Mark 16:14
Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
Translations
Afterward he appeared to the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Afterward he appeared unto the eleven as they sat at meat, and upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
Afterward he appeared to the eleven, as they sat at table, and upbraided them with their unbelief, and hardness of heart, because they believed not them who had seen him after he was risen.
And afterward he was manifested unto the eleven themselves as they sat at meat; and he upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them which had seen him after he was risen.
And afterward he was manifested unto the eleven themselves as they sat at meat; and he upbraided them with their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they believed not them that had seen him after he was risen.
Afterwards, as they are reclining (at meat), he was manifested to the eleven, and did reproach their unbelief and stiffness of heart, because they believed not those having seen him being raised;
Afterwards as they lay at table he was manifested to the eleven, and reproached [ them with] their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they had not believed those who had seen him risen.
But, afterwards, unto the eleven themselves, as they reclined, was he manifested, and he upbraided their disbelief and hardness of heart,—because, them who had looked upon him when arisen [from among the dead] they believed not;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Later, as they were eating, Jesus appeared to the Eleven and rebuked them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they did not believe those who had seen Him after He had risen.
Afterward he was revealed to the eleven themselves as they sat at the table; and he rebuked them for their unbelief and hardness of heart, because they didn’ t believe those who had seen him after he had risen.
And later he was seen by the eleven themselves while they were taking food; and he said sharp words to them because they had no faith and their hearts were hard, and because they had no belief in those who had seen him after he had come back from the dead.
Finally, he appeared vnto the eleuen as they sate together, and reproched them for their vnbeliefe and hardnesse of heart, because they beleeued not them which had seene him, being risen vp againe.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
At length he appeared to the eleven as they were at table: and he upbraided them with their incredulity and hardness of heart, because they did not believe them who had seen him after he was risen again.
Cross-references 20 of 45
- John 20:19-20
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
Jesus appears to the gathered disciples on the resurrection evening and shows them his wounds.
- Luke 24:36-43
And as they thus spake, Jesus himself stood in the midst of them, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
Jesus appears to the gathered disciples, addresses their doubts, and eats to show he is bodily present.
- Acts 1:13
And when they were come in, they went up into an upper room, where abode both Peter, and James, and John, and Andrew, Philip, and Thomas, Bartholomew, and Matthew, James the son of Alphaeus, and Simon Zelotes, and Judas the brother of James.
Identifies the upper room where the disciples gathered together.
- John 20:26-29
And after eight days again his disciples were within, and Thomas with them: then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst, and said, Peace be unto you.
Jesus appears to the disciples again, addresses Thomas’s doubt, and commends belief without seeing.
- Luke 24:13-35
And, behold, two of them went that same day to a village called Emmaus, which was from Jerusalem about threescore furlongs.
The Emmaus disciples saw the risen Jesus and reported it to the eleven.
- John 21:1-14
After these things Jesus shewed himself again to the disciples at the sea of Tiberias; and on this wise shewed he himself.
Jesus appears to his disciples while they are fishing after his resurrection.
- Luke 24:11
And their words seemed to them as idle tales, and they believed them not.
The disciples do not believe the women’s report of Jesus’ resurrection.
- Acts 1:3
To whom also he shewed himself alive after his passion by many infallible proofs, being seen of them forty days, and speaking of the things pertaining to the kingdom of God:
Jesus appeared to the disciples during the forty days after his resurrection.
- Luke 24:34
Saying, The Lord is risen indeed, and hath appeared to Simon.
Reports that the risen Lord appeared to Simon, despite the disciples’ unbelief.
- Luke 24:37
But they were terrified and affrighted, and supposed that they had seen a spirit.
The disciples react in disbelief when Jesus appears to them.
- Mark 16:9
Now when Jesus was risen early the first day of the week, he appeared first to Mary Magdalene, out of whom he had cast seven devils.
Mary Magdalene’s report of seeing the risen Jesus was not believed.
- Luke 24:41-43
And while they yet believed not for joy, and wondered, he said unto them, Have ye here any meat?
eating food proves common meal setting
- Matthew 28:9
And as they went to tell his disciples, behold, Jesus met them, saying, All hail. And they came and held him by the feet, and worshipped him.
The risen Jesus appears to the women, while Mark records his later appearance to the eleven.
- Luke 24:1
Now upon the first day of the week, very early in the morning, they came unto the sepulchre, bringing the spices which they had prepared, and certain others with them.
records resurrection on the first day
- John 20:14-18
And when she had thus said, she turned herself back, and saw Jesus standing, and knew not that it was Jesus.
The risen Jesus appears to Mary Magdalene and sends her to tell the disciples.
- Matthew 28:19-20
Go ye therefore, and teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost:
Christ commissions His disciples to teach and baptize all nations.
- 1 Corinthians 15:5
And that he was seen of Cephas, then of the twelve:
Lists Jesus’ appearance to the Twelve.
- John 20:24
But Thomas, one of the twelve, called Didymus, was not with them when Jesus came.
Thomas was absent when Jesus met the disciples.
- Mark 16:10
And she went and told them that had been with him, as they mourned and wept.
The disciples mourned and wept after hearing the resurrection report.
- John 20:1
The first day of the week cometh Mary Magdalene early, when it was yet dark, unto the sepulchre, and seeth the stone taken away from the sepulchre.
Both texts recount events of the resurrection day.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
12 sources
After His resurrection and just before His ascension Jesus appeared to the eleven while they were eating and rebuked them for unbelief and hardness of heart because they had not believed those who had seen Him after He was risen.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15 That rebuke came as He was about to leave them with a work to be understood and taken hold of intelligently, and it leads directly into His command to go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15 The commission promises salvation to him who believes and is baptized and condemnation to him who believes not, promises signs following believers, and is followed by His reception up into heaven to sit at the right hand of God while the disciples went forth and preached everywhere with the Lord working with them and confirming the message.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15Lt 44, 1901, par. 3–5 Unbelief always hardens the heart, and if cherished brings it to a state where it is unresponsive, while faith trusts what is hoped for and gives assurance of what cannot be seen.16MR 229.3Ms 185, 1903, par. 12–15Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55 The disciples met this failure with repentance and confession, were comforted by remembering His words and knowing they were forgiven, and resolved to make amends as far as they could by bravely bearing witness to Christ before the world, assured that He is with His workers to the end and will impart grace to perform whatever He assigns.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15AA 36.1
Setting and Rebuke
After the resurrection and just before the ascension Jesus appeared to the eleven while they were eating.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15Ms 154, 1904, par. 11–13 That meal gathering was the setting in which He confronted them with their failure.Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15
He upbraided them with unbelief and hardness of heart because they had not believed those who had seen Him after He was risen.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15Lt 135, 1900, par. 8–13Lt 44, 1901, par. 3–5 The reproof included Thomas, who had refused to accept his companions' report of the risen Lord. Their unbelief shows they were not gathered to celebrate the resurrection as a holy day.DA 842.2–8
The disciples later faced this failure with repentance and confession.AA 36.1 Remembering His words helped them understand what they had misunderstood, and they were comforted by knowing they were forgiven.AA 36.1 They resolved to make amends as far as they could by bravely bearing witness to Christ before the world.AA 36.1
Gospel Commission Entrusted
The rebuke was given when He was about to leave His disciples and entrust them with a work to be understood and taken hold of intelligently, and it leads directly into His command to go into all the world and preach the gospel to every creature.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15Lt 44, 1901, par. 3–5Ms 154, 1904, par. 11–13 That encounter after the resurrection, while the eleven were eating, thus becomes the setting for the worldwide gospel commission.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15
That commission promises salvation to him who believes and is baptized and condemnation to him who believes not, promises signs following believers, and is followed by His reception up into heaven to sit at the right hand of God while the disciples went forth and preached everywhere with the Lord working with them and confirming the message.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15Lt 44, 1901, par. 3–5 The disciples' task of teaching and baptizing connects with the gospel ministry's work of carrying God's final warning to the world.Ms 52, 1900, par. 13–14
The verse assures present workers, including preachers and canvassers, that Christ is with them to the end and will impart grace to perform whatever He assigns.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14Ms 154, 1904, par. 11–13 He works through those who are true and whole-hearted, so that with God nothing will be impossible and all sufficiency is of God.Lt 6, 1902, par. 11–14 Yet lack of faith among God's people can leave that missionary work nearly at a standstill.Ms 145, 1907, par. 1–2 When believers who are clustered together are converted they will hear and heed this commission and go out to work for sin-cursed cities.Lt 187, 1905, par. 10–15 Accepting Bible truth brings new hearts and changed speech, and believers go out preaching while the Lord works with them and confirms the message.Lt 44, 1901, par. 3–5
Unbelief, Faith, and Warning
Christ's rebuke for unbelief and hardness of heart because they would not believe the evidence of His resurrection presented to them shows that unbelief always hardens the heart.Ms 185, 1903, par. 12–15 If cherished, it brings the heart to a state where it is unresponsive.Ms 185, 1903, par. 12–15 In the disciples' case the resurrection was such good news they dared not believe it true lest they be disappointed.Ms 185, 1903, par. 12–15 Even when there is sufficient evidence to encourage faith, the mind seizes everything that would create darkness, and in their afflictions the Lord lets people remain in unbelief.Ms 185, 1903, par. 12–15
Unbelief is the occasion of all sin and the bond of iniquity, and its work is to twist what is straight and make crooked things that are straight.16MR 229.3Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55 Faith, by contrast, is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen, trusting what is hoped for and giving assurance of what cannot be seen.16MR 229.3Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55 When people become as little children, sitting at the feet of Jesus, learning of Him self-denial and what it is to live by faith in every word of God, then the soul finds rest and peace.16MR 229.3Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55
A woe rests upon all such unbelief and criticism.Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55 Those who persist in that course of unbelief erect a barrier that shuts out the great salvation and the riches of divine grace offered to them.Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55 Their failure to accept the testimony of those who witnessed His resurrection is a lesson for Christ's messengers: they must learn from Him and then faithfully preach the gospel He commanded.Lt 135, 1900, par. 8–13Ms 30, 1889, par. 51–55
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
75 sources
On the evening of the resurrection day the risen Jesus appeared to the eleven while they were eating their ordinary supper together behind shut doors in their home in Jerusalem, mourning and frightened and still refusing to believe those who had seen Him risen.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880ST Oct 4, 1899 He reproved them for their unbelief and hardness of heart because they had rejected the testimony of Mary Magdalene, the women, Peter, and the two travelers from Emmaus.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Apr 11, 1900ST Oct 4, 1899ST Apr 11, 1900 He then convinced them He was bodily alive and not a spirit by showing His hands and feet and side and eating before them, to comfort them and prepare them to witness to His resurrection to the world.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Sep 15, 1887ST Apr 11, 1900ST Dec 21, 1882 That meeting was no worship service and no celebration of the resurrection, since they did not yet believe He had risen, and He gave the day no blessing, no sacredness, and no command to keep it.ST Dec 2, 1880RH Mar 31, 1874ST Aug 24, 1888 It therefore gives no sanction for Sunday-keeping and no warrant for changing the Sabbath to the first day, even though it is counted as His meeting with them on the day He rose.ST Nov 18, 1886ST Jun 18, 1894ST Aug 27, 1885 The closing passage of Mark to which the verse belongs is genuine inspired Scripture, in harmony with the rest of the Bible, its absence from some copies being no proof against it.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Oct 10, 1911ST Dec 17, 1902
Authenticity of Passage
Mark 16:14 belongs to the common ending of Mark, the closing section from verse 9 to the end, the last twelve verses of the Gospel.ST Oct 10, 1911 That section is genuine Scripture and genuine inspiration, belonging with the rest of the Gospel with the same authority as what precedes it.ST Oct 10, 1911 It is in perfect harmony with the rest of Scripture and with the other Gospels, with nothing in it contrary to them, and it comes with weighty sanction and strong claims on reception and reverence.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Oct 10, 1911ST Dec 17, 1902 Its writing may have come later than the time Mark wrote the Gospel.ST Oct 10, 1911 The Revised Version retains these verses with a marginal note.
Its absence from some ancient copies and some early Greek manuscripts does not disprove its genuineness or prove it spurious.ST Nov 3, 1909 It is omitted by the two oldest Greek manuscripts and some other authorities, including the Sinaitic and Vatican manuscripts, but is found in some older manuscripts and is present in others.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Oct 10, 1911 The omission is readily explained by the easy loss of the last sheets of ancient transcribed books and by whole passages missing from early Gospel copies.ST Oct 10, 1911 Its presence in the Alexandrian, Beza, and Paris manuscripts and the Vulgate supports it, as does its quotation by Irenaeus in the second century.ST Nov 3, 1909 It was quoted in the second century, though in the third century nearly all Greek manuscripts did not contain it, which may be because those manuscripts were copies of one in which it was lost.ST Dec 17, 1902 It was placed as a completion of the Gospel in very early times, immediately after the apostolic period, as an authentic fragment, and the Gospel would be incomplete without it.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Dec 17, 1902 The verse belongs to the section Mark 16:8-20 whose genuineness is questioned.
Time Place Gathering
The appearance took place on the evening of the first day of the week after the resurrection, at the close of that day when it was nearly if not wholly past.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880ST Oct 4, 1899ST Aug 14, 1893 The eleven were together eating their ordinary evening supper at home in their common abode and private quarters in Jerusalem, in the upper room where they lived and were in the habit of eating and sleeping and eating and drinking.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880ST Oct 4, 1899RH Nov 19, 1872 It was not in the temple or synagogue and not at prayer, but a meal at their own lodging, the first time since the resurrection they were together with one exception.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880ST Oct 4, 1899RH Nov 19, 1872 Their gathering was not a religious meeting or a gathering to commemorate or celebrate the resurrection, since they did not believe reports from those who had seen Him risen.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880ST Oct 4, 1899ST Aug 14, 1893
They were gathered behind shut doors for fear of the Jews who had crucified the Lord, in retirement and comparative safety, hiding close together in the place of their familiar circumstances.ST Oct 4, 1899RH Nov 19, 1872ST Oct 5, 1882ST Aug 13, 1874 They were mourning and weeping with sadness at His death, after a day of mourning, doubts, and fears.ST Oct 4, 1899 They were in doubt, fear, anxiety, trouble, confusion and perplexity, in doubt and trouble during the first day, spending the day in bustle and activity and traveling.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Oct 5, 1882 Their meal was for a common meal and for safety, not to honor the resurrection.ST Oct 5, 1882ST Aug 13, 1874
By Bible reckoning that the day begins at sunset, the meeting came after sunset when the first day had ended and the second day had begun at night.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 13, 1882ST Nov 10, 1914ST Apr 13, 1882ST Aug 13, 1912 The resurrection first day had already passed, and it was night when the risen Jesus met the disciples.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Nov 10, 1914ST Aug 13, 1912 They had gathered at their regular home and shared lodging in Jerusalem, not by appointment, and the gathering began before the first day of the week ended.ST May 24, 1910ST Nov 10, 1914ST Aug 13, 1912 Jesus met them after the second day had begun, at the evening meal meeting after His resurrection.ST May 24, 1910ST Apr 13, 1882ST Nov 10, 1914ST Apr 13, 1882
It is counted as the one recorded meeting of Christ with His disciples on a first day and as part of the record of His appearances on the day He rose.ST Jun 18, 1894ST Aug 27, 1885RH Jun 24, 1873ST Jun 10, 1886ST Aug 6, 1912 It records one of Christ's appearances to the disciples on the day of His resurrection, among the accounts cited for the first meeting after the resurrection, to proclaim that He had risen.ST Jun 18, 1894ST Aug 27, 1885RH Jun 24, 1873 It is not evidence that He met with them on every first day or meant to establish that day as a Sabbath.ST Jun 18, 1894ST Aug 27, 1885ST Oct 21, 1897 In none of His appearances on that day did He tell them the first day was a holy day, but the appearance was to show them that He was alive and risen.ST Oct 21, 1897ST Aug 6, 1912
Rebuke for Unbelief
As they sat at meat Jesus upbraided and reproved them with unbelief and hardness of heart because until that time they had not believed those who had seen Him after He was risen.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Nov 18, 1886 The rebuke followed their disbelief of the two travelers who had seen Him on the way into the country, and the parallel account in Luke describes His showing His hands and feet and eating before them to confirm He was truly risen, then explaining that the Scriptures concerning Him had to be fulfilled and opening their minds to understand them.ST Apr 11, 1900 His appearing served to convince the disciples that He was alive and to prepare them to witness to His resurrection.ST Nov 18, 1886 Their response shows they did not yet accept the resurrection reports. The appearance came after a day of mourning, doubts, and fears.
The rejected witnesses were Mary Magdalene to whom He had appeared first, the women, Peter, and the two to whom He had appeared in another form on the way into the country to Emmaus.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Aug 24, 1888 The rebuke followed disbelief of those two travelers and of the women's report dismissed as idle tales.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Oct 17, 1878ST Apr 3, 1901 His appearance came after the women and the two disciples from Emmaus had told them what they had seen.ST Nov 11, 1889 At that appearing He confirmed the testimony of the two disciples met on the way to Emmaus while reproving the eleven for not believing that testimony.ST Apr 11, 1900
Most were not convinced until near the end of the first day.ST Mar 16, 1882 At the meeting linked to this verse they were frightened and did not believe that He had risen, were not gathered expecting to meet Him, and when He appeared they were terrified and affrighted instead of hailing Him.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Apr 15, 1889ST Mar 11, 1889 Even when He appeared to them they were frightened and thought they saw a spirit or phantom, supposing their cause was lost, and He showed them His hands and feet and ate food before them to demonstrate that He had risen bodily.ST Apr 3, 1901 Their failure to believe came because they did not know the Scripture that He must rise.ST Apr 3, 1901 They had spent the day in bustle and activity and traveling, in doubt and fear and anxiety and unbelief that He had risen.ST Mar 11, 1889
Thomas was not present when Jesus came, for a cause not stated.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Feb 10, 1887 Probably it was because he had not yet seen Him since the resurrection.ST Aug 8, 1878 The reproof also applied to Thomas who had not believed his companions' report. It is counted as the fifth recorded appearance, when Thomas was absent, and the disciples had seen Him repeatedly before some still doubted.RH Apr 12, 1860ST Nov 24, 1898 Their unbelief tested their faith in His earlier appointment to meet them in Galilee, for the eleven did not believe the women who reported that He had risen and appeared to them, and when He appeared to the eleven in person that night He rebuked them for not believing His messengers.ST Jun 8, 1904
Purpose and Proofs Given
He came on that very day in mercy to comfort hearts breaking with sadness at His death and to see them together again as of old, resuming active life and convincing them that He had risen and was bodily alive.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 4, 1899 They had spent the day in mourning and weeping, in doubts and fears behind shut doors for fear of the Jews, still not believing He had risen, so their evening meal together in the upper room at Jerusalem was no service to commemorate the resurrection.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 4, 1899 It was the first time since the resurrection they were together with one exception, gathered after they had heard the witnesses' reports yet believed neither Mary Magdalene to whom He had appeared first nor the two to whom He had appeared in another form on the way into the country.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Oct 4, 1899 When He appeared and they recognized Him, the mourning disciples were refreshed and made glad together, which confirmed that He was alive.ST Sep 15, 1887ST Nov 11, 1908
He relieved their sorrow with infallible proofs that He was truly risen, greeting them, breathing on them, showing His hands and His feet and His side, and calling for food and eating before them.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Aug 24, 1888 The rebuke followed their disbelief of the two disciples seen on the way into the country, as well as of Mary, the women, Peter and the two who walked into the country, whose reports they had refused to believe.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Aug 24, 1888 Even when He stood among them they were frightened and thought they saw a spirit, and He demonstrated that He had risen bodily and was a real, substantial being and not a phantom.ST Dec 21, 1882ST Feb 3, 1887 The parallel account describes the same showing of hands and feet and eating before them, with explanation that the Scriptures concerning Him had to be fulfilled and the opening of their minds to understand them.ST Apr 11, 1900
His appearing confirmed the testimony of the two met on the way to Emmaus and convinced the eleven that He was alive, reproving them for not believing that testimony.ST Nov 18, 1886ST Apr 11, 1900RH Oct 21, 1873RH Oct 22, 1872 By that convincing He prepared them to witness to His resurrection and kept the preaching commission before the assembled disciples on the evening of resurrection day.ST Nov 18, 1886RH Oct 21, 1873ST Jan 9, 1893 It was one of several appearances to His disciples during the forty days between resurrection and ascension, distinct from His future public appearing to the world.RH Aug 31, 1869 He had rested in the tomb on the Sabbath and resumed active work on the first day, giving ocular demonstration that He rose according to the Scriptures, which proves only that He had the right to meet His disciples on any day He chose for reasons that seemed good to Him.ST Aug 8, 1878
Those who held it placed this interview at meat on the after-eight-days occasion when Thomas was with them, probably because Thomas had not yet seen Him since the resurrection.ST Aug 8, 1878 That resurrection day itself was a day of bustle and activity, as when He joined two disciples for a long walk to Emmaus and met the eleven at Jerusalem the same evening, and not a day of rest, so resting on that day is not fitted to memorialize the resurrection. Burial by baptism and rising from the water shows faith in His resurrection, and the resurrection itself cannot be changed to another day.
Parallel Gospel Accounts
The appearing to the eleven as they sat at meat is the same appearing described in John 20:19, when they were gathered behind shut doors to eat their evening meal.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Jul 22, 1897 The parallel account in Luke describes Him showing His hands and His feet and eating before them to confirm that He was truly risen, then explaining that the Scriptures concerning Him had to be fulfilled and opening their minds to understand them.ST Apr 11, 1900 Differences between Mark's resurrection account and the other Gospels do not by themselves imply contradiction, since each reports some events and omits others.ST Mar 5, 1912 Their unbelief and hardness of heart because they did not believe those who had seen Him after He rose shows they had no faith in the resurrection at the time of the gathering described in John 20:19, so they were not meeting to commemorate it.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Mar 11, 1880ST Mar 11, 1880
Whether this interview with the eleven is the same one recorded in John 20:19 is raised as a question for study.RH May 5, 1863 Mark 16:14 with Luke 24:13 is a plain scriptural rebuttal to the claim that the disciples began keeping the first day because they met to commemorate the resurrection.RH Sep 4, 1856
After Jesus was recognized at Emmaus when supper was ready and vanished, the two arose the same hour and walked back more than eight miles to Jerusalem, found the eleven together, and told them Jesus was risen indeed, but they did not believe them. Then Jesus Himself stood in their midst in the very last moments of the first day, on that Sunday evening of the same first day on whose morning the women had gone to the sepulcher, by which time that first day was nearly if not wholly past.ST Sep 15, 1887 He said Peace be unto you and convinced them that the same Jesus who was crucified was really risen by showing His hands, His feet, and His side and by calling for food and eating in their presence. Thomas was not present when Jesus came.ST Sep 15, 1887
His salutation Peace be unto you was not said only once on that day but again after eight days, as late as the second or third day of the week.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Feb 11, 1858 His breathing on them with Receive ye the Holy Ghost affected the disciples and not the day, giving no hint of sacredness to the day itself.ST Aug 24, 1888 Saying peace does not make a day holy, and example alone proves nothing for a change of the Sabbath.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Feb 11, 1858 Their having food at hand as they sat eating together explains how they could give Him a meal when He appeared that evening.ST Sep 2, 1886 This appearing while they sat at a meal explains His later appearance when Thomas was present after eight days.RH Nov 29, 1853
No Sunday Authority
The gathering was simply the eleven eating their ordinary evening supper at home in their common abode and private quarters where they lived and were in the habit of eating and drinking and sleeping, not in the temple or synagogue and not at prayer.ST Dec 2, 1880ST Jul 1, 1880RH Nov 19, 1872RH Oct 23, 1866RH Dec 1, 1874 It was not a religious service for worship, not an appointed worship assembly, and not a gathering expecting to meet Him, but merely partaking of a meal together in retirement and comparative safety behind shut doors for fear of the Jews who had crucified the Lord.ST Jul 1, 1880RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882RH Dec 1, 1874RH Sep 10, 1857 Being in unbelief and hardness of heart for not believing those who had seen Him risen, they were in a frame to be censured rather than applauded.ST Jul 1, 1880RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882
They were not holding a service to commemorate or celebrate the resurrection or to honor the day, since they still doubted and did not believe He had risen.ST Dec 2, 1880RH Aug 18, 1868ST Aug 14, 1893 When He appeared they were frightened, terrified and affrighted instead of hailing Him, supposing their cause was lost, and they needed convincing by infallible proofs to relieve their sorrow.ST Mar 11, 1889RH Apr 14, 1874 They could not have celebrated a resurrection they did not believe had happened, having dismissed the women's report as idle tales and disbelieved Mary Magdalene, the women, Peter, and the two who walked into the country to Emmaus.ST Jul 1, 1880RH Aug 18, 1868ST Aug 24, 1888
At that meeting He made no reference to the day, pronounced no blessing on it, gave no command to henceforth observe the first day in honor of His resurrection, and gave the day no semblance of sacredness.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Sep 10, 1857ST Oct 17, 1878 The verse calls the day neither Sabbath nor holy, says nothing about a change of the Sabbath, and gives the first day no new sacredness.RH Sep 10, 1857ST Oct 17, 1878ST Jul 22, 1897 His salutation Peace be unto you and His breathing on them with Receive ye the Holy Ghost affected the disciples and not the day, giving not the remotest hint of Sunday sacredness.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Feb 11, 1858
The occurrence gives no evidence that by joining them under familiar circumstances He designed to authorize a change of worship to the resurrection day, no sanction for Sunday-keeping, no proof that the sacredness of the seventh day was transferred to the first day, no consecration of the first day, and no example of a first-day worship meeting or of early Christians customarily worshiping on the first day.ST Nov 18, 1886RH Nov 19, 1872ST Mar 16, 1882RH Mar 31, 1874 His appearance served to convince the disciples that He was alive and to prepare them to witness to His resurrection, not to institute or observe the first day as a Sabbath.ST Nov 18, 1886ST Jul 23, 1894 Their unbelief explains why they had not gathered earlier to honor the first day as a sacred day.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jul 23, 1894
Even if all His meetings with them had been on the first day it would prove nothing for the sacredness of the first day, since example alone proves nothing.RH Aug 1, 1912RH Feb 11, 1858 A first-day interview rebuking unbelief cannot stand against the express edict fixing the Sabbath to a certain day, uttered by God's own voice and engraved by His own finger on tables of stone.RH Aug 1, 1912RH Dec 17, 1857 Saying peace does not make a day holy, since the same greeting was spoken again after eight days, as late as the second or third day of the week, which would make that weekday equally holy.ST Aug 24, 1888RH Feb 11, 1858
The meeting was not an assembly He had called on the resurrection day and does not begin a gradual sanctification of the first day during the forty days of Acts 1:3 or establish it as a model for regular gatherings.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Apr 13, 1882 By Bible reckoning that the day begins at sunset, it came after sunset when the first day had ended and the second day had begun at night, so it does not show Him making that day sacred by meeting with them.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Apr 13, 1882ST Aug 13, 1912 He did not call them together on that day.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Aug 13, 1912
Their first day after the Sabbath was not a day of unbroken joy but of sorrow, doubt, mourning, and hardness continuing until He appeared, spent in bustle and activity and traveling, in fear and anxiety and trouble, confusion and perplexity.RH Feb 27, 1872ST Mar 11, 1889ST Aug 13, 1912 If they changed the Sabbath that day they did so in unbelief, so the apostles could not have changed it from the seventh to the first day on that day.RH Feb 27, 1872ST Dec 15, 1881RH Apr 14, 1874 By that reckoning it proves the day was a common ordinary secular day of ordinary activity rather than Sabbath observance, with no sacredness or Sabbath character attached to it, the disciples disturbed, distracted, divided, and in general unbelief about His resurrection and not keeping a first new Sabbath.ST Mar 11, 1889ST Aug 13, 1912
Gospel Commission Entrusted
Mark 16:14-20 introduces Christ's authoritative and urgent commission to his disciples to gather believers and take the gospel throughout the whole world.ST Jun 24, 1889RH Aug 29, 1854 That gospel entrusted to the apostles was to be preached to everyone, throughout the world and to all nations before the end.ST Jun 24, 1889RH Dec 9, 1851
The commission follows the costly work of salvation in which Christ gave his life to provide pardon and peace.ST Jun 24, 1889 Yet salvation is offered freely to all, and those who receive this gift are responsible for carrying its message and its light to others.ST Jun 24, 1889
At this appearing to the eleven as they ate after his resurrection, Jesus kept the preaching commission before the assembled disciples.ST Jan 9, 1893 Identified as Christ's commission in Mark 16:14-18, it will be revived in the final proclamation of the message.RH Oct 23, 1900
Lessons for Faith
Unbelief was general among the disciples after the resurrection, for they dismissed the report of the women as idle tales and mourned and wept because they supposed their cause was lost.ST Apr 3, 1901 Jesus reproved the eleven for refusing to believe those who had seen Him alive after He rose, and their failure to believe eyewitness testimony was unbelief and hardness of heart.ST Apr 3, 1901 Such testimony was sufficient evidence of the resurrection, yet they did not believe because they did not know the Scripture that He must rise.ST Apr 3, 1901
That some apostles were slow to accept that Jesus had risen even after others who had seen Him told them illustrates that the disciples could misunderstand or resist truth about future events.ST Nov 27, 1879 Their mistaken expectations do not prove that those events would occur in the order or at the time they supposed.ST Nov 27, 1879 Unbelief and hardened hearts can likewise lead people to reject God's message even when it is proclaimed with great urgency.ST Nov 12, 1894 Signs of the end cannot awaken those who refuse the message of Scripture, and even a warning from someone raised from the dead would not persuade them.ST Nov 12, 1894
They had greater privileges than Mary, yet they failed to believe her testimony and that of the other women who had seen Him alive after His resurrection.ST Apr 10, 1901 Jesus rebuked the apostles for this unbelief and hardness of heart in not believing Mary and the other women.ST Apr 10, 1901 In contrast He enlightened and employed Mary rather than criticizing her lack of faith, and that work could strengthen her faith.ST Apr 10, 1901
Sources