Mark 8:4
And his disciples answered him, From whence can a man satisfy these men with bread here in the wilderness?
Translations
And his disciples answered him, From where can a man satisfy these men with bread here in the wilderness?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And his disciples answered him, From whence can a man satisfy these men with bread here in the wilderness?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And his disciples answered him, Whence shall one be able to fill these men with bread here in a desert place?
And his disciples answered him, 'Whence shall any one be able these here to feed with bread in a wilderness?'
And his disciples answered him, Whence shall one be able to satisfy these with bread here in a desert place?
And his disciples answered him—Whence shall any one be able, here, to fill, these, with bread, in a desert?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
His disciples replied, “ Where in this desolate place could anyone find enough bread to feed all these people?”
His disciples answered him, “ From where could one satisfy these people with bread here in a deserted place?”
And his disciples said in answer, How will it be possible to get enough bread for these men here in a waste place?
Then his disciples answered him, Whence can a man satisfie these with bread here in the wildernes?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And his disciples answered him: From whence can any one fill them here with bread in the wilderness?
Cross-references
- Matthew 15:32-38
Then Jesus called his disciples unto him, and said, I have compassion on the multitude, because they continue with me now three days, and have nothing to eat: and I will not send them away fasting, lest they faint in the way.
Jesus feeds a multitude in a deserted place with a few loaves and fishes.
- Mark 6:35-44
And when the day was now far spent, his disciples came unto him, and said, This is a desert place, and now the time is far passed:
Christ provides bread for a crowd in an earlier feeding miracle.
- Psalms 78:19
Yea, they spake against God; they said, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?
Both question whether God can provide a table in the wilderness.
- 2 Kings 7:1-2
Then Elisha said, Hear ye the word of the LORD; Thus saith the LORD, To morrow about this time shall a measure of fine flour be sold for a shekel, and two measures of barley for a shekel, in the gate of Samaria.
A nobleman doubts that abundance can come during famine.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
The disciples ask how anyone could satisfy the crowd with bread in the wilderness, seeing no way to provide enough with only a few loaves and fishes.DA 404.1–405.218MR 115.3Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34 Their question shows unbelief, since they had already seen Jesus feed a multitude yet did not trust Him to provide again.DA 404.1–405.2 Their response was also shaped by Jewish prejudice because this crowd was Gentile.DA 404.1–405.2 The need behind the question was real, and Christ's compassion moved Him to feed the people by miracle so they would not faint on the way.18MR 115.3 Jesus fed the people and had the remaining food gathered, showing that He can provide abundantly from insufficient human resources and calling for greater faith in Him.Ms 123, 1909, par. 32–34
The feeding of the four thousand is an example whose methods are to be studied in carrying forward food work.Lt 302, 1906, par. 5 Working in that way means working economically with simple inexpensive preparations to greater advantage instead of manufacturing foods requiring large investment.Lt 302, 1906, par. 5 It also means keeping selfish private interests from being introduced to block progress of the work in the right way.Lt 302, 1906, par. 5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
9 sources
The verse belongs to a connected incident and line of narration that the division at the start of the chapter cuts sharply and abruptly, so it is to be read by paragraph to the end of the paragraph and not simply to the end of the chapter, and to be studied as part of the whole paragraph with its main thought and the relation of every sentence before and after it.ST Oct 13, 1898 It belongs to the narrative of Christ's work in Mark 6 to 13 that gives lessons of life to take home to the heart, to be compared with the parallel stories in the other gospels.ST Jul 29, 1908 While one teaching places it in the account of Jesus feeding the five thousand, the weight of teaching places it in the feeding of the four thousand.ST Aug 4, 1914RH Oct 30, 1860ST Sep 22, 1881ST Aug 5, 1913ST Aug 5, 1913
That feeding took place on the other side of the Sea of Galilee from Dalmanutha and Magdala, and after it Jesus came to Dalmanutha near Magdala by the plain of Gennesaret, where on the same occasion the Pharisees questioned Him asking for a sign from heaven.ST Jul 7, 1898 The setting was Decapolis, where thousands from the surrounding country had gathered and heard the message of salvation for three days.ST Aug 4, 1914 The need was met from a scant supply of seven loaves and a few small dried fish, which fed four thousand men besides women and children, with seven baskets of fragments left over.ST Sep 22, 1881
The verse records the disciples asking how anyone could satisfy the men with bread in the wilderness, highlighting the human impossibility and apparent impossibility of providing enough bread for the crowd with the resources at hand.ST Aug 4, 1914RH Oct 30, 1860ST Sep 22, 1881ST Aug 5, 1913ST Jun 21, 1899 They were unable to see how the small amount of food could satisfy the crowd in the wilderness, though Christ could have provided food in another way, and instead He used the little that was offered and satisfied the hungry people, teaching hope and trust.ST Aug 5, 1913 The episode displays Jesus' power and benevolence in feeding the crowd with a few loaves.RH Oct 30, 1860
The disciples' question is an example of relying on human reason and doubting God's power.ST Jun 21, 1899 The miracles in this narrative are only a small part of the number Christ wrought, recorded to give comfort to every class of people who may live upon the earth.ST Jul 29, 1908 They show Christ just as willing now to forgive the sinful as those who came directly to Him, just as willing to heal and restore the sick as to give health to the leper and hearing to the deaf, and to comfort those in trouble as the great Comforter.ST Jul 29, 1908 They show God as God of all those who will seek Him, not of the Hebrew people alone, and the Bible, though written by Hebrews, as truly for all outside the Hebrew tribes.ST Jul 29, 1908
Sources