Matthew 12:40
For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
For as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
for as Jonas was three days and three nights in the whale’s belly; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the whale's belly: so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
for as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the whale; so shall the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
for, as Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights, so shall the Son of Man be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights.
For even as Jonas was in the belly of the great fish three days and three nights, thus shall the Son of man be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights.
For, just as was Jonah in the belly of the sea-monster three days and three nights, so, will be the Son of Man, in the heart of the earth, three days and three nights.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the great fish, so the Son of Man will be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the huge fish, so will the Son of Man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
For as Jonah was three days and three nights in the stomach of the great fish, so will the Son of man be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.
For as Ionas was three daies and three nights in the whales belly: so shall the Sonne of man be three daies and three nights in ye heart of the earth.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For as Jonas was in the whale’s belly three days and three nights: so shall the Son of man be in the heart of the earth three days and three nights.
Pictures










Cross-references 20 of 41
- Jonah 1:17
Now the LORD had prepared a great fish to swallow up Jonah. And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights.
Jonah’s three days and nights in the fish provide the pattern for Jesus’ time in the grave.
- Luke 24:21
But we trusted that it had been he which should have redeemed Israel: and beside all this, to day is the third day since these things were done.
The disciples say it is the third day since Jesus’ death and crucifixion.
- Matthew 16:21
From that time forth began Jesus to shew unto his disciples, how that he must go unto Jerusalem, and suffer many things of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be killed, and be raised again the third day.
Jesus predicts his suffering, death, and resurrection on the third day.
- Mark 8:31
And he began to teach them, that the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders, and of the chief priests, and scribes, and be killed, and after three days rise again.
Jesus foretells his resurrection after three days.
- Mark 9:31
For he taught his disciples, and said unto them, The Son of man is delivered into the hands of men, and they shall kill him; and after that he is killed, he shall rise the third day.
Jesus predicts his death and resurrection on the third day.
- Matthew 28:1
In the end of the sabbath, as it began to dawn toward the first day of the week, came Mary Magdalene and the other Mary to see the sepulchre.
Places Jesus’ resurrection after the Sabbath, on the first day of the week.
- Matthew 27:63-64
Saying, Sir, we remember that that deceiver said, while he was yet alive, After three days I will rise again.
The leaders recall Jesus’ prediction to rise after three days and secure the tomb until the third day.
- Luke 24:1-7
Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulchre, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.
The empty tomb and the angels’ words confirm that the Son of man rose on the third day.
- Luke 9:22
Saying, The Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders and chief priests and scribes, and be slain, and be raised the third day.
Both describe Jesus’ death and his rising on the third day.
- 1 Corinthians 15:4
And that he was buried, and that he rose again the third day according to the scriptures:
Christ was buried and raised on the third day, as signified by Jonah.
- Mark 10:34
And they shall mock him, and shall scourge him, and shall spit upon him, and shall kill him: and the third day he shall rise again.
Jesus predicts his resurrection on the third day.
- Matthew 20:19
And shall deliver him to the Gentiles to mock, and to scourge, and to crucify him: and the third day he shall rise again.
Christ again predicts his resurrection on the third day.
- Jonah 2:1
Then Jonah prayed unto the LORD his God out of the fish’s belly,
Jonah prays from the fish’s belly, paralleling Christ’s time in the heart of the earth.
- Luke 24:46
And said unto them, Thus it is written, and thus it behoved Christ to suffer, and to rise from the dead the third day:
Both texts say Christ would rise from the dead on the third day.
- Luke 18:33
And they shall scourge him, and put him to death: and the third day he shall rise again.
Jesus predicts his resurrection on the third day.
- Mark 16:9
Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils.
Its wording places Jesus’ resurrection early on the first day of the week.
- Luke 13:32
And he said unto them, Go ye, and tell that fox, Behold, I cast out devils, and I do cures to day and to morrow, and the third day I shall be perfected.
Christ’s today, tomorrow, and third day illustrate inclusive reckoning of time.
- Luke 24:7
Saying, The Son of man must be delivered into the hands of sinful men, and be crucified, and the third day rise again.
Jesus’ death and resurrection are foretold for the third day.
- Matthew 17:23
And they shall kill him, and the third day he shall be raised again. And they were exceeding sorry.
Jesus foretells rising on the third day.
- Matthew 27:59-60
And when Joseph had taken the body, he wrapped it in a clean linen cloth,
Joseph lays Jesus in the tomb, where his body remains for the stated period.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
6 sources
Jonah's three days and three nights in the belly of the whale was a sign pointing to the Son of man being the same length of time in the heart of the earth.DA 405.3–406.2ST Oct 1, 1896 When the Pharisees and Sadducees demanded a sign from heaven, this sign of the prophet Jonah was the only sign to be given.DA 405.3–406.2 No further outward proof was given because those asking needed spiritual renovation rather than intellectual enlightenment, which mere external evidence could not provide, even such a wonder as the sun standing still for Joshua.DA 405.3–406.2 Sufficient attestation had already been given through Christ's own convicting words spoken with the power of the Holy Spirit and through signs direct from heaven, namely the angels' song to the shepherds, the star guiding the wise men, and the dove and voice at His baptism.DA 405.3–406.2
Just as Jonah's preaching was a sign to the Ninevites, so Christ's preaching was the sign to His generation.DA 405.3–406.2 Since Nineveh repented at Jonah's warning, the Ninevites will rise in judgment against the generation that rejects One greater than Jonah, leaving those rejecters condemned.DA 405.3–406.2PK 273.1
The three days and three nights in the heart of the earth were foreshadowed when Jesus was separated from His parents after the Passover and was sought for three days.LC1 30.22SP 36.2ST Dec 9, 1880 That childhood separation pointed to how His death for the sins of the world would separate Him from them for three days, after which He would reveal Himself and be found.LC1 30.22SP 36.2ST Dec 9, 1880 Then their faith would rest on Him as Redeemer of fallen humanity and Advocate with the Father.LC1 30.22SP 36.2ST Dec 9, 1880 That early experience prepared His parents for the sorrow of His death and for the hope of seeing Him again.ST Dec 9, 1880
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
83 sources
The heart of the earth is the grave where Jesus lay buried from part of Friday through the Sabbath to part of Sunday, while those who take it more broadly hold it means his being under betrayal and the power of earthly rulers and darkness from arrest to resurrection.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Feb 7, 1900RH Apr 12, 1860RH Jun 24, 1873 Three days and three nights is Jewish speech for three days in round terms, where part of a day counts as a whole, naming the same period elsewhere called on the third day and after three days.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Apr 2, 1912ST Oct 28, 1897ST Mar 8, 1910ST Oct 19, 1915 Jonah's three days in the great fish was a real deliverance made a divinely intended picture of Christ held in death and then rising.ST May 5, 1914ST Nov 13, 1893ST Jun 21, 1899ST Feb 2, 1915 It was given as the sign to a sign-demanding generation, making the resurrection the climactic proof of his Messiahship with warning of judgment as Nineveh will condemn them.ST May 17, 1899RH Jun 27, 1871ST Jul 15, 1880 He himself, not his body only, lay under death's power until God raised him, having not gone to heaven or Paradise that day, and the interval neither makes Sunday the seventh day nor moves the Sabbath.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Nov 17, 1859ST Jun 14, 1899RH Jan 5, 1860ST Dec 13, 1883
Meaning of Key Phrases
The heart of the earth is being under the power of earthly rulers and the powers of darkness under Satan, centered at that time in Roman authority, not only lying in the grave.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 11, 1912ST Oct 28, 1897ST Jan 28, 1913 Jesus entered that power when he was betrayed and arrested, when his hour and the hour and power of darkness came, and he remained under betrayal, persecution, trial, suffering, death and burial until God released him by resurrection.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906ST Oct 28, 1897 That holding began Thursday night at the start of the sixth day when he was delivered into his enemies' hands, and continued through Friday and the Sabbath to early Sunday, counted as Thursday night, Friday and Friday night, Sabbath day and following night, and Sunday morning.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906ST Oct 28, 1897ST Jan 28, 1913 The comparison with Jonah does not establish a seventy-two-hour period, for three days and three nights is a way of reckoning three days, with parts of two days and all of one day reckoned as three days.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912ST Oct 28, 1897
On the other reading held by others, the heart of the earth is the grave or tomb hewn in rock where Jesus was buried, including part of Friday, all of Saturday, and part of Sunday.ST Dec 21, 1882RH Jun 24, 1873RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jan 9, 1872ST Dec 11, 1928 On this reading the three days and three nights describe his entombment and time in Joseph's tomb before resurrection, from burial near sunset Friday to resurrection at dawn on the first day.ST Dec 21, 1882RH Apr 12, 1860RH Jun 24, 1873RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jan 9, 1872 It is fulfilled by Jesus being in the tomb during part of Friday, all of Saturday, and part of Sunday, with one whole day and parts of two other days counted as three days and three nights.ST Dec 21, 1882RH Jun 24, 1873RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jan 9, 1872ST Dec 11, 1928 Even reckoned exactly from the laying in the tomb, some counted it as three days and three nights in Joseph's tomb from evening to evening, with laying at evening and rising at evening on the seventh-day Sabbath before the first day began.RH Apr 12, 1860
Whether heart of the earth means the grave or the power of Rome and the rulers of darkness cannot always be settled from this verse alone, since the phrase occurs only here and is nowhere else defined.ST Mar 8, 1910ST Sep 25, 1893ST Mar 4, 1903RH Oct 4, 1864ST Oct 10, 1906 The grave is not literally the heart or center of the globe, and it is arbitrary to insist it means only the grave.RH Apr 7, 1851ST Mar 8, 1910ST Sep 25, 1893ST Mar 4, 1903RH Oct 4, 1864 It may mean the time Christ was handed over to his enemies and held by wicked people and the Devil, including before Pilate and on the cross as well as in the tomb, just as Jonah was held in the creature and then rose in triumph.RH Apr 7, 1851ST Sep 25, 1893ST Apr 12, 1905ST Apr 21, 1914ST Oct 10, 1906 Its exact meaning is not specified, and the verse does not by itself settle Friday versus Thursday crucifixion or whether the reference is exclusively to burial in the tomb.ST Sep 25, 1893ST Mar 4, 1903RH Oct 4, 1864ST Apr 21, 1914ST Oct 10, 1906
Three days and three nights is a Jewish idiom in which day and night means a day, so the phrase means three days in round terms and in general speech.ST Oct 28, 1897ST Mar 8, 1910ST Jan 28, 1913ST Mar 3, 1890 It does not mean a full seventy-two hours or the whole of three days, but parts of three days, the whole of the middle day with part of the first and part of the last, even a day shorter than twenty-four hours.ST Mar 8, 1910ST Oct 19, 1915ST Mar 3, 1890ST Nov 24, 1914 In Jewish and biblical reckoning part of a day counted as a whole day, with the preceding night included, so part of Friday counted as the first day, Friday night and Saturday as the second, and Saturday night and part of Sunday as the third.ST Oct 28, 1897ST Oct 19, 1915ST Jan 28, 1913ST Mar 3, 1890 The same period is elsewhere described as in three days, within three days, after three days, on the third day, and the third day since these things were done.ST Jun 11, 1912ST Mar 3, 1890ST Mar 4, 1903ST Apr 21, 1914ST Oct 10, 1906
The whale is a general term for a great fish or sea monster, the Greek ketos, not a word specifying a whale.ST Mar 4, 1903ST Oct 28, 1889ST Apr 25, 1878RH Sep 11, 1860ST Oct 29, 1885 It could refer to a large shark or other huge fish, matching Jonah's account of being swallowed by a fish, and the original description is simply a great fish.ST Mar 4, 1903ST Oct 28, 1889ST Apr 25, 1878RH Sep 11, 1860ST Oct 29, 1885 A great fish such as a sufficiently large shark could swallow a person whole, and large fish can swallow a person, so the creature's exact kind is not identified.ST Apr 25, 1878ST Oct 28, 1889ST Apr 25, 1878RH Sep 11, 1860ST Oct 29, 1885 A northern bone whale's narrow throat could not admit a man, but a sperm whale's throat is wide enough to swallow a man, and preparation could have consisted in God causing such a whale to enter the Mediterranean and be in the right place at the right time to take him up.ST Apr 25, 1878 Jonah's survival in it was miraculous, no more miraculous than the preservation of the three Hebrews in the furnace or Daniel in the lions' den.ST Apr 25, 1878ST Apr 25, 1878RH Sep 11, 1860ST Oct 29, 1885
Jonah remained alive inside the sea creature, though near destruction, and God rescued him.ST Apr 12, 1905 His prayer indicates he remained alive though his life was near destruction, and the reference is to duration under the power of an agent of destruction, just as Christ was under the power of the prince of this world controlling the Roman power.ST Apr 12, 1905 The three days and three nights describe a continuous period of about three days, possibly including only part of the first and last days, stated in the same idiom as Christ's period.ST Apr 12, 1905ST Nov 24, 1914 The likeness to Jonah does not prove seventy-two hours, because Jonah's time is stated in the same idiom, and repeated Old Testament use shows day can mean only part of a day.ST Apr 12, 1905ST Nov 24, 1914
Reckoning Three Days
The phrase does not require seventy-two full hours, for in Jewish and biblical reckoning part of a day counted as a whole day, so part of the first day with all of the second and part of the third, or parts of two days with a whole day between, could be called three days and three nights.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Apr 2, 1912ST Feb 7, 1900ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912 In that ordinary usage the same period could be named as three days and three nights and as the third day.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Mar 15, 1883 The expression heart of the earth in this reckoning reaches beyond lying in the grave alone to the time Christ was delivered into the hands of his enemies and held under their power, and the Gospel accounts of that period use time expressions with some latitude.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912 From betrayal on Thursday night at the beginning of the sixth day through Friday and the Sabbath to part of the first day, part of the sixth day with all of the seventh and part of the first could thus be reckoned as three days.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906
The three days and three nights name the same period elsewhere called the third day, on the third day, in three days, within three days, and after three days, so Jesus was to rise on the third day and not after three complete twenty-four-hour periods.ST Jun 11, 1912ST Mar 15, 1883ST Mar 3, 1890ST Feb 17, 1888ST Mar 3, 1890 Burial toward the close of Friday with the Sabbath as the second day and resurrection very early on the first day of the week fulfills the saying, and the disciples calling the first day the third day since these things were done fixes that closing day.ST Mar 15, 1883ST Mar 3, 1890ST Feb 17, 1888 Day and night was a common Jewish term for a day, and Jonah's time is stated in the same idiom without proving seventy-two hours, since his exact time in the fish is not known.ST Mar 3, 1890ST Nov 24, 1914 Scripture elsewhere counts parts as wholes in the same way, as when Esther's fast described as three days and nights ended when she went before the king on the third day, and repeated Old Testament use shows day can mean only part of a day.ST Apr 21, 1914ST Nov 24, 1914
Others take the three days and nights as a literal measure requiring three full days and nights in the tomb, so that a Friday crucifixion would demand a Monday resurrection.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Aug 5, 1852 That literal reading is used to argue for an earlier crucifixion day to fit the interval, and to claim that a first-day resurrection on that theory would make Sunday the seventh day.RH Jan 9, 1872RH Aug 5, 1852 On one such reckoning the period is counted as exactly three days and three nights in Joseph's tomb from the time Jesus was laid there at evening on the fourth day of the week to rising at evening on the seventh-day Sabbath before the first day began.RH Apr 12, 1860RH Apr 12, 1860 If two Sabbaths are placed between crucifixion and resurrection the same kind of calculation instead puts the crucifixion on Thursday two days before the Sabbath, and therefore does not establish shifting the Sabbath or resurrection day forward.RH Oct 4, 1853
The verse states the time between death and resurrection to fulfill the type, but its length has no bearing on proving the weekday of resurrection.ST Nov 24, 1914ST Jun 7, 1910 It must be read with Matthew 28:1-7, Luke 23:56, Luke 24:1-2, and Mark 16:7, answering on what day Christ was crucified, what the three days and nights mean, whether they mean absolutely seventy-two hours, when the days begin, on what day he arose, and what bearing that time has on the Sabbath question.ST Nov 24, 1914 Reading heart of the earth to mean three nights in the sepulchre creates a contradiction with crucifixion on Friday and raising on the first day, forcing the conclusion that he was either not crucified on Friday or not raised until Monday morning.ST Jun 10, 1875ST Nov 12, 1912RH Mar 15, 1860 What look like contradictions and difficulties come from understanding of texts rather than what the texts declare, and an obscure text must be interpreted to agree with plain statements rather than bending plain statements to agree with ideas about an obscure text, for the important thing is the death and resurrection itself and what that event means.ST Jun 10, 1875ST Jun 7, 1910
Arrest to Resurrection Timeline
The three days and three nights run from arrest to resurrection, not from burial alone, beginning Thursday night which by Bible reckoning is the start of the sixth day when Jesus was delivered into his enemies' hands.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906ST Oct 28, 1897 The heart of the earth in this reckoning is not identified as the grave alone but as being under earthly powers under Satan, represented at that time by Roman authority and the rulers of darkness, so the period includes betrayal, rejection by elders and priests and scribes, scourging, suffering, trial, crucifixion, death and burial until God released him by resurrection.ST Jun 11, 1912ST Oct 28, 1897ST Jul 25, 1911ST Jan 28, 1913 It is counted as Thursday night, Friday and Friday night, Sabbath day and the following night, and Sunday morning, spanning part of the sixth day, all of the seventh day, and part of the first day, ending with resurrection early on the first day.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jan 28, 1913ST May 27, 1897ST Oct 10, 1906 Day and night in this expression means a day, and three days and three nights is a way of reckoning three days in round terms and in general speech, not necessarily seventy-two full hours, since parts of two days with a whole day between, or part of the first day, all of the second, and part of the third, could be called by the same name.ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jun 11, 1912ST Oct 28, 1897ST Jan 28, 1913 The same period is elsewhere named the third day, on the third day, in three days, within three days, and after three days, and the comparison with Jonah does not establish an exact seventy-two-hour period for either.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Jun 11, 1912ST Mar 15, 1883
The prediction is fulfilled by crucifixion on Friday and burial near sunset toward the close of Friday, rest in the tomb over the seventh-day Sabbath, and resurrection at dawn or midway through the first day of the week.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jul 25, 1911ST Jan 28, 1913ST Mar 15, 1883 Under Jewish reckoning beginning the day at sunset, Friday from about noon to sunset counts as the first day, Saturday as the second, and Saturday sunset to Sunday morning as the third, while the Bible's first day began at sunset and the later Roman Sunday began at midnight afterward.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jun 14, 1899ST Apr 4, 1906ST Jan 28, 1913 Jesus was therefore buried on Friday, slept in the grave over the Sabbath which was the seventh day commanded in Scripture and observed by the Jews, and was raised the first day of the week, which was the third day as then understood in the common broad sense.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Jun 14, 1899ST Jul 25, 1911ST Jan 28, 1913ST Mar 15, 1883 At that day's close the disciples on the first day called it the third day since these things were done, fixing Sunday as the closing day.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jul 25, 1911ST Jan 28, 1913ST Mar 3, 1890ST May 27, 1897 Counted back from Sunday, Friday is the first day, the Sabbath the second, and Sunday the third, so if the betrayal was Thursday evening the period included Friday night and day, Sabbath night and day, and Sunday night into early morning, and the crucifixion cannot be placed earlier than Thursday.ST Feb 7, 1900ST Jul 25, 1911ST Mar 3, 1890ST May 27, 1897ST Oct 10, 1906
Those who held a literal measure required three full days and nights in the tomb, so that a Friday crucifixion would demand a Monday resurrection.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Apr 12, 1860RH Aug 5, 1852RH Apr 20, 1905 On that calculation the period is understood as exactly three days and three nights in Joseph's tomb counted from the time Jesus was laid there at evening, placing burial at evening on the fourth day with resurrection at evening on the seventh-day Sabbath before the first day began, or placing crucifixion on Wednesday with resurrection on the Sabbath, or placing crucifixion on Thursday with resurrection on the third day.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Apr 12, 1860RH Aug 5, 1852RH Apr 20, 1905 A Wednesday crucifixion followed by three complete twenty-four-hour periods would put the resurrection on the fourth day, conflicting with rising on the third day, and a two-Sabbaths scheme with two Sabbaths between crucifixion and resurrection shifts the crucifixion to Thursday two days before the Sabbath rather than moving the Sabbath or the resurrection.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Aug 5, 1852RH Apr 20, 1905RH Jun 2, 1851 The same literal timing has been used to support the claim that Christ had to remain seventy-two hours and that Friday crucifixion with first-day resurrection would make Sunday the seventh day, and to argue that the first day was actually the seventh day requiring the conclusion that the days of the week had been miscounted by one, which does not establish that the Sabbath or resurrection day should be shifted forward and gives no ground for undermining seventh-day observance.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Aug 5, 1852RH Apr 20, 1905RH Jun 2, 1851
Requiring a Wednesday-evening to Sabbath-evening or a Thursday to Sunday-morning entombment to make full days and nights contradicts other scriptures speaking of the same subject.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Jan 9, 1872RH Apr 12, 1860RH Apr 20, 1905 It also opposes the commemoration of his sufferings and death by Good Friday observance from the earliest ages and of his resurrection by observance of the first day in memory of a Sunday resurrection, with no dissent recorded in early history.
Jonah as Sign
Jesus treated Jonah's three days and three nights in the great fish as a real historical event and miracle forming the pattern for the Son of man's three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.ST May 5, 1914ST Nov 13, 1893ST Jun 21, 1899ST Dec 11, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889 Denying that Jonah was swallowed and kept inside the creature would make Christ's comparison rest on an impossibility and make his statement untrue.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Dec 10, 1894 Denying Jonah's experience and deliverance in the same way undermines belief in Jesus' own death and resurrection and in the truth of his existence and words.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Jun 21, 1899ST Dec 10, 1894 The creature is understood in general terms as a great fish or sea monster rather than necessarily a northern bone whale whose narrow throat could not admit a man, since a sperm whale has a throat wide enough to swallow a man and God could bring such a whale into the Mediterranean to be in the right place at the right time to take Jonah up.ST Apr 25, 1878
The saying was given as the sign of Jonah to Pharisees demanding a sign, with no other sign to be given to that sign-demanding generation.ST May 17, 1899ST Dec 10, 1894RH Jun 27, 1871ST Jul 15, 1880 Refusal to perform miracles to satisfy idle curiosity or to prove himself to scoffers teaches that the sign directs attention to Christ himself rather than supplying an excuse for indecision.RH Jun 27, 1871ST Jul 15, 1880 It points to Christ and his death and time in the grave, fulfilled in his death, as the climactic proof of Messiahship and sign from heaven, and Jonah's deliverance and resurrection prefigured Christ's resurrection.ST Dec 11, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889RH Aug 1, 1907 Christ used this definite sign in proclaiming judgment to his generation, connecting it with the Ninevites' repentance at Jonah's preaching and warning that they will condemn a generation that had a greater preacher among them.RH Oct 26, 1911 Although Jonah's experience was known as a fact for generations, it became a sign when Jesus interpreted it as one, showing that an event can occur before the generation that recognizes it as a sign and that the sign had been divinely intended from the beginning.ST Dec 11, 1893RH Aug 1, 1907
Jonah's time held in the creature and his emergence typifies Christ held in the heart of the earth and rising again, with the fish's belly representing a grave and emergence typifying resurrection.ST Dec 11, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889ST Dec 11, 1928 In this way the verse makes Jonah's deliverance an object lesson of God's power and willingness to save people and reveals God's power in raising Christ.ST Feb 2, 1915ST Nov 25, 1889 The sign is thus presented as evidence that the book of Jonah is inspired Scripture and supports faith in the unity of the God of the Old and New Testaments within one divine system.ST Dec 11, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889
Jonah's later role as a sign of death and time in the grave is distinct from his preaching as a warning to Nineveh.ST Sep 22, 1881ST Dec 11, 1893 The parallel also includes Christ's anguish as he faced the cup, his delivery into human hands, and his feeling forsaken, which Jonah's experience pictured imperfectly.ST Dec 11, 1893 Jonah's deliverance and resurrection, followed by his warning to Nineveh, picture the proclamation that followed Christ's resurrection.RH Oct 26, 1911ST Dec 11, 1893 Nineveh's repentance represents Gentiles turning to God with the world's judgment averted for a time, while Nineveh's later destruction points to the coming judgment of the world.ST Dec 11, 1893
Noah's time in the ark during the Deluge is also treated as a prefiguration of Christ's entombment, with Noah's emergence from the ark compared with Jonah's emergence from the fish and Christ's emergence from the grave in resurrection.ST Dec 11, 1928ST Dec 11, 1928 A three-year period of Noah's confinement, counted by an ancient inclusive method that included the year of entry, the year spent in the ark, and the year of exit, is described as a prophecy of the three-day period of Christ's entombment counted inclusively as one complete day with parts of the days at either end.ST Dec 11, 1928ST Dec 11, 1928 The grave is also compared with a womb, from which resurrection is a second birth.ST Dec 11, 1928
Doctrines and Controversies
The comparison places the Son of man himself in the heart of the earth for three days and three nights, not his body alone, showing that in death all that was of him was dead and he died wholly as men die, soul and body.RH Nov 17, 1859RH Feb 15, 1870 He therefore remained under the power of death until the resurrection and had not gone to heaven on the day of the crucifixion, and his resurrection preceded his glorification and ascent to the Father.RH Jan 5, 1860ST Dec 13, 1883ST Nov 4, 1880 To suppose he had departed to Paradise on that day or had returned on Sunday from another realm while lying in the tomb would divide him into two persons rather than one Christ, and the claim that he and the thief went to Paradise in the heart of the earth on the crucifixion day is rejected, with no proof that Paradise lay beneath the earth.ST Nov 4, 1880RH Jul 6, 1916 As he passed through death, grave, resurrection and then ascension, so his church as his body will follow the same order of resurrection, translation and glory at his coming.RH Jan 5, 1860ST Dec 13, 1883
This time in the heart of the earth belongs to his becoming man, dying, being buried and rising again while remaining the Son of God, his humanity never meaning that he ceased to be divine.ST Jun 25, 1902 He took the nature of man and became in all respects like his brethren, yet possessed a divinity no mere man possesses, for he was the Word who in the beginning was with God and was God and then became flesh.RH Feb 15, 1870 Divinity cannot be produced by a human body, and his coming to life again was by miracle and not by the operation of physical laws, so that God lay dead near Jerusalem for three days and three nights.RH Feb 15, 1870
The three days and three nights do not prove that Sunday is the seventh day nor shift the Sabbath forward, and the Sabbath remains the fixed point which the day of death or resurrection does not affect.RH Oct 4, 1853ST Jun 14, 1899ST Nov 24, 1914 On a reckoning of three full days and three full nights, a Friday crucifixion would require a Monday resurrection, and the argument that would make Sunday the seventh day instead puts the crucifixion on Thursday two days before the Sabbath if two Sabbaths are placed between crucifixion and resurrection.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Aug 5, 1852 The phrase need not mean exactly seventy-two hours in the grave, since the heart of the earth is not shown to mean only the grave and may mean the power of earth's rulers, the rulers of darkness, and Jonah's time in the sea monster is likewise not shown to have been exactly seventy-two hours, while Jesus repeatedly said he would rise on the third day.ST Jun 14, 1899ST Nov 24, 1914RH Apr 20, 1905 He was betrayed into their hands on Thursday night and remained in their power through Friday, the Sabbath and part of the first day, and a Wednesday crucifixion with Sabbath resurrection would put the resurrection on the fourth day in conflict with rising on the third day.ST Jun 14, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905 The question must be read with Matthew 28:1-7, Luke 23:56, Luke 24:1-2 and Mark 16:7, covering on what day he was crucified, what the three days and three nights mean, whether they mean absolutely seventy-two hours, when the days begin, on what day he arose, and what bearing that time has on the Sabbath question, with the Sabbath as the seventh day commanded in Scripture and observed by the Jews, the Bible first day beginning at sunset while Roman Sunday began at midnight afterward.ST Jun 14, 1899ST Nov 24, 1914 The chapter shows his acts to have been in accordance with mercy, the weightier matter of the law, and therefore no violation of the law, giving no justification for open wilful violation of the fourth commandment.RH Feb 3, 1852
To use his three days in the grave to justify three immersions in baptism as a sign of his burial rests on a false view of the ordinance and is not scriptural teaching about baptism.ST Jan 20, 1881 The naming of Jonah's period as three days and three nights stands as an example of the distinction between night and day.RH Dec 12, 1871
Connections and Application
Jesus lay alongside humanity in the heart of the earth for three days and three nights, as a father lay with his son in the place of punishment.ST Sep 5, 1911ST Sep 5, 1911 His coming did not remove sin or suffering from afar, but God came in the person of His Son to share the human condition and to come close to people to help them hate evil and long for purity.ST Sep 5, 1911 That being in the heart of the earth was His descent into the depths of human suffering and death, culminating in crucifixion, and by humbling Himself and bearing sin He became the foundation on which sinners can build for salvation and everlasting life.
The interval marks darkness followed by triumph, for the Son of man remained under death's power for three days and three nights in Joseph's sealed tomb and then rose, and the path from crucifixion to resurrection life is short.ST Dec 13, 1883ST Apr 6, 1888RH Mar 26, 1901 His resurrection, not death itself, preceded His glorification and ascent to the Father, bringing life, promise, and hope out of death and despair like a buried grain that brings forth new growth and like a birth into immortality.ST Dec 13, 1883RH Mar 26, 1901 His church, pictured as His body, will follow the same order of resurrection, translation, and glory at His coming.ST Dec 13, 1883
His being separated from His parents and found after three days foreshadowed His being lost to them for three days in death before revealing Himself again.ST Dec 9, 1880 Afterward they would find Him and trust Him as their Redeemer and advocate with the Father.ST Dec 9, 1880 This experience prepared them for the sorrow of His death and the hope of seeing Him again.ST Dec 9, 1880
Jonah's three days and nights in the creature's power is a sign of Jesus' mission, for Jesus too would be held three days and nights in the power of those seeking His death.RH Jun 8, 1911 The three days and three nights in the whale was a literal event used as a sign of the Son of man's three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.RH Feb 21, 1856 That truth belonged to Jonah's time and, in its relation to Christ, belongs to the end of the world.RH Feb 21, 1856
Christ's use of Jonah affirms the authority and trustworthiness of the Old Testament, showing that Christ is not separate from its accounts and that its histories teach present spiritual truth within one divine system.ST Oct 15, 1912ST Nov 25, 1889ST Feb 22, 1883 Jonah's three days and nights in the great fish were a real event and a divinely intended sign of Christ's death and time in the grave, fulfilled by Christ's death and prefiguring His resurrection and the resurrection of the dead.ST Oct 15, 1912ST Dec 11, 1893RH Mar 9, 1911 The sign is therefore evidence that the book of Jonah is inspired Scripture, to be read and understood as far as possible and then believed because Scripture is God's authoritative word, and accepting Jonah's account belongs to accepting the authority of Scripture and faith in the unity of the God of the Old and New Testaments.ST Dec 11, 1893ST Feb 22, 1883ST Jul 23, 1885
Sources