Matthew 12:38
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Translations
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from you.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Then certain of the scribes and Pharisees answered him, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Then certain of the scribes and Pharisees answered him, saying, Teacher, we would see a sign from thee.
Then answered certain of the scribes and Pharisees, saying, 'Teacher, we will to see a sign from thee.'
Then answered him some of the scribes and Pharisees, saying, Teacher, we desire to see a sign from thee.
Then, answered him, certain of the Scribes and Pharisees, saying, Teacher! we desire of thee, a sign, to behold.
Then some of the scribes and Pharisees said to Him, “ Teacher, we want to see a sign from You.”
Then some of the scribes and Pharisees said, “ Teacher, we want to see a sign from You.”
Then certain of the scribes and Pharisees answered, “ Teacher, we want to see a sign from you.”
Then some of the scribes and Pharisees, hearing this, said to him, Master, we are looking for a sign from you.
Then answered certaine of ye Scribes and of the Pharises, saying, Master, we would see a signe of thee.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Then some of the scribes and Pharisees answered him, saying: Master we would see a sign from thee.
Pictures

Cross-references
- Jonah 1:17
Now the LORD had prepared a great fish to swallow up Jonah. And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights.
Jonah’s three days and nights in the fish form the sign Jesus names.
- 1 Corinthians 1:22
For the Jews require a sign, and the Greeks seek after wisdom:
Both texts describe the Jews’ demand for a sign.
- Luke 11:29-32
And when the people were gathered thick together, he began to say, This is an evil generation: they seek a sign; and there shall no sign be given it, but the sign of Jonas the prophet.
Jesus answers a similar demand for a sign and names condemning witnesses.
- Matthew 16:1-4
The Pharisees also with the Sadducees came, and tempting desired him that he would shew them a sign from heaven.
Jesus rebukes those demanding a sign and points to the sign of Jonah.
- Luke 23:8
And when Herod saw Jesus, he was exceeding glad: for he was desirous to see him of a long season, because he had heard many things of him; and he hoped to have seen some miracle done by him.
Herod wanted Jesus to perform a miracle before him.
- John 2:18
Then answered the Jews and said unto him, What sign shewest thou unto us, seeing that thou doest these things?
The Jews ask Jesus to show a sign.
- Mark 8:12
And he sighed deeply in his spirit, and saith, Why doth this generation seek after a sign? verily I say unto you, There shall no sign be given unto this generation.
Jesus is grieved when his generation asks for a sign.
- John 6:30
They said therefore unto him, What sign shewest thou then, that we may see, and believe thee? what dost thou work?
The Jews demanded a sign before they would believe.
- Jonah 3:5-10
So the people of Nineveh believed God, and proclaimed a fast, and put on sackcloth, from the greatest of them even to the least of them.
Nineveh repented at Jonah’s preaching and was spared from destruction.
- John 4:48
Then said Jesus unto him, Except ye see signs and wonders, ye will not believe.
Jesus rebuked dependence on signs as a condition of belief.
- Matthew 12:22
Then was brought unto him one possessed with a devil, blind, and dumb: and he healed him, insomuch that the blind and dumb both spake and saw.
healing sets occasion for sign demand
- Matthew 16:3
And in the morning, It will be foul weather to day: for the sky is red and lowring. O ye hypocrites, ye can discern the face of the sky; but can ye not discern the signs of the times?
Christ rebukes them for missing the signs of the times.
- Matthew 12:24
But when the Pharisees heard it, they said, This fellow doth not cast out devils, but by Beelzebub the prince of the devils.
The leaders attribute Christ’s works to Beelzebub.
- 1 Samuel 21:1-6
Then came David to Nob to Ahimelech the priest: and Ahimelech was afraid at the meeting of David, and said unto him, Why art thou alone, and no man with thee?
David’s eating the showbread is used to explain mercy in meeting need.
- Matthew 4:3-6
And when the tempter came to him, he said, If thou be the Son of God, command that these stones be made bread.
Demanding a sign repeats Satan’s challenges to Jesus.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
18 sources
Certain religious leaders asked Jesus for a miraculous proof of His authority even though He had already healed the sick, restored sight, cast out demons, raised the dead and fed the multitude.Ms 107, 1897, par. 7–8ST Oct 1, 1896Lt 18, 1876, par. 8–9 Their demand did not come from sincere desire to understand and believe but from unbelieving, unreceptive hearts that resisted plain evidence and used calls for signs to turn minds away from the truth.ST Oct 1, 18965RED 56.1Lt 18, 1876, par. 8–99MR 182.2Ms 12b, 1896, par. 3–4 Jesus would not use divine power to satisfy curiosity or to prove Himself to hostile questioners.5RED 56.1 He called that sign-seeking generation evil and adulterous and declared it would receive only the sign of Jonah, that as Jonah was three days and three nights in the fish so He would be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth, while the repentance of Nineveh and the journey of the queen of the South to hear Solomon would condemn those who rejected One greater than Jonah and Solomon.ST Oct 1, 1896 No outward sign is to be expected now, for the sign continually given is the working of the Holy Spirit on the Word to impress the heart, and the greater miracle Christ continually works instead of gratifying curiosity is changing the hard heart to new life and obedience.16MR 228.2–229.1Lt 68, 1894, par. 12–1314MR 187.2–320MR 165.1–3
Setting of the Request
The request for a sign came immediately after Jesus for the second time healed a man who was possessed and blind and dumb.DA 321.3 It came just after the Pharisees repeated the charge that He casts out devils through the prince of devils.DA 321.3 It came just after He warned them plainly that attributing the work of the Holy Spirit to Satan cuts them off from the fountain of blessing and from the channel by which God works on the heart to bring repentance and faith.DA 321.3
At that time Jesus was devoting entire nights to prayer and spending the days thronged by great companies of people without time so much as to eat.DA 321.1–2 His friends felt He was wearing Himself out by incessant labor, were unable to account for His attitude toward the Pharisees, and some feared His reason was becoming unsettled.DA 321.1–2 The sons of Joseph were far from sympathy with His work, and reports of His life and labors filled them with astonishment and dismay.DA 321.1–2 They had heard the Pharisees' charge that He cast out devils through the power of Satan, felt keenly the reproach that came upon them through relation to Him, knew what a tumult His words and works created, were alarmed at His bold statements and indignant at His denunciation of the scribes and Pharisees.DA 321.1–2 They decided He must be persuaded or constrained to cease this manner of labor and induced Mary to unite with them, thinking that through His love for her they might prevail upon Him to be more prudent.DA 321.1–2
The demand was made amid constant hostile surveillance, with crowds pressing around and spies on His track watching every word and action to find grounds to accuse Him.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6RH Jul 6, 1911 They tracked Him saying in effect show us a sign and work some miracle, not from sincere inquiry but to report Him in distorted light.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6RH Jul 6, 1911 They hired men and greedily received false witnesses to furnish a pretext for condemning Him as a criminal.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6 They sought by scandal, reproach, and falsehood to make themselves and others believe Him a criminal.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6
The demand was made despite abundant miracles already attesting His mission and authority.ST Oct 1, 1896Lt 18, 1876, par. 8–9RH Jul 6, 1911 He had healed the sick, cast out demons, restored sight, raised the dead, and done other mighty works.ST Oct 1, 1896Lt 18, 1876, par. 8–9RH Jul 6, 1911 He had fed the multitude with five loaves and two fishes, and after His command to gather the fragments so nothing would be lost twelve baskets were gathered.Ms 107, 1897, par. 7–8 That gathering was sufficient evidence of His authority, but they closed their eyes to the light.Ms 107, 1897, par. 7–8
Unbelief Behind the Demand
The demand for a sign arose from unbelief and unreceptive hearts, exposing a wicked and thankless generation that resisted belief even when God had plainly attested Jesus by healing the sick, casting out demons, restoring sight, raising the dead, and other mighty works.ST Oct 1, 1896Lt 18, 1876, par. 8–9Ms 12b, 1896, par. 3–4 Had they turned toward Him as the Light of the world they would have recognized Him, for the ceremonies and symbols of Jewish worship pointed to Christ as their foundation and fulfillment.Ms 12b, 1896, par. 3–4 The request was not sincere inquiry for clearer understanding and faith but wicked curiosity and willful refusal to receive the evidence before them.5RED 56.19MR 182.2Ms 30, 1889, par. 44–50 Leaders used calls for signs to distract hearers from clear evidence of truth, though Christ's miracles were divine testimony to the authority of His work and mission meant to overcome prejudice and inspire faith, and they rejected that truth even to attributing His signs to the prince of devils.9MR 182.2
The demand grew from prejudice against His humble origins and from expectation of a Messiah coming with worldly honor and military power.4RED 5.1–2 Prejudice, unbelief, and false Messianic hopes combined to lead them to disregard evidence already given and the recognition their hearts had first felt, even while crowds pressed around and His healings and other mighty works already gave evidence of His divine claims.4RED 5.1–2RH Jul 6, 1911 The leaders failed to understand those ceremonies and symbols and failed to recognize Him when He came as predicted.Ms 12b, 1896, par. 3–4 He showed from Old Testament prophecies that in rejecting Him they were fulfilling those prophecies.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6
The demand for a sign as proof that He was the Son of God persisted despite His miracles and the truthful simplicity and purity of His character.4RED 33.1–3 It stood in contrast with the Samaritans, who saw no sign and witnessed no miracles yet accepted His teaching and received Him as Saviour.4RED 33.1–3 The unbelieving demand for a sign and miracle as proof of being right overlooks the very kind of evidence God has already given.Lt 40, 1890, par. 11–12 It comes from surface workers not sanctified through the truth, encased in self-righteousness so that sharp reproof cannot penetrate, hearing the most earnest and authoritative teaching without self-examination, most difficult to arouse.Lt 40, 1890, par. 11–12 Those who shut their eyes to evidence already given and insist on further signs will be passed by while others receive the blessing they rejected.16MR 228.2–229.1Ms 30, 1889, par. 44–50
Answer and Present Warning
Jesus would not work a miracle merely to satisfy wicked curiosity, to prove Himself to hostile questioners, or to spare Himself suffering, for having taken human nature He would not use divine power for His own advantage.5RED 56.1 The sign-seeking generation was called evil and adulterous, and it would receive no sign but the sign of Jonah.ST Oct 1, 1896 As Jonah was three days and three nights in the fish, so the Son of man would be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.ST Oct 1, 1896 The repentance of Nineveh at Jonah's preaching and the journey of the queen of the South to hear Solomon would stand in judgment against those who rejected One greater than Jonah and Solomon, even after healings of the sick, casting out of demons, restoring of sight, and other mighty works had already been given.ST Oct 1, 1896
No outward sign is to be given as then, but the sign manifest now and always is the working of the Holy Spirit on the teacher's mind to make the Word as impressive as possible.Lt 68, 1894, par. 12–1314MR 187.2–3 The Word of God is Spirit and life and not a dead, dry theory.Lt 68, 1894, par. 12–1314MR 187.2–3 Eternal life comes not by a granted sign but by receiving Christ's life-giving Word as flesh and blood, by eating the flesh and drinking the blood of the Son of God given in His Word.Lt 68, 1894, par. 12–1314MR 187.2–3
The verse warns against wanting something outside the Word to produce feeling, and against turning attention to dreams, visions, and other sensations, which call minds away from the Word.Lt 68, 1894, par. 12–1314MR 187.2–3 In contrast to demanding a miracle, Christ continually works the greater miracle of changing the hard heart.16MR 228.2–229.120MR 165.1–3 In that work the Holy Spirit frees people from delusion and worldly influence, brings them to understand moral truth, turns them from falsehood and sin to truth and righteousness, gives a new heart, leads them to trust Christ formed within, and makes their obedience bear spiritual fruit and their lives proclaim salvation to others.16MR 228.2–229.120MR 165.1–3 Those who shut their eyes to evidence already given and insist on further signs will be passed by while others receive the blessing they rejected.16MR 228.2–229.1
The same condition is repeated by those who have Bibles and claim to believe them yet close their eyes to light and will not receive and practice it because it condemns transgression of the law, since clear miracles do not convince those who refuse light, as when the feeding of the multitude with five loaves and two fishes and the gathering of twelve baskets under His command that nothing be lost was still met with demand.Ms 107, 1897, par. 7–8 The same spirit is acted out toward God's commandment-keeping people today by those who do not want God's way or knowledge of the truth, who greedily partake of pleasing fables, listen to falsehoods of wolves in sheep's clothing, rejoice in iniquity, infuse opposition into others, and join spies tracking every word and action to report it in distorted light and to hire men and receive false witnesses to furnish a pretext for condemning as a criminal and to make others believe it through scandal, reproach, and falsehood, though Old Testament prophecies were shown to them that in rejecting Him they were fulfilling those prophecies.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6 Persistence in that evil course stands registered against them in the books of heaven and brought eternal infamy upon the nation that rejected Him.Ms 61, 1899, par. 4–6 The unbelieving demand for a sign as proof of being right overlooks the kind of evidence God has already given and comes from surface workers not sanctified through the truth, encased in self-righteousness so sharp reproof cannot penetrate, hearing earnest and authoritative teaching without self-examination and most difficult to arouse.Lt 40, 1890, par. 11–12 Rejection of warnings, reproofs, and counsels leaves heaven's illumination powerless to set such hearers in order and opens the track for deception.Lt 40, 1890, par. 11–12
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
20 sources
Certain scribes and Pharisees asked Jesus for a sign even though He had already given many signs among them through healings, casting out demons, restoring sight, and other mighty works done before their eyes.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Jan 27, 1881RH Jun 23, 1863 Their demand did not come from honest faith but from unbelief, prejudice and resistance to truth, from curiosity and a superstitious desire for the supernatural and mysterious, and to tempt and test Him.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Oct 23, 1893RH Jun 27, 1871ST Feb 1, 1905ST Nov 28, 1906 He called the sign-seeking generation evil and adulterous and would not perform a miracle on demand as a show, for God does not work miracles to satisfy curiosity or display power.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Oct 23, 1893RH Jun 27, 1871 The only sign to be given them would be the sign of Jonah, that as Jonah was three days and three nights in the great fish so the Son of man would be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth, with His resurrection as the climax of the proof demanded.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Feb 2, 1915ST Aug 20, 1885 To demand a sign as a condition for believing rather than trusting God's word is unbelief, and seeking signs while rejecting His testing truth leads to deception and leaves the present generation blind to the foretold wonders preceding the second advent.ST Feb 1, 1905RH Jun 23, 1863ST Oct 16, 1901ST Oct 7, 1886RH Oct 25, 1853
The Request for a Sign
Certain scribes and Pharisees asked for a sign even though many signs had already been given through healing the sick, casting out demons, restoring sight, and other mighty works, miracles and wonders done among them and before their eyes.ST Oct 1, 1896RH Jul 6, 1911RH Jun 23, 1863ST Oct 7, 1886RH Dec 27, 1853 The demand did not arise from honest hearts or simple faith, but from unbelief, prejudice, false expectations about the Messiah, resistance to truth, and desire to protect their own honor and position.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Jan 27, 1881RH Jul 6, 1911ST Oct 23, 1893RH Dec 27, 1853 They failed to recognize the pure spirituality and evidence of divinity in the truthful simplicity of his character, even the word and truth of God demonstrated in his humanity.ST Jan 27, 1881ST Nov 28, 1906 Their stated readiness to believe if given enough light concealed hearts that Jesus knew.RH Dec 27, 1853
Their demand came from curiosity rather than faith, and from the naturally superstitious heart that seeks after the supernatural and the mysterious.ST Oct 23, 1893ST Feb 1, 1905ST Oct 16, 1901 That same desire for evidence beyond what God has given explains why people follow movements that show signs by healing or seeming to heal.ST Feb 1, 1905ST Oct 7, 1886 The demand was a tempting and testing of Jesus, like Satan's earlier demand that he prove his Messiahship by a miracle.RH Jun 27, 1871ST Aug 20, 1885 They claimed to discern the face of the sky yet could not discern the signs of the time, while the crowd pressed around him and spies watched for grounds to accuse him.RH Jul 6, 1911RH Jun 23, 1863 The unheeded challenge became another reason for Judas to question his course.RH Jul 26, 1906
Jesus called the sign-seeking generation evil and adulterous.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Oct 23, 1893 He would not repeat a miracle or perform a new one on demand or as a show to prove he was the Christ, refusing to make a showman of himself in answer to temptation.ST Oct 23, 1893RH Jun 27, 1871ST Aug 20, 1885 God does not work miracles to satisfy curiosity or display power.ST Oct 23, 1893
The Sign of Jonah
The only sign to be given to that evil and adulterous generation would be the sign of Jonah.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Feb 2, 1915ST Aug 20, 1885 As Jonah was three days and three nights in the belly of the great sea creature or fish, so the Son of man would be three days and three nights in the heart of the earth.ST Oct 1, 1896ST Dec 11, 1893ST Feb 2, 1915 His resurrection would be the climax of the heavenly proof demanded.ST Aug 20, 1885
Three days and three nights is a general expression that does not require seventy-two full hours.ST Dec 11, 1893 Jonah's time cannot be proved to be exactly that length.ST Dec 11, 1893 Day and night could mean a day even when short of a full twenty-four hours. Parts of three days, including one whole day and two parts as the Jews reckoned, can be so described.ST Dec 11, 1893
The heart of the earth does not mean only the grave.ST Dec 11, 1893 It means being delivered to and under the powers of earth, including Rome's power.ST Dec 11, 1893 The period therefore includes his betrayal and sufferings as well as his crucifixion.
Jonah's deliverance by God's power served as an object lesson of God's power and willingness to save people.ST Feb 2, 1915 Nineveh's repentance at Jonah's preaching and the queen of the South's journey to hear Solomon would stand in judgment against those who rejected one greater than Jonah or Solomon.ST Oct 1, 1896
An event may happen and be known for generations without being recognized as a sign until it is interpreted in the light of prophecy.RH Aug 1, 1907 The time an event occurs is therefore distinct from the time it is seen as a sign.RH Aug 1, 1907 In the same way the darkening of the sun and moon in 1780 became signs for the last generation when interpreted through prophecy.RH Aug 1, 1907 That interpretation helps identify when that generation began.RH Aug 1, 1907
Warning Against Sign-Seeking
Christ's refusal to work a miracle for idle curiosity or to satisfy those who were testing him shows that his followers are not bound to answer scoffers when they demand proof that they are God's people, and that at such times the wiser course is sometimes to refrain from speaking.RH Jun 27, 1871 To ask for a miracle as a condition for believing did not mean readiness to accept the gospel, and the demand belongs with his reproof of those who seek miraculous signs in order to believe.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Mar 4, 1889
The request expresses the desire of the naturally superstitious heart, a dominant trait in the natural man both at the first advent and now, seeking after the supernatural and the mysterious in language phrased differently today but the same in substance.ST Feb 1, 1905 It came from curiosity rather than faith, and it did not keep those who made it from rejecting him even though he was the fullness of wisdom and power and his works were already being done among them and before their eyes.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Oct 7, 1886 Such seeking while rejecting him and ignoring God's testing truth leads to deception, illustrating the desire for evidence beyond what God has given, which can draw people away from faith into error.ST Oct 16, 1901ST Oct 7, 1886 It makes seekers vulnerable to false religious claims when they do not test those claims by Scripture, and it explains why people follow a movement that shows signs by healing or seeming to heal.ST Feb 1, 1905
A sign from God is not to be rejected merely because few witnessed it, for the star marking his first coming was seen by only a few wise men, yet that limited witness did not justify rejecting the Messiah.RH Apr 13, 1876 The same blindness marks the present generation, which in the midst of a flood of light and some of the most astonishing wonders of the world cannot see that these very things were foretold to precede the second advent and the great and terrible day of the Lord.RH Jun 23, 1863 To demand assurance by a sign rather than to trust God's word is unbelief, so that ministers who are afraid to follow God's word and Spirit and insist on a sign are guilty of the same unbelief shown when the chief priests and Pharisees demanded a sign because they did not believe.RH Oct 25, 1853
Sources