AdventAI

Matthew 17:10

And his disciples asked him, saying, Why then say the scribes that Elias must first come?

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

2 sources

The question is asked after Elijah's appearance at the transfiguration and connects that appearance with the teaching that Elijah must come first.3RED 119.2–120.1 It reflects the disciples' expectation that Christ's kingdom would be set up on earth and that heavenly messengers might protect Him from what awaited Him in Jerusalem.3RED 119.2–120.1 That expectation overlooked that His suffering and death were necessary to complete the plan of salvation.3RED 119.2–120.1

The verse belongs to standing with Christ on the mount of transfiguration, beholding His beauty as chiefest among ten thousand and altogether lovely until the soul becomes radiant with the glory risen upon it.ST Jan 22, 1902 In that standing the disciple receives the call to arise and shine.ST Jan 22, 1902 That mountaintop standing sends the disciple down into the plain where souls enslaved by Satan wait to be set free by faith and prayer.ST Jan 22, 1902 That freeing work is done by drinking deeply of Christ's self-sacrificing love that seeks not its own and labors and sacrifices even to death for the saving of humanity.ST Jan 22, 1902

Sources

  1. 3RED 119.2–120.1 Redemption: Or the Miracles of Christ, the Mighty One — THE TRANSFIGURATION. Ellen G. White, 1877
  2. ST Jan 22, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 4 — THE JOY OF GIVING Ellen G. White, January 22, 1902

Pioneers and periodicals

28 sources

Coming down from the mount after seeing Elijah with Jesus glorified and being charged to keep the vision secret until His resurrection, the disciples asked about the scribes' teaching that Elijah must come first before the Messiah, resting on the promise to send Elijah before the great and dreadful day of the Lord.ST Jul 4, 1899ST Jul 23, 1885RH Mar 3, 1904ST Aug 22, 1900ST Aug 7, 1901 Jesus answered that Elijah truly shall first come and restore all things, but that Elijah is come already unrecognized and suffered at men's hands, and they understood He meant John the Baptist.RH Mar 3, 1904ST Jun 14, 1910ST Aug 7, 1901 John was that coming not by being Elijah in person but by bearing his message in his spirit and power as type and prototype calling to repentance, and had he been received he would have completed the restoring work, while his rejection left that fulfillment typical of a greater final work.RH Mar 3, 1904ST Aug 22, 1900RH Nov 5, 1903RH Apr 7, 1903ST Jun 6, 1900 That final Elijah work will be done before the second advent not by one man to one nation but by all God's people to the world in the same spirit and power, reproving sin and apostasy, while the mount vision itself displayed the coming kingdom of glory in which Elijah represents those to be translated without death and Moses those to be raised from the dead.ST Nov 7, 1900RH May 11, 1916ST May 9, 1906ST Sep 3, 1896ST Mar 20, 1901

Setting and Question

The disciples put the question to Jesus while coming down from the Mount of Transfiguration, after He had charged them to keep the vision secret until His resurrection from the dead.ST Jul 4, 1899ST Jul 23, 1885RH Mar 3, 1904 Their asking why the scribes taught that Elijah must come first joined the promised coming of Elijah to the vision they had just witnessed and to His words about rising from the dead.ST Jul 4, 1899ST Jul 23, 1885RH Mar 3, 1904

The question followed His announcement that as Messiah He must enter His glory through suffering shame and death.ST Oct 6, 1881 That announcement shocked their hopes of national regeneration, left them unable to understand, and left them sorely discouraged about their own future, so they needed to be cheered and led gradually to accept His humiliation.ST Oct 6, 1881 He had promised that some of them would see His kingdom come with power before death, a promise fulfilled six days afterward, eight days counting first and last.ST Oct 6, 1881 The setting was a secluded spur of Hermon near Caesarea Philippi where Jesus then was, from which they did not start for Galilee until at least the day after, not fortified Mount Tabor with its city which could not offer the indicated seclusion.ST Oct 6, 1881

Even after seeing Elijah with Jesus at the transfiguration, the disciples did not yet understand what they had witnessed and heard.ST Jul 4, 1899 Elias is the Greek and Latin form of Elijah used in the authorized New Testament where newer versions read Elijah.ST Jul 12, 1883 The Elias asked about is the prophet who ascended in the chariot and whirlwind of fire.ST Jul 12, 1883

The disciples shared the scribes' teaching and the prevalent Jewish expectation that Elijah must come first in person before the Messiah and before the promised deliverance and restoration.ST Aug 22, 1900RH Apr 7, 1903ST Sep 3, 1896 That expectation included the tradition that both Moses and Elijah would appear in the Messiah's time.ST Oct 6, 1881 The question rests on the promise to send Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord.ST Aug 7, 1901

The transfiguration on the mount occurred during Christ's first advent about twelve months before His earthly mission closed, and therefore was not His second coming.RH Jun 18, 1861

Elijah Come in John

Jesus affirms that Elijah truly comes first and restores all things, yet declares that Elijah has already come, was not recognized, and suffered whatever men chose to do to him, and the disciples understood that He spoke of John the Baptist.ST Jun 14, 1910ST Aug 7, 1901 The question arose after they had seen Elijah glorified with Moses and Jesus on the mount of transfiguration.ST Aug 7, 1901 John fulfilled that promised coming not by being Elijah himself returned in person but through the message he bore and in Elijah's spirit and power.ST Aug 7, 1901RH Apr 7, 1903ST Jun 6, 1900 This fulfillment did not require John to claim that he is Elijah, for John answered that he was not Elijah personally, yet Jesus identifies him as Elijah because Elijah was a type of John.RH Nov 5, 1903ST Sep 3, 1896 The verse thus introduces the distinction between Elijah's person and the prophetic spirit and work associated with him.ST Sep 3, 1896RH Dec 10, 1867ST Nov 18, 1903

John came as prototype to the same people, calling them to repentance and obedience to God's law.ST Aug 7, 1901 He came in Elijah's spirit and power, but the people failed to recognize and accept him, rejected him, mistreated him, and so did not complete the prophecy on their behalf.RH Mar 3, 1904ST Aug 22, 1900ST Aug 7, 1901 Had they received him as God's prophet, he would have fulfilled the work of preparing the people and restoring all things.RH Mar 3, 1904 His work therefore fulfilled Elijah's work and message on the condition of reception, and its rejection left the way open for a fuller fulfillment.RH Mar 3, 1904ST Jun 14, 1910ST Aug 22, 1900

Jesus teaches that John the Baptist was Elijah and was the Messenger of the Covenant.ST Aug 14, 1901 With Malachi teaching that the Messenger of the Covenant and Elijah must come again, both offices center in one man whose work is the preparation of God's people for Christ's coming.ST Aug 14, 1901

Future Work and Glory

Elijah's work will have a fuller, greater final fulfillment through God's people before Christ's second advent, with the final warning message going forth in Elijah's spirit and power.ST Aug 22, 1900RH May 11, 1916ST Sep 3, 1896ST Nov 18, 1903ST Mar 20, 1901 John represents and is the type of those who prepare a people for the second coming, just as he prepared the way for the first, possessing the same spirit and power and doing a similar work.ST Aug 22, 1900RH May 11, 1916ST Sep 3, 1896ST Mar 20, 1901 John fulfilled the coming of Elijah by coming in Elijah's spirit and power, with Elijah as his type, and Elijah is likewise the type of those who herald Christ's second coming to the world.RH May 11, 1916ST Sep 3, 1896ST Mar 20, 1901

The great and terrible day of the Lord came then only upon the Jewish nation as a nation, not upon the world, so the fulfillment in John was typical of a greater final fulfillment.ST Mar 20, 1901 That final Elijah work will be done not through one person to one country but through all God's true people to the world, with the spirit and power of Elijah to reprove sin, preach God's downtrodden truth, and be zealous for His law.ST Mar 20, 1901 It will reprove Baal sun-worshipers amid apostasy like Israel's under Ahab and the sun-worshiping Jezebel and its antitype in the great apostate church united with the state.ST Mar 20, 1901 The bearers of that final message will not claim to be Elijah or his reincarnation, but their boast will be in Christ.ST Nov 18, 1903

The transfiguration scene in the chapter represents the kingdom of glory, Jesus in His future glorified state coming in His kingdom with His saints.RH Jan 5, 1860ST Nov 7, 1900ST Aug 28, 1901 It fulfilled Christ's promise that some of the disciples would see the Son of man coming in His kingdom.ST Aug 28, 1901 In that scene Elijah, who was translated without seeing death after being taken to heaven, represents those who will be translated at Christ's coming.ST Nov 7, 1900ST May 3, 1910ST Aug 28, 1901 Moses, who died and was buried yet appears, lived again by resurrection and with Elijah represents the righteous dead who will be raised at the Lord's coming.RH Jan 5, 1860ST May 9, 1906ST Aug 28, 1901 Together they represent the righteous living who will be translated and the righteous dead who will be raised at the Lord's coming.ST Aug 28, 1901

Moses' appearance in the mountain vision does not show that the dead are consciously alive before the resurrection.RH Jan 5, 1860 The disciples recognized Moses and Elijah when they appeared and spoke with Jesus, supporting that people will know one another in heaven.ST May 13, 1908 The verse stands between transfiguration triumph on the mountain and giving the glory of His life to the needy multitude in the valley below, showing that after mountain triumph comes the labor, travail, pain and triumph of saving sick bodies and dying souls.ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 8, 1901 Standing with Christ on the mount beholding His beauty until radiant with the Lord's glory sends the disciple down into the plain where sick bodies, dying souls, and souls enslaved by Satan wait for the word of faith and prayer to set them free.ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 8, 1901 That work is done by drinking deeply of Christ's self-sacrificing love that seeks not its own and labors and sacrifices even unto death for the saving of humanity.ST Jan 22, 1902

Sources

  1. ST Jul 4, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 27 — LESSON IV.—SABBATH, JULY 22, 1899 July 4, 1899
  2. ST Jul 23, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 28 — Elias and John the Baptist July 23, 1885
  3. RH Mar 3, 1904 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 81, No. 9 — Things Which Might Have Been William Covert, March 3, 1904
  4. ST Aug 22, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 34 — WHY SEND ELIJAH AGAIN? G., August 22, 1900
  5. ST Aug 7, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 32 — ARE MR. DOWIE'S CLAIMS TRUE? August 7, 1901
  6. ST Jun 14, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 23 — Elijah the Prophet June 14, 1910
  7. RH Nov 5, 1903 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 80, No. 44 — Elijah the Restorer L. A. S., November 5, 1903
  8. RH Apr 7, 1903 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 80, No. 14 — The “Elijah Message” William Knight, April 7, 1903
  9. ST Jun 6, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 23 — ELIJAH AND HIS PROTOTYPES June 6, 1900
  10. ST Nov 7, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 45 — Note to Questioners Editor, NOVEMBER 7, 1900
  11. RH May 11, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 24 — Earth’s Last Generation — Has It Been Reached? John N. Quinn, May 11, 1916
  12. ST May 9, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 19 — The ROYAL LAW F. C. Gilbert, May 9, 1906
  13. ST Sep 3, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 35 — Answers to Questions September 3, 1896
  14. ST Mar 20, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 12 — THE SABBATH SCHOOL March 20, 1901
  15. ST Oct 6, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 38 — The Sabbath School October 6, 1881
  16. ST Jul 4, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 27 — LESSON IV.—SABBATH, JULY 22, 1899 July 4, 1899
  17. ST Jul 12, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 26 — Questions July 12, 1883
  18. ST Oct 6, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 38 — The Sabbath School October 6, 1881
  19. RH Jun 18, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 4 — MEETINGS IN MICH Joseph Bates, June 18, 1861
  20. RH Dec 10, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 30, No. 26 — EXPERIENCE Elder Joseph Bates, Third-day, December 10, 1867
  21. ST Nov 18, 1903 Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 46 — Deceiving and Being Deceived November 18, 1903
  22. ST Aug 14, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 33 — Who Is the Messenger of the Covenant John Alexander Dowie, August 14, 1901
  23. RH Jan 5, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 7 — INTERMEDIATE STATE L. Maxson, Fifth-Day, January 5, 1860
  24. ST Aug 28, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 35 — Translation and Death W. N. G., August 28, 1901
  25. ST May 3, 1910 Signs of the Times, Vol. 37, No. 17 — OUR BIBLE BAND May 3, 1910
  26. ST May 13, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 20 — With Our Inquirers May 13, 1908
  27. ST May 8, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 19 — CONFERENCE NOTES May 8, 1901
  28. ST Jan 22, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 4 — THE JOY OF GIVING Ellen G. White, January 22, 1902

Cross-references

  1. Malachi 4:5

    Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the LORD:

    The prophecy that Elijah would come first underlies the disciples’ question.

  2. Luke 1:17

    And he shall go before him in the spirit and power of Elias, to turn the hearts of the fathers to the children, and the disobedient to the wisdom of the just; to make ready a people prepared for the Lord.

    John is foretold to go before the Lord in Elijah’s spirit and power.

  3. Matthew 11:14

    And if ye will receive it, this is Elias, which was for to come.

    Jesus identifies John as the promised Elijah.

  4. John 1:21

    And they asked him, What then? Art thou Elias? And he saith, I am not. Art thou that prophet? And he answered, No.

    John denies being Elijah personally, though his work fulfills the prophecy.

  5. Mark 9:11-13

    And they asked him, saying, Why say the scribes that Elias must first come?

    The disciples ask why Elijah must come first, and Jesus explains that Elijah has already come.

  6. 2 Kings 2:11

    And it came to pass, as they still went on, and talked, that, behold, there appeared a chariot of fire, and horses of fire, and parted them both asunder; and Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven.

    Elijah is taken to heaven without dying before appearing at the transfiguration.

  7. Matthew 17:3

    And, behold, there appeared unto them Moses and Elias talking with him.

    Elijah appears with Moses on the mountain, recalling the tradition about his coming.

  8. Luke 9:28-36

    And it came to pass about an eight days after these sayings, he took Peter and John and James, and went up into a mountain to pray.

    Parallel account of the Transfiguration.

  9. 1 Kings 17:1

    And Elijah the Tishbite, who was of the inhabitants of Gilead, said unto Ahab, As the LORD God of Israel liveth, before whom I stand, there shall not be dew nor rain these years, but according to my word.

    Elijah announces drought as he confronts Israel’s apostasy.

  10. Malachi 3:1

    Behold, I will send my messenger, and he shall prepare the way before me: and the Lord, whom ye seek, shall suddenly come to his temple, even the messenger of the covenant, whom ye delight in: behold, he shall come, saith the LORD of hosts.

    Jesus identifies the promised messenger as John, who is yet to come again.

  11. John 1:23

    He said, I am the voice of one crying in the wilderness, Make straight the way of the Lord, as said the prophet Esaias.

    John identifies himself as the voice preparing the Lord’s way.

  12. Matthew 11:10

    For this is he, of whom it is written, Behold, I send my messenger before thy face, which shall prepare thy way before thee.

    Identifies John as the messenger who prepares the way.

  13. 2 Peter 1:16-18

    For we have not followed cunningly devised fables, when we made known unto you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but were eyewitnesses of his majesty.

    Both texts connect to the transfiguration and Christ’s revealed glory.