Luke 9:46
Then there arose a reasoning among them, which of them should be greatest.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Then there arose a reasoning among them, which of them should be greatest.
And there arose a reasoning among them, which of them should be greatest.
And there arose a reasoning among them, which of them was the greatest.
And there entered a reasoning among them, this, Who may be greater of them?
And a reasoning came in amongst them, who should be [ the] greatest of them.
But there entered a reasoning among them, as to who of them should be greatest.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then an argument started among the disciples as to which of them would be the greatest.
An argument arose among them about which of them was the greatest.
Now there was a discussion among them about which of them would be the greatest.
Then there arose a disputation among them, which of them should be the greatest.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And there entered a thought into them, which of them should be greater.
Cross-references
- Mark 9:33-35
And he came to Capernaum: and being in the house he asked them, What was it that ye disputed among yourselves by the way?
The disciples dispute who is greatest, and Jesus teaches them to serve.
- Matthew 18:1-4
At the same time came the disciples unto Jesus, saying, Who is the greatest in the kingdom of heaven?
Jesus teaches that becoming humble like a child makes one greatest in the kingdom.
- Luke 22:24
And there was also a strife among them, which of them should be accounted the greatest.
Both describe a dispute over who is greatest.
- Mark 10:37
They said unto him, Grant unto us that we may sit, one on thy right hand, and the other on thy left hand, in thy glory.
James and John seek places of honor beside Christ.
- Matthew 20:20-28
Then came to him the mother of Zebedee’s children with her sons, worshipping him, and desiring a certain thing of him.
A dispute over greatness prompts Jesus’ teaching that greatness means serving others.
- John 13:14-16
If I then, your Lord and Master, have washed your feet; ye also ought to wash one another’s feet.
Jesus answers the disciples’ strife over greatness by serving them and teaching that the servant is not greater than his lord.
- Luke 9:55
But he turned, and rebuked them, and said, Ye know not what manner of spirit ye are of.
Jesus rebukes the disciples’ self-seeking spirit.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
2 sources
Luke 9:46 belongs to Luke 9:26-62, which must be studied together to grasp its meaning.Ms 72, 1911, par. 1–5 It records a dispute that arose among the disciples over which of them should be considered greatest in the kingdom.DA 432.1–2 The rivalry broke out even while Jesus was telling them that He would be betrayed and killed and raised again.DA 432.1–2 They did not understand His words about His coming death and resurrection.DA 432.1–2
They tried to hide their dispute over greatness from Him.DA 432.1–2 He spoke these things while still reflecting light in the world, when the time was nearly come for Him to be taken from the disciples, and He wanted them to remember all He had said.Ms 72, 1911, par. 1–5 He wanted them to remember in preparation for coming trials and persecutions everywhere.Ms 72, 1911, par. 1–5 Studying this passage brings hearts into full harmony with Christ and intelligent understanding of His work and what He will do for those who follow on to know the Lord, whose going forth is prepared as the morning with continual increase of light.Ms 72, 1911, par. 1–5
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
17 sources
The disciples fell to arguing among themselves over rank and status, each claiming to deserve the highest place and the greatest favor from their Master.ST Sep 27, 1910ST Mar 22, 1899 The dispute grew out of pride, selfish ambition and comparisons over standing and success, and out of their continuing expectation that Christ would set up an earthly government with offices and rewards to distribute.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jul 12, 1899RH Mar 13, 1856 Jesus answered by setting a little child among them, teaching that the least is great and that true greatness comes through becoming humble and the servant of all.RH Feb 10, 1916ST May 14, 1894ST May 14, 1894ST Oct 27, 1881 Such childlike humility, dependence on God, self-denial and unselfish love are not only the path to honor but the condition of entering His kingdom.ST Oct 27, 1881 By cherishing selfishness instead of humility they grieved the Holy Spirit and lost their power to cast out devils and heal, a power not regained until unity, humility and love came at Pentecost.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Mar 19, 1914
Dispute in Context
Luke 9:46 records a debating and reasoning that arose among the disciples over which of them should be greatest.ST Sep 27, 1910ST Jul 12, 1899ST May 14, 1894ST May 14, 1894 It was an argument and a dispute among themselves about rank and status as followers of Jesus, jealous over which might have the Master's favor and seeking the greatest place.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Jul 12, 1899ST May 14, 1894ST May 14, 1894 It presents the dispute as a lesson in humility, contrasting their concern with rank against the teaching that true greatness belongs to the one who is least.ST Sep 27, 1910ST May 14, 1894ST May 14, 1894
The dispute took place on the way to Capernaum soon after Jesus took Peter, James, and John up the mountain for the transfiguration.RH Feb 10, 1916 The nine left behind felt jealous at not being favored.RH Feb 10, 1916 The dispute arose from a self-asserting spirit fed by comparisons such as ancestry, seniority, age, education, or success. It came from ambition for superiority and distinction, and from selfishness and pride, with discussions of this kind being generally stirred up by Judas.RH Mar 13, 1856RH Oct 30, 1913 Such ambition for distinction is evidence of unworthiness for the distinction sought, while true worth is modest and unassuming.RH Mar 13, 1856
The argument over which should be greatest revealed their continuing belief that Christ's kingdom would be an earthly government, with positions of authority to be assigned in it.ST Jul 12, 1899 Their material view of the kingdom kept them from taking in the spiritual truths Jesus was trying to teach them.ST Jul 12, 1899 This preoccupation with deciding which should be greatest helps explain why they were not deeply impressed by his teaching about his coming death.ST Jul 12, 1899 Their reasoning meant striving for positions of honor in Christ's kingdom, disputing who would sit at his right hand and on his left, and raising the question of wages or reward for service.RH Mar 19, 1914 It showed they had lost their first love and no longer kept the glory of God in view.RH Mar 19, 1914 The rivalry was repeated and continuing, and its continuance after Jesus spoke to Peter shows they did not understand him to have given Peter a position of authority above the others.ST Sep 29, 1881
Christ's Lesson on Greatness
Jesus met the reasoning over who should be greatest by placing a little child among the disputants and rebuking their self-asserting spirit. He taught in answer that the least among them is great. True greatness belongs to the one who is least.ST May 14, 1894ST May 14, 1894
Greatness in his kingdom comes through humble service.ST Oct 27, 1881 Whoever desires to be greatest and seeks distinction must willingly become the servant of all and be like a little child.RH Feb 10, 1916ST Oct 27, 1881
The child set before them taught that greatness requires humility, dependence on God, and trust without claims to personal worth.ST Oct 27, 1881 A child's humble dependence is not merely the path to honor or service in the kingdom but a condition of entering it.ST Oct 27, 1881 Self-denial, self-sacrifice, surrender for the good of others, and unselfish love are the way to the highest place.ST Oct 27, 1881 The child in their midst was presented as a type of greatness in the spiritual kingdom.ST Nov 18, 1897 That place illustrates the divine plan and makes the child a symbol of divine majesty.ST Nov 18, 1897
Ambition for superiority and distinction is evidence that a person is unworthy of the distinction sought.RH Mar 13, 1856 True worth is modest and unassuming.RH Mar 13, 1856 Christ's kingdom is not of this world, teaching liberty of conscience.ST Apr 23, 1912
Consequences and Present Warning
Instead of cultivating humility the nine cherished selfishness when they disputed on the way to Capernaum which of them should be greatest, soon after Peter, James and John had been taken up the mountain for the transfiguration while the rest were left behind and felt jealous at not being favored.RH Feb 10, 1916 That selfish dispute, with unbelief, dissension and strife, grieved the Holy Spirit and caused loss of the spiritual power over unclean spirits and disease that had been given on their first missionary tour.RH Feb 10, 1916 The loss was shown when they failed to cure a demon-possessed person brought to them, leaving them unable to cast out devils and to stay loyal in trial, and that power was not regained until humility, unity and love came at Pentecost.RH Feb 10, 1916 The answer given was that he who desires to be greatest must become the servant of all and be like a little child.RH Feb 10, 1916
This self-seeking spirit marked a change from their earlier consecration and power to cast out devils, heal the sick and do mighty works.RH Mar 19, 1914 Their reasoning about which should be greatest meant striving for positions of honor in Christ's kingdom, disputing who would sit at His right hand and on His left, and raising the question of wages or reward for service, showing they had lost their first love and no longer kept the glory of God in view.RH Mar 19, 1914 Left in that state they were unable to help the afflicted and to represent Christ in mercy and compassion, which proved they needed conversion and a change of heart.RH Mar 19, 1914
Jealousy over which might have the Master's favor and obtain the greatest place helped make the apostles ready to criticize Mary's sacrifice in Jesus' honor.ST Mar 22, 1899 Discussions of this kind about which would be greatest were generally stirred up by Judas, and the same spirit of rivalry led James and John to ask for the highest places in Christ's kingdom.RH Oct 30, 1913 Selfishness and pride in disputing who would be greatest show how the desire for superiority can become ambition that rejoices when others are brought low and drives people to seek self-glorification at others' expense. The same kind of striving for prominence seen in the dispute over which should be greatest applies to church politics pursued in the name of good citizenship.ST Jan 18, 1899
Sources