Matthew 21:25
The baptism of John, whence was it? from heaven, or of men? And they reasoned with themselves, saying, If we shall say, From heaven; he will say unto us, Why did ye not then believe him?
Translations
The baptism of John, from where was it? from heaven, or of men? And they reasoned with themselves, saying, If we shall say, From heaven; he will say to us, Why did you not then believe him?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
The baptism of John, whence was it? from heaven, or of men? And they reasoned with themselves, saying, If we shall say, From heaven; he will say unto us, Why did ye not then believe him?
The baptism of John, whence was it? from heaven, or from men? And they reasoned with themselves, saying, if we shall say, From heaven; he will say to us, Why then did ye not believe him?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
The baptism of John, whence was it? from heaven or from men? And they reasoned with themselves, saying, If we shall say, From heaven; he will say unto us, Why then did ye not believe him?
the baptism of John, whence was it? — from heaven, or from men?' And they were reasoning with themselves, saying, 'If we should say, From heaven; he will say to us, Wherefore, then, did ye not believe him?
The baptism of John, whence was it? of heaven or of men? And they reasoned among themselves, saying, If we should say, Of heaven, he will say to us, Why then have ye not believed him?
The immersion by John, whence was it? Of heaven, or of men? But, they, began to deliberate among themselves, saying—If we say, Of heaven; He will say unto us, Wherefore then did ye not believe him?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
What was the source of John’s baptism? Was it from heaven or from men?”They deliberated among themselves and said, “ If we say, ‘ From heaven,’ He will ask, ‘ Why then did you not believe him?’
The baptism of John, where was it from? From heaven or from men?”They reasoned with themselves, saying, “ If we say, ‘ From heaven,’ he will ask us, ‘ Why then did you not believe him?’
The baptism of John, where did it come from? from heaven or from men? And they were reasoning among themselves, saying, If we say, From heaven; he will say to us, Why then did you not have faith in him?
The baptisme of Iohn, whence was it? from heauen, or of men? Then they reasoned among themselues, saying, If we shall say, From heauen, he will say vnto vs, Why did ye not then beleeue him?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
The baptism of John, whence was it? from heaven or from men? But they thought within themselves, saying:
Cross-references
- John 1:19-27
And this is the record of John, when the Jews sent priests and Levites from Jerusalem to ask him, Who art thou?
John’s testimony and baptism are the subject of Jesus’ question.
- Luke 7:29-30
And all the people that heard him, and the publicans, justified God, being baptized with the baptism of John.
Contrasts those who received John’s baptism with leaders who rejected God’s purpose.
- Luke 20:5-6
And they reasoned with themselves, saying, If we shall say, From heaven; he will say, Why then believed ye him not?
The leaders privately weigh the consequences of answering Jesus about John’s baptism.
- Mark 11:27-33
And they come again to Jerusalem: and as he was walking in the temple, there come to him the chief priests, and the scribes, and the elders,
Jesus asks whether John’s baptism came from heaven or from people.
- Isaiah 40:3
The voice of him that crieth in the wilderness, Prepare ye the way of the LORD, make straight in the desert a highway for our God.
John’s mission fulfills the prophecy of a voice preparing the Lord’s way.
- Matthew 3:16-17
And Jesus, when he was baptized, went up straightway out of the water: and, lo, the heavens were opened unto him, and he saw the Spirit of God descending like a dove, and lighting upon him:
Heavenly signs at Jesus’ baptism affirmed him as God’s Son.
- John 1:29
The next day John seeth Jesus coming unto him, and saith, Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world.
John’s witness to Jesus as the Lamb challenged those who rejected his ministry.
- Matthew 3:1-6
In those days came John the Baptist, preaching in the wilderness of Judaea,
John’s preaching and baptism provide the context for judging the origin of his ministry.
- Malachi 3:1
Behold, I will send my messenger, and he shall prepare the way before me: and the Lord, whom ye seek, shall suddenly come to his temple, even the messenger of the covenant, whom ye delight in: behold, he shall come, saith the LORD of hosts.
The prophecy identifies John as the messenger who prepares the Lord’s way.
- Luke 7:28
For I say unto you, Among those that are born of women there is not a greater prophet than John the Baptist: but he that is least in the kingdom of God is greater than he.
Jesus declared John greater than any prophet who had risen.
- Luke 20:4
The baptism of John, was it from heaven, or of men?
Both ask whether John’s baptism came from heaven or from men.
- Matthew 11:9-11
But what went ye out for to see? A prophet? yea, I say unto you, and more than a prophet.
Jesus testifies to John’s mission and greatness.
- Matthew 21:32
For John came unto you in the way of righteousness, and ye believed him not: but the publicans and the harlots believed him: and ye, when ye had seen it, repented not afterward, that ye might believe him.
Jesus says the leaders did not believe John’s message of righteousness.
- John 10:41
And many resorted unto him, and said, John did no miracle: but all things that John spake of this man were true.
John performed no miracle, though his message was from heaven.
- Acts 19:3-5
And he said unto them, Unto what then were ye baptized? And they said, Unto John’s baptism.
John’s baptism is distinguished from baptism in the name of the Lord Jesus.
- Luke 3:12-13
Then came also publicans to be baptized, and said unto him, Master, what shall we do?
John’s baptism and ministry connect to the discussion of him.
- Luke 7:30
But the Pharisees and lawyers rejected the counsel of God against themselves, being not baptized of him.
Rejecting John’s baptism is described as rejecting God’s counsel.
- Luke 1:15
For he shall be great in the sight of the Lord, and shall drink neither wine nor strong drink; and he shall be filled with the Holy Ghost, even from his mother’s womb.
shows John was filled with the Spirit
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
11 sources
During the final visit to the temple unbelieving leaders challenged Jesus over the authority by which He acted, and He made His own answer depend on their answer about John in order to defeat their hope of twisting His words against Him.ST Feb 10, 1898DA 589.1–590.2 The question about whether John's baptism was from heaven or from men placed the priests in a dilemma no sophistry could escape.ST Feb 10, 1898
To admit it was from heaven would condemn them for not believing John, for John saw divine glory resting on Jesus at His baptism like a dove of burnished gold and heard the divine voice declare Him the beloved Son in whom He was well pleased.ST Feb 10, 1898Ms 88, 1899, par. 8–14 John testified that Jesus is the Messiah, the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world, so believing John required accepting Jesus as Messiah.ST Feb 10, 1898Ms 88, 1899, par. 8–14DA 593.1–594.2ST Apr 11, 1878 The leaders knew this, and their private reasoning put their unbelief and evasion on display.DA 589DA 593.1–594.2
To say it was merely human would turn the people against them instead of against Christ, because the people held John to be a prophet.ST Feb 10, 1898Ms 88, 1899, par. 8–14Ms 127, 1899, par. 5–9DA 593.1–594.23SP 28.1–30.1 They feared the anger of the crowd and the loss of the people's respect if they denied John's divine mission.Ms 127, 1899, par. 5–9DA 593.1–594.2RH Feb 13, 1900ST Apr 11, 1878 Their true belief was that it was of men, but stating it would bring the wrath of the people upon themselves.ST Feb 10, 1898
They reasoned privately and then hypocritically professed ignorance with the answer that they could not tell, which concealed unwillingness to face the truth about John and Christ.ST Feb 10, 1898Ms 127, 1899, par. 5–93SP 28.1–30.1 Their refusal revealed fear, unwillingness to commit themselves, evasion, and avoidance of honest judgment because of the consequences.DA 589DA 593.1–594.2COL 273.4–274.2RH Feb 13, 1900ST Apr 11, 1878 Although they had led the people to think they believed John, they rejected his witness and wanted grounds to condemn Jesus rather than truth.3SP 28.1–30.1COL 273.4–274.2RH Feb 13, 1900
Jesus therefore refused to tell by what authority He did these things, leaving the Pharisees silenced, baffled and disappointed with lowering brows, not daring to press further questions.ST Feb 10, 1898RH Feb 13, 1900 The multitude watched with intense interest and was amused to see proud, self-righteous men defeated.ST Feb 10, 1898
John's baptism and message truly came from God, for his pure, self-denying life made divine power evident, brought conviction, exposed defects in religious life and condemned wrongdoing.Ms 127, 1899, par. 5–9RH Feb 13, 190019MR 321.3 Refusing John's warning shows refusal of Christ's words as well, for those who would not heed John would not heed Christ.Ms 127, 1899, par. 5–9RH Feb 13, 1900 Yet the chief priests, scribes, elders and Pharisees feigned ignorance rather than yield to conviction and admit they were wrong, while many tax collectors, sinners and immoral women received John's testimony, repented and embraced salvation.Ms 88, 1899, par. 8–143SP 28.1–30.119MR 321.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
36 sources
In His last day of teaching in the temple the chief priests and elders demanded by what authority He acted, and He made His answer depend on their answer about the origin of John's baptism, turning their trap back upon them.ST Feb 10, 1898RH Jan 29, 1914STRH Sep 17, 1861ST Dec 26, 1892 They reasoned privately that to say it was from heaven would condemn them for not believing John, while to say it was of men would bring the anger of the people who held John as a prophet.ST Oct 11, 1899ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 23, 1886 Their deliberation was ruled by self-interest and fear of consequences rather than honest judgment, for they would not take a stand where truth brought duty or blame.RH Jun 20, 1865ST Oct 11, 1899ST Jun 15, 1882 John's baptism and message were from heaven and not from men, and to believe him was to accept Jesus as the Messiah to whom he bore witness.ST Feb 10, 1898RH Dec 9, 1852ST May 24, 1905ST Jun 15, 1882RH Aug 18, 1868 The same from-heaven-or-of-men question still tests God's special work for the present time, and those who reject present light while professing faith in past servants deceive themselves and cannot believe until they repent.RH Jun 16, 1859RH Dec 9, 1852ST Nov 11, 1880ST Jul 11, 1878ST Feb 22, 1877
The Temple Confrontation
The question belongs to Jesus' last day of teaching in the temple, when the chief priests and elders challenged Him by what authority He acted.RH Jan 29, 1914ST That confrontation followed His triumphal entry into Jerusalem and His weeping over the city, the same scene recorded most fully in Luke 19 and also in Mark 11 and John 12.ST
He met their hope to twist His words about His authority by making His own reply depend on their answer about whether John's baptism was from heaven or from men.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Dec 26, 1892ST Aug 26, 1880 By asking this He turned the challenge back on His critics and confounded them, placing them in a dilemma no sophistry could escape.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Dec 26, 1892ST Aug 26, 1880 This was answering a fool according to his folly lest he be wise in his own conceit, exposing folly without copying evil temper, meeting cavillers and skeptics through a thoughtful indirect reply rather than a blunt attack.RH Sep 17, 1861ST Dec 26, 1892
They reasoned privately among themselves and perceived His object.ST Oct 11, 1899ST Dec 16, 1886ST Aug 26, 1880 To say from heaven would expose their inconsistency and failure, for He would ask why they had not then believed John.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Oct 11, 1899ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 23, 1886ST Jan 27, 1909 To state their true belief that it was of men would turn the wrath of the people against them instead of against Christ, for all held John as a prophet and they risked angering the crowd and losing respect.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Apr 11, 1878ST Oct 11, 1899ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 23, 1886 They recognized that John's baptism came either from heaven or from human authority, but feared the consequences of admitting it came from heaven because they had not believed him.ST Apr 11, 1878ST Oct 11, 1899RH Sep 9, 1858
Their weighing of answers by consequences rather than by honest judgment showed their answer was governed by self-interest and fear rather than willingness to acknowledge truth.ST Apr 11, 1878RH Jun 20, 1865ST Oct 11, 1899ST Dec 16, 1886 They were unwilling to answer according to truth and to take a positive position when truth brought duty or blame, refusing plain affirmation and evading by claiming ignorance.RH Jun 20, 1865ST Oct 11, 1899RH Apr 21, 1868RH Mar 14, 1854 They wanted grounds to condemn Jesus, not truth, and their refusal exposed unwillingness to receive and obey.RH Feb 13, 1900RH Jun 20, 1865ST Jun 15, 1882 They knew what they believed about John but would not say it publicly because they feared the crowd's response and losing influence and exposing their rejection of his message.ST Jun 15, 1882ST Oct 11, 1899 Their conflict over John's authority revealed unwillingness to acknowledge what that authority would require of them.ST Oct 11, 1899ST Jun 15, 1882
With the multitude watching with intense interest, they hypocritically professed they could not tell.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Aug 26, 1880 Caught between surrender as unsafe religious teachers and public contempt from the multitude, they were abashed and dumfounded and silenced.ST Aug 26, 1880 Christ therefore refused to tell by what authority He did these things, withholding His answer about His authority.ST Feb 10, 1898RH Feb 13, 1900 This left them silenced, baffled and disappointed with lowering brows, not daring to press further questions, while the people were amused to see proud, self-righteous men defeated.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Aug 26, 1880
John's Heavenly Mission
John's baptism and message were from heaven and not from human authority.RH Dec 9, 1852ST May 24, 1905RH Aug 18, 1868RH Sep 19, 1871RH Jul 4, 1871 He came from God as the promised forerunner of the Messiah at the appointed time with divine credentials, bore good fruit, and was authorized by the same God who gave Jesus authority for His work.RH Dec 9, 1852ST May 24, 1905 That heavenly origin is certain.RH Aug 18, 1868
To believe John was to accept Jesus as the Messiah, for John testified that He is the Lamb of God who takes away the sin of the world.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Apr 11, 1878ST Jun 15, 1882 After Christ's baptism John saw the glory of God like a dove of burnished gold resting upon Him and heard the voice of the Infinite One proclaim Him His beloved Son in whom He is well pleased.ST Feb 10, 1898 The leaders therefore understood that to say John's baptism was from heaven would require them to explain why they had not believed John's testimony identifying Jesus as the Messiah.ST Feb 10, 1898ST Apr 11, 1878ST Jun 15, 1882
There was a gate they had to go through first: they had to believe John's preaching and receive that message as from God, and without that it was vain to show them Jesus and His authority.RH Jun 16, 1859 John's work was the warning and preparation needed before people could receive Christ, and rejecting his warning left people unable to believe in Christ.RH Sep 19, 1871 Refusing his message, though his life and warning had brought conviction, showed they would also refuse Christ's words.RH Feb 13, 1900 The kingdom would be taken from those who rejected God's requirements and given to a nation that would keep them.RH Mar 29, 1864
Fulfilled prophecy and clear evidence do not compel belief.RH Dec 9, 1852 John's ministry was doubted after expectations were disappointed, even by John himself.RH Dec 9, 1852
The Test Applied Today
There was a gate to go through first, for without believing John's preaching and receiving it as from God it was vain to try to show that Jesus and His authority were from God, and the same rule holds now, that if a man cannot be made to see that God sent servants to proclaim the hour of His judgment in the first angel's message and also the second, it is vain to try to show him the third angel's message and the Sabbath through that message.RH Jun 16, 1859 The question whether the Advent movement is from heaven must be judged, for to refuse faith and obedience in the face of that light leaves people unable to believe until they repent, and makes their guilt greater than that of the Jewish priests.RH Dec 9, 1852 The same from-heaven-or-of-men question tests the Advent proclamation, for if it fulfills the promised messages of Revelation 14 it is from heaven, and if not it is merely human and will come to nothing.ST Jul 11, 1878
That same test decides the great advent message of 1840-44, where time was the test and moving principle, and everyone who truly and heartily accepted the Bible time message settled at once that it was from heaven, with God setting His seal of approval to the time and those who publicly confessed it receiving a blessing far exceeding happy conversion, as thousands experienced.ST Jan 21, 1903 The same question is applied to the midnight cry, for if it came from heaven repeating it as a new invitation is unjustified, and if it came from people it cannot be part of prophetic fulfillment, so those who question the earlier message and claim a messenger ran before being sent must consider how they know a repeated message was truly sent.RH Jun 20, 1854 Asking whether a work is from heaven or from men creates a difficult test for the movement surrounding the expected advent, for if it is from heaven rejecting it calls for an explanation, and if it is from men the evident presence and power of God calls for an explanation, so its mistake does not by itself prove the movement was not from heaven. As John's work was the warning and preparation needed before people could receive Christ, so God's work of preparation before the second advent is likewise preceded by a warning message.RH Sep 19, 1871
The certainty of John's heavenly origin belongs also to the third message, which is likewise from heaven and not from human beings.RH Aug 18, 1868 That same either-from-God-or-from-men question is put to the work under discussion, and the reader must decide whether to reject it as delusion or embrace it as God's truth.RH Jul 8, 1875 The same test declares health reform and the Health Institute to be from heaven, supported by prophecy and the signs of the times, and therefore safe to embrace fully.RH Oct 31, 1871 The leaders' uncertainty in saying they could not tell shows blindness to God's all-important special work in their own time, for they had strong faith in Moses and the prophets of the past and honored past servants but rejected the message and work present before them, and a man deceives himself when he believes all God's past works but rejects God's present work.ST Nov 11, 1880ST Feb 22, 1877
If he rejects the special work for his own time, God will reject him, for saving faith is live faith in present truth that obeys it, gives life for it, and aids it with means and influence.ST Nov 11, 1880 The verse illustrates evasive reasoning when people fear either answer, as the Pharisees reasoned among themselves because acknowledging John's baptism came from heaven would expose their failure to believe him, and the same predicament is seen in those asked whether the apostles rested from work and observed the first day as a Sabbath, who evade saying yes without evidence or no for fear of weakening the day's sacredness, saying only that they assembled for worship when the question is specifically whether they sabbatized.ST Oct 25, 1883RH Mar 14, 1854RH Jan 13, 1852 It exposes the same evasion in those who urge the indirect objection that if the Sabbath were binding Christ would have taught it, yet will not openly affirm that the Sabbath and its commandment were peculiar to the Jewish age and ceased with it, showing unwillingness to take a positive position when truth brings duty or blame.RH Apr 21, 1868
Sources