2 Thessalonians 3:10
For even when we were with you, this we commanded you, that if any would not work, neither should he eat.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
For even when we were with you, this we commanded you, that if any would not work, neither should he eat.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
For even when we were with you, this we commanded you, If any will not work, neither let him eat.
for even when we were with you, this we did command you, that if any one is not willing to work, neither let him eat,
For also when we were with you we enjoined you this, that if any man does not like to work, neither let him eat.
For, even when we were with you, this, were we giving in charge unto you,—that, if any will not work, neither let him eat!
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For even while we were with you, we gave you this command: “ If anyone is unwilling to work, he shall not eat.”
For even when we were with you, we commanded you this: “ If anyone is not willing to work, don’t let him eat.”
For even when we were with you we gave you orders, saying, If any man does no work, let him not have food.
For euen when we were with you, this we warned you of, that if there were any, which would not worke, that he should not eate.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For also when we were with you, this we declared to you: that, if any man will not work, neither let him eat.
Pictures


Cross-references
- 1 Thessalonians 4:11-12
And that ye study to be quiet, and to do your own business, and to work with your own hands, as we commanded you;
Both command believers to work with their hands, live honorably, and provide for themselves.
- Genesis 3:19
In the sweat of thy face shalt thou eat bread, till thou return unto the ground; for out of it wast thou taken: for dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.
Both connect obtaining food with labor and the sweat of work.
- Ephesians 4:28
Let him that stole steal no more: but rather let him labour, working with his hands the thing which is good, that he may have to give to him that needeth.
Both command honest labor to provide for needs and share with others.
- Acts 20:34
Yea, ye yourselves know, that these hands have ministered unto my necessities, and to them that were with me.
Paul worked with his own hands to provide for himself and his companions.
- Acts 18:3
And because he was of the same craft, he abode with them, and wrought: for by their occupation they were tentmakers.
Paul worked as a tentmaker while carrying out his ministry.
- Proverbs 19:15
Slothfulness casteth into a deep sleep; and an idle soul shall suffer hunger.
Both connect idleness with hunger.
- 1 Thessalonians 2:9
For ye remember, brethren, our labour and travail: for labouring night and day, because we would not be chargeable unto any of you, we preached unto you the gospel of God.
Paul labored night and day so as not to burden others.
- 2 Thessalonians 3:14-15
And if any man obey not our word by this epistle, note that man, and have no company with him, that he may be ashamed.
Avoiding the disorderly is meant to shame them, while still admonishing them as brothers.
- Proverbs 18:9
He also that is slothful in his work is brother to him that is a great waster.
Slothful work is linked with wastefulness.
- Proverbs 20:4
The sluggard will not plow by reason of the cold; therefore shall he beg in harvest, and have nothing.
Refusing to labor can leave a person without a harvest and begging.
- Ecclesiastes 10:18
By much slothfulness the building decayeth; and through idleness of the hands the house droppeth through.
Idleness causes a house to decay.
- Romans 12:11
Not slothful in business; fervent in spirit; serving the Lord;
Both command diligence in labor and service to the Lord.
- 2 Thessalonians 3:6
Now we command you, brethren, in the name of our Lord Jesus Christ, that ye withdraw yourselves from every brother that walketh disorderly, and not after the tradition which he received of us.
Withdraw from disorderly believers who refuse to work.
- Proverbs 6:10-11
Yet a little sleep, a little slumber, a little folding of the hands to sleep:
Slumber and folded hands bring want.
- Proverbs 10:4-5
He becometh poor that dealeth with a slack hand: but the hand of the diligent maketh rich.
Contrasts the results of slackness and diligent labor.
- Proverbs 13:4
The soul of the sluggard desireth, and hath nothing: but the soul of the diligent shall be made fat.
Contrasts the sluggard’s unfulfilled desire with the diligent person’s abundance.
- Proverbs 24:30-34
I went by the field of the slothful, and by the vineyard of the man void of understanding;
A neglected field illustrates how idleness leads to poverty.
- Proverbs 20:13
Love not sleep, lest thou come to poverty; open thine eyes, and thou shalt be satisfied with bread.
Loving sleep leads to poverty; diligence brings provision.
- Acts 4:35
And laid them down at the apostles’ feet: and distribution was made unto every man according as he had need.
Distribution met people’s needs rather than supporting idleness.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
50 sources
The verse is Christ's command through Paul that one who is able but unwilling to work should not be fed.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3COL 247.2ST May 11, 1915 It was given to correct believers who walked disorderly in idleness as busybodies on the plea that Christ would soon return, and it calls for withdrawing from such disorder and following Paul's pattern of quiet, diligent labor for one's own bread.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3Lt 80, 1894, par. 30–33ST May 30, 1878 Paul illustrated it himself by working night and day at tentmaking to support himself and others, not because he had no right to support as a minister, but to set an example that manual toil honors God and does not weaken ministry.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3RP 29.2RH Oct 3, 1912 Work is ordained by God for all His creatures as a blessing and wholesome discipline, and idleness is sin that guards no one from temptation and wrong.RP 29.2CT 279.3GC 67.3LSEGW 87.1CH 447.2 Withholding food and support from the willfully idle does not apply to those unable to work or poor through misfortune, but is meant to prevent harmful dependence and to move them to duty, since true beneficence teaches economy, opens opportunity to work, and trains all who can work to support themselves and help others.ST May 30, 1878COL 247.2ST May 11, 1915ST May 30, 1878MH 195.1
Command's Wording and Setting
The command is Christ's through Paul that the one unwilling to work should not eat, first spoken in person while with the Thessalonians and then repeated with authority in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10AA 347.2–3 It stands joined to prayer for the free course of the word, for deliverance from unreasonable and wicked men, to confidence in the Lord's faithfulness to establish and keep from evil, and to direction of hearts into the love of God and patient waiting for Christ.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10 It was illustrated at the time by Paul's own conduct, who was not disorderly, ate no one's bread for nothing, but labored with toil night and day so as not to be chargeable to anyone, not because he lacked right to support but to make himself a pattern to follow.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10AA 347.2–3
It was directed at believers who refused to work with their hands, who walked disorderly, working not at all but as busybodies, and who were to work quietly and eat their own bread.ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3ST May 30, 1878 It corrects the error that Christ's soon return meant abandoning ordinary labor, teaching instead that the able but unwilling should not be supported with food and that Christians must earn their own living rather than live idly at others' expense.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878STB 743.5 Abstaining from labor and urging others to do the same is contrary to God's word, and such refusal is not a sign of holiness or of faithful suffering for Christ.CET 74.3–4SG2 63.1–64.2 Idleness in expectation of His coming is not guiltless, for God-given abilities are to be used and improved in useful work that blesses and benefits others.STB 743.5
It was declared at Thessalonica on the sea coast after leaving Philippi, where labor had been both in the gospel and with the hands.Ms 97, 1899, par. 5 It requires withdrawing from every brother who walks disorderly and not after the tradition received from Paul, and following Paul's example instead.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10 Those heard to walk in that disorderly way are commanded and exhorted by the Lord Jesus Christ to work with quietness and eat their own bread, while the brethren are charged not to be weary in well doing.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878
Paul's Working Example
The command was enforced by personal example at Thessalonica, where labor with toil night and day provided self-support, no food taken without payment, no burden laid on anyone, and a pattern set for others to copy.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3ST May 30, 1878Ms 97, 1899, par. 5 That night-and-day work while preaching showed how to earn one's own bread instead of living idly at the expense of fellow believers.ST May 30, 1878AA 347.2–3ST May 30, 1878 The refusal to eat another's bread for nothing and the determination not to be chargeable made the rule visible in action.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10Ms 97, 1899, par. 5
This self-supporting labor while proclaiming the Word was not from lack of right to maintenance as a minister of the gospel, but was deliberately chosen to furnish an example.Ms 93, 1899, par. 9–10ST May 30, 1878 The right to support remained, yet labor was added to it in order to model diligence for the idle.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878
The trade followed was tentmaking, by which provision was made not only for personal need but for others, proving that honest work can stand alongside Christian ministry.RP 29.2RH Oct 3, 1912CT 279.3MYP 216.1 Skill in ordinary crafts is a gift from God, and everyday toil rightly done brings Him honor.RH Oct 3, 1912CT 279.3MYP 216.1 Such manual work did not weaken ministerial appeals, even with toil-worn hands, and it opened access to persons who might otherwise not have been reached.RP 29.2RH Oct 3, 1912CT 279.3MYP 216.1
As apostle to the Gentiles, preparation had included learning the tentmaker's trade in its higher and lower branches, so that the common branches could be worked when circumstances required.Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2 Because tentmaking did not yield returns as quickly as some other lines of business, necessities were at times met only by the strictest economy.Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2
Work as Duty, Idleness as Sin
Idleness is sin, guiltless before no one and contrary to God's word, and one who is able but unwilling to work should not be given food nor expect others to provide food and support.RP 29.2RH Oct 3, 1912CT 279.3MYP 216.1LSEGW 87.3 People must be active to fill their appointed place, and to abstain from labor and urge others to do the same is error and not obedience.CET 74.3–4LSEGW 87.3 God ordained work for the beings He created, and no one in His great domain was made to be idle.LSEGW 87.1 Happiness depends on useful employment and increases as powers develop through engaging in it.LSEGW 87.1 Diligent labor is a blessing that guards against the dangers of idleness, and persevering labor, as in carefully cultivating even poor land with economy, self-denial, forethought and care, is a wholesome discipline for fallen human beings.GC 67.3CH 447.2
Work is a duty for all, and preaching the gospel does not excuse ministers from physical labor.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12RH Mar 6, 1900 Useful labor to support oneself and others is to be commended, not regarded as belittling to a minister, degrading, or a reason for discontent, and the sentiment that manual labor is drudgery fit only for others is wrong.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12RP 29.2RH Oct 3, 1912Lt 2, 1889, par. 18–19FE 417.2 Healthful and equal exercise of all the powers keeps the living machinery in best condition, with every part bearing its burden harmoniously so that muscles do not weaken through inaction while the brain carries too large a share.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12RH Mar 6, 1900 Serving God includes faithful, diligent work in the ordinary affairs of life, and idleness is condemned.COL 343.3 When not zealously engaged in God's work a person should labor with the hands, since work helps provide for one's family while indolence leaves them without needed comforts.Lt 33, 1861, par. 15–16
Charity Toward Needy and Idle
The command draws the line between inability and unwillingness, concerning those who are able but refuse to work, not those who cannot work or are poor through misfortune.ST May 30, 1878COL 247.26T 278.1–2ST May 30, 1878Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21 It corrects the idea that the nearness of Christ's return justifies abandoning ordinary labor, requiring instead quiet work and eating one's own bread rather than living idly at others' expense.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878 Refusal, not lack of power or opportunity, is what disqualifies a person from support.ST May 30, 1878ST May 11, 1915ST May 30, 1878
Those able but unwilling to work are not to be supported in idleness and are not to expect others to provide their food and board.ST May 30, 1878COL 247.2MH 195.1Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20LSEGW 87.3 Neglecting the ordinary duties of providing for daily needs makes such a person a burden to fellow believers.Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20Lt 35, 1888, par. 11–12 One who refuses to work is not to be given food, but must be active to fill an appointed place, since idleness is sin.LSEGW 87.3 Withholding support from the willfully idle is intended to move them to take up their duties and to prevent disorder and harmful idleness.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878 Giving that encourages idleness and dependence harms those it feeds, so help should instead open opportunities for people to work and develop self-support.MH 195.1Lt 31b, 1895, par. 12
Idleness is not to be encouraged by private gifts or church money.Ms 93, 1899, par. 13–14 Every man, woman, and child is to be educated to practical, useful work, learning some trade such as tentmaking or other business and putting the powers of the body to purposeful use.Ms 93, 1899, par. 13–14 Even a man in good health who has property and no need to work for his own support is still to labor to acquire means to advance God's cause and to guard his influence by diligence.Ms 93, 1899, par. 13–14 Food, clothing, and sustaining support must be withheld even from one's own son if he will not work for his own support, persists in his own way and evil companions, and brings reproach on home, youth, and God's cause.Lt 166, 1901, par. 4 To keep feeding and clothing him in that course justifies his evil and shares guilt for it, making life easy for him to continue injuring others and leading other youth away from uprightness, so he must be left to learn what it means to support himself by work.Lt 166, 1901, par. 4
The unfortunate and those who cannot pay, even through unwise management, deserve tenderness, compassion, and mercy without imprisonment, oppression, or harsh treatment.COL 247.2ST May 11, 1915Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21 Poverty from wasted time and lack of effort is different and calls for correction, since aid that leaves those faults unchanged is wasted and ineffective.COL 247.2Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21 Forgiving as God forgives lessens no duty to obey, and praying to be forgiven as we forgive does not forbid requiring what is justly due.ST May 11, 1915 The command does not justify turning away one who asks for food, because poverty may result from misfortune.6T 278.1–2 True beneficence is therefore more than giving gifts, pennies, and old clothes; it takes a liberal interest in others, teaches the improvident poor economy and self-care, opens opportunities for work and self-support, and requires work for food.Ms 156, 1901, par. 16Lt 31b, 1895, par. 12 Requiring work for food teaches the money-value of strength and time and trains widows, fatherless, young, aged, afflicted, and crippled who can work to provide for themselves, since everyone capable of eating a square meal is capable of working to pay for it, while those confined to bed and unable to work are to be helped.Ms 156, 1901, par. 16
Those with health who can support themselves must reform careless, loafing habits, husband time, and be diligent in business with economy and good management.ExVEGW 45.3SG2 120.1–121.1EW 75.1–2 They are to use God-given strength and time to provide for their families and by diligent labor earn means to help others and sustain God's cause.ExVEGW 45.3Lt 22, 1859, par. 3EW 75.1–2 Selling possessions is meant to spread the truth, not to maintain those who can earn their own support, and those who attend meetings for material benefits should instead work with their hands.ExVEGW 45.3 The wealthy are not required to support those who have health and can support themselves.SG2 120.1–121.1 Yet giving should have a worthy purpose of advancing God's cause and relieving a poor brother, even in small quiet kindnesses, and the principle does not excuse the rich from helping the afflicted, widows, and worthy poor.1T 194.1 The rich should treat the needy favorably in prices and wages rather than exploit their need, since strength is a trust as property is and the poor are as accountable for strength as the rich are for means.SG2 120.1–121.11T 194.1
Health and Training for Work
Physical work belongs to the Lord's order, and refusal to use bodily powers forfeits the right to eat.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12RH Mar 6, 1900Lt 103, 1897, par. 2 Keeping the living machinery in best condition requires healthful and equal exercise of all powers, with every part used harmoniously and bearing its burden so that muscles are not weakened through inaction while the brain carries too large a share.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12RH Mar 6, 1900 Teaching lacks vitality unless all parts of the human machinery are equally exercised, and labor to support oneself and others is to be commended rather than regarded as belittling to a minister of the gospel.Ms 97, 1899, par. 10–12 Preaching the gospel does not excuse ministers from physical labor, and they should gain exercise through useful work and help those who host them rather than let others wait on them, since neglecting such exercise harms health.RH Mar 6, 19003T 211.1
Applied to schooling, one third of the time now occupied in book study using the mental machinery should be occupied in learning lessons in the right use of one's own physical powers.Lt 103, 1897, par. 2 The right use of oneself covers the whole circle of obligations to oneself, to the world, and to God, and it elevates labor so that physical power is used proportionately with mental power.Lt 103, 1897, par. 2
Useful manual labor is part of the gospel plan, for God when enshrouded in the pillar of cloud directed that every youth should be taught some line of useful employment.MYP 177.1Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2 Jews both wealthy and poor therefore taught sons and daughters some useful trade in addition to literary instruction.MYP 177.1Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2 The purpose is that when adverse circumstances arise no one will be dependent on others but will be able to earn his own bread and provide for his own necessities.MYP 177.1Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2 Knowing by such training how hard money is to obtain guards against spending means foolishly.Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2 Paul the apostle to the Gentiles illustrates the command because he learned the tentmaker's trade in its higher and lower branches so he could work at the common branches when circumstances demanded, and because tentmaking did not bring returns as quickly as some other lines of business he at times supplied his necessities only by the strictest economy.Ms 97, 1899, par. 1–2
The same principle supports training missionaries in practical skills so they can provide for themselves, serve others, and teach others to work.HL 139.1 Learning a trade is not degrading but helps a person become self-supporting and useful to others.FE 417.2 Those able to work should not avoid their share of life's labor or expect others to provide for them.HL 139.1ST Jan 18, 1916 Education should help people work more effectively and with higher aims, not enable them to escape difficult tasks, and work honors God when people do their part and help those who are weaker or less informed.ST Jan 18, 1916
Refusing to work for a living does wrong and brings evil results upon the refuser.Ms 90, 1899, par. 10–12 That refusal produces laziness at the foundation of many shipwrecked lives, extravagance, and every evil.Ms 90, 1899, par. 10–12 It condemns the sentiment that manual labor is degrading drudgery fit only for others, as seen when white people refuse to wait on themselves or cultivate land and raise food, crowd into cities to live by scheming rather than by patient toil, and make themselves dependent on the labor of Black people in the cotton fields.Ms 90, 1899, par. 10–12 The remedy requires learning and doing useful physical labor, with Black people taught how to cultivate and raise their own food so they are not dependent, and white people taught to do their own work instead of holding to non-working sentiments.Ms 90, 1899, par. 10–12 Patient, joyous, useful labor brings health to the mental, moral, and physical powers, and educating people to engage in it is the highest and most abiding missionary work.Ms 90, 1899, par. 10–12
Family Society and Spiritual Application
Those who refuse to work should not expect to eat, and this rule requires teaching children patient industry and giving them useful work to do.SA 20.2ST Aug 19, 1875Lt 33, 1861, par. 15–16HM Jun 1889 Daughters in particular are to be taught useful labor and self-support rather than encouraged in indolence, and are to follow the calls of duty instead of using inability as an excuse to be fed.ST Aug 19, 1875 Idleness is sin and produces much sin, for it weakens moral strength and leaves the idle open to temptation, while active hands and minds find no time to heed the suggestions of the enemy and idle hands and brains are ready for Satan to control.SA 20.2HM Jun 1889 Children are therefore called to be useful and to deny themselves in order to help others, which yields the most healthful pleasure ever enjoyed.HM Jun 1889 Such labor requires cultivation and proper development of the physical being together with the mental, since physical work does not prevent cultivation of the intellect, and when a person is not zealously engaged in God's work he should labor with his hands, because work is a duty that helps provide for one's family while indolence leaves family members without needed comforts.Lt 33, 1861, par. 15–16HM Jun 1889
People should work to provide for their own needs, and the Waldenses applied this through persevering labor by carefully cultivating even poor mountain land.GC 67.3 They taught their children economy, self-denial, forethought, and care, and regarded such labor as a wholesome discipline for fallen human beings.GC 67.3 One who is able to work should earn the means to support himself rather than depend on others for food and board.Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20Lt 35, 1888, par. 11–12 Neglecting ordinary duties to provide for daily needs makes such a person a burden to fellow believers, so the remedy is to seek employment, overcome idleness, and become self-sustaining.Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20Lt 35, 1888, par. 11–12
The duty to work belongs to spiritual and religious life as well as to earthly affairs.Lt 2, 1889, par. 18–19 Those who refuse to work by sharing the light God has given them are spiritual idlers who should not expect to keep receiving His rich grace as spiritual nourishment or to gain more light.Lt 80, 1894, par. 30–33SBAWP 37.3 Believers are to use their abilities in winning souls to Christ.Lt 80, 1894, par. 30–33 One who has surrendered to God must actively resist sin by looking to Jesus, use every available means, and bring every energy to laboring with God, with faithful service joining physical labor to the effort to grow in spiritual knowledge, since work is neither degrading nor a reason for discontent.Lt 2, 1889, par. 18–19
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
108 sources
The verse commands that an able person who refuses to work when work is to be done has no right to eat and should go without food, for daily toil is the price of daily bread.ST May 30, 1878RH Dec 18, 1900ST Oct 7, 1913RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904 It does not condemn those who cannot work through sickness, disability, helplessness, or lack of employment, but only the one who would not work.ST May 30, 1878ST May 11, 1915ST Oct 7, 1913 It corrects those who abandoned ordinary occupations because they thought Christ's soon return or devotion required it, requiring instead quiet, steady labor so each earns and eats his own bread and does not live idly at others' expense.ST May 30, 1878ST May 18, 1904 It is a command from the Lord Jesus Christ given through both precept and example, illustrated by Paul's night-and-day labor so as not to burden others, and joined with Genesis 3:19 it makes work necessary for earning bread while harmonizing with the fourth commandment.RH Nov 15, 1853RH Jun 25, 1901ST Jun 3, 1908ST Nov 25, 1880 Trusting God for daily bread and praying for provision never excuses waiting passively, but requires honest effort and use of the ability and opportunity God gives.RH Jan 27, 1916RH Mar 21, 1912ST Feb 11, 1886ST Apr 22, 1903ST Jul 22, 1875
Words and Historical Setting
The command was laid down while Paul was still staying with the Thessalonians, with his companions present with him.RH Nov 15, 1853ST Nov 12, 1912 It was directed to those who were able to work but refused, requiring that they should not expect others to provide their food.RH Nov 15, 1853ST Nov 12, 1912
The distinction is between one who would not work and one who cannot work, for refusal and not inability is what forfeits support.ST May 30, 1878ST May 11, 1915ST May 30, 1878 It does not apply to infants, since the command to work does not apply to them, so they may eat without working.ST Apr 10, 1879 It does not condemn those who suffer because they cannot find employment or are forced to accept starvation wages, for it concerns those who choose not to work.ST Jun 28, 1899 Those who are sick, feeble, crippled, disabled, or helpless in any way are to be treated differently from the strong and healthy who are able to earn a living but refuse.ST May 11, 1915ST Oct 7, 1913 Those who cannot pay, even through unwise management, must be shown mercy without imprisonment, oppression, or harsh treatment, while those who refuse to work have no right to food and support.ST May 11, 1915
It corrects believers who had abandoned their ordinary occupations because they thought Christ's soon return meant they should stop work.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878 It also corrects those who abandoned occupation in the mistaken expectation that idleness would foster prayer and devotion, for instead they became disorderly busybodies.ST May 18, 1904 Christians are to work quietly and earn and eat their own bread, and not live idly at others' expense.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878ST May 18, 1904 The requirement addresses people in the church who were living without working, and it remains in force as a Christian rule.ST May 18, 1904
It is a command from the Lord Jesus Christ to work quietly, earn one's own living, and avoid burdening others.ST Jun 3, 1908 It stands among Paul's instructions that establish Christ's teaching through both precept and example, with Paul's example to be followed only in the things in which he followed the Lord. Joined with Genesis 3:19, it presents work as necessary for earning bread, so that refusal to work means a person should not eat.ST Nov 25, 1880 It does not condemn the Sabbath and cannot be used against Sabbath-keeping.RH Jun 10, 1873 The Sabbath is not a day of idleness but a day of abstinence from labor given to active participation in religious duties, to be kept in a spiritual manner in rejoicing, in meditation on the law, and in admiring the workmanship of God, and the verse must harmonize with the fourth commandment, since both existed together during the former dispensation and cannot clash.RH Jun 10, 1873
The duty to work implies a God-given right to the means and opportunity to labor, since God would not command people to do what is impossible by denying them those means, and work is necessary for life.RH Jan 25, 1906 Industry is made a duty under both the law and the gospel, requiring people who are able to work to labor rather than live in idleness.RH May 9, 1912 It declares that those unwilling to work should not expect to eat, presenting work as a divine commission for all people in every age and supporting the value of manual labor and teaching practical work.RH Nov 1, 1906
Duty and Sin of Idleness
Working is a divine commandment and not merely a way to make a living, and daily toil is the price of daily bread in both its physical and spiritual meaning, given to supply strength for service.RH Dec 18, 1900RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904 If anyone who is able to work when there is work to do refuses to work for any reason whatever, he forfeits the right to eat, shall not eat, and deserves to starve.RH Dec 18, 1900RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904 Whoever assists or encourages him in idleness encourages disobedience to God.RH Dec 18, 1900 The more earnestly people serve, the greater their need for food, so those who desire the Living Bread in fullest measure must most earnestly impart spiritual blessing to others.RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904
Idleness is disorderly and sinful, and refusing to work is wrong and contrary to God's word, so one who will not work should not expect to eat.LS 224.1–226.2RH Oct 27, 1868RH Jan 27, 1916GSAM 239.2 Refusing to work after asking God for a livelihood is actual sin, for trusting God to provide daily bread does not mean waiting passively but is shown by working to earn food.RH Jan 27, 1916 Treating work itself as sinful and urging others to abstain from it leads them into error, for manual labor is not a sin.LS 224.1–226.2GSAM 239.2 Refusing to work and refusing to humble oneself to honest toil is iniquity, and that refusal is where sin begins.RH Jul 30, 1867 Idle hands and brains are ready for Satan to control, since active hands and minds find no time to heed temptation while idle hours give opportunity for temptation, and idleness is sin and produces much sin.HM Jun 1889
Instead of honest bodily labor for food and raiment, the idle man seeks them by betting on horse-races, card-playing, and living from the losses of others, and indolence opens the door to other vices, loss of respect, drunkenness, abandonment, and misery in this life.RH Jul 30, 1867 Obedience means earning bread day by day by plowing land and gathering the harvest, rather than neglecting work for amusement, bringing comfort, quiet, confidence, and happiness.RH Jul 30, 1867 A father's industry or idleness is copied by his sons, so the character formed by obeying or disobeying the command to work descends to the children.RH Jul 30, 1867 The command supports the duty to use time productively rather than waste it, with useful reading and study as ways to make spare time beneficial, and it calls children to be useful and to deny themselves to help others, which gives the most healthful pleasure, requiring cultivation of the physical being together with the mental, since physical labor does not prevent cultivation of the intellect.HM Jun 1889RH Oct 27, 1868
Trying to get something for nothing is wrong, and Christians must not live off others.RH Jun 25, 1901 Unwillingness to labor disqualifies a person from being fed, idleness is disorderly, and quiet steady work is required so each person provides his own living and pays full price for what he receives, since borrowing puts one in servitude and honest conduct requires work.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Jan 29, 1867RH Jan 24, 1871 The idea that the world owes anyone a free living is false, and it is exposed by asking what the idler has done to put the world in his debt.ST Oct 7, 1913ST Mar 4, 1889ST Jun 24, 1880 The strong and healthy who are able to earn a living should not be given food while refusing to work, but should work for a living just as others do and be glad for the ability, while those who are sick, feeble, crippled, or helpless in any way are to be treated differently.ST Oct 7, 1913ST Jun 24, 1880 Those able to support themselves but willing to let others carry their share should labor willingly, help themselves and others in need, and not make themselves a burden, being willing to eat what they have earned and wear what they have paid for.RH Jan 29, 1867RH Jan 24, 1871
Useful, regular work is the duty, while work must remain subordinate to service to God.ST Nov 4, 1886 The principle applies to using the mind for a useful purpose as well as working with the hands to provide life's necessities, and refusing to work makes a person a sluggard. Time is a trust from God to be used in honest industry after worship, prayer, self-examination, Bible reading, and needed rest, even when available work pays little, and wasting time by refusing modest wages is a sin against God and a disgrace.RH Aug 24, 1869 Honest work is respectable whatever its kind, and one willing to take available hard labor is more honorable than one who rejects it and relies on others' help, for avoiding useful work for pride, fashion, or an easier life is condemned.ST May 15, 1884 Steady, cheerful work and contentment with an ordinary livelihood are praised, rather than abandoning useful labor for wealth and ease which can destroy those who give up active pursuits.RH Mar 19, 1861
Work is necessary for accomplishing things, and the command applies to human labor as well as spiritual service, as when people plant, reap, teach, preach, or help save a soul.ST Jul 30, 1894 Faithful, purposeful work is more fulfilling than idleness or pleasure sought merely to pass time, and success requires effort.ST Jul 8, 1897ST Nov 25, 1880ST Feb 15, 1899 Hard work in this sinful world is a blessing that gives good appetite and healthful bodies, bringing increase, profit, and life to the righteous, and honest toil keeps people from being gossips and busybodies.ST Nov 25, 1903 Labor is noble and holy, serving as worship and giving purpose, while idleness brings despair.ST Nov 25, 1903ST Feb 15, 1899 Toil is the rule of life and idleness does not provide needs, so those who refuse to work can expect hardship, the man not working is having a hard time, and the Bible promises no food to the loafer.ST Nov 25, 1880ST Feb 15, 1899 This applies to the idle person who waits for something to happen instead of working, who relies on others and eats their bread instead of earning his own, imposing losses and burdens on those who trust and support him and making himself a burden instead of a help.ST Jul 8, 1897RH Jan 24, 1871
Paul's Example and Ministers
Paul's night-and-day tent-making illustrates the command not to eat without working, for he labored hard even at night so as not to be a burden or be chargeable to anyone.ST May 30, 1878RH Nov 15, 1853RH Jun 25, 1901 His avoidance of debt and obligation, on the principle that borrowing puts one in servitude, is to be copied, with each person working quietly and steadily to provide his own living and pay full price for what is received rather than living off others or trying to get something for nothing.RH Nov 15, 1853RH Jun 25, 1901 His work could provide for himself and others while also giving opportunities to reach people.RH Oct 3, 1912ST May 30, 1878 Skill in ordinary crafts is a gift from God to be honored in everyday labor, and manual work does not weaken Christian ministry.RH Oct 3, 1912
Although Paul had the right to support as a minister, he made his labor an example for others.ST May 30, 1878 Physical labor remains a duty from which ministers are not excused by preaching, with every power to be used in balance rather than leaving the muscles inactive while the brain bears too much burden, and work exercises and strengthens the body.RH Mar 6, 1900 Jesus' faithful work to earn life's necessities provides the same example, and work is both commanded by God and encouraged by the examples of Christ and Paul.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Nov 29, 1899
The rule does not prevent support for ministers called to preach, for the church should help provide suitable food and clothing for them and their families while they serve.RH Aug 19, 1852 Traveling preachers are expected to labor actively and sustain themselves rather than depend on church funds.RH Jun 18, 1861 A minister should work with his hands when he has nothing else to do rather than show too little willingness to work, and members including church leaders are expected to work rather than live idly.RH Sep 21, 1905RH Oct 13, 1859
Money raised by systematic benevolence is for advancing the cause of the third angel's message, not for bestowal on the poor in the church.RH Jan 7, 1862 Present hunger or nakedness is to be relieved, but beyond this there is no duty to support people who have strength to labor or means of a living, and in nine cases out of ten continued help to them proves an injury.RH Jan 7, 1862 Brethren must know how means are to be expended before handing it out, be familiar with preachers and know their circumstances, wants, and how money is appropriated, and withhold their hands if means thus raised are appropriated to other objects.RH Jan 7, 1862
Charity and Church Discipline
Apostolic sharing of possessions was to supply need, not to indulge idleness.RH Feb 20, 1855RH Nov 20, 1856 Carried out together with withdrawing from every disorderly brother, following the apostles' example of laboring night and day so as not to be chargeable, commanding busybodies to work with quietness and eat their own bread, and noting and admonishing the disobedient as a brother, it is the remedy for trials with the slothful and impostors when believers share goods.RH Feb 20, 1855RH Nov 20, 1856 It keeps the church from being burdened with drones and impostors while the needy are cared for, burdens are borne equally, and means are left to sustain the cause of truth.RH Feb 20, 1855RH Nov 20, 1856
Charitable gifts must not be used to sustain idleness, and those unwilling to work are not to be supported with food or other means but called to labor quietly and provide for themselves.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878RH Aug 19, 1852 Withholding charity from the able but unwilling is intended to move them to take up their duties and to prevent disorder and harmful idleness.ST May 30, 1878ST May 30, 1878 Hunger can awaken the idle to return to useful work and responsible living.ST Nov 14, 1878 Taking the command to heart guards against indigence more effectively than laws that foster slothful dependence on generosity.
Need caused by sloth must be distinguished from genuine distress and from people who are truly unfortunate.ST Jan 11, 1905ST Oct 7, 1913RH Jan 12, 1869 Help may be given to relieve immediate hardship, but continuing to support the indolent diverts aid from those truly in need and is wrong.RH Jan 12, 1869 Those who cannot pay, even through unwise management, must be shown mercy without imprisonment, oppression, or harsh treatment, but those who refuse to work have no right to food and support.ST May 11, 1915 Christians may share goods when circumstances demand it, but that prospect must not excuse remaining idle. Those who refuse counsel should not expect help from the church, and poverty may result from poor management and sloth.ST Sep 16, 1889
Hospitality among believers must not be abused by idleness, for God has no place for drones.RH Jan 10, 1907 When work has not been requested, the needy should be offered work, such as chores on a farm, and offering a meal in exchange for reasonable work is consistent with the command.ST Jan 11, 1905ST Jan 11, 1905 This applies to idle beggars and able-bodied tramps who make begging a business, distinguished from genuine need.ST Jan 11, 1905ST Oct 7, 1913ST Jan 11, 1905 Refusing to provide for one who will not work is not rejection beyond Christian help; it avoids supporting an idle, profligate life and may bring the person to a right mind.ST Jan 11, 1905 A child who avoids ordinary household tasks learns responsibility when the expected benefit is withheld until he works, as when kindling must be carried before food is given.RH Oct 7, 1915RH Dec 3, 1908
The poor are to be helped in ways that encourage work and self-support rather than dependence, for when a person can get by without labor because others do the work, he will not labor, so help should enable people to help themselves.RH Jul 14, 1863 Those able should earn their own food rather than depend on alms, since honest labor even for bare necessities preserves independence and gives a better example to children than begging.RH Jan 6, 1863 Providing work is the best charity because it meets need while preserving self-respect and manhood.RH Jul 14, 1863RH Jan 6, 1863 Famine relief upholds this by providing paid work to sustain families, and missions should teach self-reliance rather than be treated as responsible for those who will not seek work.RH Sep 11, 1900ST Oct 17, 1900 Paying poor women to make garments lets them earn bread rather than fostering dependence, and people should do their utmost before asking help.ST Oct 13, 1881ST Nov 18, 1880
The rule applies spiritually to church life: members who take no part in the church's work and show no spiritual activity are fruitless, dead professors and need not be retained on the roll after patient care has failed, but be removed from roll and fellowship if restoration efforts fail.ST Apr 16, 1885ST Jul 16, 1885 Converts should be trained for active service rather than left spiritually inactive, since the discipline of work teaches service.ST Aug 14, 1884 Contributing money does not excuse disorderly conduct or entitle people to disregard worship and fellowship while expecting toleration.ST Aug 7, 1879 Forgiving as God forgives lessens no duty to obey, and does not forbid requiring what is justly due.ST May 11, 1915
Those who disobey are to be admonished as brothers, not treated as enemies, but believers are to take note of them and avoid keeping company with them.ST Jan 11, 1905
Trusting God for Daily Bread
Trusting God to provide daily bread does not mean waiting passively, and prayer for daily needs must be joined with honest effort to earn a living.RH Jan 27, 1916RH Mar 21, 1912ST Feb 11, 1886ST Jun 26, 1884 Refusing to work after asking God for a livelihood is actual sin, and one who is able but unwilling to work should not expect to eat or to have others provide food.RH Jan 27, 1916RH Mar 21, 1912ST Feb 11, 1886ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jun 26, 1884 God provides through the ability and opportunity to work, so people are to work as part of the means through which he supplies need, using what he gives rather than expecting a miracle while ordinary provision is possible.RH Mar 21, 1912ST Feb 11, 1886 Trust in his care and protection does not replace prudent means, justify doing nothing, or excuse idleness and laziness; Christians are to be diligent and industrious.ST Feb 11, 1886ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jun 26, 1884
God provides food but people must work to gather it, for as he feeds birds without carrying food to their nests, so people must work to obtain their food.ST Apr 22, 1903ST Jul 22, 1875 Birds do not sow, reap, or store, yet they gather what is provided and do not suffer, while people with greater faculties and power are to cooperate with God in sowing, reaping, and storing.ST Apr 22, 1903 Refusal to plow and labor causes poverty, want, hunger, and begging.ST Apr 22, 1903 Trusting the Lord, doing good, and laboring diligently brings food, raiment, and contentment, for no good thing is withheld from those who walk uprightly.ST Apr 22, 1903
Daily toil is the price of daily bread, and one who refuses to work forfeits the right to eat and receive food.RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904 This covers the prayer for daily bread in both its physical and spiritual meaning, with equal dependence on God for both kinds of food.RH Nov 3, 1904 Daily bread in both senses is given to provide strength for service.RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904 The more earnestly people serve, the greater their need for food, so those who seek the Living Bread in fullest measure should most earnestly share spiritual blessing with others.RH Aug 8, 1907RH Nov 3, 1904
Work is necessary for accomplishing things, and the command applies to human labor as well as spiritual service, for people work with God when they plant, reap, teach, preach, or help save a soul.ST Jul 30, 1894 The Christian life is active, especially in spiritual work, as illustrated by labor with the hands.ST Mar 20, 1893 After receiving the feast of the word, believers are to work.RH May 26, 1868 Work is the proper use of food's strength and a practical fruit of genuine faith, since faith works through love and produces works revealing Christ's presence, so justification by faith is no excuse for idleness or sin.RH May 18, 1905 Refusing to work is therefore sufficient reason to withhold food.ST Mar 20, 1893RH May 18, 1905
The command affirms that people must work, while allowing that they may also play.ST It does not make recreation wrong.ST Restorative recreation can renew body, mind, and spirit, whereas pleasure that inflames evil passions is sinful.ST
Home and Training Children
In the home every member is to take interest in household work, and children are to be taught early to share duties suited to their ability and to be responsible for them.RH Oct 27, 1863RH Aug 17, 1911RH Oct 31, 1912 Neglect of home duties in order to rely on others for a living violates the rule that one able but unwilling to work should not eat.RH Oct 27, 1863RH Aug 17, 1911RH Oct 31, 1912 Parents are to model industry and help children carry out regular tasks, giving them useful work suited to age and strength, teaching them to do it well, and helping them learn to enjoy it.RH Oct 31, 1912RH Aug 27, 1914 Daughters are to be taught useful labor and self-support rather than encouraged in indolence, and to follow the calls of duty.ST Aug 19, 1875 Idleness endangers children and can make them a harmful influence on others.RH Aug 27, 1914
The command warns against idleness and requires teaching children useful work or a trade.ST Feb 19, 1885 A boy is to earn extra spending money or go without it, for requiring effort rather than supplying everything through wealth prevents idleness and spoiled conduct.ST Feb 19, 1885 Where machinery has displaced much manual labor, lack of education can leave people unable to earn even a bare living, so necessity drives children toward schooling.ST Nov 7, 1892 Education is to help people work more effectively and with higher aims, not to enable escape from difficult tasks, and work honors God when each does his part and helps those weaker or less informed.ST Jan 18, 1916
Idleness is sin and produces much sin, because active hands and minds find no time to heed temptation while idle hands and brains are ready for Satan to control.HM Jun 1889ST Jun 23, 1914 Idle hours give Satan opportunity to approach and tempt.HM Jun 1889ST Jun 23, 1914 Children are called to be useful and to deny themselves to help others, which gives the most healthful pleasure.HM Jun 1889 This requires cultivation and proper development of the physical being together with the mental, and physical labor does not prevent cultivation of the intellect.HM Jun 1889
Pupils are to support themselves through useful labor such as farming or a trade, and teachers too may work with their hands.RH Apr 6, 1905RH Mar 18, 1915 Work is not degrading, and allowing children to grow up without learning useful labor is sinful, for practical knowledge is essential even for those preparing for holy service.RH Mar 18, 1915 Teachers and students earning support through farm work learn self-reliance and perseverance through difficulty.RH Apr 6, 1905RH Mar 18, 1915 Converts and children are to be taught that labor is honorable and idleness disgraceful.RH Jan 9, 1913 Doing one's own work benefits both the worker and those helped, strengthening the body and clearing the mind.RH Jan 9, 1913
Health, Work and Society
Work supports a healthy appetite and helps the body make use of the food it needs, while idleness weakens the body and leads to decay.ST Nov 7, 1900 The body itself proves the justice of the rule by denying a healthy appetite to the one who does not work.ST May 8, 1901 Exercise quickens the heart and blood flow, wears away the old man, stirs every eliminating organ to carry off waste, brings fresh color to the cheeks, brings every bodily function into more normal condition, and increases the capacity to receive joy even in this sin-cursed earth, and where a man is too feeble to exercise himself the strong should bear his infirmity by giving massage and other forms of passive exercise.ST May 8, 1901 Physical activity stimulates the stomach and bowels to function, and hard outdoor work gives a relish for simple food, whereas luxury, confinement, and inactivity take appetite away.RH Jul 18, 1907 How much is eaten should correspond to how much is worked, so that those who do little should eat little.ST Sep 12, 1916RH Jul 14, 1863
With less outdoor labor and more sedentary city or office life, the appetite for simple foods naturally lessens and should not be forced with rich, highly seasoned dishes, since that leads to indigestion and disease.ST Sep 12, 1916 One who stops working should not keep the eating habits formed during hard work.RH Jul 14, 1863 Food should be reduced in proportion to lost sleep, because sleep renews the body's power to digest and receive nourishment, while overeating amid nervous strain further disrupts sleep, and when sleep is completely absent fasting is recommended until sleep returns.RH Dec 8, 1863
Joining a strike and stopping work when willing and able is condemned, along with unions that compel men to stop, hinder others from working, and stigmatize honest men who obey God by working whenever they can find work.RH Dec 18, 1900 If a man refuses to work when able and there is work to do, for any reason whatever, he shall not eat and deserves to starve, and whoever assists or encourages him in idleness encourages disobedience to God.RH Dec 18, 1900 The same rule is applied to laborers who would not work even when harvest fields needed workers while Japanese immigrants were willing to toil, with preventing them from working violating this basic law of God.ST Apr 19, 1910 It is applied to those who evade work and seek a living without useful service, whose unwillingness economic arrangements cannot cure because it is a fault of character that only God can change.ST Apr 9, 1912
It opposes schemes that would take others' accumulated property to support people in chosen idleness, since one able to work should not expect others to provide food when refusing to work.RH Sep 17, 1901 It is echoed in the demand that everyone labor and that those who refuse be made to go without food.ST Jan 27, 1914 It is applied to convicts, requiring that they do enough work to cover the expense they cause rather than be kept idle and supported through taxes.ST Aug 24, 1888
Work is required and idleness has no place in a follower of Christ's service, with work as a blessing that earns wages and Christ's help able to make even a hard task easier.ST People should recognize their responsibilities and calling and work rather than live as a burden on others.RH Apr 1, 1915 Idleness is forbidden and labor and industry are encouraged, for idleness is inconsistent with Christian life and service.RH Oct 4, 1864ST Mar 8, 1883 Expecting the public to support someone merely because he claims to be holy is warned against, since Christians are to earn their living and not expect others to provide food while unwilling to work.
After the fall, toil in making a living became a privilege and an honor.RH Dec 25, 1913 Work is useful and honorable, a way to worship God, and a means to care for one's family even when pay is small. Believers should work with their own hands and not be idle, providing for themselves through honest labor, a duty that does not require life insurance or another similar scheme.ST Aug 12, 1897
Sources