Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
Then came the word of the LORD to Samuel, saying,
King James Version, Revised Version
Then came the word of the LORD unto Samuel, saying,
Then came the word of the Lord unto Samuel, saying,
Then came the word of Jehovah unto Samuel, saying,
And the word of Jehovah is unto Samuel, saying,
And the word of Jehovah came to Samuel, saying,
Then came the word of Yahweh unto Samuel, saying—
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then the word of the LORD came to Samuel, saying,
Then the LORD’s word came to Samuel, saying,
Then the Lord said to Samuel,
Then came the worde of the Lord vnto Samuel, saying,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the word of the Lord came to Samuel, saying:
Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 15:3
Now go and smite Amalek, and utterly destroy all that they have, and spare them not; but slay both man and woman, infant and suckling, ox and sheep, camel and ass.
God commands Saul to destroy Amalek completely, a command he later disobeys.
- 1 Samuel 15:22-23
And Samuel said, Hath the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams.
Samuel rebukes Saul’s disobedience, declaring obedience better than sacrifice.
- Deuteronomy 25:17-19
Remember what Amalek did unto thee by the way, when ye were come forth out of Egypt;
God commanded judgment on Amalek for its attack on Israel.
- 1 Samuel 15:28
And Samuel said unto him, The LORD hath rent the kingdom of Israel from thee this day, and hath given it to a neighbour of thine, that is better than thou.
Samuel announces that Saul’s kingdom is taken from him and given to another.
- 1 Samuel 15:26
And Samuel said unto Saul, I will not return with thee: for thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, and the LORD hath rejected thee from being king over Israel.
Saul is rejected as king for rejecting the LORD’s word.
- Exodus 17:14-16
And the LORD said unto Moses, Write this for a memorial in a book, and rehearse it in the ears of Joshua: for I will utterly put out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven.
The LORD vows to destroy Amalek and wage war against them through generations.
- Deuteronomy 25:19
Therefore it shall be, when the LORD thy God hath given thee rest from all thine enemies round about, in the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee for an inheritance to possess it, that thou shalt blot out the remembrance of Amalek from under heaven; thou shalt not forget it.
Commands blotting out Amalek.
- 1 Samuel 15:19
Wherefore then didst thou not obey the voice of the LORD, but didst fly upon the spoil, and didst evil in the sight of the LORD?
Samuel asks Saul why he disobeyed the Lord.
- 1 Chronicles 4:43
And they smote the rest of the Amalekites that were escaped, and dwelt there unto this day.
The Simeonites destroy the surviving Amalekites.
- 1 Samuel 15:20-21
And Saul said unto Samuel, Yea, I have obeyed the voice of the LORD, and have gone the way which the LORD sent me, and have brought Agag the king of Amalek, and have utterly destroyed the Amalekites.
Saul denies wrongdoing and blames the people.
- 1 Samuel 15:15
And Saul said, They have brought them from the Amalekites: for the people spared the best of the sheep and of the oxen, to sacrifice unto the LORD thy God; and the rest we have utterly destroyed.
Saul excuses sparing the animals as an offering to God.
- 1 Samuel 15:24
And Saul said unto Samuel, I have sinned: for I have transgressed the commandment of the LORD, and thy words: because I feared the people, and obeyed their voice.
Saul confesses his disobedience to the LORD’s command.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
5 sources
The word of the Lord came to Samuel with a message about Saul, opening the account of Saul's disobedience.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11Lt 46, 1891, par. 12–15PP 627.3Lt 10, 1873, par. 23–26 Samuel was to carry it to Saul as instruction from God Himself, from the same divine authority that had placed Saul on the throne.PP 627.3 It concerned judgment long delayed against Amalek for its assault on Israel and for its continued rebellion, commanding Saul to punish Amalek and to utterly destroy everything belonging to them.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11PP 627.3Lt 10, 1873, par. 23–26
Saul disobeyed by sparing the best of the cattle and sheep, then excused himself by saying they were kept to offer as a sacrifice, while insisting that he had obeyed.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11 The message declared that he had turned back from following God and had not kept His commandments, so that God's wrath was kindled against him.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11Lt 46, 1891, par. 12–15Lt 10, 1873, par. 23–26 Through this act he lost his soul.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11 Yet in this commission Saul still had opportunity to prove his fidelity by obedience.PP 627.3
The word distressed Samuel, who grieved over it and cried to the Lord all night, though he knew he must deliver it.Lt 46, 1891, par. 12–15 When confronted, Saul denied his wrongdoing until the facts left him no room for denial, yet he did not confess his sin but regarded himself as mistreated.Lt 28a, 1893, par. 1–3 His profession of obedience did not take away his guilt, for obedience is more acceptable to God than sacrificial offerings.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11
God's word thus exposes disobedience so that it must be faced rather than justified or evaded, warning against self-deception and evasion of responsibility.Lt 46, 1891, par. 12–15Lt 28a, 1893, par. 1–3 Neither religious purpose nor financial gain can justify breaking God's law, and when men reject the light they have received, God may at last punish them and destroy what they have gained.Ms 7, 1886, par. 10–11
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
43 sources
The word of the Lord came to Samuel by night to declare that Saul had turned back from following God and had not performed His commandment, and was therefore rejected from being king that another might take his place.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Dec 12, 1895ST Oct 31, 1895ST Sep 20, 1883 The command Saul had broken was to utterly destroy Amalek for its treacherous ambush of faint and weary Israel after Egypt, yet from pride and covetousness he spared Agag alive and kept the best of the flocks and herds while destroying only what was vile.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Oct 17, 1895RH Mar 10, 1874ST Jul 9, 1912 His course proves that the Lord demands obedience as the purest and highest worship, for to obey is better than sacrifice and to hearken than the fat of rams, and no offering preserved by disobedience can be acceptable.ST Dec 12, 1895ST Jul 9, 1912ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903 Partial obedience is disobedience, for obedience must be complete, exact and literal without adding, diminishing or choosing which commands to keep according to human judgment or convenience.ST Oct 17, 1895RH Oct 25, 1864ST Jun 25, 1885ST May 9, 1878ST Aug 12, 1889 His rejection warns that rebellion is as witchcraft and stubbornness as idolatry, that a man may grieve away the Spirit and pass beyond hope while still vigorous, and that clinging to what God commands to give up costs throne, blessing and soul.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Feb 19, 1885ST Apr 11, 1911ST Apr 15, 1913ST May 9, 1878
Setting in Saul's Reign
Then came the word of the LORD unto Samuel to announce that Saul was rejected from being king because he had turned back from following God and had not performed His commandments, and that another would be raised up to take his place.ST Dec 12, 1895ST Oct 31, 1895ST Sep 20, 1883ST Dec 11, 1884 It came after Saul had already failed a first great test yet had been given further trial and opportunity to retrieve his character, and his deliberate rejection of the word sent to him was followed by the Lord's rejection of him.ST Oct 31, 1895ST Dec 11, 1884 The transgression of the commission to destroy the Amalekites is what drew the message to Samuel and opened the record of disobedience that cost the kingdom.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Dec 11, 1884
It marks the final and culminating stage of a gradually developing character, coming after quite an interval following the presumptuous offering of sacrifices for which Saul was told his rule would not continue, and proving him no longer worthy of his position.ST Aug 12, 1889ST Jun 13, 1906 It was his second great test of whether he would honor and obey the Lord, and it was his final test, in which his apostasy was settled and his probation was closed.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Jun 13, 1906 Though the Lord had purposed to set aside Saul's family, He still granted Saul success against Moab, Ammon, Edom, Amalek and Philistia, yet because Saul had missed his opportunity he could never permanently subdue the Philistines.ST Aug 31, 1882 Commanded to devote Amalek to utter destruction, Saul led 200,000 footmen and 10,000 men of Judah numbered at Telaim to the most brilliant victory of his life, and on his march homeward he set up at Carmel in Judah a monument to his own victory.ST Aug 31, 1882 The Lord gave the message to Samuel that night, before Samuel went to meet Saul the next morning.ST Aug 31, 1882RH Mar 17, 1904 After this a person may pass beyond hope and divine forbearance while still vigorous, after which the Lord withdraws His Spirit.ST Jun 13, 1906
The command behind the message doomed Amalek as a nation heaven had doomed to annihilation and utter destruction, in punishment for their treacherous ambush of Israel at Rephidim between the wilderness of Sin and Sinai, when they smote the faint and weary hindmost shortly after Israel left Egypt and before Sinai.ST Jul 13, 1904ST Apr 23, 1902 The command was just because they were wholly given over to evil and keeping them alive could bring only corruption and evil to others, so that it was better for them to die than for many others to be corrupted by them.ST They had utterly shut God away in spite of His efforts to save them through the sojourn of His faithful servants such as Abraham and Isaac among them, and sometimes death is the greatest blessing that can come to the wicked because he ceases his own sinning and will not corrupt others.ST Because Israel was a theocracy under God's political and spiritual rule, the people in carrying out His command acted as executors of His will and were not guilty of murder, and were instead rebuked and punished for disobeying by sparing some of those they were commanded to destroy.RH Oct 21, 1862 The judgment on Amalek is typical of what will come upon the nations of the world that utterly reject God, and men who see and know so little of God's reasons should not pass judgment on Him.ST
Saul's Act of Disobedience
God had commanded utter destruction of Amalek, sparing neither people nor ox, sheep, camel nor ass, but Saul saved Agag the king alive and the best of the sheep, oxen, fatlings, lambs, beasts of burden and all that was good, destroying only what was vile and refuse.ST Aug 31, 1882RH Dec 9, 1915RH Mar 10, 1874RH Oct 25, 1864ST May 9, 1878 He was instructed to destroy the Amalekites and all they possessed, leaving alive neither man nor beast, yet he spared the king and the finest flocks and herds while claiming he had obeyed the commandment of the Lord.ST Oct 17, 1895RH Oct 25, 1864ST May 9, 1878 His partial obedience in that war was disobedience and did not count as obedience, for it is not safe either to fall short of what God commands or to add one's own course of action.ST Oct 17, 1895RH Oct 25, 1864RH Oct 3, 1907
From pride he spared Agag to heighten the honor of his triumphal return and display of victory at Carmel and Gilgal, intending to offer the cattle in sacrifice and make a triumphant show.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 9, 1878 From covetousness he allowed the people to spare the finest flocks, herds and beasts of burden, following human wisdom by sparing Agag and the flocks.ST Aug 31, 1882ST Feb 4, 1897 His display of victory and apparent kindness did not replace obedience, and his favorable position and outward success did not prevent his downfall.ST Jul 9, 1912 That presumptuous disregard of God's explicit will cost him his throne and his soul, warning that what appears good may ultimately become a curse.ST Feb 4, 1897
He claimed he had obeyed and thought he had obeyed, yet excused sparing the best to sacrifice to God.ST Oct 17, 1895ST May 9, 1878ST Aug 12, 1889 He argued that only the spirit and end of the precept matter, that securing the good it proposed is true obedience, that God is not whimsical and arbitrary, and that breaking the letter while keeping the spirit honors the law equally, twisting the saying the letter killeth but the spirit giveth life.ST May 9, 1878 God viewed the matter very differently, as Saul doing his own will and not the Lord's, trying to obey his own idea of the spirit of the command instead of its plain letter.ST May 9, 1878ST Jul 29, 1889 He at last confessed he had transgressed the commandment of the Lord because he feared the people and obeyed their voice, exposing self-deception and the evasive heart that claims a right to make even one exception.ST May 9, 1878ST Mar 5, 1912 God's command was not to be softened or set aside according to personal judgment or convenience, but to be followed exactly without substituting one's own will.RH Oct 8, 1861RH Oct 3, 1907
The act revealed pride and self-will, for having lost humility to self-exaltation which never yields obedience, he heard the command in arrogance.ST Feb 19, 1885ST Jul 13, 1904 He treated his royal dignity as greater than Samuel and the prophets, and presumed that God should accept terms set by the king.ST Feb 19, 1885 It was a test of his character showing selfishness, obstinacy, rashness and weakness, and his partial obedience showed he could not be trusted to rule Israel.ST Oct 17, 1895 That determination to rule as an independent monarch proved he could not be trusted with royal power as the Lord's vicegerent, and God's commands require full obedience, not partial obedience or excuses.ST Aug 31, 1882
Rejection and Its Aftermath
Because Saul deliberately rejected and quit the work God sent him to do, failing to carry out the clear commission to destroy the Amalekites completely and substituting his own will while claiming he had obeyed, the Lord rejected him from being king, removed him from the throne, and raised up another to take his place.ST Dec 12, 1895ST Jun 25, 1885ST Dec 11, 1884ST Jul 13, 1904RH Oct 3, 1907 His rejection as king followed his own rejection of the word of the Lord, for he did not follow the Lord when it was his privilege to do so.ST Dec 12, 1895ST Jun 25, 1885ST Dec 11, 1884 His downfall is dated from that failure, from which his repentance came too late.ST Jul 13, 1904
His rebellion is as the sin of witchcraft and his stubbornness as iniquity and idolatry, rebellion being equivalent to idolatry.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Jun 25, 1885ST May 9, 1878 The chapter is therefore an awful lesson on the sin of witchcraft, teaching also that obedience is better than sacrifice.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Apr 15, 1913
A person may pass beyond hope and divine forbearance while still vigorous, after which the Lord withdraws His Spirit; Saul's disobedience was his final test, his apostasy was settled, and his probation was closed.ST Jun 13, 1906 He grieved away the Spirit of God, and because of that presumption the Spirit left him.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Feb 19, 1885 From there began his continuing downward course of rashness, weakness, failure and rejection, and he lived on in that unhappy state.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Feb 19, 1885ST Apr 11, 1911 The Lord finally refused to have anything to do with him, so that when the Lord did not answer him he sought help from a woman with a familiar spirit, and he ended his life by his own hand and died apart from God, a lost man.RH Dec 9, 1915ST Sep 15, 1898
Saul's disobedience thwarted God's plan as it affected Saul himself and his welfare, costing him his throne and his soul.ST Feb 4, 1897 His favorable position and outward success did not prevent his downfall, warning that what appears good may ultimately become a curse. Saul captured Agag king of the Amalekites and brought him alive to Gilgal, where Samuel slew him.ST Apr 23, 1902 Though judged, a remnant of Amalek remained, and David later defeated the Amalekites on several occasions before the Simeonites finally destroyed them in Hezekiah's time.RH Sep 15, 1874
Obedience Better Than Sacrifice
The word to Samuel means the Lord demands obedience as the purest and highest worship, for which no substitute devised by man can stand.ST Dec 12, 1895 Thus saith the Lord alone is guide and standard, no matter how pleasing or humanly reasonable any other course may appear.ST Dec 12, 1895 God speaks through prophets to instruct men in His will, and His commands require full obedience, not partial obedience or excuses.
To obey is better than sacrifice and to hearken than the fat of rams.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Apr 15, 1913RH Sep 16, 1915 The offerings God required were meant to show loyalty by willingly giving up a portion of one's own possessions, so offering animals preserved from the Amalekites in disobedience to the command to destroy them would not have been acceptable even if nothing had been said about their disposal.ST Aug 12, 1889 Because destruction had been commanded, the act was doubly wrong, showing covetousness, selfishness and disobedience in the highest degree on the part of both king and people.ST Dec 30, 1903ST Aug 12, 1889 Saul was rejected for sparing the best sheep and oxen contrary to command, even though he intended to offer them as sacrifices, proving obedience matters more than burnt offerings and that disobedience must not be treated as a small matter nor human judgment substituted for what God commands.ST Dec 30, 1903ST Aug 27, 1902 Religion is obedience, and sacrifice not accompanied by obedience is an abomination in the sight of the Lord.ST Aug 27, 1902
Partial obedience is disobedience and does not count as obedience.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Mar 5, 1912 Obedience must be complete, exact and literal, neither falling short of what God commands nor adding one's own course, nor diminishing nor softening the command according to personal judgment or convenience.ST Oct 17, 1895RH Oct 25, 1864 Deciding which of God's commands to obey or choosing which commandments to keep is rebellion, and men cannot honor God by substituting their own judgment for the way He commanded them to act.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Jun 25, 1885ST Nov 9, 1915 God's law cannot be bent to suit human convenience, and His commands are not for human judgment or disregard.RH Dec 20, 1870 Saul thought he had obeyed though he spared Agag and let the people keep the best sheep and oxen, and this test of character showed he could not be trusted to rule Israel, while his self-deception in sparing Agag and the best cattle exposed that sparing did not fulfill the command.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Mar 5, 1912 His obeying in part and stopping short of complete obedience cost him the blessing and the kingdom, for his rejection of the Lord's word led to the Lord's rejection of him as king and the taking of the kingdom from him.ST Jun 25, 1885ST Nov 9, 1915
This proves God requires literal obedience, just as the spirit of obedience to the Sabbath command consists in actual observance of its letter, the seventh day set apart and hallowed to commemorate creation on which God Himself rested.ST Jul 29, 1889 Those who profane the Sabbath God appointed and commanded and offer Him another day in its place likewise disobey and displease God.RH Sep 16, 1915 Saul tried to obey his own idea of the spirit of the command instead of its plain letter to utterly destroy the Amalekites and all that they had, and for that God rejected him.ST Jul 29, 1889 His deposing sin was quitting the work God sent him to do and turning to worship, leaving his plain work to sacrifice the spared sheep and oxen in hope of doing something better and more distinctly religious, thinking their fatness and the delight of worship would please God more than finishing the slaughter.ST Apr 17, 1879 The Lord is no better pleased today with shirking plain duty under plea of doing religious service, even praying or exhorting, than He was in the days of Saul.ST Apr 17, 1879 God has a design for His work and success depends on following it rather than substituting human plans, for failing to carry out what God directs mars the work and can lead to ruin.RH Feb 6, 1879
Disobedience remains serious even when presented as serving God and when its spirit is claimed to be kept.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Dec 20, 1870ST Aug 27, 1902 Saul claimed he had obeyed but had spared sheep and oxen and excused this as an offering to God, thinking the sacrifice would justify his disobedience, yet his disobedience cost him the kingdom and warns that questioning or disregarding God's commands brings loss.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 27, 1902 His failure to destroy fully was not excused by his own judgment that a partial alternative of saving what he considered valuable for sacrifice would be acceptable.RH Dec 20, 1870 No excuse for disobedience will be accepted and there is no justification for transgression, not the greatness of the transgressor, not offerings made to the poor, not pressure of public opinion, and obedience is the way of life with no exception while transgression leads to death.ST Aug 27, 1902
Links and Present Warnings
The link runs from Agag, king of the Amalekites whom Saul took alive, to Haman who is called an Agagite.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 23, 1902ST Jan 20, 1898 Haman is understood as descended from Agag, their king, which ties him to the Amalekites as the Lord's bitter enemies.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 23, 1902 That descent explains Mordecai's refusal to bow to Haman as though he were God.ST Sep 20, 1899 Saul's destruction of the Amalekites was punishment for their treacherous ambush of Israel at Rephidim between the wilderness of Sin and Sinai, when they struck the faint and weary hindmost shortly after Israel left Egypt and before Sinai.ST Apr 23, 1902 Haman the Agagite's plan to destroy all the Jews because Mordecai the Benjamite would not bow was vengeance for Israel's destruction of his nation and a continuation of that original Amalekite treachery and cruelty.ST Apr 23, 1902
Agag pictures something cherished that must be given up in obedience to God.RH Dec 10, 1861 The question stands whether believers still cherish an Agag, something they refuse to give up, and sparing Agag despite Samuel's command cost Saul his kingdom, showing that disobeying God's prophet is serious.RH Dec 10, 1861 Modern indulgences are likened to Agag, with warning that people who cling to what they are commanded to give up risk losing what they have.RH Oct 8, 1861 Full consecration requires thorough removal of sin with nothing held back from God.RH Feb 17, 1859 Saul's favorable position and outward success did not prevent his downfall, warning that what appears good may ultimately become a curse.
Saul obeyed in part, sparing Agag and the best sheep and cattle, and this refusal to obey fully cost him the blessing.ST Nov 9, 1915 His course warns against choosing which commandments to keep and stopping short of complete obedience.ST Nov 9, 1915 Clinging to what is commanded to be given up risks losing what is already possessed.RH Oct 8, 1861
Sources