Luke 24:39
Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.
Translations
Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit has not flesh and bones, as you see me have.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me have.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
See my hands and my feet, that it is I myself: handle me, and see; for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye behold me having.
see my hands and my feet, that I am he; handle me and see, because a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me having.'
behold my hands and my feet, that it is I myself. Handle me and see, for a spirit has not flesh and bones as ye see me having.
See my hands, and my feet,—that it is, I, myself: Handle me, and see! because, a spirit, hath not, flesh and bones, as ye perceive, I, have.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Look at My hands and My feet. It is I Myself. Touch Me and see— for a spirit does not have flesh and bones, as you see I have.”
See my hands and my feet, that it is truly me. Touch me and see, for a spirit doesn’ t have flesh and bones, as you see that I have.”
See; my hands and my feet: it is I myself; put your hands on me and make certain; for a spirit has not flesh and bones as you see that I have.
Beholde mine handes and my feete: for it is I my selfe: handle me, and see: for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as ye see me haue.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
See my hands and feet, that it is I myself; handle, and see: for a spirit hath not flesh and bones, as you see me to have.
Pictures


Cross-references 20 of 69
- John 20:19-20
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
The risen Jesus appears to the gathered disciples and shows them his wounds.
- Mark 16:14
Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
Jesus appears to the eleven and rebukes their disbelief in his resurrection.
- John 20:27
Then saith he to Thomas, Reach hither thy finger, and behold my hands; and reach hither thy hand, and thrust it into my side: and be not faithless, but believing.
The risen Jesus invites Thomas to examine his hands and side.
- Luke 24:30-31
And it came to pass, as he sat at meat with them, he took bread, and blessed it, and brake, and gave to them.
The risen Jesus is recognized by the Emmaus disciples as he breaks bread.
- 1 Corinthians 15:44
It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body. There is a natural body, and there is a spiritual body.
Contrasts the natural body with the spiritual body raised at the resurrection.
- Philippians 3:21
Who shall change our vile body, that it may be fashioned like unto his glorious body, according to the working whereby he is able even to subdue all things unto himself.
Believers’ bodies will be fashioned like Christ’s tangible, glorious body.
- John 20:20
And when he had so said, he shewed unto them his hands and his side. Then were the disciples glad, when they saw the Lord.
The risen Jesus shows the disciples his wounded hands and side.
- Acts 1:3
To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God:
Jesus showed himself alive after his suffering through many proofs, including his bodily appearances.
- Acts 10:41
Not to all the people, but unto witnesses chosen before of God, even to us, who did eat and drink with him after he rose from the dead.
Chosen witnesses ate and drank with Jesus after his resurrection.
- John 20:26
And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them: then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.
Jesus appears again with Thomas present to confirm his resurrection.
- 1 Corinthians 15:5
And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
Names Peter among those who saw the risen Jesus.
- 1 Corinthians 15:50
Now this I say, brethren, that flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God; neither doth corruption inherit incorruption.
Contrasts flesh and blood with Christ’s tangible flesh and bones.
- 1 Corinthians 15:53
For this corruptible must put on incorruption, and this mortal must put on immortality.
The mortal puts on immortality at the resurrection.
- 1 John 3:2
Beloved, now are we the sons of God, and it doth not yet appear what we shall be: but we know that, when he shall appear, we shall be like him; for we shall see him as he is.
Believers will be like Christ when he appears.
- 1 Corinthians 15:20
But now is Christ risen from the dead, and become the firstfruits of them that slept.
Christ’s bodily resurrection is the firstfruits and pledge of believers’ resurrection.
- Matthew 28:9
And as they went to tell his disciples, behold, Jesus met them, saying, All hail. And they came and held him by the feet, and worshipped him.
The risen Jesus meets the women, who hold his feet and worship him.
- Acts 1:11
Which also said, Ye men of Galilee, why stand ye gazing up into heaven? this same Jesus, which is taken up from you into heaven, shall so come in like manner as ye have seen him go into heaven.
The same bodily Jesus who ascended will return in like manner.
- Mark 16:12-13
After that he appeared in another form unto two of them, as they walked, and went into the country.
The two disciples report seeing the risen Jesus, but the others do not believe them.
- Luke 24:34
Saying, The Lord is risen indeed, and hath appeared to Simon.
The disciples report that the risen Jesus appeared to Simon.
- 1 John 1:1
That which was from the beginning, which we have heard, which we have seen with our eyes, which we have looked upon, and our hands have handled, of the Word of life;
John testifies that the apostles saw and handled Christ in bodily form.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
31 sources
On the evening of His resurrection Jesus stood suddenly among His disciples behind shut doors, and as they were terrified supposing they had seen a spirit He held out His hands and feet to show He was the same Jesus who had been crucified.6RED 35.1–3ST Sep 26, 1878Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63COS 184.3–185.3 By bidding them to behold, handle and see He proved He was bodily present in a real, tangible body of flesh and bones that could be touched, and not a spirit without substance.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 1878Ms 40, 1903, par. 19 The prints of the nails still in His hands and feet, with His wounded side, divine countenance and familiar voice, made Him known even to those who had never seen Him before, and turned fear, sorrow and unbelief into recognition, faith, peace and inexpressible joy.6RED 35.1–3ST Sep 26, 1878DA 802.1–803.23SP 217.1–3 His offered hands and feet point to His work of taking away sin and ransoming men, so that peace and salvation are to be found by looking to Jesus alone as the overcoming Mediator and not by human works, and He carried those wounds with Him to heaven where He pleads the merits of His blood as remembrance of the price paid.GC 152.1–4GC88 152.1–4ST Aug 16, 18836RED 94.3–95.1 His resurrection was victory over death by which those who sleep in Jesus will be raised to glorious immortality, so heaven is no longer an indefinite region tenanted by intangible spirits but a personal home connected with Jesus whom they knew and loved, whom those who recognized Him hastened to worship.Ms 80, 1886, par. 18–203SP 236.1GC 152.1–4ST Nov 22, 1883ST Oct 31, 1878
Risen Body Recognized
On the evening of the resurrection day at Jerusalem Jesus suddenly stood among the disciples in the upper chamber behind doors shut for fear of the Jews, while they were hearing the report of those who had journeyed to Emmaus, with hands uplifted in blessing.Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63COS 184.3–185.3 They were terrified and frightened, supposing they had seen a spirit.Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63COS 184.3–185.3 He appeared to them there in the upper room twice and told them to remain in Jerusalem for a time.3SP 225.2
He was the same Jesus who had been crucified, and His hands and feet still bore the prints and marks of the nails, with His wounded side also shown and His divine countenance and familiar voice confirming Him.6RED 35.1–3ST Sep 26, 18783SP 217.1–33SP 236.1ST Oct 10, 1878 By those marks the disciples recognized Him as their risen Lord, so that there was no room for unbelief in the minds of the eleven about His identity.3SP 213.2–3ST Oct 10, 18786RED 52.1–2 Even many who had never before seen Him knew Him by those wounded and pierced hands and feet and hastened to pay Him homage, including believers later gathered in Galilee who recognized Him at once when He stood suddenly in their midst.3SP 236.1
By inviting them to behold, handle, and see His hands and feet, He proved He had a real, tangible body of flesh and bones that could be touched and examined.6RED 35.1–3Ms 113, 1897, par. 22ST Sep 26, 1878Ms 80, 1886, par. 18–20Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12 He was bodily present and not a spirit without substance, for a spirit does not have flesh and bones and has no physical body.ST Sep 26, 1878Ms 80, 1886, par. 18–20Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12DA 802.1–803.2 His wounds and tangible form helped them believe that He had truly risen bodily and was He Himself alive again.6RED 35.1–3Ms 110, 1901, par. 4–12DA 802.1–803.2
Further proof was given in that they saw Him and talked and journeyed with Him, and watched Him eat a piece of bread and honeycomb and drink before them.Ms 40, 1903, par. 19Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63COS 184.3–185.3Ms 203, 1898, par. 9 His body had not seen corruption, and their testimony of encountering Him together with the empty tomb and the shroud and napkin left behind gave clear evidence He was alive again and truly risen from the dead.Ms 203, 1898, par. 9 The marks of the nails identified Him as the crucified Jesus, and seeing Him and watching Him eat helped turn doubt into faith and joy and left the eleven without doubt, although some other followers were only partly convinced.3SP 234.1
He allowed them to touch Him after He had ascended to His Father and returned, having received power from His Father.SG1 74.1EW 154.2–155.1 His return and physical presence, which they could see and touch, confirmed He was the same Jesus risen bodily and not a spirit.SG1 74.1EW 154.2–155.1
The sight dispelled fear and sorrow and turned doubt and unbelief into recognition, believing faith, comfort, peace and inexpressible joy as they acknowledged their risen Saviour.DA 802.1–803.2COS 184.3–185.3 Yet they were joyful and hardly believed, and lack of faith kept them from fully enjoying the surprise.Ms 155, 1904, par. 61–63 Some other followers were only partly convinced, and some doubted.3SP 234.1ST Oct 10, 1878
Salvation Hope Worship
The hands and feet He holds out bear the wounds that show He Himself has taken away sin and ransomed His people, bringing them peace.GC 152.1–4GC88 152.1–4 The call to behold them is a call to look to Jesus alone, for as Mediator He has overcome and gives peace to those who believe the gospel.ST Aug 16, 1883 Peace and salvation come through Christ's work and not through human works.GC 152.1–4GC88 152.1–4ST Aug 16, 1883 True faith in that finished work then appears in a holy life and in useful service to others.GC 152.1–4GC88 152.1–4
He keeps His wounded hands and feet and carried those wounds with Him to heaven.6RED 94.3–95.1 There His sympathies are unchanged, and He identifies Himself with suffering humanity.6RED 94.3–95.1 He receives the prayers of His people and pleads before God the merits of His own precious blood, showing His wounded hands and feet as a remembrance of the price He paid for His redeemed.6RED 94.3–95.1 His resurrection was a victory over death, and those who sleep in Jesus will also be raised to glorious immortality.Ms 80, 1886, par. 18–20
The same Jesus who spoke on earth as never man spoke continued after His resurrection as educator to the disciples in the upper chamber and at Emmaus.15MR 23.4Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19 He opened to them the Scriptures concerning Himself and laid open the straight chain of prophecy about Himself.ST Oct 10, 187815MR 23.4Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19 He thus bound their hearts with holy, new and sacred hope and joy, leaving no room for unbelief about His identity in those who fully received it, though others believed only partly.ST Oct 10, 187815MR 23.4Lt 37, 1887, par. 18–19 He was seen and talked with, His body had not seen corruption, and together with the empty tomb and the shroud and napkin left behind this gave abundant, clear evidence that His resurrection was certain.Ms 203, 1898, par. 9Ms 94, 1897, par. 28–30 That uncontroverted evidence made of none effect the falsehood of the Jewish priests and established Christianity.Ms 94, 1897, par. 28–30
Because the disciples conversed and journeyed with Him and handled Him even in His resurrected body, He was proved not to be a spirit without substance.ST Nov 22, 1883ST Oct 31, 1878 This changed all their views and contemplations of heaven.ST Oct 31, 1878 Heaven could no longer appear as an indefinite, incomprehensible space, a region of unlimited space tenanted by spirits without substance and filled with intangible spirits.ST Oct 31, 1878 Heaven became personal and was connected with the thought of Jesus whom they had known and loved and reverenced, and was looked upon as their future home.ST Nov 22, 1883ST Oct 31, 1878
Those who recognized Him by the marks of the nails hastened to pay Him homage and worshiped Him, even many who had never seen Him before knowing Him by those marks.3SP 236.16RED 54.1–2DA 818.2–819.1 His divine countenance together with His hands and feet still wounded and pierced identified Him as He Himself, the Saviour, to believers gathered both in Jerusalem and in Galilee.3SP 236.16RED 54.1–2DA 818.2–819.1 Yet some doubted, showing that people may resist faith and lose blessing through unbelief.6RED 54.1–2Lt 115, 1904, par. 5–6 Choosing hope and courage rather than spreading doubt brings greater happiness and helpfulness.Lt 115, 1904, par. 5–6
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
137 sources
Beholden with wounded hands and feet on the evening of the resurrection day, Jesus stood in person among the frightened disciples to prove he himself risen from the dead and not a ghost or apparition.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Dec 17, 1894ST May 28, 1896RH Jun 25, 1861 His body was real and touchable flesh and bones, changed to immortal and incorruptible yet still natural, and without blood because flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom, while those who held the other position teach his glorified body still had material blood.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Mar 13, 1907ST Apr 20, 1904ST May 28, 1896ST Feb 4, 1903 The contrast gives no proof of a conscious soul living apart from the body in death, for at death the spirit as life returns to God and death and resurrection are not predicated of immortal beings.RH Jul 12, 1864RH Oct 30, 1855RH Nov 7, 1865RH Jul 4, 1865 The meeting gives no command, example or blessing for resting on the first day or keeping Sunday holy in honor of the resurrection, since the disciples met only to eat in fear and unbelief and he said nothing to sanctify that day.ST Oct 5, 1882RH Nov 14, 1871RH May 1, 1900ST Apr 12, 1883ST Nov 18, 1886 The same flesh-and-bones Jesus ascended bodily into heaven and will come again in like visible manner, and his resurrection is the firstfruits and pattern of the resurrection of the just to real and recognizable bodies like his.RH Apr 30, 1872ST Jan 15, 1902ST Jun 6, 1878ST Jun 6, 1916RH May 30, 1854
Appearance Setting and Wording
The saying belongs to Jesus appearing in person in Jerusalem on the evening of the resurrection day after the two disciples returned from Emmaus, standing in their midst in their common lodging behind shut doors with the greeting Peace be unto you while they were eating supper.ST May 28, 1896ST May 24, 1910ST Feb 23, 1915RH Nov 14, 1871 He entered unseen with them and withheld himself from sight until their unbelief in his resurrection was manifested, for they had heard he was risen but did not believe it.ST Feb 23, 1915 The interview that evening was with the entire company of the disciples, the eleven with Thomas absent, and it was only this one first day on which he thus met with them.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Feb 13, 1872 He met their terror at supposing they had seen a spirit by pointing to his hands and his feet as proof that it is he himself, inviting them to handle him and see, explaining that a spirit does not have flesh and bones as he has, then showing his hands and feet and eating a piece of broiled fish and honeycomb before them.ST May 28, 1896
The disciples were terrified, sorrowful and unbelieving when he appeared, supposing they had seen a spirit, and he withheld himself until their unbelief was manifested and then rebuked it and gave visible proof to make them witnesses.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Aug 14, 1893 They were frightened, thinking they saw a ghost, and needed this bodily demonstration of seeing and touching him to believe that he was truly alive.ST Oct 28, 1908ST Aug 14, 1893 They still doubted the resurrection and were bewildered and slow to believe their own eyes, so they were not keeping the first day to commemorate an event they did not yet believe in nor meeting to worship him as the risen Lord.ST Oct 17, 1878ST Oct 28, 1908ST Apr 24, 1901 He did this because, having been crucified on the preparation the sixth day, he must rise the third day to fulfill what was written in the law of Moses and the prophets and the Psalms that Christ should suffer and rise from the dead the third day, and he must have witnesses who had seen him on that day to testify that he rose on that day and to refute the lying testimony of the Jews and the hired soldiers.ST Oct 4, 1899 The object of this meeting was to qualify the disciples as witnesses of these things, not to consecrate the first day of the week as the Christian Sabbath.ST Oct 4, 1899
The meeting occurred at the very close of the first day and after sunset when the second day had begun, late near sunset and possibly extending into the second day, after an eight-mile return from Emmaus.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Nov 10, 1914ST Dec 11, 1901RH Feb 25, 1862 The day was far spent when Jesus met the two disciples at Emmaus, and only after they returned eight miles to Jerusalem to the apostles gathered in their common abode did Jesus appear to the assembled group and show himself.ST Dec 11, 1901 The appearance therefore belongs to the meeting after the first day had ended and the second day had begun, not to Sunday, and was spoken in the evening after the first day of the week had already gone by uncelebrated, unkept, and unobserved.ST Nov 10, 1914ST Dec 11, 1901
The account is the same meeting described in Mark 16:14 and John 20:19, giving particulars Luke alone gives without contradicting Matthew, Mark and John.ST Mar 5, 1912ST Apr 28, 1909 Luke did not witness the events himself but received them from the Lord through Peter, and wrote first, before Matthew or Mark and John.ST Mar 5, 1912 His account tells particulars concerning the resurrection that the others did not tell, including this appearance and Jesus' discourse to the amazed, unbelieving disciples on the evening of the first day, and omits events they clearly brought out, without contradicting Matthew, Mark, and John, who each also stated what was true under the same guidance without trying to harmonize their statements, so all the various statements of the four evangelists can be accounted for together in a harmony of the Gospels.ST Mar 5, 1912ST Apr 28, 1909
The sayings placed after Luke 24:29 making the first day the Sabbath are a spurious interpolation with no inspired authority, and a change of Sabbath would require equally explicit testimony.RH Jan 13, 1859 Luke 24:30-39 contains no command from the risen Christ making the first day of the week the Sabbath and no authority for resting on the first day and working from the second day to the seventh.RH Jan 13, 1859 A change of the Sabbath from the seventh to the first day would require testimony just as explicit with a much better title to inspiration.RH Jan 13, 1859
The word spirit here means the ghost, phantom or apparition the frightened disciples superstitiously imagined, whether as angel, demon or ghost, not a definition of every spirit.ST Aug 30, 1877ST Apr 3, 1901ST Aug 23, 1877RH Sep 19, 1854 The apostles thought they were seeing a spiritual being, such as an angel or demon, not the spirit of a dead person, and the verse does not identify the spirit the disciples thought they saw as a human spirit, since spirits without flesh and bones can also be angels.ST Apr 3, 1901RH Apr 3, 1866 The Greek is pneuma, not daimon, and pneuma has several meanings and can also describe a body such as Christ's risen body; spirit in Scripture can mean Deity, angel or demon, or life, as the setting decides.ST Apr 3, 1901ST Aug 23, 1877RH Sep 19, 1854 Jesus showed that, by the disciples' own idea of a spirit, he was not one, since he had flesh and bones they could see and touch, yet his resurrected body was spiritual and could appear without a visible entrance, yet was bodily.ST Aug 23, 1877 This verse does not say whether spirits are mortal or immortal, or whether they die, and when a person dies, the spirit, meaning the person's life, returns to God who gave it and is not a new conscious being.ST Apr 3, 1901
The wording is flesh and bones, not flesh and blood, which matters because flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom or exist in the restored relation.ST May 28, 1896 Jesus' resurrection body was material even though raised a spiritual body, and he took that same flesh-and-bones body with him into heaven, where he now is as a resurrected, glorified man.ST May 28, 1896 Christians hope to have their bodies fashioned after his glorious body, and the condition of the redeemed will be real, tangible, and without sin to mar its appreciation.ST May 28, 1896
Bodily Identity Proved
The risen Jesus stands bodily present before his disciples as the same person who was crucified and buried, not a spirit, phantom or another being.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Apr 28, 1909RH Sep 18, 1855ST May 9, 1878ST Apr 11, 1900 His own words, I myself, identify him as the same self before death and after, mortal before and immortal afterward, without passage into another person.RH Sep 18, 1855ST May 9, 1878ST Jun 12, 1884 His hands and feet can be seen and touched, and his possession of flesh and bones proves he is not a spirit returning from the dead but himself alive after death.ST Dec 17, 1894ST Apr 28, 1909ST May 9, 1878ST Apr 11, 1900ST Jun 12, 1884 His eating before them further confirms the reality of the bodily resurrection, and the same literal body ascended to heaven where he remains a literal person.RH Sep 18, 1855ST May 9, 1878
He proves this identity by showing his hands and his feet, inviting the disciples to behold, handle and see.ST Sep 26, 1878ST Sep 15, 1887RH Jun 25, 1861ST May 28, 1896ST Oct 6, 1914 Those hands and feet bear the nail marks, with the spear wound also shown, so that voice, wounds and touch together confirm recognition.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Jun 25, 1861ST Oct 6, 1914RH Oct 21, 1862 He showed them to dispel their frightened supposition that they had seen a spirit, ghost or mere phantom, demonstrating a real, substantial, tangible body of flesh and bones.ST Sep 26, 1878ST Sep 15, 1887RH Jun 25, 1861ST Oct 6, 1914RH Oct 21, 1862 He showed them again and ate broiled fish and honeycomb before them to demonstrate that he had truly risen bodily.ST Sep 15, 1887RH Jun 25, 1861ST May 28, 1896
Seeing and handling that risen physical body with its wounds turned terror, sorrow and doubt into joy, faith, worship and hope.ST Oct 14, 1889ST Sep 15, 1887RH Jun 13, 1865ST Mar 8, 1905 They were still astonished and slow to believe and wondered even while rejoicing, yet the proof met disciples bowed in sorrow and unbelief despite reports of the women and of the two from Emmaus who had known him in the breaking of bread.ST Oct 14, 1889ST Sep 15, 1887 Their testimony rests on direct personal knowledge of a real resurrection, on what they themselves saw, handled, heard and spoke, including eating with him.ST Jun 11, 1896RH Jun 5, 1866 That encounter changed their conception of his mission, confirming that he truly came to bring repentance and remission of sins, that though buried he lived and would reign on David's throne as Messiah, and that he will come again to abolish sin and re-create the earth as an eternal tangible dwelling for saints.ST Oct 14, 1889ST Jun 11, 1896 The hands he lifted in blessing were the same pierced hands of the cross, and the same Jesus who had lain three days in the tomb refreshed them together by manifesting himself after the travelers returned from Emmaus.ST Oct 14, 1889RH Jun 13, 1865ST Nov 11, 1908
That presented crucified body is himself and the only evidence on record on which their faith in his resurrection rests.RH Nov 26, 1872 He calls that marked body himself, expressing personality and identity as strongly as possible.RH Nov 26, 1872 He did not hold two bodies between resurrection and ascension, a spiritual body and a resuscitated natural body worn at times like clothing, nor a temporary body apart from his real self, but one literal self.RH Nov 26, 1872
To question whether he rose in bodily form, or to hold no definite opinion about it, is heresy making men unfit for ministry.RH Jun 9, 1910ST Aug 19, 1913 Denial that he rose in a real physical body with flesh and bones that could be handled and seen treats the testimony of Matthew and Luke beyond Mark as unreliable embellishment.ST Mar 13, 1907 Such denial abandons the Bible as authority and the common faith in Christ as vicarious sacrifice who died for sins, in his miraculous conception and virgin birth, in his true death and resurrection, in his moral perfection and sinlessness, and in physical miracles altogether.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Sep 9, 1909 Rejection of the bodily resurrection in favor of a merely spiritual sense, or of a spiritual presentation deceiving the apostles into thinking they saw his body, rejects a cardinal point of Christian belief.RH Jun 9, 1910ST Aug 19, 1913ST Oct 6, 1909
Nature of Risen Body
His risen body is real, tangible, material flesh and bones that can be seen and handled, not a phantom, ghost, ethereal or disembodied spirit.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Feb 27, 1879RH Apr 4, 1871RH Nov 8, 1853 It is a spiritual body that is still perfectly natural, a glorified spiritual body that can eat and drink, as shown when he ate broiled fish and honeycomb before them.ST Feb 27, 1879RH Apr 4, 1871RH Nov 8, 1853 His display of hands and feet with invitation to touch proves bodily resurrection, not resurrection of an immortal soul, and his body is the firstfruits and pattern proving the immortal saints will likewise have real flesh with decay removed.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Feb 27, 1879RH Nov 8, 1853 The same reality belongs to angels, who are likewise real corporeal material beings.ST Jul 23, 1874
From the tomb he came forth with the human body changed to an immortal, incorruptible spiritual body, still literal and able to be seen and handled.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Nov 26, 1872RH Sep 1, 1859RH Oct 31, 1865ST Sep 23, 1908 It was no longer a mortal corruptible body like present bodies, yet it still bore the marks of crucifixion in hands and feet by which his personality and identity were proved.RH Nov 26, 1872RH Sep 1, 1859RH Jul 29, 1875RH Oct 31, 1865ST Aug 17, 1876 That Mary and the Emmaus disciples did not at first know him was not because the body was strange but because their eyes were holden.RH Nov 26, 1872 With that same changed body he ascended and will ever bear it, never laying it aside as worthless, never leaving the mortal body to rot or annihilating it to ascend in a mere spirit body.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Nov 26, 1872RH Oct 31, 1865ST Sep 23, 1908 The glory of his immortality was veiled because mortal eyes could not bear to see it, though at one stage described as immortal but not yet fully glorified.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Sep 1, 1859
His resurrection body has flesh and bones but not blood.ST Apr 20, 1904RH Dec 11, 1855ST May 24, 1905ST Aug 17, 1876ST Mar 31, 1909 When the body becomes immortal, blood-life gives way to spirit-life, distinguishing the spirit-life of the resurrection from the blood-life that dominates mortal existence, while body and life remain real.RH Dec 11, 1855ST May 24, 1905ST Aug 17, 1876ST Mar 31, 1909 His blood was shed on the cross and is not in it, for flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of God, and the life principle is something else, namely being made alive by God's Spirit.RH Dec 11, 1855ST Aug 17, 1876 Thus flesh and blood excludes blood, not bodily form, explaining how the saints can have bodies and still inherit God's kingdom with flesh and bones fashioned after his.ST Apr 20, 1904RH Dec 11, 1855 Through the second Adam God's children receive a higher life than Adam's original life, renewed according to spirit-life rather than corrupted blood-life, with contrast between present and future bodies described as flesh associated with blood versus future life.ST Mar 31, 1909 Those who held otherwise taught that his glorified body still had material blood as the same body he had before.ST Feb 4, 1903
He could appear among them without visible entrance and move away from earth in ways ordinary bodies cannot, yet eat, drink, walk and speak and show wounds from crucifixion.ST Nov 30, 1915RH Jul 29, 1875RH Jan 28, 1902 His immortality's glory was veiled because mortal eyes could not bear it.ST Mar 13, 1907 He ascended bodily and visibly in that same flesh-and-bones body, with no indication of change or spiritualizing at the ascension.ST Jun 6, 1878RH May 30, 1854RH Jun 25, 1872 That glorified bodily form, bearing nail marks in hands and feet and wound in side, was taken to heaven where as glorified man he now wears the same humanity on the throne of the universe that he wore while suffering on earth.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Sep 23, 1908 He remains kinsman to humanity, remembering conflicts, temptations and sorrows and feeling sympathy for human weakness.ST Sep 23, 1908 His physical presence with disciples during the forty days were real encounters, not his second coming, which could occur only after he had ascended and gone away, including ascent to the Father to present his offering for humanity and return to prepare them for their work.RH Jun 25, 1872ST May 24, 1899
His scars remain in glory in hands, feet, side, head and heart.ST Apr 7, 1914RH Dec 26, 1907ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1901RH Feb 24, 1910 The nail prints, spear mark and thorn scars recall loving service and sacrifice at Calvary and remain as witnesses to saving love and as lasting sight for angels and men of what sin did, so warning never fades and suffering need never be re-enacted.ST Apr 7, 1914ST Sep 23, 1908RH Mar 19, 1901RH Feb 24, 1910 By those familiar wounds and voice disciples knew him as their beloved Master.ST Sep 19, 1878ST Oct 6, 1909 When believers see him face to face they will know him by those scars and their joy will be complete.RH Dec 26, 1907
Matter is not inherently impure.RH Apr 4, 1871 Eve was made of matter and flesh and blood, yet was holy, showing the human body can be pure and perfect.RH Apr 4, 1871
Spirits, Death and Resurrection
The verse shows that a spirit does not have flesh and bones, but it does not tell what the nature of the substance of a spirit is, whether spirits are mortal or immortal or die, and the exact nature of a spirit cannot be known in this life, nor does it teach that a spirit must be a disembodied conscious being.RH Jul 12, 1864
The spirit named is not called the spirit of man, and gives no proof of a conscious human soul separate from the body living on in death, of immaterial souls, or of consciousness in death.RH Oct 30, 1855RH Nov 7, 1865RH Jul 4, 1865
A depiction of disembodied souls with eyes, fingers and tongues, as in the parable of the rich man and Lazarus, conflicts with the teaching that a spirit does not have flesh and bones and cannot establish consciousness after death.ST Jul 15, 1913
The words are fully clear when spirit is understood as spirit beings made known in Scripture, good angels and evil and unclean spirits such as those cast out, and give no proof for immortal departed souls of dead men.RH Nov 7, 1865
Angels are called spirits yet have bodies and appeared to Lot in the form of men, so the spirit contrasted with the risen body could have been an angel, and the spirits meant are spirits from heaven appearing in the form of men yet without flesh and bones as men have.RH Oct 30, 1855RH Jul 4, 1865
Spiritual beings, including angels and evil spirits, do not have flesh and bones as human beings do, but they are still real and individual beings, and their lack of a body like ours does not mean they cannot exist, for a spiritual body is distinct from a natural body.ST Dec 12, 1906
An evil spirit may take complete possession of someone who yields to it, but otherwise can only trouble that person outwardly.ST Dec 12, 1906
Spirits are without flesh and bones and therefore are not matter in the ordinary sense of what makes itself known by means of the bodily senses, yet immateriality is real existence rather than nonentity, with spirit as a substance different from matter, and spirituality as the positive expression of that difference.RH Sep 13, 1864
The risen one identifies his hands and feet, invites touch, and eats broiled fish and honeycomb, showing a physical resurrection, not the resurrection of an immortal soul, for death and resurrection are not predicated of immortal beings.
When a person dies the spirit as life returns to God who gave it and is not a new conscious being, and the resurrection refutes the idea that an immortal part never dies while the mortal part never rises.
Those who held the opposite taught that the verse supports human spirits existing apart from the body after death as real personal beings without a material body, with personality and with their own powers, not merely an endowment of man, just as the body has its own endowments distinct from itself.RH Apr 3, 1866RH Nov 7, 1865
In that teaching the verse distinguishes the risen bodily presence from a spirit, affirms a belief the Pharisees held about the existence and nature of such spirits of departed dead men, and without that doctrine the words distinguishing a spirit from bodily form would have been unintelligible.RH Apr 3, 1866RH Nov 7, 1865
The risen Christ was a real, bodily person whose hands and feet could be seen and touched, with immortal flesh and immortal bones, not a formless spirit or merely the appearance of a spirit.RH Jun 8, 1869ST Feb 15, 1899RH Oct 8, 1903RH Jun 25, 1861
He is spiritual, yet also literal and embodied, a material intelligence possessing body and parts, with body and parts and passions, like His Father in person whose glory and person He exactly represents, yet a distinct being from God the Father and not the Father Himself.RH Jun 8, 1869RH Aug 19, 1858
This proves God and Christ are not immaterial but material organized intelligences, and supports the teaching that Christ has a distinct form and personality and that creation in the image of God can refer to physical form.RH Oct 8, 1903RH Aug 19, 1858RH Jan 5, 1860
He took on Abraham's human lineage and is the promised Seed through whom Abraham's inheritance comes, and those who belong to Him by faith share in the blessing promised to Abraham.ST Feb 15, 1899
His bodily resurrection is the example, firstfruits, pledge and pattern of the resurrection of the just, when mortality puts on immortality.RH Apr 30, 1872ST Jun 6, 1916ST Aug 26, 1875
Because the resurrected saints will be like Him, they too will be real, bodily people with real, recognizable, touchable spiritual bodies of flesh and bones fashioned like His glorious body, suited to live on the material new earth and fitted to possess the earth and the material universe as an everlasting inheritance when redeemed from Adam's fall.RH Apr 30, 1872RH Aug 19, 1858
The body that came out of the grave was the same body that had been crucified, bearing the wounds that identified Him, and its recognizable features confirmed His identity, yet it was nevertheless glorified, able to appear among them and move away from earth in ways ordinary bodies cannot.RH Jul 29, 1875
His eating further shows He had a material body after the resurrection, and His hands and feet showed the disciples He was truly Himself, not a spirit.RH Apr 30, 1872
Sunday and Sabbath Claim
The evening appearance gives no command, example, blessing or sanction for resting on the first day, for working from Sunday to Saturday, or for keeping Sunday as Sabbath, holy day or sacred observance in honor of the resurrection.RH May 1, 1900ST Nov 18, 1886ST Nov 11, 1889ST Oct 21, 1897ST Aug 6, 1912 He stood among the disciples while they were together eating supper with doors shut for fear of the Jews, terrified and supposing him a spirit, and rebuked their unbelief and showed his hands and his feet and invited them to handle him to prove he himself was bodily risen with flesh and bones, and ate before them.RH May 1, 1900ST Apr 12, 1883ST Nov 18, 1886ST Nov 11, 1889 That proving work was meant to convince them of the resurrection and make them witnesses to it, not to establish the first day as Sabbath or sacred day, and it disproves any first-day sabbath.ST Nov 18, 1886ST Nov 11, 1889ST Oct 21, 1897ST Aug 6, 1912 They were not gathered to celebrate or honor the resurrection and were not keeping the day as a Sabbath or in any way in honor of that event, since they still doubted and he rebuked their unbelief, so the meeting was not a religious gathering to celebrate Sunday.ST Oct 5, 1882RH May 1, 1900ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jun 6, 1900
They were not celebrating the resurrection, worshiping, or keeping the day, for they disbelieved the reports of the women and the Emmaus witnesses, mourned, disputed, and needed rebuke.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Feb 20, 1879ST Jun 6, 1900 They were gathered in their ordinary dwelling and common abode for an evening meal and sitting at meat behind shut doors for fear of the Jews, in the midst of a day of confusion and activity rather than a religious assembly held to honor the resurrection.ST Oct 5, 1882RH May 1, 1900ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jun 6, 1900 They could see and touch him, and he had flesh and bones unlike a spirit, yet while eating supper at home they still did not believe he had risen, which proves they were not keeping that day to commemorate the resurrection since they did not yet believe it had happened.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Feb 20, 1879ST Jun 6, 1900 He made no reference to that day and gave no instruction to observe it, and his greeting of peace on the first day does not establish that day as a Sabbath.ST Apr 12, 1883ST Aug 24, 1888ST Oct 21, 1897ST Jun 6, 1900RH Feb 11, 1858
He said and did nothing there honoring, mentioning or appointing the first day to holy use, sanctifying it as the Father sanctified the seventh, changing the Sabbath to the first day or to ascension day, or taking the first day upon his lips, which is inconsistent with any change.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Nov 14, 1871 He entered their common lodging while they ate their evening meal after the Emmaus return, not to commend their celebration of his resurrection but to upbraid them for unbelief respecting it.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Nov 14, 1871 It was only this one first day on which he thus met with them, and neither his appearing, his breathing the Holy Spirit upon them, nor anything else he said or did gives even remote indication of a purpose to change the Sabbath.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Nov 14, 1871 Nothing there is inconsistent with the commandment that the seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Nov 14, 1871
The resurrection day was a busy day of secular activity, travel, confusion, anxiety and unrest, not rest or worship.ST Oct 5, 1882RH Aug 1, 1871RH Dec 16, 1858 He walked seven and a half miles to Emmaus and fifteen miles in all without rebuke, taught as before, and pronounced peace, proving the first day had not become Sabbath.RH Aug 1, 1871RH Dec 16, 1858RH May 5, 1851 He spent the day doing the very same prophetic teaching work he did before his crucifixion, instructing the two disciples on the way to Emmaus and meeting and teaching the eleven at the close of the day, which proves he did not cease from his work of redemption on the first day.RH Aug 1, 1871RH May 5, 1851 The gathering was not a daytime worship meeting or worship assembly for the first day but a night appearance after the return to Jerusalem, with Thomas absent and most present still not believing he had risen, so it shows no regard for the first day on account of the resurrection.RH Aug 1, 1871RH May 5, 1851 He gave no teaching about a new Sabbath at that favorable opportunity and gave no rebuke for the fifteen miles traveled that day, and the resurrection day cannot be called the Lord's day on the ground that the Lord rested on it.RH Aug 1, 1871RH Dec 16, 1858RH May 5, 1851
He appeared to convince unbelievers and qualify them as witnesses who saw him that third day to fulfill Moses, prophets and Psalms that Christ should suffer and rise the third day and to refute the Jews' hired soldiers, not to consecrate the first day.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905 He proved to his terrified disciples that he was no phantom or spirit but his real self with flesh and bones, showing his hands and his feet and telling them to handle him and see, and eating a piece of broiled fish and honeycomb before them to convince them.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905 Having been crucified on the preparation the sixth day, he must rise the third day to fulfill what was written in the law of Moses and the prophets and the Psalms concerning the Messiah.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905 He must have witnesses who had seen him on that day to testify that he rose on that day and to refute the lying testimony of the Jews and the hired soldiers, so the object of the meeting was to qualify the disciples as witnesses of these things, not to consecrate the first day as the Christian Sabbath.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Apr 20, 1905
Those who held the opposing position taught that by this and repeated meetings after rising, the descent of the Spirit and weekly assemblies he honored and hallowed the first day as his own Lord's day while after resurrection paying no regard to the seventh day.RH Apr 29, 1873 The resurrection is also described as bringing the true rest foreshadowed by the ancient Sabbath to its completion and ending its ceremonial shadows.ST Jan 2, 1879
Person, Return and Hope
The same literal, corporeal Jesus with flesh and bones who could be seen and touched and handled is the one who was taken up into heaven and will come again in like manner as a real, personal, visible bodily return, not merely a spiritual or figurative coming to believers.ST Jan 15, 1902ST Jan 11, 1883ST Nov 8, 1910ST Aug 27, 1885ST May 15, 1907 He identified himself by the words It is I Myself and offered his wounded hands and feet and side to be seen, examined and touched, proving he was not merely a spirit but tangible and bodily.ST Jan 15, 1902ST Jan 11, 1883ST Aug 27, 1885 The one who rose was the same person who had been crucified and buried, who broke bread and ate and drank and walked and talked with the disciples, who spent forty days with them and then ascended in that same body.ST Jan 11, 1883ST Nov 8, 1910ST May 15, 1907 He remained bodily the same Jesus when he ascended, and that supports hope in his personal return and in the resurrection of the just in his glorified divine and human person.ST Jan 11, 1883ST Aug 27, 1885
His bodily presence establishes that heaven is personal and substantial and connected with Jesus whom they knew and loved, not indefinite space tenanted by intangible spirits without substance.ST Nov 22, 1883ST Oct 31, 1878ST May 13, 1903 The proof by seeing and handling his risen physical body and by his eating changed the disciples' conception of his mission, showing he truly came to bring repentance and to remit sins.ST Oct 31, 1878ST Jun 11, 1896 In the near future he will come again to abolish all sin and re-create the earth as an eternal, actual, tangible dwelling-place for his saints, a real home with him like Eden restored and a new heavens and new earth for an eternal tangible dwelling and inheritance.ST Jun 11, 1896ST May 13, 1903ST Apr 22, 1875 The disciples had conversed and journeyed with him and handled him even in his resurrected body while he spoke hope and comfort to them, so heaven could no longer appear as an indefinite, incomprehensible region of unlimited space filled with intangible spirits but was looked upon as their future home.ST Nov 22, 1883ST Oct 31, 1878ST Apr 22, 1875
His appearances during the forty days before his ascension were real encounters in which they could handle him as flesh and bones unlike a spirit or phantom, not his second coming, which could occur only after he had ascended and gone away.RH Jun 25, 1872 On the very day of resurrection he ascended to the Father and returned, having been in God's presence sometime between telling Mary in the morning that he had not yet ascended, as recorded in John 20:17, and appearing in the evening.RH Mar 30, 1876ST Nov 30, 1915
He stood in person among the disciples gathered in the upper chamber in Jerusalem and proved the certainty of his resurrection in the same crucified body with flesh and bones, lifting in blessing the same hands that had been pierced on the cross.ST Oct 14, 1889 His greeting Peace be unto you met disciples bowed in sorrow and unbelief despite the reports of the women and the testimony of the two from Emmaus that he was known in the breaking of bread, and confirmed their renewed faith.ST Oct 14, 1889 After revealing himself to those traveling to Emmaus and to those gathered in Jerusalem, he opened Moses and the prophets to show that Scripture had foretold his birth, life, mission, death and resurrection and was fulfilled in him. This revived hope that though their hopes had been buried with him he lived and would reign on the throne of David, helping them accept him as the Son of God and the promised Messiah.ST Oct 14, 1889
Comfort and Assurance
His pierced hands and feet prove that he who did no sin truly died the cursed death of the cross, shedding precious blood to meet the need of the broken law so that man can taste bliss.ST Aug 8, 1878 Looking at those wounds in love awakens the hidden life within.ST Aug 8, 1878 Behold his hands teaches to look to Jesus alone for how faith is obtained, for he took away sin and redeemed the sinner, and as Mediator who has overcome he gives peace to those who believe the gospel, since salvation comes by his work and not by human works.ST Aug 16, 1883
His hands and feet answer any question whether he loves people, bearing on his very body the marks and proofs of his love for them.RH Nov 17, 1863 That love proved there is strong, ardent, constant and active, so high and deep and long and broad that its dimensions cannot be comprehended and it passes knowledge, in contrast to human love for him which is weak, cold, fickle, indolent, limited and minute, with nothing done or suffered to point to as proof.RH Nov 17, 1863 His scars in head, side, hands and feet attest that those who trust in him have had their sins washed away through his blood, and the judgment record will show whether faith is fixed in him as the one who gave his life as ransom and whether hope is anchored within the heavenly veil.ST May 18, 1904
His greeting Peace be unto you and showing of hands and feet reassured disciples who were grieving and ashamed of their unfaithfulness, that they might be peaceful and strong in him, a message of peace and brotherhood for all time and the whole household of believers. His presence in the church through the Holy Spirit is just as real and as searching as his bodily standing among the disciples and displaying his hands and feet. That proof stands between the cross and the sepulcher and the meeting in Galilee where he comforted, instructed and established them, and the ascension in majesty with his ransomed captives to be visibly absent until he comes as conqueror.RH Aug 13, 1872 The fact is to be fixed indelibly on the mind not as mere opinion but as living reality, much thought of and realized, so as to leaven the whole character and life, renewing and strengthening all that is holy and pure and uprooting all that is wicked.RH Aug 13, 1872
A spirit does not have flesh and bones, distinguishing a spirit from a physically embodied person, so that Michael contending over Moses' body cannot be reduced to a spirit contending with fleshly lusts.RH Jun 26, 1856 In its plain natural sense the risen Christ appeared bodily to his disciples and invited them to touch him, proving he was not a spirit but had a tangible body of flesh and bones.RH Jun 25, 1872 This distinguishes his physical post-resurrection appearance from claims that a deceased person might manifest in physical form, for his was a real tangible body of flesh and bones, not the body of a spirit.RH Jun 25, 1872RH Feb 16, 1911
His bodily presence after the resurrection attests that he fully shared human nature, with a real tangible human body like ours that could be seen and touched, its hands and feet bearing wounds.ST Dec 22, 1887ST Apr 11, 1878 He proves he is still man, still God manifest in the flesh, not pure Spirit, and that same Jesus, God in the flesh, was received up into glory and shall come again in like manner, because the Son was given to humanity forever, not merely loaned for his earthly life. His resurrection was not merely his spirit leaving his dead body at death, but happened after he had lain in the grave with his body missing from the tomb, confirmed by his invitation to handle him and his eating before the disciples.ST Apr 3, 1884 It is confirmed by eyewitnesses who saw and spoke with him and saw him ascend, showing he was the same person crucified and buried, alive again in a tangible body that ate, drank and spoke with followers rather than as a spirit.RH Oct 7, 1862RH Oct 7, 1862
He proved to the eleven that he is the same One who was crucified, showing pierced hands and feet and wounded side, letting them handle him, eating with them, and laying open the straight chain of prophecy about himself, so there was no room for unbelief in their minds about his identity.ST Oct 10, 1878 He demonstrated his identity by showing them the body that had been slain, with yet open wounds.RH Nov 21, 1871RH Aug 13, 1872 His risen body retained the form of the Son of Man, the same real bodily person the disciples knew, whom they could see and touch, his flesh and bones showing he was not a spirit.ST Nov 8, 1910
Sources