1 Corinthians 5:12
For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do not ye judge them that are within?
Translations
For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do not you judge them that are within?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do not ye judge them that are within?
For what have I to do to judge them also that are without? do ye not judge them that are within?
For what have I to do with judging them that are without? Do not ye judge them that are within,
For what have I to do with judging them that are without? Do not ye judge them that are within?
for what have I also those without to judge? those within do ye not judge?
For what have I [ to do] with judging those outside also? ye, do not ye judge them that are within?
For what have I to do to be judging them who are without? Do, ye, not judge, them who are within,
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
What business of mine is it to judge those outside the church? Are you not to judge those inside?
For what do I have to do with also judging those who are outside? Don’ t you judge those who are within?
For it is no business of mine to be judging those who are outside; but it is yours to be judging those who are among you;
For what haue I to doe, to iudge them also which are without? doe ye not iudge them that are within?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For what have I to do to judge them that are without? Do not you judge them that are within?
Cross-references
- Matthew 18:15-17
Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
Gives the church’s steps for addressing persistent wrongdoing among believers.
- 2 Thessalonians 3:6
Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us.
Both address withdrawing from disorderly members within the church.
- 1 Corinthians 5:5
To deliver such an one unto Satan for the destruction of the flesh, that the spirit may be saved in the day of the Lord Jesus.
The offender is put outside the church in hope of recovery and repentance.
- 2 Thessalonians 3:14-15
And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed.
Separate from disobedient members, yet admonish them as brothers.
- 1 Timothy 1:20
Of whom is Hymenaeus and Alexander; whom I have delivered unto Satan, that they may learn not to blaspheme.
Paul delivers offenders to Satan, leaving them to their chosen course.
- Romans 14:13
Let us not therefore judge one another any more: but judge this rather, that no man put a stumblingblock or an occasion to fall in his brother’s way.
Both teach discernment in judging within the church and avoiding stumbling a fellow believer.
- John 12:47-48
And if any man hear my words, and believe not, I judge him not: for I came not to judge the world, but to save the world.
Christ came to save, while his word judges those who reject him at the last day.
- 1 Corinthians 5:6
Your glorying is not good. Know ye not that a little leaven leaveneth the whole lump?
Tolerated sin spreads through the whole church, supporting its removal.
- 1 Corinthians 6:1-6
Dare any of you, having a matter against another, go to law before the unjust, and not before the saints?
Disputes among believers should be judged within the church.
- Acts 5:1-11
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Ananias and Sapphira’s deception was judged within the church.
- Titus 3:10
A man that is an heretick after the first and second admonition reject;
The church is to reject a divisive person after admonition.
- 2 Corinthians 2:5-11
But if any have caused grief, he hath not grieved me, but in part: that I may not overcharge you all.
The disciplined person is to be forgiven and comforted after repentance.
- Romans 2:1-3
Therefore thou art inexcusable, O man, whosoever thou art that judgest: for wherein thou judgest another, thou condemnest thyself; for thou that judgest doest the same things.
Both address judging others while committing the same sins.
- 1 Corinthians 5:1
It is reported commonly that there is fornication among you, and such fornication as is not so much as named among the Gentiles, that one should have his father’s wife.
The incestuous conduct in the Corinthian church is an example of its vile members.
- Romans 16:17
Now I beseech you, brethren, mark them which cause divisions and offences contrary to the doctrine which ye have learned; and avoid them.
Says to mark and avoid those causing divisions contrary to doctrine.
- Galatians 6:1
Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.
Directs spiritual members to restore one overtaken in sin.
- 1 Corinthians 5:2
And ye are puffed up, and have not rather mourned, that he that hath done this deed might be taken away from among you.
It is cited alongside Paul’s teaching about removing a harmful church member.
- Matthew 18:18
Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.
Both concern the church’s exercise of spiritual authority under Christ.
- John 20:23
Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
The church’s authority includes dealing with sins.
- Ephesians 5:11
And have no fellowship with the unfruitful works of darkness, but rather reprove them.
Commands believers to avoid fellowship with works of darkness and reprove them.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
The verse places upon the church the responsibility to judge and correct those who are within its fellowship.1T 117.2SLP 179.3–180.14SP 44.1–45.1 It does not place upon the church that responsibility toward those who are without.1T 117.24SP 44.1–45.1 That inward responsibility requires confronting immoral conduct that disgraces the church and making decided efforts to show unchristian members their wrongs, rather than leaving the evil uncorrected.1T 117.2SLP 179.3–180.1 If those so dealt with do not reform, they are to be separated from the faithful, so that the church may remain clean and pure.1T 117.2
Those who willfully cherish sin while professing godliness are not to be received as members, yet persons having faults may be included so that they can learn and correct their errors.4SP 44.1–45.1 Judas was accepted despite his defects in order to give him opportunity to learn, but he afterward chose not to walk in the light.4SP 44.1–45.1 Even the church in its best condition was not composed entirely of the pure and sincere.4SP 44.1–45.1 One who has placed himself beyond the fellowship by rejecting light and truth and violating God's law cannot be fellowshiped, and even if he repents his case must be left alone while the rebuke of the church remains, so that the standard of morality is not lowered.Lt 17, 1861, par. 8
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
45 sources
The verse draws the line between those inside the church and those outside it, requiring believers to judge those within their own fellowship while leaving those outside to the judgment of God.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 27, 1911CO 25.2 It was written concerning a vile and incestuous sin openly carried on and cherished without sorrow within the Corinthian church.ST May 19, 1881ST Aug 18, 1909ST Mar 24, 1881 The judging commanded is the united action of the church to decide whether a person's openly sinful practices are compatible with belonging to it, and to put away one who persists without repentance after efforts to correct and heal.RH Apr 27, 1911CO 25.2RH Jul 10, 1856ST Feb 6, 1896 That discipline must be done with meekness, mourning and prayer for the transgressor as a brother, seeking his repentance and recovery, and if he repents he is to be forgiven, comforted and welcomed back with love.CO 25.2RH Jul 6, 1868ST May 3, 1910ST Apr 21, 1898ST Sep 21, 1904 Toward those outside, whom believers are not to judge, the work is not condemnation or coercion but seeking their salvation through the gospel of peace and spreading the light of truth.ST Feb 12, 1894ST Jan 30, 1907ST Mar 5, 1894RH Jun 6, 1871
Words and Setting
The verse draws a sharp line between those inside the church and those outside it, assigning believers responsibility to judge those within their own fellowship while leaving those outside to the judgment of God and not to their own judging.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 27, 1911RH Jul 10, 1856RH Oct 13, 1874ST Feb 6, 1896 That inward judgment concerns whether a person's openly sinful, manifest practices in actual deeds are compatible with belonging to the church, and when a professing believer persists in known violation of God's law and in serious wrongdoing he may be disciplined, excluded from fellowship, put away and removed from among the members rather than treated as worthy of fellowship.RH Jan 9, 1855RH Apr 27, 1911CO 25.2RH Jul 10, 1856RH Oct 13, 1874 It is the church's united action, guided by the Spirit and taken in Christ's name through its divinely ordained process, not an individual's personal judgment of another, and even the excluded one is still to be treated with meekness and admonished as a brother rather than counted as an enemy.RH Jan 9, 1855ST Feb 6, 1896 If he later repents he is to be forgiven, comforted, and welcomed back with love.CO 25.2
The occasion was a terrible sin discovered within the Corinthian church, a vile and incestuous case with horrible and detestable sins cherished among its own members without sorrow of heart.ST May 19, 1881ST Aug 18, 1909ST Mar 24, 1881 The shameful practices were carried on openly and without shame and called for the church's attention under sharp apostolic rebuke.ST Jul 8, 1889RH Sep 2, 1873ST Aug 24, 1888 Those involved professed Christ yet lacked thorough consecration to God, being only partially converted.ST Mar 24, 1881
The corruption was not confined to a few but involved a large part of the church, leaving it widely divided between a part worthy of high commendation and a part fallen into great depravity and carrying on the greatest abuses under the Christian name.ST Jul 8, 1889ST Aug 24, 1888 Paul reproved the church for tolerating such gross sins instead of mourning and praying for the transgressor, whose soul was in danger and whose conduct injured the cause.RH Jul 6, 1868ST May 30, 1911 After the reproof the church was stirred and the sinners repented.ST May 30, 1911
Nothing concerning duty or what is permissible can be drawn from the practice of the Corinthian church, but all must be learned from Scripture and the sacred word, while the principles of the chapter apply to similar cases in every age.RH May 7, 1872ST Jul 8, 1889ST Aug 24, 1888 Paul's own example shows the meaning, for before Felix, a Gentile who was also his judge, he did not make himself the judge of those outside but respectfully explained faith in Christ and spoke of continence, righteousness, and the coming judgment.ST Feb 19, 1885
Duty to Judge Within
The judging commanded is the united action of the church, guided by the Spirit and taken in Christ's name and spirit, including receiving members and disfellowshipping them according to God's Word, and it is not one person's private judgment of another.ST Feb 6, 1896CO 21.1–2ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jun 13, 1900 Only discipline carried out as Christ directs is confirmed in heaven, and the church has no authority to act contrary to that Word.CO 21.1–2 The warning against judging does not forbid this inward discipline when it is so guided and so carried out.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jun 13, 1900 It may act only when sinful conduct is manifest in actual deeds.ST Feb 6, 1896
This judgment decides whether a person's openly sinful practices are compatible with belonging to the church, and when a member persists in such sin without repentance the church is to put that person away and remove him from among its members and from its communion.RH Apr 27, 1911CO 25.2RH Jul 10, 1856RH Oct 13, 1874ST May 3, 1910 It includes refusing fellowship with a professing believer who persists in serious wrongdoing rather than treating him as worthy of fellowship or acting as though his wrongdoing is excused.RH Jul 10, 1856RH Oct 13, 1874ST May 3, 1910 The church should withdraw fellowship from one who refuses correction after efforts to correct and heal, leaving him for a time to the course he has chosen, which may awaken his sense of need and lead him to repentance.CO 25.2ST Sep 21, 1904ST Aug 6, 1896 This is church discipline and not personal hostility, not a declaration that the person is beyond salvation, for he remains someone to help and labor for, and if he later repents he is to be forgiven, comforted, and welcomed back with love.CO 25.2ST May 3, 1910
The church must first examine itself, then address scandalous conduct that dishonors God or causes division, weakness, and harm to others.ST Sep 24, 1896ST Aug 6, 1896RH Apr 7, 1868 Weaknesses or occasional falls met with humility are not grounds for the same response as scandalous offending and refusal to be corrected.RH Apr 7, 1868 Such discipline must seek God's glory and the salvation of souls, not express personal spite or antipathy.ST Sep 24, 1896 Those who claim membership must live according to God's word, and if they persist in covetousness they must be removed from fellowship.RH Dec 2, 1858 Covetousness is a conspicuous sin among members that is often not seriously rebuked or made a matter of discipline, although fornication, idolatry, lying, and theft bring discipline, and a covetous person cannot abound in giving.ST Feb 4, 1886
The same responsibility reaches members who persist after faithful labor in breaking the Sabbath, attending dances, or engaging in other questionable acts.RH Feb 6, 1900 Retaining them does no good for the church, the individuals, or the world, and drags God's standard down.RH Feb 6, 1900 Those within the same body must judge one another, because a man is held responsible for the actions of any society, company, firm, or association to which he belongs unless he protests its wrong actions and withdraws.RH Apr 13, 1876 He cannot lend his money and influence to festivals, dances, and gambling and then excuse himself by staying away, for he shares guilt for what his group does because wrongdoing spreads through the whole group.RH Apr 13, 1876 When one walks disorderly, the others should withdraw fellowship rather than leave the body responsible for him.ST May 13, 1880
How Discipline Is Done
Judging those within is the united action of the church, guided by the Spirit and taken in Christ's name, not an individual's personal judgment of another, and it may act only when sinful conduct is manifest in actual deeds.ST Feb 6, 1896 That judging is to be done in order through the divinely ordained process of holding trials of erring members and expelling them from fellowship when required.ST Feb 6, 1896RH May 22, 1866 Faithful labor with the erring member must come first, with due notice of the trial, and expulsion only by a two-thirds vote of the entire membership.RH May 22, 1866 Counsel is to be secured through the State Conference Committee, from an experienced preacher or, if that cannot be had, from experienced and judicious lay brethren.RH May 22, 1866 In case of outrageous crime where guilt is manifest, previous labor may at the discretion of the church be dispensed with.RH May 22, 1866
Officers and members have distinct relations in this watchcare, with the elder placed at the head to move out humbly but firmly for the right and the members to rally around and support him in what is right.RH Mar 10, 1868 This inward judging corrects past mistakes and removes disorder and confusion.RH Mar 10, 1868 It raises the moral standard high, which helps members grow in divine life and draws outsiders who would be an honor to the cause to unite with the church.RH Mar 10, 1868
Discipline addresses gross sin among professed believers and lives that dishonor God or cause division and weakness, and the church must not act as though such wrongdoing is excused but must remove the unrepentant from the church.ST May 3, 1910ST Sep 24, 1896 When scandal occurs the church should mourn and pray for the transgressor, whose soul is in danger and whose conduct injures the cause.RH Jul 6, 1868 The offender is to be treated with meekness and admonished as a brother, not counted as an enemy, and remains someone to help and labor for.RH Jan 9, 1855ST May 3, 1910 Such judgment is church discipline, not personal hostility or spite or antipathy, and not a declaration that the person is beyond salvation.ST May 3, 1910ST Sep 24, 1896 It seeks God's glory and the salvation of souls, must not use physical force or persecution, and does not give leaders lordship over believers' faith.ST Sep 24, 1896
When a member continues to live as a subject of Satan rather than submitting to Christ, the church withdraws its sanction and delivers the person over to Satan, making clear that it does not approve the conduct.ST Apr 21, 1898 The act declares the Lord's sentence upon one who has put away faith and good conscience and by that course has taken himself off the ground where he can claim God's blessing.ST Dec 24, 1896 The chastisement is meant to teach him not to blaspheme and to lead to repentance, reformation, and recovery from Satan's snare.ST Apr 21, 1898ST Dec 24, 1896
The biblical warning against judging does not prohibit this proper discipline of those within, as distinct from judging those outside.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jun 13, 1900 Believers remain responsible for addressing wrongdoing within the church when discipline is guided by the Spirit and carried out in Christ's name and spirit.ST Jun 13, 1900ST Jun 13, 1900
Purposes and Outcomes
Faithful judging of those within keeps the body pure and shows that open violation of God's commandments is not tolerated or approved.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Aug 4, 1874 It stands the church clear before the world.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Apr 27, 1911 By precept and example it sets forth principles that give a certain token of where God's true church is found.RH Aug 4, 1874 This responsibility is limited to recognizing that a member's openly sinful practices belong outside the church and acting accordingly, putting out the one who persists in such sin after labor for reformation, and it does not extend to judging those outside.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Aug 4, 1874RH Apr 27, 1911 The church is not to tolerate members who love and foster sin even under a religious cloak, but must bring its members to account, labor to reform those unworthy and unwilling to conform to wholesome principles, and remove them when they will not reform.RH Aug 4, 1874
Tolerating iniquity leaves unworthy members in the body to cast an influence detrimental to truth and allows evil to spread.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874 It loads the hearts of the faithful who are striving for purity and holiness, harms the faithful, and fails both the church's purpose and the sinners themselves.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874 It disgusts honest souls watching to see whether the church does good, hinders God's Spirit, and turns progress rapidly downward until the worldly level is reached.RH Aug 4, 1874 Retaining those who persist in wrongdoing after faithful labor does no good for the church, the individuals, or the world, drags God's standard down, and leaves souls to go to ruin.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Sep 29, 1874RH Feb 6, 1900
Discipline withdraws the church's sanction from one who continues in conduct contrary to Christ and makes clear that the offender stands outside its fellowship.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898 It leaves him for a time to the course he has chosen.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Sep 21, 1904 This is meant to bring him to recognize his position and to awaken his sense of need.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Sep 21, 1904 So awakened, he may be led to repentance and reformation, to recovery from Satan's snare, and to return to the Lord.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Apr 21, 1898ST Sep 21, 1904
If the one put away later repents, he is to be forgiven, comforted, and welcomed back with love.CO 25.2 Even while removed he remains someone to help and labor for, and this judgment is not personal hostility nor a declaration that he is beyond salvation.ST May 3, 1910 The church must love sinners and help them turn from sin, yet it cannot carry out that saving work through people who persist in evil.ST May 3, 1910
Church and the World
The distinction in the verse is between responsibility toward those inside the fellowship and lack of responsibility toward those outside it, so officers of the church are not to condemn or discipline people who are outside the church.ST Jul 3, 1907STST Mar 5, 1894 Judgment of those within is a separate matter from that prohibition, and the church has no authority to condemn outsiders or to use earthly power to advance Christ's kingdom.STST Mar 5, 1894 Christians are not to sit in judgment on the world, but like Christ are to seek the world's salvation through the gospel of peace rather than through coercion.ST Feb 12, 1894ST Jan 30, 1907 People outside the church are judged by God, while Christ's cause advances through preaching and persuasion, not by coercive force, earthly power, outward restraint, or man-made rules.ST Jan 30, 1907ST Mar 5, 1894ST Feb 12, 1894 True religion works from within outward, not by outward restraint, so the church has no business disciplining the world and a nation is not made Christian by law.ST Feb 12, 1894
For that reason the verse opposes using law to enforce Sunday observance and to make the nation Christian by national reform.ST Feb 12, 1894 To those outside, whom believers are to judge not, the church's work is to spread the light of truth.RH Jun 6, 1871
Sources