Joshua 7:16
So Joshua rose up early in the morning, and brought Israel by their tribes; and the tribe of Judah was taken:
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
So Joshua rose up early in the morning, and brought Israel by their tribes; and the tribe of Judah was taken:
So Joshua rose early in the morning, and brought Israel by their tribes; and the tribe of Judah was taken:
Revised Version, American Standard Version
So Joshua rose up early in the morning, and brought Israel near by their tribes; and the tribe of Judah was taken:
And Joshua riseth early in the morning, and bringeth Israel near by its tribes, and the tribe of Judah is captured;
And Joshua rose early in the morning, and caused Israel to come forward by their tribes, and the tribe of Judah was taken.
So Joshua rose up early in the morning, and brought Israel near by their tribes,—and, the tribe of Judah, was seized;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So Joshua arose early the next morning and had Israel come forward tribe by tribe, and the tribe of Judah was selected.
So Joshua rose up early in the morning and brought Israel near by their tribes. The tribe of Judah was selected.
So Joshua got up early in the morning, and made Israel come before him by their tribes; and the tribe of Judah was taken;
So Ioshua rose vp earely in the morning and brought Israel by their tribes: and the tribe of Iudah was taken.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Josue, therefore, when he rose in the morning, made Israel to come by their tribes, and the tribe of Juda was found,
Pictures

Cross-references
- Joshua 7:24-26
And Joshua, and all Israel with him, took Achan the son of Zerah, and the silver, and the garment, and the wedge of gold, and his sons, and his daughters, and his oxen, and his asses, and his sheep, and his tent, and all that he had: and they brought them unto the valley of Achor.
Achan’s concealed sin is exposed, and he and his household are punished.
- Joshua 7:1-5
But the children of Israel committed a trespass in the accursed thing: for Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, took of the accursed thing: and the anger of the LORD was kindled against the children of Israel.
Achan’s sin brought Israel’s defeat at Ai.
- Joshua 7:11-12
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
Israel’s disobedience brought national guilt and the loss of God’s help.
- Joshua 7:21
When I saw among the spoils a goodly Babylonish garment, and two hundred shekels of silver, and a wedge of gold of fifty shekels weight, then I coveted them, and took them; and, behold, they are hid in the earth in the midst of my tent, and the silver under it.
Achan confesses coveting, taking, and hiding the spoil.
- Joshua 6:18-19
And ye, in any wise keep yourselves from the accursed thing, lest ye make yourselves accursed, when ye take of the accursed thing, and make the camp of Israel a curse, and trouble it.
The warning explains what Achan took and why taking it was forbidden.
- Hosea 2:15
And I will give her her vineyards from thence, and the valley of Achor for a door of hope: and she shall sing there, as in the days of her youth, and as in the day when she came up out of the land of Egypt.
The Valley of Achor, a place of trouble, becomes a door of hope.
- Joshua 8:1-2
And the LORD said unto Joshua, Fear not, neither be thou dismayed: take all the people of war with thee, and arise, go up to Ai: see, I have given into thy hand the king of Ai, and his people, and his city, and his land:
After Achan’s punishment, Israel attacks Ai again and succeeds.
- Joshua 7:11
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
God identifies Israel’s sin and the concealed stolen goods.
- Acts 5:1-11
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Ananias and Sapphira’s concealed sin parallels Achan’s sin in Israel.
- Joshua 7:5
And the men of Ai smote of them about thirty and six men: for they chased them from before the gate even unto Shebarim, and smote them in the going down: wherefore the hearts of the people melted, and became as water.
Achan’s hidden sin is exposed as the cause of Israel’s defeat and thirty-six deaths.
- 1 Chronicles 2:7
And the sons of Carmi; Achar, the troubler of Israel, who transgressed in the thing accursed.
Achan is remembered as the troubler of Israel.
- Leviticus 27
And the LORD spake unto Moses, saying,
Defines what is devoted or set apart.
- Joshua 7:6
And Joshua rent his clothes, and fell to the earth upon his face before the ark of the LORD until the eventide, he and the elders of Israel, and put dust upon their heads.
Joshua and Israel’s elders mourn before the ark as the sin is exposed.
- Joshua 6:19
But all the silver, and gold, and vessels of brass and iron, are consecrated unto the LORD: they shall come into the treasury of the LORD.
The silver, gold, and metal vessels were consecrated to the Lord and placed in his treasury.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
55 sources
In obedience to special direction from the Lord, Joshua rose early in the morning and brought Israel forward by tribes before the Lord for solemn investigation, and the tribe of Judah was taken by divine selection.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–154T 492.2–3PP 494.2–495.1PP 497.2–3 The search then narrowed step by step from tribe to family to household to the individual, until Achan was singled out as the troubler of Israel.ST Sep 1, 1909Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–124T 492.2–3 The taking proves the Lord is acquainted with hidden dishonesty however men try to hide it, for He sees selfishness, avarice and deception and will bring them to account.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9ST May 5, 1881 One man's secret covetousness and theft brought guilt, a curse and God's displeasure upon the whole camp, so Israel could not stand before its enemies and suffered defeat.Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.2SG4 182.1–2 Hidden sin must therefore be searched out and dealt with promptly and put away, so the camp is cleansed and others are not contaminated.CH 672.25T 147.111MR 209.1–210.2
Morning Investigation Process
In obedience to special directions from the Lord, Joshua rose up early in the morning and brought Israel forward by tribes before the Lord for a solemn investigation into the sin in the camp.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15PP 494.2–495.1PP 497.2–3 Israel was thus brought tribe by tribe before the Lord as the hidden guilt was uncovered.ST Sep 1, 1909Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–12ST May 12, 1881 In that uncovering God searched out the guilt and showed that He knows what people misunderstand or misinterpret and can vindicate those who trust Him.ST May 12, 1881
The search narrowed step by step from tribe to family to household to the individual, with the tribe of Judah taken first.ST Sep 1, 1909Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–12PP 494.2–495.1PP 497.2–3 The lot fell on Judah, Achan's tribe, and the search then narrowed to his family and finally to him.ST Sep 1, 1909Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–124T 492.2–3 Through that narrowing Judah was selected and then a family, a household, and finally Achan, who was singled out and identified as the troubler of Israel.Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–124T 492.2–3PP 497.4PP 494.2–495.1PP 497.2–3
The taking of Judah was by divine selection, with God Himself pointing out the hidden wrongdoer through the process He showed.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15Ms 81, 1893, par. 85–87Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 The guilty person had not been named beforehand, but those responsible had to identify him by the process God showed them.Ms 81, 1893, par. 85–87 When those in charge do their duty God Himself thus points out the hidden wrongdoer, proving He will not tolerate covered sin.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20
The investigation followed Israel being driven before its enemies at Ai because one man's secret sin brought guilt and a curse upon the whole camp.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–51T 139.2SG4 182.1–2 That hidden theft was an accursed thing in the midst so Israel could not stand before its enemies until it was taken away, and God required the people to sanctify themselves while His Spirit searched out the concealed sin and the camp had to be cleansed.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–51T 139.2SG4 182.1–2 The bringing by tribes belongs to the march from Gilgal to the overthrow of Jericho and the conquest of Ai, and to the account of Achan meeting the dire penalty of his sin with his household and all he possessed at Gilgal, where the curse was wiped from Israel.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2ST Jul 27, 1882PP 613.3–614.2
Nature of Achan's Sin
Achan coveted a wedge of gold and a Babylonish garment and kept them contrary to God's directions, hiding what he had taken, including what was dedicated to God.1T 139.2Ms 12, 1862, par. 15–19Lt 11, 1870, par. 8Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 His secret keeping made the hidden thing an accursed thing in the midst of Israel, so that one man's coveting and hiding brought guilt and defeat upon the whole camp until it was searched out and taken away.1T 139.2Ms 12, 1862, par. 15–19Lt 11, 1870, par. 8Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 He acted knowingly against God's command, and his concealed theft and disobedience were charged against the whole people and ended with his destruction.Ms 12, 1862, par. 15–19Lt 11, 1870, par. 8Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 His destruction with his household and all he possessed wiped the curse from Israel.1T 139.2
His covetousness did not spring up at once but grew gradually until it became a ruling habit that led to ruin.PP 496.2–3ST Sep 1, 1909 He cherished greed until it deadened his judgment and left him to fall when temptation came.PP 496.2–3ST Sep 1, 1909 His history and its terrible results teach the seriousness of violating the tenth commandment.PP 496.2–3
His covetousness, theft, and taking of what was dedicated to God brought Israel defeat and caused the loss of thirty-six lives.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24 God regards such sins as grievous, and professed righteousness does not hide them.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24 His deliberate concealment and dissembling made the wrongdoing especially grievous and brought God's displeasure upon all Israel's armies.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24Lt 13, 1869, par. 14–15
His fall shows that temptation can bring a person to ruin even when feeling secure, and that temptation cannot be resisted in one's own strength.4MR 218.3–220.2Lt 58, 1880, par. 5 For that reason Israel was warned to shun idolatry and close ties with idolaters, including intermarriage, and to shun even the borders of sin, because compromise could lead to ruin.4MR 218.3–220.2 God is faithful both to His promises and to His warnings, and the review of past failure is to inspire gratitude for His care and humility about not following His revealed will, a lesson to be applied personally.4MR 218.3–220.2
God Exposes Hidden Sin
The taking of Judah first shows obedience to special directions from the Lord, with Joshua rising early in the morning and bringing Israel forward by tribes so that divine selection itself pointed out the hidden wrongdoer as the first step toward exposing the offender.Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–12Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15 That taking proves the Lord is acquainted with the hidden things of dishonesty however men try to hide them, for He is in earnest and jealous and cannot look upon iniquity or let it pass without being exposed.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 God’s search proceeded by identifying the guilty tribe, thereby bringing concealed selfishness, avarice, and deception to light, for He sees such sins and will bring them to account.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9ST May 5, 1881 In the solemn time when truth must meet principalities and powers and the rulers of the darkness of this world and spiritual wickedness in high places, harboring falsehood, dissembling, and dishonesty like Achan’s causes loss of power and leaves God’s people unable to stand before their enemies.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 Every person has an open case between himself and God and must individually seek God’s glory and the success of His cause, put away everything offensive, make straight paths for the feet, hold the fort, make an entire consecration of soul and body to do God’s will, and let conviction become a working agent that reaches the heart and purifies the soul temple of defilement, not stopping till sin is corrected and put away.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 Achan’s destruction looks terrible but was necessary because the same principles that controlled him had been brought into his family, and that influence would have been dangerous to all Israel.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9
The deliberate, step-by-step sifting was a lesson never to be forgotten, given by having Joshua act early to present the people by tribes until Judah was pointed out, in order to expose the hidden sin in the camp and bring the guilty to confession.18MR 143.4–144.1Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5 Israel was brought tribe by tribe so the person responsible for the defeat at Ai could be identified, for Achan’s hidden theft had brought defeat on Israel though the people did not know what he had done, the camp had to be cleansed, and God’s Spirit searched out the concealed sin to expose the accursed thing.18MR 143.4–144.1Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5 That same lesson requires hidden wrongdoing to be exposed and removed, with each person examining personal conduct before judging others.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5
Although the guilt was being exposed, Achan did not confess but braved it out as though innocent while the sifting continued from Judah to a family to a household and finally to himself, the Lord’s directions exposing him though the guilt was hidden.Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–12Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–154T 492.2–3 When the lot fell on Judah, Achan’s tribe, and the search then narrowed to his family and finally to him, his fear did not lead him to confess, and he was exposed as guilty.Lt 13, 1893, par. 9–124T 492.2–3 He stayed silent even after he knew the crime had been exposed, and confessed only when he could no longer conceal his guilt.4T 492.2–3PP 497.4 That late admission did not show genuine repentance, for it came in hope of escaping the consequences, not from sorrow for sin or a changed purpose.PP 497.4
The concealed sin in the midst of Israel offended God, who knew all about it, and though by His mighty power He had done a great and glorious work for Israel, that sin barred His way so He could not do what He would, just as the world’s Redeemer could not do many mighty works in certain places because of unbelief.3T 239.1–3Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15 God withheld His blessing, thousands died in battle, and He would not go into battle with Israel while concealed sin remained among them, showing that one person’s hidden transgression could bring judgment and trouble on the whole camp.3T 239.1–3Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15 Achan did not hold a holy office, and his position did not make the sin less serious.3T 239.1–3 God’s people are therefore responsible to clear the way by discipline, by cleansing themselves from all filthiness of the flesh and perfecting holiness in the fear of the Lord, by calling sin by its right name and putting it away, hating the sin but loving the sinner, so God can work for them.Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15
Trouble Upon All Israel
One man's secret sin brought guilt and a curse and God's displeasure upon the whole camp, so that Israel could not succeed against its enemies while the sin remained and was driven before them in defeat.Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.2SG4 182.1–23T 239.1–33T 519.1 Achan coveted a golden wedge and a Babylonish garment and hid what he had taken, and that hidden thing was an accursed thing in the midst of Israel so that Israel could not stand before its enemies until it was taken away.Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.2SG4 182.1–2 His concealed transgression brought trouble on all Israel, God withheld His blessing and would not go into battle with them while concealed sin remained, thousands died in battle, and the whole congregation suffered for one man's transgression with judgment coming also upon his family.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–23T 239.1–3ST May 12, 1881 The sin of one man discomfited the entire army, and a wrong course pursued by one person toward his brother turns the light of God away from His people until the wrong is searched out and the cause of the oppressed is vindicated.3T 519.1
The accursed thing had to be exposed and removed, with the people required to sanctify themselves and with God Himself pointing out the hidden wrong through the taking of tribe and family and household until the guilty one was singled out.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2ST May 12, 1881 That sifting ended with the destruction of Achan with his household and all he possessed to wipe the curse from Israel and remove it from among them.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2 After Achan was punished God's wrath against Israel was turned away, and Joshua was commanded to advance against Ai again.ST May 12, 1881
The whole church bears responsibility and comes under God's rebuke when it knowingly makes light of a member's or minister's defects, as Israel did because of Achan, having failed in its duty by failing to be vigilant to detect sin and to deal with sin among its people.3T 239.1–3EDFCP 5.2–4ST May 12, 1881PP 519.4–520.2 Israel was rebuked for failing to detect the sin among them and then promptly sought it out, showing the duty to search out hidden guilt rather than pass it by.ST May 12, 1881PP 519.4–520.2 Achan did not hold a holy office, and his position did not make the sin less serious.3T 239.1–3
The evil was not confined to the sinner but corrupted others and withheld God's blessing from the church until purged by repentance and change of course.Ms 52, 1902, par. 8–918MR 147.5–6 Backbiting and slander, cherishing envy and hatred, going as talebearers, accusing and condemning, blackening character, and carrying false reports that cause hearers to lose the Spirit of God, are worse than Achan's sin because their influence spreads to many and defiles them.Ms 52, 1902, par. 8–918MR 147.5–6 Like that sin they are a root of bitterness whereby many are defiled, corrupting minds and spirits, and God cannot bless the church till this evil is removed.Ms 52, 1902, par. 8–918MR 147.5–6
Cleansing the Church Today
Hidden wrongdoing among God's people cannot be left covered or excused but must be searched out and dealt with without delay, with the sinner required either to put away sin or to be separated from fellowship, so that others are not contaminated and the camp is cleansed and others learn to fear God.CH 672.25T 147.111MR 209.1–210.27MR 210.1–2Ms 9, 1880, par. 47–54 Reformers who treasure solemn, purifying truths must lift the standard far higher and choose poverty, reproach, separation from friends, or any suffering even unto death rather than defile the soul with sin or transgress God's law.5T 147.1 Thorough work is required to cleanse the camp from Achans, for sin and sinners left in the church contaminate others, and those in responsible positions must not allow sin to remain in a brother but must show him he must put it away or be separated.CH 672.25T 147.1
Those who do wickedly and refuse to repent after the admonitions and warnings of God's faithful messengers are as Achan in the camp, deceived and deceiving, and must not be retained on the books or in fellowship but must be disfellowshipped, lest the saints be held accountable for evil deeds.11MR 209.1–210.2Lt 215, 1902, par. 1–10 To retain them would be an insult to the God of heaven.11MR 209.1–210.2Lt 215, 1902, par. 1–10 Nor is one guilty of serious wrongdoing fit to be treated as qualified for public ministry or fellowship while the sin remains unaddressed, for hidden or tolerated sin can bring the curse upon the whole community.Lt 51, 1888, par. 22–23
God Himself points out the hidden wrongdoer when those in charge do their duty, for He will not tolerate covered sin, and what He did with Israel then lays responsibility on all who stand in high positions of trust, for He has not changed and is the same in the gospel as in ancient Israel.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 If those who know the truth become careless and pass by sin in their midst, He holds them equally responsible with the open transgressor, and hidden sins forfeit His favor.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 Leaders and teachers must therefore closely guard righteousness and judgment, refuse to let things drift or treat sin as unimportant, give youth a right impression of sin and uncleanness, and labor diligently to separate the Achans from the camp.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 The same spirit that possessed Achan is still at work unrepented and unpurged in men in important positions, because restoration has not been made and there has been no falling on the Rock and being broken, and there is no hope for God's institutions unless leading men let the Word into the mind, lest deceptions enveloped in mist and fog growing blacker than velvet come so they never know at what they stumble.Ms 88, 1900, par. 15–17 Joshua acted under a special duty and burden laid on him by God to reprove and correct prevailing sins with discretion so the frown might be turned away, and those who do not have that discretion and duty must not hinder, question, doubt, find fault with, or accuse of a wicked fault-finding spirit those who do, for God is not to be trifled with and His warnings cannot be disregarded with impunity.3T 270.1
Imperceptible covetousness, selfishness, love of money and love of the world through the ranks of Sabbath-keepers destroys the spirit of sacrifice and takes the sacrifice from God's altar, and unless rooted out brings certain destruction as sure as Achan's.1T 140.1SG4 183.1RH Jan 13, 1863 Those with it in the heart are unaware of it because it gains upon them imperceptibly as they love the world and its gain and increase, and unless there is an entire change with arising to renew strength and covenant, sacrificing for God and denying self for truth's sake, they will perish with the world.1T 140.1RH Jan 13, 1863 Means are not man's own but lent by God who made men His stewards, and to call them one's own and hoard them brings swift loss when His prospering hand is removed and all is snatched away in a moment.1T 140.1RH Jan 13, 1863 The loftiness of man is soon to be brought down and the pride of man humbled, with kings and nobles, rich and poor alike bowing when the withering plagues of God fall.1T 140.1RH Jan 13, 1863
God judges as Achan's sin all robbery of His cause, seeing every case and passing judgment as He did on Achan.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 This includes workers who measure themselves by themselves and compare themselves among themselves over wages, becoming dissatisfied and wanting to be greatly favored, saying if another receives so much they should receive as much, selling to the highest bidder, becoming wise above what is written, practicing double-dealing, and appropriating means for their own use and robbing the treasury with the evil leaven of selfishness and covetousness surrounded by unbelief.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23 It includes selfishly taking funds from an institution's treasury, and selfish neglect, withholding means from the field where God appointed it, and taking means by hard dealing, which is robbery in every sense, an abuse of His Spirit, and a thing He hates.Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 Such dishonest sacred work dishonors God and will be revealed, and is not met by divided, feeble, half-hearted and unwilling payments but requires clean work and full restitution of both principal and interest with everything possible done to redeem the past and a turn from sin to righteousness.Lt 80, 1897, par. 4–5Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 Until that is done those responsible walk without light, with blinded spiritual discernment and no real sense of justice and mercy and equity and truth, questioning, criticizing, envying and excusing themselves contrary to His plain will, and such men are not with God and cannot give the right mold to the work nor supply the necessities of laborers in hard fields.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6
Corrupt hearts with selfishness and exaltation, wanting to be foremost when God and brethren did not place them there, weigh God's people down as clogs, so the work progresses but little, truth takes little effect, few are added, and servants are discouraged.SG4 167.1–2 A wrong course pursued by one person toward his brother turns the light of God away from His people until the wrong is searched out and the cause of the oppressed is vindicated.3T 519.1 God gives such opportunity to reform and enlightens them as to love of self and other sins, but when they will not heed and will not be reformed He in mercy rids the church of them and gives them up to their own ways to be filled with their own doings, so the honest are enlightened and remain.SG4 167.1–2 Then God's people must show tender feelings and discrimination, with enlarged hearts and broad and deep feelings, noble sympathy, largeness of soul and disinterested benevolence, and the church can triumph in God, for just as long as selfishness is allowed to dry up kindly sympathy and tender thoughtful love and interest for brethren, every virtue will be corroded.3T 519.1
In a solemn time when truth must meet principalities and powers and rulers of darkness and spiritual wickedness in high places, harboring falsehood, dissembling and dishonesty leaves God's people without power to stand before enemies, and every person has an open case between himself and God.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 Each must individually seek God's glory and the success of His cause, examine personal conduct before judging others, put away everything offensive, make straight paths for the feet, hold the fort, make entire consecration of soul and body to do His will, and let conviction become a working agent reaching the heart and purifying the soul temple until sin is corrected and put away.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 Sin must be called by its right name and put away, with all filthiness cleansed and holiness perfected in His fear, hating the sin but loving the sinner, so He can work for His people and clear the way barred by sin as unbelief limited mighty works elsewhere.Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15 Review of past failures is to inspire gratitude for His care and humility over failure to follow His revealed will, applied personally with shunning even the borders of sin, for He is faithful both to promises and to warnings.4MR 218.3–220.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
68 sources
After the shameful defeat at Ai with thirty-six men killed, Joshua rose early in the morning and brought Israel forward by tribes before the Lord, and the tribe of Judah was taken as the first narrowing step toward the guilty man.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 1, 1910 That defeat came from hidden sin in the camp joined with self-confidence, when Israel attacked little Ai in its own strength with a few men without seeking God.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Apr 30, 1912RH Apr 20, 1911 One man's covetous theft of what was devoted to the Lord brought trouble, loss of victory and humiliation upon all Israel, because God's people are bound together as one body so that cherished sin in one weakens the whole camp.RH Dec 1, 1910ST Aug 1, 1911ST Mar 17, 1909ST Apr 30, 1912 God's ordered search by tribe to family to household to man made the guilt clear and gave Achan time to confess voluntarily, but he stayed silent over his hidden treasure until confession was forced and too late.RH Sep 23, 1873RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1873ST Jun 13, 1906RH Oct 16, 1856 Victory came only after the sin was searched out, confessed and put away by destruction of the transgressor, opening the way to advance again and turning the valley of trouble into the door of hope.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Aug 1, 1911ST Feb 14, 1906RH Dec 31, 1914ST Nov 15, 1899
Defeat At Ai Setting
Joshua 7:16 stands after the victory at Jericho, when Israel was defeated at Ai with thirty-six men killed, bringing national shame and melted hearts and leaving Joshua and the elders mourning with torn garments and dust before the ark.RH Dec 1, 1910ST Feb 23, 1915RH Dec 2, 1873RH Oct 4, 1870RH Apr 28, 1904 The defeat came because hidden sin was in the camp through Achan taking gold and silver and other things from Jericho that were consecrated for the treasury of the Lord and hiding them among his own goods for himself, so that what was consecrated to be a blessing became the accursed thing when appropriated to common use.RH Dec 1, 1910ST Feb 23, 1915RH Dec 2, 1873RH Oct 4, 1870 Though the people did not know sin had been committed, they were smitten before their enemies and their hearts became as water, and the failure to trust God delayed possession of the land.ST Mar 21, 1911RH Dec 2, 1873RH Oct 4, 1870 The morning search in which Joshua brought the tribes before the Lord and Judah was selected began the process by which Achan was identified as the guilty man.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Dec 2, 1873RH Oct 4, 1870
The loss at Ai came from the undetected presence of sin joined with self-confidence after the victory at Jericho, which had been given wholly by God's power while Israel only marched with the ark.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Apr 30, 1912RH Apr 20, 1911 Made self-confident, Israel attacked little Ai in its own strength with only a few men without seeking God to know what He would have them do.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Apr 30, 1912RH Apr 20, 1911 They failed to seek Him even after the first defeat to learn the cause, and the defeat that followed brought humiliation before final triumph came through faith.ST Apr 30, 1912RH Apr 20, 1911
The action belongs on the march from Gilgal to the overthrow of Jericho and the attempt on Ai, where Israel met the penalty of sin.ST Jul 27, 1882ST Feb 14, 1906 It took place in the narrow defile leading from the plain of Jordan with its palm-trees and fertility and rest up to the highlands of Canaan.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906 Israel pressed on up the glen past the place of judgment, with the conquest of Jericho behind and the strong enemy and narrow way ahead.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906
The exposing and punishment of the sinner left a corpse under a pile of stones, stiff and stark below his cairn, after swift and terrible punishment purged the camp and restored victory.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 13, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906 The place was called the Valley of Achor, meaning trouble, and the name came to stand for trouble and for sorrow and despair.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 13, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906 It remains a rugged valley of defeat and sharp justice, where the trouble of exposure gives new hope only when sorrow drives to God by standing in faith in His grace and living in conscious fellowship of peace with Him.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906
Early Morning Tribal Search
After the defeat Joshua rose early in the morning and brought Israel forward by their tribes before the Lord to identify the person responsible for the trespass, and the tribe of Judah was taken as the first step in exposing the hidden sin in the camp.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916RH Apr 8, 1902 That morning action began the tracing of guilt to Achan the son of Carmi the son of Zabdi the son of Zerah.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Sep 28, 1916 Israel was brought before the Lord tribe by tribe, with Judah selected in the process that exposed Achan's sin and showed that hidden covetousness and deceit bring trouble upon the whole community until brought to light and dealt with.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Dec 2, 1858
The search narrowed in order from tribe to family to household to individual, from all Israel to Judah to Achan.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Sep 23, 1873RH Jul 29, 1909RH Jul 29, 1909 It proceeded by lot from all Israel's tribes to Judah, then to his family and household, selecting first a tribe, then a family, then individuals, the same manner of choosing by lot used to identify a tribe in the selection of a king in Joshua 7:16-18.RH Sep 23, 1873ST Jul 1, 1903RH Oct 16, 1856 The careful step-by-step proceeding made the guilt clear as the search closed in, so Israel would have no reason to claim that an innocent person had suffered.RH Sep 23, 1873RH Oct 16, 1856 When Judah was selected Achan had increasing reason to fear that he would be exposed, yet saw the search closing in through Judah's families and households without confessing, proving his sin was not safely hidden.RH Oct 16, 1856RH Jul 29, 1909
The casting of lots gave him time and opportunity to confess voluntarily, to deliberate, repent and make restitution and make right his wrong.RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873 He had plenty of time to deliberate before he was taken, even while watching the chiefs of his own tribe lamenting and knowing his buried gold in the middle of his tent was the root of the bitterness, yet he had no idea of repenting or restoring.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873 He valued his treasure more than the lives and happiness of his people and even the fate of his nation, remained silent and gloated over his booty until his confession was forced.RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873RH Jul 29, 1909 That forced confession came too late to save him and too late to lead to true repentance, after the people had been humbled and the guilty man found.RH Apr 8, 1902ST Jun 13, 1906
Nature Of Achan's Trespass
Achan took what had been devoted and set apart for the treasury of the Lord as the first-fruits of the spoils of Canaan, to be brought into the sanctuary and converted to sacred use, and hid it among his own goods for himself.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Dec 2, 1873RH Apr 8, 1902 What was consecrated to be a blessing if placed in the Lord's treasury became the accursed thing when appropriated to common use, and to be an Achan is to have the Lord's money among one's own stuff and to be dishonest as a steward in handling what belongs to another.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Apr 14, 1910 God requires what is set apart for Him to remain dedicated to Him, for He is exact in His requirements and withholding what is holy brings a reckoning, even though His mercy is long-suffering, and the victory at Jericho and its spoils belonged to Him.ST Oct 15, 1902RH Apr 8, 1902
Going sword in hand over the prostrate wall into a great house in Jericho, perhaps a great man's dwelling or the king's palace, he coveted and took for his own possession a goodly Babylonish garment woven entirely of gold and fit for a king, two hundred shekels of silver probably in a wrought purse or bag, and a wedge of gold of fifty shekels weight.RH Dec 2, 1873ST Apr 15, 1903 That wealth had been gained by vice and oppression and was sacred to idols, to Baal and Ashtaroth, yet consecrated to the Lord to be purged by fire so that the spoils of idols would decorate the tabernacle and the wrath of man would redound to the glory of the God of Heaven.RH Dec 2, 1873 Instead of considering how worthily they would grace the tabernacle, he hid God's property in a trench dug in the earth under his tent, taking gold and clothing contrary to God's command.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873ST Apr 15, 1903
Israel had been plainly warned not to take those devoted things, so the act was disobedience to God's express directions and command.RH Jun 1, 1916ST Apr 15, 1903RH Apr 8, 1902 Disobedience among a people who had witnessed His power is deeply offensive to Him and not to be lightly regarded, bringing His wrath, and disregard of His express directions must be dealt with decisively.RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 23, 1873 It was robbery of God whose eye as Owner was fixed on him, and it rested on thinking it made little difference whether God was obeyed.RH Dec 2, 1873ST Mar 5, 1912
The theft came from habitual covetousness, secret, wary, persistent and utterly obstinate.RH Dec 2, 1873 He kept guard neither over his eyes nor the lusts of his heart, but cherished greed until it became habit and deadened his judgment, leaving him to fall when temptation came.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 2, 1873 He loved the Babylonish garment, the silver shekels and the wedge of gold for themselves as a true miser, and his covetousness led him to take and hide the spoil, bringing defeat on Israel while his stolen wealth was destroyed.RH Nov 4, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873 That hidden covetousness with its concealed selfishness, avarice and deception was brought to light in the search from tribe to guilty man, warning that covetousness in God's people, though it may grow unnoticed and gradually, leads to destruction as surely as Achan's did.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1858
His family was like-minded and connected with him in the sin, sharing his crime by helping hide the spoil in the tent and standing with him in it in every respect.ST Apr 30, 1912RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873 Therefore as God is just they shared his doom, suffering death by stoning and fire with him.ST Apr 30, 1912RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873
One Sinner Troubles All
When Achan stole the devoted thing, the whole company was held accountable and punished until the sin was uncovered and the transgressor punished. RH Dec 2, 1858RH Apr 13, 1876 Though the people did not know that sin had been committed in their midst, they were smitten before their enemies for his sake and their hearts became as water so that they could not stand before their enemies. RH Oct 4, 1870RH Sep 23, 1873 As a body they were held responsible for sins in their midst, and judgment fell on his family while the whole congregation suffered for one man's transgression. ST May 12, 1881RH Sep 23, 1873
The hidden covetousness and deceit of one man brought trouble, defeat, loss of victory and humiliation upon all Israel. RH Dec 1, 1910RH Dec 2, 1858ST Aug 2, 1883 That one person's wickedness in the camp could bring discomfiture to the whole people, costing the defeat of the army and the lives of thirty-six men besides his own family. RH Oct 4, 1870RH Oct 1, 1901 It stands as an awful lesson of the fearful consequences and awful results of even one sin and sinner among God's people at the very beginning of the conquering of the Canaanites and the division of the land. ST Mar 17, 1909
God's people are bound together as one body in one, so if one sins others suffer in consequence. ST Aug 1, 1911ST Apr 30, 1912 The hidden transgression of one man prevented the blessing of the Lord from descending upon a whole people, and one member's cherished sin can hold back God's blessing from the whole people. ST Aug 1, 1911ST Jun 16, 1914 The presence of one Achan was sufficient to weaken the whole camp, so that Israel was defeated, lost a victory and was chased before enemies. RH Apr 14, 1910ST Nov 15, 1899 Sin within God's people can hinder the manifestation of God's power and the reception of the Holy Spirit, and the secret unholy life of one member renders the church almost powerless to accomplish good until the evil is gotten rid of and the guilty one is brought to punishment. RH Apr 14, 1910RH Oct 4, 1870ST Nov 15, 1899
One or a few hidden wrongdoers can hinder the usefulness of many, dividing members, spreading distrust, corrupting others and paralyzing efforts to save people. ST Apr 6, 1882 One sinner may diffuse darkness which excludes the light of God from the entire congregation and keeps God's light from the community. RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 23, 1873 Tolerating such disobedience to God's express directions can bring His displeasure and His frown upon the whole congregation, for disregard of His directions brings His wrath and disobedience is exceedingly offensive to Him and not to be lightly regarded. RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 23, 1873
The sifting begun here ended with Achan and his house taken to the valley of Achor and utterly destroyed by stoning and fire, and the valley's name came to stand for trouble, sorrow and despair. RH Sep 28, 1916ST Jun 9, 1898ST Apr 30, 1912 His crime received the same death penalty as murder, blasphemy, Sabbath-breaking, idolatry and disobedience to parents, showing that no one can sin against God with impunity and that influence for evil over the church cannot be hidden, for ways and thoughts hidden from men are known to God and angels. RH Aug 13, 1857RH Oct 4, 1870 This proves the penalty of death was attached to the other commandments equally with the Sabbath and not to the Sabbath alone. RH Apr 12, 1864 That death inflicted by men was punishment under the civil code of the Hebrew nation into which the ten commandments were for the time incorporated, representing final retribution, so when the Jewish polity ceased that civil infliction ceased while the real penalty to be inflicted by God as Lawgiver remains. RH Apr 12, 1864
God Searches And Exposes
Joshua 7:16 shows God's ordered, heart-searching work that brings concealed selfishness, avarice and deception to light by bringing Israel forward tribe by tribe until Judah was taken as the step that uncovered Achan's sin.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1873RH Feb 19, 1857 Hidden sin cannot stay hidden, for what is concealed from men is known to God and angels and will be brought to account, and Achan could not conceal his sin from God though he tried to hide it.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1873RH Jul 3, 1860 He knew the gold buried in the middle of his tent was the root of the bitterness while he watched the chiefs of his own tribe lamenting over defeat at Ai with thirty-six dead, national shame, melted hearts, and mourning with torn garments and dust before the ark, yet he refused the open chance to confess and restore because he valued his treasure more than the lives and happiness of his people and even the fate of his nation.RH Dec 2, 1873 The account therefore stands as a warning that hidden sin among God's people will be found out, and that every person must answer to Him for secret as well as open sins.RH Feb 19, 1857RH Jul 3, 1860
God would just as surely have revealed that hidden sin before the march on Ai as afterward if Joshua and the leaders had been living in abiding fellowship of the Holy Spirit with spiritual discernment to detect sin and put it away.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 In thus searching out guilt He shows that He knows what people misunderstand or misinterpret and can vindicate those who trust Him.ST May 12, 1881 To be accursed in this account is to be set apart for destruction under the ban, devoted to extirpation and annihilation.ST Jan 18, 1877RH Jun 11, 1872
The bringing of Israel forward by tribes to expose the offender, ending in death by stoning, proves the penalty of death was attached to the other commandments equally with the Sabbath, not to the Sabbath alone.RH Apr 12, 1864 That death inflicted by men was punishment under the civil code of the Hebrew nation into which the ten commandments were for the time incorporated, representing final retribution.RH Apr 12, 1864 When the Jewish polity ceased that civil infliction ceased, while the real penalty to be inflicted by God as Lawgiver remains.RH Apr 12, 1864
Cleansing Opens Future Victory
Victory came only after the sin was put away, for hidden sin had to be confessed before the people could receive God's help.ST Aug 1, 1911RH Sep 11, 1913 Achan was sifted out and removed before Israel was prepared to advance by faith into the promised inheritance, since one member's cherished sin can hold back God's blessing from the whole people who are bound together as one body.ST Aug 1, 1911RH Dec 31, 1914 The searching by tribes begun here belonged to Israel's need to be cleansed, with Judah identified first as the tribe from which the offender would be found, showing that sin within God's people can hinder the manifestation of God's power until the church is cleansed of such sin.ST Nov 15, 1899 After Achan was punished God's wrath against Israel was turned away, and Joshua was commanded to advance against Ai again.ST May 12, 1881
A cleansed and purified camp makes the valley of Achor the door of hope and opens the way for great victories for God to follow great reformation of heart and life.RH Sep 28, 1916 The loss at Ai came from the undetected presence of sin in the camp joined with self-confidence in sending only a few men to take the city, and the sifting begun the morning after the defeat in bringing Israel forward tribe by tribe, with Judah taken first in tracing guilt to Achan the son of Carmi the son of Zabdi the son of Zerah, ended with Achan and his house taken to the valley of Achor and utterly destroyed.RH Sep 28, 1916 Complicity of God's people with an evil world works weakness and defeat, as Achan's covetousness in taking miserable spoil from a tent broke God's law and brought shame on Israel's ranks in the narrow defile leading from the plain of Jordan to the highlands of Canaan, but being taught by trouble and purging the accursed thing makes disaster a way for hope to come again, with swift terrible punishment purging the camp and restoring victory as Israel pressed on up the glen past Achan lying stiff and stark below his cairn.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Feb 14, 1906 That rugged valley of defeat and sharp justice was named Achor meaning trouble, marking the corpse left under a pile of stones after the conquest of Jericho behind with its palm-trees, fertility and rest.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Feb 14, 1906 The trouble of that exposure gives new hope only when sorrow drives to God, by standing by faith in His grace and living in conscious fellowship of peace with Him and rejoicing in hope, for hope is the brightness before God's face and comes from looking at Him in the blue sky above the pass, not from fixing the eyes on past victory at Jericho, nor on the judged sinner under the stones, nor on the narrow way and strong enemy ahead.ST Feb 14, 1906
If the people had surrendered fully to God and allowed no Achan in the camp, they could have entered their promised rest in Joshua's day, with the victory at Jericho continuing throughout the land and God's power displayed to the world, since Achan's presence kept Israel from being wholly devoted to God.ST Jan 22, 1894 God may permit defeat because He is not glorified or to try the faith of His people, yet that defeat at the wicked city of Ai followed by conquest when they went again under different circumstances does not forbid going again.ST Sep 26, 1906 When those connected with the work so relate themselves to Him that He receives the glory, they may build again and conquer.ST Sep 26, 1906 The disaster at Ai caused by Achan's disobedience at Jericho was chastisement for moral dereliction to all influenced by his spirit and at the same time a trial of faith to all, even to Joshua, and the early-morning bringing of Israel by tribes with Judah taken belongs to that wise purpose, whether for correction or for trial of faith, by which all things work together for good to them that love God, so that grief over such chastisement should be not for material loss but for the slack morals that made it necessary, and no catastrophe to God's people however fatal in appearance can shorten the arm of the Lord.ST Aug 8, 1906
As Achan was to Israel so Ananias and his wife were to the early church, except the manifest presence of the Holy Ghost and Peter's spiritual insight detected and put away their sin beforehand and turned possible defeat into revival with multitudes added to the Lord.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 God would just as certainly have revealed Achan's hidden sin before the march on Ai if Joshua and the leaders had been living in abiding fellowship of the Holy Spirit with spiritual discernment to detect sin and put it away.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 The whole account stands written for admonition upon whom the ends of the world are come.RH Sep 28, 1916
Call To Put Away Sin
Sin must not be excused and covered up but diligently searched out and put away, for perpetual failure in life and labor comes from cherished hidden sin in heart or life.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Jun 16, 1914 Each person must let memory and the Spirit reveal the history of his life, examine his ways, and individually be right with God.ST May 12, 1881ST Jun 16, 1914 Each must clear the King's highway by confession and faithfulness, for if obstacles are not removed in that way they will be removed by an overwhelming scourge from the Almighty.ST Jun 16, 1914 The morning search tribe by tribe that took Judah first and traced guilt to Achan the son of Carmi the son of Zabdi the son of Zerah shows Israel promptly seeking out sin after defeat at Ai, when the undetected presence of sin joined with self-confidence in sending only a few men had cost the victory.ST May 12, 1881RH Sep 28, 1916
When darkness settles upon God's people and they do not know the cause, they must earnestly seek Him in great humility and self-abasement until the wrongs which grieve His Spirit are searched out and put away.RH Sep 23, 1873 Disobedience hinders the work of God today, for God is particular with reference to obedience and obedience is more acceptable than sacrifice.RH Jun 16, 1863RH Sep 23, 1873 Obedience is an individual work that no other can cover, as the obedience of Moses and Aaron and the elders could not cover other sin, just as the whole camp was stayed for complaining Miriam.RH Jun 16, 1863 Only when hearts are examined and every clog and weight is put away will the work move on in power, when believers walk up to the light, keep the commandments fully, have the faith of Jesus, live holy lives, pray fervently, give means, work together in order, and stand at their post in the whole armor.RH Jun 16, 1863
To be an Achan is to have the Lord's money among one's own stuff, to be dishonest as a steward in handling what belongs to another.RH Apr 14, 1910 Achan stole what belonged to God's treasury and mixed it with his own, and the presence of that one man was sufficient to weaken the whole camp, defeat Israel, lose the victory, and chase them before enemies.RH Jan 13, 1863RH Apr 14, 1910 Imperceptible, unrecognized covetousness, selfishness, love of money and love of the world dries up sacrifice, and calling what God lent as steward one's own and hoarding it while loving the world and its gain makes destruction as sure as Achan's.RH Jan 13, 1863 Unless it is rooted out by entire change, by arising to renew strength and covenant through sacrificing for God and denying self for truth's sake, hoarded wealth will be snatched away in a moment when the prospering hand is removed, and loftiness and pride will be brought down when rich and poor alike bow under withering plagues and those unchanged perish with the world.RH Jan 13, 1863 God requires what is set apart for Him to remain dedicated to Him, for He is exact in His requirements and withholding what is holy brings a reckoning, though His mercy is long-suffering.ST Oct 15, 1902
The execution of Achan for covetousness stands as a striking and significant warning to be studied.ST Feb 4, 1886 It does not mean every covetous professor will be visibly struck down in this age.ST Feb 4, 1886 Covetousness shuts a man out of heaven as surely as lying, drunkenness, idolatry, or adultery, and liberality is as essential to being a Christian as faith, love, or prayer.ST Feb 4, 1886
An Achan in the soul is a hidden idol enthroned above God and stronger than God, dearest to the heart yet standing in the way of sanctification for years.ST Oct 16, 1879 It pulls a man suddenly from his knees in closet prayer to satisfy appetite and cuts short Bible reading to satisfy appetite.ST Oct 16, 1879 It must be torn from God's throne and dashed away at once in order to worship God only, and putting it away brings rejoicing.ST Oct 16, 1879 Entire consecration leaves nothing unyielded, uncovering and removing whatever is held back from God as the search of Israel uncovered Achan's hidden wrongdoing that had brought guilt upon the people.RH Feb 17, 1859
Tolerating sin can bring displeasure upon the whole congregation, for as a body God's people are held responsible for sins in their midst and one sinner may diffuse darkness which excludes His light from the entire congregation.RH Sep 23, 1873 Disregard of express directions brings wrath, and disobedience and sin are exceedingly offensive and not to be lightly regarded, especially among a commandment-keeping people honored with remarkable exhibitions of power.RH Sep 23, 1873 If those in responsible positions pass over the people's sins they virtually sustain and justify the sinner and are guilty alike with him and will receive displeasure just as surely.RH Jun 16, 1863RH Sep 23, 1873 The church must therefore at once take decided measures to put sin from them and purge out the Achans, until there is a company free from dead weights.RH Sep 3, 1872RH Sep 23, 1873 Those without living faith implanted in the heart will falter and depart from the holy little flock, while those who stand each trying test will soon shout victory, and the truly honest will heed the last loud cry until there is a company of Israelites indeed bound together by the Sabbath.RH Sep 3, 1872 So long as an Achan is in the camp the church cannot prosper and cannot move forward, whether a false worker whose presence hindered the work, an unconverted person bringing defeat as Achan's disobedience brought defeat at Ai, or an unconverted member whose dishonest business, selfishness, quarreling, tyranny at home, and reproach upon the truth hinder the work.RH Jun 16, 1863RH Feb 14, 1907RH Apr 3, 1913ST Dec 25, 1893
Sources