Matthew 5:30
And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
Translations
And if your right hand offend you, cut it off, and cast it from you: for it is profitable for you that one of your members should perish, and not that your whole body should be cast into hell.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
And if thy right hand shall cause thee to sin, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And if thy right hand causeth thee to stumble, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not thy whole body go into hell.
'And, if thy right hand doth cause thee to stumble, cut it off, and cast from thee, for it is good to thee that one of thy members may perish, and not thy whole body be cast to gehenna.
And if thy right hand be a snare to thee, cut it off and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members perish, and not thy whole body be cast into hell.
And, if, thy right hand, is causing thee to stumble, cut it off, and cast it from thee,—for it profiteth thee, that, one of thy members, should perish, and not, thy whole body, into gehenna, depart.
And if your right hand causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to depart into hell.
And if your right hand causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to lose one part of your body than for your whole body to be cast into hell.
If your right hand causes you to stumble, cut it off, and throw it away from you. For it is more profitable for you that one of your members should perish, than for your whole body to be cast into Gehenna.
And if your right hand is a cause of trouble to you, let it be cut off and put it away from you; because it is better to undergo the loss of one part, than for all your body to go into hell.
Also if thy right hand make thee to offend, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for better it is for thee that one of thy members perish, then that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And if thy right hand scandalize thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is expedient for thee that one of thy members should perish, rather than that thy whole body be cast into hell.
Cross-references
- Mark 9:43-48
And if thy hand offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter into life maimed, than having two hands to go into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
Both warn that removing what leads to sin is better than being cast into hell.
- Matthew 18:8-9
Wherefore if thy hand or thy foot offend thee, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into everlasting fire.
Both urge removing what leads to sin rather than being cast into Gehenna fire.
- Luke 12:5
But I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: Fear him, which after he hath killed hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, Fear him.
Both warn that God has power to cast a person into Gehenna.
- Matthew 10:28
And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
Both warn that God can destroy soul and body in hell.
- Matthew 5:22
But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.
Both warn of Gehenna as the place of future punishment.
- Exodus 20:14
Thou shalt not commit adultery.
Jesus explains the seventh commandment.
- Mark 9:47
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out: it is better for thee to enter into the kingdom of God with one eye, than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire:
Both warn that offending members can lead to being cast into Gehenna.
- Colossians 3:5
Mortify therefore your members which are upon the earth; fornication, uncleanness, inordinate affection, evil concupiscence, and covetousness, which is idolatry:
Both call for putting sinful desires to death.
- Matthew 23:33
Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell?
Both warn of being cast into Gehenna.
- Galatians 5:24
And they that are Christ’s have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts.
Both call for putting sinful desires to death.
- James 3:6
And the tongue is a fire, a world of iniquity: so is the tongue among our members, that it defileth the whole body, and setteth on fire the course of nature; and it is set on fire of hell.
Both use Gehenna for future punishment.
- Mark 9:45
And if thy foot offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter halt into life, than having two feet to be cast into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
Both warn that it is better to lose a member than be cast into Gehenna.
- 2 Kings 23:10
And he defiled Topheth, which is in the valley of the children of Hinnom, that no man might make his son or his daughter to pass through the fire to Molech.
Identifies the valley from which Gehenna takes its name.
- Jeremiah 7:31-33
And they have built the high places of Tophet, which is in the valley of the son of Hinnom, to burn their sons and their daughters in the fire; which I commanded them not, neither came it into my heart.
The Valley of Hinnom is associated with death and judgment.
- Matthew 5:1-2
And seeing the multitudes, he went up into a mountain: and when he was set, his disciples came unto him:
Introduces the discourse that includes the verse.
- Romans 6:6
Knowing this, that our old man is crucified with him, that the body of sin might be destroyed, that henceforth we should not serve sin.
The passage connects putting away sin with crucifying the old self so that sin no longer rules.
- Matthew 10:38
And he that taketh not his cross, and followeth after me, is not worthy of me.
Following Christ may require costly renunciation.
- Matthew 16:26
For what is a man profited, if he shall gain the whole world, and lose his own soul? or what shall a man give in exchange for his soul?
Gaining the world cannot compensate for losing one’s soul.
- Matthew 16:24
Then said Jesus unto his disciples, If any man will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.
Both give Christ’s costly terms of following.
- Mark 8:34
And when he had called the people unto him with his disciples also, he said unto them, Whosoever will come after me, let him deny himself, and take up his cross, and follow me.
Taking up the cross means denying self and submitting to Christ.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
78 sources
The right hand stands for anything cherished as precious, valuable or essential that causes wrong, leads into sin, or hinders spiritual life and growth.ST Sep 10, 1885Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16AAP 6.3 Cutting it off and casting it away is not a command to injure the body but a figure for decisive surrender, removal and sacrifice to save the soul.MYP 56.1DA 523.4Lt 25b, 1892, par. 8–9 It demands that whatever causes sin, hinders growth, or dishonors Christ be rejected and put away with no concession or compromise, even at great personal cost as severe as losing hand or eye.ST Sep 10, 1885DA 298AAP 6.3RH Feb 10, 1903 What must be cut off includes evil traits and cherished habits, sensual indulgence, intense love of money, self-reliance and self-righteousness, and worldly ties that obstruct God's work or lead others astray.Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16ST May 20, 18975T 340.1STMW7 55.1STA 93.2 It is profitable to suffer that loss rather than let sin bring ruin on the whole person, for eternal life is worth every lifelong persevering sacrifice.ST Sep 10, 1885DA 298HSP 10.5Lt 106a, 1896, par. 48
Setting in Sermon on Mount
The saying was spoken on a mountainside in the Sermon on the Mount, given especially to the disciples but within hearing of the assembled multitude gathered from Galilee and many other regions.DA 298.2–3 It belongs to Christ's instruction on the principles of His kingdom of divine grace rather than earthly glory.2SP 204.1 His followers must learn and obey that instruction rather than insist on their own way, putting aside conduct opposed to His teaching and forming Christlike character, with failure to do so bringing condemnation.Ms 151, 1902, par. 8–9 That instruction is to be read and written on the heart, with Christian character shaped by God's Spirit and faith purifying the soul from objectionable tendencies whether hereditary or cultivated.ST May 10, 1910 These lessons are to be exemplified in life, and living them can make a deeper and more lasting impression than preaching them.6T 472.1
It reveals the law's far-reaching claims, not a cold code of commands and human traditions, but God's enduring standard of righteousness, holy, just and good.FE 237.1 On the mount the law is shown to reach far beyond outward acts, condemning every evil action and demanding perfect obedience.ST Jan 9, 1912 The claims of the law require the spirit of the law in the heart, because the state of the heart regulates the life and character.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34 New converts must be impressed with these far-reaching principles, or labor to instruct them in the law will be lost.Lt 7, 1886, par. 34
It was taught with divine authority rather than repeating human traditions, setting aside the continually repeated they say and it hath been said of the rabbinical schools, which corrupt the mind, and giving instead a greater and certain wisdom to be accepted over the unstable words of men.8T 310.2Ms 41a, 1896, par. 20 Its teaching opposed the doctrines and practices of the self-righteous scribes and Pharisees and challenged their misrepresentation of God as stern and without compassion, mercy or love.FE 309.1 It directs people to God's truth and away from corrupting influences, as the standard by which conduct and character are to be shaped rather than the repeated traditions and teachings of human authorities.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 20Ms 41b, 1896, par. 19–22 In that sermon it warns that failing to walk in the light God has given separates people from Him, with darkness coming in proportion to the light allowed to shine on the path.ST Mar 26, 1896
Meaning of the Imagery
The right hand, like the right eye, stands for anything cherished as precious, valuable, useful, dear, or essential that causes offense, leads into sin, or hinders religious life and spiritual growth.ST Sep 10, 1885Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16AAP 6.3HSP 10.5ST Dec 7, 1882 It is a valued indulgence or attachment that must be put away even at great personal cost rather than allowed to endanger eternal life.ST Sep 10, 1885AAP 6.3HSP 10.5ST Dec 7, 1882MYP 56.1 A cherished sin so retained keeps the soul in bondage and makes living faith ineffective, preventing growth and nearness to God.Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16
Cutting it off and casting it away is a figure for decisive surrender, removal, and sacrifice to save the soul, not a command to mutilate the body or injure oneself.MYP 56.1DA 523.4Lt 25b, 1892, par. 8–9 The hand is a picture of what must be surrendered in self-surrender and obedience, because keeping what corrupts the whole character leaves no way to be saved.MYP 56.1DA 523.4 Even personal dignity must be yielded rather than letting the natural heart rule against plain commands.Lt 25b, 1892, par. 8–9
Cutting off the hand represents the surrender of the will, because sin retains its hold through the will. Surrendering the will often feels like consenting to go through life maimed, wounded, or crippled, yet it is better for self to be maimed if thus one may enter into life.Lt 106a, 1896, par. 48 Sin must therefore be treated with utmost seriousness and never made light of, giving up what is as precious as the right hand rather than keeping it while practicing sin.Lt 106a, 1896, par. 48
Just as a person would give up a hand to stop disease from spreading and destroying the body, so a person should give up what leads the soul toward sin and destruction. Whatever causes the soul to stumble must be sacrificed in order to be saved from sin itself and restored to the divine image. What looks like disaster is the door to highest benefit. The loss of the right hand shows how completely one who understands that a course sets him against God would reject it, no more choosing it than severing his own hand, calling for decisive action to avoid sin and its deadly consequences.Lt 18, 1901, par. 3
Call to Decisive Separation
Anything that draws into sin must be decisively rejected, forsaken and put away, for losing something valuable is better than letting sin bring the whole person to destruction.DA 298RH Feb 10, 190312MR 336.1 Anything causing sin or hindering spiritual growth and the forming of character in cooperation with God, anything leading into sin and dishonoring Christ, anything dear to the carnal nature that causes stumbling, including every darling indulgence, cherished idol and cherished sin, must be given up and cut off rather than allowed to endanger eternal life, degrade character, mislead others and bring death to the soul.RH Feb 10, 190312MR 336.1Ms 180, 1901, par. 5–7 The removal must allow no concession or compromise, with urgent determined resistance and perseverance through spiritual opposition, and nothing permitted to lead toward hell or imperil eternal life.12MR 336.1Ms 180, 1901, par. 5–7 Merely recognizing sin is not enough, for sin must be decisively forsaken as if removing a right eye or cutting off a right hand, which shows the seriousness of turning from sin to God rather than continuing in it.Lt 107, 1903, par. 15–19Ms 35, 1903, par. 6
The separation is to be made even at great personal cost, however painful and severe, as severe as losing a hand, eye or arm.ST Sep 10, 1885AAP 6.3RH Nov 18, 19095T 222.1–3Ms 5, 1885, par. 10–12 Even what is as dear, precious, valued and useful as hand or eye, a valued indulgence or attachment that hinders religious life and leads to sin, must be sacrificed if it causes offense rather than allowed to endanger eternal life and faithfulness to truth.ST Sep 10, 1885AAP 6.3RH Nov 18, 19095T 222.1–3Ms 99, 1902, par. 28 The path to heaven requires self-denial and effort, and the prize of eternal life is worth every necessary effort and sacrifice, of infinite value, so welcoming the aid of the Holy Spirit and cooperating with it calls for efforts and sacrifices proportionate to the object to be attained.ST Sep 10, 1885RH Nov 18, 1909Ms 99, 1902, par. 28 This includes giving up self-reliance, self-righteousness, worldly associations and human approval and the approbation of men when they obstruct the way to heaven, and being willing to renounce human wisdom and receive the kingdom as a little child.ST Sep 10, 1885Ms 99, 1902, par. 28
The demand applies even to one weak point in an otherwise strong character, for indulging one sin divides the heart's service and is no trifling matter, and that sin must be overcome rather than excused.Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16MYP 91.1Ms 35, 1903, par. 6 Retaining a sensual indulgence or lust, or any cherished sin become as dear or useful as hand or eye, keeps the soul in bondage and makes living faith ineffective, preventing spiritual growth and nearness to God.Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16MYP 91.1 If such sins are retained Satan can use them as snares, while true repentance turns from sin to God.Ms 35, 1903, par. 6
Obedience is intelligent faith, and service to God is self-denial requiring soberness, thoughtfulness and decided purpose to obey all requirements even when obedience takes away what is as dear as the right eye or right arm.Ms 99, 1902, par. 28ST Jul 28, 1898 Intellect must be used in spiritual matters as in business, conscientiously weighing evidence, thinking deeply and counting the cost, because eternal life is to be gained or lost.ST Jul 28, 1898 The warfare between good and evil has not grown less fierce than in the days of Christ, the path to heaven is no smoother, and self still battles fiercely for supremacy.Ms 99, 1902, par. 28
What Must Be Cut Off
Evil traits of character must be closely examined, uprooted and separated lest they corrupt the whole person and destroy influence for good, even when the separation is painful as losing a cherished member.ST May 20, 1897STMW7 55.1STA 93.2STBk 93.2Lt 56, 1896, par. 10 The offending hand and eye stand for hidden depravity, evil desires and faults whether hereditary or cultivated and Satan-inspired, and favorite vices formed by habit, requiring personal purification through obedience to the truth.STMW7 55.1STA 93.2STBk 93.2Lt 56, 1896, par. 10Lt 40, 1892, par. 23–26 Selfishness, covetousness, harshness and unkindness must be taken out of the life, with pride, sensuality, selfish ambition and self-esteem also cut away, otherwise they make a person offensive to God and neglectful of those needing help.ST May 20, 1897ST2 36.2STM2 20.2
Sensual indulgence and lust kept in the heart hold the soul in bondage and make living faith ineffective, preventing growth and nearness to God, and must be decisively put away though as precious and useful as the right hand.Ms 4, 1904, par. 15–16 Every cherished habit or practice that dishonors God degrades character, can mislead others and brings death to the soul, and must be removed whatever the sacrifice rather than forfeit eternal life.DA 438.2–439.1 Intense love of money is like a right arm that must be cut off or it will cost salvation, and parting with money for the work of saving others feels to a selfish heart like cutting off the right hand, while a generous heart finds the demand small and relieving.5T 340.1SG2 231.1Lt 9, 1857, par. 1–4
For a covetous man who loves money, some of it not honestly gained, being saved requires painful self-denial as severe as taking out the right eye or cutting off the right arm, by redeeming the time and making restitution wherever he has wronged anyone as it comes to mind.3T 549.5 That painful work is his only hope of pardoning love with no other way, repeated efforts fail without it, yet if in the few remaining days of life he begins there will be hope, while going on as before leaves his case hopeless to lose both worlds, see the saints glorified in the heavenly city while himself thrust out, with no part in the precious life purchased at infinite cost which he sold for earthly riches.3T 549.5
Self-reliance, self-righteousness, self-confidence, human wisdom, self-sufficiency and cherished human plans and purposes, however desirable and flawless they seem, must be sacrificed when they oppose God's purposes, spiritual health and the future well-being of His cause.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Dec 7, 1882Ms 99, 1902, par. 28RH Oct 23, 1900Ms 147, 1899, par. 4–5 Obedience means renouncing human wisdom to receive the kingdom as a little child, parting with self-righteousness, sacrificing the approbation of men and worldly associations when they obstruct the way to heaven, and yielding plans to wiser judgment to protect the soul.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Dec 7, 1882Ms 99, 1902, par. 28Lt 32, 1875, par. 9–14 Giving up one's own way and ideas to receive counsel and follow wiser judgment can feel as painful as losing a right hand or right arm, yet the loss is preferable to losing eternal life.ST Sep 10, 1885Lt 32, 1875, par. 9–14Ms 147, 1899, par. 4–5
Worldly associates and human approval must be given up when they hinder religious life and stand in the way of faithfulness, and influence or advantage must be surrendered rather than used to obstruct God's light or weaken those God is using, for that is grievous sin.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Dec 7, 1882Lt 25b, 1892, par. 18 It is better to suffer loss of a member than to bring another into a wrong course, and in a community of different temperaments and backgrounds all must guard against leading one another to forget God.Lt 25b, 1892, par. 18Ms 103, 1909, par. 6 The warning reaches even disciples whose conduct turns away one Christ is drawing.DA 438.2–439.1
The hand and eye to remove are the inward inclination to feel abused and slighted, complain of brethren, suppose they purpose a hard and trying position, discern things in a wrong light with incorrect and unjust suppositions that feel real, bear false witness in the heart, harass life with miserable reflections and grievances kept fresh and gone over again and again, and recall thwarted will and changed plans as if harm were designed.Lt 10, 1894, par. 6–8Lt 10, 1894, par. 9–11 These are direct insinuations of Satan cutting and bruising the soul and bringing unhappiness on self and loved ones.Lt 10, 1894, par. 6–8Lt 10, 1894, par. 9–11 Cutting off means quelling that inclination, ceasing to worry, fret, complain and reflect upon brethren, seeing good in everything, looking past the brother to Jesus to receive His likeness with single eye to His glory, trusting the heavenly Father as a child trusts a parent without fear, resting secure as His property by creation and redemption under His special care and letting Him make all work for sanctification, which reshapes ways and thoughts and gives confidence in brethren.Lt 10, 1894, par. 6–8Lt 10, 1894, par. 9–11
Ministers and workers in responsible positions who gratify selfish propensities, do only what agrees with tastes and ideas, make provision for pride and sensuality, carry out selfish ambitions and plans, are full of self-esteem and do not grow in grace and knowledge must have evil propensities cut off and be separated from them or they cannot be acceptable before God.ST2 36.2STBk 93.2Lt 40, 1892, par. 23–26STM2 20.2 They must put on Christ, find in Him wisdom, sanctification and redemption, dedicate themselves without reservation and take Him as personal Saviour to represent His religion.ST2 36.2 Accepting and retaining workers who persist in imperfections and give no full proof of ministry greatly lowers the standard, so candidates must be thoroughly examined as to qualifications before ordination rather than after they are established and have put their mould upon the work.ST2 36.2
Business interests that bind hand and foot and whatever entangles and holds back from God-given work must be cut to the last thread, with cherished things kept back as a snare cut out and taken off if necessary, to throw oneself without reserve wholly into the work stepping by faith into the unseen with God helping and holding in His strong arms.Lt 127, 1894, par. 6–7Ms 26, 1899, par. 29–30 The soul must be cleansed from corrupt practices such as unjustly taking another's means, which fail the law and gospel taught on the Mount, choosing to lose even what is as dear as eye or hand rather than do a dishonest action, working with exactitude and diligence and bringing solid timbers into character.Lt 12a, 1893, par. 4Ms 26, 1899, par. 29–30 A valued course or line of labor that is breaking down physical and mental strength by exhausting strain must be stopped at once with thorough rest and entire change of work, calling unused organs of the brain into exercise rather than drawing on future capital and risking complete ruin on the very brink of the precipice.Lt 35, 1893, par. 9–106MR 225.2 Though feeling like taking off the right arm and taking out the right eye, the sacrifice is positively necessary and pays, for after months of complete change a person may through God's blessing become as a new man.Lt 35, 1893, par. 9–106MR 225.2
Straight testimony must continue, as in Monterey, even if it cuts off what is as precious as right arm or right eye, confronting wrong without compromise so God can purify a people zealous for good works.15MR 333.3Ms 4, 1860, par. 20–21 Missionaries must separate from selfish desires and inclinations rather than follow them, for choosing those desires dishonors God, harms His cause and makes a person unfit to be sent abroad.Ms 109, 1894, par. 3 Facing and acknowledging wrong without defending self can feel like losing a right hand or right arm in decisive break with attachment, as when it was painfully hard for Dr. Kellogg to admit his mistakes.Lt 29, 1904, par. 2Lt 4, 1885, par. 7–8 Cutting off means dying to self by thoroughly confessing past wrongs and making them right as far as possible with no deception or impurity remaining, giving up even things seeming essential to happiness rather than keeping them while practicing sin.Ms 48, 1894, par. 8Lt 11, 1864, par. 14–16
The verse calls for choosing even loss of the right hand rather than showing disrespect to God in anything, with full resolve to obey Him and preserve obedience over dignity and cherished interests rather than let the natural heart rule against His plain commands.5MR 365.4–367.3Lt 25b, 1892, par. 8–9Lt 67, 1887, par. 1–4 This applies to keeping the Sabbath holy by accepting even the heaviest day of labor when the work is the Lord's work in His cause, refusing personal business or advantage.Lt 67, 1887, par. 1–4 The image is also putting self to death and giving up self-centered struggle so Christ may live within, humbling self before God, removing what hinders forming character in cooperation with God, and severing anything earthly coming between the person and God as preparation for seeing His face and becoming Christlike.Ms 79, 1906, par. 9Ms 11, 1896, par. 1–4Ms 180, 1901, par. 5–7Ms 231, 1902, par. 67–72 A follower must give up what is precious rather than abandon principle with faithfulness firm, for the amputation is the cutting out of selfishness from the character by truth, without which there is no hope of eternal life or faithful service.Ms 79, 1906, par. 9Lt 48, 1892, par. 14–15Ms 43, 1900, par. 46
Worth and Power of Surrender
It is profitable to lose one member rather than have the whole body cast into hell, for losing something valuable is better than letting sin bring destruction, death and ruin on the whole person.DA 298Lt 106a, 1896, par. 48DA 438.2–439.1Lt 16f, 1892, par. 22–23 Anything drawing a person into sin, dishonoring Christ, degrading character, misleading others and bringing death to the soul must be decisively rejected and put away, whatever the sacrifice.DA 298Lt 106a, 1896, par. 48DA 438.2–439.1 The comparison of giving up what is as precious as the right hand in order to enter the kingdom maimed stresses decisive separation from sin and warns against making light of wrongdoing.Lt 106a, 1896, par. 4812MR 336.1Lt 16f, 1892, par. 22–23 Nothing should be allowed to lead toward hell or imperil eternal life, and the image calls for urgent, determined resistance to sin and perseverance through spiritual opposition.DA 438.2–439.112MR 336.1Lt 16f, 1892, par. 22–23
Eternal life is worth every necessary effort and lifelong persevering sacrifice, for it is of infinite value.ST Sep 10, 1885HSP 10.5RH Nov 18, 1909MYP 56.1Ms 99, 1902, par. 28 Anything cherished that hinders religious life, spiritual growth and progress heavenward — a valued indulgence or attachment, self-reliance, self-righteousness, worldly associations, human wisdom and human approval — must be put away even at great personal cost rather than allowed to endanger eternal life.ST Sep 10, 1885HSP 10.5RH Nov 18, 1909MYP 56.1Ms 99, 1902, par. 28 The hand and eye are figures for such indulgences to be cut off, not a command to injure the body.ST Sep 10, 1885HSP 10.5MYP 56.1 Faith is intelligent faith and service is self-denial requiring soberness, thoughtfulness and decided purpose, using intellect, weighing evidence, thinking deeply and counting the cost, because eternal life is to be gained or lost and the warfare between good and evil is no less fierce than in Christ's day, the path to heaven no smoother, and self still battles fiercely for supremacy.RH Nov 18, 1909Ms 99, 1902, par. 28ST Jul 28, 1898 Welcoming the aid of the Holy Spirit and cooperating with it requires efforts and sacrifices proportionate to the value of the object to be attained, and this complete separation makes calling and election sure.HSP 10.5RH Nov 18, 1909Ms 99, 1902, par. 28
Surrendering the will to God in this painful sacrifice does not destroy it, for when yielded to God it is restored, purified and joined to the divine will. What appears to be loss brings spiritual victory, as weakness and suffering become means through which faith is strengthened. The change is accomplished when Christian character is shaped by God's Spirit and faith purifies the soul from objectionable tendencies, whether hereditary or cultivated.ST May 10, 1910Ms 46, 1894, par. 10ST Mar 5, 1912 When Satan-inspired attributes represented by the hand and eye are surrendered, Christ's love makes the person tender and compassionate.Ms 46, 1894, par. 10Ms 67, 1894, par. 6–8Ms 43, 1900, par. 46 The Word of God received and lived produces faith working through love that purifies the soul and removes inherited evil tendencies and wrong traits strengthened by habit, before their power corrupts the whole person and destroys influence for good, and the struggle ends when truth enters the heart and its affections through the Holy Spirit so that the will is submitted to God and the whole person is brought under Christ's rule.Ms 99, 1902, par. 28ST Mar 5, 1912Ms 67, 1894, par. 6–8Ms 43, 1900, par. 46 The amputation is the cutting out of selfishness from the character by the truth of God, without which there is no hope of eternal life.Ms 46, 1894, par. 10ST Mar 5, 1912Ms 43, 1900, par. 46
Overcoming requires earnest, determined effort, urgent resistance and perseverance through opposition, with self-denial and toil.Lt 12a, 1893, par. 412MR 336.1Lt 16f, 1892, par. 22–23 When truth is brought into the sanctuary of the soul and enshrined in the heart, its sanctifying power produces virtue in word, deportment, character and spirit.Lt 12a, 1893, par. 4 So a person becomes a representative of Christ in every place and under all circumstances, working with exactitude and diligence and bringing solid timbers of character into the building instead of seeking an easy time without exertion of muscle and nerve and taxing of mind and body, choosing to lose even what is as dear as eye or hand rather than do a dishonest action.Lt 12a, 1893, par. 412MR 336.1Lt 16f, 1892, par. 22–23
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
110 sources
Christ's command to cut off the offending right hand is figurative, calling for complete and immediate separation from anything that causes stumbling, however dear, useful or painful to lose.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Apr 16, 1867RH Jun 6, 1871RH Aug 29, 1871RH Nov 27, 1860 The hand stands for a cherished sin or indulgence, evil traits and inordinate desires, and also for precious possessions, pursuits, plans and even near family or friends when their influence would lead away from truth.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Mar 13, 1907RH May 8, 1879RH Apr 16, 1867RH Apr 16, 1867 In the Sermon on the Mount Christ thus magnifies the law beyond outward acts to motives, thoughts, desires and passions, showing that hatred and lust are already transgression requiring a cleansed heart and perfect obedience through Him.RH Sep 14, 1869ST Sep 27, 1883RH May 17, 1864RH Jul 26, 1870RH May 17, 1864 It is profitable to suffer that loss and enter life without it than to keep it and have soul and body together cast into Gehenna after the resurrection and judgment.STST Mar 13, 1907ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 22, 1869 That Gehenna is a real future place of retributive fire where God destroys body and soul until nothing remains, not the grave or Hades, and not never-ending misery.ST May 22, 1879RH May 23, 1865RH Jun 12, 1860RH Jan 17, 1856RH Aug 29, 1871
Sermon Setting and Context
Matthew 5:30 belongs to Christ's Sermon on the Mount in Matthew 5-7, his first discourse and inaugural address, his longest discourse, spoken from a mountain.ST May 5, 1881RH Mar 31, 1859ST Aug 30, 1877RH May 17, 1864ST Jun 14, 1883 In that same teaching he deals with lust in the heart as adultery, with divorce, and with swearing oaths.RH May 17, 1864 The sermon is to be read in connection with the sermon in Luke 6:12-49, sometimes called the Sermon on the Plain.ST Jan 23, 1896
It was delivered after Jesus chose the twelve, after healing the people on the level place, to disciples and a gathered crowd, addressing their spiritual needs.ST May 5, 1881ST Jan 23, 1896 It was spoken to disciples on the mountainside and first spoken to a gathered multitude centuries ago, yet it carries lessons meant to be understood in their original setting and applied more deeply, with spirit and life for all time.ST May 17, 1905ST Jul 29, 1897 Its meaning holds spiritual riches that call for inward purity and consecration rather than mere outward morality, and is received through thoughtful meditation in the quiet hour by believing and following Christ in simplicity.ST Jul 29, 1897
The sermon presents the moral law and the principles of true religion, including the character required of those who are subjects of his spiritual kingdom.ST Jan 15, 1880ST Apr 9, 1896 Its introduction is the nine beatitudes, which set forth the blessings bestowed from heaven upon those who seek and develop righteousness, God-likeness of character.ST Aug 6, 1912 It gives a full portrait of the Bible Christian and sets a high standard for Christian life, whose real meaning is spiritual and whose principles are to shape people's lives.RH Jan 21, 1875ST Oct 4, 1899 It is Jesus's fullest verbal declaration of the underlying principles of the law, which as a written expression of righteous principles is a transcript of the character of Jehovah, verbally declaring righteousness and truth, justice and mercy that found living expression in the life of Immanuel.ST Aug 6, 1912 Its practical teaching cannot be separated from fellowship with God in Christ.RH Jun 2, 1903
It enforces the moral commandments on all people for all time as the enduring moral standard by which character is formed.RH Mar 31, 1859 It was spoken by the same divine voice that gave the law at Sinai, and did not retract or nullify any portion of that law.ST Sep 22, 1909 Its teaching reaches the inner being and calls for a life of faith and consecration rather than mere outward morality.ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 29, 1897 Its principles are incompatible with deliberately going to war and killing fellow human beings, with angry, explosive behavior as the fruit of remaining carnality and an unsanctified nature, and with acceptance of commercialism and the law of the market.ST Jun 6, 1900RH Jul 24, 1900ST Apr 6, 1882
The verse belongs to Jesus's argument in Matthew 5:17-35 on the ten commandments written on tables of stone, where the three commandments he quoted are sufficient to explain his subject of the whole law.RH Dec 1850 Its instruction is to be read and written on the heart, shaping Christian character by God's Spirit, with faith purifying the soul from objectionable tendencies, whether hereditary or cultivated.ST May 10, 1910 Its requirements provide a searching test of whether a person has kept God's moral law in both letter and spirit, so that candid examination reveals sin and the need of a Saviour and leads to repentance and salvation.RH Dec 10, 1872 Rules of application were given in Matthew 5 to make the Ten Commandments fit Israel's particular circumstances, while Christ's rules for holy living made sacrificial offerings obsolete.ST Sep 8, 1914RH Feb 21, 1854 The closing call to hear and do his sayings covers that whole sermon and embraces all God's commandments, and doing them is building on solid rock that stands when rain descends and floods come and winds blow, while not doing them is building on sliding sand that falls greatly; hearing his words must be followed by doing the work he lays before the church.RH Dec 1850ST Aug 30, 1877
Hand and Cutting Imagery
The command to cut off the right hand is figurative, not a literal order to maim the body or practice self-mutilation, but a forceful picture of separating completely from whatever causes stumbling and endangers salvation.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Apr 16, 1867RH Apr 10, 1913RH Oct 31, 1865ST May 11, 1915 Losing limbs in this life does not mean imperfection in the next, for in God's kingdom there will be no imperfect people, no pain, no sickness, and no mutilated bodies.ST Mar 13, 1907 The language of losing a member rather than having the whole body cast into hell is figurative for final punishment rather than literalistic proof about the body, yet hell itself is not merely a figure but a real place of future punishment.RH Oct 31, 1865RH Oct 31, 1865ST May 12, 1881 The call is not merely to avoid sin but to hate it, giving up anything closely bound to a person, however controlling, that causes sin.RH Apr 10, 1913ST May 11, 1915
The right hand stands for things very dear and useful in this world, such as deft skill of the hand, loved pursuits like art and music and highest harmony, profitable employment, cherished earthly possessions, hopes, joys, ambitions, plans, relationships, human wisdom, self-confidence and self-sufficiency, and stays and supports of life.RH Oct 23, 1900ST Mar 13, 1907RH May 8, 1879RH Oct 17, 1907ST Jan 7, 1886 Anything as dear or useful as a right hand, if it obstructs obedience to truth and loyalty to Christ, must be put away however painful the loss, even going without the highest harmony and art rather than keeping it and having the whole body cast into hell.ST Mar 13, 1907RH May 8, 1879RH Oct 17, 1907 When the wisest and most cherished human plans and purposes that seem desirable and without flaw stand in direct opposition to God's purposes, they must be sacrificed and cut away, because God sees they are not for the spiritual health of the person and for the future well-being of His cause.RH Oct 23, 1900 No power or capacity of life is to be held back or reserved, whether hand for covetous pursuit of wealth and honor, foot for worldliness, or eye for forbidden things, but all is to be separated from sin and consecrated fully.ST May 12, 1881ST Jan 7, 1886 This can require a hard struggle against deeply rooted desires and habits, yet grace and power can overcome them.RH Oct 17, 1907
The offending hand or eye can represent a near and dear family member, especially a wife as a man's right arm of strength, and also a son, daughter, or near friends whose influence would lead a believer away from truth.RH Apr 16, 1867RH Apr 16, 1867RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879 Cutting off means firmly refusing to give up the truth even if that requires painful separation from former associations, worldly ties, and costly sacrifice for the truth, for it is better to enter life maimed and deprived of something precious than to keep it and be cast into hell whole.RH Apr 16, 1867RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879RH Feb 19, 1867 Such complete sacrifice shows appreciation for Christ's sacrifice and is accepted by God.RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879 Faithfulness under that test may move family members to accept the truth and be saved, while yielding the truth risks perdition for the believer and may lead the family to perdition, and the nearby teaching on divorce also presents a wife's serious offense as grounds for divorce.RH Apr 16, 1867
The right hand also represents a cherished sin, favorite transgression, besetting sin, valued indulgence or attachment, evil traits of character, selfish propensities, deeply rooted foolish desires and inordinate affections, including lust, violence, evil passions and sinful appetites, and cherished idols.ST Sep 10, 1885RH May 8, 1879RH Jun 6, 1871RH Apr 24, 1866ST Nov 11, 1889 It includes self-reliance, self-righteousness, worldly associations, and human approval when they obstruct the way to heaven, for eternal life is worth every necessary effort and sacrifice.ST Sep 10, 1885 Healing the corruption brought into the world requires painful denial that goes beyond refusing pleasure to enduring pain, tearing away desire or separating from its object when it cannot otherwise be extinguished, as painful as piercing with a sword and dividing soul and spirit while God sits on the soul as a refiner's fire to burn up dross.RH Aug 7, 1855 Refusing to cut off a favorite sin means refusing Christ, who will not accept a person while cherished sins are concealed and retained, and wanting an easy, comfortable, safe and genteel ride to heaven is self trying to bargain with Christ, for unless greedy self is cast out Christ cannot flood the soul with peace and joy and power.RH Apr 24, 1866ST Nov 11, 1889RH Aug 7, 1855
Cutting off means complete separation and prompt, decisive, thorough resolve, to chop off at a single blow by watchfulness, prayer and well-doing and not saw off by degrees, vanquishing inward foes promptly and completely.RH Jun 6, 1871 It is like a surgeon amputating a diseased member to save the whole body from death and ruin, removing whatever peculiar sin ensnares a person and would work ruin in order to save them.RH Aug 29, 1871ST Jun 5, 1879 Soothing measures and delay will not free the enslaved appetite, as seen in the drunkard, but thorough resolve and struggle against sin are necessary for entering God's kingdom.RH Nov 27, 1860 What is precious or useful can still stand in the way of a higher life and must be surrendered when it does, giving up what is good for what is better and what is better for what is best, and doing many good works while knowingly indulging one sin does not preserve a person, for that sin can destroy the foundation of hope and reveal hypocrisy.RH Oct 8, 1872ST Jun 5, 1879 This inward victory prepares to stand firmly for truth and come off victorious when bitter outward persecution comes from wicked men and devils, while refusing the painful work means turning aside from the holy way to everlasting perdition.RH Jun 6, 1871RH Aug 7, 1855
Decisive Renunciation of Sin
Anything that causes stumbling, obstructs obedience, hinders religious life or puts eternal life at risk must be given up, however useful, precious or painful the loss may seem.STST Mar 13, 1907RH May 8, 1879RH May 17, 1864RH Sep 29, 1859 The right hand stands for things very dear in this world such as deft skill of the hand and loved pursuits like art and music even to the highest harmony, profitable employment pursued on sinful principles, a valued indulgence or attachment, self-reliance and self-righteousness, worldly associations and human approval.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Mar 13, 1907RH May 8, 1879 It is profitable and better to suffer loss in this life and enter God's kingdom without the cherished thing than to keep it and have the whole body cast into hell and be destroyed eternally.ST Sep 10, 1885STST Mar 13, 1907RH May 17, 1864RH Sep 29, 1859 The same rule reaches the church, which must separate from members whose worldly influence harms God's work and let even highest talent go rather than have the whole body destroyed, for the church can bear other burdens better than sin.STST Mar 13, 1907
Indulged lust, violence, evil passions and sinful appetites must be eradicated from the heart, because indulgence strengthens them to ruin and perdition.RH May 8, 1879 The commandments in their full reach include the heart, so hatred and lust are already sins under the law and not harmless desires that become sinful only when acted out, and the first inward motions of transgression must be watched with great fear, hated and resisted rather than merely avoided or neglected from day to day.ST Sep 27, 1883RH Dec 3, 1857ST May 11, 1915 Christian character must be shaped by God's Spirit, with faith purifying the soul from objectionable tendencies whether hereditary or cultivated.ST May 10, 1910 Holiness therefore calls for decisive rejection of sin rather than allowing it to corrupt the life.RH Nov 24, 1859
Renunciation must be immediate and absolute with no compromise, delay, soothing measures or dallying, covering every sinful desire, motive and purpose and even small bosom sins and seemingly harmless habits like frivolous joking and careless speech.RH Nov 27, 1860RH Feb 27, 1908RH Feb 17, 1859RH Nov 25, 1858RH Jul 3, 1860 One cherished sin knowingly kept can stop moral progress, weaken character, destroy hope and reveal hypocrisy, and outward respectability, religious duties and gifts cannot save one who secretly loves and practices iniquity.RH Feb 17, 1859RH Jun 3, 1858RH Nov 25, 1858 The cutting off pictures the painful sacrifice required to overcome every besetting sin, and victory over each sin is necessary to enter the kingdom.RH Nov 27, 1860RH Feb 27, 1908 Refusing to cut off a favorite transgression means refusing Christ, for he will not accept a person while cherished sins are concealed and retained.RH Apr 24, 1866 Entering life requires decided purpose and sober counting of the cost, complete ending of sinful practices rather than tolerating them, self-denial and effort, overcoming to the end, for it is better to lose what is precious than to perish forever in eternal destruction rather than eternal life.RH Nov 18, 1909RH Jun 3, 1858RH May 15, 1855
Costly self-sacrifice that gives up what is good for what is better and what is better for what is best shows appreciation for Christ's sacrifice, and complete sacrifice is accepted by God and devoted to His cause.RH Oct 8, 1872RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879 Inward foes such as evil traits of character and selfish propensities must be vanquished promptly and completely at a single blow, to chop off and not saw off by degrees through watchfulness, prayer and well-doing, and this inward victory prepares for standing stiffly for truth and coming off victorious when bitter outward persecution comes from wicked men and devils.RH Jun 6, 1871 The struggle is seen in the drunkard's enslaving appetite, which soothing measures and delay will not free and which must be met with thorough resolve, for the choice is between renouncing sin and losing the soul.RH Nov 27, 1860 So complete is habit's power to overwhelm the will that a confirmed drunkard said he could sever his hand but could not give up drink, showing that surrender even of something precious is preferable to being lost.ST
Hell After Resurrection
Hell is Gehenna, the Greek word rendered hell, meaning the Valley of Hinnom south of Jerusalem outside the city.RH Jan 17, 1856RH Mar 7, 1865ST May 12, 1881 That valley was once used for the worship of Moloch and afterward was polluted with filth and the carcasses of animals and the dead bodies of criminals, where constant fires were kept burning to consume them and avert pestilence and where worms fed.ST Dec 17, 1902ST Nov 16, 1876ST May 12, 1881 So made, Gehenna became a picture and type of utter destruction, and the reference to hell concerns that final place of punishment where sin and those identified with sin will be destroyed.ST Dec 17, 1902ST Nov 16, 1876 The Greek preposition eis in the casting into hell expresses motion into a place, for though used once and not compounded with the verb it can mean into, as when the body is cast into hell.ST May 17, 1883
Gehenna is the future place of punishment for the wicked that will exist after the judgment, not the grave, not Hades the place of the dead, and not a torment now in existence where the wicked go at death.RH Jan 17, 1856RH Jul 2, 1872RH May 23, 1865 It is a literal place of retributive fire in the most emphatic sense, where the final wrath upon the wicked is fulfilled as prophesied where their worm does not die and the fire is not quenched, identical with the everlasting fire prepared for the Devil and his angels.ST May 22, 1879RH Jun 12, 1860RH Jun 15, 1869 It is better to lose a bodily member than for the whole body to be cast there.ST May 22, 1879RH Jun 12, 1860 This punishment follows the resurrection, when the person again has a body, and warns of destruction involving the whole person rather than describing the soul's condition between death and resurrection.RH Jul 2, 1872RH May 23, 1865
The wicked are cast into Gehenna alive with soul and body together, not as mere dead corpses but as living beings with bodily members, and not as disembodied souls suffering between death and resurrection.ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 22, 1869 The picture of a person retaining bodily members when cast there, and the warning that the whole body should be cast there, proves that entrance into Gehenna follows resurrection from death and hades, since God is able to cast into Gehenna even after men have died once by raising them to life again.ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 22, 1869 The mention of the whole body being cast there supports that this punishment involves the person with bodily members after the resurrection, where the wicked are cast and destroyed.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Jul 2, 1872RH May 23, 1865
The language of losing a member and of the whole body being cast into hell is figurative for final punishment rather than a literal instruction to maim the body, and the threat of being cast into Gehenna, the Valley of Hinnom, is a figure for that final punishment.RH Oct 31, 1865RH Oct 31, 1865 The comparison teaches that language about punishment in the future state is figurative in this respect, and gives no reason to interpret body literally as prescribing mutilation.RH Oct 31, 1865RH Oct 31, 1865 Yet hell itself is not merely a figure but a real place of future punishment of the wicked, where the wicked will suffer final punishment in literal resurrected bodies with the body sharing in the punishment, while the right hand and right eye stand for earthly things as dear as a right eye or right hand that must be sacrificed in obeying God.ST May 12, 1881
The punishment in Gehenna is terrible suffering and anguish, not momentary and not only putting the wicked out of the way.RH Jun 22, 1869 The loss threatened is not merely loss of the kingdom of God but that loss joined with the fire of Gehenna, so that suffering even severe loss such as being drowned in the ocean is preferable to being cast into the fire of hell, and whatever peculiar or besetting sin would work ruin must be cut off to save the person as a surgeon amputates a diseased member to save the whole body from death.RH Aug 29, 1871RH Jun 22, 1869 Yet the verse teaches perishing, not endless misery or never-ending punishment: it is better for one member to perish than for the whole body to perish when cast into hell, and after the resurrection fire from God consumes the wicked, body and soul, until nothing remains to burn.RH Aug 29, 1871ST Nov 16, 1876ST Sep 30, 1930 What the worm does not devour is consumed by fire, so the warning that the whole body may be cast into Gehenna points to the final complete destruction of the wicked, and the wording is used to challenge the claim that matter cannot be subject to moral punishment.RH May 23, 1865ST Sep 30, 1930
Law Magnified to Heart
The verse belongs to the explanation of the sixth and seventh commandments in Matthew 5:27-32, where the principles are shown to extend farther than their bare wording and to be made all-important.RH Sep 14, 1869RH May 17, 1864RH May 17, 1864 It is part of the comment on the law of marriage, showing the full reach and spirit of the institution and of the commandment against adultery.RH Jul 26, 1870RH Jan 23, 1900 It stands in the same mountain teaching that deals with lust in the heart as adultery, with divorce, and with swearing oaths.RH May 17, 1864 In that setting it helps reveal further kinds of sin included under those commandments and guards the sacredness and purity of family life and the home against actions that break it apart.RH May 17, 1864RH May 17, 1864RH Jan 23, 1900
In Matthew 5:17-48 every act is brought under the strict test of the moral law, superficial interpretations are corrected, temporary civil concessions for hardness of heart are set aside, and what God meant from Adam is declared.ST Sep 27, 1883RH May 17, 1864RH Jan 5, 1911 Christ explains, lives, preaches, confirms, magnifies and honors the Father's law, speaking what the Father gave Him to teach.RH May 17, 1864ST Aug 31, 1915RH May 17, 1864 He does not abolish, enlarge, diminish, reverse, replace or revoke it with a new code, and His teaching that the moral law of the Ten Commandments covers everything pertaining to human life shows its full reach includes the heart.ST Sep 27, 1883RH May 17, 1864RH May 17, 1864ST Aug 31, 1915RH Jan 5, 1911
The law as a transcript of Jehovah's character reaches beyond outward acts to the heart, including motives, cherished thoughts, desires, passions, words and choices.RH May 17, 1864RH May 17, 1864RH Jul 11, 1865RH Feb 17, 1859ST Mar 11, 1889 Its commands against sin also forbid sinful thoughts, desires and movements of the heart, so that hatred and lust are already sins under the law and not harmless desires that become sinful only when acted out.ST Sep 27, 1883RH Jul 11, 1865ST Mar 11, 1889 Keeping the commandments is therefore spiritual and comprehensive, concerning love for God and others and not merely outward conduct.RH Feb 17, 1859ST Mar 11, 1889 Salvation requires genuine conversion and a cleansed heart with perfect obedience that human effort alone cannot meet, but which Christ through the Spirit enables in those who trust Him.ST Sep 27, 1883RH May 17, 1864RH May 17, 1864
The command to remove an offending member illustrates the seriousness of sin and the need to put it away rather than face final judgment, since sinful thoughts and desires also come under judgment. The law's penalties are no longer executed by human authorities but their execution is reserved for the day of judgment. Read together with the Ten Commandments in Exodus 20:1-17, this teaching acts as a detector of weak and worthless links in the chain of character habits, exposing every sin such as uncontrolled temper, cheating a neighbor, and intemperance in eating or drinking as a flaw.ST Oct 21, 1908 One unsound link will plunge into eternal ruin unless Christ exchanges the bad link for a good one.ST Oct 21, 1908
Church and Daily Applications
The teaching applies to the church as well as to the individual, for whatever causes stumbling or hinders God's work must be given up however useful or precious it seems, since it is better to suffer loss in this life than to be destroyed eternally.STST Mar 13, 1907 Members whose worldly influence harms God's work may need to be removed even when their abilities, counsel, giving, deft skill, or highest talent make them seem indispensable, and the church must let such talent go and separate such a person rather than have the whole body destroyed, without killing or harming the person.STST Mar 13, 1907 The church can bear other burdens better than sin, and losing limbs in this life does not mean imperfection in the next, for in God's kingdom there will be no imperfect people, no pain, no sickness, and no mutilated bodies.STST Mar 13, 1907 If only one part of a body were diseased it could be removed to preserve the rest, but a wholly diseased body cannot be saved by cutting off parts, as illustrated by Rome.ST Dec 15, 1881 The same rule applies to school discipline, where after private correction and further efforts with witnesses and the school fail, a pupil may be asked to leave so the harmony of the school is preserved, since it is better to remove one member than to let the whole body suffer.RH Oct 4, 1906
Right use of that severing hand protects the tempted, supports the weak, leads home the erring, and comforts the penitent.RH Sep 2, 1873 Even the right arm must be cut off and cast away when it offends by being raised only to smite, for it is profitable to remove church discipline entirely rather than keep a discipline that only punishes.RH Sep 2, 1873 Such misuse harms the whole body and should itself be removed rather than kept as mere punishment.RH Sep 2, 1873 Following Christ can require painful separation from former associations and worldly ties that stood between people and the truth, since clinging to them could keep them from preparing for the Lord's coming.RH Oct 17, 1907RH Feb 19, 1867 The offending hand or eye can represent a close family member such as a wife, son, or daughter, or near and dear friends, whose influence would lead a believer away from truth, and cutting off means firmly refusing to give up the truth even if that requires separation.RH Apr 16, 1867RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879
Yielding the truth risks perdition for the believer and may lead the family to perdition, while faithfulness may move family members to accept the truth and be saved, and the nearby teaching on divorce also presents a wife's serious offense as grounds for a husband to divorce her.RH Apr 16, 1867 Costly sacrifice for the truth, including renouncing near and dear friends, shows appreciation for Christ's sacrifice, and complete sacrifice is accepted by God and devoted to His cause.RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879 Anything cherished that leads to sin must be decisively renounced however valued it may be, whether worldly associates, self-righteousness, approval of people, cherished earthly possession, hope, joy, ambition, or relationship, and the hand so put away is not to be understood literally.ST Dec 7, 1882RH Oct 17, 1907 This can require a hard struggle, but grace and power can overcome even deeply rooted desires and habits, and it is better to enter life deprived of something precious than to keep it and be cast into hell whole.RH Feb 17, 1874ST Aug 14, 1879RH Oct 17, 1907
The image of cutting off the right hand is applied to abandoning tobacco and pipe-smoking, with a Christian to give it up rather than keep practicing what conflicts with his teaching so as to be a true light to others, and a needless appetite must be denied rather than excused, since failing to conquer it weakens moral strength and confidence before God.RH Mar 31, 1863RH Dec 13, 1853 It is better to give up even something as valuable as a hand than to use it to pass the wine cup in a way that brings ruin to another soul, for the hand that passes the cup should be severed rather than used to cause that harm.ST Mar 16, 1904 Progress in health reform, including giving up coffee and intemperate eating and drinking, may require painful sacrifice, yet must be accepted with determination to move forward.RH Apr 23, 1867 Frivolous joking and careless speech, though seemingly harmless, can endanger spiritual life and must be overcome, since salvation and heaven matter more than preserving anything that leads into sin.RH Jul 3, 1860 Giving up wrong conduct includes murmuring, complaining, and speaking of others' faults, for it is better to part with every sinful or unruly member than to keep it and be cast into hell.RH Sep 7, 1869
The same decisive removal covers signing a saloon license, prideful dress that encourages wrong conduct, billiards and theatergoing that harm the young, intellectual luxury that avoids serving others, and fashionable amusements chosen over God's joy.ST Mar 16, 1904RH Mar 31, 1863RH Apr 23, 1867RH Dec 13, 1853RH Jul 3, 1860 Anything keeping a person from wholehearted service to God must be surrendered however precious it is, with nothing held back from Christ in daily life, enduring to the end, in willingness expressed by action and readiness to join the redeemed on Mount Zion.RH Feb 17, 1859RH Aug 25, 1859 The affairs of life need not be abandoned when they can be subordinated to a higher purpose, but cherished human plans, purposes, hopes, earthly gain, ambitions, habits, and disagreeable traits must be given up when they obstruct faithful service and oppose God's purposes.ST Jun 22, 1882RH Nov 7, 1854 No power or capacity is to be reserved for a forbidden use, whether hand for covetous wealth, foot for worldliness, or eye for forbidden things, but sin is to be given to Jesus for righteousness so that Christ's purity shines.RH Feb 17, 1859RH Apr 27, 1905
Those who proclaim the third angel's message must not let fear of people prevent defending right principles and essential truths of the gospel, while still showing heaven's love, and the straight testimony that exposes faults is to be accepted rather than resisted.RH Apr 27, 1905 An idol, whatever attachment would destroy the highest eternal interest, must be abandoned even when doing so feels as painful as losing a bodily member, since it is better to sacrifice what causes offense than to face hell.RH Nov 7, 1854 God as Physician may deal severely by taking away friends, hopes, earthly gain, and all stays and supports of life as a cleansing scourge and chastening to heal the dying soul.RH May 6, 1862 The flesh is weak and the heart shrinks and trembles at the stroke and may moan and pray for the cup to be removed, yet all is to be yielded up without murmuring against His ways, trusting sustaining grace to do the work, adding Thy will be done and resting calm, knowing that if God is friend all things work for good and His goodness shall be seen in the end, for with His favor loss is gain and without His favor all is lost.RH May 6, 1862 The loss of a hand figures removing whatever leads into sin, since it is better to give up one thing than to lose the whole person in hell, a comfort also spoken at a funeral.RH Nov 23, 1911
Knowingly clinging to even one sin or refusing to abandon a harmful pleasure blocks real prayer and spiritual power, because losing one part is better than bringing the whole person to destruction.RH Dec 26, 1912 Even a right hand, a right eye, or life itself cannot excuse neglect of what God requires, for no earthly consideration may take precedence over duty to Christ.RH Feb 23, 1864
Sources