AdventAI

Psalms 88:12

Shall thy wonders be known in the dark? and thy righteousness in the land of forgetfulness?

King James Version

Translations

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Pioneers and periodicals

45 sources

The dark and the land of forgetfulness are death and the grave, called Sheol in Hebrew and Hades in Greek, where all the dead go to a place without order where light is as darkness.ST Feb 6, 1907ST Oct 15, 1912ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1865ST Aug 18, 1881 The questions expect no for an answer, for God's wonders and righteousness are not known or declared there.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Aug 4, 1909 The dead are unconscious and know nothing, with no remembrance, thought, feeling, work, device, knowledge, or wisdom.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Feb 6, 1907ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1865ST Dec 4, 1884 They do not praise, remember, thank, or hope in God, and do not at death ascend to heaven in praise or descend to hell fire, but remain silent until the resurrection.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1854RH Sep 26, 1865RH Aug 5, 1862 Man is therefore mortal and not possessed of an immortal soul, immortality being found only in the gospel of Christ to be put on at the resurrection, so there is no probation after death and no conscious spirits returning to communicate with the living.RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jan 8, 1857ST Aug 18, 1881RH Jul 10, 1860ST Oct 9, 1879

Language and Setting

The dark named in the verse is death and the grave, a land of darkness and forgetfulness where wonders, lovingkindness, faithfulness and righteousness are not known or declared.ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1865ST Dec 4, 1884ST Aug 28, 1884 It is the land of darkness and the shadow of death without order where the light is as darkness, where those long dead dwell.ST Nov 25, 1886 It is the dust where good and bad alike go at death, where all the dead go and where there is no work, knowledge, or wisdom and the dead are unaware.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Mar 30, 1882 The land of forgetfulness is that same grave, called Sheol in Hebrew and Hades in Greek, the place of the dead.ST Feb 6, 1907ST Aug 18, 1881RH Aug 27, 1872RH Feb 16, 1864RH Oct 31, 1865 In that Sheol, the dark land of forgetfulness, wonders are not known and righteousness is not remembered, and that which can praise and remember and know goes at death into silence.ST Oct 15, 1912RH Dec 23, 1862RH Aug 27, 1872

The questions ask for no for an answer: wonders are not known in the dark and righteousness is not known in the land of forgetfulness, and the dead do not arise and praise.ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1865ST Aug 4, 1909ST Sep 28, 1904 For this reason the verse is a plea against the approach of death, since praise and remembrance belong to the living and death stops praise, thanksgiving, and declaration.RH Aug 5, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858ST Sep 28, 1904 Its picture of being buried before having time to act or even think shows the sudden helplessness of death.RH Feb 18, 1909

The primary and scriptural meaning of Sheol is a land of darkness as darkness itself and the land of forgetfulness, with no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, so the dead there are unconscious and know nothing.RH Feb 16, 1864RH Oct 31, 1865 When Hades was chosen as the Greek word to represent Sheol its inspired meaning is the same, so there is no knowledge in Hades.RH Oct 31, 1865 The idea of conscious activity with rewards and punishments was later mingled in from heathen mythology, but the inspired meaning still stands, and there is no Gehenna or hell-fire there.RH Oct 31, 1865 This description rules out Hades as a place where living beings enjoy Paradise, since death is the gate to Hades, where the dead have no knowledge, wisdom, work, or plans.RH Apr 20, 1869

Unconscious Sleep in Death

The dark is the grave where nothing of God is known or declared, and entering it leaves a person knowing less than before, for if some things are forgotten there all things may be.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Feb 6, 1907RH Sep 26, 1865ST Dec 19, 1900ST Aug 18, 1881 There thought and action are suspended, with no remembrance, thought, mental awareness, feeling, or emotion.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Dec 19, 1900RH Apr 18, 1871 The dead are therefore unconscious and do not remember or know what they once knew.ST Feb 6, 1907RH Sep 26, 1865ST Aug 18, 1881

The forgetfulness does not belong to the body alone, for the body separated from what thinks has no knowledge to forget and cannot remember or think or exercise any mental power.RH Feb 2, 1864 It belongs to the thinking, remembering part itself, which goes into the land of forgetfulness and forgets its knowledge at death.RH Feb 2, 1864 That which can praise God and remember and know goes at death into silence and ceases to praise.RH Dec 23, 1862ST Dec 19, 1900 What is spoken of is the whole person, whose thinking and other personal faculties cease, so speech and action attributed to the dead are personification and not proof of conscious converse after death.ST Dec 19, 1900ST Mar 27, 1879

In that state the memory of the dead is forgotten, their love and hatred and envy have perished, and their thoughts perish.ST Nov 25, 1886 There is no work, device, knowledge, or wisdom in the grave, where all the dead go.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Dec 4, 1884RH Feb 16, 1864 The dead lie unaware in the dust, without knowledge, thought, interest in the living, or activity, whether righteous or wicked.ST Dec 4, 1884ST Dec 4, 1884ST Mar 11, 1886 Judgment, reward, and punishment therefore remain future.ST Mar 11, 1886

The dead do not know or respond to what takes place in the world and have no awareness of what happens on earth.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Sep 18, 1901ST Apr 16, 1912 They do not remember the events of their lives and cannot see or converse with one another.ST Jun 23, 1881 They do not return to reveal the secrets of that realm nor come back as conscious spirits to communicate with the living.ST Apr 16, 1912ST Sep 18, 1901 They remain there until they return.ST Apr 11, 1900

Death is a sleep of forgetfulness, like a sleeping man who knows nothing of what goes on around him, incapable of feeling or emotion.ST Mar 30, 1882ST Nov 1, 1883 Good and bad alike go at death to that dust, that dark grave.ST Mar 30, 1882ST Dec 4, 1884 There they remain unaware and inactive, without knowledge or praise, rather than in heaven.ST Oct 2, 1884ST Oct 2, 1884 They sleep thus until the Lord brings them back at the resurrection at Christ's coming.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Oct 2, 1884ST Oct 2, 1884

Silence Toward God

In the dark of the grave, the land of forgetfulness, God's wonders are not known and His righteousness is not known, nor are His lovingkindness and faithfulness remembered, declared or proclaimed by the dead.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1854RH Sep 26, 1865ST Dec 19, 1900 The questions expect no for an answer, for the dead do not arise and praise God, and thought and action are suspended in that dark, forgetful silence.ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1854ST Dec 19, 1900 The forgetfulness belongs not to the body alone, which separated from the thinking part has no knowledge to forget and cannot remember or think or exercise any mental power, but to the soul itself, the part that thinks and remembers, which goes into that land and forgets its knowledge, knowing less on entering that state than before.RH Feb 2, 1864 If some things are forgotten there, all things may be, for the memory of the dead is forgotten, their love and hatred and envy have perished, their thoughts perish, and there is no work, device, knowledge or wisdom in the grave.RH Feb 2, 1864ST Nov 25, 1886 Sheol is thus a place of darkness and forgetfulness where the dead do not rise to praise God or proclaim His lovingkindness and faithfulness, and where they cannot receive preaching.RH Sep 26, 1854ST Aug 18, 1881

Death ends remembrance of God, praise, thanksgiving, declaration of His lovingkindness and faithfulness, and hope in His truth.ST Nov 25, 1886RH Sep 26, 1865 That which can praise God and remember and know goes at death into the land of forgetfulness, so that man as a conscious being goes into silence and ceases to praise Him.RH Nov 18, 1858RH Dec 23, 1862 The grave is darkness and forgetting where the dead cannot know God's wonders and righteousness, declare His lovingkindness and faithfulness, arise and praise Him, or remember and thank Him.RH Aug 5, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858 For this reason the approach of death is pleaded against, because praise and remembrance belong to the living and death stops praise to God.RH Aug 5, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858 If the soul survived death and went at once to heaven to praise God unceasingly, such pleading would have no place, for the expectation is to die entirely and remain dead and buried without ascending to heaven.RH Aug 5, 1862

The dead therefore do not at death enter into God's presence, ascend to heaven to join in unceasing praise, go to be with Christ, or go into hell fire, but remain silent and unable to praise until the resurrection.RH Sep 26, 1865RH Aug 5, 1862RH Jun 12, 1860 They do not know more than the living, they exercise no power of mind, with no remembrance of God and no thanksgiving to Him.RH Sep 26, 1865RH Jun 12, 1860 The place of the dead is the grave, a place of darkness and unconsciousness rather than heaven, where the dead remain unaware until the Lord brings them back at the resurrection.RH Jun 12, 1860ST Oct 2, 1884 The dead do not consciously praise God before they arise in the resurrection.RH Sep 26, 1854

Those whose trust is in God will pass through this valley of the shadow of death comforted by His rod and staff and will come again from it.ST Nov 25, 1886 The dead remain there until they return, and they will live by Him who died and lives again.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Apr 11, 1900 The dead do not know or respond to what takes place in the world, yet this supports the hope of their later return.ST Apr 11, 1900

Doctrine and False Teachings

The verse denies the immortality of the soul and shows man to be mortal.RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jan 8, 1857 Death is a state of utter unconsciousness for the thinking being and of decay and ruin for the body.RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jul 10, 1860 The forgetfulness does not belong to the body alone, for the body separated from the soul has no knowledge to forget and cannot remember or think or exercise any mental power, but belongs to the soul itself, the part that thinks and remembers, which goes into the land of forgetfulness and forgets its knowledge.RH Feb 2, 1864 A man knows less when he enters that state than he did before, and if some things are forgotten there all things may be, while God's wonders, lovingkindness, faithfulness and righteousness are not known or declared in that dark land.RH Feb 2, 1864 This proves the dead are unconscious, for immortality is subject to neither death nor decay, but is to be sought by patient continuance in well doing and is found only in the gospel of Christ to be put on at the resurrection.RH Feb 2, 1864RH Oct 20, 1874

There is no probation after death.ST Aug 18, 1881 The grave is a land of darkness and forgetfulness where God's wonders and righteousness are not known or declared, and the dead do not rise to praise God or proclaim His loving-kindness and faithfulness.ST Aug 18, 1881 The dead cannot hear a message, repent, or act, so preaching to them in Sheol in the grave would be futile.ST Aug 18, 1881 For the same reason the dead do not possess greater knowledge of truth than the living and are not conscious spirits returning to communicate, for they know nothing, do not know what happens on earth, do not praise the Lord or hope in His truth.ST Oct 9, 1879ST Sep 18, 1901

The conscious meeting and talking pictured in the rich man and Lazarus cannot take place immediately after death.ST Mar 30, 1882ST Jun 23, 1881ST Mar 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877 Death is a land of darkness, the dust, the grave, where good and bad alike go and where the dead are unconscious and incapable of feeling or emotion.ST Mar 30, 1882 In hades the dead have no knowledge or wisdom, cannot remember the events of their lives, cannot see or converse with one another, their thoughts perish, they do not praise the Lord, and their condition is sleep, not conscious life.ST Jun 23, 1881ST Mar 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877 Seeing Abraham and fixed rewards and punishments belong instead to the resurrection and final judgment at Christ's coming, when the cases of the righteous and wicked are fixed forever and reward and punishment remain future.ST Mar 30, 1882ST Mar 11, 1886

The description rules out Hades as a place where living beings enjoy Paradise and rules out conscious rewards and punishments there.ST Mar 30, 1882ST Jun 23, 1881RH Mar 28, 1865RH Jun 12, 1860RH May 5, 1874 Sheol is a place of silence, secrecy, sleep, rest, darkness, corruption, worms and dust, where God's wonders are not known and His righteousness is not made known or proclaimed.ST Jun 23, 1881RH Mar 28, 1865RH May 5, 1874 The dead are in the grave, in the dark and in the land of forgetfulness, not with Christ in heaven nor in hell fire, for they praise not the Lord and exercise no power of mind, with no remembrance of God and no thanksgiving to Him.RH Jun 12, 1860 That is the primary and scriptural meaning of Sheol, a land of darkness as darkness itself and of forgetfulness with no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, carried over when Hades was chosen as its Greek equivalent, so there is no knowledge in Hades and no Gehenna or hell-fire there, while the idea of conscious activity with rewards and punishments was later mingled in from heathen mythology.RH Oct 31, 1865 Death is therefore an enemy's land rather than birth into a higher life or a gate to endless joy, and the dead do not arise and praise God while in the grave.ST Aug 28, 1884ST May 15, 1884RH Oct 20, 1874 Unless there is a resurrection it is eternal destruction with nothing remaining except the particles of which the person was composed, so life after death depends on resurrection.RH Jul 10, 1860ST May 15, 1884

Sources

  1. ST Feb 6, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 6 — WORK FOR THE DEAD Charles Nelson, February 6, 1907
  2. ST Oct 15, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 40 — Departing and Being with Christ W. H. Littlejohn, October 15, 1912
  3. ST Nov 25, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 45 J., November 25, 1886
  4. RH Sep 26, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 26, No. 17 — Unconsciousness in Death September 26, 1865
  5. ST Aug 18, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 31 — IS SIN ETERNAL?—NO. 13. BY ELD. J. N. LOUGHBOROUGH, OF SOUTHAMPTON, ENGLAND. John Norton Loughborough, August 18, 1881
  6. ST Aug 4, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 30 — OUR BIBLE BAND August 4, 1909
  7. RH Feb 2, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 10 — Are the Dead Conscious? No. 5. R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, February 2, 1864
  8. ST Dec 4, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 46 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, December 4, 1884
  9. RH Sep 26, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 7 — THE ATONEMENT J. M. Stephenson, September 26, 1854
  10. RH Aug 5, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 20, No. 10 — The State of the Dead John Milton, August 5, 1862
  11. RH Jan 8, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 10 — The Immortality of the Soul January 8, 1857
  12. RH Jul 10, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 8 — THE DESTINY OF THE UNGODLY G. P. Wilson, July 10, 1860
  13. ST Oct 9, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 38 — Modern Spiritualism Editor, October 9, 1879
  14. ST Aug 28, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 33 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, August 28, 1884
  15. ST Mar 30, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 13 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, March 30, 1882
  16. RH Aug 27, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 11 — Moses and the Prophets on the Place and Condition of the dead Third-day, August 27, 1872
  17. RH Feb 16, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 12 — Are the Dead Conscious? No. 7. R. F. Cottrell, February 16, 1864
  18. RH Oct 31, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 26, No. 22 — Eld. R. F. Cottrell's Seventh Reply R. F. Cottrell, October 31, 1865
  19. RH Dec 23, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 21, No. 4 — Scriptural Investigation M. E. Cornell, Third-Day, December 23, 1862
  20. ST Sep 28, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 38 — PSALMS F. D. Starr, September 28, 1904
  21. RH Nov 18, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 26 — THE STATE OF THE DEAD John Milton, November 18, 1858
  22. RH Feb 18, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 7 — Amid the Ruins of Italy's Earthquake CHAS. T. EVERSON, February 18, 1909
  23. RH Apr 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 17 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, April 20, 1869
  24. ST Dec 19, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 51 — Condition of Man in Death—Positive Testimony December 19, 1900
  25. RH Apr 18, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 37, No. 18 — Discussion at Rochester Colony, Mich M. E. Connell, Third-day, April 18, 1871
  26. ST Dec 19, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 51 — Condition of Man in Death—Positive Testimony December 19, 1900
  27. ST Mar 27, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 13 — General Articles Dudley Marvin Canright, March 27, 1879
  28. ST Dec 4, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 46 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, December 4, 1884
  29. ST Mar 11, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 10 — Not Dead, but Sleepeth Epsilon, March 11, 1886
  30. ST Apr 11, 1900 Signs of the Times, Vol. 26, No. 15 — THE NATURE OF MAN John O. Corliss, April 11, 1900
  31. ST Sep 18, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 38 — Character of Its Teachings W. A. Colcord, September 18, 1901
  32. ST Apr 16, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 16 — Man in Death Charles L. Taylor, April 16, 1912
  33. ST Jun 23, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 24 — DIVES AND LAZARUS John Nevins Andrews, June 23, 1881
  34. ST Apr 16, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 16 — Man in Death Charles L. Taylor, April 16, 1912
  35. ST Nov 1, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 41 — That Blessed Hope Ellet Joseph Waggoner, November 1, 1883
  36. ST Oct 2, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 37 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, October 2, 1884
  37. ST Oct 2, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 37 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, October 2, 1884
  38. RH Jun 12, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 4 — THE STATE OF THE DEAD June 12, 1860
  39. RH Oct 20, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 44, No. 17 — Spiritualism: The Satanic Deception and Its Fruits J. H. Waggoner, October 20, 1874
  40. RH May 5, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 21 — Dives and Lazarus John Nevins Andrews, May 5, 1874
  41. ST Mar 15, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 12 — THE RICH MAN AND LAZARUS March 15, 1877
  42. ST Jun 23, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 24 — DIVES AND LAZARUS John Nevins Andrews, June 23, 1881
  43. RH Mar 28, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 25, No. 17 — The Wicked Dead John Nevins Andrews, Third-Day, March 28, 1865
  44. RH May 5, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 21 — Dives and Lazarus John Nevins Andrews, May 5, 1874
  45. ST May 15, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 19 — One-Sided Religion May 15, 1884

Cross-references

  1. Psalms 115:17

    The dead praise not the LORD, neither any that go down into silence.

    Both describe the dead as silent and unable to praise the Lord.

  2. Psalms 6:5

    For in death there is no remembrance of thee: in the grave who shall give thee thanks?

    Both describe the dead as having no remembrance or thanksgiving to God.

  3. Ecclesiastes 9:5-6

    For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.

    The dead know nothing, and their love, hatred, and envy have perished.

  4. Job 10:21-22

    Before I go whence I shall not return, even to the land of darkness and the shadow of death;

    Both describe the place of the dead as a land of darkness.

  5. Isaiah 38:18

    For the grave cannot praise thee, death can not celebrate thee: they that go down into the pit cannot hope for thy truth.

    Both say the dead cannot praise God or hope in his truth.

  6. Ecclesiastes 9:10

    Whatsoever thy hand findeth to do, do it with thy might; for there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave, whither thou goest.

    Says there is no knowledge or activity in Sheol.

  7. Job 17:13-16

    If I wait, the grave is mine house: I have made my bed in the darkness.

    Both describe Sheol as darkness, corruption, and rest in the dust.

  8. Job 14:12-15

    So man lieth down, and riseth not: till the heavens be no more, they shall not awake, nor be raised out of their sleep.

    The dead lie asleep in Sheol, awaiting God’s call.

  9. Psalms 89:48

    What man is he that liveth, and shall not see death? shall he deliver his soul from the hand of the grave? Selah.

    Both teach that all go to the grave.

  10. Isaiah 14:9-11

    Hell from beneath is moved for thee to meet thee at thy coming: it stirreth up the dead for thee, even all the chief ones of the earth; it hath raised up from their thrones all the kings of the nations.

    Depicts the dead in Sheol receiving the king of Babylon.

  11. Psalms 30:9

    What profit is there in my blood, when I go down to the pit? Shall the dust praise thee? shall it declare thy truth?

    Both ask whether the dead can praise God or declare his truth.

  12. Psalms 143:3

    For the enemy hath persecuted my soul; he hath smitten my life down to the ground; he hath made me to dwell in darkness, as those that have been long dead.

    says long-dead dwell in darkness

  13. Ezekiel 32:18-32

    Son of man, wail for the multitude of Egypt, and cast them down, even her, and the daughters of the famous nations, unto the nether parts of the earth, with them that go down into the pit.

    Places hades in the depths and contrasts it with the land of the living.

  14. Job 3:17-19

    There the wicked cease from troubling; and there the weary be at rest.

    Describes the dead as at rest and free from oppression.