Matthew 12:27
And if I by Beelzebub cast out devils, by whom do your children cast them out? therefore they shall be your judges.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And if I by Beelzebub cast out devils, by whom do your children cast them out? therefore they shall be your judges.
And if I by Beelzebub cast out demons, by whom do your children expel them? therefore they shall be your judges.
And if I by Beelzebub cast out devils, by whom do your sons cast them out? therefore shall they be your judges.
And if I by Beelzebub cast out demons, by whom do your sons cast them out? therefore shall they be your judges.
'And if I, by Beelzeboul, do cast out the demons, your sons — by whom do they cast out? because of this they — they shall be your judges.
And if I cast out demons by Beelzebub, your sons, by whom do they cast [ them] out? For this reason they shall be your judges.
And, if, I, in Beelzebul, am casting out the demons, In whom are, your sons, casting them out? Wherefore, they, shall be, judges of you.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And if I drive out demons by Beelzebul, by whom do your sons drive them out? So then, they will be your judges.
If I by Beelzebul cast out demons, by whom do your children cast them out? Therefore they will be your judges.
And if I by Beelzebub send evil spirits out of men, by whom do your sons send them out? So let them be your judges.
Also if I through Beelzebub cast out deuils, by whom doe your children cast them out? Therefore they shall be your iudges.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And if I by Beelzebub cast out devils, by whom do your children cast them out? Therefore they shall be your judges.
Cross-references
- Mark 3:22
And the scribes which came down from Jerusalem said, He hath Beelzebub, and by the prince of the devils casteth he out devils.
Records the same Beelzebub accusation against Jesus.
- Matthew 12:22
Then was brought unto him one possessed with a devil, blind, and dumb: and he healed him, insomuch that the blind and dumb both spake and saw.
The healing prompted the charge Jesus answers.
- Luke 11:19
And if I by Beelzebub cast out devils, by whom do your sons cast them out? therefore shall they be your judges.
Jesus challenges the accusers over their own exorcists.
- Matthew 9:34
But the Pharisees said, He casteth out devils through the prince of the devils.
The Pharisees repeat the charge that Jesus casts out demons by Beelzebub.
- Mark 3:30
Because they said, He hath an unclean spirit.
It recounts the charge that Jesus acted by an unclean spirit.
- Matthew 12:31-32
Wherefore I say unto you, All manner of sin and blasphemy shall be forgiven unto men: but the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost shall not be forgiven unto men.
Defines the unforgivable sin of attributing Christ’s work to the devil.
- Matthew 12:23
And all the people were amazed, and said, Is not this the son of David?
The people’s amazement at Jesus’ miracle leads them to call him the Son of David.
- Luke 11:20
But if I with the finger of God cast out devils, no doubt the kingdom of God is come upon you.
Jesus says his casting out demons shows that the kingdom of God has come.
- 2 Kings 1:6
And they said unto him, There came a man up to meet us, and said unto us, Go, turn again unto the king that sent you, and say unto him, Thus saith the LORD, Is it not because there is not a God in Israel, that thou sendest to enquire of Baal-zebub the god of Ekron? therefore thou shalt not come down from that bed on which thou art gone up, but shalt surely die.
Names the Philistine god from which the title originated.
- Luke 11:14
And he was casting out a devil, and it was dumb. And it came to pass, when the devil was gone out, the dumb spake; and the people wondered.
parallel account of the same healing
- Luke 10:17
And the seventy returned again with joy, saying, Lord, even the devils are subject unto us through thy name.
The seventy report that devils were subject to them through Jesus’ name.
- John 10:20
And many of them said, He hath a devil, and is mad; why hear ye him?
Jesus is accused of acting under demonic influence.
- Mark 9:38
And John answered him, saying, Master, we saw one casting out devils in thy name, and he followeth not us: and we forbad him, because he followeth not us.
outsider casting out devils in Christ's name
- Luke 4:33-36
And in the synagogue there was a man, which had a spirit of an unclean devil, and cried out with a loud voice,
Jesus casts out an unclean spirit by his authoritative word.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
16 sources
After He gave sight and speech to a blind and mute man possessed by a devil, so that the crowd wondered if He was the Son of David, the Pharisees charged that He drove out devils only by the prince of the devils, and knowing their thoughts He answered by asking by what power their own children and followers cast them out.DA 321.3Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13 If His work were by the evil ruler, their own exorcists would stand condemned by the same charge, so their inconsistency is exposed and those Jewish exorcists will condemn the unjust judgment as judges against the accusers.Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19Lt 87, 1901, par. 12–14Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13 His relieving of the afflicted was not from Satan but a manifestation of the holy power of God that could not be evaded or explained by natural causes.Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–194MR 360.1LS 96.1–3 To ascribe what the Holy Spirit has done to Satan is the sin against the Holy Ghost, for which there is no forgiveness, because it wilfully rejects and cuts off the channel by which God works on the heart and communicates blessing, leaving the soul where repentance and faith cannot reach it.DA 321.34MR 360.1Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–125MR 204.3 Speaking against Jesus Himself without discerning His divine character can still be forgiven, for through the Spirit the sinner can yet be brought to see error, repent, and have guilt washed away in His blood.DA 321.3
Setting and Argument
The saying was spoken after Jesus healed a man possessed with a devil who was blind and dumb, so that he both spoke and saw, and this was the second such healing.DA 321.3Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19 At that sight the people wondered whether He was the Son of David, while the Pharisees repeated the charge that He cast out devils only by Beelzebub, the prince of the devils.DA 321.3Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19 Knowing their thoughts, Jesus turned the charge back on them by asking by whose power their own children, people, and followers cast out devils.Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19Lt 87, 1901, par. 12–14Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13SPBC 144.2
Those Jewish exorcists will condemn the unjust judgment and stand as judges against the accusers.Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–19Lt 87, 1901, par. 12–14Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13SPBC 144.2 If the charge against Jesus were true, their own children who cast out devils would also be acting by Beelzebub.Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13ST Oct 1, 1896 This exposes the inconsistency of condemning in Jesus what they accept in their own people.Lt 87, 1901, par. 12–14Ms 73, 1897, par. 11–13ST Oct 1, 1896
His work of relieving the afflicted was not from Satan but was a manifestation of the holy power of God, in contrast to Beelzebub and Satan's work.Ms 31a, 1898, par. 16–194MR 360.1LS 96.1–3 The healings and expulsions done before them could not be evaded or explained by natural causes, and no man had done or could do such works.4MR 360.1 The Pharisees made the charge without any reason from Him, though inwardly convinced that divine power attended Him.DA 322.1–2Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–12 They persisted in unbelief because accepting the evidence would have required confessing their sin, and so deliberately resisted the truth and chose deception.DA 322.1–2Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–12
News of this accusation reached Jesus' brothers together with reports that He spent whole nights in prayer, was thronged all day without time even to eat, and was wearing Himself out by incessant labor.DA 321.1–2 It was also reported that He took an unaccountable attitude toward the Pharisees and was feared by some to have lost reason.DA 321.1–2 Feeling the reproach, astonished, dismayed, and alarmed at His bold statements and denunciation of the scribes and Pharisees amid the tumult, they decided to persuade and constrain Him to stop this labor.DA 321.1–2 They induced Mary to join them in prevailing on Him through love for her to be more prudent.DA 321.1–2
Sin Against the Spirit
To call the casting out of devils by Christ the work of Beelzebub is to ascribe to Satan what belongs to God and what the Holy Spirit has done, and this is the sin against the Holy Ghost, for which there is no forgiveness.4MR 360.1Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–125MR 204.3 The healings and expulsions of devils were done openly before the accusers and could not be evaded or explained by natural causes, and no man had done or could do such works, showing them to be a manifestation of the holy power of God.4MR 360.1 Yet in unbelief the leaders claimed He healed through the devil and was in league with hell, though He had given them no reason for that charge, and they persisted in unbelief because to accept the evidence would have required them to confess their sin.4MR 360.1Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–12 By stubbornly, sullenly and ironheartedly determining to close the eyes to all evidence and attributing God's holy power to satanic agencies, they sinned against the Holy Ghost and committed the unpardonable sin, and the same sin is committed by those who say the shut door is of the devil.4MR 360.15MR 204.3
To speak against Jesus Himself without discerning His divine character can still be forgiven, because through the Holy Spirit the sinner can yet be brought to see the error and repent.DA 321.3 Whatever the sin, if the soul repents and believes, the guilt is washed away in His blood.DA 321.3 But willfully to reject the work of the Holy Spirit and declare it to be from Satan cuts off the channel by which God works upon the heart and communicates with men, and cuts men off from the fountain of blessing.DA 321.3 It places the soul where repentance and faith cannot come to it, so that when the Spirit is finally rejected there is nothing more that God can do for the soul.DA 321.3
Christ's works showed God's love and offered sinners the way to everlasting life, so to assign to satanic agency works of divine power and miracles done in His name is a serious rejection of the evidence for His work.Lt 34, 1906, par. 10–128RED 63.1 In unbelief the leaders spoke of the Son of God as a mere human being and used their talent of speech to abuse the world's Redeemer.4MR 360.1 Their words are written by the recording angel in the books of heaven.4MR 360.1
Warning and Obedience
The charge that healing deliverance came by the prince of devils exposed what appears when a heart is separated from God and no longer under the subduing power of the Holy Spirit, the attributes of Satan himself made manifest.Lt 57, 1895, par. 8 Such a condition sends forth an influence contrary to truth and justice and righteousness, and its fruit is oppression of fellow men.Lt 57, 1895, par. 8 It is seen in the relation of workers to one another and in the desire of one institution to control all others.Lt 57, 1895, par. 8
The question by whose power their own people cast out devils belongs to Christ's rebuke of the Jews who opposed Him, turning their accusation back upon them.Lt 57, 1895, par. 8SPBC 144.2 The same oppressive, rebellious spirit is shown by men entrusted with weighty responsibilities who have no living connection with God.Lt 57, 1895, par. 8SPBC 144.2 Like Korah, Dathan, and Abiram, they indulge the very spirit of those opposers, doing despite to the Holy Spirit even after warnings from God have come again and again.Lt 57, 1895, par. 814MR 116.2 The warning therefore applies to all who resist repeated warnings and oppose the Holy Spirit.14MR 116.2SPBC 144.2
To call the shut door of the devil commits the same sin of ascribing to Satan what belongs to God.5MR 204.3 Those who do so make a mighty effort yet come into close quarters, lost in foggy terrible fear and seized with anguish of spirit, daring not admit the door is shut.5MR 204.3 At last they admit the charge is against their own lives, and they shall die the death.5MR 204.3 Escape is to look at the Pattern and follow Him, for He is meek and lowly in heart, shutting the eyes to everything but present saving truth.5MR 204.3
Fanaticism is Satan's counterfeit of God's work, set over against Christ's work which is from God and not from Beelzebub.LS 96.1–3 It cannot truly imitate heaven's work.LS 96.1–3 When its fruit ripens the difference between the two becomes unmistakable.LS 96.1–3
Christ's instruction in this rebuke must be held as firm as a rock, while those who hold it remain meek and lowly and tenderhearted.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 11–12 Every word He speaks must be strictly heeded and not one lost sight of, because His counsel is life eternal and the truth abides forever.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 11–12 Trusting any lie or pretense instead of His teaching costs eternal life.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 11–12 Straight paths must be made for the feet lest the lame be turned out of the way, and those who mislead the lame from safe paths are accountable for setting at naught His life-giving counsel for words of deception originating with the father of lies.Ms 37a, 1909, par. 11–12
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
31 sources
Jesus healed a man made blind and mute by demonic possession, an undeniable good work done by His word and by the Spirit through Him, which the Pharisees, unwilling to admit it was by God, attributed to Beelzebub the prince of devils.ST Mar 25, 1880ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 8, 1875ST May 17, 1899 He first answers that every kingdom divided against itself cannot stand, so Satan casting out Satan would work his own destruction, for evil is overcome by the finger of God.ST May 29, 1884RH Feb 4, 1875ST May 17, 1899 He then turns the charge back, that if He casts out by Beelzebub by whom do their own sons and followers cast them out, so their accepted practice exposes the unfairness of condemning His work while accepting theirs and they shall be their judges.ST Apr 8, 1875ST May 17, 1899ST Mar 10, 1881 Deliberately attributing miracles plainly known to be wrought by the Spirit through Him to Satan in order to avoid the truth is the blasphemy against the Holy Ghost, the unpardonable sin.RH Feb 4, 1875ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909 It is unpardonable not because God is not merciful but because the soul rejects the only power by which sin can be taken away, leaving without hope because having rejected the mightiest evidence nothing else will move him.ST Oct 6, 1909ST May 12, 1909
Setting and Wording
The occasion was the healing at Capernaum of a man made blind and mute by demonic possession, whom Jesus delivered so that he both spoke and saw.ST Mar 25, 1880ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 8, 1875RH Feb 4, 1875ST May 17, 1899 It was an undeniable good work, done by His word and by the Spirit working through Him.ST Mar 25, 1880ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 8, 1875ST Sep 4, 1907 The cure belonged to the charge that He cast out devils by Beelzebub, which He then turned back with the question by whom their own children cast them out.ST Apr 8, 1875ST Sep 4, 1907
The multitudes were amazed and asked if He was the Son of David, meaning the Messiah.ST May 29, 1884RH Feb 4, 1875ST May 17, 1899 That was the first general public confession of His true mission.ST May 17, 1899 It prevailed that when the Messiah came He would cast out devils and none but He could do such a work.ST May 29, 1884 The Jews themselves claimed to cast out demons but had never made the blind see and the mute speak.ST May 17, 1899ST May 17, 1899 They could not deny the miracle, and they feared the common people would recognize its genuineness.ST May 17, 1899
The accusers were Pharisees from Jerusalem, opposed to Him and watching with envy and jealousy.ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 8, 1875ST May 17, 1899 Despising Him in His humility and determined at all hazards to resist His work, they were unwilling to admit the work was by the Spirit of God because that would admit He was what He claimed to be.ST May 29, 1884RH Feb 4, 1875 To avoid acknowledging evident truth and unpopular truth they attributed the wonderful work to Beelzebub rather than to the Spirit of God.ST Mar 25, 1880ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 8, 1875RH Feb 4, 1875ST Mar 25, 1880
Beelzebub is the Jews' name for the chief and prince of devils.ST May 17, 1899ST Mar 10, 1881ST Sep 4, 1907 He is the filth god and leader of evil spirits, not a reference to the Philistines' god of Ekron.ST May 17, 1899ST Mar 10, 1881ST Jul 8, 1889 His work stands in contrast to Christ's, whose work is from God.LS 96.1–3ST Sep 4, 1907
The surrounding chapter also shows His healings, including the man with the withered hand, were works of mercy in accordance with the weightier matters of the law and therefore lawful Sabbath acts.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Oct 8, 1894RH Sep 19, 1854 His reasoning exposed hypocrisy and a false estimate of the Sabbath.RH Sep 19, 1854 He did not set aside the Sabbath commandment, and the chapter gives no justification for open willful violation of the fourth commandment.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Sep 19, 1854
Authority to cast out devils was not confined to the twelve apostles, for people other than Christians also cast them out.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jan 2, 1893 The children of the Pharisees themselves claimed to cast them out.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Jan 2, 1893 His healing of demoniacs unable to believe shows healing did not require that they first acknowledge Him as the Messiah.ST Nov 1, 1910
Christ's Refuting Argument
He first met the charge with the plain principle that every kingdom, city, or house divided against itself is brought to desolation and cannot stand, so that if Satan casts out Satan he is divided against himself and works his own destruction.ST May 29, 1884RH Feb 4, 1875ST May 17, 1899 The devil cannot be cast out by the devil, but evil is overcome by the finger of God.RH Jun 26, 1860 The claim that He wrought by Beelzebub was therefore foolish as well as blasphemous.ST May 29, 1884RH Feb 4, 1875
He then turned the accusation back with the question that if He casts out by Beelzebub, by whom do their own children cast them out, so that they shall be their judges.ST Apr 8, 1875ST May 17, 1899ST Mar 10, 1881 If the charge were true the same judgment would fall on the accusers' own sons, people, and followers who claimed to cast out demons.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Sep 16, 1880ST Mar 26, 1894 Their own accepted practice exposed the inconsistency and unfairness of condemning His work while accepting theirs, and stood as judgment against them.ST May 17, 1899ST Sep 16, 1880ST Mar 26, 1894ST Mar 14, 1906 People other than Christians also claimed this work, and Jesus challenged His accusers to account for by whose power their own exorcists wrought.ST Mar 14, 1906
The force of the question lay in using the opponents' own professed belief for the sake of argument in order to put them on the defensive.ST Sep 16, 1880ST Sep 16, 1880 He did not stop to prove independently that His power came from heaven.ST Sep 16, 1880 Nor did the argument establish that their partisans could actually expel demons, for they were incapable of delivering the demon-possessed.ST Sep 16, 1880 If those followers did not cast out demons, the Pharisees' own claim was false, while if the charge were true those followers would also be doing Satan's work and would condemn the Pharisees who approved them.RH Feb 16, 1869
Those children shall be judges because they accepted Christ while the Pharisees themselves rejected Him, and authority to cast out devils was not confined to the twelve apostles.ST Jan 2, 1893 In this He reasoned from Scripture and called hearers to judge and decide about the truth.RH Aug 9, 1864 A man is judged by the authority he himself appeals to.RH Feb 3, 1852
The question placed the Pharisees before a choice: if He casts out by God's power and Spirit, God's kingdom has come to that person and has come near and among them in His person, teaching, and work as its future King.ST Mar 26, 1894ST Feb 5, 1902RH Feb 16, 1869 Opposition to such a work aligned them with Satan rather than God.ST Feb 5, 1902 His driving demons out proved He had bound Satan the strong man by overcoming him, showing He is stronger than the devil who held captives and can bind him and strip away his power.ST Jan 6, 1909 That binding means limiting Satan's power and defeating him encounter after encounter, in each deliverance removing Satan's dwelling, filling the person with His own presence and Spirit, leaving the person sane, and defeating Satan in many different ways on every occasion they met.ST Jan 6, 1909
He was the means devised to reveal God to humanity, so the Jews' rejection despite having been entrusted with the Scriptures that foretold Him showed they did not know God.
Sin and Present Application
The warning about the sin against the Holy Spirit comes immediately after this dispute, for the deliberate attributing of miracles wrought by the Spirit through Jesus to Beelzebub, to Satan and to the direct agency of the devil, in order to avoid acknowledging evident truth, is the specific, blasphemous and impious instance of that unpardonable sin, while all other sins will be forgiven.RH Feb 4, 1875ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909RH Aug 27, 1901 He had healed a demoniac who was blind and dumb so that he both spoke and saw, a work that amazed the people and moved them to ask if He was the Son of David, since casting out devils was expected of the Messiah, yet unwilling to admit the work was done by the Spirit of God because that would admit He was what He claimed to be, His accusers attributed it to Beelzebub the prince of devils.RH Feb 4, 1875ST Sep 4, 1907ST Oct 6, 1909 That refusal to acknowledge the evident work of the Holy Spirit was exposed as foolish as well as blasphemous by the principle that a kingdom, city, or house divided against itself cannot stand, so that Satan casting out Satan would work his own destruction.RH Feb 4, 1875 Those who heard Christ and experienced His Spirit's power removing disease were in danger of joining that rebellious accusation and committing the unpardonable sin.RH Apr 21, 1874
It is unpardonable not because God is not merciful but because the soul rejects the only power by which sin can be taken away, rejecting God's remedy and means for saving men.ST Oct 6, 1909ST May 12, 1909 The Holy Spirit is the power of God by which He operates, by which He created the earth and garnished the heavens, by which every miracle has been wrought, and by which man is changed from sin to righteousness together with the sacrifice of Jesus Christ.ST May 12, 1909 To bring that charge after seeing the most marked manifestations of the Spirit and hearing such teaching as the world never heard leaves without hope, for having rejected the mightiest evidence nothing else will move him and God cannot save him where he puts himself.ST May 12, 1909 Having known the mighty power of God, to choose the world and Satan leaves nothing by which he can be reached, and he who perishes without hope perishes of choice, like one deliberately plunging from a life-boat or refusing to grasp the life-line.ST May 12, 1909
That act is sinning willfully after receiving knowledge of the truth and the second manner of sinning against the Holy Spirit, to which there remains no more sacrifice for sins but a certain looking for judgment and fiery indignation to devour the adversaries.RH Aug 27, 1901 It is far worse than despising Moses' law, which brought death without mercy, for it tramples under foot the blood of the covenant offered in the sanctuary above by the High Priest and does despite to the Spirit of grace, counting that blood as an unholy thing and its saving power as no more than any other blood on earth.RH Aug 27, 1901 It leaves the sinner to vengeance and to a fearful falling into the hands of the living God.RH Aug 27, 1901
A person now who to avoid truth perverts plain declarations of Scripture and ignores the plainest principles of interpretation places himself in the same condition of darkness and blindness of mind, offering himself to strong delusions to be led by the devil to whatever conclusions he wills, like a blind man who cannot see or know where he is going.RH Mar 29, 1870 This warns against yielding any point of truth to avoid a heavy cross, sacrifice, or trial, since once that course is entered no one knows where he will be led.RH Mar 29, 1870 The chapter gives no justification for open willful violation of the fourth commandment, for the acts of Jesus in Matthew 12 were in accordance with mercy, a weightier matter of the law, and therefore were no violation of the law.RH Feb 3, 1852 When a defender of Sabbath-breaking appeals to Matthew 12, that chapter itself becomes the scales that weigh him and find him wanting, for a man is judged by the authority he himself appeals to.RH Feb 3, 1852
The devil cannot be cast out by the devil, but evil is overcome by the finger of God, and the contrast between Beelzebub's work associated with Satan and Christ's work which is from God shows fanaticism to be Satan's counterfeit of God's work.LS 96.1–3RH Jun 26, 1860 That counterfeit cannot truly imitate heaven's work, and when its fruit ripens the difference between the two becomes unmistakable.LS 96.1–3 The same principle applies to human conflict, where bitterness is not driven out by bitterness but sweetness and meekness dispel it.RH Jun 26, 1860
Sources