Revelation 11:8
And their dead bodies shall lie in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And their dead bodies shall lie in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And their dead bodies lie in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also their Lord was crucified.
and their dead bodies [are] upon the broad-place of the great city (that is called spiritually Sodom, and Egypt, where also our Lord was crucified,)
and their body [ shall be] on the street of the great city, which is called spiritually Sodom and Egypt, where also their Lord was crucified.
And their dead bodies [lie] upon the broadway of the great city, the which is called, spiritually, Sodom and Egypt, where, their Lord also was crucified.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Their bodies will lie in the street of the great city—figuratively called Sodom and Egypt— where their Lord was also crucified.
Their dead bodies will be in the street of the great city, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where also their Lord was crucified.
And their dead bodies will be in the open street of the great town, which in the spirit is named Sodom and Egypt, where their Lord was put to death on the cross.
And their corpses shall lie in the streetes of the great citie, which spiritually is called Sodom and Egypt, where our Lord also was crucified.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And their bodies shall lie in the streets of the great city, which is called spiritually, Sodom and Egypt, where their Lord also was crucified.
Cross-references
- Revelation 11:3
And I will give power unto my two witnesses, and they shall prophesy a thousand two hundred and threescore days, clothed in sackcloth.
The witnesses prophesy in sackcloth before their apparent death.
- Revelation 17:5
And upon her forehead was a name written, MYSTERY, BABYLON THE GREAT, THE MOTHER OF HARLOTS AND ABOMINATIONS OF THE EARTH.
The great city is named Mystery Babylon, the mother of harlots.
- Isaiah 1:10
Hear the word of the LORD, ye rulers of Sodom; give ear unto the law of our God, ye people of Gomorrah.
Both texts call an unfaithful people Sodom.
- Exodus 5:2
And Pharaoh said, Who is the LORD, that I should obey his voice to let Israel go? I know not the LORD, neither will I let Israel go.
Pharaoh’s denial of the Lord exemplifies Egypt’s spirit.
- Revelation 17:18
And the woman which thou sawest is that great city, which reigneth over the kings of the earth.
Both texts identify a symbolic woman or place as the great city.
- Genesis 19:4-5
But before they lay down, the men of the city, even the men of Sodom, compassed the house round, both old and young, all the people from every quarter:
Sodom’s corruption illustrates the city’s comparison to Sodom.
- Revelation 11:4
These are the two olive trees, and the two candlesticks standing before the God of the earth.
The witnesses are identified as the two olive trees.
- Jude 1:7
Even as Sodom and Gomorrha, and the cities about them in like manner, giving themselves over to fornication, and going after strange flesh, are set forth for an example, suffering the vengeance of eternal fire.
Recalls Sodom’s destruction as an example of divine judgment.
- Genesis 19:24-25
Then the LORD rained upon Sodom and upon Gomorrah brimstone and fire from the LORD out of heaven;
France’s corruption parallels Sodom’s destruction.
- Deuteronomy 32:32
For their vine is of the vine of Sodom, and of the fields of Gomorrah: their grapes are grapes of gall, their clusters are bitter:
Invokes Sodom as a scriptural image.
- Matthew 10:15
Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city.
Is cited with Revelation 11:8 as a warning of judgment.
- Revelation 14:8
And there followed another angel, saying, Babylon is fallen, is fallen, that great city, because she made all nations drink of the wine of the wrath of her fornication.
Both identify the city as the great city.
- Revelation 11:12
And they heard a great voice from heaven saying unto them, Come up hither. And they ascended up to heaven in a cloud; and their enemies beheld them.
The witnesses are lifted up in heaven in view of their enemies.
- Deuteronomy 29:23
And that the whole land thereof is brimstone, and salt, and burning, that it is not sown, nor beareth, nor any grass groweth therein, like the overthrow of Sodom, and Gomorrah, Admah, and Zeboim, which the LORD overthrew in his anger, and in his wrath:
Describes the land’s desolation after the cities’ destruction.
- Revelation 11:2
But the court which is without the temple leave out, and measure it not; for it is given unto the Gentiles: and the holy city shall they tread under foot forty and two months.
The forty-two months correspond to 1,260 prophetic days.
- Genesis 19:8
Behold now, I have two daughters which have not known man; let me, I pray you, bring them out unto you, and do ye to them as is good in your eyes: only unto these men do nothing; for therefore came they under the shadow of my roof.
Cited as a clue to Sodom’s sin.
- Ezekiel 16:1-15
Again the word of the LORD came unto me, saying,
Jerusalem is portrayed as an unfaithful wife.
- Jude 1:5
I will therefore put you in remembrance, though ye once knew this, how that the Lord, having saved the people out of the land of Egypt, afterward destroyed them that believed not.
The Lord brought his people out of Egypt, a type of the wicked world.
- Revelation 11:13
And the same hour was there a great earthquake, and the tenth part of the city fell, and in the earthquake were slain of men seven thousand: and the remnant were affrighted, and gave glory to the God of heaven.
shows earthquake falling on the city afterward
- Exodus 12:31-42
And he called for Moses and Aaron by night, and said, Rise up, and get you forth from among my people, both ye and the children of Israel; and go, serve the LORD, as ye have said.
The flight of Scripture-loving people from France is compared with Israel’s flight from Egypt.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
16 sources
The great city in whose street the dead bodies lie is France, spiritually called Sodom and Egypt where Christ was crucified in His people.4SP 190.3–4GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3GC 269.4–270.1GC 272.1–273.2 Egypt means atheism and open defiance of the living God as Pharaoh refused to know Jehovah, and Sodom means corrupt lawbreaking marked above all by licentiousness and sexual immorality.GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3 Near the close of their twelve hundred and sixty years of prophesying in sackcloth from A.D. 538 to 1798, the two witnesses were to be killed by a new satanic power from the bottomless pit, foretelling the suppression of the Scriptures and rejoicing over their public humiliation until the Spirit of life entered them after three days and a half.4SP 190.3–4GC 266.1–4GC88 265.3–266.3GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3 That crucifixion of Christ in His disciples was displayed in France century after century in Waldenses, Albigenses, Reformation martyrs, hunted Huguenots and the Church in the Desert, and most terribly in Paris in the St. Bartholomew Massacre when tens of thousands were murdered with the sanction of king, priests and pope.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–34SP 191.1–2GC 272.1–273.2 It was fulfilled in 1793 when France by national decree renounced God, burned the Bible, abolished the Sabbath and degraded marriage to a temporary civil contract to be taken and cast off at pleasure, while blasphemy exalted the basest men and declared Christ an impostor.GC 269.4–270.1GC88 269.4–270.14SP 192.24SP 192.1 The world is now a second Sodom under the same spiritual corruption, so the eleventh chapter with the eighteenth must be read to learn the judgments yet to fall on the cities and to make ready a people to stand in the day of God's preparation.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–911MR 294.2–295.2
City, Names and Time
The great city in whose street the dead bodies lie is France, where powers working through the papacy produced moral corruption like that of Sodom and idolatry and spiritual darkness like that of Egypt, and where Christ was figuratively crucified in the persecution and murder of His faithful people.4SP 190.3–4GC 269.4–270.1 Spiritually called Egypt means atheism, open denial of the living God and defiance of His commands, because of all nations in Bible history Egypt most boldly denied the existence of the living God and resisted His commands, as Pharaoh proudly refused to know Jehovah or let Israel go, so the fulfilling nation would voice the same denial of the claims of the living God with the same unbelief and defiance.GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3 Spiritually called Sodom means corrupt lawbreaking pre-eminently marked by licentiousness and sexual immorality, so that breaking the law of God especially manifested in that sin would be a pre-eminent characteristic of the fulfilling nation.GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3
The slaying is done a little before 1798, as the witnesses approach the end of their prophesying in sackcloth ending in 1798, when they finish their testimony.GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3 It is done by the beast ascending out of the bottomless pit as a new manifestation of satanic power making open war on the Bible, distinct from papal Rome that had kept the Bible hidden.GC 268.3–269.3GC88 269.2–3
The forty-two months and the thousand two hundred and threescore days are the same, representing the 1,260 years of oppression of the church by Rome and papal supremacy.GC 266.1–4GC88 265.3–266.3 That period begins in A.D. 538 and terminates in 1798, when a French army entered Rome and made the pope a prisoner and he died in exile, after which the papal hierarchy never wielded its former power.GC 266.1–4GC88 265.3–266.3 The persecution of the church did not continue through the entire period, because God in mercy cut short the fiery trial, and through the Reformation persecution was brought to an end prior to 1798.GC 266.1–4
Slain Witnesses and Crucified Lord
The verse describes the killing and public humiliation of the two witnesses when they finish their testimony near the end of their 1,260-year testimony during the French Revolution.4SP 190.3–4GC 266.1–4GC88 265.3–266.3 It foretold the suppression of the Scriptures during papal supremacy and the terrible results to come especially on France from the domination of the man of sin.GC 266.1–4GC88 265.3–266.3 Those dwelling on earth rejoice over them and make merry while their bodies lie unburied, until after three days and a half the Spirit of life from God enters them and they stand on their feet.4SP 190.3–4GC 266.1–4
Where also our Lord was crucified means France crucified Christ in the person of His disciples.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3GC 272.1–273.2 In no land was enmity against Christ more strikingly displayed and in no country did the truth meet more bitter and cruel opposition century after century.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3 Century after century the blood of the saints was shed there in persecution of the confessors of the gospel.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3
That centuries-long crucifixion includes Waldenses laying down their lives upon the mountains of Piedmont for the word of God and for the testimony of Jesus Christ, and their brethren the Albigenses of France bearing similar witness.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3 It includes disciples in the days of the Reformation put to death with horrible tortures while king and nobles and high-born women looked on.GC 271.1–3 It includes brave Huguenots pouring out their blood battling for sacred rights as outlaws with a price on their heads hunted like wild beasts.GC 271.1–3GC88 271.1–3 It includes the Church in the Desert in the eighteenth century still cherishing the faith while meeting by night on mountainside or lonely moor, chased by dragoons, dragged to lifelong slavery in the galleys in horrible torture, shot down unarmed on their knees in prayer, and left dead at every four paces and hanging from trees until the country was made a vast gloomy wilderness.GC 271.1–3
In the streets of Paris Christ was crucified in His saints in the Massacre of St. Bartholomew with the king's approval and the signal from the palace bell.4SP 191.1–2 More than thirty thousand were killed in three days, and the pope celebrated the massacre with a jubilee.4SP 191.1–2 The blackest act of that persecution was that same St. Bartholomew Massacre when thousands of trusting Protestants were dragged from homes and murdered in cold blood in Paris for seven days and throughout France for two months until seventy thousand perished by sanction of the king urged on by Romish priests.GC 272.1–273.2 As Christ had been the invisible leader of His people from Egyptian bondage, so Satan was the unseen leader of his subjects in multiplying martyrs.GC 272.1–273.2
Egypt was fulfilled in 1793 when the French Legislative Assembly decreed that there was no God and renounced belief and worship of a Deity.GC 269.4–270.1GC88 269.4–270.1 The decree was joyfully accepted by the people of Paris and elsewhere, making France the single nation to lift its hand as a nation against the Author of the universe.GC 269.4–270.1 Sodom was fulfilled during the Revolution in licentiousness and moral debasement like that which brought destruction on the cities of the plain.GC 269.4–270.1GC88 269.4–270.1 It was fulfilled especially in degrading marriage from a sacred permanent union to a mere transitory civil contract to be taken and cast loose at pleasure, called the sacrament of adultery.GC 269.4–270.1GC88 269.4–270.1
The word of truth lay dead in the streets of infidel France because the Bible and God's law were rejected, and those who opposed God's requirements rejoiced.4SP 192.24SP 192.1 The Bible was publicly burned, the Sabbath was abolished, and an atheistic power openly rejected God and His word, completing the work of suppressing biblical truth begun by Romanism.4SP 192.24SP 192.1 In that supreme homage to Satan the same master-spirit that multiplied martyrs led in the Revolution.GC 272.1–273.2 Jesus Christ was declared an impostor under the rallying cry against the Wretch, heaven-daring blasphemy and abominable wickedness went hand in hand, and the basest and most cruel men were exalted.GC 272.1–273.2 Christ in His characteristics of truth, purity, and unselfish love was crucified there in that rejection, and the bloodshed and terror that followed were the harvest of that rebellion.4SP 192.24SP 192.1GC 272.1–273.2
Warning for Cities Today
The whole eleventh chapter must be read, every verse, together with the scenes of the eighteenth chapter, to learn the things yet to take place in the cities.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9 It gives special indications of coming judgments upon cities and of a coming display of power because of the sins of the great cities.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9 That display was already seen in the recent destruction of a sinful city for its sins.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9 The destruction warns against ignoring the prophecy, making light of it, or meeting it with indifference.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9 It warns against flattering self that greater buildings will be built, and against defiantly investing means in city enterprises, lest power be exercised to counteract such efforts.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9 It calls men who have abused privilege and wronged their fellow men to hear the voice and to make amends.21MR 91.4–5Lt 158, 1906, par. 8–9
The world now is a second Sodom, spiritually corrupt like Sodom, and the end is right upon us.11MR 294.2–295.2 Because the world is in this condition there must be a message to make ready a people to stand in the day of preparation.11MR 294.2–295.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
103 sources
The two lifeless forms are the Old and New Testaments silenced and cast down as a dead letter by national power, left exposed as if driven from the earth.RH Aug 1, 1912GSAM 80.1RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jul 13, 1915ST Nov 28, 1895 The open way where they lie is France, a leading thoroughfare of the larger symbolic city, during its organized assault on Scripture near the close of the twelve hundred and sixty years reckoned 538 to 1798.RH Dec 9, 1851GSAM 80.1RH Oct 28, 1862RH Aug 1, 1912ST Apr 4, 1911 That city is called Sodom for open licentiousness and breaking of the seventh commandment and Egypt for atheist defiance in the spirit of Who is Jehovah that I should obey His voice, denying God, calling death an eternal sleep and Jesus an impostor.RH Jul 11, 1912ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jan 15, 1901RH Jan 14, 1862ST Apr 4, 1911 There Christ is afresh put to death by striking at His people, blotting out His truth and warring on His Gospel, in a three and a half year trampling when the Bible was forbidden, burned and mocked and its institutions set aside for reveling and the worship of reason.RH Oct 28, 1862RH Mar 25, 1858ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jun 27, 1871GSAM 80.2 Those who held the city to be spiritual Babylon in its papal and fallen Protestant form set France beside it as one tenth that fell, while all agree the slain Word rose again when restraint was reversed and Bible societies spread it abroad before its enemies.RH Dec 9, 1851ST Jul 13, 1915ST Oct 31, 1911RH Aug 1, 1912RH Dec 9, 1851
City Street and Bodies
The dead bodies lying in the street are the Old and New Testaments overcome and killed after finishing their testimony in sackcloth, made a dead letter by suppression under national authority and left exposed in a slain, suppressed condition in infidel France between 1793 and 1798, as if driven from the earth.GSAM 80.1RH Oct 28, 1862ST Nov 28, 1895 The killing was wrought by the beast from the bottomless pit stirring up and working through worldly men to make war against them, condemning God's two witnesses to death.GSAM 80.1ST Nov 28, 1895 The street where the bodies lie is France, a prominent street or part within the larger symbolic city, identified as the tenth part of the city that fell around 1798 within the ten divisions of the Western Roman Empire and the papal realm.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Aug 1, 1912ST Apr 4, 1911 It was there, as the 1260 years neared their close, that organized atheism attacked the Scriptures and sought to destroy religion, not by literal killing of bodies but by assault on the divine witnesses.RH Aug 1, 1912ST Apr 4, 1911
The great city is not a literal city but a symbolic prophetic city, whose explanation is itself given in symbols through the spiritual names Sodom and Egypt and the place where Jesus was crucified.RH Aug 1, 1912RH Dec 9, 1851 Its street is where the witnesses lie for three and a half years, in the event included in the second woe.RH Dec 9, 1851 Spiritually called Sodom means licentiousness, corruption, lawlessness and violation of the seventh commandment, manifested in easy divorce, adultery, illegitimate births, open reveling and the setting aside of the week of divine origin for a ten-day period whose closing day was given to excessive reveling.ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jan 15, 1901ST Apr 4, 1911RH Jan 14, 1862ST Apr 22, 1903 Paris in the Revolution displayed this moral condition, plunging into the religion of desire and reason, of lust and imagination, with heaven-daring blasphemy and abominable wickedness going hand in hand while the basest and most cruel and vicious men were exalted.RH Jan 14, 1862ST Apr 22, 1903
Spiritually called Egypt means atheism, infidelity and defiance of God's authority like Pharaoh's Who is Jehovah that I should obey His voice, or I know not Jehovah.ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jan 15, 1901ST Apr 22, 1903 France fulfilled this when its assembly publicly denied God, the constitutional bishop of Paris declared his taught religion priestcraft without sacred truth or history and that Deity did not exist and stripped off his robes, death was declared an eternal sleep, Jesus was declared an impostor, the Bible was prohibited by the national assembly and burned, and every sacred institution was turned to mockery.ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jan 15, 1901ST Apr 22, 1903 Egypt is also a spiritual symbol not merely of a geographical place but of bondage and darkness, sin which is transgression of the law, heathen darkness and idolatry and opposition to God, from which God calls His people to freedom and the inheritance of the heavenly Canaan and the liberty of the everlasting gospel.RH Jul 11, 1912ST Feb 10, 1914RH Jan 2, 1913ST Sep 5, 1900ST Mar 25, 1903 It signifies the wicked world and the condition of sin and darkness, picturing the call out as Israel was called out of Egypt and Christ was called out of Egypt.ST Feb 10, 1914ST Mar 25, 1903ST Apr 14, 1914 France brought such spiritual bondage through infidelity and war against the Bible, persecuting and driving from the kingdom great numbers who cherished Scripture as Israel had fled Egypt, while deifying human passions and reason, treating the people as sovereign and effectively divine, and denying a supreme Being in connection with Pharaoh's challenge and the public blasphemy of 1793.RH Jan 14, 1862
Where also our Lord was crucified means spiritually crucifying the Lord of glory by attacking Christ's people, destroying those who clung to Christ and the Bible, blotting out His truth, profaning the Gospel, Cross and communion symbols, and waging war on the Bible by banning and burning it, abolishing biblical institutions, setting aside the weekly rest, and prohibiting baptism and communion.RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904RH Jan 15, 1901RH Jan 14, 1862 Christ is slain in His people and crucified anew in His Word where atheists sought to blot out His truth and make His memory perish.RH Mar 25, 1858ST Apr 4, 1911ST Apr 22, 1903 As Christ rose after being crucified, so God's call brought the Word back to life and its truth endured, and the rejoicing over its apparent defeat did not last.ST Apr 4, 1911 Past names like Sodom and Egypt are used in this way as familiar prophetic names for later people, kingdoms, cities or powers embodying the same principles, with Sodom, Egypt and the city where Jesus was crucified serving as object lessons and warnings to people, churches, nations and rulers who follow those principles.ST Jul 9, 1874ST May 7, 1902
Identity of Two Witnesses
The two witnesses whose bodies lie in the street are the Scriptures of the Old and New Testaments, the one predicting beforehand what would occur and the other noting the fulfillment in the lives of Christ and of His church.RH Aug 1, 1912GSAM 80.1ST Jul 13, 1915ST Sep 8, 1909 They were attacked and overcome as the 1,260-year period of papal supremacy and persecution came to an end, overcome and killed by the beast ascending out of the bottomless pit, which is Satan stirring up and working through worldly men to make war against them.RH Aug 1, 1912GSAM 80.1ST Sep 8, 1909 Their dead bodies lying exposed is their slain, suppressed condition, left as if the Bible would be driven from the earth, while their enemies rejoiced over them.GSAM 80.1ST Jul 13, 1915ST Dec 11, 1928 That time connected with them is the 1260 days as so many literal years, during which God's people were oppressed and the Scriptures suppressed, and the prophecy is past, not a future event.ST Jul 13, 1915ST Sep 8, 1909 The assault on God's word failed because its enemies rejoice over it only as it reproves them, the revolution turned against itself, and afterward Bible societies spread the Scriptures so that the witnesses were brought back to life and lifted up in the sight of their enemies.ST Jul 13, 1915ST Dec 11, 1928 As such they stand as enduring witnesses to the truth of Christianity and to Christ's divine mission.ST Jul 8, 1913ST Sep 23, 1889
They are also God's living word in two phases: the written word and that same word spoken, lived and made visible in Christ, the apostles, His people and the church, the two agreeing together as a twofold unimpeachable witness.ST May 21, 1896ST Nov 14, 1906ST Aug 12, 1913ST Mar 17, 1909ST Apr 1, 1897 In Christ's day they were the writings of the prophets that went before and the works God wrought through Christ in harmony with the prophets.ST May 21, 1896 It is by God's word that judgments have come upon men and that heaven has withheld and given rain.ST May 21, 1896 During the 1,260 years of the Dark Ages, reckoned from 538 to 1798, they are in mourning and trial, represented by sackcloth, when God's truth was nearly lost both in the written word and in the lives of His people.ST May 21, 1896ST Aug 12, 1913ST Apr 1, 1897 They are not two literal men sent to prophesy before the end, but the manifestation of the two phases of God's living word in the earth, with the closing part of the chapter covering the time of the judgment beginning in 1844 and ending when the work of judgment is done.ST Apr 1, 1897 The double witness now is the unchangeable word come down and the same word revealed in the lives of His people as living apostles, the one witness God's word and the other that word as manifest in the lives of His children, the Old Testament record and the New Testament word spoken and lived.ST May 21, 1896ST Aug 12, 1913ST Mar 17, 1909 Together the Old Testament prophecies about Christ and the New Testament record of His life and works testify to His divine mission and stand as enduring witnesses to the truth of Christianity.ST Sep 23, 1889
Daniel's and John's prophetic books form an important part of the two witnesses, or two prophets, whose testimony tormented the people of the earth by exposing the wickedness of the Papal kingdom and foretelling judgments against it when its appointed time was fulfilled.RH Jan 24, 1856 These witnesses, the Old and New Testaments, bring the commandments of God into clear view, with truth having power to restrain those who break the commandments and to silence those who hear it.RH Aug 5, 1851 Obeyed truth sanctifies every part of a person and prepares them to reflect Christ and receive immortality.RH Aug 5, 1851 Their death and resurrection are figurative, unlike the real death and resurrection of the martyrs in the first resurrection. The three and a half days associated with the dead witnesses are prophetic days, not three and a half literal days, rejecting the idea that saints' bodies lie unburied for three and a half years.RH Mar 25, 1858
Those who held a different explanation made the dead bodies the millions who laid down their lives in honor of the true testimony of the two witnesses, who give plain truth about the teachings of the Lord to guide believers to see and walk in the light instead of traditional errors.ST Jan 15, 1885 Another application places faithful witnesses in the East Indies through revolving centuries, prophesying in sackcloth while their bodies lay as dead in the streets of the city which they had once peopled.RH May 13, 1862
Fulfillment in Revolutionary France
The great city is infidel, atheistic France in the years 1793 to 1798, also reckoned as 1793 to 1796, understood as a nation and as one of the ten kingdoms that rejected the light of the Reformation.RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jul 13, 1915RH Mar 5, 1901RH Jan 15, 1901RH Mar 5, 1901 At the close of the 1,260 years the two witnesses, the Old and New Testaments, lay dead there after finishing their testimony in sackcloth, made a dead letter by suppression under national authority so that it appeared the Bible would be driven from the earth and its enemies rejoiced.RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jul 13, 1915ST Jun 8, 1904 France bore the spiritual names Sodom for licentiousness and Egypt for atheism like Pharaoh's Who is Jehovah that I should obey His voice, and it was the place where the Lord was crucified by spiritually crucifying Him in seeking to blot out His truth.RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jun 8, 1904 This was fulfilled in the formal repudiation of God and the Bible by revolutionary France in 1793, a little before 1798, when Bibles were burned and every sacred institution was turned to mockery, with the light afterward going throughout the world in Bible societies, liberty of conscience, and a resetting of gospel truths to prepare for the second coming.ST Jun 8, 1904RH Mar 5, 1901
France is the street where the witnesses were slain and the tenth part of the city that fell around 1798.RH Dec 9, 1851 The city is not Rome alone or the Catholic Church alone but comprises Protestant and Catholic religion across the ten divisions of the Western Roman Empire, identified as spiritual Babylon, with France as its street and fallen tenth.RH Dec 9, 1851 France is also described as one tenth of mystical Babylon within the Roman dominions where God's Word had languished for more than twelve centuries, in contrast with Jerusalem called the holy city and Babylon called the great city.ST Apr 4, 1911 Once a chief supporter of the Papacy and a place where early Protestant witnesses suffered persecution, France became the source of a blow against papal Rome and therefore raised hopes that papal power would end.RH Aug 1, 1912
The slaying was organized atheism near the close of the 1260 years of testimony in sackcloth, attacking the Scriptures and seeking to destroy religion, and it was not a literal killing of bodies.RH Aug 1, 1912 The attack in France during the Revolution was directed against the Bible and against religion generally, not solely against the Catholic Church.RH Jan 21, 1862 Since the witnesses could be found among Catholics as well as Protestants, an attack on Catholics alone would still strike the witnesses where they were present in France.RH Jan 21, 1862
The terrible condition lasted three and a half years, reckoned as the Reign of Terror from 1792 to 1795, when efforts were made to destroy the Bible, religion, and those who defended them.GSAM 80.2RH Mar 5, 1901 For that time the Bible was trampled in the dust, religion was cast out as unworthy of civilized beings, God's name was daringly blasphemed, and the streets ran with blood until the senate recalled the Bible in hope of a better state.RH Jun 27, 1871 Hostility was acted out in public when an ass was paraded with Christian symbols and the Old and New Testaments tied to its tail, then the Scriptures were burned amid mockery, the burning representing the witnesses' figurative death and the public display giving that rejection literal expression.RH Aug 8, 1912 The period of suppression is identified as three and a half prophetic years, ending when religious restrictions were reversed in June 1797 and the Bible was again free to bear witness in France.RH Aug 8, 1912
The assault abolished biblical institutions, set aside the weekly rest of divine origin for a ten-day period whose closing day was given to excessive reveling, and prohibited baptism and communion.RH Jan 15, 1901ST Apr 22, 1903 The constitutional bishop of Paris publicly declared his taught religion priestcraft without sacred truth or history, declared that Deity did not exist, and stripped off his robes.ST Apr 22, 1903 Sacrifice was offered to the goddess of reason represented by a woman of ill fame, even a lewd female worshiped as the goddess of reason, while the streets of the great city ran with blood in revolution.RH Jun 27, 1871ST Apr 22, 1903 The national assembly prohibited the Bible, Jesus was declared an impostor, death was declared an eternal sleep, heaven-daring blasphemy and abominable wickedness went hand in hand with the basest and most cruel and vicious men exalted, so that Satan seemed to reign supreme and Christ in His Word was crucified anew.ST Apr 22, 1903
The revolt against papal despotism and tyranny struck at all religion because the Papacy represented Christianity in the view of the French.RH Apr 28, 1910RH Mar 26, 1914 France, burdened by the papal hierarchy and ready to reject the Papacy but loving sin and unwilling to accept Christianity, plunged into infidelity and sought to destroy all revealed religion and set up the religion of desire and reason, of lust and imagination.ST Apr 22, 1903 The French Revolution was the culmination of teaching that rejected the Word of God, for which the Papacy entrenched in church and state and school was held responsible through the ignorance of men who sought to destroy God's Word because they did not know it.ST Apr 22, 1903 In the application to the French Revolution the city represents spiritual Babylon and the Papacy, and France's revolt against Rome and religion is the blow that strikes the city at the close of the 1260 years reckoned from the decree of supremacy in 533 to 1793 and fulfilled in the Reign of Terror in 1793.RH Apr 28, 1910RH Sep 30, 1915
The devil's master-stroke in France came too late because the Bible was already multiplying in other tongues through pioneer mission work in other lands, and its seeming defeat demanded special power from God for quickening and exaltation.ST Oct 31, 1911 As soon as the blind force of the French effort was spent the revival came through the great Bible societies in England, Scotland, America and elsewhere and faithful colporters going forth laden with the Word of God, while the revolution turned against itself.ST Jul 13, 1915ST Oct 31, 1911 The suppression ended when the senate recalled the Bible, and afterward in the beginning of the nineteenth century Bible societies were organized, liberty of conscience was granted, the Bible was especially preserved and printed in the language of every known nation and sent broadcast by the millions, and the witnesses were brought back to life and lifted up in the sight of their enemies.ST Jul 13, 1915RH Jun 27, 1871RH Mar 5, 1901RH Aug 8, 1912
The upheaval raised hopes that papal power would end by a blow from France.RH Aug 1, 1912 The spread of the Bible in people's own languages gave force to the testimony of the two witnesses and helped bring about the shortening of the period of papal supremacy and persecution.RH Jul 25, 1912 One of the distant results of the French Revolution, in which Revelation 11:7-13 was fulfilled, was the birth of the Haitian black republic.RH Jul 25, 1907
France was spiritually Egypt because it brought spiritual bondage through infidelity and war against the Bible, persecuted those who cherished Scripture, and drove great numbers of them from the kingdom as Israel had fled Egypt.RH Jan 14, 1862 It was also like Egypt in idolatry, deifying human passions and reason, treating the people as sovereign and effectively divine, and denying a supreme Being.RH Jan 14, 1862 This defiance is connected with Pharaoh's challenge to God and with the public blasphemy against God and the Bible that accompanied the Revolution in 1793.RH Jan 14, 1862
The anarchy overturned the established order, abolished titles of nobility, and confiscated large landed estates for government revenue.ST Jun 8, 1882RH Mar 21, 1871ST May 23, 1878 Those estates were divided into small parcels and sold at auction for the benefit of the public exchequer.RH Mar 21, 1871ST May 23, 1878 The French governmental power that made war in an attempt to extirpate the Bible and Christianity is the power represented by the scarlet beast, later embodied in the Napoleon dynasty.RH Jan 24, 1856
Prophetic Context and Timing
Revelation 11:8 belongs to the prophecy of the two witnesses under the seven trumpets of Revelation 8 to 11, an episodic and supplementary prophecy whose main events occur during the sixth trumpet while its beginnings reach into the distant past and its ending reaches into eternity.ST Apr 4, 1911ST Apr 4, 1911ST Mar 28, 1911 It pauses the trumpet series to show special events connected with the trumpet period, providing a basis for renewed worldwide prophesying and assuring God's people that they and their work are remembered despite the prevalence of war, before the trumpet account of the fate of nations resumes at Revelation 11:14.ST Apr 4, 1911ST Mar 28, 1911ST Jun 15, 1904 The verse shows where the witnesses are left after they finish their testimony in sackcloth and the beast from the abyss makes war with them, overcomes them and kills them, their dead bodies lying in the street of the great city spiritually called Sodom and Egypt where also their Lord was crucified.ST Apr 4, 1911ST Oct 24, 1911ST Apr 22, 1903 It belongs to a period of strife in which God's Word bears double witness and the final phase of the gospel goes forth, presenting additional events and evidence that the end of the world's history is approaching.ST Oct 24, 1911
The seven trumpets reach to the end of this age, cover the gospel age and give a history of earthly nations and their conflicts, reaching the coming judgment and the day of reward and retribution.ST Sep 14, 1882ST May 13, 1880 The three last trumpets are all woe trumpets, and the seventh brings woe upon the earth and not blessing, the anger of the nations and not peace, the coming of the wrath of God, the time for the dead to be judged, the rewarding of the saints, and the pouring out of the seven last plagues in which the wrath of God is filled up.ST Sep 14, 1882 The man of sin continues from the falling away until destroyed by the brightness of Christ's coming, leaving no place for a temporal millennium of peace before the end.ST Sep 14, 1882 The prophetic outline traces the kingdoms formed from the division of the fourth universal empire, describes the plague of Mohammedanism, and carries the vision toward eternity.
The witnesses testify in sackcloth through the 1260 days as so many literal years of papal supremacy and persecution in the Dark Ages, during which God's people were oppressed and His Scriptures were suppressed.RH Aug 1, 1912ST Sep 8, 1909ST May 21, 1896 The period is reckoned from 538 to 1798 and also from a decree of supremacy in 533 to 1793, ending with a fierce onslaught as the period closed when the witnesses are overcome and killed after finishing their testimony.RH Aug 1, 1912GSAM 80.1RH Oct 28, 1862 Their period of mourning and trial represented by sackcloth is the long centuries when God's truth was nearly lost both in the written word and in the lives of His people, the Old Testament record predicting beforehand and the New Testament noting fulfillment in Christ and His church.ST Sep 8, 1909ST Aug 12, 1913 In Christ's day the twofold witness was the writings of the prophets that went before and the works God wrought through Christ in harmony with them, by which judgments have come and heaven has withheld and given rain.ST May 21, 1896
The prophecy is past, not future, fixing the time of the end to 1798 at the close of the 1260 days of persecution, with the witnesses coming into prominence before the world after obscurity, pictured as an ascent to heaven in a cloud while their enemies watch.ST Sep 8, 1909RH Apr 3, 1900ST Nov 28, 1895 Dated periods in the trumpet prophecy include the 1260 years from 538 to 1798, the five months beginning July 27, 1299 and reaching to 1449, and 391 years and 15 days from thence to August 11, 1840, after which the next great events are the judgment, the day of God's wrath, and the coming of Christ.ST Nov 28, 1895 The close of the sixth trumpet on August 11, 1840 leads to the sounding of the seventh trumpet in 1844 when Christ takes up the final phase of His ministry in the cleansing of the sanctuary.ST Jun 15, 1904
Revelation 11 brings this history to the time marked by the 2300-day prophecy, when the heavenly temple was opened and the investigative judgment began, portraying France's heaven-defying work before that point.RH Nov 24, 1910 The events while the seventh angel is sounding take place before the saints receive immortality and therefore occur while the saints are still mortal.RH Mar 27, 1856 The chapter's prophetic events mark the time of the Advent proclamation, which correctly announced the end of prophetic time and brought God's people to the beginning of the judgment of the righteous dead before Christ's return.RH Aug 24, 1869 The same prophetic chain traces God's church through the Christian age and marks the persecuting powers that oppress it, continuing through Revelation 12 and leading to the church's deliverance on Mount Zion.RH Aug 14, 1856
The two-witnesses portrayal is one of the great lines of symbolic and literal prophecy whose converging lines bring the world almost to the focal center, showing that the end of earthly rule is nearly over and Christ's coming is near.ST Nov 28, 1900ST Dec 14, 1904 It stands as one of seven great time dramas in Revelation and one of twelve great lines of prophecy from Daniel, Revelation and the Gospels that begin in widespread periods in the past but gather in the time of the end and the second coming of Jesus the Messiah, closing with the downfall of the false and the everlasting triumph of the true, portraying God's mighty witnesses in the great controversy from Christ's first advent to the glorious consummation.ST Oct 20, 1909 Its foundation is the vision of the two olive trees and the candlestick in Zechariah 4, repeated to John with the purpose of presenting a more important prophecy.
The beast from the abyss that kills them is Satan stirring up and working through worldly men to make war against them, an event identified with the French Revolution.GSAM 80.1RH Jul 7, 1874 The abyss in this account is understood as an earthly place, not a place outside the earth.RH Jul 7, 1874 The chapter must to some extent be studied with Revelation 12 to understand Revelation 17:8-11 and the beast that was and is not with its seven successive heads.ST Sep 3, 1912
City as Babylon Doctrine
The great city is spiritual Babylon, not Rome alone or the Catholic Church alone, comprising Protestant and Catholic religion across the ten divisions of the Western Roman Empire and identified with Mystery Babylon the mother of harlots and her daughters.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Dec 9, 1851 It is the apostate nominal church, not the literal city of Rome, the church that opposed Christ and was responsible for His crucifixion being spiritually called Sodom and Egypt.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Dec 9, 1851 France is the street where the witnesses were slain and the tenth part of the city that fell around 1798.RH Dec 9, 1851
The great city spiritually called Sodom and Egypt is Babylon including at least the Protestant churches, so that to call people out of Babylon to escape partaking of her sins and then gather them into open communion with those same churches is not true separation but uniting in fellowship with Babylon, Egypt and Sodom.RH Feb 9, 1869 It is the nominal church made up of human ecclesiastical organizations, portrayed as once a faithful city become an apostate harlot, whose corrupt condition fits these titles and whose part in putting the Lord to death explains the reference to where He was crucified.RH Dec 9, 1851RH Dec 9, 1851 These titles show why God's people must separate from corrupt religious influences.RH Dec 9, 1851
It was Babylon that slew the Lord Jesus Christ, because the corrupt Jewish church that caused His death forms an important part of that great city.RH Feb 21, 1854 The people of God in all ages have to a very great extent been commingled with this great city.RH Feb 21, 1854 In contrast, because the Christian church in none of its forms reigned over the kings of the earth, the great city which reigns over kings cannot mean the Christian church but means the earthly power of human governments, as taught by those who held that distinction.RH Feb 21, 1854
The symbolic city marked by Sodom-like wickedness and Egypt-like opposition to God, and by the place where Christ was crucified, represents spiritual Babylon and the Papacy, with France's revolt against Rome and religion as the blow striking the city at the close of the 1260 years.RH Sep 30, 1915RH Mar 31, 1874 Applied to the papal church, it describes corruption, persecution and departure from Christ's teachings.RH Mar 31, 1874 The prophecy belongs to professedly Christian persecuting powers.
Sodom as a spiritual name can describe God's own people when apostatized from Him, just as Isaiah applies it to the faithless Jewish church.RH Feb 20, 1855ST Jun 29, 1876 The symbolic great city is thus associated with a professedly religious body rather than a civil power.RH Feb 20, 1855
The world itself is spiritually called Sodom and Egypt, a place of powerful attraction for God's people and a realm from which they must be called out.RH Aug 29, 1912 Spiritual Egypt is the present bondage in which workers of iniquity hold God's people, from which God is now about to rescue them to save them in His kingdom just as He delivered Israel from literal Egypt. As He then manifested His power with bare arm and stretched-out hand in judgments upon those keeping His people in bondage, so He will close His contest with workers of iniquity in the last days by visiting plagues of similar nature and largely identical form upon men.
Application and Connections
Egypt in the verse is a spiritual symbol of bondage, darkness, sin and error, and of the wicked world itself, from which God calls His people out into the liberty of the everlasting gospel and the inheritance of the heavenly Canaan.RH Jul 11, 1912ST Mar 25, 1903ST Apr 14, 1914RH Apr 4, 1907RH Mar 2, 1916 As He called Israel out of literal Egypt and as Christ was called out of Egypt, so He calls people out of spiritual bondage into gospel freedom.ST Mar 25, 1903RH Apr 4, 1907 The God who brought Israel out with mighty, infinite, creative power is the only God, the covenant God who remembers His promise and delivers, and the Giver of the law.RH Mar 2, 1916 By infinite sacrifice Jesus Christ bought every soul on earth out of that spiritual Egypt, and that love appeals both to sinners still in its darkness and to Christians already redeemed from its bondage.RH Mar 2, 1916 The world spiritually called Sodom and Egypt exerts powerful attraction, yet God’s people must be called out from it and led into present truth even before reaching the promised land.RH Aug 29, 1912RH Apr 4, 1907
That call to escape present destruction embraces every member of the family, requiring earnest care for children and youth as well as adults.RH Apr 22, 1915 The great city spiritually called Sodom and Egypt is Babylon, including at least the Protestant churches, and to call people out of Babylon that they partake not of her sins and then gather them into open communion with those same churches is not true separation but uniting in fellowship with Babylon, Egypt and Sodom.RH Feb 9, 1869
The double witness now is the unchangeable word of God come down and that same word revealed in the lives of His people as living apostles.ST May 21, 1896 God’s witness is primarily His word, shown in the Scriptures and in Christ’s life and the lives of His children, and the church in each generation is a living witness to the truth and power of that Word even through errors, wanderings, backslidings and persecutions.ST Apr 22, 1903ST Jan 16, 1907 In Christ’s day the twofold unimpeachable witness was the writings of the prophets going before and the works God wrought through Christ in harmony with them, by which judgments came upon men and heaven withheld and gave rain.ST May 21, 1896 After lying as if dead when infidel France endeavored to destroy them from the earth, and after mourning through the 1260 years of the Dark Ages, God’s providence overruled the attack to enable them to testify more widely.ST May 21, 1896
Their seeming defeat as the Bible under assault demanded special power from God for quickening and exaltation.ST Oct 31, 1911 The devil’s master-stroke in France came too late because the Bible was already multiplying in other tongues through pioneer mission work in other lands, and as soon as the blind force of the French effort was spent revival came through the great Bible societies in England, Scotland, America and elsewhere and faithful colporters going forth laden with the Word.ST Oct 31, 1911 Slain for confessing Christ, the witnesses do not end in death but rise and proclaim truth widely, confronting pagan rulers and Roman priests, shaking the scarlet throne and exposing the Man of Sin.RH Nov 12, 1861
The great city also portrays those who rejoice when accusing witnesses are silenced, as if removal brought peace and quiet, welcoming silenced protest and taking pride in having no opposition.ST Nov 25, 1897 Turning toward the world repeats that hostility to Christ through hostility to the Bible, as shown when militant unbelief in revolutionary France attacked Scripture to suppress its spiritual light amid wickedness and defiance of God.ST Apr 7, 1881 Joining secret lodges for money and worldly fellowship is facing toward that spiritual Egypt where the Lord was crucified.RH Jun 16, 1874
As hostile powers formerly at enmity united to crucify Christ, so the same place will crucify truth again when the proposed union of evangelical denominations is completed.RH Oct 22, 1872 That union will bring persecution by civil law upon those who adhere to the Bible and keep its commandments.RH Oct 22, 1872 Before that consummation the true and loyal people will be separated from the Babel of confusion by the message of Revelation 9-12, leaving the united churches with the salt of the earth removed and the Spirit of God totally withdrawn.RH Oct 22, 1872
The destruction of Sodom and Gomorrah stands as a terrible memorial of God’s wrath against sin.RH Jul 1, 1858 Paris as spiritual Sodom is a large city needing sustained spiritual workers.RH Feb 25, 1904 Under the seventh angel the kingdoms of this world become Christ’s, but not by conversion of states and not because nations as states are born again, for in the same connection the nations are angry, which is not the condition of a converted person nor preparation for conversion, and God’s wrath falls upon them for destruction, not conversion.ST Feb 11, 1897
The longer supplementary prophecy to which the verse belongs covers the trumpet period through the close of the sixth trumpet with emphasis on its later events, assuring God’s people that they and their work are remembered despite prevailing war.ST Mar 28, 1911 Its prophecies of the Christian dispensation culminate in Christ’s coming glory.ST Oct 14, 1889 The two witnesses are the Old Testament prophecies about Christ and the New Testament record of His life and works, together testifying to His divine mission as enduring witnesses to the truth of Christianity.ST Sep 23, 1889 The destruction of the nations under the seventh trumpet belongs to the completion of Christ’s kingdom, beginning with presentation of David’s heir to the Jews and gathering of God’s people from all nations.RH Mar 25, 1873
Sources