AdventAI

Psalms 78:20

Behold, he smote the rock, that the waters gushed out, and the streams overflowed; can he give bread also? can he provide flesh for his people?

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version, King James Version, Webster Bible

    Behold, he smote the rock, that the waters gushed out, and the streams overflowed; can he give bread also? can he provide flesh for his people?

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    Behold, he smote the rock, that the waters gushed out,
    And the streams overflowed;
    Can he give bread also?
    Can he provide flesh for his people?

  • Revised Version

    Behold, he smote the rock, that waters gushed out, and streams overflowed; can he give bread also? will he provide flesh for his people?

  • American Standard Version

    Behold, he smote the rock, so that waters gushed out,
    And streams overflowed;
    Can he give bread also?
    Will he provide flesh for his people?

  • Young's Literal Translation

    Lo, He hath smitten a rock, And waters flow, yea, streams overflow. 'Also — bread [is] He able to give? Doth He prepare flesh for His people?'

  • Darby Translation

    Behold, he smote the rock, and waters gushed out, and streams overflowed; is he able to give bread also, or provide flesh for his people?

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    Lo! he hath smitten a rock, And waters, have gushed out, Yea, torrents, have rushed along,—Food also, can he give? Or provide flesh for his people?

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    When He struck the rock, water gushed out
    and torrents raged.
    But can He also give bread
    or supply His people with meat?”

  • World English Bible

    Behold, he struck the rock, so that waters gushed out,
    and streams overflowed.
    Can he give bread also?
    Will he provide meat for his people?”

  • Bible in Basic English

    See, the rock was cut open by his power, so that the water came rushing out, and overflowing streams; is he able to give us bread? is he able to get meat for his people?

  • Geneva Bible

    Behold, he smote the rocke, that the water gushed out, and the streames ouerflowed: can hee giue bread also? or prepare flesh for his people?

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Because he struck the rock, and the waters gushed out, and the streams overflowed. Can he also give bread, or provide a table for his people?

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

15 sources

After God struck the rock so that water gushed out and streams overflowed, the people asked whether He could also furnish a table in the wilderness and give bread and meat to sustain them.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7
Their question was distrust and unbelief in the heart, tempting God and speaking against Him despite the evidence already given, in rebellion against the light, covenant and salvation they had received.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7
Their murmuring did not spring from real hunger but from lust learned in Egypt, where they had lived largely on flesh food, showing dissatisfaction with the simple, wholesome food provided and disregard for wise restraint of appetite.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7ST Sep 29, 1881
God withheld flesh because He knew it was not man's natural food but would bring disease and shorten life, for He was leading them into the wilderness to train them in right habits that they might be a pure, holy and healthy people, yet their self-indulgence brought physical and mental decline and their distrust kindled His anger in judgment.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7ST Sep 29, 1881
Even so, God did set a table and sustain His people in the wilderness, showing His power to supply is not limited to water, so those who have Christ abiding within and fully receive heavenly truth will advance in the divine life and will not complain and forget God when trials come.6T 178.1–28MR 361.1–362.2Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5ST Nov 11, 188913MR 98.3

Wilderness Unbelief and Rebellion

Psalm 78 recounts how richly God blessed Israel and how poorly, unfaithfully and ungratefully the people returned His benefits.CT 457.2Ms 96, 1899, par. 21–2213MR 265.2 It is a song for the wilderness journey, to be kept in time as the people marched, and attentive reading of it brings correction and instruction, calling hearers to turn from reliance on lawyers and come into harmony.Ms 190, 1901, par. 7–8 After He struck the rock so that waters gushed out and streams overflowed in abundance, Israel asked whether He could also give bread and provide flesh and furnish a table in the wilderness.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7Ms 96, 1899, par. 21–2213MR 265.2 Even after seeing that blessing they treated past provision as no assurance of further supply, exposing unbelief that looks at poor, unpromising conditions and doubts His power to provide.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.18MR 361.1–362.2

Their question showed distrust, discontent and unbelief despite the evidence already received.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 It was tempting God in the heart by asking meat for lust, and speaking against God.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 It was rebellion against the light and covenant and salvation received, and constantly working against a good God.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7Ms 38, 1898, par. 22 Their murmuring did not come from hunger but from lust formed in Egypt, where they had become accustomed to flesh food and had subsisted largely upon it.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 Dissatisfied with the simple, wholesome food supplied, they disregarded His provisions and wise limits on appetite, with weeping and murmuring and complaining that He had brought them out to pine away and die in the wilderness.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7ST Sep 29, 1881

God withheld flesh meat because He knew it is not man's natural food but would produce disease and shorten life.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 In leading them into the wilderness He purposed to educate them in correct habits that they might be a pure, holy, healthy people.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 He provided the very best food that would have preserved them in health and lengthened their lives.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 Yielding to self-indulgence and self-gratification instead brought physical and mental decline.Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7Ms 38, 1898, par. 22ST Sep 29, 1881 Their unbelief and distrust of His salvation kindled His anger and brought judgment against them.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39PP 378.4–379.1Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 Through disobedience they brought themselves into the state that was the sure result of their own course of action.Ms 38, 1898, par. 22 Under rebuke and chastisement they repented, but afterward they fell again under temptation.Ms 38, 1898, par. 22

Divine Provision and Trust

The questioning came after the rock had been struck and water had gushed out in overflowing streams, yet the people still asked whether bread could be given and meat provided for them in the wilderness.8MR 361.1–362.2Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1], par. 26–27 The answer is that a table was indeed set in the wilderness and the people were sustained there, proving that the power that brought water from the rock was not limited to water alone.8MR 361.1–362.2Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1], par. 26–27 The same care extends to food and to what the earth yields for diligent workers, showing that the ability to supply is not confined to one kind of gift.13MR 98.3Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1], par. 26–27 That blessing and provision do not cease even as the earth grows old and changes.13MR 98.3

The flowing water from the rock stands as assurance that a table can be spread for God's people even in barren places.6T 178.1–2 With divine blessing joined to proper cultivation, the earth will supply what faithful, diligent workers need.6T 178.1–2Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1], par. 26–27 Where He directs His people, His blessing will rest on the place and make the land produce good crops and make a home in the wilderness.8MR 361.1–362.2Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5 This holds despite poor, unpromising conditions and doubts about fertility, as seen in the application to the school land, which could be made productive under God's blessing though its fertility was questioned.8MR 361.1–362.2Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5

In contrast stands the example of complaining when trials came and forgetting the source of strength.ST Nov 11, 1889 Those who have Bible religion, with Christ abiding in them and they in Him, will continually advance in the divine life.ST Nov 11, 1889 Those who fully receive truth of heavenly origin will become sanctified through it, so that when trials come they will not complain and forget God as Israel did.ST Nov 11, 1889

Sources

  1. Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Lt 103, 1896 Ellen G. White, written July 17, 1896
  2. PP 378.4–379.1 Patriarchs and Prophets — FROM SINAI TO KADESH—33 Ellen G. White, 1890
  3. Ms 155, 1899, par. 1–7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 155, 1899 Ellen G. White, written November 17, 1899
  4. ST Sep 29, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 37 — General Articles Ellen G. White, September 29, 1881
  5. 6T 178.1–2 Testimonies for the Church Volume Six — INDUSTRIAL REFORM. Ellen G. White, 1901
  6. 8MR 361.1–362.2 Manuscript Releases, vol. 8 [Nos. 526-663] — MR No. 630—Ellen White and Avondale College Ellen G. White, written August 31 – November 5, 1894; published 1990
  7. Ms 77, 1894, par. 1–5 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 77, 1894 Ellen G. White Estate, Ellen G. White, written August 30–31, 1894
  8. ST Nov 11, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 43 — HAVE LIGHT IN YOURSELVES.[^1] Ellen G. White, November 11, 1889
  9. 13MR 98.3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 13 [Nos. 1000-1080] — MR No. 1012—Qualifications of Parents and Teachers; a Call to Leave Battle Creek Ellen G. White, written September 24, 1898; published 1990
  10. CT 457.2 Counsels to Teachers Parents and Students — THE WORD AND WORKS OF GOD Ellen G. White, 1913
  11. Ms 96, 1899, par. 21–22 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 96, 1899 Ellen G. White, written July 20, 1899
  12. 13MR 265.2 Manuscript Releases, vol. 13 [Nos. 1000-1080] — MR No. 1043—The Bible as Our Study Book Ellen G. White, written July 20, 1899; published 1990
  13. Ms 190, 1901, par. 7–8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 190, 1901 Ellen G. White, Ellen G. White Estate, written August 16, 1901
  14. Ms 38, 1898, par. 22 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 38, 1898 Ellen G. White, written March 11, 1898
  15. Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1], par. 26–27 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 8, 1894 [Copy 1] Ellen G. White, written February 1894

Pioneers and periodicals

20 sources

God had smitten the rock so that waters gushed out and streams overflowed, yet the people still asked whether he could give bread also and provide flesh for his people.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jun 1, 1916 Their question was unbelief, distrust and ingratitude toward his goodness and power to save, driven by lust and dissatisfaction that despised the food from heaven though he had supplied water and manna.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907ST Oct 11, 1899ST Apr 22, 1889 That failure to trust him kindled his anger so that fire burned among them.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907ST Apr 22, 1889 The history stands as an example and warning for those living in the last days not to forget past help and murmur at each new need, but to remember his faithfulness and trust his promises.ST Nov 11, 1889RH Apr 20, 1869RH Jan 21, 1858RH Dec 8, 1910RH Jul 2, 1857 He who set a table in the wilderness has full power and ownership to provide for his people and his work, yet yielding to appetite for flesh instead of his simple wholesome provision brought disease and leanness of soul.ST Sep 29, 1881RH Jan 21, 1858RH Dec 8, 1910ST Nov 29, 1883RH Jul 14, 1874

Israel's Doubt in Wilderness

He had smitten the rock so that waters gushed out and streams overflowed, yet they asked if he could give bread also and provide flesh for his people.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 3, 1903ST Oct 11, 1899 The miracle of abundant water had been witnessed, and still they questioned his power to supply food.RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jun 1, 1916RH Sep 3, 1903ST Oct 11, 1899 Their question showed how quickly a new want can make the heart distrust his ability despite experienced provision.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Oct 11, 1899

Their asking was unbelief, distrust and ingratitude.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907ST Oct 11, 1899RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856 Though they had seen his wonders and provision, they doubted his goodness and his power and ability to save.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856 They did not trust God or his power to save.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856

Their demand for bread and especially for flesh was driven by lust and dissatisfaction.RH Feb 28, 1907ST Oct 11, 1899ST Nov 29, 1883RH Dec 21, 1905 Though he had supplied water and commanded the clouds and given manna from heaven, they lusted for other food and despised the food from heaven.ST Oct 11, 1899ST Apr 22, 1889RH Dec 21, 1905 He had given a simple diet suited to a demanding journey requiring endurance and faith, but their craving led him to grant flesh, which they would have been better without, and the granted desire brought disease and leanness of soul.RH Feb 28, 1907ST Nov 29, 1883RH Dec 21, 1905 This unbelief and failure to trust God and his salvation kindled the Lord's anger so that fire burned among them.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Feb 28, 1907ST Apr 22, 1889

The setting is the journey after leaving Sinai, leading into sad and dreary wandering for forty years in the great and terrible wilderness.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Sep 14, 1916 An unceasing train of funerals passed out of the camp until all the generation of the men of war from twenty years old and upward was wasted out and consumed.RH Sep 14, 1916 Not one unbeliever was left except Caleb and Joshua, who saw them all die.RH Sep 14, 1916 Those desert sands were a training ground to humble and prove what was in their hearts, and to Caleb and Joshua and the younger generation a school for higher service.RH Sep 14, 1916

The verse belongs to a historical psalm that presents human unfaithfulness alongside God's faithfulness.ST Mar 11, 1908ST Dec 5, 1911 It recounts God's wonderful deliverances and providence in leading, protecting, redeeming and restoring his people from Jacob's return from Padan-aram to the Exodus, showing the making of a nation.ST Mar 11, 1908ST Jun 11, 1894ST Dec 5, 1911 It recounts Israel's wilderness history as an example for later generations, showing unbelief at the root of their provocations when discouraged they spoke against God and his chosen leaders.RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856 Those deliverances for his people were wrought through Jesus Christ, the Angel of God's presence, who was with Israel.ST Dec 5, 1911

Warning and Trust Today

The wilderness record was written as an example for later generations living in the last days, because unbelief lay at the root of Israel's provocations when, though they had seen God's wonders, they doubted His goodness and power to save and spoke against Him and His chosen leaders.RH Dec 8, 1910RH Jul 2, 1857RH Feb 28, 1856 That same likeness of doubting after the rock was smitten and water given is fulfilled in these days, enough to make one weep, yet God's bearing with it shows He is truly of long compassion.RH Jan 21, 1858

The verse warns against forgetting past help and murmuring when a new need or trial comes, for it shows how quickly people distrust God's ability to meet a new need despite experienced provision.RH Apr 20, 1869 Under want the heart should remember past faithfulness and trust His promises rather than murmur, and remembering His former care strengthens confidence in Him and in His power to save.RH Apr 20, 1869 Those who have Bible religion, with Christ abiding in them and they in Him, will continually advance in the divine life and become sanctified through truth of heavenly origin, so that when trials come they will not complain and forget the source of their strength as Israel did.ST Nov 11, 1889

Complaining by God's people now is no less inexcusable than Israel's murmuring after Sinai, when unbelief and failure to trust God and His salvation kindled the Lord's anger so that fire burned among them even though He had commanded the clouds and given manna from heaven.ST Apr 22, 1889 It is only the Lord's mercies and unfailing compassions, new every morning, that keep them from being consumed.ST Apr 22, 1889

The episode was recorded as a warning against wrong habits of eating and drinking that contribute to disease.RH Dec 8, 1910 God had given a simple, wholesome diet suited to a demanding journey requiring endurance and faith, but dissatisfaction with it showed disregard for His provisions and wise limits on appetite.ST Sep 29, 1881ST Nov 29, 1883 Yielding to self-indulgence and lust for flesh brought physical and mental decline, disease and leanness of soul, though the desire was granted, and they would have been better off without it.ST Sep 29, 1881ST Nov 29, 1883RH Dec 21, 1905

God set a table in the wilderness for the vast camp of Israel, which means He has full power and ownership to provide for His people and His work, with the cattle on a thousand hills always His.RH Jul 14, 1874 Raining gold and silver from heaven for publishing and traveling would have been as easy as feeding Israel.RH Jul 14, 1874 Yet He may withhold that easy miraculous supply and leave His workers in poverty in order to set an example of faith, humility, perseverance, sacrifice and endurance for those who enter the work afterward.RH Jul 14, 1874

Sources

  1. RH Apr 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 17 — CONFIDENCE IN GOD H. C. Miller, Third-day, April 20, 1869
  2. RH Feb 28, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 9 — E. F. COLLIER E. F. Collier, February 28, 1907
  3. RH Jun 1, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 27 — The Bible Year R. G. Seymour, June 1, 1916
  4. ST Oct 11, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 41 — MAN'S PRIMITIVE AND BEST DIET OCTOBER 11, 1899
  5. ST Apr 22, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 16 — UNBELIEF AND ITS PUNISHMENT April 22, 1889
  6. RH Jan 21, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 11 — A Testimony of Faith P. D. Lawrence, January 21, 1858
  7. RH Dec 8, 1910 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 87, No. 49 — The Open Bible in Every Home George B. Starr, December 8, 1910
  8. RH Jul 2, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 9 — OUR EXAMPLES July 2, 1857
  9. ST Nov 11, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 43 — HAVE LIGHT IN YOURSELVES.[^1] Ellen G. White, November 11, 1889
  10. ST Nov 29, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 45 — Temperance W. N. Glenn, November 29, 1883
  11. ST Sep 29, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 37 — General Articles Ellen G. White, September 29, 1881
  12. RH Jul 14, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 5 — The Spirit of Sacrifice James White, July 14, 1874.
  13. RH Sep 3, 1903 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 80, No. 35 — Dedication of the New Headquarters in Washington A. G. Daniells, Thursday, September 3, 1903
  14. ST Oct 11, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 41 — MAN'S PRIMITIVE AND BEST DIET OCTOBER 11, 1899
  15. RH Feb 28, 1856 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 22 — OUR EXAMPLES R. F. C., February 28, 1856
  16. RH Dec 21, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 51 — A Fleshless Diet From a Biblical and Christian Standpoint D. H. KRESS, M. D., December 21, 1905
  17. RH Sep 14, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 46 — Caleb and Joshua R. D. Quinn, September 14, 1916
  18. ST Mar 11, 1908 Signs of the Times, Vol. 34, No. 11 — Lessons from Deuteronomy Editor, March 11, 1908
  19. ST Dec 5, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 48 — 3611 — The Psalms and Our Lord M. L. M., December 5, 1911
  20. ST Jun 11, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 31 — International S. S. Lessons Monday, June 11, 1894

Cross-references

  1. Numbers 11:4-6

    And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?

    Israel craves meat and rejects God’s wilderness provision.

  2. Exodus 17:6

    Behold, I will stand before thee there upon the rock in Horeb; and thou shalt smite the rock, and there shall come water out of it, that the people may drink. And Moses did so in the sight of the elders of Israel.

    God brought water from the rock for Israel in the wilderness.

  3. 1 Corinthians 10:11

    Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.

    Israel’s wilderness experiences were recorded as examples and warnings for later generations.

  4. Psalms 106:14-15

    But lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert.

    Israel craves flesh in the wilderness, and God grants their request with harmful results.

  5. 1 Corinthians 10:4

    And did all drink the same spiritual drink: for they drank of that spiritual Rock that followed them: and that Rock was Christ.

    Israel drank from the spiritual Rock, identified as Christ.

  6. Numbers 11:31-33

    And there went forth a wind from the LORD, and brought quails from the sea, and let them fall by the camp, as it were a day’s journey on this side, and as it were a day’s journey on the other side, round about the camp, and as it were two cubits high upon the face of the earth.

    God provides quail in response to Israel’s craving, then strikes the people with a plague.

  7. Psalms 105:40

    The people asked, and he brought quails, and satisfied them with the bread of heaven.

    Both describe God providing food for Israel in the wilderness.

  8. Exodus 16:4-15

    Then said the LORD unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.

    God provides bread and flesh for Israel in the wilderness.

  9. Numbers 11:18-23

    And say thou unto the people, Sanctify yourselves against to morrow, and ye shall eat flesh: for ye have wept in the ears of the LORD, saying, Who shall give us flesh to eat? for it was well with us in Egypt: therefore the LORD will give you flesh, and ye shall eat.

    God promises meat for the people despite Moses’ doubt about providing enough.

  10. Exodus 16:2-3

    And the whole congregation of the children of Israel murmured against Moses and Aaron in the wilderness:

    Israel complained about the food provided in the wilderness.

  11. Psalms 78:26-31

    He caused an east wind to blow in the heaven: and by his power he brought in the south wind.

    God gives them the flesh they demanded, then answers their lust with wrath.

  12. Psalms 78:24

    And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.

    God gave manna from heaven as food for his people.

  13. Psalms 78:25

    Man did eat angels’ food: he sent them meat to the full.

    Describes the heaven-sent food they rejected.

  14. John 6:31-32

    Our fathers did eat manna in the desert; as it is written, He gave them bread from heaven to eat.

    Jesus contrasts wilderness manna with the true bread from heaven.

  15. 1 Corinthians 10:5

    But with many of them God was not well pleased: for they were overthrown in the wilderness.

    gives Paul's verdict on their unbelief

  16. Psalms 114:8

    Which turned the rock into a standing water, the flint into a fountain of waters.

    Both describe God bringing water from the rock during Israel’s wilderness journey.

  17. Acts 7:36

    He brought them out, after that he had shewed wonders and signs in the land of Egypt, and in the Red sea, and in the wilderness forty years.

    Both recount God’s signs and provision for Israel in the wilderness.

  18. 1 Corinthians 10:6

    Now these things were our examples, to the intent we should not lust after evil things, as they also lusted.

    Israel’s craving serves as a warning against evil desire.