1 Samuel 24:5
And it came to pass afterward, that David’s heart smote him, because he had cut off Saul’s skirt.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, American Standard Version
And it came to pass afterward, that David’s heart smote him, because he had cut off Saul’s skirt.
And it came to pass afterward, that David's heart smote him, because he had cut off Saul's skirt.
And it came to pass afterward, that David’s heart smote him because he had cut off Saul’s skirt.
And it cometh to pass afterwards that the heart of David smiteth him, because that he hath cut off the skirt which [is] on Saul,
And it came to pass afterwards that David's heart smote him, because he had cut off Saul's skirt.
And it came to pass afterwards that David’s heart smote him,—because he had cut off the corner [of the robe] which belonged to Saul.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Afterward, David’s conscience was stricken because he had cut off the corner of Saul’s robe.
Afterward, David’s heart struck him because he had cut off Saul’s skirt.
And later, David was full of regret for cutting off Saul's skirt.
And the men of Dauid said vnto him, See, the day is come, whereof the Lord sayde vnto thee, Beholde, I will deliuer thine enemie into thine hande, and thou shalt doe to him as it shall seeme good to thee. Then Dauid arose and cut off the lap of Sauls garment priuily.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
After which David’s heart struck him, because he had cut off the hem of Saul’s robe.
Pictures

Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 26:9-11
And David said to Abishai, Destroy him not: for who can stretch forth his hand against the LORD’s anointed, and be guiltless?
David refuses to harm Saul and leaves his fate to God.
- 1 Samuel 24:17
And he said to David, Thou art more righteous than I: for thou hast rewarded me good, whereas I have rewarded thee evil.
Saul acknowledges David repaid his evil with good and was more righteous.
- 2 Samuel 16:10-12
And the king said, What have I to do with you, ye sons of Zeruiah? so let him curse, because the LORD hath said unto him, Curse David. Who shall then say, Wherefore hast thou done so?
David endures Shimei’s abuse, leaving judgment to the LORD rather than retaliating.
- 1 Samuel 24:11
Moreover, my father, see, yea, see the skirt of thy robe in my hand: for in that I cut off the skirt of thy robe, and killed thee not, know thou and see that there is neither evil nor transgression in mine hand, and I have not sinned against thee; yet thou huntest my soul to take it.
The cut skirt serves as proof that David spared Saul and acted innocently.
- 1 Samuel 24:12
The LORD judge between me and thee, and the LORD avenge me of thee: but mine hand shall not be upon thee.
David leaves judgment between himself and Saul to the Lord.
- 1 Samuel 24:21
Swear now therefore unto me by the LORD, that thou wilt not cut off my seed after me, and that thou wilt not destroy my name out of my father’s house.
Saul acknowledged David had spared him and admitted his own error.
- 1 Samuel 24:14
After whom is the king of Israel come out? after whom dost thou pursue? after a dead dog, after a flea.
echoes David's flea comparison for Saul's pursuit
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
7 sources
David was a shepherd lad to whom God had promised the throne, yet helpless in himself, standing against Saul the established monarch who was bent on holding fast his power.ED 254.2–3 While Saul was seeking David's life, he came into the wilderness and entered unattended into the very cave where David with his men of war lay hidden, and David's men urged him to do to his enemy as seemed good to him.MH 484.2 David could have killed Saul but spared his life, refusing to stretch forth his hand against him and refusing to let his men harm him.PP 661.2–3MH 484.21SP 383.2–384.2SG4 91.1PP 736.3–4
David only secretly cut off the edge or piece of Saul's skirt or robe.PP 661.2–3MH 484.21SP 383.2–384.2SG4 91.1PP 736.3–4 In cutting the robe he meant to prove that he would not harm Saul.SG4 91.1 Afterward his heart smote him, his conscience troubled and reproached him and he felt remorse and repentance, showing his tender, courteous and forbearing character and sensitive conscience, since even damaging the king's garment or this lesser act of disrespect weighed on him as wrong though he had spared Saul's life.PP 661.2–3MH 484.21SP 383.2–384.2SG4 91.1PP 736.3–4
His remorse was because Saul was the Lord's anointed, anointed king over Israel by God's command and David's master to be honored for his position, even though the Lord had declared the kingdom should be taken from Saul because of disobedience.MH 484.21SP 383.2–384.2SG4 91.1PP 736.3–4 The cutting of the robe therefore stands as proof that David had not harmed Saul or his house.PP 736.3–4 God places men in positions of responsibility and He alone has power to correct or remove them when they err, so men must not take God's work of judging into their own hands.MH 484.2
The verse teaches forbearance under wrong and shows what trusting the word of God does, enabling one to withstand the power of the whole world.MH 484.2MH 485.1ED 254.2–3 Forbearance means that when suffering real or supposed wrong the spirit is not to chafe, remembering that one's own life record will soon pass in review before God.MH 484.2MH 485.1 In bearing wrong, self is the enemy most to be feared, no vice harms character more than human passion not under control of the Holy Spirit, and no victory is so precious as victory gained over self.MH 485.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
24 sources
David hid in a cave at En-gedi while Saul was hunting him with three thousand chosen men, and when Saul entered the same cave helpless and was delivered into his hand, David spared his life and only cut off a piece of his robe despite his men urging him to kill him.ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904 His heart smiting him afterward means his conscience troubled and reproached him even for merely cutting the robe.RH Mar 23, 1916RH Jun 23, 1868ST Sep 9, 1889 He blamed himself because Saul was the Lord's anointed appointed for that time, and in reverence for Saul's position and the order God had established he would not raise his hand against him or lessen respect for him.ST Sep 9, 1889STRH Dec 24, 1867 In sparing his bitter enemy when he was wholly in his power, David showed mercy, magnanimity and restraint, leaving his cause, protection and advancement in God's hands and trusting God to bring him to the throne in His own time and way rather than seizing it by violence.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Feb 17, 1904ST Apr 9, 1912ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jan 17, 1906 He held up the cut skirt to prove he bore Saul no malice and had not sinned against him, and that soft answer turned away wrath so that Saul wept and confessed David was more righteous than himself, teaching returning good for evil, loving the enemy and overcoming evil with good.RH Mar 23, 1916RH Sep 26, 1871ST Feb 17, 1904ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jul 24, 1884
Setting and Conscience
Saul was hunting David with three thousand chosen men, pursuing him from valley to valley and mountain to mountain like a wild beast until David, driven from home and destitute with only a few companions in dire straits, hid in a cave at the rocks of the wild goats of En-gedi.ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904 Saul entered the same cave asleep and helpless and was thus delivered into David's hand, while David's men urged him to kill Saul as the promised deliverance.ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904 David, himself already anointed, stole in and only severed a fold from Saul's mantle rather than taking vengeance.ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904
The pursuit belongs to the long wicked career recorded in 1 Samuel 14-31, in which Saul departed from God and lost tenderness of conscience, sense of accountability, humility, uprightness and dependence on God.ST Sep 20, 1883 Evil reigned in his heart and the Spirit of God had departed from him, yet he still held the throne as an apostate king and pursued David far and near year after year.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Apr 22, 1903 He did so because David, of another family and tribe, was likely to be his successor, and though God had announced He had chosen a man to fill Saul's place and Saul was impressed that David was that man, Saul in self-idolatry sacrificed justice, humanity and truth to unholy ambition and pride and was wholly incapable of submitting to God's choice.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Apr 22, 1903
By this time David had served Saul with humble obedience and a life above reproach, and his faithfulness to God stood in marked contrast to Saul's rebellious course as a constant rebuke to him.ST Sep 9, 1889 Saul had fully determined to leave no effort untried to have David slain and that policy controlled his whole later life even when David's miraculous escapes showed God's direct providence.ST Sep 9, 1889 David clearly understood his relations with the king and his own ultimate right to the kingdom, and many Israelites had reached the same conclusion with a provisional court already gathering about him, so the act displays the widely different principles on which the two men acted.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Sep 9, 1889 Despite his envy, jealousy and crimes, Saul had noble traits that might have led him to God's favor if he had cultivated them and removed his evil qualities.ST Feb 19, 1885
David's heart smiting him means his conscience troubled and reproached him afterward for merely cutting off a piece of Saul's robe, even though he had spared Saul's life.RH Mar 23, 1916RH Jun 23, 1868ST Sep 9, 1889RH Dec 24, 1867ST Jan 17, 1906 His remorse reveals the tenderness of his conscience and his religious integrity.RH Jun 23, 1868 David felt even that act against Saul was wrong because Saul was the Lord's anointed, appointed to his position for that time.ST Sep 9, 1889STRH Dec 24, 1867RH Nov 11, 1873 David blamed himself because the act could lessen respect for Saul, and in reverence for Saul's position and for the order God had established he would not strike his enemy, rebel against him, or raise his hand against the Lord's anointed, though himself already anointed.ST Sep 9, 1889STRH Dec 24, 1867RH Nov 11, 1873
A smitten heart is also conscience convicting a man after scorning a godly poor man, when remembering the poor man's simple meal, his uplifted face and the words of his thankful prayer together with one's own laugh of derision brings humiliation.ST Mar 1, 1877 That humiliation turns to better purpose when the sin is seen again in its true light.ST Mar 1, 1877 The same tenderness that made David's conscience smite him even for cutting a piece from Saul's cloak highlights how far he later fell when he murdered a valiant soldier to cover his adultery.ST May 6, 1897
Mercy and Trust
David showed mercy, magnanimity, loyalty and restraint toward Saul his bitter enemy and persecutor, and even when Saul was wholly in his power he would not harm him, take vengeance into his own hands, or turn against him, but left his cause, protection, future advancement and judgment in God's hands.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Feb 17, 1904ST Apr 9, 1912ST Apr 7, 1909ST It is safe to commit one's cause to God and to trust in God rather than seek the destruction of persecutors in personal persecution.ST Apr 11, 1911ST Feb 17, 1904ST Apr 9, 1912ST Apr 7, 1909
He only severed a fold from Saul's mantle and then used the cut skirt as a pacific argument and soft answer to prove he bore Saul no malice and had no intent to harm him.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904 Calling out that some bade him kill Saul but his eye spared him, he held up the skirt to prove there is neither evil nor transgression in his hand and he has not sinned against Saul.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jun 15, 1904 This gentle response turned away wrath, so Saul lifted up his voice and wept and confessed that David was more righteous than himself and acknowledged David's goodness and his own wrongdoing, for David had rewarded him good whereas he had rewarded David evil.RH Sep 26, 1871ST Jul 24, 1884ST Jun 15, 1904
The account teaches returning good for evil, loving the enemy and patiently enduring wrongful persecution, leaving vengeance to God and overcoming evil with good, and soft answers hold as good today.RH Mar 23, 1916RH Sep 26, 1871ST Feb 17, 1904ST Jul 24, 1884 Though Saul was hunting him and David had the chance to kill him, David would not seize the throne by taking Saul's life, but trusted God to fulfill the prophecy choosing him as king and to bring him to the throne in God's own time and way and to judge between him and his enemies.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Jan 17, 1906 That restraint was a greater victory than killing Saul.ST Sep 9, 1889
Through his disheartening experiences with Saul, though driven into the fastnesses of the mountains for protection and though his persecutor was at times wholly within his power, David held steadily to his purpose not to harm the Lord's anointed.RH Dec 6, 1906 This shows one who could form a purpose and hold to it, brave, determined, cool, yet tender and kind as a young man, and those sterling qualities of heart are what God saw when He looked upon his heart in selecting him to be king, and they stood him in good stead for forty long years as he brought from a disorganized confederation of tribes a strong, united kingdom.RH Dec 6, 1906 Purpose and mission are the same, and one who can select and hold a worthy purpose has the traits of character that make a good and true missionary.RH Dec 6, 1906 His forbearance even when he had opportunity to take vengeance on his adversary reflects a strength of principle that helped him overcome human weakness.ST Nov 11, 1880
His remorse over cutting a piece from Saul's cloak highlights how far he later fell when he murdered a valiant soldier to cover his adultery.ST May 6, 1897 His dealing with Saul stands as wisdom in action, alongside Noah at the flood, Abraham in Canaan, Moses in Egypt, John the Baptist at the annunciation, Paul before the Roman tribunal, and Elijah in opposing Jezebel.RH Dec 4, 1913
Sources