Joshua 7:18
And he brought his household man by man; and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
And he brought his household man by man; and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
and he brought his household man by man; and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
And he brought his household man by man; and Achan the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
and he brought near his household man by man; and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
and he bringeth near his household by men, and Achan — son of Carmi, son of Zabdi, son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah — is captured.
And he caused his household to come forward man by man, and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
and he brought near his household, man by man,—and, Achan son of Carmi son of Zabdi son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was seized.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And he had the family of Zabdi come forward man by man, and Achan son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was selected.
He brought near his household man by man, and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was selected.
Then the house of Zabdi came forward man by man, and Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, was taken.
And he brought his houshold, man by man, and Achan ye sonne of Carmi, the sonne of Zabdi, the sonne of Zerah of the tribe of Iudah was take.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And bringing his house man by man, he found Achan the son of Charmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zare of the tribe of Juda.
Pictures

Cross-references
- Joshua 7:11-12
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
Achan’s hidden theft brought guilt, defeat, and the loss of God’s presence.
- Joshua 7:24-26
And Joshua, and all Israel with him, took Achan the son of Zerah, and the silver, and the garment, and the wedge of gold, and his sons, and his daughters, and his oxen, and his asses, and his sheep, and his tent, and all that he had: and they brought them unto the valley of Achor.
Achan and his household are punished, and God’s anger is turned away.
- Joshua 7:1-5
But the children of Israel committed a trespass in the accursed thing: for Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, took of the accursed thing: and the anger of the LORD was kindled against the children of Israel.
Achan’s sin brings trouble and defeat upon Israel.
- Joshua 6:18-19
And ye, in any wise keep yourselves from the accursed thing, lest ye make yourselves accursed, when ye take of the accursed thing, and make the camp of Israel a curse, and trouble it.
God forbade taking Jericho’s devoted goods and consecrated its silver and gold to the Lord.
- Hosea 2:15
And I will give her her vineyards from thence, and the valley of Achor for a door of hope: and she shall sing there, as in the days of her youth, and as in the day when she came up out of the land of Egypt.
The Valley of Achor, named for Achan’s trouble, becomes a door of hope after cleansing.
- Acts 5:1-11
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Concealed sin is exposed and punished, like Achan’s.
- Joshua 7:11
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
Israel’s defeat and guilt are traced to Achan’s sin.
- Leviticus 27:28
Notwithstanding no devoted thing, that a man shall devote unto the LORD of all that he hath, both of man and beast, and of the field of his possession, shall be sold or redeemed: every devoted thing is most holy unto the LORD.
Both describe things devoted to the LORD as set apart and not redeemable.
- Joshua 7:13
Up, sanctify the people, and say, Sanctify yourselves against to morrow: for thus saith the LORD God of Israel, There is an accursed thing in the midst of thee, O Israel: thou canst not stand before thine enemies, until ye take away the accursed thing from among you.
God commands Israel to sanctify itself and remove the accursed thing.
- Joshua 7:5
And the men of Ai smote of them about thirty and six men: for they chased them from before the gate even unto Shebarim, and smote them in the going down: wherefore the hearts of the people melted, and became as water.
Defeat and thirty-six deaths reveal the consequences of hidden sin.
- Joshua 8:1-29
And the LORD said unto Joshua, Fear not, neither be thou dismayed: take all the people of war with thee, and arise, go up to Ai: see, I have given into thy hand the king of Ai, and his people, and his city, and his land:
After Achan’s punishment, Israel advanced against Ai and won.
- 1 Chronicles 2:7
And the sons of Carmi; Achar, the troubler of Israel, who transgressed in the thing accursed.
Records Achan, called Achar, as the troubler of Israel.
- Joshua 7:24
And Joshua, and all Israel with him, took Achan the son of Zerah, and the silver, and the garment, and the wedge of gold, and his sons, and his daughters, and his oxen, and his asses, and his sheep, and his tent, and all that he had: and they brought them unto the valley of Achor.
Lists the lineage and household members involved in the judgment.
- Genesis 46:12
And the sons of Judah; Er, and Onan, and Shelah, and Pharez, and Zerah: but Er and Onan died in the land of Canaan. And the sons of Pharez were Hezron and Hamul.
Zerah is named among Judah’s descendants who came down into Egypt.
- Joshua 6:19
But all the silver, and gold, and vessels of brass and iron, are consecrated unto the LORD: they shall come into the treasury of the LORD.
Achan kept for himself spoil consecrated to the LORD.
- 1 Samuel 10:20-21
And when Samuel had caused all the tribes of Israel to come near, the tribe of Benjamin was taken.
Saul was identified through a similar staged selection.
- 1 Samuel 15:3
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
illustrates devoted to destruction
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
55 sources
The verse records the final step of a God-directed sifting from tribe to family to household to man by man until Achan of Judah was taken as the one who had troubled Israel.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15 His taking exposed deliberate coveting, stealing, and hiding of what God had forbidden and devoted to destruction, bringing an accursed thing into the midst of the camp.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–23T 239.1–3Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24ST May 5, 1881 One man's transgression laid guilt, displeasure, and curse upon all Israel, so God could not be with them or give success in battle and they were driven back with loss of life.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.2 The accursed thing had to be removed by the destruction of Achan with his household and all he possessed, which wiped away the curse and turned away God's anger.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2ST May 12, 1881 The case therefore warns the church today to examine itself for hidden covetousness and sin that shuts out God's presence, to put it away by repentance and cleansing, lest blessing be withheld and destruction follow.PP 497.2–31T 140.1Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9SG4 183.1RH Jan 13, 1863
Investigation Identifying Achan
The verse records the final step of a God-directed, morning-by-morning sifting that narrowed from tribe to family to household and then man by man until Achan was taken.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15PP 494.2–495.1ST May 12, 1881 The lot first singled out Judah, then his family, then his household, and finally him personally as the individual.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–154T 492.2–3PP 494.2–495.1 He is named with his full ancestry as Achan, the son of Carmi, the son of Zabdi, the son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, and identified as the one who had troubled Israel.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15PP 494.2–495.1ST May 12, 1881
The Lord did not name Achan directly but showed the responsible men how to find him.Ms 81, 1893, par. 85–87Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 He Himself pointed out the hidden wrongdoer through the solemn step-by-step process when the sin was covered and unknown.Ms 81, 1893, par. 85–87Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20
Achan made no confession but braved it out as though innocent while the investigation narrowed until his guilt was fastened upon him.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–154T 492.2–3PP 497.4 He remained silent even after hearing that the crime had been exposed, and his guilty fear became visible as he was pointed out.4T 492.2–3PP 497.4 He confessed only when he could no longer hide it, and his admission came too late to benefit him.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 10–15PP 497.4 It did not show genuine repentance, because it lacked sorrow for sin, a changed purpose, and hatred of evil.PP 497.4
His identification was followed by a request for confession and by discovery of the stolen goods, establishing his guilt beyond question.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34 This was done so the people would not charge God with injustice or Joshua with harshness before punishment.ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 53, 1902, par. 31–34 The taking and meeting of the penalty occurred at Gilgal, Israel's first encampment in the promised land.ST Jul 27, 1882PP 613.3–614.2
Nature of Achan's Sin
The taking was for coveting, seizing, and secretly hiding what God had forbidden and devoted to destruction, a wedge of gold and a Babylonish garment, also called a Babylonian garment.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–23T 239.1–3Ms 12, 1862, par. 15–19Lt 11, 1870, par. 8 By secreting them he brought an accursed thing into the midst of Israel.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–23T 239.1–3Ms 12, 1862, par. 15–19 His secret keeping of the gold and the garment stands as dissembling and covering, a concealed sin whose influence is compared to wider harm through those joined to men in responsible positions.Lt 11, 1870, par. 8Lt 13, 1869, par. 14–15
The theft and concealment were deliberate, done with knowledge that taking the forbidden goods violated God's command.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 It was covetousness, theft, concealment, and misuse of what was dedicated to God, together with selfishness, greed, deception, dissembling, dishonesty, and falsehood.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24ST May 5, 1881Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 God sees hidden sin and brings it to light, regards these sins as grievous, and searches out those who cherish them to face His judgment, so that professed innocence cannot hide wrongdoing from Him.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24ST May 5, 1881 His sin cost thirty-six lives and was charged upon the whole camp.Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4
His covetousness had not sprung up at once but had grown gradually into a settled, binding habit.PP 496.2–3ST Sep 1, 1909 That habit dulled his judgment and moral perception and made him an easy prey to temptation when it came, so that he took what God had forbidden.PP 496.2–3ST Sep 1, 1909 He would have been horrified at the thought of bringing disaster on Israel, yet his history shows the grave consequences and ruin that follow, exposing covetousness as a deadly yet common sin often treated lightly.PP 496.2–3ST Sep 1, 1909
Hidden covetousness, selfishness, love of money, and love of the world can be gained imperceptibly and remain unrecognized in the heart, drying up sacrifice.SG4 183.1RH Jan 13, 1863 Taking the sacrifice from God's altar, treating means lent as stewards as one's own, hoarding it up, and loving the world and its gain and increase require an entire change to sacrificing for God and self-denying sacrifice for the truth's sake.SG4 183.1RH Jan 13, 1863 Unless rooted out by renewing covenant with God and renewing strength in Him, covetousness and love of the world bring sure destruction, so that those who hoard what God entrusted will have His prospering hand removed till all is snatched away in a moment and will perish with the world.SG4 183.1RH Jan 13, 1863
Taking means for personal use and demanding all one thinks one should have is robbing God's treasury and robbery in every sense of the word.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 It includes selfish appropriation of institutional and mission funds for one's own use, selling to the highest bidder, driving men in hard places, withholding means from the appointed field, becoming wise above what is written in the law, measuring self by self and comparing self with others, and double-dealing.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 God looks on workers in schools, institutions, and churches who do so exactly as He looked on the sin of Achan.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110 Such men are not with God but are surrounded by an atmosphere of unbelief, cannot give the right mold to the work, cannot supply the necessities of laborers in hard fields who sacrifice part of their wages, and cannot rightly serve the work, and God sees every such case and will pass judgment on them.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110 The hidden appropriation exposes abuse of the Spirit of God, lack of principle with perverted ideas that God hates, blindness in spiritual discernment with no real sense of justice and mercy and equity and truth, with excuses and unwillingness to make restitution, so that full clean work is required, with restitution of both principal and interest, before His censure is removed.Ms 97, 1899, par. 21–23Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6
The hidden covetous spirit that took possession of Achan still works in men in important positions.Ms 88, 1900, par. 15–17 It remains as a living, unrepented thing unless purged away by repentance, by making restoration, and by falling on the Rock and being broken.Ms 88, 1900, par. 15–17 Without letting the Word of the Lord into the mind and receiving a thorough transformation of heart softened and subdued by the love of Christ, there is no hope for God's institutions.Ms 88, 1900, par. 15–17 Then deceptions increasing blacker than velvet blind men who ought to know God and Jesus Christ, prayer with humble broken hearts is neglected, and God will surely humble those who will not humble themselves.Ms 88, 1900, par. 15–17
Sin Troubled All Israel
The singling out of Achan, son of Carmi, son of Zabdi, son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, man by man from his household, exposes how one man's hidden theft of what was devoted to destruction brought guilt, displeasure, rebuke and curse upon all Israel.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–5Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.23T 239.1–3Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24 While that forbidden, accursed thing — a golden wedge and a Babylonish garment coveted, taken and secreted — remained in the camp, God could not give success, be with them in battle, or bless them.Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–141T 139.23T 239.1–3 Israel was therefore driven before enemies, defeated, discomfited and weakened, losing thirty-six lives, until the people were told to sanctify themselves against the morrow and the camp was cleansed.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–51T 139.23T 519.1Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24 The searching out of the wrongdoer by God's searching Spirit shows that a wrong course pursued by one toward his brother turns God's light away from His people until the wrong is searched out and the cause of the oppressed is vindicated, and that professed innocence cannot hide grievous covetousness, theft, concealment and misuse of what was dedicated to God.Ms 12, 1893, par. 3–53T 519.1Lt 14a, 1893, par. 21–24
His sin was charged upon the whole camp, so the whole congregation suffered under God's offense even after He had done a great and glorious work for them by mighty power.ST May 12, 1881Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15Lt 51, 1888, par. 22–23Lt 19, 1887, par. 3–4 His offense brought judgment on his household as well as curse upon Israel as a community.ST May 12, 1881Lt 51, 1888, par. 22–23 The sin in the midst barred God's way so He could not do what He wanted, just as unbelief kept the Redeemer from doing many mighty works.Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15
His discovery when households were brought forward one by one revealed hidden sin among the people.ST May 12, 1881 It taught Israel that failing to be vigilant in uncovering sin among them brought God's rebuke for lack of vigilance.ST May 12, 1881PP 519.4–520.2
The same reckoning holds for defects of character in any member or minister when the church makes light of them, for they are then charged to the whole church and the whole church stands under rebuke.EDFCP 5.2–48MR 208.1 Knowingly placing over the flock as minister a man of known weakness of character, little moral power and present darkness assumes his defects and makes them its own, dishonoring God and lowering the standard of righteousness.EDFCP 5.2–4 Such knowing tolerance of evil, hiding the eyes from it and walking contrary to God's will, brings guilt more grievous than that of Israel over Achan.EDFCP 5.2–4
Punishment Cleansed the Camp
God required the accursed thing to be taken away and the people to sanctify themselves against the morrow, and Achan with his household and all that he possessed was destroyed, which wiped the curse from Israel, removed God's frown, and turned away His anger from Israel.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2ST May 12, 1881 The singling out man by man to Achan, son of Carmi, son of Zabdi, son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah, led to the execution of the divine sentence against him as the guilty one who had coveted and secreted the forbidden spoil.1T 139.2SG4 182.1–2ST May 12, 1881 Though the destruction looks terrible it was right, for the very same controlling principles had been brought into his family and that influence would have endangered Israel if left among them.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9 God is jealous, cannot look upon iniquity, and cannot let falsehood, dissembling, dishonesty and iniquity pass without exposure.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9
The special duty and burden was laid upon Joshua to exercise discretion in promptly searching out, reproving and correcting prevailing hidden wrong so the frown might be turned away, and the same responsibility rests on those in high positions of trust to guard righteousness and judgment, not to pass by sin or leave things to drift, but to work diligently to separate the Achans from the camp.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–203T 270.1 God has not changed but is the same in the gospel as in ancient Israel, still by His Spirit pointing out wrongdoers and showing He will not tolerate sin, deception, falsehood and moral corruption among His people.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 Those who act the part of Joshua will be questioned, doubted, found fault with and accused of a wicked fault-finding spirit, yet His warnings cannot be disregarded with impunity, and those who know the truth and hear His word daily and become careless will be held equally responsible with open transgressors when hidden sins cause loss of His favor.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–203T 270.1
Truth and purity require thorough work to cleanse the camp from Achans, for Achan stands for sin and sinners hidden under a cloak of godliness who contaminate others, and sin must be dealt with promptly so others are not contaminated and may fear God.CH 672.25T 147.17MR 210.1–2 Those in responsible positions must not suffer sin in a brother and must not cover up and excuse sin, but must show him he must either put away his sins or be separated and disfellowshipped from the church.CH 672.25T 147.17MR 210.1–2Lt 215, 1902, par. 1–10Ms 9, 1880, par. 47–54 Retaining those who do wickedly and refuse to hear admonition and warning and refuse to repent, after the record of Achan's exposure, is contrary to the will of God, dishonors God and insults heaven, for one who does evil and refuses to repent endangers the whole community.11MR 209.1–210.2Lt 215, 1902, par. 1–10 Backbiting is a corrupting evil that must likewise be purged before God can bless His people, and it is worse than Achan's sin.18MR 147.5–6 Cherishing envy and hatred against brethren, going as talebearers, accusing and condemning, blackening character, and carrying false reports that cause even the hearers to lose the Spirit of God, spreads not only in those who cherish it but as a root of bitterness whereby many are defiled, corrupting minds and spirits, and God cannot bless the church till it is purged unless the guilty repent and change their course.18MR 147.5–6
Warnings for Church Today
Achan's being taken man by man stands as warning that covetousness brings destruction as surely as his sin did, and that covetousness and love of the world, unless rooted out, end in destruction for those who hoard what God entrusted, who will perish with the world unless they change.1T 140.1SG4 183.1 Hidden covetousness, selfishness, love of money and love of the world can be gained imperceptibly and unrecognized in the heart, drying up sacrifice, and taking the sacrifice from God's altar and treating means lent as stewards as one's own and hoarding it up, with loving the world and its gain and increase, requires an entire change to sacrificing for God and denying self for truth's sake through renewing covenant with God and renewing strength in Him.RH Jan 13, 1863 Without that change God's prospering hand is removed so that all is snatched away in a moment.RH Jan 13, 1863 Review of his case warns that temptation can lead to a fall even when feeling secure and facing great danger, teaching not to trust personal strength to resist but to recognize danger and learn humility from past mistakes.4MR 218.3–220.2Lt 58, 1880, par. 5
Achans in the camp bring God's frown upon the whole church, for their corrupt hearts, selfishness, exaltation, love of self, and wanting to be foremost when God and brethren have not placed them there weigh God's people down with clogs, cause God's work to progress but little, discourage God's servants, and keep others from being added to the church.SG4 167.1–2 God gives such ones opportunity to reform and enlightens them as to their sins, but if they will not heed and be reformed He gives them up to their own ways to be filled with their own doings and in mercy rids the church of them, for which His peculiar people should praise God for the relief and remain unaffected by their influence.SG4 167.1–2 When the church suffers difficulty or spiritual decline, members should examine themselves with humility for hidden sin that shuts out God's presence, since one person's transgression could hold back God's blessing and weaken the whole community until the sin was found and put away.PP 497.2–3 Each person now has an open case with God in a solemn time of opposition and must earnestly seek God's glory, put away everything offensive to Him, make straight paths for the feet, hold the fort, make an entire consecration of soul and body to God, and let conviction reach the heart in purification of the soul temple from defilement, not stopping till every sin is corrected and put away, lest God leave His people to apparent defeat.Ms 13, 1894, par. 6–9
God searches out concealed wrongdoing and vindicates those who trust in Him, for hidden guilt brought to light when households were examined one by one shows professed innocence cannot hide wrongdoing.ST May 12, 1881 Dishonesty involving sacred things dishonors God and will be brought to light, calling for full repentance and restitution.Lt 80, 1897, par. 4–5 Such selfish taking of means belonging to God's cause by driving men in hard places and withholding means from the appointed field is robbery in every sense, an abuse of the Spirit of God and a lack of principle with perverted ideas that God hates, revealing blindness in spiritual discernment with no real sense of justice and mercy and equity and truth, with excuses and unwillingness to make restitution, so full clean work is required, with restitution of both principal and interest, before God's censure is removed.Lt 210, 1900, par. 4–6 Sins equal to Achan's in the Wellington community help explain lack of success there, showing the same lesson applies to sin hidden in a person's home or heart, called the accursed thing that had to be dealt with because while it remained God could not give success against enemies, which can hinder God's blessing and harm others.Lt 4, 1892, par. 10–14Lt 51a, 1893, par. 6–7
God's people must clear the way by discipline, by cleansing themselves from all filthiness of the flesh and perfecting holiness in the fear of the Lord, by hating sin while loving the sinner, by calling sin by its right name and putting it away instead of tampering with it until it no longer seems sinful, with every person responsible and cooperating so God can work, since sin in the camp barred His way so He could not do what He wanted, as unbelief hindered mighty works.Ms 13, 1894, par. 13–15 This places responsibility on those who stand in high positions of trust to guard righteousness and judgment, to not pass by sin and transgression or leave things to drift, and to work diligently to separate the Achans from the camp, for God has not changed and by His Holy Spirit still points out the wrongdoers and will not tolerate sin, deception, falsehood and moral corruption, holding those who know the truth and hear His Word daily equally responsible with open transgressors if they become careless, so that hidden sins among them cause loss of His favor.Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 Truth and purity require thorough work to cleanse the camp of the Achans, who stand for sin and sinners hidden in the church defiling the soul under a cloak of godliness, by promptly dealing with sin and sinners so others are not contaminated and may fear God, with those in responsible positions not suffering sin in a brother but showing him he must either put away his sins or be separated from the church.5T 147.17MR 210.1–2 As a people professing to be reformers treasuring the most solemn, purifying truths, the standard must be elevated far higher, with church members stopping covering up and excusing sin and acting at all times as in God's presence, realizing the eye of God is ever upon them and character, motives, desires, purposes and most secret thought are as clear as sunlight to Him, and every Christian choosing poverty, reproach, separation from friends, losses, suffering and even death before dishonor or transgression of God's law and before defiling the soul with sin.5T 147.17MR 210.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
64 sources
The verse records the last step of a sifting by lot from tribe to family to household to man by man, until Achan was singled out and taken.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 23, 1873 He is named by his full descent as son of Carmi, son of Zabdi, son of Zerah, of the tribe of Judah.ST May 12, 1881ST May 12, 1881RH Sep 28, 1916 The exposure came after Israel's defeat at Ai with thirty-six men fallen, when Joshua and the elders lay mourning before the ark, and it proved that sin hidden from men cannot stay hidden from God who Himself directed the discovery.ST Sep 1, 1909ST Mar 21, 1911ST Feb 23, 1915RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 2, 1873 His taking laid bare a covetous taking and hiding of what was devoted to God from Jericho, a Babylonish garment with silver and gold concealed in his tent, which robbed God and troubled all Israel.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Nov 4, 1873RH Aug 13, 1857ST Apr 30, 1912RH Dec 2, 1873 One man's trespass therefore brought defeat and shame on the whole body, and only by searching out the sin, confessing it, and purging the camp by judgment in the valley of Achor could anger be turned away and the way to victory and hope be opened again.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 23, 1873RH Sep 28, 1916
Identification and Setting
The verse records the final narrowing of a staged investigation by lot from tribe to family to household to man by man until Achan was taken.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 23, 1873RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1858 The households were brought forward one by one and examined one by one, tribe by tribe and family by family and person by person, until the guilty man was identified and selected.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 23, 1873RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1858RH Nov 4, 1873 The one taken is named by full ancestry as Achan son of Carmi son of Zabdi son of Zerah of the tribe of Judah.ST May 12, 1881ST May 12, 1881ST Jul 27, 1882RH Sep 28, 1916ST Oct 15, 1902 The line shows four generations from going into Egypt to reentering Canaan: Zerah son of Judah came from Canaan into Egypt, Zabdi son of Zerah was born in Egypt, Carmi was son of Zabdi, and Achan son of Carmi came into Canaan forty years after the exodus and sinned at the taking of Jericho, the first city taken in the land.RH Jan 2, 1913
The setting is Israel's defeat at Ai after the victory at Jericho, when Israel failed to trust God.ST Mar 21, 1911ST Feb 23, 1915RH Sep 28, 1916ST Apr 30, 1912ST Feb 14, 1906 It was the first attempt to press up the narrow defile from the plain of Jordan to the highlands of Canaan, undertaken in self-confidence with only a few men without seeking God to know what He would have them do.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Apr 30, 1912ST Feb 14, 1906 Thirty-six warriors fell, with great mourning in the camp, and Joshua and the elders wept with torn garments and dust before the ark as hearts melted in shame.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Dec 2, 1873 The account stands before the conquering of the Canaanites and the division of the land.ST Mar 17, 1909 Failure or burning permitted by God because He was not glorified or to try faith does not forbid building again and trying again under different circumstances unto conquest, as Israel went again after defeat before Ai and conquered.ST Sep 26, 1906
The taking led to utter destruction in the valley of Achor at Gilgal, Israel's first encampment in the land, by stoning and fire of Achan with his household and wealth.ST Jul 27, 1882RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916RH Nov 4, 1873ST Apr 30, 1912 He was left dead under a cairn in the rugged valley named Achor, that is trouble, and the valley's name became a sign of trouble, sorrow and despair.ST Jun 9, 1898ST Feb 14, 1906 The gradual narrowing gave long delay and plenty of time to deliberate, repent, confess voluntarily and make restitution.RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1873RH Jul 29, 1909 Fear grew as the circle closed from all Israel to Judah to the Zarhite family to the household of Zabdi to Achan, yet he gloated over his booty and braved it out thinking his sin securely hidden until confession was forced and too late to avail or lead to true repentance, an awful hour when he wished he had confessed sooner.RH Apr 8, 1902RH Dec 2, 1873ST Jun 13, 1906RH Oct 16, 1856RH Jul 29, 1909 God Himself directed the exposure and became the accuser, proving hidden sin cannot stay hidden from God though hidden from men, and Joshua's prayer was followed by this discovery bringing concealed wrongdoing to light.ST Sep 1, 1909ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1873ST Sep 5, 1900RH Jul 3, 1860
Nature of Achan's Sin
Achan coveted, took and hid spoil from Jericho against God's command, including a Babylonish garment with silver and gold, and he hid what was God's property among his own goods in a trench dug under his tent.ST Feb 23, 1915RH Nov 4, 1873RH Aug 13, 1857RH Dec 2, 1873ST Apr 15, 1903 His taking was deliberate appropriation for himself, and he gloated over his booty instead of confessing and making restitution.RH Nov 4, 1873RH Aug 13, 1857RH Dec 2, 1873 His keeping of the gold and the Babylonish garment marked him out to be removed before Israel could advance by faith into the inheritance.RH Nov 4, 1873RH Dec 31, 1914ST Apr 15, 1903
He went sword in hand over the fallen wall to the dwelling of a great man of Jericho, perhaps even the king's palace, with greedy eye alert for plunder.RH Dec 2, 1873 Keeping guard neither over his eyes nor over the lusts of his heart, he looked eagerly and saw and desired a noble trophy, a royal robe, a goodly Babylonish garment woven entirely of gold and fit for a king.RH Dec 2, 1873 Near it lay two hundred shekels of silver, probably in a wrought purse or bag, and a wedge of gold of fifty shekels weight.RH Dec 2, 1873 He at once desired these for his own possession because he loved treasure for its own sake as a true miser, without considering how worthily they would grace the Tabernacle.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873
What he took was devoted to God, for Jericho and all in it were devoted, the city to destruction and Rahab and all her family to salvation.RH Apr 8, 1902 The silver and gold and vessels of brass and iron were consecrated to come into the treasury of the Lord, to be purged by fire and converted to sacred use, even to decorate the sanctuary of the King of kings.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Apr 8, 1902 The spoils of battle belong to the conqueror, and God was leading Israel's armies and overthrew Jericho's walls by His own power, so to Him belonged the spoils and their disposition.RH Apr 8, 1902 This had been told plainly to all the people on the very day the city was overthrown, with warning to keep from the devoted thing lest they make themselves accursed and make the camp of Israel a curse and trouble it, and all Israel heard and shouted approval.RH Apr 8, 1902 The wealth of Jericho had been the gain of vice and oppression, its treasures sacred to Baal and Ashtaroth, but the wrath of man was to redound to God's glory.RH Dec 2, 1873
A devoted thing is devoted to God for whatever purpose He chooses, sometimes destruction as with the Amalekites and sometimes use in the sanctuary.ST Apr 30, 1912 When men pervert what God devoted to their own service and common use, it becomes the accursed thing, as blessing perverted becomes curse, righteousness becomes sin, and life becomes death.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 30, 1912 What was consecrated to be a blessing if placed in the Lord's treasury became the accursed thing when appropriated to common use.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 30, 1912 The root of the act was covetousness as a habit, secret, wary, persistent and utterly obstinate, with concealed selfishness, greed and deception.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 2, 1873 Greed can grow gradually into a binding habit, dull moral perception, dry up sacrifice, make one an easy prey to temptation, and bring certain destruction unless rooted out.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Jan 13, 1863ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 2, 1873
In this he robbed God of the consecrated first-fruits of the spoils of Canaan, not remembering they were already the Lord's and the eye of their Owner was fixed on him.RH Dec 2, 1873RH Dec 2, 1873 He valued his treasure more than the lives and happiness of his people and the fate of his nation.RH Dec 2, 1873 His family were like-minded with himself, and since God is just their sharing his doom by stoning and fire proves they stood with him in that sin in every respect.ST May 12, 1881ST Apr 30, 1912RH Dec 2, 1873 He broke God's plain command and treated obedience as unimportant, violating one of the other commandments of the decalogue, for which he was taken and put to death by stoning.RH Apr 12, 1864ST Mar 5, 1912RH Apr 8, 1902
Corporate Guilt and Punishment
One man's trespass troubled all Israel and turned away blessing from the whole community, showing the awful result of even one sin and one sinner among God's people.ST Aug 1, 1911RH Jun 1, 1916 The staged search from tribe to family to household to man by man exposed Achan of Judah as the one who had violated the command and brought the trouble, and his identification with subsequent confession and discovery of the stolen goods established guilt beyond question.ST Sep 1, 1909RH Sep 23, 1873 His betrayal brought curse, defeat at Ai, and shame on the ranks, and cherished sin in one member can hold back God's blessing from the whole people.ST Aug 1, 1911ST Feb 14, 1906 When sin is found among God's professed people it is offensive and must not be treated lightly but decisively removed, for if those responsible overlook it the whole congregation is held accountable, and one sinner can spread darkness shutting out light.RH Jun 1, 1916
Israel was bound together as one body, so that if one member suffers all suffer and if one sins others suffer in consequence, rejecting the claim that no one is his brother's keeper.ST Apr 30, 1912 Though ignorant of the trespass, Israel was smitten before enemies for his sake, their hearts becoming as water so they could not stand, at the cost of the defeat of the army and thirty-six men besides his own family.ST Apr 30, 1912RH Oct 4, 1870 Members share responsibility for the actions of an association they belong to unless they protest and withdraw, as God held Israel accountable for the theft until the sin was exposed and the transgressor punished.RH Apr 13, 1876 Secret unholy life in one member exerts great evil influence and can render the church almost powerless to do good until it exerts itself to get rid of the evil, and those persisting in it would do better to withdraw that it may go free than to remain unconverted within it and at last suffer for their transgressions and the ruin brought on the cause.RH Oct 4, 1870
Achan was accursed, set apart under the ban of Jericho and devoted to destruction, separated from the living and the community.ST Jan 18, 1877RH Jun 11, 1872RH Apr 30, 1867 His taking and stoning for breaking one of the other commandments proves the death penalty was attached equally to all ten commandments and not peculiar to the Sabbath.RH Apr 12, 1864 That stoning illustrates the penalty inflicted by the magistrate when the ten commandments were incorporated into the civil code of the Hebrew nation, punishing the offender against the national constitution for the time being and representing final retribution.RH Apr 12, 1864 That civil penalty ceased with the Jewish polity and is distinct from the real penalty to be inflicted by the great Lawgiver.RH Apr 12, 1864
The search with confession and punishment vindicated God's honor and justice before the people, and the swift terrible punishment purged the camp.RH Sep 23, 1873ST Feb 14, 1906 Hidden guilt was brought to light, showing that God searches out concealed wrongdoing, and execution of the sentence turned away His anger from Israel.ST May 12, 1881ST May 12, 1881 The defeat was a chastisement to all in Israel influenced by his spirit, since all chastisement comes from moral failure, and at the same time a trial of faith to all, even to Joshua, since trial of faith comes to all.ST Aug 8, 1906 Whatever happens to God's people is for their good for correction or trial or both, and no catastrophe to His people or cause, even if apparently fatal, can shorten His arm.ST Aug 8, 1906
God rebuked Israel for failing to be vigilant in uncovering the hidden sin.ST May 12, 1881 He would have revealed it as surely before the march on Ai as afterward if Joshua and the leaders had lived in abiding fellowship of the Holy Spirit with spiritual discernment to detect sin and put it away.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 The defeat came from undetected sin joined with self-confidence in sending only a few men, and the taking of Achan led to utter destruction in the valley of Achor.RH Sep 28, 1916
Cleansing and Restored Hope
The camp had to be cleansed and purified by removing the hidden sin, and victory came only after that sin was put away.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916ST Aug 1, 1911 The defeat at Ai traced to sin hidden in the camp, uncovered by careful investigation that brought the households forward one by one until Achan son of Carmi son of Zabdi son of Zerah was taken, and he and his house were then taken to the valley of Achor and utterly destroyed.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916ST Jun 13, 1906 That valley of Achor then became the door of hope because the camp was cleansed and purified, and the place associated with trouble became a sign of hope when sin was revealed and put away.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 13, 1906 Cherished sin in one member could hold back blessing from the whole people, joined as it was in this case with self-confidence in sending only a few men to Ai.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Aug 1, 1911
Complicity of God's people with an evil world works weakness and defeat.ST Feb 14, 1906 Israel was baffled in the first attempt to press up the narrow defile from the plain of Jordan to the highlands of Canaan following the capture of Jericho, because for miserable spoil found in a tent Achan in covetousness broke God's laws and drew shame on Israel's ranks.ST Feb 14, 1906 His being taken led to swift, terrible punishment that purged the camp, leaving him dead under a cairn in the rugged valley named Achor, that is, trouble.ST Feb 14, 1906 Yet if taught by trouble God's people purge themselves of the accursed thing, disaster makes a way for hope to come again.ST Feb 14, 1906
The pile of stones over the corpse is not to be stared at for hope.ST Feb 14, 1906 Jericho with its memories of conquest lies behind, the corpse lies below the stones, and the narrow way with the strong enemy lies in front, and hope is not found by fixing the eyes on any of them.ST Feb 14, 1906 Sorrow becomes hope only when it drives to God and to standing in His grace in conscious fellowship of peace with Him, rejoicing in hope.ST Feb 14, 1906 Hope is the brightness that goes before God's face, seen only by looking higher up to Him who goes before.ST Feb 14, 1906
Achan's presence in the camp represents sin hindering the people from receiving the promised rest.ST Jan 22, 1894 If Israel had been wholly devoted to God and no Achan had been allowed in the camp, the victory at Jericho would have continued through the conquest.ST Jan 22, 1894 Then God's power would have been made known throughout the world, the disobedient would have been destroyed and Satan's kingdom would have ended.ST Jan 22, 1894 What God could have accomplished in Joshua's day through a fully sanctified people would otherwise take six thousand years through His people in their weakness, transgressions, and lack of faith.ST Jan 22, 1894
Great victories for God invariably follow great reformations of heart and life in putting away the accursed thing and returning to purity and power, which is what brought Christ to die.RH Sep 28, 1916 God does not need to repeat severe judgments, because these Old Testament object lessons of abhorrence of sin are sufficient for all time.RH Sep 28, 1916
Scriptural Parallels and Types
What Achan was to Israel, Ananias and his wife were to the early church, for hidden sin in the camp caused defeat at Ai through undetected sin joined with self-confidence in sending only a few men, and the careful investigation traced it tribe by tribe and household by household to Achan son of Carmi son of Zabdi son of Zerah until he was taken and destroyed with his house in the valley of Achor.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 God would have revealed that sin just as surely before the march on Ai as afterward if Joshua and the leaders had lived in abiding fellowship of the Holy Spirit with spiritual discernment to detect sin and put it away, and the valley of Achor then became the door of hope because the camp was cleansed and purified.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 In the early church the manifest presence of the Holy Spirit gave Peter spiritual insight and discernment to detect their sin and put it away before God's great work went forward, so instead of a defeat like Ai there was revival with multitudes of men and women added to the Lord.RH Sep 28, 1916RH Dec 1, 1910 Perpetual failure in life and labor comes from cherished sin hidden in heart or life, God does not need to repeat severe judgments because these Old and New Testament object lessons of abhorrence of sin are sufficient for all time, and great victories for God invariably follow great reformations of heart and life in putting away the accursed thing and returning to purity and power, which is what brought Christ to die.RH Sep 28, 1916
The account stands in connection with Acts 5, where the sin was not simply lying, though lying is heinous, but hypocrisy of the worst kind wishing to have a reputation for generosity and benevolence without the necessary self-denial.ST May 10, 1883 The discovery in stages by bringing Israel forward first by tribe and then household by household until Achan was taken is compared with the selection of Saul, showing how a lot could make clear before the people that a choice came from God.ST Jul 1, 1903 Achan's taking of what was devoted to God makes him, identified by his family line and tribe as the man taken from among the households, an example of God's exacting claim over what is holy and of the reckoning for withholding it.ST Oct 15, 1902
Call to Present Church
God regards sin among His professed people as offensive and does not permit it to be treated lightly, and when sin is found it must be searched out and decisively removed rather than ignored.RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 23, 1873 If those responsible overlook it the whole congregation is held accountable, for one sinner can spread darkness that shuts out God's light from the congregation.RH Jun 1, 1916 God's church ought to be bound together as one body where if one member suffers all suffer and if one sins others suffer in consequence, rejecting Cain's claim that no one is his brother's keeper.ST Apr 30, 1912 Members share responsibility for the actions of an association they belong to unless they protest and withdraw, for Israel was held accountable for Achan's theft and punished until the sin was exposed and the transgressor punished.RH Apr 13, 1876
One Achan was enough to weaken all Israel, and every church and almost every family with its own Achan hinders success and holds back blessing.RH Apr 14, 1910 Israel could not move forward while one Achan was in the camp, for one person's disobedience stops the whole body even when leaders and others are obedient.RH Jun 16, 1863 An unconverted person can likewise bring defeat, and unconfessed sin hinders prayers and spiritual victory so that confession should come before seeking God's help.RH Sep 11, 1913ST Jun 17, 1897 The church must be cleansed of its Achans before it can have apostolic purity and receive the fullness of the Spirit's power, for his sin drove God's power from Israel and weakened work to save others.ST Nov 15, 1899 Removing such false workers is followed by renewed blessing, rising and advancing by faith into the inheritance.RH Feb 14, 1907
Concealed covetousness and deceit among God's people harm the whole community and must be brought to light, reproved, and the unrepentant separated so the community may be clean.RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 2, 1858RH Sep 23, 1873 The Achans are dead weights without living faith implanted in the heart who will falter and depart, and the church will rise by having them purged out so that those who stand each trying test will shout victory.RH Sep 3, 1872 Being an Achan means mixing what belongs to God with one's own goods, having the Lord's money among one's accounts, stealing what belonged to God's treasury for self.RH Apr 14, 1910 It means taking sacrifice from His altar, treating means lent as stewards as one's own and hoarding it, and loving the world and its gain and increase.RH Jan 13, 1863 Whoever wants the church refreshed and the home filled with the Spirit's power for instructing children must examine accounts and put away that sin to enjoy the refreshing collectively, with complete consecration that withholds nothing from God.RH Apr 14, 1910RH Feb 17, 1859
Achan taken and marked for sure destruction warns that hidden covetousness, selfishness and love of money gained imperceptibly and unrecognized dries up sacrifice and brings sure destruction unless rooted out by renewing covenant with God and renewing strength in Him unto self-denying sacrifice for the truth's sake.RH Jan 13, 1863 His execution for keeping the gold and Babylonish garment is a striking warning about covetousness, but it is not an authoritative example of how God will deal with every covetous professor in every age.ST Feb 4, 1886 Otherwise God's prospering hand will be removed so that all is snatched away in a moment and the covetous perish with the world.RH Jan 13, 1863 Removing the hindrance is an individual work requiring self-examination, putting away everything that clogs, walking up to the light, keeping God's commandments fully and having the faith of Jesus, for God is particular with reference to obedience and obedience is more acceptable than sacrifice.RH Jun 16, 1863
Each person individually must be right with God, examine ways, remember vows made in crisis and extremity, clear the King's highway, and confess before seeking God's help, lest the Almighty remove all obstacles by an overwhelming scourge, since hidden sin cannot be excused or covered without consequence to all.ST Jun 16, 1914RH Sep 11, 1913 An Achan can be a hidden idol kept in the soul that stands in the way and keeps prayer for sanctification from being answered.ST Oct 16, 1879 Such an Achan can be a pipe loved more than God and stronger than God, that lifts a man from his knees in closet prayer and cuts short Bible reading to satisfy craving, and it must be torn from God's throne and cast away so that God alone is worshiped, which brings freedom and rejoicing.ST Oct 16, 1879 Secret sin is known to God though hidden from men and no one can sin against Him with impunity, and one member's secret unholy life exerts great evil influence that can render the church almost powerless to accomplish good until it exerts itself to get rid of the evil.RH Oct 4, 1870 Those who persist in unholy life would do better to withdraw from the church that it may go free than to remain unconverted within it and at last suffer for their own transgressions and the ruin brought upon the cause, as shown when Israel ignorant of the trespass was smitten with hearts as water at cost of the defeat and thirty-six men besides his own family.RH Oct 4, 1870
Sources