Matthew 16:1
The Pharisees also with the Sadducees came, and tempting desired him that he would shew them a sign from heaven.
Translations
The Pharisees also with the Sadducees came, and tempting desired him that he would show them a sign from heaven.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
The Pharisees also with the Sadducees came, and tempting desired him that he would shew them a sign from heaven.
The Pharisees also and the Sadducees came, and, tempting, desired him that he would show them a sign from heaven.
And the Pharisees and Sadducees came, and tempting him asked him to shew them a sign from heaven.
And the Pharisees and Sadducees came, and trying him asked him to show them a sign from heaven.
And the Pharisees and Sadducees having come, tempting, did question him, to shew to them a sign from the heaven,
And the Pharisees and Sadducees, coming to [ him], asked him, tempting [ him], to shew them a sign out of heaven.
And, the Pharisees and Sadducees coming near, putting him to the test, requested him, a sign out of the heaven, to shew unto them.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Then the Pharisees and Sadducees came and tested Jesus by asking Him to show them a sign from heaven.
The Pharisees and Sadducees came, and testing him, asked him to show them a sign from heaven.
And the Pharisees and Sadducees came and, testing him, made a request to him to give them a sign from heaven.
Then came the Pharises and Sadduces, and did tempt him, desiring him to shew them a signe from heauen.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And there came to him the Pharisees and Sadduccees tempting: and they asked him to shew them a sign from heaven.
Pictures

Cross-references
- Mark 8:11-12
And the Pharisees came forth, and began to question with him, seeking of him a sign from heaven, tempting him.
The Pharisees test Jesus by demanding a sign from heaven, and he refuses.
- Matthew 12:38-40
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Jesus answers the leaders’ test for a sign by pointing to Jonah and his resurrection.
- Luke 12:56
Ye hypocrites, ye can discern the face of the sky and of the earth; but how is it that ye do not discern this time?
Both rebuke people for seeking signs while failing to discern the present time.
- Matthew 12:39-41
But he answered and said unto them, An evil and adulterous generation seeketh after a sign; and there shall no sign be given to it, but the sign of the prophet Jonas:
Jesus gives Jonah’s three days as the sign and contrasts the generation’s response with Nineveh’s repentance.
- Luke 11:16
And others, tempting him, sought of him a sign from heaven.
Opponents demand a sign from heaven to test Jesus.
- Luke 11:29-30
And when the people were gathered thick together, he began to say, This is an evil generation: they seek a sign; and there shall no sign be given it, but the sign of Jonas the prophet.
Jesus rejects demands for a sign and names Jonah as the sign to his generation.
- John 6:30-31
They said therefore unto him, What sign shewest thou then, that we may see, and believe thee? what dost thou work?
They ask Jesus for a sign and appeal to the manna given in the wilderness.
- Jonah 1:17
Now the LORD had prepared a great fish to swallow up Jonah. And Jonah was in the belly of the fish three days and three nights.
Jonah’s three days in the fish foreshadow Jesus’ time in the grave and serve as the sign he names.
- Jonah 3:4-5
And Jonah began to enter into the city a day’s journey, and he cried, and said, Yet forty days, and Nineveh shall be overthrown.
Jonah’s warning was the sign given to Nineveh.
- John 4:48
Then said Jesus unto him, Except ye see signs and wonders, ye will not believe.
Jesus addresses reliance on signs rather than belief.
- Matthew 15:32-39
Then Jesus called his disciples unto him, and said, I have compassion on the multitude, because they continue with me now three days, and have nothing to eat: and I will not send them away fasting, lest they faint in the way.
The demand for a sign follows Jesus’ feeding of the four thousand.
- Matthew 11:5
The blind receive their sight, and the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, and the deaf hear, the dead are raised up, and the poor have the gospel preached to them.
Miracles had already been done before a sign was demanded.
- Exodus 16:4
Then said the LORD unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.
Bread from heaven is given as a sign, as they ask Jesus for one.
- 1 Kings 18:36-38
And it came to pass at the time of the offering of the evening sacrifice, that Elijah the prophet came near, and said, LORD God of Abraham, Isaac, and of Israel, let it be known this day that thou art God in Israel, and that I am thy servant, and that I have done all these things at thy word.
Elijah’s sign of fire from heaven demonstrates prophetic miracles.
- 2 Kings 20:9-11
And Isaiah said, This sign shalt thou have of the LORD, that the LORD will do the thing that he hath spoken: shall the shadow go forward ten degrees, or go back ten degrees?
The sun’s shadow turns back as a sign from the LORD.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
9 sources
The Pharisees joined with the Sadducees against Jesus, coming to test Him by demanding a sign from heaven.DA 404.1–405.2DA 405.3–406.2 What they wanted was an outward wonder, asking Him to repeat before them the mighty miraculous works He had performed across the sea that they had heard about.DA 404.1–405.24RED 88.12SP 275.1–2ST Mar 15, 1877 They presented the demand as a request for evidence and proof that He was the Son of God and of the divine identity and authority of His work and mission.Ms 55, 1890, par. 44RED 88.12SP 275.1–2ST Mar 15, 1877
God had already attested His mission by heavenly signs, including the angels' announcement, the star that guided the wise men, and the dove and voice at His baptism.DA 404.1–405.2DA 405.3–406.2 Christ had also already performed many miracles as a manifestation of divine power to testify to His work, to sweep away prejudice and inspire faith, together with convincing arguments of truth, evidence of His character and divinity, and calls to believe and repent, but the leaders ignored them because they had entrenched themselves in refusal to hear and receive the truth.Ms 55, 1890, par. 42SP 149.1–3 The demand did not come from a sincere desire for clearer views of truth or to learn, trust, and learn how to please God, but from unbelief, pride, curiosity, self-interest and hope for temporal benefit, reflecting a shallow, outward religion.Ms 55, 1890, par. 4DA 407.12SP 149.1–32SP 275.1–2ST Mar 15, 1877
One aim was to divert the minds of the hearers from the clearest evidences already presented, and when diversion failed they charged that His remarkable signs were worked through Beelzebub, the prince of devils.Ms 55, 1890, par. 4 Jesus did not perform a miracle to satisfy unbelief and pride, but left their challenge unanswered.DA 718.1DA 407.1 No external sign could meet their real need, which was not further intellectual evidence but spiritual renewal, and His Spirit-empowered words convicting them of sin were God's sign for their salvation.DA 404.1–405.2DA 405.3–406.2
The true sign of His divine mission is the gospel's regenerating power, as the Holy Spirit makes God's word able to free people from Satan, give a new heart, transform character, and lead them to love God and keep His commandments.DA 407.1 Their focus on miraculous signs and perishable food missed the greater gift He offered of spiritual wisdom and grace that endure to everlasting life, in contrast to the Samaritans who accepted His teaching, recognized their need of a Saviour, and received Him without asking for a sign or seeing miracles, showing that openness to truth rather than signs leads to receiving Christ.2SP 149.1–32SP 275.1–2ST Mar 15, 1877 Judas noticed that Jesus left the challenge unanswered and took it as a sign that He would not assert royal power or wage the aggressive warfare Judas expected, which fed Judas's doubts and rebellion.DA 718.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
37 sources
The Pharisees and Sadducees, though rivals, came together in an unusual united effort to test Jesus with hostile purpose rather than honest inquiry.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Jan 2, 1879RH May 4, 1911RH Feb 5, 1901 They demanded a wonder from heaven to prove his authority, dismissing his mighty works, teaching and perfect life as insufficient and as possibly done by evil power.ST Aug 25, 1881ST Jan 27, 1881AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Oct 13, 1898ST Sep 22, 1881 Though able to read the sky to judge the weather, they failed to discern the signs of the times in the prophecies being fulfilled before them that marked him as the Messiah.ST Jun 28, 1899AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Jan 2, 1879RH Aug 27, 1872ST Sep 26, 1878 Jesus refused to gratify curiosity with a spectacle, rebuked them as hypocrites and a wicked and adulterous sign-seeking generation, and gave them only the sign of Jonah in his three days in the grave and resurrection as the climax of the evidence.RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1861ST Oct 6, 1898ST Sep 22, 1881ST Jun 28, 1899 It is therefore duty to discern the fulfilled signs of Christ's near return and to heed Scripture rather than demand further proof, lest professed believers repeat their blindness and be left unprepared.ST Mar 25, 1875ST Sep 26, 1878ST Oct 6, 1898STST Dec 30, 1880
Setting and Requesters
The Pharisees and the Sadducees were rival religious leaders opposed to Jesus, yet in this verse they come together in an unusual united effort against him.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Jan 2, 1879ST Sep 22, 1881ST Jan 8, 1880 Their alliance to test him by demanding a sign from heaven was another attempt to compromise him with the authorities, and it marked an increase in the danger he faced.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Jan 2, 1879ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 22, 1881
The demand took place near Dalmanutha, after Jesus had fed the four thousand on the other side of the lake.ST Jul 7, 1898
Their coming was to tempt and to try or test him, with a hostile, wicked and mischievous purpose rather than an honest search for proof or sincere faith.RH May 4, 1911RH Feb 5, 1901RH Nov 20, 1860ST Jan 9, 1879RH Jan 11, 1870 Through them Satan sought to turn Jesus aside from his work and thwart the plan of salvation.ST Sep 17, 1912
Demand for a Sign
The demand was for a sign from heaven to prove authority and sonship with God, dismissing the miracles already worked as possibly done through demonic power and insisting that only a heavenly wonder would establish the claim.ST Aug 25, 1881ST Jan 27, 1881ST Mar 15, 1877ST Sep 22, 1881 What was proposed was bread from heaven or wonders in the sky involving the sun, thunder, hail, fire and rain.ST Sep 22, 1881 The demand was also an importuning to repeat before them out of idle curiosity the wonderful works already done on the other side of the sea.ST Aug 25, 1881ST Mar 15, 1877
It came despite abundant evidence already given in mighty works, divine teaching, perfect life and character, Scripture, current events and John's preaching.AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Oct 13, 1898ST Sep 26, 1878ST Sep 22, 1881ST Oct 13, 1898 That evidence included giving sight to the blind, making the lame walk, cleansing lepers, opening the ears of the deaf, raising the dead and preaching the gospel to the poor.ST Dec 30, 1880 The words of Moses and the prophets already supplied were better evidence and more convincing than even the greatest miracle.ST Dec 30, 1880
The request sprang from unbelief, unwillingness to accept what conscience and evidence disclosed, pride, prejudice, self-interest and idle curiosity.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Oct 13, 1898ST Jun 28, 1899ST Oct 13, 1898 It was pretense rather than sincere faith or honest search for proof, having a mischievous purpose and seeking further signs merely to satisfy curiosity after demonstrations of power already seen.ST Oct 13, 1898ST Jun 28, 1899 They hardened their hearts and rejected the evidence of the divine mission, and since they were not satisfied with what had already been done no sign that could be given would have satisfied them, for they would not have believed even if it had been granted.RH Jul 25, 1854ST Jun 28, 1899ST Dec 30, 1880ST Mar 17, 1914
Through them Satan sought to turn Jesus aside from his work and thwart the plan of salvation.ST Sep 17, 1912 The offer presented was worldly fame and glory, that he should display his greatness so people would believe in him and honor him, whose evil result beyond the appeal Jesus saw.ST Sep 17, 1912 Their scornful demand, ignoring his miracles and all evidences of divinity in the truthful simplicity of his character and his pure and elevated spirituality, stands in marked contrast to the Samaritans.ST Jan 27, 1881 The Samaritans asked for no sign and saw no miracles, yet received his teachings, were convicted of their great need of a Saviour, and accepted him as Redeemer, placing them in a much more favorable position before God than those who refused the salvation offered them.ST Jan 27, 1881
Failure to Discern
Though able to read ordinary signs in the sky and judge the weather from them, the Pharisees and Sadducees failed to discern the signs of the times when they tested Jesus by demanding a sign from heaven.ST Jun 28, 1899AUST Jun 14, 1920ST Jan 2, 1879RH Aug 27, 1872 Their request had wicked motives, and His answer exposed that they could read the weather from the sky yet overlooked the evidence already given that He was the Messiah.AUST Jun 14, 1920RH Nov 20, 1860 That demand belonged to a failure to recognize the signs God had already given of the Messiah's first advent, and it drew His rebuke for reading the weather while missing those signs.ST Jun 28, 1899AUST Jun 14, 1920 From the signs God has given people can judge the moral condition of the world, and those signs can show when deliverance for God's people is near.RH Nov 20, 1860
The signs they missed are discerned by watching prophecy come to fulfillment, which indicates with certainty the events to follow, especially when prophecy identifies events as signs that a great event is near.ST Jan 2, 1879 Old Testament prophecies they professed to believe were being fulfilled before them, marking the time of the Messiah's first advent and identifying Jesus as the Messiah.ST Jan 2, 1879RH Aug 27, 1872ST Jan 9, 1879ST Jan 8, 1880 Although God had given many signs marking the Messiah's first coming, they still demanded a sign from heaven because they had failed to recognize the signs already given.ST Sep 26, 1878 Their blindness was to the signs of the Messiah in Scripture, in current events, in John's preaching, and in Jesus' miracles, teaching, and life.ST Sep 22, 1881 Their demand for a sign suited to themselves was the mark of a faithless generation, to whom only the sign of Jonah would be given, Jonah's warning itself being a sign to Nineveh and his three days and nights in the fish foreshadowing Jesus' three days and nights in the grave.ST Sep 22, 1881
Their failure to heed the prophetic signs showed that their professed faith in the prophets was not genuine and led them to reject the promised Messiah. It was spiritual blindness, and the same failure to recognize the signs of the times can occur among people who bear the name of Christ.ST Refusing to discern God's promised signs is hypocrisy deserving the rebuke "Ye hypocrites," bringing severe condemnation and the same guilt upon Christians who ignore their fulfillment. The professed people of God at the first advent refused to discern, heed, or believe the signs God had already given, and that refusal was indifference and wickedness that brought a terrible rebuke from the Son of God.ST Sep 26, 1878 Their failure to heed those signs left them unprepared and led to their part in condemning Christ.RH Aug 27, 1872
Christ's Response
Jesus would not gratify idle curiosity by performing a new miracle or repeating one merely to make a spectacle, for the demand to show a sign from heaven was a tempting test with a mischievous purpose rather than an honest search, importuning him to repeat before them the wonderful works done on the other side of the sea.ST Aug 25, 1881ST Jun 28, 1899ST Aug 20, 1885 They were not satisfied with the demonstrations of power already seen and would not have believed even if it had been granted, so he would not waste miracles on them.ST Aug 25, 1881ST Jun 28, 1899 He answered their questions directly and exposed their folly without sharing their evil temper, then left to avoid a hostile controversy that could have shortened his opportunities to serve, leaving their challenge unanswered.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894RH May 4, 1911RH Sep 17, 1861 He rebuked them as hypocrites and as a faithless, wicked and adulterous sign-seeking generation, commanding people to watch and discern the signs of the times.ST Oct 6, 1898ST Sep 22, 1881RH Feb 5, 1901
The generation seeking a sign would receive only the sign of Jonah.ST Jun 28, 1899ST Sep 22, 1881 Jonah's warning was itself a sign to Nineveh, and Jonah's three days and nights in the fish foreshadowed Jesus' three days and nights in the grave.ST Sep 22, 1881 His resurrection was the climax of the evidence of his Messiahship demanded of him.ST Aug 20, 1885
His leaving the challenge unanswered was seen by Judas as an ignored challenge that deepened his doubt and rebellion and gave him further reason to question Jesus.ST Dec 17, 1912ST Dec 24, 1894 The question about discerning the signs of the times still challenges people who recognize and speak of the signs of coming judgment but may be unable to face what their own warnings imply.RH Feb 27, 1872
Warning for Later Generations
It is duty to discern the signs of the times when they are fulfilled, for the Lord gives signs to show when Christ's return is near.ST Mar 25, 1875ST Oct 6, 1898 As it was sin for the Pharisees to disbelieve the signs given them, it is equally wrong now to disregard the fulfilled signs showing that the second advent is near.ST Mar 25, 1875 Jesus commands people to watch and discern the signs of the times in connection with recognizing that the end is near.ST Oct 6, 1898
People should heed the Scriptures rather than require a sign before believing or obeying God's plainly stated word.ST Jan 15, 1880 The call is to be content with the plain Word of God, whose prophetic truths are clear, and to avoid demanding signs God has not given.ST Oct 13, 1898 This demand came after He had already given sight to the blind, made the lame walk, cleansed lepers, opened the ears of the deaf, raised the dead, and preached the gospel to the poor, and after prophecy had already been fulfilled in His coming and mission.ST Dec 30, 1880ST Jan 15, 1880 The words of Moses and the prophets are better evidence and more convincing than even the greatest miracle, and one who rejects the word of God will not be convinced by any evidence.ST Dec 30, 1880 Those who will not hear Moses and the prophets would not be persuaded even by someone rising from the dead, which proves that since they were not satisfied with what had already been done, no sign that could be given would have satisfied them.ST Dec 30, 1880ST Jan 15, 1880
When God has plainly spoken in His Word, no sign is needed to show that His commands should be obeyed, so the request for a sign warns against delaying obedience while demanding further proof.RH Jun 15, 1911 The same failure to recognize the signs of the times that marked the Pharisees and Sadducees can occur among people who bear the name of Christ.ST Although God had given many signs marking the Messiah's first coming, people still demanded a sign from heaven because they had failed to recognize the signs already given, and their demand brought a sharp rebuke for not discerning the signs of the times.ST Sep 26, 1878
That inability is spiritual blindness, and their failure to heed the prophetic signs showed that their professed faith in the prophets was not genuine and led to rejecting the promised Messiah, so the rebuke Ye hypocrites was deserved.ST The professed people of God at the first advent refused to discern, heed, or believe the signs God had already given, instead tempting Christ by asking for a sign from heaven, and that refusal was indifference and wickedness bringing a terrible rebuke from the Son of God.ST Sep 26, 1878 Refusing to discern God's promised signs is hypocrisy and brings severe condemnation, and neglecting prophecy and the signs God gives is just as wicked now.ST Sep 26, 1878 Such neglect can leave Christians unprepared for Christ's second advent and bring a similar rejection and the same guilt.
Like the signs at His first coming, the signs of His coming are discernible but not so overwhelming that the unwilling are forced to accept them, for people without a disposition to receive truth could reject the signs already given and demand a greater sign.RH Jul 25, 1854 The request had wicked motives, and the answer pointed out that people could read the weather from the sky but failed to discern the signs of the times.RH Nov 20, 1860 From the signs God has given people can judge the moral condition of the world, and these signs can show when deliverance for God's people is near.RH Nov 20, 1860
Their demand did not arise from lack of evidence, for even after seeing His miracles they hardened their hearts and rejected the evidence of His divine mission, and no sign could remove such unbelief.ST Mar 17, 1914 Their experience teaches that people in every age can harden their hearts and reject the evidence God gives.ST Mar 17, 1914 People may likewise miss the signs of the second advent if they do not study what the Bible says about them.ST Sep 26, 1878
Sources