Translations
And the serpent said to the woman, You shall not surely die:
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die:
And the serpent said to the woman, Ye shall not surely die:
And the serpent saith unto the woman, 'Dying, ye do not die,
And the serpent said to the woman, Ye will not certainly die;
And the serpent said unto the woman,—Ye shall not die,
“ You will not surely die,” the serpent told her.
“ You will not surely die,” the serpent told the woman.
The serpent said to the woman, “ You won’t really die,
And the snake said, Death will not certainly come to you:
Then the serpent said to the woman, Ye shall not die at all,
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the serpent said to the woman: No, you shall not die the death.
Pictures


















Cross-references 20 of 86
- Genesis 2:17
But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it: for in the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.
God warns that disobedience brings death, which the serpent denies.
- Romans 5:12
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Adam’s transgression brought sin and death into the world, affecting all humanity.
- John 8:44
Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.
Both identify the serpent as Satan, the father of lies.
- Revelation 12:9
And the great dragon was cast out, that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world: he was cast out into the earth, and his angels were cast out with him.
Identifies the Eden serpent as Satan, the deceiver of the world.
- Romans 6:23
For the wages of sin is death; but the gift of God is eternal life through Jesus Christ our Lord.
Contrasts the denial of death with sin’s wages of death and God’s gift of eternal life.
- Matthew 4:1-4
Then was Jesus led up of the Spirit into the wilderness to be tempted of the devil.
Christ bore the wilderness test Adam failed and overcame temptation through Scripture.
- Ezekiel 18:4
Behold, all souls are mine; as the soul of the father, so also the soul of the son is mine: the soul that sinneth, it shall die.
Contrasts the serpent’s denial of death with the sinner’s stated fate.
- Genesis 3:15
And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.
The promised woman’s seed will defeat the serpent after the deception.
- 2 Corinthians 11:3
But I fear, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtilty, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ.
Eve’s deception by the serpent warns of minds being led astray from Christ.
- Genesis 3:22
And the LORD God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil: and now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever:
God bars fallen humanity from the tree of life, preventing life forever in sin.
- 2 Timothy 1:10
But is now made manifest by the appearing of our Saviour Jesus Christ, who hath abolished death, and hath brought life and immortality to light through the gospel:
Christ brings life and immortality to light through the gospel, against the serpent’s claim.
- Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
The dead know nothing, contradicting the serpent’s claim.
- Genesis 3:19
In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.
Adam’s disobedience brings hardship and return to dust, contradicting the serpent’s claim.
- 2 Corinthians 11:14
And no marvel; for Satan himself is transformed into an angel of light.
Satan’s deceptive appearance as an angel of light echoes the serpent’s lie.
- 1 Timothy 2:14
And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression.
Eve was deceived by the serpent and entered into transgression.
- Revelation 20:2
And he laid hold on the dragon, that old serpent, which is the Devil, and Satan, and bound him a thousand years,
Identifies the Eden serpent as the devil and Satan.
- Luke 4:6
And the devil said unto him, All this power will I give thee, and the glory of them: for that is delivered unto me; and to whomsoever I will I give it.
Satan offers Christ the kingdoms and dominion gained through humanity’s fall.
- Hebrews 2:14
Forasmuch then as the children are partakers of flesh and blood, he also himself likewise took part of the same; that through death he might destroy him that had the power of death, that is, the devil;
Christ’s death destroys the devil, who holds the power of death.
- 1 Corinthians 15:22
For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.
Contrasts death through Adam with life through Christ.
- Ezekiel 18:20
The soul that sinneth, it shall die. The son shall not bear the iniquity of the father, neither shall the father bear the iniquity of the son: the righteousness of the righteous shall be upon him, and the wickedness of the wicked shall be upon him.
The sinner’s death directly contradicts the serpent’s promise.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
84 sources
Satan speaking through the serpent directly contradicted God's warning, denying that disobedience and eating the forbidden fruit would bring death in order to lead to transgression and ruin.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1 Joined to that denial was the promise that eating would open the eyes and make them as gods knowing good and evil, with greater wisdom and exaltation, implying God had not meant His warning and was selfishly withholding good to restrict liberty.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1 The denial is the first lie and first lesson on natural immortality, teaching that humans cannot die and sinners live on.RH Sep 11, 19162RED 9.2–10.1Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11 That immortality lie founds Spiritualism and pretended communion with the dead, and from it came eternal torment and purgatory that falsely make God a cruel tyrant whose threatenings need not be taken literally.RH Sep 11, 1916GC88 561.2Ms 51, 1890, par. 3–9SG1 113.2GC88 533.2–534.3 By contrast the verse warns that sin brings death, God means what He says and requires strict obedience, while Christ came not to abolish the law Adam transgressed but to mediate and restore obedience.Ms 10, 1894, par. 2–3Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–244T 11.3ST May 29, 1901
Speaker, Denial and Setting
The denial is Satan himself speaking, directly contradicting God's warning that disobedience in eating the forbidden fruit would bring death.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–112RED 9.2–10.1 He assured Eve that she and Adam would not die, meaning that God did not mean what He said and that His warning would not actually be fulfilled but was meant only to frighten them.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–112RED 9.2–10.1 The denial was joined to the promise of greater wisdom, knowledge, power, nobler development, greater happiness, exaltation and a higher, broader existence through breaking the law.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–112RED 9.2–10.1 By it he made God's word seem untrue in order to encourage distrust of the Creator as restricting liberty, to lead into transgression and ruin, and to lay the groundwork for deceiving the world down to the last remnant of time when all except those kept through faith in God's Word are swept into fatal security to be awakened only by wrath.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11RH Sep 11, 1916
He spoke not openly but through the serpent as his medium, working in concealment under its form and disguise.4SP 351.2–352.1Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11PP 53.5RH Feb 24, 18741SP 35.1 As father of lies he put his direct contradiction of the expressed word of God into the serpent's mouth, so that Eve heard the denial from a creature rather than recognizing the fallen foe.4SP 351.2–352.1Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11PP 53.5RH Feb 24, 1874 Angels had cautioned her not to separate from her husband in daily labor because with him she would be in less danger than alone, yet absorbed in her pleasing task she unconsciously wandered from his side, felt apprehension at being alone, then dismissed fear deciding she had sufficient wisdom and strength to discern evil and withstand it.PP 53.5 Having no thought that the fascinating serpent could be the medium of the fallen foe whose address by an angel-like being would have excited her fears, she lingered instead of fleeing.PP 53.5RH Feb 24, 18741SP 35.1
The serpent was then a creature of fascinating appearance, beautiful, bright like burnished gold, winged and moving through the air while eating fruit.4SP 351.2–352.1Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31PP 53.51SP 35.1SG3 42.2 Gazing with mingled curiosity and admiration on the forbidden tree and its beautiful fruit, Eve questioned why God had withheld it, giving the tempter his opportunity to address her as if discerning her thoughts.PP 53.5 He spoke in a musical, seductive voice with subtle praise of her loveliness, using flattery, envy, distrust, questioning and unbelief to make disobedience desirable.PP 53.5RH Aug 4, 1910 She wrongly regarded him as a friend concerned for her welfare, and was drawn by the flattering hope of gaining higher knowledge when seeking her husband and bringing his words to their Maker would have delivered them.PP 53.5RH Aug 4, 1910SG3 42.2
The denial reveals Satan as the author of evil, charging God with his own false character and giving the impression God does not mean what He says.Lt 91, 1900, par. 6–7 The same deception that tempted Adam and Eve still tempts people today, sounding from generation to generation so that men and women keep falling into the snare despite Adam's disobedience and its fearful consequences.Lt 91, 1900, par. 6–7ST May 29, 1901 The lie concealed itself beneath apparent truth, presenting forbidden knowledge as a blessing while hiding that transgression had made him an outcast from heaven, and it led Eve to distrust God's wisdom and cast away faith.Lt 91, 1900, par. 6–7ED 24.1–2ST May 29, 1901 The evil offered as knowledge proved to be disobedience itself, whose promised opening brought only sight of shame and ruin, loss of the covering of heavenly light, nakedness, hiding from the Creator's voice, and expectation of condemnation never known before.ST May 29, 1901
It was spoken in a garden at a dense, leafy, fruit-bearing tree where a man and a woman stood on either side reaching toward its branches.PP 504
Promises and Accusations Against God
Joined to the denial that disobedience would bring death is the promise that eating will open the eyes and make the eaters as gods knowing good and evil.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 The promise offers lifting to a more exalted sphere of existence with a broader field of knowledge, wisdom, power, nobler development, greater happiness, equality with God Himself, great light and freedom, enlightened, expanded and ennobled understanding, and a higher state of knowledge and existence.4SP 351.2–352.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31RH Feb 24, 1874ST Nov 18, 1913 It presents transgression of the law as the way to greater wisdom and exaltation, to freedom from restriction of liberty, to exalting man and placing him where God should be, and it is joined to flattering inducement and questioning of the words of God to lead into disobedience and transgression and to make truth of no effect and prevent oneness in doing God's will.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.12RED 9.2–10.1Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 The same temptation employed in Eden is the temptation employed still, with Satan as the alpha and omega of so-called higher science theories.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 The denial rests on the claim that humans were created immortal and that God withheld the fruit to keep them from gaining knowledge and becoming like Him.2RED 9.2–10.1RH Feb 24, 1874LC1 114.1
The verse accuses God of untruth by making His word seem untrue and leading Eve and then Adam to believe He did not mean what He said about death.GC 531.2–532.14SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24 It accuses Him of selfish jealousy in withholding the fruit lest they be exalted to equality with Himself, of unkindness in withholding great good, of arbitrary restriction of liberty, and of using warning only to frighten, glossing truth with falsehood to make transgression appear a real blessing.4SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31 It works by wily insinuations and false assertion against the character of God, and accepting it was the beginning of disobedience and transgression that gave the knowledge of guilt God did not want, opened the floodgates of woe upon the world, and is continued vigilantly to lead men to accept Satan's assertions as proof against God and against the restoration of God's image.GC 531.2–532.1Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24
The verse presents God's prohibition as never to be carried out but meant only to frighten Adam and Eve and keep them in subordination without knowledge or power.Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31PP 96.1ST Nov 18, 1913LC1 114.1 It charges God with forbidding the most desirable tree for its delicious flavor and exhilarating influence in order to withhold knowledge which is power and to prevent equality with Himself.Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–31RH Feb 24, 1874 Because Eve showed no immediate sign of death, Adam entertained the denial and ate also.RH Feb 24, 1874ST Nov 18, 1913 The same denial that God's threatenings to punish transgression are only to frighten was repeated by great, worldly, honored and wise men in Noah's generation against the warning of the flood, insisting the Maker would never destroy His creatures, bidding the people be at peace and fear not while mocking Noah and continuing as though God had not spoken.PP 96.1
Tempter Method and Fall
To back the denial the tempter claimed he himself had eaten the forbidden fruit and thereby gained the power of speech, argued that eating could no more bring death than merely touching, and argued death was impossible because they had already eaten of the tree of life.Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–11Lt 245a, 1903, par. 29–311SP 37.2PP 54.1–2 He presented the divine warning as an empty threat meant only to frighten and keep them from greater knowledge, power and happiness, and offered his own speech and experience as supposed proof the fruit was harmless.Ms 140, 1903, par. 10–111SP 37.2PP 54.1–2 Eve felt no immediate sign of displeasure, but that did not make the claim true.1SP 37.2
Eve erred first in wandering from her husband and being alone when angels had cautioned her not to separate in daily labor, for with him she would be in less danger; absorbed in her pleasing task she unconsciously left his side, felt apprehension, then dismissed fear deciding she had wisdom and strength enough to discern evil and withstand it.PP 53.5SG1 20.2 Lingering around the forbidden tree, gazing with mingled curiosity and admiration on its beautiful fruit, questioning why it was withheld, listening to the tempter's musical voice and subtle praise of her loveliness, and entering into controversy instead of fleeing, she gave him his opportunity.PP 53.5ST Feb 13, 1896 She had no thought the fascinating serpent could be the medium of the fallen foe, wrongly regarded him as a friend concerned for her welfare, and dared to doubt whether the word about death meant just as spoken.PP 53.5SG3 42.2SG1 20.2 In answering she even added a prohibition against touching which had not been given.ST Feb 13, 1896
She would have been safe had she refused to argue and parley, defended the truth, sought her husband, and turned to her Maker for help.4SP 351.2–352.1SG3 42.2 Resistance would have brought help, driven the accuser away, and preserved integrity, for the test was mild and she had no need of that tree.ST May 12, 1890 The same pattern is still repeated when people doubt and argue about requirements and accept human theories that disguise the same devices.4SP 351.2–352.1
Willing to listen, she first doubted the word, then received the lying sophistry as very wise, coveted what was forbidden above all others, longed for independence to be a law to herself with no restraint, mistrusted goodness despite abundance of life, garden, beauty and pleasant employment, forgot great love, and deemed God selfish, unkind, unjust and unnecessarily restricting liberty and advancement.Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33RH Feb 24, 1874ST Feb 13, 1896SG3 43.1 The denial glossed truth with falsehood to make transgression appear a real blessing, charging that the most desirable tree was forbidden for its delicious flavor and exhilarating influence to keep them in subordination and withhold knowledge which is power.Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33RH Feb 24, 1874 Curiosity was excited to pry into unsearchable plans and reason about the cause of the restriction, the very course that had ruined the rebel himself.SG1 19.1EW 117.2
Believing, she put forth her hand, took and ate finding it pleasing to the eye and pleasant to the taste, expressed astonishment at the serpent's speech, told Adam all that had been said, and gave to him.Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33RH Feb 24, 1874SG1 20.2 Adam was not deceived as she was, but being tempted by his wife, moved by love and seeing her apparently unchanged, he also ate and both disobeyed and fell.Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11ST Nov 18, 19131SP 37.2 Through her influence he accepted the claim that what was said about death was not meant, and together they distrusted their Creator, forfeited favor, and opened the floodgates of woe, ruin, expulsion, curse and guilt upon the world.4SP 351.2–352.1GC88 531.1–532.1Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33Ms 104, 1893, par. 10–14Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11
No immediate harm appeared; Eve felt a pleasurable exhilaration and no ill effect, and Adam saw her unchanged, so experience seemed to confirm the lie and proved stronger in their minds than the express word.CTBH 42.1–3RH Feb 24, 1874SG3 41.1ST Jan 23, 1879 Because she showed no immediate sign of death Adam entertained the denial, allowed himself to be led by that experience, and ate too.CTBH 42.1–3ST Jan 23, 1879ST Nov 18, 1913 Yet consequences still follow though judgment is delayed.CTBH 42.1–31SP 37.2
There was nothing harmful or poisonous in the fruit itself; the danger was in listening and venturing to break the single test of loyalty, obedience, faith and love.Ms 10, 1894, par. 2–3Ms 21, 1898, par. 29–33 The tree stood near the tree of life in the midst of the garden as the indispensable condition of existence, with free permission to eat of every other tree and prohibition of this one on pain of death, with promise that endurance under exposure to temptation would place them finally beyond the tempter's power in perpetual favor. Even violating one seemingly small command was grave sin, though resistance was possible.ST Jun 18, 1894ST May 12, 1890
The method was subtle cunning and deceit rather than force, making a lie appear a very desirable fact by denial joined to promise, bearing false witness against the Creator while exalting self.Ms 145, 1897, par. 2–421MR 193.2–41SP 31.1–32.2 Its instruments were flattery, envy, distrust, questioning and unbelief, offering forbidden speculative knowledge as improvement of condition though gaining it required disobedience.RH Aug 4, 19105T 502.2RH Aug 4, 1910 The same subtle argument still deceives.Ms 145, 1897, par. 2–421MR 193.2–4
Shut out of heaven with no return to favor, the adversary deliberately planned destruction by leading them to disobedience, consulting with his angels, taking another form and feigning interest in man.SG1 19.1EW 117.2 He could take no happiness nor exercise power while they obeyed, so they had to be made to forfeit favor, incur the frown, and come under his direct influence and jurisdiction that he might gain supremacy over the race and carry on earth the rebellion begun in heaven by declaring the law could not be obeyed.SG1 19.1EW 117.2 To that end he struck at truthfulness by creating doubt whether what was said about death was meant, then excited curious reasoning.SG1 19.1EW 117.2
Having overcome the first parents by shaking confidence, doubting wisdom and justice, and shifting his own cruelty upon the Father, he exulted in the ruin wrought.4SP 354.1–3 He lures from allegiance by contrasting bondage under stern decrees with liberty under his own mild sway, still seeking today to tempt to sin and then destroy if he can.4SP 354.1–3
Results and False Covering
The promised opening of the eyes proved true only in bringing discernment of folly, guilt, shame and ruin, knowledge of evil and bitter taste of transgression, loss of innocence and of the garments of light and presence that had enveloped them, nakedness, hiding from the Creator's voice in the garden, and expectation of condemnation never known before.Ms 145, 1897, par. 2–421MR 193.2–4ST Feb 13, 1896ST May 29, 1901 Believing the denial that disobedience would not bring death led both to eat and to gain a knowledge they would never have had in obedience, an experience in disobedience and disloyalty in which they knew they were naked because innocence and surrounding light from God had departed.Ms 145, 1897, par. 2–421MR 193.2–4ST Feb 13, 1896 Adam afterward learned that death meant return to the ground whence he was taken as dust, exposing as false the claim that God did not mean what He said.
Their sewing of fig leaves into aprons represents the arguments transgressors of God's law have used ever since to cover the nakedness caused by sin, a covering still made whenever truth calls attention to disobedience in order to hide the nakedness of the soul.Ms 145, 1897, par. 2–421MR 193.2–4 Believing the words put Adam and Eve on Satan's side, for the denial that disobedience would bring death appealed to pride by promising exaltation and escape from death apart from the way pointed out in the Scriptures.Lt 25, 1904, par. 17Lt 23, 1904, par. 16–18ST Jun 14, 1905 That pride shows itself in unwillingness to be accounted as nothing and to recognize Christ as the only One who can save to the uttermost all who accept Him, seeking salvation and a way other than God devised.Lt 25, 1904, par. 17Lt 23, 1904, par. 16–18ST Jun 14, 1905
The verse belongs to temptation to seek forbidden knowledge, presenting disobedience as a blessing that would bring wisdom, power, greater happiness and a higher existence, while hiding that transgression had made the tempter an outcast from heaven.5T 503.3ED 24.1–25T 502.2 The lie concealed itself beneath apparent truth, offering a supposed improvement of condition through speculative knowledge whose gaining required disobedience, and leading to distrust of God's wisdom and casting away of faith.ED 24.1–25T 502.2RH Aug 4, 1910 Instead of gaining knowledge that brings lasting joy they gained only acquaintance with sin and its results, disloyalty, estrangement of humanity from God and separation of earth from heaven, loss of Eden, and knowledge God never intended them to have which ends in eternal death.5T 503.35T 504.28T 290.1–3 Obeying God's requirements in Jesus' strength keeps people from that knowledge.5T 504.2
Speaking through the serpent the verse lied against God and bore false witness about the Creator while exalting the tempter in preference to God, with a seductive voice that allured the mind.MWISDAP 53.2STB 396.2–3 Although Adam had walked and talked with God and God in foreknowledge and providence could have kept and directed them if they had heeded the warning against evil, they allowed themselves to be beguiled and believed the false statements.STB 396.2–3 Their minds, though divinely created and sinless, came under the working of another power and were so fully seduced that they could no longer discern the power leading them into apostasy, showing that the same seducing power still works human minds into apostasy and loss of discernment.MWISDAP 53.2STB 396.2–3 Choosing the deceiver instead of God, who is truth, brought loss, confused the mind, weakened mental and spiritual powers, and made people unable to appreciate God's gifts.ED 25.3
Their listening and disobedience brought a curse upon nature, so the created world thereafter testified imperfectly about its Creator and could not reveal His character in perfection.8T 255.3–256.1 Evil, sin and death did not come from God but resulted from disobedience, with the knowledge of evil entering the world through that deception.5T 503.3
Immortality Lie Refuted
“Ye shall not surely die” was the first lie ever uttered, Satan’s direct contradiction of God’s warning spoken to Eve through the serpent, assuring her she was created immortal and could not die even in disobedience.RH Sep 11, 19162RED 9.2–10.1Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11RH Feb 24, 1874LC1 113.2 It was his first lesson on natural immortality, teaching that humans cannot die and that sinners live on, resting on the claim that God had withheld the fruit to keep them from gaining knowledge and becoming as gods knowing good and evil.2RED 9.2–10.1Ms 51, 1890, par. 3–9RH Feb 24, 1874SG1 113.2EW 182.1 Eve received that sophistry as very wise, longing for the fruit above all others and finding no immediate harm in touching and eating, then giving also to her husband and trading happiness in ignorance of sin for degradation, sin and guilt.Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11RH Feb 24, 1874 That temptation opened the floodgates to the world, so that all deceptions, prevarications and misrepresentations are comprised in it, and yielding even in little things entraps as birds in the snare of the fowler.Ms 56, 1897, par. 7–11
After eating they would have become immortal sinners by eating also of the tree of life, so God drove them from Eden and guarded its way lest they perpetuate life in sin.EW 103.2SG1 113.2EW 182.1 The flaming sword placed around the tree of life, which alone could perpetuate immortality, proves the denial false, for not one of Adam’s family has passed that sword and eaten.SG1 113.2GC88 533.2–534.3EW 182.1 There is therefore not an immortal sinner in existence, and the teaching contradicts God’s declaration that the sinner dies.SG1 113.2GC88 533.2–534.3EW 182.1 The soul that sins dies an everlasting death that lasts forever with no hope of resurrection, and then the wrath of God is appeased.SG1 113.2EW 182.1 Immortality is an attribute of God alone, and the word of God nowhere teaches that the human soul is immortal, though popular ministers reiterate the lie from the pulpit and the people receive it as pure Bible truth.SG4 259.3–260.2
From that immortality lie came belief that the sinner will live in eternal misery, the teaching of an eternally burning hell and the invention of purgatory.Ms 51, 1890, par. 3–9SG1 113.2GC88 533.2–534.3EW 183.1 Satan commanded his angels to make special effort to spread the deception that man is immortal, and once received it prepares the way to hold up God as a revengeful tyrant who plunges all who do not please Him into hell to ever feel His wrath while they writhe in eternal flames and He looks down with satisfaction.4SP 354.1–3EW 183.1 These teachings falsify the character of God to make Him appear severe, revengeful, arbitrary and unforgiving, clothing Him with Satan’s own cruelty, hiding Satan’s agency, depriving humanity of divine strength and making people dupes and subjects of satanic agencies.Ms 51, 1890, par. 3–94SP 354.1–3 They cause God to be hated by many instead of loved and admired, and lead many to believe the threatenings of His word will not be literally fulfilled because to plunge created beings into eternal torments would be against His benevolence and love, when God is love and all He created was pure, holy and lovely until sin was brought in by the first great rebel.4SP 354.1–3EW 183.1
The denial of death laid the groundwork for Spiritualism as Satan’s masterpiece of deception, developed little by little through history toward full accomplishment in the last remnant of time.RH Sep 11, 1916GC88 561.2GC 561.2–562.1ST Dec 8, 19094SP 379.1 That long-prepared final effort will sweep the whole world except those kept by the power of God through faith in His Word into delusion, lulling them to a fatal security to be awakened only by the outpouring of the wrath of God, until God lays judgment to the line and sweeps away the refuge of lies.RH Sep 11, 1916GC 561.2–562.1ST Dec 8, 19094SP 379.1 The lie is perpetuated in the last days bound up in corrupt harmony under a corrupt leader with the fallen churches that rejected light, the papal man of sin presenting a rival sabbath, and the apostate Protestant power with two horns like a lamb speaking as a dragon, all blessed by Satan personating Christ, while the only hope is the remnant who keep the word of Christ’s patience and refuse to worship the beast and his image.Ms 16, 1884, par. 3–4 The same lie is the foundation of pretended communion with the dead and of ancient worship of the dead, but familiar spirits are not the spirits of dead people but evil angels, the messengers of Satan continuing the same deception, so that supposed worship of dead men and fellowship with them is in reality worship of demons and fellowship with devils.PP 685.4
Law Sabbath and Judgment
The same denial that divine threatenings only frighten was repeated by great, worldly, honored and wise men, men of science and philosophy, in Noah's generation against the warning of the Flood.PP 96.1ST Sep 8, 1881 It taught that God's threatenings of punishment for transgression are only to intimidate and will never be carried out, so there is no need to be alarmed or to fear.PP 96.1ST Sep 8, 1881 Applied to the Flood it taught that the God who made the world would never destroy the world by water and never punish the beings He created, because that is not in accordance with science and philosophy, but that people should be at peace and fear not.PP 96.1ST Sep 8, 1881 While the world was arrayed against God's justice and laws, Noah was mocked as crazy and a wild fanatic, and people continued in disobedience and wickedness as though God had not spoken.PP 96.1ST Sep 8, 1881
The same deceiving power that tempted Eve tempts people today to set aside God's holy seventh-day Sabbath hallowed at creation, sustained by the manna, and placed in the bosom of the Decalogue, and to substitute Sunday as a spurious first-day sabbath exalted by the man of sin to lead the world into rebellion and obliterate God's distinguishing sign.Ms 104, 1893, par. 10–14Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12 The lie presents God as too kind to punish disobedience and gives a false excuse to break His law while claiming to be sinless, and Eve's response warns against trusting that excuse, since genuine sanctification comes only through obedience to God's truth and commandments.BS 56.1–57.1 Satan has kept up the same deceptive work upon human minds from that day to this, gaining control of every mind that receives his lies, leading people to refuse God's Word as it reads and choose his lies rather than a Thus saith the Lord, and urging them by religious teaching into disregard and decided transgression of the fourth commandment.Ms 19, 1894, par. 10–12 That same lie that transgressing God's law will not bring death but will make transgressors as gods knowing good and evil is voiced by ministers who disregard God's claim and uphold the first day as the Sabbath, teaching by influence and example that God's law can be broken and causing a lie to be received as truth.Lt 24b, 1896, par. 1–4
Adam and Eve's venturing to take the forbidden fruit seemed simple and unworthy of notice yet brought bitter experience with awful consequences: the fall, expulsion from Eden and loss of Eden, and the opening of the floodgates of woe to the world.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6 Their punishment shows God as severe and exacting against disobedience, not merciful in the sense of excusing sin, and proves mercy does not cover or lessen guilt while sin is continued.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Lt 6, 1880, par. 60–63 Justice and mercy go hand in hand, mercy covering guilt only after sin is repented of and forsaken, and God's gift of His Son to die to pay the debt of transgression and save the fallen race exalts the sacred character of God's law instead of excusing its breach.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6 Sinners still practice iniquity because they flatter themselves that the sword of justice will never be raised against them and ease their consciences into carnal security, when in truth God is a God of justice who will visit workers of iniquity with retributive judgments.Lt 6, 1880, par. 60–63
By contrast the verse warns that sin brings death, that God's justice does not fail, and that He means what He says and requires strict obedience to His commandments.4T 11.3ST May 29, 19015T 365.2 The denial bred distrust of the Creator as restricting liberty and imagined that transgression would bring great light and freedom and entrance into a more exalted state, but the claim proved false. Adam learned after sin that death meant return to the ground whence he was taken as dust, and the promised opening of eyes proved true only in opening eyes to discern folly, to know evil, to taste the bitter fruit of transgression, to see shame and ruin, to know nakedness as the result of transgression with the covering of heavenly light gone, to hide from the voice of the Creator in the garden, and to expect divine condemnation never known before.ST May 29, 1901 Despite the example of Adam's disobedience and its results bringing woe upon the world, that same denial has sounded from generation to generation, tempting people today as it tempted Adam and Eve, so that men and women fall into the snare and by thought and act spread the impression that God does not mean what He says.ST May 29, 19015T 365.2
The same temptation Satan employed in Eden, questioning God's words joined to the flattering inducement that eyes shall be opened and men shall be as gods, exalting man and placing him where God should be, is the temptation he employs today as the alpha and omega of so-called higher science theories to lead into disobedience and make truth of no effect and prevent oneness with Christ in doing God's will.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 The lie is perpetuated in the last days bound up in corrupt harmony under a corrupt leader with the fallen churches that rejected light, the papal man of sin presenting a rival sabbath, and the apostate Protestant power with two horns like a lamb speaking as a dragon, all blessed by Satan personating Christ, while the only hope is the remnant who keep the word of Christ's patience and refuse to worship the beast and his image.Ms 16, 1884, par. 3–4 It was the great original lie and first sermon ever preached on the immortality of the soul, teaching that sin would not bring death and man is naturally immortal, crowned with success with terrible results, and minds have been brought to receive that sermon as truth while ministers preach it, sing it, and pray it.SG4 258.2SG4 259.3–260.2 The word of God nowhere teaches that the human soul is immortal, for immortality is an attribute of God alone, yet what popular ministers reiterate from the pulpit is received as pure Bible truth, and because they have trampled truth underfoot and preferred fables they have nothing to shield their flocks from the baleful influence of Spiritualism founded on that lie.SG4 259.3–260.2
The lie denies that sin brings death and sets Satan's word against God's word that the soul that sins shall die, making sin agreeable, keeping souls from coming back to allegiance in keeping His commandments, and leading the impenitent transgressor to choose continued sin rather than obedience.Ms 25, 1887, par. 8–9 It gives the false assurance that sin is harmless and that God will accept disobedience, and it is believed because the natural perverted heart loves the lie more than the truth.Ms 25, 1887, par. 8–9ST Dec 15, 1887 The verse is thus used to mean disobedience is safe and carries no penalty, a lie voiced by ministers who disregard God's claim and uphold the first day of the week as the Sabbath.Lt 24b, 1896, par. 1–4
Christ Appetite and Obedience
The fall through indulgence of appetite proves that the only hope of regaining Eden is through firm denial of appetite and passion.SG4 120.23T 139.1–2RH Jun 22, 1916 Eve had every fruit freely given to make her happy, yet the forbidden fruit appeared more desirable, she was intemperate in desire, she ate and through her influence her husband ate also, and a curse rested upon them both and upon the earth because of their sin.SG4 120.2 The same beguiling has continued since the fall, with the human family following Eve in disobedience, letting appetite control reason, disregarding prohibitions, violating the laws of health and running to excess in almost everything, so that disease has steadily increased as effect follows cause.SG4 120.23T 139.1–2 That decline from a high, holy and happy condition came through human choices and violations of law, not through Providence.3T 139.1–2 Abstemiousness in diet and control of all the passions preserves the intellect and gives mental and moral vigor, bringing the propensities under control of the higher powers so men can discern between right and wrong, the sacred and the common.RH Jun 22, 1916 Christ left His home in heaven to come to this world to show by His own life how man can resist temptation, and all who truly sense that sacrifice will cheerfully deny self and choose to be partakers with Him of His sufferings.RH Jun 22, 1916
The same enticement still fastens perverted appetite on men through tobacco.Lt 8, 1893, par. 6 Satan exults in tempting appetite because tobacco paralyzes the sensitive nerves of the brain, palsies the brain and confuses the judgment so that sacred things are not discerned.Lt 8, 1893, par. 6 Once the narcotic appetite is formed it takes firm hold of the mind and will, bringing bondage in which Satan controls the will, eternal realities are eclipsed, man cannot stand forth in his God-given manhood but is a slave to perverted appetite, and his steps tend toward perdition and not heavenward.Lt 8, 1893, par. 6 Accepting the denial that disobedience brings death was the beginning of disobedience and transgression in this world, disobedience to express command that gave a knowledge of guilt not intended for man and opened the floodgates of woe upon the world.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24Ms 25, 1887, par. 8–9 It is questioning of the divine word joined to flattering inducement that eyes shall be opened and men shall be as gods, exalting man and placing him where God should be.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24 By that lie sin is made agreeable, truth is made of no effect, souls are kept from coming back to allegiance in keeping the commandments and from oneness in doing the divine will, and the impenitent transgressor is led to choose continued sin rather than obedience, because the perverted natural heart loves the lie more than the truth.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24Ms 25, 1887, par. 8–9
Satan has continued the work commenced in Eden, working vigilantly to lead men to accept his assertions as proof against God, working against Christ in His effort to restore the image of God in man and imprint the divine similitude in his soul, even through so-called higher science theories of which he is alpha and omega.Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24 There was nothing harmful in the fruit itself; the danger was in listening to Satan and venturing to break the single mild test of loyalty and obedience, leaving the choice of whom to believe, God who declares death as the penalty or Satan who denies it.Ms 10, 1894, par. 2–3 Christ did not come to abolish the law Adam transgressed, and He could not simply change one precept to meet fallen man; His leaving heaven and becoming poor to give man another test of loyalty was not made to let sin live forever.Ms 10, 1894, par. 2–3 Through the alluring flattery to rise above the sphere of humanity instead of obeying as men within their humanity, man lost the original mind given in Eden, showing disobedience contrary to the nature given in Eden, while Christ restores obedience by becoming man and mediating between man and God.Ms 16, 1897, par. 23–24Lt 121, 1897, par. 3–4 Adam's transgression brought sin into the world and serves as a warning against disobeying God, yet people continue to violate the commands and repeat the fall through their own choices.2RED 74.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
261 sources
The serpent directly denied God's warning that eating from the forbidden tree would bring certain death, insisting that disobedience would not bring death at all.ST Mar 3, 1914ST Feb 15, 1905ST Feb 5, 1885 It was the first lie spoken on earth and the origin of the false teaching that human beings possess natural inherent immortality and live on consciously after death.ST Feb 5, 1885ST Jun 6, 1900ST Apr 9, 1912 The account is literal history of the creation and fall involving a real serpent, garden, tree and disobedience, not allegory or myth.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 28, 1881ST Jan 3, 1911 By denying the penalty of death it undermines salvation through Christ, the resurrection, the second coming and the judgment, and became the root of eternal torment, purgatory, and salvation apart from Christ's atonement.RH May 27, 1915ST Aug 28, 1884ST Feb 6, 1893 Immortality belongs to God alone and eternal life is only His gift through Christ at the resurrection, while sinful humanity incurred complete death and returns to dust until then.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Feb 1, 1883ST Feb 19, 1902ST Jun 2, 1898RH Nov 12, 1872
Denial and Immortal Lie
The serpent's words are a direct denial of God's warning that eating from the tree of knowledge would bring certain death, asserting instead that the transgressors would not die at all.ST Mar 3, 1914ST Jan 14, 1875RH Apr 7, 1868RH Jun 20, 1907RH Aug 3, 1876 The Hebrew form of God's warning intensifies certainty by repeating the verb for dying, and the serpent contradicts it outright in order to lead into sin by promising escape from its consequence and even gain from it.ST Feb 5, 1885RH Apr 7, 1868RH Aug 3, 1876 That denial was the first deliberate lie uttered on earth, making true the description of the devil as a liar and murderer from the beginning, since by it death came upon the whole human race.ST Jan 14, 1875ST Dec 17, 1874ST
The verse is the origin and first promulgation of the doctrine of natural inherent immortality, the claim that the soul cannot die but survives consciously apart from the body.ST Feb 5, 1885ST Aug 26, 1880ST Jun 6, 1900ST Apr 9, 1912RH Jun 20, 1907 It is the clearest, most direct and concise statement of that doctrine to be found in Scripture, and indeed the only apparent biblical support for it, while many other texts directly oppose it.ST Feb 15, 1905ST Apr 9, 1912 As taught there, dying does not bring real death because human beings possess within themselves an independent life principle, a secret something immune to death that makes them akin to the divine and immortal apart from God.ST Apr 9, 1912ST Believing it placed humanity on the side of heaven's enemies, and the same falsehood has ever since been the belief of heathen nations and the effective instrument of deception down to the present.ST Feb 15, 1905ST Jun 6, 1900
The account is literal history of creation and fall, not allegory, tradition, poem, or fictional story to be interpreted rationally and spiritually.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 28, 1881ST Jan 3, 1911ST Apr 7, 1914 A literal serpent spoke the words in a literal garden involving a literal tree and literal fruit, and Jesus treated the account as literal history so that belief in Genesis is bound to belief in Him.ST Sep 20, 1899RH Dec 14, 1905 To treat it as invented undermines confidence in Moses' account and the credibility of his writings, and rejecting that scriptural foundation belongs to the Higher Criticism that rejects other Bible teachings, alongside Darwinism and evolution.RH Sep 11, 1916ST Jul 28, 1881ST Jan 3, 1911
The lie undermines salvation through Christ by making the resurrection, second coming, and future judgment seem unnecessary, teaching that people receive reward at death and can communicate as the so-called dead with the so-called living.ST Aug 28, 1884ST Feb 6, 1893ST Sep 24, 1894ST Feb 1, 1883 Received as pleasant truth it becomes the last great delusion threatening to swamp the world, hindered by nothing but the plain truths of God's word repeated again and again.RH Sep 11, 1916ST Aug 28, 1884 It is the root and seed of eternal torment in conscious misery, purgatory, saint-worship and Mariolatry, prayers and masses for the dead, intercession of saints, demon-worship, heathen mythology, transmigration of souls, universal salvation, and doctrines and practices relying on human merit or supplementing Christ's saving work.RH Apr 7, 1868ST Feb 6, 1893ST Nov 15, 1910ST Sep 24, 1894 It is the doctrine of Lucifer, opposite to true godlikeness, since selfish ambition and self-seeking exaltation to godlike status are Satan's defining attributes, not God's.RH May 27, 1915
Human beings were created able to receive immortality by obedience or lose life by disobedience, and after sin they incurred death, lost access to the tree of life lest sinful existence live forever, and returned to dust.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Jun 12, 1879ST Dec 9, 1880 Death is complete loss of life, thought and knowledge until God gives life again, for the life given was not a separate heavenly being dwelling in the body but life itself taken back into God's keeping at death.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Jul 30, 1912ST Dec 9, 1880 The serpent's assurance was proved false because Eve and Adam did die, and the belief in an immortal part surviving death was invented to make his words appear true.ST Feb 1, 1883ST Jul 30, 1912 Immortality belongs to God alone and must be sought and received as His gift through Jesus Christ, coming to the righteous only through righteousness by faith at Christ's coming and through resurrection, with the second Adam alone able to give life that never ends.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Feb 1, 1883ST Jun 12, 1879ST
Doctrines taking the serpent's side against the Bible entered the church after the apostles through the great apostasy and falling away from the faith to seducing spirits.ST Jun 11, 1912RH Aug 26, 1862 Together with the companion claim that human beings can become as God by a power within themselves, the denial of death forms one of two doctrines of demons set forth at the beginning of the Bible, leading away from utter and absolute dependence upon the Lord Jesus Christ for salvation.ST Jun 11, 1912 The lie proves its speaker had already apostatized and fallen from heaven before tempting the woman, placing his fall immediately after creation was finished and at the beginning of this world.ST Dec 17, 1874ST Dec 17, 1874 Through tempting and causing humanity to fall Satan gained possession of the earth, the inheritance given to Adam passing into his hands until Christ redeems it, as he continues on earth the warfare over God's commandments begun in heaven in order to persecute humanity and make others miserable.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Dec 17, 1874ST Jan 17, 1878
Eden Test and Deception
The denial belongs to the Eden test in which loyalty was proved by refraining from one tree, with life promised for obedience and death threatened for disobedience.ST Feb 6, 1893ST May 4, 1904RH Aug 22, 1854RH Nov 22, 1906 That test bore directly on appetite, for uprightness of body comes only by obeying the laws of health in eating, dressing and breathing according to divine principles, uprightness of mind by Christian education, and uprightness of soul by feeding upon God's word. Adam was created in the image of God and upright in body, in mind and in soul, and the whole gospel hidden in that Eden history is the restoration of that image in humanity by leading children to live these truths. When the serpent denied that following their own way would bring death, the first humans believed it and joined to it the promise of becoming like God and knowing good and evil, gaining knowledge of evil and thereafter unable to find goodness by looking within.ST May 4, 1904 By yielding, man became servant to the evil one who entered Eden, the earth came under a curse, and the denial became the foundation for the doctrine of the soul's inherent immortality and for Spiritualism identified with ancient sorcery and necromancy, undermining salvation through Christ by making resurrection and future judgment seem unnecessary.ST Feb 6, 1893
The serpent was Satan's medium contradicting God's exact warning in Genesis 2:17 that disobedience would bring certain death, raising a question of veracity between God and Satan.ST Feb 19, 1902RH Nov 12, 1872RH Oct 8, 1872 It was a deliberate lie told with knowledge of its falsehood, pressed upon the mind not that Eve might think as the tempter thought but that she might think as he wanted her to think, leaving her hypnotized and enslaved to his will.ST Feb 19, 1902 Its aim is to enslave to his own will every soul induced to yield to lying suggestion, opposite to God who would establish people in truth as He sees it to serve Him freely, gladly, with unchained will, with escape only through the truth by the Son making the captive truly free.ST Feb 19, 1902 Its meaning is that the dead do not die but live on consciously in indestructible personality near the living and can be sent back to appear to them, as claimed in the sending of dead Samuel to wicked Saul, and that eating brings not death but freedom from the mortal body into enlarged higher life as gods.ST Jun 2, 1898RH Nov 12, 1872 That teaching nullifies God's penalty and leaves no real death of the whole man, continuing in heathen deification and worship of dead heroes and in the modern claim that there is no death but transition, so that amid the daily throng passing through death men still believe the father of lies that death does not exist.ST Jun 2, 1898RH Nov 12, 1872 It is the foundation of the theory that man is immortal and cannot die and that death is unreal and humanity needs no resurrection, which would make Christ's resurrection of no interest or importance, against which stands the truth that resurrection to everlasting life is of transcendent importance to be sought at cost of all; the doctrine of separate existence of an immortal soul was invented to sustain the first lie, for if man had never sinned he would have reached the immortal state without seeing death and the idea would never have existed, and when all that is outward, tangible and visible falls in death the untruth would be apparent without belief in an invisible medium of continued life.ST Apr 8, 1903RH Oct 8, 1872ST Oct 22, 1894 The entire hope of the dead rests instead in resurrection at the second coming of Christ, met only by the truth of the Word of God and the second-advent hope that the dead know not anything.ST Jun 2, 1898
Joined to the promise of becoming like gods, the denial overcame man as a free moral agent on probation to disobey God's holy law, take the forbidden fruit, commit sin and fall completely lost and sold into Satan's hands with all creation endowments, so that the Son of man must come to save, recreate and restore to original Edenic purity.ST Apr 21, 1898ST Mar 11, 1897ST Oct 22, 1894 Yielding perverted the natural powers and faculties given by the Creator so that the race since is easily led into sinful indulgence, and while being tempted does not make a person evil, yielding makes a person subject to Satan's control as long as sinful practice is continued.ST Apr 21, 1898 The work is ruin by hypocrisy, deception and fraud, proving lying deception the chief way evil spirits destroy human beings, in opposition to God's truth as the source of error.RH Sep 7, 1869ST Oct 11, 1877 It began by implying God was deceiving Adam and Eve, making God responsible for the existence and continuation of sin, which is the beginning of the sinner's favorite pretext of blaming God from which all animosity toward God and His Word comes.ST Mar 10, 1898 The same plausible manner keeps the language of what God has said while denying its practical working and operation, agreeing with God's word in word while rejecting its real fulfillment, as repeated by those who say the gifts of the Spirit and of prophecy are right to the close of time yet deny their actual operation, as the Jews held the Messiah in prophecy right yet rejected the true Saviour at the first advent.RH Dec 19, 1865
First Lie Against God
The same denial that disobedience would not bring death is still used to make alcohol, narcotics and sin appear harmless by promising added life through transgression, and Eve's brief decision to believe it opened the fall through which sin entered the world and brought immeasurable suffering, proving that sincerity does not remove guilt or consequence.ST Mar 24, 1881ST Aug 17, 1915RH Dec 10, 1861ST Jun 6, 1878 That denial was one of the agencies set in operation to defeat the eternal purpose revealed in Genesis 1 and 3, an opposition that goes down in eternal ruin when the purpose is completed with God's dwelling with men, all tears wiped away, death as the last enemy destroyed, and all things in heaven and on earth gathered together in Christ.ST Aug 17, 1915RH Dec 10, 1861ST Jun 6, 1878 By it man did not continue in uprightness but apostatized, fell under the power of the enemy, lost Paradise, was excluded from the tree of life, brought God's curse upon the earth, and brought death in by sin to pass upon all men.ST Mar 24, 1881RH Dec 10, 1861ST Jun 6, 1878 It carried from heaven to Eden a self-serving confederation movement put forward under plea of the good of God's subjects in order to gain monopoly control of His kingdom, exalt a rival throne above God and be like the Most High.ST Aug 17, 1915 It means the first parents fell by reaching to be like God by their own effort instead of recognizing they were already made in His likeness, and by that effort lost that likeness, raising the old question of supremacy over who is God and rightful King and who shall be worshiped and served, which comes to its climax just before the second coming in the choice between worshiping the Creator and worshiping the beast and his image, and which is answered by the gospel of the kingdom teaching the supremacy of God as Creator-King and restoring fallen man through the Son of God in the flesh to likeness to God.ST Aug 17, 1915ST Mar 26, 1902
The fall violated God's moral law from the beginning, which proves the law existed from the beginning and that the tempter sinning from the beginning is the first or father of sinners.RH May 26, 1853ST Mar 30, 1915 Eve was tempted with becoming like gods by eating the forbidden fruit, Adam was not deceived but knowingly chose to follow his wife rather than obey God, and both choices violated the first commandment.RH May 26, 1853 The breaking of the tenth commandment in Genesis 3:1-6 shows the ten precepts of the Decalogue were known and could be violated before they were spoken from Sinai.RH May 26, 1853ST Mar 30, 1915 That transgression came by covetousness, which is selfishness as inordinate love for what is thought to bring profit and pleasure and desire to gratify self regardless of others' rights, appealing to the lust of the flesh, the lust of the eyes and the pride of life, so the tenth commandment was transgressed before any other, making Adam and Eve's sin the earthly parallel to Satan's fall in heaven and the same ruling spirit that rules all sinful men.ST Mar 30, 1915 The serpent's denial that disobedience would bring death implied God's warning was only meant to frighten, claimed eating would open their eyes and raise them to higher knowledge and existence while suggesting God withheld it from jealousy, and because Eve showed no immediate sign of death Adam entertained the denial and ate also.ST Nov 18, 1913 The deception was carried out by the Devil through the serpent, which had held a position above the other animals but had its powers taken away as judgment for being so used, and the curse in Genesis 3:15 moves from the literal serpent to the Devil whom it represented.ST Nov 18, 1913RH May 26, 1853
The verse promised great gain and godlike knowledge through forbidden experience, assuring that disobedience could occur without suffering death, as illustrated when desire to know both good and evil led on to grief and sorrow.ST Feb 26, 1885RH Jan 12, 1869RH Dec 1, 1863 Its lie, thou shalt not die, caused the first disobedience and left man seeing only a broken law whose penalty demanded the life of those refusing obedience, with no way back to allegiance, claiming the sinner shall not die contrary to God's word that the sinner shall die.ST Feb 26, 1885RH Jan 12, 1869RH Dec 1, 1863 By denying death it teaches natural immortality, which is the doctrine of devils to seduce in the latter days, against which mercy provides remedy in Jesus the Saviour who saves from sin and releases from death.RH Dec 1, 1863ST May 20, 1908ST Feb 20, 1893 It contradicts God's warning that disobedience brings death, yet the penalty was not revoked though its execution was stayed so people could accept reconciliation through the Messiah, for death means passing from an animate to a lifeless state, ceasing to live and losing vital functions completely and irreparably, and those rejecting Him will ultimately perish.ST Feb 26, 1885RH Dec 1, 1863ST May 20, 1908 That first lie is a dangerous deception that would become a final overpowering delusion, denying that the dead are truly dead contrary to David's statement that the dead do not praise the Lord, deceiving Eve unto loss of Eden, teaching by Spiritualism the same false promise of continued life after death, and leading to the sin, sorrow, pain and death experienced by mortals whose eyes were opened only to shame, nakedness and ruin, while the same denial has spread generation to generation that God does not mean what He says.ST Feb 26, 1885RH Jan 12, 1869ST May 20, 1908ST Feb 20, 1893RH May 29, 1855
The lie flourishes among apostates and heathen, treats the serpent as truthful, obscures the resurrection, and will at last control those whose names are not written in the book of life.ST Jun 14, 1905RH Apr 8, 1909ST Feb 10, 1887RH Aug 12, 1862 It began as the first parliament of religions held in Eden near the sources of the Euphrates, a summer school of religious philosophy where the best people on earth discussed the veracity of Jehovah, in which the serpent as a great intellect promised intellectual growth and his higher-critical denial of God's word prevailed and would at once have replaced the ancient creed of the race, except the owner of the park refused to tolerate the parliament on the premises and drove it out.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Feb 10, 1887 It expresses the doctrine of natural immortality of the soul as the essence of Spiritualism, able to take many appealing forms and deceive, and as the great lie that human beings are already immortal and cannot die it will be promoted through Spiritualism and woven into Protestant politics as foundation of a coming system of government.RH Apr 8, 1909RH Aug 12, 1862 It entered Christian teaching through Platonic philosophy and helped turn expectation of Christ's coming from joyful hope into dread by associating it with endless torment for the world.RH Apr 8, 1909RH Aug 12, 1862 By appealing to human pride in denying that disobedience brings death it led Adam and Eve to place themselves on Satan's side and seek a way other than God's way, while traditions of a primal age of purity, the origin of evil, the serpent, the tree of life and the promise of redemption remain as dispersed and distorted memories of the Eden fall and its truths.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Nov 13, 1893ST Feb 10, 1887
Sources