every one was faithful, for Judas was among them and would betray Jesus.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Dec 17, 1912 He had been among those who objected to the plain teaching, and at that time made shipwreck of faith, so that Jesus declared that one of the twelve He had chosen was a devil, Judas Iscariot who would betray Him.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Jul 15, 1897 Peter's later failure under trial shows that his confession needed to be lived out by seeking Christ's help, surrendering his own will, and revealing Christ's steadfast, self-denying character, and Christ could have helped him remain loyal and resist temptation.ST May 12, 1898 The faithful refuse to go back to the formalists, scribes and Pharisees, the tradition of the elders, and lifeless formalism that teaches for doctrine the commandments of men.ST Jul 15, 1897
Sifting Shaking and Loyalty
The question was put after many disciples went back and walked no more with him, and it marked a shaking time that prepared the early church for Pentecost.RH Dec 31, 1914 His plain teaching in John 6 showed that a more deeply spiritual experience was necessary to keep his people from being sifted out in the coming hour of crisis.RH Dec 31, 1914 The testing separated loyalty that remains from disloyalty that leaves, with Judas sifted out while the other disciples still needed the spirit of seeking the highest place, jealousy, murmuring, and covetousness sifted out of them before Pentecost.RH Dec 31, 1914
The same question applies whenever tests turn people away from him.ST Oct 8, 1896 Such departure exposes professions that are only empty forms, while those who remain must be ready to answer that they will not also go away.ST Oct 8, 1896 This stands against the contrast between Enoch, who walked with God when God was unseen, and people who refused to walk with Christ when God was manifested in the flesh.ST Oct 8, 1896
Desertion by many does not change the truth, for the foundation of God stands sure.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873 Even when the evidences that a work is of God are overwhelming there is no reason to doubt, no honorable discharge, and no safe place to retreat, even when some cease fighting, hide, or desert to the enemy.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Aug 26, 1873 Safety is only in abiding with the truth and moving forward with the work of the Lord no matter who goes away.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Aug 26, 1873 Before leaving it is sensible to first ask where one is going and whether anything better is to be gained by the exchange, since the message holds the words of eternal life and there is nowhere else to go.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Aug 26, 1873 The same choice faces those tempted in the perils of the last days to leave God's cause when trials come and others go away.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873
The question serves as a searching appeal during a time of sifting when many are turning from God's commandments, putting to each believer whether they too will turn away from Jesus.RH Jul 10, 1860 The answer is to depend on Christ to hold and save, to confess him as the Christ who secures eternal life, and to resolve not to leave him.RH Jul 10, 1860 No one else can give rest or satisfy the heart.RH Jul 10, 1860
Doctrine of Life and Choice
The chapter expresses God's will for his people that life comes through Christ, who joins believers to himself in this life and for eternity.RH Jun 18, 1901 Though they may die, his life is in them, hidden with him, and those who have eternal life in him will be raised at the last day.RH Jun 18, 1901 That life comes not from material food but from receiving the bread from heaven, which is God's living Word.ST Sep 17, 1912
Eternal life is promised on the condition of belief in the Son, and the chapter gives this promise repeatedly, each time conditional.RH Dec 2, 1858 Spiritual life comes through believing in Christ, bringing the person into harmony with God's law of life.ST Oct 6, 1909 This life is distinct from natural life, being God's gift of eternal life.ST Oct 6, 1909 That the twelve could choose whether to remain with Jesus or go away shows that created beings with the power of choice make moral decisions, and their choice falls within the scope of moral conduct concerning right and wrong.ST Mar 30, 1915
Present Application to Believers
The question stands before every follower tempted to depart for business, wealth, carnal pleasure, earthly things, or half-heartedness after others have turned away because the teaching seemed hard.RH Dec 16, 1862RH Aug 4, 1859RH Sep 25, 1856 Before leaving, the tempted one is to ask where he is going and whether anything better is to be gained by the exchange, since there is nowhere else to go for life and hope.ST May 19, 1881RH Sep 2, 1873RH Aug 4, 1859 Leaving him means losing the one who gives peace through his blood, hope through his word, strength, victory through his love, and salvation, so the fitting response is to remain near him, cleave to him, serve him faithfully, and look with joy toward life with him.RH Dec 16, 1862
It becomes a personal call to answer that one will not also go away when others turn back, relying on his word.RH Jul 10, 1860 A difficult or humbling truth is not to be rejected as a hard saying but to be loved and cherished in the heart.RH Mar 1, 1864 He meets the tempted believer in the decisive hour of choice between enslaving habit and faithful ministry, with crowned brow, saddened face and great heart of love, in a sorrowful, loving challenge not to leave him. Feeling that heart of love drives the helpless sinner to cry out for salvation and receive complete deliverance from bondage, so that former love for sin becomes intense hatred of it and power to present him as a perfect Saviour.
The question is a tender appeal to a backsliding Christian to answer his call rather than abandon him, for his compassionate look can lead even a denier to repentance as he intercedes for his followers to share his inheritance and kingdom.RH Nov 24, 1859 It underscores the shock of forsaking him despite many proofs that he was the Son of God and the only hope, as seen in the disciples' abandonment of him in his agony.RH Jul 25, 1871 It warns against abandoning the cause of God and truth and giving up the hope of eternal life or judging oneself unworthy of it for temporary gratification.RH Jun 21, 1864
It challenges disciples who shrink back from the clear teaching that the indwelling Spirit can sanctify them for God's use not to leave when the Spirit can redeem from sin and purify a people for him.ST May 17, 1910
Sources