John 6:60
Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is an hard saying; who can hear it?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is an hard saying; who can hear it?
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Many therefore of his disciples, when they had heard this, said, This is a hard saying; who can hear it?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Many therefore of his disciples, when they heard this, said, This is a hard saying; who can hear it?
many, therefore, of his disciples having heard, said, 'This word is hard; who is able to hear it?'
Many therefore of his disciples having heard [ it] said, This word is hard; who can hear it?
Many, of his disciples, therefore, when they heard, said—Hard, is this discourse,—Who can, thereunto, hearken?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
On hearing it, many of His disciples said, “ This is a difficult teaching. Who can accept it?”
Therefore many of his disciples, when they heard this, said, “ This is a hard saying! Who can listen to it?”
Then, hearing this, a number of his disciples said, This is a hard saying; who is able to take in such teaching?
Many therefore of his disciples (when they heard this) sayde, This is an hard saying: who can heare it?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Many therefore of his disciples, hearing it, said: This saying is hard, and who can hear it?
Cross-references 20 of 23
- John 6:66
From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him.
Many disciples leave Jesus after finding his teaching difficult.
- John 6:53-56
Then Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Except ye eat the flesh of the Son of man, and drink his blood, ye have no life in you.
These are the words the disciples called hard, connecting eating Christ’s flesh and drinking his blood with life in him.
- John 6:35
And Jesus said unto them, I am the bread of life: he that cometh to me shall never hunger; and he that believeth on me shall never thirst.
Jesus identifies himself as the bread of life, the teaching they found hard.
- John 6:51
I am the living bread which came down from heaven: if any man eat of this bread, he shall live for ever: and the bread that I will give is my flesh, which I will give for the life of the world.
Jesus identifies the living bread as his flesh given for the life of the world.
- John 6:68-69
Then Simon Peter answered him, Lord, to whom shall we go? thou hast the words of eternal life.
Peter affirms faith in Jesus, who has the words of eternal life, after many disciples turn away.
- John 6:54
Whoso eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, hath eternal life; and I will raise him up at the last day.
Eating Christ’s flesh and drinking His blood is the teaching the disciples called hard.
- John 6:27
Labour not for the meat which perisheth, but for that meat which endureth unto everlasting life, which the Son of man shall give unto you: for him hath God the Father sealed.
Jesus directs the crowd from perishable food to food that endures to eternal life.
- John 6:40
And this is the will of him that sent me, that every one which seeth the Son, and believeth on him, may have everlasting life: and I will raise him up at the last day.
Believers in the Son receive everlasting life and are raised at the last day.
- John 6:56
He that eateth my flesh, and drinketh my blood, dwelleth in me, and I in him.
The disciples call the teaching about eating Christ’s flesh and drinking his blood hard.
- John 6:64-65
But there are some of you that believe not. For Jesus knew from the beginning who they were that believed not, and who should betray him.
Jesus identifies their unbelief and says coming to him depends on the Father.
- John 6:41-42
The Jews then murmured at him, because he said, I am the bread which came down from heaven.
They murmur at Jesus’ claim to have come down from heaven.
- John 6:67
Then said Jesus unto the twelve, Will ye also go away?
Jesus asks the twelve whether they too will leave.
- John 6:37
All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out.
Christ promises to receive all who come to him.
- Matthew 25:24
Then he which had received the one talent came and said, Lord, I knew thee that thou art an hard man, reaping where thou hast not sown, and gathering where thou hast not strawed:
The servant calls his lord hard, as the disciples call Jesus’ saying hard.
- Exodus 16:14-15
And when the dew that lay was gone up, behold, upon the face of the wilderness there lay a small round thing, as small as the hoar frost on the ground.
Manna supplies the background for the discourse about bread from heaven.
- John 6:44
No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day.
only those drawn by the Father remain
- John 6:1-14
After these things Jesus went over the sea of Galilee, which is the sea of Tiberias.
same narrative leading to discourse
- Psalms 78:24
And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.
Manna provides background for Jesus’ discourse about the bread of life.
- Matthew 13:14-15
And in them is fulfilled the prophecy of Esaias, which saith, By hearing ye shall hear, and shall not understand; and seeing ye shall see, and shall not perceive:
Closed hearts and dull hearing prevent understanding and conversion.
- Deuteronomy 8:3
And he humbled thee, and suffered thee to hunger, and fed thee with manna, which thou knewest not, neither did thy fathers know; that he might make thee know that man doth not live by bread only, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the LORD doth man live.
Both connect life with receiving God’s word.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
106 sources
Many of His disciples heard His teaching that He is the bread of life come down from heaven and that they must eat His flesh and drink His blood to have eternal life, and they murmured at it as a hard saying no one could hear.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17RH Sep 18, 1900Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 The eating and drinking is not of literal flesh and blood, for the flesh profits nothing, but to believe in Him as Redeemer, receive Him by faith as a personal Saviour, and enter the living union in which He dwells in them and they in Him.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Ms 143, 1907, par. 13–15Ms 106, 1905, par. 15–26ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 It is to receive His words as spiritual food until they become part of the life, by studying the Scriptures, keeping them before the mind, and obeying His sayings and commandments in sanctified obedience.Lt 82, 1895, par. 18CH 400.4–401.1Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Ms 25a, 1895, par. 27Ms 42, 1890, par. 85–95 They stumbled because they lacked spiritual perception and faith, had followed for miracles and hope of an earthly kingdom, and were unwilling to accept the self-denial, cross, and complete change the truth exposed as necessary.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 26–28Ms 41b, 1896, par. 28–322SP 238.3–239.2DA 383.1Ms 9, 1898, par. 31–32 His words deliberately tested every soul and revealed character, so that from that time many went back and walked no more with Him while those who recognized His words of eternal life remained, and the same separating work is done whenever purifying truth is presented.Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26Lt 49a, 1896, par. 135MR 263.1–2RH Feb 24, 1916ST Nov 4, 1897
Setting of the Saying
This saying belongs to the explanation of the spiritual meaning of the loaves after the feeding of the multitude, given as the Bread of life teaching, with the walking on the water standing between the miracle and the discourse.DA 383.2–384.19MR 242.1Lt 13, 1876, par. 1–3 That spiritual teaching connected with the miracle was difficult for many disciples to understand and accept, and its further revelation tested those who followed Him.DA 383.2–384.1DA 383.1 It exposed to a closer test those who were drawn by hopes of worldly benefit and who followed in hope of an earthly kingdom.DA 383.2–384.1DA 383.1
The hard saying was that Christ is the bread of life come down from heaven, that His flesh is meat indeed and His blood is drink indeed, and that a person must eat His flesh and drink His blood to have eternal life and be raised at the last day.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 It promised that the one who eats and drinks dwells in Christ and Christ in him, lives by Christ and lives forever by Him.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7Lt 67, 1900, par. 7–95MR 263.1–2 The eating and drinking is receiving Christ's words as spiritual food and drink for the soul, receiving Him as a personal Saviour with true earnest belief, looking constantly to Him, and being united with Him through daily, hourly faith which works by love and purifies the soul.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27ST Jul 15, 1897 It is receiving the word into the life by carefully studying the Scriptures and carrying the Word into daily obedience to all its precepts, keeping His sayings and His commandments and thereby abiding in His love even as He kept His Father's commandments, by which believers become partakers of the divine nature and one with Christ and are formed into a character like His.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–175MR 263.1–2ST Jul 15, 1897 Those who so receive draw spiritual vitality from Him as the branch draws nourishment from the vine, never hunger and never thirst for higher or more satisfying food, grow up into the full stature in Christ, receive nourishment sufficient for all needs of the soul, receive forgiveness of sins, and are sanctified unto eternal life, for it is the Spirit that quickens and Christ's words are spirit and life while the flesh by itself profits nothing.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27Ms 78, 1898, par. 6–7 Whoever will do God's will shall know whether the doctrine is of God, but the teaching tests every soul, requiring willingness to share His trials, to obey under any temptation, to refuse to yield truth whatever the consequences, and to walk as He walked in order to gain eternal life in the kingdom of God.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–175MR 263.1–2
Many hearers took the words literally as a command to consume blood, which the ritual law forbade, and treated them as sacrilegious instead of grasping their spiritual meaning.DA 390.1–24RED 96.1 With earthly minds His symbolical words about His person and office were insufferable to them, and they misinterpreted their meaning.ST Jul 15, 18974RED 96.1 Moral darkness kept them from fully comprehending and understanding the lesson at the time.2SP 282.1–283.24RED 96.1 What was not understood then was afterward made plain by subsequent events, and His words became a stay to their hearts when He walked no more with them and sustained them after He was no longer with them.2SP 282.1–283.24RED 96.1
Jesus knew in Himself that they murmured at this hard saying, asked if this offended them, and pointed them to His coming ascension to where He was before.Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–9Lt 67, 1900, par. 7–9Ms 73, 1899, par. 9–10 He thereby challenged how they would respond when they saw the Son of man ascend up where He was before, since they already struggled to believe that He had come down from heaven, reproving them that if they could not receive His coming down they would be less able to receive His ascension.4RED 96.2Ms 73, 1899, par. 9–102SP 282.1–283.2 He explained that eternal life comes not from His human flesh itself, for the flesh profits nothing, but through faith in His words and in the saving power and efficacy of the sacrifice He would make for the world, for it is the Spirit that gives life and the words He speaks are spirit and life.4RED 96.2Lt 67, 1900, par. 7–92SP 282.1–283.2 His teaching and example, His life and death, are the heavenly food that gives spiritual life, vigor, strength, and everlasting life, as temporal bread gives strength to the body so faith in Christ and obedience to His teachings give spiritual vigor.4RED 96.22SP 282.1–283.2 Their murmuring complaint came from disciples who had never been partakers with Christ, who had listened as many listen to the Word but had not eaten the truth as bread from heaven, revealing an unsanctified heart that has not beheld Christ as the Lamb of God and has not been molded by the Holy Spirit, the same criticism, murmuring and unbelief His servants still meet, leading to going back and walking no more with Him in contrast to those who remain because He has the words of eternal life.Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–92SP 282.1–283.2
He spoke these words deliberately, knowing that many followers would turn away because of them.Lt 208a, 1902, par. 20–21ST Nov 4, 1897 He spoke them to test every soul, to bring His hearers to decide for or against Him, to reveal their true feelings and expose character and hidden temptation, showing those not wholly with Him who would oppose Him at His trial.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13ST Nov 4, 1897 He spoke the truth about His work and about the bread from heaven before leaving them so they could be proved in advance, so that their later apostasy would not surprise or unduly try the faithful disciples and would protect His future work from being turned onto wrong paths.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 137MR 185.4 The saying thus sets up the contrast with the twelve, for Peter remained because he recognized that Jesus had the words of eternal life.5MR 263.1–2ST Nov 4, 1897
Meaning of Eating and Drinking
The eating and drinking is not of literal flesh and blood, for the flesh by itself profits nothing; it is the Spirit that gives life, and Christ's words are spirit and life.Ms 143, 1907, par. 13–15ST Apr 9, 1912Lt 6, 1903, par. 14–22RH Sep 18, 1900Lt 47, 1891, par. 17–22 The saying was not a command to consume human flesh or blood in a physical sense, but concerns receiving Christ and His life-giving words in faith, with true life coming from receiving Him rather than from a merely physical understanding.Ms 106, 1905, par. 15–26ST Apr 9, 1912RH Sep 18, 1900 Earthly minds misread the symbolic words about His person and office, yet He does not dilute the symbol because it conveys truths about His person and work.ST Apr 9, 1912
To eat and drink is to believe in Him as Redeemer, to receive Him as a personal Saviour, to look constantly to Him, and to receive Him by faith with true earnest belief.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Ms 106, 1905, par. 15–26Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27 It is the necessary spiritual relationship with Him entered through the daily, hourly exercise of faith which works by love and purifies the soul, and a parable spoken in figure for true, earnest belief.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27RH Feb 24, 1916 Those who truly receive His word never hunger, and those who believe in Him never thirst for higher or more satisfying food, but draw continually from Him as the living bread and find eternal life and a fresh, living spiritual experience.Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27COL 129.3–130.4
It is to receive and assimilate His words as spiritual food and drink until they become part of the life.CH 400.4–401.1Lt 241, 1903, par. 9–10Ms 63, 1890, par. 5–7 This is done by keeping God's Word and truth continually before the mind, studying them, taking them in, understanding them, practicing their teachings, and bringing them into daily life.Lt 82, 1895, par. 18CH 400.4–401.1Ms 42, 1890, par. 85–95Ms 63, 1890, par. 5–7 It means living by what God has revealed and keeping its precepts instead of leaving Scripture for human suppositions, for His words are the conditions of salvation and the mysteries of godliness are to be grasped in practical experience.CH 400.4–401.1Ms 42, 1890, par. 85–95Lt 241, 1903, par. 9–10 Spiritually men and women are built up from the food given to the mind, the Bible contains the bread sent down from heaven that gives spiritual growth, while books and magazines that lead the mind astray hinder spiritual growth and are not to be spent time in reading.Lt 43, 1905, par. 4
It is to be doers of the Word by acting the flesh and blood now while it is called today, believing the Word, appropriating it, taking it into practical life, and obeying it.Ms 25a, 1895, par. 27Lt 23, 1896, par. 22–235MR 41.2–42.1 Eating His flesh is keeping His sayings and His commandments and thereby abiding in His love, even as He kept His Father's commandments and abode in His love, living in harmony with the Redeemer through sanctified obedience to all Scripture.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–175MR 263.1–2 The Bible stands as the great educating Book answering what to do to work God's works — first believe on Him whom God sent, next work — and the same lesson is taught under the symbol of the vine and its branches.Ms 25a, 1895, par. 27Lt 23, 1896, par. 22–23 The teaching addresses the heart and moral nature, takes possession of the will, calls for obedience to Christ, and feeds hungry souls with the word of the infinite God instead of froth and fables or human maxims and customs that blind the eyes.5MR 41.2–42.1Lt 5, 1898, par. 13–15
His teaching, example, life, and death are the heavenly food that gives spiritual life, strength, and vigor through faith in His words and in the saving power and efficacy of the sacrifice He would make for the world.4RED 96.22SP 282.1–283.2 As temporal bread gives strength to the body, so faith in Christ and obedience to His teachings give spiritual vigor and everlasting life.2SP 282.1–283.2 The living oracles are His flesh and blood even before He was crucified, the directions given by Christ as the invisible Leader of Israel in the Old Testament Scriptures are full of marrow and fatness, and His work as the substitute for all sin was the only hope of ancient Israel.21MR 44.1–2Lt 40, 1899, par. 17–18 After God's plan was fulfilled in Christ's death the New Testament was written to reflect its light back upon past ages, giving significance to the whole Jewish economy and making its plain directions for practical holiness and obedience binding in the life of everyone who claims to be a Christian.21MR 44.1–2
Those who so receive Him are made one with Christ in this life and remain one for eternity, dwelling in Him and He in them.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2RH Jun 18, 19015MR 263.1–2 They become partakers of the divine nature, formed into a character like His, escaping the world's corruption, and sharing in a transformed experience through which the Word enters the life.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17Lt 253, 1904, par. 6–8 They grow up into the full stature of men and women in Christ Jesus, receive nourishment sufficient for all the needs of the soul, receive forgiveness of sins, and are sanctified unto eternal life, so that though they may die His life is in them and He will raise them at the last day.Ms 12a, 1901, par. 1–2RH Jun 18, 1901 Whoever will do God's will shall know whether the doctrine is of God, and receiving His words in this way brings life as a privilege with practical, lasting value.Ms 68, 1897, par. 95MR 263.1–2
Why Disciples Stumbled
Their limited comprehension could not discern the spiritual meaning of eating His flesh and drinking His blood, because they lacked depth of faith and spiritual perception to understand that feeding on the divine Word gives spiritual life and growth.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 26–28Ms 77, 1906, par. 1–5Ms 41b, 1896, par. 28–32ST May 12, 1898Ms 38, 1897, par. 15–17 The difficulty came from unbelieving and selfish minds that could not grasp the figure for receiving His life and character, and the natural heart cannot comprehend plain truth about the bread from heaven and eternal life.Ms 77, 1906, par. 1–5Ms 95, 1898, par. 17–22 Many today have no greater depth of faith and spiritual perception and turn away for the same reason when human ideas and maxims are held above the Word that gives strength, wisdom, integrity, and moral power.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 26–28Ms 41b, 1896, par. 28–32
With earthly minds they misread His symbolic words about His person and office, made them insufferable to themselves, misconstrued them, and misinterpreted messages sent by God.ST Apr 9, 1912Ms 25, 1897, par. 18–19ST Jul 15, 1897Ms 106, 1905, par. 31–34 Pure truth was strange to senses corrupted by worldly ideas and maxims, so superficial understanding could not comprehend truth that is deep, pure and unadulterated, and only those who serve Him from pure, loving hearts can receive His Word.Ms 25, 1897, par. 18–19Ms 57, 1898, par. 26 The saying concerns receiving Christ and His life-giving words in faith, not literal eating, and He did not soften or dilute the symbol to remove the offense but left the truth so all who desired could trace it out, explaining that the Spirit gives life, the flesh profits nothing, and His words are spirit and life to be each received for himself by faith and obedience unto partaking of the divine nature and oneness in spiritual life with Christ.ST Apr 9, 1912Ms 95, 1898, par. 17–22ST Jul 15, 1897
Many had followed for miracles and hopes of worldly benefit and an earthly kingdom, including freedom from Rome, and the further revelation tested those so drawn.DA 383.2–384.1DA 383.1DA 391.2–3 When He presented Himself as the bread of life and made clear His kingdom was spiritual and rejected earthly rule, the teaching became difficult and mysterious to minds fixed on hope that He would be received as a national Messiah and establish a temporal reign.Ms 9, 1898, par. 31–32DA 391.2–3 Receiving Him meant accepting His character and teaching, surrendering cherished ambitions, and living self-sacrificially, meekly, and humbly, but worldly-minded people, including some professing to be His disciples, had no desire for His spiritual kingdom or His self-sacrificing way and turned away.Ms 9, 1898, par. 31–32DA 391.2–3
The truth exposed their sins and showed their need for a complete change, unreserved consecration, self-denial, and the cross.2SP 287.1–24RED 100.1DA 392.2–3 They were unwilling to give up self-righteousness, worldly desires, cherished sin, and self, to share His trials, obey under temptation, and walk as He walked, so people who welcome truth at first are offended when it calls for self-denial and a changed life.2SP 238.3–239.2COL 47.2DA 392.2–3 They welcome praise but turn from truth when it calls them to repentance and obedience, and those who receive the truth gladly may later take offense at correction and refuse the effort and self-denial required to change their lives, though a clean heart and pure life with repentance shown in conduct are necessary and outward profession and religious forms cannot take their place.2SP 287.1–24RED 100.14RED 84.1–3 Offended by reproof they turned away, illustrating how truth separates those willing to receive it from those who reject it, how people who welcome the gospel while life is easy may be offended when God's word confronts cherished sin or brings reproach and trial, and how stony-ground hearers faint when tribulation, persecution, reproach, or the pointing out of cherished sin comes.COL 47.2DA 392.2–3
They would not accept truth that rebuked them or exposed their lives as out of accord with righteousness, but welcomed praise and preferred human praise and flattery to God's admonition.Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–152SP 287.1–2 Rather than undertake self-denial and reform they were displeased, counted the way too strait, and thought the call to return and the responsibility to work with Christ too hard, whether that call is to return to God, to live apart from the world, to accept self-denial and sacrifice instead of only hearing of reward, or for Christians in business to work with Christ according to entrusted gifts.Lt 146, 1900, par. 14–15Lt 13, 1898, par. 6–87MR 174.1RH Apr 12, 1870ST Jan 29, 1880 There is no harmony between the children of light and the children of darkness, so the call to live apart from the world feels like a hard saying that worldly-minded people cannot accept or understand, yet the call must be heeded, the Spirit's work revealing that a person is helpless to save himself, and those who share His sufferings will share His glory.Lt 13, 1898, par. 6–8RH Apr 12, 18705T 431.2
They had listened but had never been partakers with Christ nor eaten the truth as bread from heaven, so the demand to eat His flesh and drink His blood offended them.Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–9Lt 23, 1896, par. 1 That offense reveals an unsanctified heart that has not beheld Him as the Lamb of God and has not been molded by the Holy Spirit, and hearing and recognizing truth as correct is not enough unless the heart also accepts and lives it and keeps pace despite further trials.Ms 46, 1898, par. 5–91T 543.1–2 Those who remain satisfied with a low Christian life, trust in their own activity, planning, study and teaching, and fail to see that without Him they can do nothing, will at last reject as too hard the requirement to receive His transforming grace in the heart, have thoughts and imagination purified and brought into captivity to His will, become one with Him instead of mingling the sacred with the common and carnal and nurturing self.Lt 23, 1896, par. 1Ms 68, 1897, par. 19 Teachers among them had theories but no abiding, living experience and were spiritually starved because they do not receive Him as the source of life, for the teaching calls for actual spiritual experience, genuine conversion and new birth, and tasting that the Lord is gracious, not merely naming Him.Ms 171, 1905, par. 4–5Ms 68, 1897, par. 19
Their reaction exposed unbelief allowed to grow into habit, showing faith not genuine and position weak.Ms 56, 1897, par. 2–6Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26 The hard saying tested whether they would receive His words or cling to human ideas and reject the blessing He offered, and their departure was the result of unbelief.Ms 56, 1897, par. 2–6Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26 Their hearing was superficial with a shallow foundation not dug deep and riveted to the Eternal Rock and without a sure foundation in God's word, like stony-ground hearers who receive the word at once with joy but have no root, do not count the cost or bring the word face to face with habits of life.6T 132.37MR 174.1FE 459.3–461.1 When test and trial comes to every soul, those not firmly grounded murmur when the Lord's words seem too demanding and abandon Him when tested, becoming heady, highminded, self-sufficient traitors who make shipwreck of faith and walk no more with Him.Ms 68, 1897, par. 237MR 174.1FE 459.3–461.1
Testing and Turning Away
On hearing the teaching many of His disciples murmured at it and were offended by it, calling it a hard saying that no one could hear, and from that time many went back and walked no more with Him.Lt 82, 1907, par. 10–17RH Sep 18, 1900Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–275MR 263.1–2ST May 12, 1898 They stumbled because they found the word about eating His flesh and drinking His blood difficult to accept, lacking the spiritual perception to grasp that His words are spirit and life and that true life comes by receiving Him rather than by a merely physical understanding.RH Sep 18, 1900Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27ST May 12, 1898 Some heard and yet turned away, though His words give life and all who believe in Him receive everlasting life, never hungering and never thirsting for higher or more satisfying food.Lt 270, 1903, par. 28–30Lt 208, 1906, par. 17–27
His words tested every soul, exposing character, vital relation to Christ, and hidden temptation at work.Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26RH Feb 24, 1916Ms 67, 1897, par. 18 The test revealed unbelief allowed to grow into habit, faith not genuine and position weak, as men were brought to decide for or against Him and to reveal their true feelings whether they would receive His words or cling to human ideas and reject the blessing offered.Ms 67, 1897, par. 22–26Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13RH Feb 24, 1916 Those not wholly with Him were thus shown to be those who would oppose Him at His trial, and some who did not believe, were offended by His sayings, and left Him became His bitterest persecutors, in contrast to true disciples who practiced His teachings and taught others to do the same.Lt 49a, 1896, par. 13Lt 17, 1891, par. 34–35Ms 67, 1897, par. 18
The turning away sets up the contrast with the Twelve, for when asked if they also would go away Peter remained because he recognized that Jesus had the words of eternal life.5MR 263.1–2ST Nov 4, 1897 Jesus had spoken those words to test them, and while many turned back and stopped following Him, Peter stayed with Him on that ground.5MR 263.1–2ST Nov 4, 1897
What was plain to believers became a stumbling block to them, for the natural heart could not comprehend it and moral darkness kept them from fully comprehending His lessons at the time.2SP 282.1–283.2Lt 60, 1894, par. 16–184RED 96.1 The lessons were intended to expose self, and what they murmured at then was afterward made plain by subsequent events and by the resurrection.2SP 282.1–283.212MR 257.1–258.2Ms 67, 1897, par. 18 After His resurrection and the coming of the Holy Spirit at Pentecost the Spirit joined divine truth to their minds and gave saving understanding of His teaching as spirit and life, and His words became a stay to their hearts when He walked no more with them.2SP 282.1–283.212MR 257.1–258.24RED 96.1
In this the verse shows how truth separates those willing to receive it from those who reject it.DA 392.2–3Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–1513MR 10.3–11.1 Because the truth exposed their sins and showed their need for a complete change, those offended by reproof turned away rather than give up self-righteousness and worldly desires and take up self-denial.DA 392.2–3 People whose hearts resist the truth may leave rather than give up their own ideas when those ideas conflict with it.DA 392.2–3Ms 97, 1898, par. 13–1513MR 10.3–11.1
Living by the Words
John 6 holds lessons that are precious and important yet only faintly understood, setting out the conditions of eternal life and a life that measures with the life of God.FE 455.3–456.1Ms 54, 1898, par. 1–2 The chapter must be read and studied with prayer for understanding, with clearness of understanding asked of God, and its teachings must be brought into practical daily experience.Lt 57, 1904, par. 6Ms 78, 1902, par. 5–7Lt 43, 1905, par. 4 That daily living of the fifth and sixth chapters of John is the mystery of godliness, and the knowledge so gained enables distinguishing the true from the false in days of peril.Lt 57, 1904, par. 6Ms 94, 1899, par. 8–9 Spiritually men and women are built up from the food they give the mind, for the Bible contains the bread sent down from heaven that gives spiritual growth, while books and magazines that lead the mind astray hinder growth and are not to be spent time in reading.Lt 43, 1905, par. 4 Those truths rebuke spiritual weakness and show that strength comes from walking in the light given, depending on God and not on human beings, refusing to look to any human for power, experience, strength, guidance, or wisdom and refusing bondage to man, but looking to Jesus as the true Light, following Him to have the light of life, and receiving Him by faith to have sanctification and righteousness and an exceeding great reward.Ms 78, 1902, par. 5–7
Feeding upon Christ's words as His very flesh and blood is the important education needed by children and youth and men and women to become workers together with God.Ms 202, 1898, par. 2 That education includes being taught in regard to the law of Jehovah and the penalty of transgression, and understanding that God accepts the ransom made by the Saviour in behalf of each person who is obedient to the law.Ms 202, 1898, par. 2 Eating the Word means taking its truth into the life and practicing it, and truth so received shapes influence and speech.Ms 74, 1897, par. 27 Teachers must therefore know the Word through experience before they can properly teach it to others.Ms 74, 1897, par. 27
Eating the flesh and drinking the blood of the Son of God is necessary to comprehend and appreciate the truth as it is in Jesus, meaning continual growth in grace, bringing truth into the daily experience, asking God in prayer for this blessing along with all other blessings, and being taught daily in the school of Christ.Lt 93, 1901, par. 11 It is actual experience, being truly converted and born again and able to see and discern the requirements of the spiritual kingdom, tasting that the Lord is gracious rather than merely naming Christ.FE 458.2–459.2Ms 68, 1897, par. 19 Its meaning must be studied and cherished in the heart as truth that works by love and purifies the soul, bringing thorough conversion, new life, and humility instead of self-esteem and boasting of personal capabilities.Lt 95, 1901, par. 18–19 When the natural man, what hereditary tendencies, nationality, education, and circumstances have made him, is changed by grace, the Word received as spirit and life brings a new heart, new purposes, and new impulses, with fruit in the heart, fruit in the lips, and fruit in the character, some thirty, some sixty, and some one-hundred-fold.2MR 92.4
Those who eat and drink open the mind to the entrance of God's word with determination to practice it, and receive light and understanding to the simple.FE 458.2–459.2 They learn as newborn babes to desire the sincere milk of the word that they may grow thereby, the frivolous life is changed and forsaken, character is transformed, the feet are placed on Christ as the first round of the ladder heavenward, and step by step heavenward Christ is revealed in spirit, words, and actions.FE 458.2–459.2 Through abundant grace they are built up as lively stones into a spiritual house, a holy priesthood, to offer up spiritual sacrifices acceptable to God by Jesus Christ.FE 458.2–459.2 God sets study of His Word before people as a rich banquet to feast on by partaking of it, and partaking increases spiritual strength and gives growth in grace and in knowledge of the truth, forms and strengthens habits of self-control, removes the infirmities of childhood such as fretfulness, wilfulness, selfishness, hasty words and passionate acts, and develops in their place the graces of Christian manhood and womanhood.Ms 54, 1903, par. 19 Receiving Him and drawing continually from Him as the living bread gives eternal life and a fresh, living experience that gives power and freshness to teaching and witness, for His words are Spirit and life, while those who do not feed on these words are drawn into misleading pursuits that weaken character and mental strength, and receiving and obeying them purifies and strengthens the mind and leads to a life shaped by truth.COL 129.3–130.4FE 379.1–2
Its teachings, together with Christ's prayer, are to cure dissension and lead to unity with one another and with Christ.21MR 346.1–3 Living that prayer in practical life brings that unity, expressing God's will for His people.Lt 131, 1900, par. 1–3
The same murmuring appears in the last days when truth must be spoken in reproof and warning irrespective of consequences and when truths of momentous importance are presented.7MR 180.1–2Ms 57, 1898, par. 26 Many thought to be disciples become offended at the greatest Teacher, count the way too strait, and walk no more with Him, exposing a shallow foundation not dug deep and not riveted to the Eternal Rock.7MR 180.1–27MR 174.1FE 459.3–461.1 Those whose hearts are not in harmony with the truth as it is in Jesus, who cherish theories of their own that are not the truth and whose sentiments the truth does not harmonize with, rather than give up their own ideas become offended, make shipwreck of faith, turn from the truth, and leave those who obey it, as heady, highminded, self-sufficient traitors turning away from Christ.7MR 180.1–27MR 174.1 Others will receive the truth and take the places made vacant by those who became offended and left, and truth will bear away the victory.7MR 180.1–2 When a statement from the Word needed for purification of the soul meets pride, many who received the truth enthusiastically at first abandon Christ as false disciples, yet practical godliness applied strengthens the ranks, and this turning away over purifying truth has always occurred and will continue to the close of earth's history.5MR 121.2 To the believing soul the truth of God's Word is as eating from the tree of life, but unless men voluntarily appropriate it so that it becomes the very life of the soul, they have no spiritual life.Ms 57, 1898, par. 26
Mere outward connection with any church will not save, but personal faith in a personal Saviour brings the soul into spiritual union with Christ.16MR 277.1 The chapter defines the righteousness of Christ that must be accepted, without which a person does not have the wedding garment and is not fit for the marriage feast.Ms 13, 1899, par. 1–2 It affirms the sufficiency of the Old Testament Scriptures, so that those who believe the Old Testament would also believe the New.Ms 32, 1900, par. 30–32 Christ is the bread from heaven who satisfies the soul's hunger, yet feeding the mind on worldly entertainment leaves no appetite for this heavenly food or for spiritual instruction, so each person is called to choose whom to serve and to seek life and spiritual strength in Christ.Lt 58a, 1898, par. 17–20 Feeding upon Christ must be with contrition of heart because of sin and only with the leaven of sin put away, as the Passover lamb was eaten with bitter herbs pointing back to the bitterness of bondage and was kept with unleavened bread with no leaven allowed in the houses.PP 278.1 To a converted heart God's Word as nourishment for the spiritual mind turns what once seemed barren into fullness of life and beauty.Ms 202, 1898, par. 7
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
54 sources
After hearing his teaching that he is the bread of life and that they must eat his flesh and drink his blood to live, many of his disciples complained that the saying was too hard to be heard.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Sep 18, 1900ST May 12, 1898 What he meant was not literal eating but receiving him by faith as the source of spiritual life, for it is the Spirit that gives life and his words are spirit and life.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 1897ST Aug 16, 1905ST Sep 1, 1881 They stumbled because their minds were earthly and unbelieving, seeking temporal bread and power rather than spiritual life, and their murmuring exposed their motives and tested their faith.RH Feb 24, 1916ST Oct 8, 1896ST May 2, 1916ST Feb 8, 1905ST Jul 16, 1894 Many therefore turned back and walked with him no more, while Peter confessed for the twelve that he alone has the words of eternal life.ST Nov 4, 1897ST Oct 8, 1896ST Jan 14, 1897 Such humbling and searching truth must not be rejected because it is difficult or demands self-denial and sacrifice, but must be loved, received, and obeyed in practical life.RH Apr 12, 1870RH Aug 4, 1859RH Mar 1, 1864ST Aug 10, 1904RH Jan 15, 1857
Context and Wording
The saying belongs to the whole discourse after the feeding of the five thousand in John 6:22-71, in which Jesus teaches that he is the bread of life.ST Jun 27, 1900 That teaching sets forth his work, the power given to him, and the necessity of receiving him as the Bread of Life, containing spiritual truth that feeds all who desire it.ST May 12, 1909
It was heard at Capernaum from hearers so spiritually dull that they did not grasp its meaning. That Capernaum teaching in chapter six is markedly different in tone and elevation from his teaching in Jerusalem in chapter seven.ST Mar 14, 1911
The question who can hear it calls for more than merely hearing words.ST Oct 8, 1896 It calls for responsive hearing of the kind urged in the messages to the churches in Revelation.ST Oct 8, 1896 Those offended by his teaching that they must eat his flesh and drink his blood called it a hard saying and left without asking or waiting for an explanation.RH Nov 18, 1862
Meaning of Hard Saying
The hard saying was the teaching that they must eat his flesh and drink his blood to have eternal life and dwell in him, which means receiving him by faith as the source of spiritual life and receiving his life-giving words, not literal eating.ST Apr 9, 1912RH Sep 18, 1900ST May 12, 1898ST Jul 15, 1897ST Jul 16, 1894 To earthly, natural minds without spiritual perception the symbolical words about his person and office were insufferable and unbearable, so they misread and misinterpreted their meaning and asked who could consent to such talk.ST Apr 9, 1912ST May 12, 1898ST Jul 15, 1897ST Jul 16, 1894ST Apr 10, 1893 Their answer was murmuring, offense, and lack of faith, and many turned back and walked no more with him.RH Sep 18, 1900ST May 12, 1898ST Jul 16, 1894ST Apr 10, 1893 He did not dilute or soften the symbolical representation to remove the offense, because it conveys the truth about his person and work, but left the truth so that all who desired could trace it out.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 1897
His word is his flesh and the spiritual food of life, and eating him is eating the Word.ST Aug 16, 1905 This means recognizing his life, power, and Spirit in the word rather than treating it as mere human speech, and it is not done by eating the consecrated host.ST Aug 16, 1905 It is the Spirit that gives life, and his words are spirit and life.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 1897ST Sep 1, 1881 It is not his human flesh that gives eternal life, but faith in his words and in the efficacy of the sacrifice he was to make for the world, each receiving for himself by faith and obedience, by which believers become partakers of the divine nature and one in spiritual life with him.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Jul 15, 1897ST Sep 1, 1881 Moral darkness kept the murmurers from fully comprehending this at the time, though later events made it plain and a stay to their hearts when he no longer walked with them, and when he reproved their murmuring at his claim to have come down from heaven he asked how they would receive him when they saw him ascend to where he was before.ST Sep 1, 1881
The hard saying also included his plain teaching about his humiliation, suffering, mission, and death, and about the character of his kingdom and what his disciples must possess to be favored by God.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Dec 24, 1894ST Mar 30, 1888 To those who expected a Messiah bringing temporal power and glory it seemed to end their hopes, because they would not accept his call to self-denial, purity, and sacrifice.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Mar 30, 1888 Their faith in the prophecies and in the sacrificial services should have shown him to be their fulfillment as the Lamb of God, yet it did not help them recognize him.ST Mar 30, 1888 The faithful disciples did not take offense, though they only dimly understood the spiritual good he promised.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894
The saying tested them over laboring for the food that endures to eternal life and over the necessary spiritual relationship between him and his followers.RH Feb 24, 1916ST May 2, 1916 They had followed for temporal bread meeting temporal needs, for miracles, food, and political power, captivated by miracles rather than by the more important truth he preached, instead of for spiritual life and spiritual truth.ST May 2, 1916ST Feb 8, 1905ST Oct 8, 1896 Their difficulty tested their faith, exposed their character and motives, and separated those seeking him for the loaves from those willing to follow him for truth.RH Feb 24, 1916ST Oct 8, 1896 The question is also over the Spirit's work to make people alive to overcome sinful deeds and become sanctified, from which some shrink and are urged not to turn away from him.ST May 17, 1910 He had led and taught them according to their strength, but now gave deeper instruction and spoke these words to test them, leaving the contrast with the twelve, for Peter remained because he recognized that he had the words of eternal life.ST Nov 4, 1897ST Jul 15, 1897
Unbelief and Departure
Many of his disciples found the saying difficult to accept and to understand because of unbelief, lack of faith, and lack of spiritual perception, and in murmuring and taking offense they grieved him.RH Feb 24, 1916ST Oct 8, 1896ST Jul 16, 1894ST Sep 1, 1881 Their words tested their faith and exposed their character, since they could not grasp the spiritual relationship with him that he taught.RH Feb 24, 1916ST Oct 8, 1896 Many therefore turned back and walked no more with him, and this marked a separation among his followers.ST Nov 4, 1897ST Oct 8, 1896ST Jan 14, 1897RH Mar 16, 1869ST Mar 15, 1905 Against those who left stands the confession made for the twelve that Christ alone has the words of eternal life, believed and known as the Son of God with a knowledge possessed by none others.ST Nov 4, 1897ST Jan 14, 1897 No belief will endure unless it rests on the true foundation of his own word.ST Jan 14, 1897
Their open rebuke before the multitude increased their disaffection until they left greatly displeased and with disdain.ST Sep 1, 1881 They wished to wound him and to gratify the malice of the Pharisees, making the fatal mistake of rejecting God's counsel to them.ST Sep 1, 1881 He looked after these erring ones with eyes of pitying tenderness but made no attempt to prevent the disaffected from leaving.ST Sep 1, 1881 They are the shallow, enthusiastic, stony-ground hearers who receive the word immediately with joy and with great zeal.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915ST May 3, 1877 They urge others to embrace it and condemn careful, hesitating hearers as cold and unbelieving, yet they have no root in themselves.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915
They have not accepted the cross as part of religious life, have not counted the cost, have not brought the word face to face with all their habits of life, and have not yielded themselves fully to its control.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915ST May 3, 1877ST Jun 30, 1881 When affliction, persecution, tribulation, temptation, reproof, or a call to patience, self-denial, radical change, and sacrifice and reproach for the truth's sake comes, especially when the word points out some cherished sin, they are easily offended.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915ST May 3, 1877ST Jun 30, 1881 Their ardor dampens and they faint like a sun-scorched plant without depth of root.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915 They had received the gospel as a way of escape from suffering rather than as a deliverance from sin, looking at present inconvenience and trial and forgetting eternal realities.ST Jan 28, 1889ST Jan 26, 1915
Some were offended by searching, testing truth because their obedience had lasted only while following him seemed popular and prosperous.ST Oct 23, 1901 Though convicted they would not yield the will to God or accept the terms of salvation because they did not immediately comprehend his words, feeling his gospel too strait.ST Aug 4, 1898ST Sep 21, 1904 They prove that not all who are connected with God's work become a permanent part of it, like lumber used for ladders and stagings and false floors that is cast aside when the building is finished, and like those who helped Noah build the ark yet perished in the Flood.ST Sep 21, 1904 God is now testing men as never before to decide who will be built into his glorious temple to endure forever and who will be cast aside as refuse lumber.ST Sep 21, 1904 Judas was among those who called the teaching hard.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894 The moment exposed his unbelief and marked the beginning of his shipwreck of faith, as he then gave room to doubt, envy, suspicion, bitterness, and hatred.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894
The other disciples did not take offense, though they only dimly understood the spiritual good he promised, and this helped distinguish faithful disciples from those who would turn away.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894ST Dec 24, 1894
Life Received by Faith
John 6 teaches that life comes from Christ as the bread from heaven, and that this bread must be received in order to live.ST Sep 17, 1912 That life does not come merely from the physical food eaten, but from God's living and eternal Word.ST Sep 17, 1912 The same chapter teaches that spiritual life comes through believing in Christ and placing the life in harmony with God's law.ST Oct 6, 1909 This spiritual life is distinct from the natural life received from parents and sustained by food, air, and sunshine.ST Oct 6, 1909
Receiving and living by God's word is necessary for eternal life, for Jesus is the Word made flesh.ST Jan 13, 1914 Eternal life is in the Son, so that those who have the Son have life.ST Jan 13, 1914 This teaching sets forth his work, the power given to him, and the necessity of receiving him as the Bread of Life, containing spiritual truth that feeds all who desire it.ST May 12, 1909 Feeding on him gives life, and feeding on God's Word means sharing in God's life and being joined to him by an unbreakable bond.ST Apr 15, 1903
Christ is the divine remedy for sin, and those who receive him have eternal life.RH Jun 18, 1901 Believers are made one with Christ in this life and remain one with him for eternity.RH Jun 18, 1901 Though they may die, his life is in them, and he will raise them at the last day.RH Jun 18, 1901
God gives eternal life now through Jesus Christ in response to faith, and believers have this life by faith and will retain it through the ages to come. This eternal life is distinct from immortality, which is deathlessness and incorruptibility bestowed on Christ's people at the resurrection.
His promises in John 6 to raise up at the last day are conditional upon compliance with the conditions stated.RH Jun 13, 1854 Those who do not comply will therefore not be raised then.RH Jun 13, 1854 This proves two distinct resurrections, with the blessed and holy raised a thousand years before the rest of the dead.RH Jun 13, 1854
Warning for Present Hearers
The saying reaches believers who meet trials over points of faith they find difficult to accept, and it covers humbling gospel truths that are hard to bear.RH Aug 4, 1859RH Mar 1, 1864 Such truth is not to be rejected because it is difficult or humbling, but is to be loved and cherished.RH Mar 1, 1864
The teaching sounds hard when it calls for self-denial and sacrifice for Christ, and those who prefer to hear only of the Christian's reward must still face its claims, since those who share in suffering will share in glory.RH Apr 12, 1870RH Sep 13, 1870 The duty to give means for the cause can strike hearers as unbearable even when they know their duty.RH Jan 15, 1857 Christians in business remain responsible according to entrusted gifts to work with Christ and use their means to advance God's cause, and that responsibility stands even when practice contradicts it.ST Jan 29, 1880
Teachings are called hard when they require treating others as one wishes to be treated, which includes forgiving, showing mercy, keeping others' faults private, doing good to enemies, surrendering the cloak, and going the second mile, so that calling Him Lord requires doing what He says.RH Sep 18, 1855 In the same way God's holy, just, and good law has been portrayed as an unbearable saying that cannot be accepted, with contempt shown by claiming it has been abolished or changed.RH May 20, 1902 What is needed is not self-righteous obedience to human ideas about the law, but the living law renewed in the heart through an inflow of love that produces a character like Christ's and shows the law written in the heart.RH May 20, 1902
True preaching agitates the community and demands a complete revolution of practice in those who hear.RH Nov 29, 1853 Public preaching is not to be abandoned for a quiet and unobtrusive way merely because the subject is new or because hearers want time for quiet consideration without dispute.RH Nov 29, 1853 Truth must be pressed home to heart and conscience by public argument and lectures even when hearers complain of reproach and of stirring up the people.RH Nov 29, 1853
Preachers who avoid doctrines that offend the carnal mind do so to escape a like complaint and to protect their influence.RH Jul 29, 1875 When the meaning of a saying is not grasped by the natural mind, hearers may speak against it and then turn back, distorting Scripture rather than accepting its practical meaning.ST Apr 10, 1893
People may come eagerly to hear yet resist its testing truth as too hard to accept.ST Aug 10, 1904 Merely hearing is not enough, for the message must be received and obeyed in practical life.ST Aug 10, 1904 Those who refuse it may meet it again as a witness against them in the judgment.ST Aug 10, 1904
Sources