John 2:18
Then answered the Jews and said unto him, What sign shewest thou unto us, seeing that thou doest these things?
Translations
Then answered the Jews and said to him, What sign show you to us, seeing that you do these things?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then answered the Jews and said unto him, What sign shewest thou unto us, seeing that thou doest these things?
Then answered the Jews, and said to him, What sign showest thou to us, seeing that thou doest these things?
The Jews therefore answered and said unto him, What sign shewest thou unto us, seeing that thou doest these things?
The Jews therefore answered and said unto him, What sign showest thou unto us, seeing that thou doest these things?
the Jews then answered and said to him, 'What sign dost thou shew to us — that thou dost these things?'
The Jews therefore answered and said to him, What sign shewest thou to us, that thou doest these things?
The Jews therefore answered, and said unto him, What sign, dost thou point out to us, in that, these things, thou doest?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
On account of this, the Jews demanded, “ What sign can You show us to prove Your authority to do these things?”
The Jews therefore answered him, “ What sign do you show us, seeing that you do these things?”
Then the Jews put this question to him: What sign of authority have you to give us, seeing that you do these things?
Then answered the Iewes, and saide vnto him, What signe shewest thou vnto vs, that thou doest these things?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
The Jews, therefore, answered, and said to him: What sign dost thou shew unto us, seeing thou dost these things?
Cross-references
- Matthew 12:38-40
Then certain of the scribes and of the Pharisees answered, saying, Master, we would see a sign from thee.
Religious leaders demand a sign, and Jesus points to one connected with His death and resurrection.
- Matthew 21:12-13
And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves,
Both describe Jesus cleansing the temple and confronting its misuse.
- John 3:2
The same came to Jesus by night, and said unto him, Rabbi, we know that thou art a teacher come from God: for no man can do these miracles that thou doest, except God be with him.
Nicodemus recognizes Jesus’ signs as evidence that God is with him.
- Mark 11:15-17
And they come to Jerusalem: and Jesus went into the temple, and began to cast out them that sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves;
Both describe Jesus cleansing the temple.
- Matthew 27:40
And saying, Thou that destroyest the temple, and buildest it in three days, save thyself. If thou be the Son of God, come down from the cross.
Passersby repeat the twisted temple saying at the cross.
- Luke 11:29-30
And when the people were gathered thick together, he began to say, This is an evil generation: they seek a sign; and there shall no sign be given it, but the sign of Jonas the prophet.
Jesus answers sign-seeking with the sign of Jonah.
- John 2:22
When therefore he was risen from the dead, his disciples remembered that he had said this unto them; and they believed the scripture, and the word which Jesus had said.
The disciples understood Jesus’ words after his resurrection and believed.
- Luke 19:45-46
And he went into the temple, and began to cast out them that sold therein, and them that bought;
Parallel account of Jesus driving out those selling in the temple.
- Matthew 21:23
And when he was come into the temple, the chief priests and the elders of the people came unto him as he was teaching, and said, By what authority doest thou these things? and who gave thee this authority?
The leaders challenge Jesus’ authority in the temple.
- Matthew 26:61
And said, This fellow said, I am able to destroy the temple of God, and to build it in three days.
Both portray Christ’s words about the temple as misrepresented.
- Psalms 69:9
For the zeal of thine house hath eaten me up; and the reproaches of them that reproached thee are fallen upon me.
The disciples recall this Scripture after Jesus cleanses the temple.
- Matthew 21:13
And said unto them, It is written, My house shall be called the house of prayer; but ye have made it a den of thieves.
Christ condemns the temple traffic as robbery.
- Malachi 3:1
Behold, I will send my messenger, and he shall prepare the way before me: and the Lord, whom ye seek, shall suddenly come to his temple, even the messenger of the covenant, whom ye delight in: behold, he shall come, saith the LORD of hosts.
The prophecy foretells the Lord’s coming to his temple, where Jesus acts with authority.
- 1 Corinthians 3:17
If any man defile the temple of God, him shall God destroy; for the temple of God is holy, which temple ye are.
Cited alongside John 2 in the discussion of bodily care and spiritual life.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
15 sources
After He drove the traders and money changers from the temple courts at Passover, the priests and rulers demanded what sign of authority He could show for interrupting their market and trade.DA 163.4–164.3Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–10Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–12DA 154.3–155.1 They asked this though they had already been given convincing evidence of His divine mission in His works, the conviction of the Holy Spirit upon their hearts, the display of divine power in the cleansing itself, and the prophecies they should have recognized.DA 163.4–164.3Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–122SP 121.2–122.1 Their question came from offended unbelief, pride, jealousy, and refusal to repent, to protect their own influence rather than yield to conviction that He might be God's prophet and the promised Messiah.DA 163.4–164.3Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–12DA 162.1–4 The cleansing itself was already the strongest proof of His divine commission, so no further sign would convince them once that act had failed to do so.ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.1ST Jan 4, 1877 In answer He pointed to His own death and resurrection, speaking of destroying the temple and raising it in three days, meaning the temple of His body.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–102SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877
Temple Cleansing Setting
The demand for a sign belongs to the Passover cleansing of the temple, when the courts at Jerusalem were crowded and the selling of sacrificial animals and the exchanging of money had become a source of fraud and profit for the priests.DA 154.3–155.1 The question about authority arose directly out of what Jesus did in that defiled setting.DA 154.3–155.1
Through that cleansing He announced His messianic mission and began His public work.ST Jul 28, 1909 The temple had been intended as God's dwelling place and as an object lesson for Israel and the world, and through the incarnation God dwells in humanity, so that saving grace makes the human heart His temple again.ST Jul 28, 1909 The dignitaries of the temple judged His actions, yet news of those actions helped open the way for Him in Galilee, where many lamented the abuse of the temple and the arrogance of the priests and hoped He might be the promised Deliverer.2SP 151.2
The rulers' demand came after He had cleansed the temple courts, and on the following day He healed the sick, relieved the afflicted, taught the people, and silenced objections with His wisdom.ST Apr 15, 1886 Nicodemus witnessed those works and concluded that He was sent by God.ST Apr 15, 1886 His course in cleansing the temple proved Him a truer friend to the temple than the priests and rulers whose conduct had profaned it.Ms 120, 1901, par. 5–6
Demand Despite Conviction
The demand for a sign was made by the priests and rulers, the chief priests and elders, and the temple authorities, to call Jesus to justify His authority for cleansing the temple and interrupting its market and trade.DA 163.4–164.3Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–122SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.1 They challenged Him to show by what right He drove out the traders and stopped the traffic they themselves permitted.DA 162.1–4ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909
They made this demand though convincing evidence of His divine mission had already been given them in His works and in the light He brought to their hearts.DA 163.4–164.3Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–122SP 121.2–122.1 The Holy Spirit had pressed that evidence upon them, and strong proof of His divine commission had been seen in the display of divine power in the cleansing act itself.Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–122SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.11RED 80.3–81.1 They had the sacred scrolls and the prophecies they should have recognized, yet still asked for a sign.ST Aug 4, 1909
The question did not arise from lack of evidence, for they had closed their hearts to conviction and were determined not to yield to Him.Ms 37, 1894, par. 11–12DA 162.1–4 It came from offended unbelief, and from pride, jealousy, and refusal to repent in the face of words that convinced them and power they recognized.DA 163.4–164.3DA 162.1–4 They suppressed the conviction that He might be God's prophet and the promised Messiah, choosing opposition rather than submission from fear of losing the authority they followed.DA 163.4–164.3 They treated His mission as an unwarranted innovation because the temple authorities permitted the traffic, and their desire to protect their own influence and authority led them to demand a sign rather than accept the evidence.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909
They asked with outward fear and deference, from lingering fear left by what they had witnessed.2SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.11RED 80.3–81.1 They concluded He must be a prophet sent from God to restore the sanctity of the temple.LC1 80.3–81.11RED 80.3–81.1 Yet they asked from unbelieving hearts, unable to recognize who He was.2SP 121.2–122.1LC1 80.3–81.1
The cleansing itself was already the strongest proof of His divine commission, displaying divine power before them.ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.1ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909 Their demand overlooked that proof, and no further sign would convince or persuade them once that act had failed to do so.ST Jan 4, 1877LC1 80.3–81.1ST Jan 4, 1877
Resurrection Sign Foretold
The demand for a sign was a challenge to His authority for His actions in cleansing the temple and interrupting its market and trade.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–102SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877 In answer He spoke of destroying the temple and raising it in three days.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–102SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877 By this He pointed to His own death and resurrection, for the temple He would raise was His own body.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–102SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877
The leaders took His words only as a claim about the Jerusalem building, mistaking them for a claim about Jerusalem's temple.2SP 121.2–122.1ST Jan 4, 1877 His body was the earthly temple of the Son of God, so His words bore upon both the Jerusalem temple and His body.2SP 121.2–122.1 After His resurrection the disciples remembered His words and understood their meaning.2SP 121.2–122.1
His words were twisted into the claim that He had said He would destroy the temple.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–10 At the cross this distorted claim was repeated as a taunt.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–10 There it was also used as evidence against Him.Ms 52, 1897, par. 7–10
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
21 sources
After He drove the sellers and money changers from the temple, the Jewish leaders demanded proof of His authority to do so.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Feb 22, 1899ST Aug 20, 1894ST Feb 22, 1899ST Oct 11, 1899 They had witnessed divine power and possessed the prophecies, yet from unbelief and desire to protect their own influence they resisted conviction and overlooked the proof already given.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909 The cleansing itself was the strongest evidence of His divine commission, which no further sign would overcome if rejected.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877 He answered by offering His death and resurrection in three days as the sign, speaking of the temple of His body as the true meeting place where God dwells with humanity through His becoming flesh.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Dec 19, 1907ST Aug 23, 1910ST Apr 20, 1915ST May 7, 1902 The demand for a sign marks a backslidden church blind to the mightiest sign before it in God's truth revealed in Christ, and teaches that holy things must not be treated as common but met with willing submission to God.ST Jul 28, 1909ST Sep 17, 1894ST Nov 28, 1906
Setting and Demand
The demand for a sign was an answer to Jesus' cleansing of the temple, challenging Him to prove His authority for acting as He had done.ST Feb 22, 1899ST Aug 20, 1894ST Feb 22, 1899ST Jul 9, 1896ST Oct 11, 1899 It came after He drove out the sellers and money changers, the traders and merchants, and expelled them from the temple and its courts.ST Aug 20, 1894ST Feb 22, 1899ST Jul 9, 1896ST Aug 20, 1894ST Oct 11, 1899 Those who made it were the Jews in the sense of the Jewish leaders, the chief priests and elders, the rulers and temple authorities.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909ST Oct 11, 1899
They asked although the cleansing itself displayed divine power and was the strongest proof of His divine commission.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909 They had the sacred scrolls and prophecies that should have led them to recognize Him, yet from fear and deference, from unbelief and desire to protect their own influence, they resisted conviction that He was the Messiah.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909 Because they themselves permitted the traffic, they treated His mission as an unwarranted innovation, and in demanding a further sign they overlooked the proof already given.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 4, 1909 No further sign would persuade them if they rejected that evidence.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Jan 4, 1877
Their question followed the signs He had done in Jerusalem at the feast, which had led many to believe in Him.ST Mar 15, 1899 This cleansing was an earlier occasion, distinct from the other cleansing that took place during His final visit to Jerusalem.ST Apr 14, 1898 The Jews' reply about forty-six years of building, counted from Herod's preparations for rebuilding the temple, places this first Passover of His ministry in A.D. 28.RH Dec 19, 1907 The rulers' demand came after He cleansed the temple courts, and on the day that followed He healed the sick, relieved the afflicted, taught the people, and silenced objections with His wisdom, leading Nicodemus to conclude He was sent by God.ST Apr 15, 1886
Christ's Answering Sign
When challenged to justify cleansing the temple, Jesus answered by speaking of the temple of His body, declaring it would be raised in three days, while the Jews mistook His words for a claim about the Jerusalem temple building they said had taken forty-six years to build.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Dec 19, 1907 The demand came from the chief priests and elders questioning His authority, arising from fear and deference yet overlooking the strong proof already given by His act.ST Jan 4, 1877 The forty-six years, counted from Herod's preparations for rebuilding the temple, place this first Passover of His ministry in A.D. 28.RH Dec 19, 1907
Destroying the temple points to His death and raising it in three days points to His resurrection, which He offered as the sign of His authority.ST Jan 4, 1877ST Aug 23, 1910ST Apr 20, 1915 Scripture had foretold that He would die so others might live and be raised, and His faith in those promises was His authority for driving them out.ST Apr 20, 1915 The earthly temples also foreshadowed His life, ministry, and sacrifice.ST Aug 23, 1910
The tabernacle and temple services pointed to His incarnation and to His mediatorship in the flesh.ST May 7, 1902 His body is the true temple, the appointed meeting place between God and humanity through the Son becoming human and dwelling among people.ST May 7, 1902ST May 7, 1902 Through the incarnation God dwells in humanity, and He is the foundation of the spiritual temple God establishes, while saving grace makes the human heart His temple again.ST Jul 28, 1909ST May 7, 1902ST May 7, 1902
Lessons and Warnings
The closing of the temple against common traffic teaches that holy things must not be treated as common.ST Sep 17, 1894 God's service calls for willing submission to His law and directions.ST Sep 17, 1894 It does not consist in care for human traditions while neglecting what God has made holy.ST Sep 17, 1894
Through cleansing the temple Jesus announced His messianic mission and began His work.ST Jul 28, 1909 The temple had been intended as a dwelling place for God and an object lesson for Israel and the world.ST Jul 28, 1909 Through the incarnation God dwells in humanity, and saving grace makes the human heart His temple again.ST Jul 28, 1909
Christ's words on this occasion were misrepresented and used in an attempt to prove that He was an impostor.RH Jan 18, 1870
The demand for a sign is the mark of an apostate, backslidden church that is ever looking for signs.ST Nov 28, 1906 Such sign-seeking blinded those making the demand to the mightiest sign of all before them, the demonstration of the word and truth of God in the humanity of Jesus.ST Nov 28, 1906 The same demand repeats when the Christian church departs from the simplicity of the Word to seek merit in sacred places, holy things, and bones and relics of departed saints.ST Nov 28, 1906 That superstition brings appeal to civil law to support traditional dogma and brings the Dark Ages and all the fearful persecutions that followed.ST Nov 28, 1906
Sources