John 7:19
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you keepeth the law? Why go ye about to kill me?
Translations
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you keeps the law? Why go you about to kill me?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you keepeth the law? Why go ye about to kill me?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Did not Moses give you the law, and yet none of you doeth the law? Why seek ye to kill me?
hath not Moses given you the law? and none of you doth the law; why me do ye seek to kill?'
Has not Moses given you the law, and no one of you practises the law? Why do ye seek to kill me?
Did not, Moses, give you the law? And yet, not one of you, doeth the law!—Why, seek ye, to slay, me?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Has not Moses given you the law? Yet not one of you keeps it. Why are you trying to kill Me?”
Didn’ t Moses give you the law, and yet none of you keeps the law? Why do you seek to kill me?”
Did not Moses give you the law? Even so, not one of you keeps the law. Why have you a desire to put me to death?
Did not Moses giue you a Law, and yet none of you keepeth the lawe? Why goe ye about to kill me?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Did Moses not give you the law, and yet none of you keepeth the law?
Cross-references
- Exodus 20:13
Thou shalt not kill.
Plotting to kill Jesus violates the commandment against murder.
- John 5:16-18
And therefore did the Jews persecute Jesus, and sought to slay him, because he had done these things on the sabbath day.
Jesus’ Sabbath healing prompted the rulers to seek his death.
- John 7:23
If a man on the sabbath day receive circumcision, that the law of Moses should not be broken; are ye angry at me, because I have made a man every whit whole on the sabbath day?
Circumcision under Moses’ law is contrasted with the law they fail to keep.
- Matthew 5:17
Think not that I am come to destroy the law, or the prophets: I am not come to destroy, but to fulfil.
Christ says he came to fulfill the law, not destroy it.
- Exodus 31:18
And he gave unto Moses, when he had made an end of communing with him upon mount Sinai, two tables of testimony, tables of stone, written with the finger of God.
both show law given through Moses
- Deuteronomy 5:1-22
And Moses called all Israel, and said unto them, Hear, O Israel, the statutes and judgments which I speak in your ears this day, that ye may learn them, and keep, and do them.
Moses gave Israel the commandments at Horeb.
- Malachi 4:4
Remember ye the law of Moses my servant, which I commanded unto him in Horeb for all Israel, with the statutes and judgments.
Cited as another reference to the law of Moses.
- Nehemiah 10:29
They clave to their brethren, their nobles, and entered into a curse, and into an oath, to walk in God’s law, which was given by Moses the servant of God, and to observe and do all the commandments of the LORD our Lord, and his judgments and his statutes;
Cited as another reference to the law of Moses.
- Romans 8:3-4
For what the law could not do, in that it was weak through the flesh, God sending his own Son in the likeness of sinful flesh, and for sin, condemned sin in the flesh:
God sent Christ so the law’s righteousness might be fulfilled in believers.
- Nehemiah 9:13-15
Thou camest down also upon mount Sinai, and spakest with them from heaven, and gavest them right judgments, and true laws, good statutes and commandments:
same first-time giving sense of make known
- John 5:46-47
For had ye believed Moses, ye would have believed me: for he wrote of me.
Jesus says Moses wrote of him and refers to Moses’ writings.
- Luke 24:44
And he said unto them, These are the words which I spake unto you, while I was yet with you, that all things must be fulfilled, which were written in the law of Moses, and in the prophets, and in the psalms, concerning me.
Both texts name the law of Moses.
- Romans 3:31
Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
Faith establishes rather than abolishes the law.
- John 7:1
After these things Jesus walked in Galilee: for he would not walk in Jewry, because the Jews sought to kill him.
The Jews sought to kill Jesus.
- Leviticus 12:3
And in the eighth day the flesh of his foreskin shall be circumcised.
Moses’ law prescribed circumcision on the eighth day.
- Mark 7:8-9
For laying aside the commandment of God, ye hold the tradition of men, as the washing of pots and cups: and many other such like things ye do.
Human traditions displace God’s commandments.
- John 7:49
But this people who knoweth not the law are cursed.
The passage connects this criticism of lawbreakers with the charge that the people do not know the law.
- Romans 3:28
Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.
Both texts address the law and whether keeping it justifies.
- Luke 24:27
And beginning at Moses and all the prophets, he expounded unto them in all the scriptures the things concerning himself.
Moses’ writings are included among the Scriptures.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
16 sources
Jesus confronted the rulers with their own contradiction, that though the law had been given through Moses none of them kept it, and their secret plot to kill Him was itself proof of their disobedience and hypocrisy.DA 455.1–2Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 72, 1895, par. 16 His question laid bare their hidden murderous intent and struck their guilty consciences with momentary terror, yet instead of answering they grew more enraged, denied seeking His life, accused Him of having a demon, and tried to turn the people aside.1RED 86.1–87.12SP 340.1–2LC1 86.2 Their lawbreaking lay in being exact about forms, ceremonies, and rules of their own invention while breaking the Sabbath and other precepts, setting aside what God had made sacred, and disregarding the great principles of justice, mercy, and love.SPBC 142.2Lt 11, 1903, par. 1–5Lt 38, 1896, par. 36–37 The law He spoke of is holy, just, and good, which He came not to lessen or destroy but to fulfill, its righteous requirements being lived out through a sanctified heart empowered by God.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16 The verse therefore calls for self-examination leading to love for one another, an end to backbiting and criticism, and repentance instead of self-righteous satisfaction, lest like those who prized themselves as Abraham's children yet refused to obey, the sacred trust be taken away and given to others.STGC 49.1–2ST Apr 20, 1888Ms 149, 1898, par. 18
Confrontation Exposing Hypocrisy
Jesus laid bare the rulers' contradiction that although Moses had given them the law, not one of them was keeping it, and their plot to kill Him was itself the proof of their disobedience and hypocrisy.DA 455.1–2Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 72, 1895, par. 16 He confronted those who claimed the law of Moses while failing to keep it, so that their opposition to Him stood in direct contradiction to the law they professed to obey.Lt 376, 1906, par. 3–8Ms 72, 1895, par. 16 Their plan to take His life contradicted the very law they claimed to uphold.DA 455.1–2Ms 72, 1895, par. 16
The clash came while they insisted on the law's requirements yet persecuted Him for teaching the sanctity of God's statutes and freeing them from senseless restrictions.1RED 86.1–87.12SP 340.1–2 Although they had received the law through Moses and demanded its observance, they did not live by its principles.1RED 86.1–87.12SP 340.1–2 His healing of a man on the Sabbath exposed their own lawlessness, for their effort to kill Him after that act of mercy showed they were lawbreakers.2SP 340.1–2LC1 86.2
His question, why they went about to kill Him, exposed their hidden murderous purpose and struck their guilty consciences.1RED 86.1–87.12SP 340.1–2DA 456.2–4 The accusation revealed their intentions to them and briefly filled them with terror.LC1 86.2DA 456.2–4 Instead of answering, they grew more enraged and sought to divert the people from His charge.1RED 86.1–87.12SP 340.1–2LC1 86.2 They denied that anyone sought His life and accused Him of having a demon or devil, suggesting His works were done by an evil spirit, and they concealed their designs rather than heeding the warning.2SP 340.1–2LC1 86.2DA 456.2–4
Nature of Their Lawbreaking
Their failure was exactness about forms and ceremonies and minor rules of their own invention while disregarding the great principles of the law — justice, mercy, and love.Lt 11, 1903, par. 1–5 They broke the Sabbath and the other precepts, forgot God's requirements, and perverted, displaced, and set aside through human inventions what God had committed to them as sacred.SPBC 142.2Lt 38, 1896, par. 36–37 Even in that disobedience they set themselves up as judges to condemn those moved by the Holy Spirit to speak God's word.SPBC 142.2Lt 38, 1896, par. 36–37
The law Moses gave is holy and just and good, and Christ did not come to lessen or destroy any of its precepts but to fulfill it.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16 Its righteous requirements are lived out through a sanctified heart and the new power God gives as people obey and work in harmony with Christ.Lt 189, 1909, par. 12–16 The verse means God requires His people to walk in the light He gives them, His requirements are always reasonable and just, yet He cannot accept less than perfect obedience to His commandments.ST Mar 26, 1896
Warning and True Obedience
John 7:19 calls every hearer to examine whether daily life actually carries out what God requires, and in practice that examination turns on cherishing love for one another and putting an end to backbiting and criticism.STGC 49.1–2 It stands as a warning against perverted ideas and against imperiling God's cause and one's own influence, urging instead to follow God and heed His counsel.Lt 73, 1900, par. 1 It exposes a self-righteousness that claims to respect God's law while not keeping it, leaving its holders unaware of their need for repentance, confession, and reformation.ST Apr 20, 1888
The same condition is found in professed Christians who deny their faith by their works, bear no fruit to God's glory, and rest satisfied with their own righteousness instead of seeking healing from Christ.ST Apr 20, 1888 Failure to walk in the light given was separating the Jewish people from God, with darkness coming upon them in the same proportion as light had shone upon their pathway.ST Mar 26, 1896 God requires His people to walk in the light He gives, His requirements are always reasonable and just, yet He cannot accept less than perfect obedience to His commandments.ST Mar 26, 1896 Had they used their God-given responsibility and obeyed the plainly revealed will of God made known through patriarch and prophet, they would have exhibited to the world character and works of an elevated order in harmony with the accumulated light upon their pathway.ST Mar 26, 1896
Although they had the truth and the law of God they did not keep it, while holding exalted views of themselves as the favorites of heaven, the only people of God, and the children of Abraham, and refusing to repent and be converted.Ms 149, 1898, par. 18 Because they did not keep the law, the sacred trust was taken from them and transferred to other peoples and to other nations.Ms 149, 1898, par. 18 True children of Abraham obey as Abraham obeyed, who was called the friend of God because he bore the trying test and started at once on the long painful journey to offer up his promised only son to become a great nation without hesitating to reason the matter out.Ms 149, 1898, par. 18
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
25 sources
Jesus charged that although the people had received God's perpetual moral law through Moses, none of them kept it, exposing their contradiction in claiming to uphold Moses while breaking it.ST Oct 15, 1896RH Aug 10, 1869RH Aug 20, 1872ST Nov 17, 1881ST Nov 15, 1910 Their seeking to kill Him proved the charge true, for murdering Him violated the very command against killing.RH Dec 28, 1869ST Sep 11, 1884ST Jun 11, 1894 He spoke this when accused of breaking the law for making a paralytic wholly whole on the Sabbath, yet His works of healing and mercy were lawful and upheld the true letter and spirit of the law, violating only human tradition heaped upon the day.ST Jun 11, 1894RH Apr 7, 1851 He defended the healing by showing that the Jews let the later Sabbath yield to the older rite of circumcision so the law would not be broken, while they condemned His following the still older and eternal principle of mercy and His Father's command.ST Nov 14, 1900RH Oct 15, 1872 God requires His people to walk in the light He gives with perfect obedience, but the Jews and Pharisees trusted in the law without keeping it, failing in compassion and mercy and resting in self-righteousness without repentance, as do professed Christians who deny faith by their works.ST Jun 25, 1912ST Apr 20, 1888ST Mar 26, 1896
Setting and Language
Jesus joined temple worship with helpful ministry on the Sabbath, confronting those who claimed the law of Moses while failing to keep it and asking why they sought to kill him. He had been accused of violating the law because he healed a whole man on the Sabbath, and the questions put to him about his teaching were intended to stir doubt and suspicion. The man healed was a paralytic, and the rulers who insisted on the law persecuted Jesus even though he upheld God's statutes and freed them from senseless restrictions.ST Nov 17, 1881 Their effort to kill him exposed the inconsistency between their claim to honor the law and their own conduct.ST Nov 17, 1881
The setting falls in the last six months before the crucifixion, when Jesus was entering the shadow of the cross.ST Feb 15, 1883 There he answered his opponents with the Old Testament, with his heart resting on its prophecies and promises, showing absolute reliance on its words from his deepest convictions in the midst of his greatest trials.ST Feb 15, 1883 The conflict belonged to the plotting of the priests and rabbis against him, and after their plotting was defeated he left Jerusalem for the Mount of Olives and returned to teach in the temple the next morning. The chapter division interrupts a sentence that continues into John 8.ST Nov 15, 1910
To say Moses gave the law means Moses made it known and commanded it for the first time.RH Oct 29, 1872 The word give carries all that give or command carries, with the added thought of first-time giving, having the same force as madest known.RH Oct 29, 1872 This treats Moses as its giver and confirms the law's place in the writings of Moses.ST Feb 15, 1883
The law Moses gave is the law of God, the perpetual moral law distinct from the abolished Levitical law.RH Aug 20, 1872 It is distinguished from the ceremonial law of Moses discussed in John 7:23.RH Aug 10, 1869 The charge of failing to keep it while seeking to kill him points specifically to the sixth commandment against killing.RH Aug 10, 1869 Yet calling it the law of Moses does not by itself establish that it means only the Ten Commandments, since other laws were also given at Horeb.ST May 23, 1911
Rebuke and Sabbath Defense
The charge is that although the people received the law through Moses, none of them kept it, exposing the contradiction between claiming to uphold Moses' law and failing to keep it.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Nov 17, 1881ST Nov 15, 1910ST May 12, 1909ST Oct 15, 1896 That failure was proved by their seeking to kill Jesus even while they claimed the law.ST Oct 15, 1896ST Nov 17, 1881ST Nov 15, 1910ST May 12, 1909 The chapter division interrupts a sentence that continues into John 8.ST Nov 15, 1910
Their seeking to kill Jesus proves the charge, since killing him violated the command against killing.RH Dec 28, 1869ST Sep 11, 1884ST Jun 11, 1894 Killing Christ, like Cain's killing of Abel, violated the law rather than fulfilled it, so calling his murderers law-keepers exposes the contradiction.RH Dec 28, 1869 Their rejection of him was part of a wider pattern of setting God's commandments aside through human traditions, and they ultimately put him to death contrary to the law.ST Sep 11, 1884
His question about why they sought to kill him revealed that he knew their true feelings toward him.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Oct 15, 1896 He read the secrets of their hearts and knew the character and life history of every man present.ST Nov 5, 1896 Their guilty consciences were struck by his accusation, but it increased their rage.ST Nov 17, 1881 They tried to conceal their murderous purpose by denying that anyone sought to kill him and diverting attention from his charge.ST Nov 17, 1881 His enemies still sought to seize him, but did not lay hands on him.ST Nov 14, 1900
In the Sabbath dispute he defended making a man completely whole on the Sabbath by comparing it with circumcision performed on the Sabbath so the law would not be broken, and called them to judge righteously rather than by appearances.ST Nov 14, 1900 The Sabbath is the later law originating with Moses, while circumcision is the older law given before Moses through the fathers, and mercy is the older eternal principle.RH Oct 15, 1872 The Jews make the later Sabbath yield to the older circumcision by circumcising on the Sabbath and yet claim to keep the law of Moses without breaking it, which was a conflict of positive law with positive law.RH Oct 15, 1872 They then condemned him for healing a whole man on the Sabbath, which was following the older moral principle of mercy and also a still later law, the special command of his Father to finish the works given him, and was a conflict of moral law with positive law.RH Oct 15, 1872
His Sabbath works of healing and deeds of mercy were lawful and did not violate or relax God's law.ST Jun 11, 1894RH Apr 7, 1851 Their complaints against his healing reflected burdensome human traditions, not the law's true letter and spirit.ST Jun 11, 1894 Christ's Sabbath conduct upheld the law and showed how the day was properly observed.ST Jun 11, 1894 What he violated was human tradition heaped upon the Sabbath law, not the law itself, leaving him without sin whom none can convict of sin.
He reasoned with them from the Scriptures and then called upon them to judge and decide with regard to the truth.ST Nov 14, 1900RH Aug 9, 1864 This proves that reason and judgment are not laid aside in the Scriptures but are made use of and appealed to in order to persuade men to choose the truth.RH Aug 9, 1864 He called them to judge righteously rather than by appearances.ST Nov 14, 1900 The verse makes two charges against the Pharisees, that none of them keeps the law and that they seek to kill Jesus.ST Oct 29, 1896 By judging him without a hearing they prove both charges true, because the law requires a hearing before it judges, so condemning him unheard both breaks the law and shows murderous intent.ST Oct 29, 1896
Call to Genuine Obedience
The charge that none kept the law means God requires His people to walk in the light He gives them.ST Mar 26, 1896 His requirements are always reasonable and just, and He cannot accept less than perfect obedience to His commandments.ST Mar 26, 1896 Had the chosen people used their God-given responsibility and obeyed the plainly revealed will made known through patriarch and prophet, they would have exhibited character and works of an elevated order in harmony with the accumulated light upon their pathway.ST Mar 26, 1896 Failure to walk in that light was separating them from God, with darkness coming upon them in the same proportion as light had shone upon their pathway.ST Mar 26, 1896
The Jews claimed to respect God's law but did not keep it.ST Apr 20, 1888 The Pharisees' trust in the law did not mean they kept it, for they failed to live out the compassion and mercy He taught and their effort to have the law justify them was misplaced.ST Jun 25, 1912 Their treatment of Jesus, of publicans, and of sinners exposed that failure.ST Jun 25, 1912 Their self-righteousness left them unaware of their need for repentance, confession, and reformation.ST Apr 20, 1888 The same is true of professed Christians who deny their faith by their works, bear no fruit to God's glory, and rest satisfied with their own righteousness instead of seeking healing from Christ.ST Apr 20, 1888
Those who appealed to the law Moses gave did not keep that law themselves.ST Nov 5, 1896 While they accused Jesus and accused the woman taken in sin and sought to kill Him, He read the secrets of their hearts and knew the character and life history of every man present.ST Nov 5, 1896 Their own particular sins, beginning with the eldest and ending with the youngest, proved them more guilty than the woman they condemned.ST Nov 5, 1896 Sin blinds men to their own faults while sharpening them to detect the faults of others.ST Nov 5, 1896 He did not excuse sin or lessen the sense of crime, but He came not to condemn; His work was to reach into human woe and degradation, to lift up the debased and sinful, to lead the sinner to eternal life, and to bid the trembling penitent to sin no more.ST Nov 5, 1896 Hatred against Him was growing as the shadow of the cross deepened and the climax of His earthly life drew near.ST Nov 5, 1896
Sources