Exodus 16:3
And the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
Translations
And the children of Israel said to them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for you have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
And the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
and the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
And the children of Israel said to them, O that we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh-pots, and when we did eat bread to the full: for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
and the children of Israel said unto them, Would that we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
and the children of Israel said unto them, Would that we had died by the hand of Jehovah in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh-pots, when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
and the sons of Israel say unto them, 'Oh that we had died by the hand of Jehovah in the land of Egypt, in our sitting by the flesh-pot, in our eating bread to satiety — for ye have brought us out unto this wilderness to put all this assembly to death with hunger.'
And the children of Israel said to them, Would that we had died by the hand of Jehovah in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh-pots, when we ate bread to the full; for ye have brought us out into this wilderness, to kill this whole congregation with hunger!
and the sons of Israel said unto them—Oh that we had died by the hand of Yahweh, in the land of Egypt, when we remained by the pot of flesh, when we did eat bread to the full,—for ye have brought us forth into this desert, to cause all this multitude to die by famine.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ If only we had died by the LORD’s hand in the land of Egypt!” they said. “ There we sat by pots of meat and ate our fill of bread, but you have brought us into this desert to starve this whole assembly to death!”
and the children of Israel said to them, “ We wish that we had died by the LORD’s hand in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the meat pots, when we ate our fill of bread, for you have brought us out into this wilderness to kill this whole assembly with hunger.”
And the children of Israel said to them, It would have been better for the Lord to have put us to death in the land of Egypt, where we were seated by the flesh-pots and had bread enough for our needs; for you have taken us out to this waste of sand, to put all this people to death through need of food.
For the children of Israel sayde to them, Oh that we had dyed by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when wee sate by the flesh pots, when wee ate bread our bellies full: for yee haue brought vs out into this wildernesse, to kill this whole company with famine.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the children of Israel said to them: Would to God we had died by the hand of the Lord in the land of Egypt, when we sat over the flesh pots, and ate bread to the full. Why have you brought us into this desert, that you might destroy all the multitude with famine?
Cross-references 20 of 56
- Numbers 11:4-5
And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?
Israel again longs for Egypt’s food and craves meat in the wilderness.
- Exodus 16:22-30
And it came to pass, that on the sixth day they gathered twice as much bread, two omers for one man: and all the rulers of the congregation came and told Moses.
The manna’s double portion and cessation on the seventh day taught Sabbath observance.
- Psalms 78:24-25
And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.
God fed Israel manna from heaven in the wilderness, even as they complained of hunger.
- Numbers 11:33-34
And while the flesh was yet between their teeth, ere it was chewed, the wrath of the LORD was kindled against the people, and the LORD smote the people with a very great plague.
Israel’s craving for meat was followed by God’s wrath, plague, and death.
- 1 Corinthians 10:5-6
But with many of them God was not well pleased: for they were overthrown in the wilderness.
Israel’s wilderness failures are warnings against evil desire.
- Exodus 20:10
But the seventh day is the sabbath of the LORD thy God: in it thou shalt not do any work, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, thy manservant, nor thy maidservant, nor thy cattle, nor thy stranger that is within thy gates:
The commandment’s seventh day is the same Sabbath identified in Exodus 16.
- Exodus 16:15
And when the children of Israel saw it, they said one to another, It is manna: for they wist not what it was. And Moses said unto them, This is the bread which the LORD hath given you to eat.
God answered the hunger complaint with manna.
- Psalms 106:14-15
But lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert.
Israel craved food in the wilderness, and God granted their request but sent leanness to their souls.
- Exodus 16:35
And the children of Israel did eat manna forty years, until they came to a land inhabited; they did eat manna, until they came unto the borders of the land of Canaan.
Israel ate manna for forty years, until reaching Canaan.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11
Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.
The manna account is presented as an example written for later generations.
- Psalms 78:19
Yea, they spake against God; they said, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?
Israel questioned whether God could provide a table in the wilderness.
- Exodus 14:11-12
And they said unto Moses, Because there were no graves in Egypt, hast thou taken us away to die in the wilderness? wherefore hast thou dealt thus with us, to carry us forth out of Egypt?
Israel reproached Moses at the sea, fearing death in the wilderness and preferring Egypt.
- Exodus 17:3-4
And the people thirsted there for water; and the people murmured against Moses, and said, Wherefore is this that thou hast brought us up out of Egypt, to kill us and our children and our cattle with thirst?
next murmuring showing same ignorance of sin
- Numbers 14:2-3
And all the children of Israel murmured against Moses and against Aaron: and the whole congregation said unto them, Would God that we had died in the land of Egypt! or would God we had died in this wilderness!
Israel again longs for Egypt and complains about the wilderness journey.
- Deuteronomy 8:3
And he humbled thee, and suffered thee to hunger, and fed thee with manna, which thou knewest not, neither did thy fathers know; that he might make thee know that man doth not live by bread only, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the LORD doth man live.
Israel’s hunger and manna teach that life depends on God’s word, not bread alone.
- Psalms 78:30-31
They were not estranged from their lust. But while their meat was yet in their mouths,
Israel’s craving for flesh was met with provision, then judged while they ate.
- Psalms 105:40
The people asked, and he brought quails, and satisfied them with the bread of heaven.
God provides Israel with quail and satisfies them with bread from heaven.
- Numbers 21:5
And the people spake against God, and against Moses, Wherefore have ye brought us up out of Egypt to die in the wilderness? for there is no bread, neither is there any water; and our soul loatheth this light bread.
Israel murmurs against God and loathes the manna as unsatisfying.
- Exodus 16:22-23
And it came to pass, that on the sixth day they gathered twice as much bread, two omers for one man: and all the rulers of the congregation came and told Moses.
The people gather twice as much bread, prompting the Sabbath instruction.
- Hebrews 3:12
Take heed, brethren, lest there be in any of you an evil heart of unbelief, in departing from the living God.
Israel’s complaint exemplifies an evil heart of unbelief.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
63 sources
About a month after leaving Egypt the whole congregation in the wilderness of Sin turned against Moses and Aaron, wishing they had died in Egypt and charging that they had been led out to be killed with hunger.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17CTBH 178.4–179.2SG3 248.1Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15 Their wants were still supplied and stores were only nearly spent, yet fear of future lack for themselves and their children blinded them to provision as need arose.Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20PP 292.1–31SP 221.1–222.1 Their murmur against God's appointed leaders was murmur against God Himself, showing criminal unbelief, ingratitude for repeated deliverances, and unwillingness to endure hardship for freedom to serve Him.SG3 248.1Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20PP 292.1–3SG3 250.13T 85.1–3 God had brought the trial on the point of appetite to prove whether they would trust Him and walk in His law, and He answered with bread from heaven morning by morning.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17CTBH 178.4–179.2Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30 The flesh pots they longed for were the flesh meat of Egypt, the cry of a taste perverted by slavery and lustful appetite, and the same rebellion is repeated whenever His people despise His plain provision and return to indulgence after light on health reform has been given.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30HLT1 52.3–53.1CTBH 43.1–44.2CH 133.3RH Mar 3, 1910
Historical Setting and Wording
The complaint belongs in the wilderness of Sin about thirty days after the departure from Egypt, spoken soon after the deliverance at the Red Sea and the song of praise that followed it.CTBH 178.4–179.2Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15SG3 298.1–299.2 That deliverance had carried more than a million people safely over on dry ground with the waters standing as walls on the right and the left, while the cloud stood behind Israel as darkness to the Egyptians and light to Israel, until the Egyptians were overthrown in the sea with none remaining.Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15 God was then proving whether the people taken as a nation from another nation by signs and wonders would trust their Deliverer, and their murmuring over difficulties in the way left them without excuse when the law was afterward declared at Sinai.SG3 298.1–299.2
It was the whole congregation speaking against Moses and Aaron, wishing they had died in Egypt and charging that they had been brought forth into this wilderness to kill the whole assembly with hunger.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17SG3 248.13T 85.1–3TCBMP 97.1PP 303.4–304.1 The charge laid blame on leaders bearing heavy responsibility when circumstances turned adverse, yet murmuring against them in hardship was murmuring against God.Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–203T 85.1–3 The move itself was not at human command, for the departing from the wilderness of Sin was in obedience to the command of God.Ms 38, 1890, par. 12
Their present needs were still supplied and their stores were only nearly exhausted, with no way seen to obtain more, and they had not yet gone hungry.Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20PP 292.1–31SP 221.1–222.1 The complaint came from fear that they and their children would lack food in the future, expecting death rather than trusting provision as needs arose.PP 292.1–31SP 221.1–222.1ST Jul 9, 18942T 656.2–657.21SP 223.1–2 Imagined future want blinded them to goodness and mercy, making them ungrateful for gifts already given.ST Jul 9, 18942T 656.2–657.2
They remembered sitting by the flesh pots and eating bread to the full, recalling plentiful meat and full bread, and lusting even for the leeks and onions of Egypt.CTBH 178.4–179.21T 128.3–129.1 That food in Egypt had generally been cheap and had only seemed satisfying because hard labor gave keen appetites, while imagination of its goodness was now distorted.ST Aug 12, 1880 The Egyptians who had come out with them were the first to complain about the food.ST Aug 12, 1880
The whole setting stood under divine leadership in the pillar of cloud and fire, with Christ as leader and teacher and preserving power upon them through the forty years of guidance.Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15Lt 112, 1909, par. 18–19 The desert journey itself involved thirst, heat, and fatigue on foot through a barren land, hardships that could have prompted even greater complaints.ST Aug 15, 18784T 296.3 Even so, the trial over bread and water tested faith, and only those who walk trustingly without questioning, who are not laggards and do not block the way, are registered as good and obedient servants.Ms 38, 1890, par. 12
Unbelief Ingratitude and Rebellion
The cry was an evil heart of unbelief, criminal after a sure promise, distrusting God for the future while present wants were still supplied.SG3 248.1PP 292.1–31SP 221.1–222.1SG3 250.1SG3 251.2 Difficulties in the way were treated as impossibilities, confidence failed, and nothing ahead was seen but death for themselves and their children.SG3 248.1PP 292.1–3SG3 250.1 God was proving whether they would trust Him who had taken them as a nation from another nation by signs and wonders, and their murmuring over hardship and wish to return left them without excuse when the law was afterward declared at Sinai.SG3 298.1–299.2
They forgot repeated deliverances and goodness after being called out in mercy to worship without hindrance.PP 292.1–31T 128.3–129.1RH Jan 6, 1863 He had heard their anguish under overtaxing labor and the putting of their children to death, had promised to be their God and take them to Himself as a people, and had promised to lead them to a large and good land.SG3 250.1 He had wrought for them by miracles, delivered them many times, and proved them by bringing them into strait places, yet when tried they forgot His wonderful dealings.1T 128.3–129.1RH Jan 6, 1863
The complaint was ingratitude and lack of trust and submission, an unwillingness to suffer hardship for His sake and to rely on promised help.1T 128.3–129.1RH Jan 6, 1863CET 158.1CET 158.2–159.2 Craving for the flesh pots expressed distrust and rebellion despite care and promises, preferring their own desires to the simple food and habits He was teaching.HL 282.1–2 Imagined future need blinded them to goodness and mercy, so fear about what might come made them ungrateful for gifts already given.2T 656.2–657.2
Murmuring against Moses and Aaron as bearers of heavy responsibility was murmuring against God, including continual complaining against both.Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–203T 85.1–3Lt 3, 1884, par. 12 Moses was charged with all trials as God's devoted servant, though he was only God's instrument to bring the people into submission and obedience.SG3 250.13T 89.1–90.1 When appetite was restricted and close requirements were brought to bear, he was reflected upon as arbitrary and seeking to rule and be altogether a prince over them.3T 85.1–33T 89.1–90.1Ms 3, 1871, par. 2–4
They wickedly wished to have remained in Egypt with plenty of meat and bread, preferring the comforts and apparent security of slavery to hardship and self-denial in God's service.CH 111.1–2SG3 250.11SP 223.1–2 The withheld comforts tested whether they valued serving God and the freedom He had given more than pleasures enjoyed in bondage. Some would rather face slavery, diseased bodies, sickness, and even death than give up rich food for a plain diet.CH 111.1–21SP 223.1–2SG3 251.2
God's Testing and Provision
The hunger in the wilderness was a trial brought on the point of appetite to test faith and to educate the people to rely on promised protection and care, proving whether they would walk in the law.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17CTBH 178.4–179.2Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20HL 281.3CET 158.1 Longing for the food of Egypt and accusing Moses and Aaron of bringing the whole assembly out to die revealed distrust of God's care even after repeated deliverance, and complaints against the bearers of heavy responsibility were complaints against God Himself.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17Ms 21, 1897, par. 18–20SG4 173.1–174.1 When tested after deliverance they responded with murmuring and wishing they had died in Egypt where they had plenty, showing lack of trust and submission and unwillingness to endure a difficult self-denying path.HL 281.3CET 158.1SG4 173.1–174.1 The manna that followed tested obedience and preserved the Sabbath through the forty years of wandering.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17
God answered the murmuring by miracle with bread from heaven to stop all complaining, angels' food given morning by morning, the best food that could possibly be given, just as He wrought miracles to give pure water from the rock when they were thirsty.Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30UTFF 5.1Lt 112, 1909, par. 18–19 The great trouble addressed was flesh, and though He could have supplied meat He gave bread from heaven instead, leading them where a flesh diet could not be obtained in order to educate and discipline and train them into correct habits.Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16UTFF 5.1 That daily miracle, with the Sabbath preserved through the wandering, together with preservation under the pillar of cloud and fire, gave unmistakable evidence that they were led and protected by divine power.Ms 77, 1899, par. 15–17Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15Lt 112, 1909, par. 18–19 The hunger complaint after the deliverance at the sea and the song of praise was thus met not with abandonment but with condescending provision.Ms 125, 1909, par. 14–16Ms 21, 1897, par. 12–15
The restriction of diet and the choice of manna were for physical, mental, and moral good, for as Maker of man God knew what food would preserve health in the very best condition and meet physical necessities.Lt 44, 1903, par. 22–23Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8ED 38.26T 372.2 He promised to take sickness away if they obeyed and followed Him fully, so that despite the hardships of wilderness life none of the tribes was feeble, and He would carry them into Canaan and establish them there a pure, holy, happy people.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30ED 38.2UTFF 5.1 Focusing on Egypt's meat pots led them to despise the bread provided to preserve that threefold health, revealing dissatisfaction with God's own arrangement to feed them with manna rained from heaven.Lt 44, 1903, par. 22–23Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–86T 372.2 He withheld flesh because He understood its influence upon the human system and would have a people who in physical appearance would bear divine credentials notwithstanding their long journey, and He would have given flesh if it had been essential for health.UTFF 5.1
God designed to remove the feverish Egyptian diet and restore appetite to a pure healthy state to enjoy the simple fruits given to Adam and Eve in Eden, even intending to bring His people back to live upon simple fruits, vegetables, and grains.Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8UTFF 5.1 He was about to establish them in a second Eden, a goodly land with fruits and grains of His providing, wishing them in perfect health and soundness on entering it.Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8 His name could not be glorified unless the people acknowledging Him as the God of heaven were in perfect soundness of health, so that surrounding heathen nations would glorify the God of Israel for His wonderful work.Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8 Their murmuring is recorded as a warning to avoid unbelief and escape the consequences of disobedience, for God was proving whether they would trust Him who had taken them a nation from another nation by signs and wonders, and their failure to endure the trial left them without excuse when He afterward came down on Sinai to declare His law Himself.ST May 31, 1910SG3 298.1–299.2
Fleshpots Appetite and Diet
The flesh pots are flesh meat and the appetite for meat eating, and sitting by them recalls plentiful meat and full bread in Egypt.HLT1 52.3–53.1CTBH 43.1–44.2Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24Lt 50, 1908, par. 17–20 To hunger for them now is to go back to eating flesh meat and indulging perverted appetite after light against it has been given.Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24Lt 50, 1908, par. 17–20 The standard is to leave off meat, tea, coffee, and butter, to eat temperately of fruits, grains, and vegetables in wise combinations, and to limit quantity and eat only two meals a day when clear thought is needed, which preserves brain and nerve power and keeps the mind sanctified and the intellect strong.Lt 50, 1908, par. 17–20 Flesh meat is not the right food where fruits, grains, and nuts are abundant, for it tends to animalize the nature, rob of love and sympathy, give the lower passions control over the higher powers, hinder growth in grace and an even temper and upright moral character through the sympathy of brain and nerves with the stomach, produce erroneous thinking and acting, and bring cancers, tumors, and pulmonary diseases, so that if ever healthful it is not safe now.Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24
Taste had been perverted in Egypt, and the cry for flesh was lustful appetite controlling reason.Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8CTBH 118.1–119.1HLT1 52.3–53.1Lt 5, 1868, par. 10–125MR 392.3–393.2 It was unwillingness to accept restriction for good and to be restored to a pure healthy state to enjoy the simple fruits given in Eden, rebellion against requirement, charging hardness in prescribing food that could not satisfy wants or sustain life, and claiming to choose food better than the Maker who knew what would preserve health best and meet physical necessities.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30Ms 69, 1912, par. 6–8CTBH 118.1–119.1Lt 5, 1868, par. 10–12 Departing from given light to follow the imagination of the heart in order to gratify depraved appetite is choosing food said to be not best for health.Lt 5, 1868, par. 10–12
Fixing attention on Egypt's meat pots bred dissatisfaction with the bread and water provided to preserve physical, mental, and moral health, turning to despising, murmuring against heaven-appointed food, and hating the bread of heaven given for good and health.CH 111.1–26T 372.2RH Jun 11, 1914Lt 26, 1908, par. 7Ms 103, 1898, par. 8 Desire grew as it was dwelt upon, until appetite turned people against what sustains them and resisted provision.6T 372.2RH Jun 11, 1914Ms 103, 1898, par. 8 The complaint preferred slavery and even death to going without the desired food, and the demand for flesh was rebellion whose consequences were speedily felt.CH 111.1–2Lt 26, 1908, par. 7
God led into the wilderness where a flesh diet could not be obtained in order to educate and discipline and train into correct habits, restricting diet and to a large degree taking flesh food away.UTFF 5.1HL 96.2Lt 3, 1884, par. 3 Though He could have miraculously supplied meat, He gave instead the bread of heaven, angels' food, and He would have given flesh if it had been essential for health, since He created and redeemed.UTFF 5.1HL 96.2Ms 38, 1898, par. 11 He withheld it because He understood its influence upon the human system and would have a people who in physical appearance would bear the divine credentials notwithstanding the long journey, intending to bring them back to simple fruits, vegetables, and grains and to carry them into Canaan and establish them there a pure, holy, happy people with not a feeble one in all their tribes by taking away all sickness.UTFF 5.1Lt 3, 1884, par. 3 Putting diet on a wrong basis by accommodating it to appetite, especially in treating the sick, is contrary to that plan of temperance.Lt 3, 1884, par. 3
The determined demand for the flesh of dead animals made Him wroth, and discontent and murmuring for the fleshpots led to permission to eat animal food for a short time in the temporary granting of quails, while manna remained the food provided for training and best suited to the purpose.MH 311.2HLT1 52.3–53.1CTBH 43.1–44.2UTFF 5.1ST Jun 13, 1916 Eaten to excess in gluttony it brought its sure harmful result in plague, disease, and death to many and to thousands while the flesh was still between the teeth.CH 111.1–2HLT1 52.3–53.1CTBH 43.1–44.2ST Jun 13, 1916Lt 26, 1908, par. 7 Indulgence of perverted appetite led into numerous grievous sins, caused falling in the wilderness, forfeited special blessings, and kept them from being established in Canaan as a holy, happy people with none feeble.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–302RED 42.1–43.2 Choosing what has been said to be not best forfeits blessing and health and hinders growth in grace and heavenly knowledge and prevents partaking of the divine nature without having escaped the corruption in the world through lust.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30Lt 5, 1868, par. 10–12
Warning and Present Application
The complaint in the wilderness is repeated whenever professed believers, called out to worship without hindrance and proved by strait places, forget wonderful dealings and deliverances when trial comes.1T 128.3–129.1SG4 173.1–174.1CET 158.2–159.2 Instead of submitting to the leading and enduring a difficult self-denying path, they look back to former security and plenty, think they have a hard time, lust for what they left as Israel lusted for leeks and onions, sink into discouragement and distrust, and murmur that they would rather have died where they were.1T 128.3–129.1SG4 173.1–174.1CET 158.2–159.2 Those who profess truth for the last days and do this do worse than Israel did.1T 128.3–129.1
The same rebellion is repeated when modern Israel rejects the light on health reform given in the last days to reform unnatural habits and preserve body and mind in health for good in this world and eternal happiness in the next.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30 By that reform God purposes to lead His people through to the heavenly Canaan, as He restricted Israel's diet for their good, promised to take sickness away if they obeyed fully, and gave angels' food morning by morning, yet they fostered a perverted appetite, charged Him with hardness in prescribing what could not satisfy or sustain life, claimed to choose food better than He could, and would not submit, bringing disease and death in the wilderness.Lt 41a, 1874, par. 28–30 To return now to the flesh pots of Egypt is to go back to eating flesh meat and indulging perverted appetite after precious light and warnings against it have been given.CH 133.39T 159.3Ms 24, 1902, par. 9–11Lt 3, 1884, par. 10Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24 It disregards light, poisons the life-giving current in the veins by self-indulgence, and lets appetite turn people against what sustains them and draw them back toward what they had left behind.CH 133.39T 159.3Ms 24, 1902, par. 9–11
That testing and proving bears especially on ministers of the gospel and others supported by the tithe from the storehouse, and on all professed believers whose example influences the churches.Ms 24, 1902, par. 9–11Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24 Those who proclaim the most solemn truth ever given must not set an example of returning to meat eating and self-indulgence rather than service to God, nor poison the life-giving current by indulgence, even though the use of flesh meat is not to be made a test.RH Mar 3, 1910RH Feb 3, 1916Ms 24, 1902, par. 9–11Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24 Teachers who hanker after hurtful foods injure themselves and by example make it harder for students to follow healthful practices.Lt 141, 1899, par. 3–5 Flesh meat is not the right food where fruits, grains, and nuts are abundant, for it tends to animalize the nature, rob of love and sympathy, give lower passions control over higher powers, hinder growth in grace, an even temper, and upright moral character through the sympathy of brain and nerves with the stomach, produce erroneous thinking and acting, and is unsafe now when cancers, tumors, and pulmonary diseases are largely caused by it.Ms 37, 1909, par. 23–24
Not hungering for the flesh pots means leaving off meat, tea, coffee, and butter, eating temperately of fruits, grains, and vegetables in wise combinations, limiting quantity and eating only two meals a day when clear thought is needed, so that brain and nerve power are preserved, the mind sanctified, and the intellect kept strong.Lt 50, 1908, par. 17–20 It means putting plain wholesome food on the table, dispensing with harmful food such as hot biscuits which cause dyspepsia, moving from principle under strict rules of diet, educating taste after the divine plan, elevating the standard as nearly as possible to the divine order, and not changing course to meet the wishes of friends or relatives, whether one or two or a host, who live contrary to that wise arrangement.Lt 3, 1884, par. 10 Hunger for temporal food is not the greatest calamity, for man is to live by every word from God, with physical wants secondary to His requirements and submission to His choice of proper food.2RED 42.1–43.2 Faith when tested over bread and water should be strong, active, and enduring, speaking blessing for bountiful dealing, learning self-denial now rather than counting restraint of unhealthy appetite and a plain diet as real suffering or starvation, preferring slavery, diseased bodies, and even death, and walking trustingly without questioning instead of obeying only when direction suits human inclination and ideas.2RED 42.1–43.2Ms 38, 1890, par. 12SG3 251.2 Only such will be registered as good and obedient servants who do not lag, block the way, or put the stone before the wheel, for bread and water is all that is promised to the remnant in the time of trouble.Ms 38, 1890, par. 12SG3 251.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
130 sources
Israel spoke these words in the wilderness of Sin about a month after leaving Egypt, when the food brought out had run low and starvation seemed ahead, wishing they had died amid Egypt's meat and full bread rather than be led out to die hungry.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Jan 25, 1910ST Oct 31, 1906RH Dec 23, 1851ST Apr 24, 1879 Addressed to Moses and Aaron as bringing them out to kill them, the complaint was really against God, springing from unbelief about the future and from a distorted memory that recalled Egypt's food while forgetting its bondage and God's deliverances.ST Apr 22, 1875RH Jun 12, 1900ST Jul 30, 1902ST Nov 7, 1895ST Jul 30, 1902 Though provoked, God answered with mercy by raining bread from heaven, giving wholesome manna six days a week for forty years and flesh to meet their craving.ST Jun 6, 1906ST Dec 17, 1912RH Sep 12, 1871 The manna came as a test of obedience to His law, treating the Sabbath as an already known and binding institution a month before Sinai, not as first made or commanded there.RH Dec 23, 1851RH Apr 11, 1854RH May 7, 1857ST Jun 10, 1880RH Jun 10, 1862 By the threefold weekly miracle of daily manna, a double portion on the sixth day, and none on the seventh, He fixed the true seventh day, Saturday, in unbroken continuity with creation when He had blessed and hallowed it.RH Aug 19, 1915ST Jul 22, 1880ST Jun 10, 1880ST Feb 26, 1894RH Nov 28, 1871
Wilderness Setting and Timing
The complaint belongs to the march from the Red Sea toward Sinai, in the wilderness of Sin between Elim and Sinai, after the crossing, the song of Moses, and the stay at Elim with its wells and palms.RH Dec 17, 1861RH May 7, 1857 It is the murmuring for bread in Sin, where the people longed for Egypt's plentiful food and charged Moses and Aaron with bringing the whole assembly into the wilderness to die of hunger.ST Jun 10, 1880RH Dec 17, 1861RH Dec 23, 1851 That stay followed the one-day journey from Elim by divine direction, whose weekday is not stated.RH May 7, 1857RH May 7, 1857
It came about a month after leaving Egypt, thirty to thirty-two days after the departure on the fifteenth day of the first month, on or about the fifteenth day of the second month in the second month after the exodus.RH Jul 14, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Apr 24, 1879 That was about a month before Israel reached Sinai, more than a month before Sinai, one month and three days before Sinai, thirty days before coming to the desert of Sinai on the fifteenth day of the third month, and before the law was spoken there.ST Oct 31, 1906RH Dec 23, 1851RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jul 14, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854 From that camp between Elim and Sinai the seventh day was specially marked by the withholding of manna.ST Oct 31, 1906RH May 7, 1857
The provisions brought from Egypt were exhausted, herbage was scanty and flocks diminishing, with no human prospect of feeding the host, so famine seemed to stare them in the face and trembling faith asked whether God could furnish a table in the wilderness.ST Feb 11, 1913ST Oct 22, 1902ST Jun 10, 1875 Their alarm at leaving Egypt's food behind and fearing starvation became the setting for God to supply food there.ST Oct 22, 1902ST Dec 17, 1912 That same night the Lord sent quails in the evening in answer, and manna began raining the next morning, on the sixteenth day, falling six days successively until the commanded Sabbath; the first quail before the manna was distinct from the later one in Numbers 11 after they tired of manna, and the manna was miraculous food supplied six days a week for forty years rather than a natural tamarisk secretion.ST Apr 24, 1879ST Apr 22, 1889ST Dec 17, 1912
All the murmuring is not stated to have occurred on the very day of arrival in Sin, and its timing is not given; it came only after they had been there long enough to feel the pangs of hunger, so it does not establish that manna began falling on the day of entrance.ST Jun 10, 1880RH May 7, 1857RH Apr 17, 1900 There is no evidence the congregation was traveling from Elim to Sin on a Sabbath, and the sixth day when twice as much was gathered is the weekly sixth day numbered at creation, not a sixth day counted from the first fall of manna, with nothing said about five preceding days of manna.RH May 7, 1857RH Nov 15, 1864RH Dec 20, 1864RH Dec 20, 1864 Even marching at God's command would have been obedience rather than doing their own work forbidden by the Sabbath law, no more a violation than marching around Jericho seven days in succession forty years later.RH Dec 20, 1864RH Dec 20, 1864
The verse stands in the history part of Exodus, chapters 1 to 18, telling the great deliverance from bitter bondage and oppression and how they became a nation with thorough organization, efficient leadership, a complete code of laws, and an established form of worship.RH Jan 20, 1916 The name Exodus means going out, referring to the departure of Israel from Egypt.RH Jan 20, 1916
Words of the Complaint
In the wilderness the whole congregation turned on its leaders with the wish that they had died by the hand of the Lord in Egypt rather than face hunger where they were.ST Aug 18, 1909ST Nov 3, 1881RH Dec 5, 1871ST Jun 10, 1875 With no human prospect of feeding the host, their trembling faith gave way to the unbelieving question whether God could furnish a table in the wilderness, and they chose death in Egypt over life on the journey.RH Dec 5, 1871RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jun 10, 1875 Their words came about a month after leaving Egypt, in the wilderness of Sin, after earlier deliverance and despite the Lord's care, revealing how hardship made them forget that God was guiding them.RH Feb 13, 1913ST Jun 10, 1875 They looked back nostalgically on Egypt, said they had eaten their fill there, and accused Moses and Aaron of bringing the whole assembly out to die.ST Aug 18, 1909ST Nov 3, 1881
They pictured themselves as having sat by the flesh pots and eaten bread to the full, and set Egypt before their minds as a place of abundant food and security.ST Jul 22, 1880RH Dec 17, 1861ST Aug 18, 1909ST Jun 10, 1875 That longing belonged to the setting of the manna's provision, for the chapter whose central topic is the fall of the manna opens with this complaint for bread in the wilderness of Sin after leaving Egypt.ST Jul 22, 1880RH Dec 17, 1861ST Jan 25, 1910 They claimed they had enjoyed plenty there and charged that they had been brought out to die of hunger.ST Jul 22, 1880ST Jan 25, 1910 Their interest in the Sabbath then began to be specially awakened, when God supplied manna for six days, none on the seventh, and preserved the sixth day's supply for the seventh, so that these recurring miracles marked the seventh day.ST Jul 22, 1880
They laid the blame on Moses and Aaron, saying ye have brought us forth into this wilderness to kill this whole assembly with hunger.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Jan 25, 1910ST Aug 18, 1909ST Jun 10, 1875 The complaint arose after the short journey from Elim by divine direction, and it became the setting in which God gave manna to prove whether they would walk in His law.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Jan 25, 1910RH May 7, 1857 Their charge was unjust, distrustful of God's care, and nostalgic for former security despite its bondage.ST Aug 18, 1909RH Feb 13, 1913 In the warm land through which they traveled the answer included instruction to boil or bake food on the sixth day so that no such work would be done on the seventh.ST Jul 22, 1880
Though the word Ye was aimed at Moses and Aaron, the murmuring was really against Christ who directed the leaders, for the leaders were obeying Him.ST Nov 7, 1895ST Jul 30, 1902RH Aug 13, 1872 They had not yet dared to murmur openly against God, so they aimed reproaches at His instruments, but the bitter words glanced off Moses and Aaron and struck God who wielded them.ST Nov 7, 1895ST Jul 30, 1902 To complain about God's tools while saying Ye is to accuse God without daring to name Him, and if they had acknowledged that God had brought them there they would have trusted Him to care for them.ST Jul 30, 1902RH Aug 13, 1872 So complaint against God's messenger over temporal support is complaint against God Himself, exposing the dealing with man instead of God seen when givers suspect the minister seeks their property to enrich himself while he seeks only fruit that redounds to their account.ST Nov 7, 1895RH Aug 13, 1872
The cry beginning Would to God we had died in Egypt started with the mixed multitude of Egyptians who had joined Israel from terror at the plagues without understanding God's character and law and without conversion.RH Nov 25, 1873 Seized with homesickness on the barren desert, with minds reverting to the flesh-pots and full bread and fertile valley of the Nile in contrast to the waste before them, they saw only ruin, starvation and death with no provision or water for the millions, and deprecated life itself.RH Nov 25, 1873 Destitute of faith despite proved goodness, love, power and wisdom in the plagues and at the Red Sea, they complained against their leaders, and the influence spread like a plague until nearly all Israel joined it.RH Nov 25, 1873 Satan and his host stirred the disaffected in their tents to urge return to Egypt and mutiny against Moses, until even the best and purest felt it, while Moses withstood it by calm faith that the God who parted the sea into walls of water could feed and give drink.RH Nov 25, 1873 God quieted them for a time with manna from heaven and water from the rock, yet the carnal heart remained unsubdued and repeated the same murmuring at every new trial until Moses was provoked to sin and Aaron yielded to idolatrous worship.RH Nov 25, 1873
Unbelief Behind the Words
The cry in the wilderness exposed trembling faith and distrust about the future rather than present starvation, for there was still food for present necessities when fear of future want took hold.ST Apr 22, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875RH Sep 12, 1871 The whole assembly imagined itself and its children famishing on the long journey, with no human prospect of subsistence unless God should work a perpetual miracle.ST Jun 10, 1875RH Sep 12, 1871 In unbelief they asked in effect whether God could furnish a table in the wilderness, doubting that He who had delivered them could provide for them there.ST Apr 22, 1875RH Feb 13, 1913ST Oct 22, 1902ST Jun 10, 1875RH Sep 12, 1871 Their alarm at leaving Egypt's remembered abundance behind became the setting in which God would supply them, yet their longing revealed how quickly hardship made them forget His guidance and care.RH Dec 5, 1871RH Feb 13, 1913ST Oct 22, 1902
Discontent distorted memory and bred ingratitude, making Egypt's food seem better than it was while bondage was forgotten.RH Jan 6, 1863ST Jul 30, 1902RH Oct 5, 1916 They remembered sitting satisfied while forgetting overtaxing labor, the putting to death of their children, and the anguish from which God had delivered them in answer to their cries. They forgot the plagues upon Egypt, the deliverance through the Red Sea, the song of deliverance, the healing of the bitter water, and the covenant blessings and power pledged to them.RH Jun 12, 1900 They forgot also the promise to take them as His people and lead them to a large and good land, and the promise that no disease would rest upon them if they obeyed. Gratitude thus proved dependent on present circumstances, quickly lost when difficulty or loss came.ST Jul 30, 1902
They were unwilling to endure hardship in freedom for God's service, though they had suffered much in bondage to the Egyptians.RH Jan 6, 1863 True faith would have borne inconvenience and even real suffering cheerfully after so wonderful a deliverance, but they were ready to faint at any suffering on the way to the promised land. They treated difficulties as insurmountable obstacles, lost confidence, saw nothing before them but death, and pictured their children starving. They would trust God no further than they could see continual evidences of His power with their eyes, though He stood ready as a present help and permitted supplies to run short that their hearts might turn to Him for tokens of love and continual care. The withheld comforts tested whether they valued serving God and the freedom He gave above the indulgences of bondage.
The murmuring proved hearts hardened by centuries of oppression, having lost true knowledge of God and of His law, with no sense of sinning against Him who had brought them out with great signs and wonders.ST Jun 6, 1906 Doubting God after many proofs of care and faithfulness was the greater rebellion, tempting Him without excuse even while following a leadership not yet fully tested.ST Sep 29, 1881 Newly come from slavery as a poor, ignorant, doubtful, idolatrous and fleshly multitude of more than three million, they were not yet fitted for the Land of Promise but must first be taught and proved.ST Jan 30, 1907 Though the complaint was extremely wicked, He made no charge for it but answered with mercy.ST Jun 6, 1906
Sources