Genesis 27:35
And he said, Thy brother came with subtilty, and hath taken away thy blessing.
Translations
And he said, Your brother came with subtlety, and has taken away your blessing.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And he said, Thy brother came with subtilty, and hath taken away thy blessing.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said, Thy brother came with guile, and hath taken away thy blessing.
and he saith, 'Thy brother hath come with subtilty, and taketh thy blessing.'
And he said, Thy brother came with subtilty, and has taken away thy blessing.
Then he said, Thy brother came in with deceit,—and took away thy blessing.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
But Isaac replied, “ Your brother came deceitfully and took your blessing.”
He said, “ Your brother came with deceit, and has taken away your blessing.”
And he said, Your brother came with deceit, and took away your blessing.
Who answered, Thy brother came with subtiltie, and hath taken away thy blessing.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And he said: Thy brother came deceitfully and got thy blessing.
Cross-references
- Genesis 25:29-34
And Jacob sod pottage: and Esau came from the field, and he was faint:
Esau had sold his birthright to Jacob for food before Jacob took the blessing.
- Hebrews 12:16-17
Lest there be any fornicator, or profane person, as Esau, who for one morsel of meat sold his birthright.
Esau sold his birthright and later could not regain the blessing.
- Genesis 32:24-30
And Jacob was left alone; and there wrestled a man with him until the breaking of the day.
Jacob wrestles in prayer before facing Esau.
- Genesis 28:13-15
And, behold, the LORD stood above it, and said, I am the LORD God of Abraham thy father, and the God of Isaac: the land whereon thou liest, to thee will I give it, and to thy seed;
God renews the promised blessing to Jacob and promises to guide and keep him.
- Genesis 25:23
And the LORD said unto her, Two nations are in thy womb, and two manner of people shall be separated from thy bowels; and the one people shall be stronger than the other people; and the elder shall serve the younger.
God foretold that the elder would serve the younger.
- Genesis 29:25
And it came to pass, that in the morning, behold, it was Leah: and he said to Laban, What is this thou hast done unto me? did not I serve with thee for Rachel? wherefore then hast thou beguiled me?
Laban deceives Jacob in turn.
- Genesis 27:6-17
And Rebekah spake unto Jacob her son, saying, Behold, I heard thy father speak unto Esau thy brother, saying,
Rebekah directs Jacob in a deceptive plan to obtain Isaac’s blessing.
- Genesis 27:18-29
And he came unto his father, and said, My father: and he said, Here am I; who art thou, my son?
Jacob deceives Isaac and receives the blessing.
- Genesis 27:41
And Esau hated Jacob because of the blessing wherewith his father blessed him: and Esau said in his heart, The days of mourning for my father are at hand; then will I slay my brother Jacob.
Esau hates Jacob over the blessing and plans to kill him.
- Malachi 1:2-3
I have loved you, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, Wherein hast thou loved us? Was not Esau Jacob’s brother? saith the LORD: yet I loved Jacob,
Jacob and Esau illustrate differing divine favor and inheritance.
- Hebrews 12:16
Lest there be any fornicator, or profane person, as Esau, who for one morsel of meat sold his birthright.
Esau is profane for trading his birthright for food.
- Hosea 12:3-4
He took his brother by the heel in the womb, and by his strength he had power with God:
Describes Jacob wrestling and prevailing with God.
- Genesis 25:28
And Isaac loved Esau, because he did eat of his venison: but Rebekah loved Jacob.
Explains Isaac’s love for Esau.
- Hebrews 11:20
By faith Isaac blessed Jacob and Esau concerning things to come.
Isaac’s blessing of Jacob and Esau is described as an act of faith.
- Romans 9:13
As it is written, Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I hated.
Contrasts God’s favor toward Jacob with Esau’s.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
16 sources
Jacob took by deception and fraud the blessing his father meant for Esau as the firstborn.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887CH 110.2 Esau had already rashly sold his birthright to Jacob for food, despising its value and controlled by appetite.ST Feb 24, 1887CH 110.21SP 108.1–2 The birthright and blessing were already Jacob's by God's promise that the elder would serve the younger, and he and Rebekah should have trusted God to fulfill it in His own way and time instead of taking a wrong course through lack of faith.SG3 115.1ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887 Jacob's deceit reacted upon him in retribution through grief, fear, flight, twenty years of exile in which he was himself defrauded, and trouble from his own sons, until he repented and God heard his prayer and preserved him.ST Feb 24, 1887ED 147.1–2GC88 620.1–3ST Jul 31, 1884GC 619.2–620.1 Esau's bitter sorrow came too late to undo his loss, warning that those who trade their heavenly heirship for selfish pleasure and appetite will find no opportunity for repentance to reverse the choice in the day of God, though they seek it with tears.CH 110.21SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1
How the Blessing Was Taken
Thy brother came with subtilty describes how Jacob obtained from Isaac by deceiving him the blessing Isaac intended for Esau as the firstborn.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1884GC88 616.1–21SP 122.3 It was taken by deception and fraud, and Isaac himself recognized that deceit as the means by which Esau lost the blessing.ST Feb 24, 1887CH 110.2ST Jul 31, 1884GC88 616.1–2 Esau had already rashly sold his birthright to Jacob with a solemn oath.ST Feb 24, 18871SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1 He did so as one reckless and controlled by appetite, despising its value for food.CH 110.21SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1 The blessing that Jacob received would have belonged to Esau himself had he not so sold it.ST Feb 24, 18871SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1
The birthright and its blessing were already Jacob's by God's promise that the elder would serve the younger.SG3 115.1ST Feb 24, 1887ED 147.1–2ST Jul 31, 1884 Rebekah and Jacob should not have used a wrong course to bring about God's purposes, but should have trusted God to fulfill His promise and purpose in His own way and time.SG3 115.1ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887ED 147.1–2ST Jul 31, 1884 Their resort to deceit instead of waiting for fulfillment in due time showed lack of faith.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1884 The prosperity of the blessing depended on God and on a person's conduct, not merely on firstborn privilege.SG3 115.1 Esau would have received blessing or faced adversity according to his actions, and Jacob could have received God's blessing even without the privileges usually given to the firstborn.SG3 115.1
Consequences, Repentance, and Warning
The wrong of taking the blessing by deception reacted upon Jacob in retribution, bringing sin and grief, fear of Esau's rage and revenge, painful self-reproach and a troubled conscience, hatred from his brother, flight from his father's house, separation from his mother, and exile.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1884GC88 616.1–2ST Nov 20, 1879 He regarded his long exile as the consequence of his own conduct, and he feared that his rash act had cost him the blessing God intended for him.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Nov 20, 1879 That retribution included twenty years of exile in which he himself was wronged and defrauded until he was forced to flee for safety.ED 147.1–2 There was also a second harvest when the evils of his own character cropped out in his sons, proving that what a person does is the fruit of what he is.ED 147.1–2
Though wroth with Jacob's covetous iniquity, God does not contend forever nor remain always wroth.ED 147.1–2 After seeing his ways He promises to heal him and to lead him, to restore comforts to him and to his mourners, and to give peace to him that is far off and to him that is near.ED 147.1–2 The fraud by which the blessing was obtained, connected with the earlier fraud by which the birthright was obtained, was sin that had to be repented of.GC88 620.1–3GC 619.2–620.14SP 437.21SP 122.3 He repented of that fraud before his night of wrestling for deliverance, and because he had repented God heard his prayer and mercifully preserved his life and saved him.GC88 620.1–3GC 619.2–620.14SP 437.21SP 122.3
God does not excuse or tolerate evil, and concealed, unconfessed sin leaves people without confidence to seek deliverance.GC88 620.1–3 Sins must be repented of beforehand and blotted out in order to have confidence with God in the time of trouble, when fear and anguish would otherwise overwhelm faith and cut off the power to plead for deliverance.GC 619.2–620.1 God's people will have no concealed sins in that time because their sins have already gone before them to judgment.4SP 437.2 Esau was greatly distressed and regretted his rash act when he learned of his loss, but his sorrow came too late to undo it or remedy it, and bitter repentance and great sacrifice could not restore what he had lost.CH 110.21SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1 His loss warns that the unrighteous who count the redemption purchased by Christ of little value, and who trade their heirship to heaven for selfish pleasure and gratification, perishable treasures, unhealthy appetite, corrupt passions and hurtful lusts, will find in the day of God no place or opportunity for repentance to reverse the choice, although they seek it carefully and with tears.1SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879SG3 116.1–117.1 The same kind of subtilty and deception by which the brother's blessing was taken is practiced by those standing in high places of trust through secret working, deceptive reasoning, partiality and hypocrisy, turning away from obeying God's Word.Lt 7, 1896, par. 1–4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
43 sources
Isaac was telling Esau that Jacob had come in disguise while Esau was hunting in the field and had taken the firstborn blessing Isaac intended for Esau, because Isaac's dim sight kept him from knowing his own sons.ST Sep 22, 1898ST Jul 31, 1901ST Jan 3, 1911ST Jan 3, 1911ST Sep 22, 1898
God had already promised that the elder would serve the younger and that Jacob would inherit the blessing of Abraham and Isaac, yet Rebekah and Jacob tried to secure by human scheming what God had promised, showing lack of faith that God could fulfill His purpose in His own way and time.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1901ST
The act was trickery, fraud and sin in which Jacob lived out the name supplanter, yet he valued God's promise and blessing above everything else, unlike Esau who despised and sold his birthright for temporary appeasement of appetite.ST May 17, 1910ST Jan 14, 1913ST Feb 28, 1906ST Apr 1, 1897ST Oct 4, 1905
The deceit enraged Esau so that he resolved to kill Jacob, forcing Jacob to flee to distant Mesopotamia for many long years in separation from his mother, where he himself suffered deceit and cruel treatment in retribution for his own overreaching.ST Jul 31, 1901ST Jan 3, 1911ST Jan 9, 1912ST Jan 9, 1912
Esau could not regain by tears or venison what he had deliberately sold, for after long space for repentance his crying was regret for personal loss with no godly sorrow for despising his birthright.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Feb 23, 1915ST Mar 31, 1881RH May 15, 1866RH Jun 10, 1902
His case warns that those who trade their heavenly and eternal inheritance for selfish and worldly pleasure will find no opportunity to reverse that choice, so when the Lord promises a thing believers should quietly wait on Him instead of becoming impatient with human schemes.ST Apr 24, 1879ST Jul 31, 1901RH May 15, 1866
Words and Setting
Isaac was telling Esau that Jacob had come with deception and taken away the blessing he had intended for Esau.ST Sep 22, 1898ST Jan 3, 1911ST Mar 30, 1888ST Sep 22, 1898 Jacob obtained by fraud the place intended for Esau as the firstborn, and this left Esau in a secondary place and led to Jacob fleeing home because of his brother's hatred.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Oct 1, 1902 Esau afterward sought to inherit the blessing with tears but was rejected, for he could not recover what he had deliberately sold because he could not change the transaction.ST Mar 30, 1888 Jacob had come to Isaac disguised as Esau and received the blessing intended for his brother.ST Sep 22, 1898
Jacob got his father Isaac's blessing by deception while Esau was hunting in the fields.ST Jul 31, 1901 His dim sight kept him from knowing his own sons, so he blessed Jacob and passed Esau.ST Sep 22, 1898RH Nov 4, 1858 That ignorance and forgetfulness in the creature, estranging love and knowledge until a father does not know his own sons, stands in contrast to the Lord, who knows who are His and whose eye is everywhere and knows all things, never darkened by time, place, speech, or apparel but always over them.RH Nov 4, 1858
The blessing was bound up with the birthright of the firstborn.RH May 30, 1912 In this family that birthright included a double share of the family property, authority in the family, and the priesthood, and it also involved the line through which Christ would come and, in a measure, the salvation of the human race.ST May 17, 1910 Jacob received the blessing associated with the firstborn while Esau said his brother had taken it from him by deceit.RH May 30, 1912
Isaac's words of blessing were prophetic.ST Sep 22, 1898 He blessed Jacob in God's name, in keeping with his spiritual desire, while his words to Esau reflected a carnal desire.ST Sep 22, 1898 Jacob's success by this wrong course taken with Rebekah did not remove Esau's opportunity to seek God's blessing.ST Sep 22, 1898
The verse belongs to the continuing story of Abraham and his family, showing the gradual development of faith in Abraham's line and the defects of Isaac and his two sons.ST Jan 6, 1909 It stands on the way to Jacob's victory when he became Israel, prevailer with God.ST Jan 6, 1909 It belongs to the early patriarchal age with Abraham and Ishmael, Isaac in the fields at eventide, Rebekah at the well, Esau with face reddened by desert sun-heat, and Joseph's splendid funeral procession, set in a half-peopled world of flocks, pastoral rest, and plain human existence preserved within the Old Testament as part of the spectacle of human history.RH Feb 22, 1912
Promise and Human Scheming
God had already promised that the elder would serve the younger, that Jacob would be a prince in Israel and inherit the blessing given to Abraham and Isaac, yet Isaac was about to give that blessing to Esau while Esau was hunting in the fields.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1901 Rebekah urged Jacob to deceive his father, and his mother's influence led him into the wrongdoing.ST Jul 31, 1901ST Apr 12, 1883 The family pursued the promised inheritance in material terms, with favoritism and division, and without fully appreciating its spiritual blessings.ST Jan 14, 1913
Rebekah and Jacob tried to secure by human schemes what God had promised, because they lacked faith that God could fulfill His promises without their help.ST Jul 31, 1901ST They should have trusted God to fulfill His purpose in His own way and time, and left the Lord alone so the blessing would have come to Jacob just as God promised.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1901 The promise would have been fulfilled in due time if Jacob had waited instead of trying to secure it himself.ST Jul 31, 1884 Human impatience and ingenuity to help God fulfill His promise only bring trouble, the same lack of faith first seen in Abraham.ST Jul 31, 1901ST
The act was trickery, fraud, duplicity, deception, disobedience, transgression and sin peculiarly abhorrent to God.ST Feb 28, 1906RH Mar 30, 1869 In it Jacob acted out the meaning of his name supplanter, showing overreaching, mercenary, covetous character.ST Jan 14, 1913ST Apr 1, 1897 He first took advantage of Esau's appetite to purchase the birthright and then obtained by fraud the father's blessing designed for his brother.ST Apr 1, 1897 At the time Jacob was not yet converted but longed to know and do God's will and valued God's promise and blessing and the birthright above everything else.ST May 17, 1910ST Oct 4, 1905 Esau by contrast was a worldly man willing to trade his birthright for food and for temporary appetite and advantage.ST May 17, 1910ST Oct 4, 1905 God regarded Jacob's desire and repentance though He could not approve the deceptive method.ST Oct 4, 1905
Those who held the other reading taught that Jacob's evil act in obtaining Isaac's blessing through deceit was driven by desire for temporal advantage rather than spiritual ends.ST Oct 4, 1905
Consequences for Jacob
The taking of the blessing by deception enraged Esau, who resolved to kill Jacob and seek revenge, and that hatred forced Jacob to flee from home and from Canaan to the distant country of Rebekah's father's people in Mesopotamia, where he remained many long years.ST Jul 31, 1901ST Jan 3, 1911ST Oct 4, 1905 His flight followed both wrongs, first taking advantage of Esau's hunger to obtain the birthright and then taking the blessing intended for the firstborn, which left Esau in a secondary place.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Oct 4, 1905 That treachery in taking away the blessing by deceit was a return to the country from which God had called Abraham out, which Abraham would not reenter nor let Isaac reenter.
The scheming brought lifelong separation of mother and son, with Rebekah wholly separated from the son who comforted her, bringing grief, fear, and family trouble through lack of faith that God could fulfill His promises without their help.ST Feb 24, 1887ST Jul 31, 1901STRH Jul 4, 1865 Although the deception succeeded in obtaining the blessing, it brought hatred and flight from home, with more than twenty years before reconciliation and lasting enmity between their descendants.ST Oct 1, 1902 Jacob the supplanter therefore needed a complete change of heart to be placed among the Israel of God, and his prolonged struggle with the angel later brought his sin sharply before him and led him to deep humility.STRH Jul 4, 1865
God's providence may seem slow, but it brings retribution sooner or later, and after overreaching and supplanting others Jacob himself encountered overreaching.ST Jan 9, 1912ST Jan 9, 1912 His unbrotherly, wicked deceit toward his brother and father brought sorrow, calamity, and flight, and he later suffered similar deceit and cruel treatment from Laban, illustrating the return of evil deeds upon the doer.RH Apr 26, 1870ST Mar 31, 1881ST Jul 27, 1915 He was even favored with a view of the direful effect of his deception upon his posterity to the latest generation, showing how as centuries passed they would become more and more deceitful and covetous and wicked until the end.RH Oct 4, 1864
The deceit brought sin, guilt, sorrow, anxiety, and fear of Esau's rage, driving Jacob into exile hated by Esau and painfully aware of guilt.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Oct 4, 1905 He recognized the wrongdoing as a departure from integrity and a stain of sin that troubled his conscience, and he regarded his long exile as the consequence of his own conduct.ST Nov 20, 1879 He feared that his rash act had cost him the blessing God intended for him, since the promise would have been fulfilled in due time if he had waited instead of trying to secure it himself, and in another teaching the evil act was driven by desire for temporal advantage rather than spiritual ends.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Oct 4, 1905
God did not erase or ignore that past but worked from it under providence, so that what followed was shaped by what had come before and set in motion his flight and the evils of his life.RH Apr 17, 1900 Long-continued afflictions came upon him as God's chastisement for sin, working deep and thorough repentance in him, and when he went down into Egypt it was closed up forever and the rod was withdrawn, his sojourn there being the time appointed for his ripening for the kingdom of God with his life ending in heavenly brightness.ST Jul 21, 1881 His later experience at the brook Jabbok made him one who prevailed with God and men as Israel, standing on the way to Jacob's victory in the gradual development of faith in Abraham's line despite the defects of Isaac and his two sons.ST Jan 6, 1909RH Apr 17, 1900RH Jul 4, 1865
Though Jacob repented and God accepted his repentance and gave him assurance of eternal life, God left him to suffer the bitter consequences in this life.RH Mar 30, 1869 Even with clearer sight of the heinousness of taking away the blessing, the sin could not have been put away had he not repented of it previously.RH Oct 4, 1864 His later prayer for deliverance from Esau was heard and his life preserved because he had repented, showing that concealed, unconfessed sin would leave a person without confidence to plead for deliverance in the time of trouble, so God's people must confess their sins now that they may be blotted out before that crisis.RH Nov 14, 1912
Esau's Loss and Warning
Esau understood that the blessing had been taken from him and was gone from his reach.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Mar 31, 1881 No bringing of savory venison afterward could regain it, and bitter tears could not reverse what had been settled.ST Mar 31, 1881RH May 15, 1866 He could not recover what he had deliberately sold, because the transaction could not be changed.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Mar 31, 1881 The birthright and blessing meant controlling influence in the family and succession to the spiritual blessings through Abraham by which all nations were to be blessed.RH Jun 10, 1902 Those honors Esau discredited and despised, bartering them to selfishly take advantage of his hunger for temporary appeasement of base appetite.ST Oct 4, 1905RH Jun 10, 1902 Jacob's taking advantage of that hunger to obtain the birthright, followed by obtaining the blessing, were the two wrongs that moved Esau to seek revenge.ST Oct 4, 1905
More than forty years of space for repentance was left to Esau unimproved, in which he could have realized and repudiated his sale of the birthright.RH Jun 10, 1902 His strong crying and tears afterward were regret for the blessing selfishly considered as personal loss, with no godly sorrow for despising his birthright, confirming his indifference.RH Jun 10, 1902 Hebrews 12:14-17 connects this loss with the earlier sale and says that when he later sought the blessing with tears he was rejected.ST Feb 23, 1915 That rejection concerned his father's decision, not a change of mind by Esau himself.ST Feb 23, 1915
His distress and regret came too late to undo his rash choice, for it was too late to undo what he had done.ST Apr 24, 1879RH May 15, 1866 In this he warns that people who trade their inheritance in heaven and their eternal birthright for selfish pleasure and worldly pleasure will find no opportunity to reverse that choice in the day of God.ST Apr 24, 1879RH May 15, 1866 One who surrenders a lasting inheritance for a short-lived desire, even for food, may later be unable to regain it even when seeking it with tears.RH May 15, 1866RH Mar 20, 1879 So the story is applied as a warning that some who turn away from God may lose the hope of eternal life beyond recovery.RH Mar 20, 1879 The contrast between Jacob being loved and Esau being hated describes God's choosing and granting greater privileges to Jacob, rather than assigning Esau to eternal condemnation.ST Feb 23, 1915
Doctrine and Practical Lessons
Jacob's taking of his brother's blessing by an unrighteous course was driven by coveting his brother's birthright and blessing, and that covetousness was idolatry breaking the first and second commandments, which proves the law against coveting was already in force before Moses. Isaac's dim sight that led him to bless Jacob and pass by Esau is an example of how ignorance and forgetfulness in the creature can estrange love and knowledge, so that a father does not know his own sons.RH Nov 4, 1858 It stands in contrast to the Lord, who knows who are His and whose eye is always over them, never darkened by time, place, speech, or apparel, for His eye is everywhere and He knows all things.RH Nov 4, 1858
Jacob in taking the blessing by fraud and deceit, having already acquired the birthright by selfishly taking advantage of his brother's need, represents a religious class who desire the Lord's blessing and try to obtain it by any means, by might or right, by hook or crook, by principle or policy.ST Nov 18, 1897 That class sacrifices principle, takes the unholy suggestions of the faithless, and unites with the world and the State, acting from interference in God's plan to bring the Promised Seed through chosen channels and from lack of faith that God can fulfill His promises without their help.STST Nov 18, 1897 The same lack of faith was first seen in Abraham and is found at the basis of nearly all union of church and state.ST The blessing they seek is temporal instead of spiritual, a matter of place or position, of loaves and fishes, and their effort ends in utter disappointment at last.ST Nov 18, 1897
Jacob the supplanter needed a complete change of heart to be placed among the Israel of God.ST Human impatience and ingenuity to help God fulfill His promise only bring trouble, as shown when Rebekah urged Jacob to deceive his father while Esau was hunting in the fields, though God had already promised that Jacob would be a prince in Israel and inherit the blessing given to Abraham and Isaac.ST Jul 31, 1901 If Rebekah had left the Lord alone, the blessing would have come to Jacob just as God promised, instead of bringing Esau's murderous rage, Rebekah's lifelong separation from the son who comforted her, and Jacob's flight to a distant country for many long years through bitter experiences, difficulties, hardships, and distresses.ST Jul 31, 1901 When the Lord promises a thing He will perform it at the proper time, so believers should not become impatient or uneasy with human schemes but quietly wait on the Lord, and when they are ready to receive His blessings He will promptly bestow them.ST Jul 31, 1901
Sources