AdventAI

Luke 20:33

Therefore in the resurrection whose wife of them is she? for seven had her to wife.

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

2 sources

In Luke 20:33 the Sadducees press their denial of the resurrection with a test case in which seven brothers had successively each been married to the same woman, demanding whose wife she would be if the dead were raised.3SP 48.2–3Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Their question rests on the assumption that people will resume earthly marriages and relationships after the resurrection.3SP 48.2–3 They use that assumption to make bodily resurrection appear absurd.3SP 48.2–3

It is an artful question intended to entangle Christ.Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 He answers plainly and intelligently, bringing precious light to the people.Ms 71, 1897, par. 27

Sources

  1. 3SP 48.2–3 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — JESUS AND THE PHARISEES. Ellen G. White, 1878
  2. Ms 71, 1897, par. 27 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 71, 1897 Ellen G. White, written July 11, 1897

Pioneers and periodicals

24 sources

The Sadducees, who denied the resurrection, put to Jesus the case of a woman successively married to seven brothers who each died childless under the law requiring a widow to marry her husband's brother.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901STST Oct 25, 1910 Their question whose wife she would be in the resurrection assumed that earthly marriage continues in the same way after the dead are raised, in order to make the resurrection appear incompatible with that arrangement.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854 Jesus answered that those counted worthy to obtain that world and the resurrection neither marry nor are given in marriage, but do not die there and are like the angels as children of God and of the resurrection.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 28, 1930RH Mar 18, 1902 He proved from Moses that the dead will be raised, because God is the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob.RH Sep 15, 1874ST Jan 18, 1883 The teaching concerns the future resurrection, not life between death and resurrection, and does not mean the dead remain alive as conscious souls, for that would make a resurrection unnecessary.RH Sep 15, 1874ST

Question's Setting and Intent

The question was put to Jesus by the Sadducees, who denied the resurrection, posing the case of a woman successively married to seven brothers, each of whom died, and asking whose wife she would be in the resurrection.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901STST Jan 18, 1883ST Oct 28, 1930 The case invoked the law requiring a childless widow to marry her deceased husband's brother, with all seven brothers in turn taking the same woman and dying childless and without children.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Oct 25, 1910 In asking it they were applying earthly marriage and that brother-marriage law to life after the raising of the dead, assuming that marriage continues in the same way after the dead are raised.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854 On another understanding held by some, the question instead assumes that marriage will not continue in the resurrection and then asks whose wife she will be.ST Sep 22, 1881

The question was meant to challenge belief in the resurrection, reflecting denial of it and challenging its possibility.ST Feb 6, 1901STST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854 It sought to make resurrection appear incompatible with the marriage arrangement.ST Oct 25, 1910 It belonged to the captious efforts of the scribes and Pharisees and Sadducees to entrap Jesus.ST Oct 28, 1913ST Apr 21, 1909

The setting shows the dispute was about whether the dead will have a future life through resurrection, since without resurrection there was denied any future life.RH Apr 5, 1860 Belief in the resurrection of the body was common among the Jews at the time of Christ and the apostles.ST May 15, 1879 The question comes after the parable of the husbandman and before the discourse on the destruction of Jerusalem and the second coming.ST Apr 21, 1909 Luke's statement that some will be accounted worthy to obtain that world is not made incorrect by its absence in Matthew and Mark, since Luke was equally inspired.RH Mar 10, 1868

Life in Coming World

The challenge comes from deniers of the resurrection with a case of a woman successively married to seven brothers, each of whom died childless, asking which man would be her husband when the dead are raised.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901RH Apr 2, 1914RH Mar 18, 1902 It rests on carrying earthly marriage and the law about a childless man's brother marrying his widow over into life after the resurrection.ST Oct 1, 1894 The answer is that those counted worthy to obtain the coming world and the resurrection neither marry nor are given in marriage.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Feb 6, 1901RH Apr 2, 1914RH Mar 18, 1902 In that world they do not marry or enter marriage and they do not die, but are like the angels and are children of God and of the resurrection.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Apr 2, 1914ST Oct 28, 1930RH Mar 18, 1902 The issue is the future resurrection, not an intermediate state of conscious souls, and the appeal to God as the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob establishes that God will raise the dead rather than explaining the conscious state of the dead.RH Mar 18, 1902

Equality with the angels means the redeemed are no longer below them, not that humans become angels.ST Oct 28, 1930 Their future relationships are not governed by the marital arrangements of this life.RH Mar 18, 1902 Those counted worthy to obtain that world are judged worthy before the resurrection takes place.RH Apr 2, 1914

The coming age for God's children will be marked by extraordinary physical and mental powers and glory. The assurance of resurrection given here is repeated to maintain and strengthen the faith of Adam's dying descendants in God's promise.ST Sep 7, 1904

Resurrection Proved, Errors Excluded

The Sadducees' question about the woman married in turn to seven brothers who each died childless was put to deny and challenge the resurrection, and Christ's reply was meant to prove from Moses that the dead will be raised.RH Sep 15, 1874STST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854 His proof was drawn from God revealing Himself as the God of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, which establishes that God will raise the dead, not that the patriarchs had never died.RH Sep 15, 1874ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 The dead of whom He spoke are truly dead, and His answer recognizes that they will live again, for the resurrection is the awakening of the dead.ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 That assurance of the resurrection is repeated to maintain and strengthen the faith of Adam's dying descendants in God's promise.ST Sep 7, 1904

The whole exchange concerns the future resurrection and marriage as it will be when the dead are raised, not life or the condition of the dead between death and resurrection.RH Sep 15, 1874STRH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 It is not given to explain the conscious state of the dead, and it does not teach that people remain alive as conscious immortal souls.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 To treat the reply as proof that all the dead are already alive would make a resurrection unnecessary, contradict the very point Christ set out to prove, and fail to answer the Sadducees' challenge.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 He did not correct their denial by saying the dead are already consciously alive and therefore need no raising, but by affirming from Moses that there will be a resurrection.ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856

Jesus' statement that those counted worthy neither marry nor are given in marriage and cannot die belongs to life in the future resurrection, where marriage does not continue.RH Feb 25, 1915 It does not teach that Christians should be celibate in this life or that celibacy makes people like angels now.RH Feb 25, 1915 The Sadducees' question is an argument against the resurrection, but it does not make the resurrection incredible.ST Jan 18, 1883RH Dec 12, 1854RH May 26, 1859 Doubts about the resurrection can weaken confidence in the gospel, which declares that the dead will be raised.ST Sep 7, 1904RH May 26, 1859

Sources

  1. ST Oct 1, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 47 — LESSON II.—SABBATH, OCTOBER 13, 1894 October 1, 1894
  2. ST Feb 6, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 6 — THE GOD OF THE LIVING Pittenger, February 6, 1901
  3. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 14 — Question Corner
  4. ST Oct 25, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 42 — Shiloh: the Man of Sorrows October 25, 1910
  5. ST Oct 25, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 43 — LESSON VI.—SABBATH, NOVEMBER 11, 1899 October 25, 1899
  6. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  7. ST Oct 28, 1930 Signs of the Times, Vol. 57, No. 42 — BIBLE SILENT ON THIS QUESTION October 28, 1930
  8. RH Mar 18, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 11 — An Artful Question Well Answered March 18, 1902
  9. RH Sep 15, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 13 — Scriptures Perverted J. H. Waggoner, September 15, 1874
  10. ST Jan 18, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 3 — The Resurrection Ellet Joseph Waggoner, January 18, 1883
  11. ST Sep 22, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 36 — THE SAINTS ARE NOT TO BE WITH CHRIST TILL HE COMES John Nevins Andrews, September 22, 1881
  12. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  13. ST Oct 28, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 42 — Our Bible Band Editor, October 28, 1913
  14. ST Apr 21, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 16 — OUR BIBLE BAND April 21, 1909
  15. RH Apr 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 20 — SADDUCEEISM Fifth-Day, April 5, 1860
  16. ST May 15, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 20 — JOSEPHUS UNRELIABLE Eld. D. M. Canright, May 15, 1879
  17. RH Mar 10, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 13 — DISCUSSION WITH ELD. JOHNSON, Dudley Marvin Canright, March 10, 1868
  18. RH Apr 2, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 14 — The Judgment M. G. Huffman, Thursday, April 2, 1914
  19. ST Sep 7, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 36 — DEATH AND RESURRECTION W. A. Sweany, September 7, 1904
  20. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  21. RH Jun 12, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 8, No. 7 — THE FIRST AND NINETEENTH CENTURIES June 12, 1856
  22. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  23. RH Feb 25, 1915 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 92, No. 10 — Celibacy C. M. S., Thursday, February 25, 1915
  24. RH May 26, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 1 — A POPULAR ERROR Fifth-Day, May 26, 1859

Cross-references

  1. Mark 12:23

    In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.

    The Sadducees ask whose wife she will be when the dead rise.

  2. Matthew 22:23-33

    The same day came to him the Sadducees, which say that there is no resurrection, and asked him,

    A parallel account of the question about marriage in the resurrection.

  3. Exodus 3:6

    Moreover he said, I am the God of thy father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. And Moses hid his face; for he was afraid to look upon God.

    Jesus cites God’s words about the patriarchs to show that the dead are raised.

  4. Deuteronomy 25:5-6

    If brethren dwell together, and one of them die, and have no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger: her husband’s brother shall go in unto her, and take her to him to wife, and perform the duty of an husband’s brother unto her.

    The Sadducees’ hypothetical is based on Moses’ law for a childless man’s brother.

  5. 1 Corinthians 15:51-52

    Behold, I shew you a mystery; We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed,

    Both texts describe the resurrection and the future age.

  6. John 11:24

    Martha saith unto him, I know that he shall rise again in the resurrection at the last day.

    Martha speaks of the resurrection as a familiar belief.

  7. Acts 23:6-8

    But when Paul perceived that the one part were Sadducees, and the other Pharisees, he cried out in the council, Men and brethren, I am a Pharisee, the son of a Pharisee: of the hope and resurrection of the dead I am called in question.

    Shows the Pharisees’ belief in the resurrection.

  8. John 5:28-29

    Marvel not at this: for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice,

    Christ has authority to raise the dead to resurrection.

  9. 2 Timothy 2:17-18

    And their word will eat as doth a canker: of whom is Hymenaeus and Philetus;

    Paul condemns the claim that the resurrection is past.

  10. Matthew 22:46

    And no man was able to answer him a word, neither durst any man from that day forth ask him any more questions.

    Jesus’ opponents were unable to answer him.