John 12:5
Why was not this ointment sold for three hundred pence, and given to the poor?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible, Revised Version, Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Why was not this ointment sold for three hundred pence, and given to the poor?
Why was not this ointment sold for three hundred shillings, and given to the poor?
'Wherefore was not this ointment sold for three hundred denaries, and given to the poor?'
Why was this ointment not sold for three hundred denarii and given to the poor?
Why was, this perfume, not sold for three hundred denaries, and given unto the destitute?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Why wasn’ t this perfume sold for three hundred denarii and the money given to the poor?”
“ Why wasn’ t this ointment sold for three hundred denarii and given to the poor?”
Why was not this perfume traded for three hundred pence, and the money given to the poor?
Why was not this oyntment sold for three hundreth pence, and giuen to the poore?
Pictures


Cross-references
- Matthew 26:8-9
But when his disciples saw it, they had indignation, saying, To what purpose is this waste?
The disciples object that the costly ointment could have been sold to help the poor.
- Mark 14:4-5
And there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said, Why was this waste of the ointment made?
The objection says the costly ointment could have been sold and given to the poor.
- Mark 14:6-8
And Jesus said, Let her alone; why trouble ye her? she hath wrought a good work on me.
Jesus defends Mary’s act as a good work and says she anointed him beforehand for burial.
- John 11:1-44
Now a certain man was sick, named Lazarus, of Bethany, the town of Mary and her sister Martha.
Jesus raised Mary’s brother Lazarus, prompting her gratitude.
- Matthew 26:13
Verily I say unto you, Wheresoever this gospel shall be preached in the whole world, there shall also this, that this woman hath done, be told for a memorial of her.
Her anointing is promised remembrance wherever the gospel is preached.
- Luke 7:37-38
And, behold, a woman in the city, which was a sinner, when she knew that Jesus sat at meat in the Pharisee’s house, brought an alabaster box of ointment,
A woman anoints Jesus’ feet at a meal.
- Mark 14:3
And being in Bethany in the house of Simon the leper, as he sat at meat, there came a woman having an alabaster box of ointment of spikenard very precious; and she brake the box, and poured it on his head.
Both describe the anointing with precious ointment from an alabaster box.
- Mark 14:8
She hath done what she could: she is come aforehand to anoint my body to the burying.
Mary’s act of anointing Jesus honors him before his burial.
- Mark 14:10-11
And Judas Iscariot, one of the twelve, went unto the chief priests, to betray him unto them.
shows Judas's response after the reproof
- Matthew 26:10
When Jesus understood it, he said unto them, Why trouble ye the woman? for she hath wrought a good work upon me.
Jesus defends Mary’s anointing as a good work.
- Mark 14:9
Verily I say unto you, Wheresoever this gospel shall be preached throughout the whole world, this also that she hath done shall be spoken of for a memorial of her.
Her anointing is promised remembrance wherever the gospel is preached.
- Luke 7:38
And stood at his feet behind him weeping, and began to wash his feet with tears, and did wipe them with the hairs of her head, and kissed his feet, and anointed them with the ointment.
A woman washes and anoints Jesus’ feet.
- Deuteronomy 15:11
For the poor shall never cease out of the land: therefore I command thee, saying, Thou shalt open thine hand wide unto thy brother, to thy poor, and to thy needy, in thy land.
The poor are always present, and people can do them good.
- Luke 12:33
Sell that ye have, and give alms; provide yourselves bags which wax not old, a treasure in the heavens that faileth not, where no thief approacheth, neither moth corrupteth.
Both speak of selling possessions and giving to the poor.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
45 sources
Judas objected to Mary's costly anointing of Jesus by asking why the ointment was not sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor, rebuking her generous gift as waste.DA 557Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–215RED 45.2–46.1 His plea for the poor was false, a pretense concealing covetousness and dishonesty, for as keeper of the disciples' money bag he cared nothing for the poor but longed to control the proceeds for himself.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2DA 558.4–560.1 Mary in love and gratitude gave her most precious treasure to honor her Saviour who had forgiven her and raised her brother, anointing Him for burial while He was still with them.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.26T 310.1–2 Jesus approved and accepted her deed rather than condemning it, showing her unselfish devotion shamed Judas' selfish calculation and that honoring Christ is no waste.Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–214RED 108.2–109.24T 550.4 Christ's rebuke wounded Judas' pride and let greed control him, so that he who valued money above his Lord soon sold Him for thirty pieces of silver, warning against hiding selfishness under concern for the poor.CET 172.2–173.1EW 228.2DA 720.11T 192.12SP 379.1–2
Setting and Wording
The question was asked by Judas, rebuking Mary for her costly gift by asking why the ointment had not been sold for three hundred pence and the money given to the poor.DA 557Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–215RED 45.2–46.1Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7 His stated concern for the poor was the form his rebuke took.DA 557Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–21
It was spoken at a supper in honor of Jesus at Bethany six days before the Passover, when Jesus had stopped for rest and refreshment on His way from Jericho to attend the feast at Jerusalem, just before His betrayal and death.ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 175, 1905, par. 2 The supper was made by Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus had healed of leprosy, in order to show Jesus special honor.ST Jul 22, 1886DA 557.1–2 Jesus sat at the table with Simon on one side and Lazarus, whom He had raised from the dead, on the other, while Martha served at the table and Mary listened earnestly to every word from His lips.ST Jul 22, 1886 It was a feast for Jesus during His final visit there, with many Jews present and some watching Him with hostility, an occasion on which critics would have censured Him for allowing His friends to honor Him.DA 557.1–216MR 318.2–319.1
Mary had bought an alabaster box of precious ointment at great personal sacrifice to anoint the body of Jesus at His death.ST Jul 22, 1886 Hearing many say Jesus would be elevated to kingly authority when He went to Jerusalem, she readily believed it and rejoiced that her Saviour would no longer be despised and rejected and obliged to flee for His life.ST Jul 22, 1886 In love and gratitude she wished to be the first to honor Him, and seeking to avoid observation she anointed His head and His feet with the precious ointment and then wiped His feet with her long, flowing hair.4RED 108.2–109.2ST Jul 22, 1886 She did this as one whom Christ had lifted from despair and who had learned from Him and served Him.DA 568.1–2
His question deceived his fellow disciples and influenced Simon the host, spreading distrust of Mary's devotion and turning the table to whispered charges of waste.4RED 108.2–109.2 His complaint reproached Christ for allowing her offering and stirred others to disaffection.RH Aug 7, 1900 The objection to the costly ointment being used for Him was fault-finding with Jesus' presence at a social gathering, not a sound reason to condemn generous conduct.Lt 2, 1878, par. 6–8
False Plea Exposed
Judas's talk of charity for the poor was false, a pretense and excuse that concealed covetousness, selfishness, hypocrisy, ambition and dishonesty.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.2SG1 44.1 He cared nothing for the poor and did not intend to help them, and his claim that the ointment should have been sold for them arose not from pity but from greed.DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.14RED 108.2–109.2EW 228.2ST Jul 22, 1886 Mary's grateful, unselfish devotion shamed and rebuked that selfishness, exposing the contrast between her love and his calculation.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.2SG1 44.1
He was treasurer of the disciples' united funds and kept the money bag, dishonestly taking money meant for God's service and for the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–24RED 108.2–109.2SG1 44.1ST Jul 22, 1886 Entrusted with gifts for Christ's work and to relieve necessity, he diverted small sums for himself and sometimes kept for himself what had been given for them.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3SG1 44.14T 486.3–487.2Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 He longed to get the value of the ointment into his own hands for selfish use, and objected when money was spent on what he considered unnecessary.20MR 146.1–2DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.2 Had it been sold the proceeds would have gone into his hands, and the poor would have received no benefit.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.2
He put a price on all his actions, calculating the value of the alabaster box and the money that might come into his control, and judging that the treasury had suffered a loss.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–24T 41.1–42.14T 485.14T 486.3–487.2 As a speculator wanting financial gain he grudged Mary's generous gift and paid himself according to his own selfish estimate.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–24T 486.3–487.2 He justified taking by reasoning that his labor was not sufficiently appreciated and that he could pay himself as he saw fit, a principle that corrupted his conscience, and he treated saving money as evidence of godliness.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 Those who have received pardoning love do not stop so to calculate the value of an offering made to Christ, but regret only that it is not richer and more valuable.4T 485.1
Though he had been with Christ during His ministry, his covetousness was not cured but was held fast as a precious treasure and became more and more confirmed, while Christ's lessons on unselfishness were unheeded.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3 His love of money led him to idolize the little treasure entrusted to his care to be used for the benefit of the church and to relieve the necessities of the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3 Association with Christ had not made him one with Christ and had not cultivated within his heart a sincere sympathy for those for whom Christ gave His life.6T 264.2–265.1 The disciples did not know at that time that he was a thief, but they knew it afterward.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3
Devotion Honored
Mary's generous gift was gratitude to her Savior who had forgiven her many sins and raised her beloved brother from the dead, and its great value made her devotion all the more evident.DA 558.4–560.1SG1 44.1EW 134.2 She showed how highly she prized Jesus by counting the most precious gift none too costly for Him, while Judas valued money above Him.2SP 379.1–24RED 112.1 Her unselfish devotion shamed and rebuked his selfishness and covetousness.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.2SG1 44.1EW 134.2
Jesus approved, justified and accepted Mary's deed rather than reproving or condemning her.Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–21Lt 189, 1909, par. 4Lt 189, 1909, par. 2–3 People may criticize and condemn a good act without considering the motive behind it, but her act illustrates that such criticism is to be discerned rightly.Lt 70, 1910, par. 17–21 The objection to her anointing was not to be accepted, for honoring Christ with the best of one's substance is a good work.4T 550.4Lt 189, 1909, par. 4
She had acted with prophetic anticipation of His burial.Lt 189, 1909, par. 2–3 The poor were always present, but Jesus would not remain with them.Lt 189, 1909, par. 2–3 By His own words that act joins her to Him and to the gospel throughout all time as true religion that knows God and Jesus Christ whom He sent.Lt 135, 1897, par. 15–16 The broken alabaster box has by its memory inspired many to loving service, and that influence continues.6T 310.1–2 Every impulse of the Holy Spirit leading to goodness is noted in the books of heaven, and in the day of God she, having given herself as an instrument for the Spirit's working, will be permitted to behold all the outworking of her deed and will rejoice in it.6T 310.1–2
Her offering to Jesus was not waste, even though it was made from a very valuable treasure.4T 550.4RH Aug 7, 1900 Faithful stewards can serve both Christ's cause and the poor, while giving Christ's cause priority.4T 550.4 Caring for the poor must not lead to neglect of God's cause.4T 550.4 Those who have received pardoning love do not stop to calculate the value of an offering made to Christ, but regret only that it is not richer and more valuable.4T 485.1
Road to Betrayal
The rebuke Jesus spoke and implied over the ointment laid bare a covetousness and love of money that calculated what might have come into controlling hands if it had been sold and counted the treasury as having suffered loss.4T 41.1–42.1DA 720.13SP 125.25RED 45.2–46.1ST Jun 27, 1878 That exposure annoyed and irritated him, and though the reproof was not personal in form it wounded pride and wakened anger and desire for revenge until long-indulged greed took control and resentment deepened.4T 41.1–42.1DA 720.13SP 125.2ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.3 Revenge thus combined with avarice, and the covetous spirit made him receptive to Satan and willing to sell his Master for silver.5RED 45.2–46.1ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.3
Where Mary showed by her gift how highly she prized the Saviour, Judas valued money above Him and prized his Lord only enough to sell Him to wicked men for a few pieces of silver, for thirty pieces of silver.CET 172.2–173.1EW 228.2SG1 181.11T 192.1SG2 232.1 He coveted the costly ointment poured upon Jesus and complained because he wanted it in his own possession to apply to his own use and turn into money, rather than seeing it lavished upon the Saviour.SG1 181.11T 192.1SG2 232.1 He balanced the life of the Son of God against a paltry sum, and after being reproved before others his love of money made him willing to betray his Master.CET 172.2–173.1EW 228.25RED 45.2–46.1ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.3
Unchecked sin makes a person vulnerable to temptation and can lead the soul captive, for one neglect to manifest the spirit of Christ opens the way for another and still another until selfishness becomes a devouring passion which nothing but the power of Christ can subdue.DA 720.16T 264.2–265.1 His complaint expressed an accusing, self-justifying, unsanctified heart unwilling to humble itself, be converted and repent, stubbornly justifying its course and refusing to surrender sin even while conscience was awakened to lead to repentance.DA 720.1Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 In this he became increasingly like Satan the great accuser, devoid of mercy and justice and love of God, acting as director and judge and lawyer rather than as a father, keeping some points of law while neglecting mercy and love.Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9 His example shows that a person must repent to be forgiven, and warns against professing devotion while misrepresenting others and using religious claims to justify a betraying course, against a superficial religion that does not give up the world for Christ, and against becoming set in objectionable traits until given over to a corrupt nature.Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9Lt 28, 1888, par. 37–38
Generosity and Stewardship
Costly offerings freely given in worship are not waste, and everything need not be done in the cheapest manner.4T 550.45T 268.1–2 The murmur that devotion to Christ is waste is covetous, for honoring Him with the best of one's substance is a good work.4T 550.45T 268.1–2 Caring for the poor must not lead to neglect of God's cause, since faithful stewards can serve both while giving Christ's cause priority.4T 550.4 The sanctuary was not designed to honor man but the God of Heaven, the rightful owner of the gold and silver, who gave specific directions how everything was to be done to teach that He is a being of greatness and majesty to be worshiped with reverence and awe.5T 268.1–2 That same spirit that called Mary's devotion waste still objects to generous expense in building for God.5T 268.1–2
The verse warns against using concern for the poor as an excuse to withhold support from the cause of truth.1T 192.12SP 379.1–24RED 112.1 Judas covered a covetous, selfish heart with pious, conscientious regard for the poor, coveting the costly ointment poured upon Jesus and complaining because he wanted it in his own possession instead of seeing it lavished upon the Saviour, to apply it to his own use and sell it for money.1T 192.1 He begrudged the gift to Jesus, valuing money above Him and prizing his Lord only enough to sell Him to wicked men for a few pieces of silver, and his covetousness and anger led him to betray his Lord for money, balancing the life of the Son of God against a paltry sum while Mary's offering showed how highly she prized Jesus by counting the most precious gift none too costly for Him.1T 192.12SP 379.1–24RED 112.1 The same covetous, cold, calculating spirit is manifested by many who profess Christ today, whose offerings to His cause are grudgingly bestowed or withheld altogether under plausible excuses and pretense of wide philanthropy that it is better to give to the poor.1T 192.14RED 112.1 They hide selfishness under put-on conscientiousness, fear that systematic benevolence makes them like the nominal churches, plead secrecy in giving, and neglect the plain command to sell what they have and give alms.1T 192.1
Practical sympathy is a test of the purity and unselfishness of the heart.6T 264.2–265.1 Satan ruins the soul by closing the heart to the needs of others and preventing the expression of love and sympathy, and Judas, planning constantly to benefit self while professing concern for the poor, proves that association with Christ had not made him one with Christ and had not cultivated within his heart a sincere sympathy for those for whom Christ gave His life.6T 264.2–265.1 In this he represents a large class of professed Christians today who are as near to Christ as he was yet are in the same danger of being outside of Christ as the sport of temptation.6T 264.2–265.1 His course warns to guard against the first deviation from righteousness, for one neglect to manifest the spirit of Christ opens the way for another and still another until selfishness becomes a devouring passion which nothing but the power of Christ can subdue.6T 264.2–265.1 But the true Christian shows faith by investing in the cause of truth and is known by works, for faith without works is dead.4RED 112.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
73 sources
The question was put by Judas Iscariot, the treasurer who kept the money bag, at the supper in Simon's house at Bethany where Mary anointed Jesus.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jan 21, 1897RH Mar 24, 1910 The ointment was spikenard, the costliest oil then known, valued at three hundred pence, about a laboring man's wages for a year.ST Apr 5, 1905RH Aug 25, 1868ST Jan 3, 1911 His plea for the poor was not from care for them, for he was a thief who stole from the bag and wanted the price in his own hands to use himself.ST Oct 9, 1879RH Aug 7, 1900ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899 Jesus exposed the hypocrisy and defended Mary's act as a good work of unselfish love that honored Him while He was alive and prepared His body for burial, while the poor would remain to be helped afterward.ST May 12, 1914ST Jun 14, 1905RH Nov 20, 1913ST Apr 5, 1905 The verse thus warns against a covetous, censorious spirit that calls costly thank-offerings waste, measures service by money instead of love, and puts a plea for the poor against wholehearted devotion to Christ.ST May 25, 1882ST Jun 16, 1887ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 15, 1870
Setting and Occasion
The saying was uttered at a supper six days before the Passover in the house of Lazarus at Bethany, where Jesus had stopped for rest and refreshment on His way from Jericho to attend the feast at Jerusalem.ST Jul 22, 1886 The supper was made by Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus had healed of leprosy, to show Jesus special honor.ST Jul 22, 1886 Jesus sat at the table with Simon on one side and Lazarus, whom He had raised from the dead, on the other, while Martha served at the table and Mary listened earnestly to every word from His lips.ST Jul 22, 1886 His arrival at Bethany was the first of those six days, and the following day, the fifth day before Passover, was the Sabbath spent at Lazarus's home.
It was a gathering honoring Jesus in Simon's house at Bethany a few days before His crucifixion.RH Mar 24, 1910 It broke in upon the peace of Jesus with Lazarus, Mary and Martha at Bethany, when the anointing of Jesus was called waste and valued at more than three hundred pence that should have been sold and given to the poor.RH Dec 3, 1867 It was a feast after Lazarus was raised, where Mary anointed Jesus' feet with precious ointment and wiped them with her hair.RH Dec 3, 1867ST Nov 17, 1898 The objection to Mary's use of costly spikenard, that it should have been sold for three hundred pence and the money given to the poor, was not raised by one alone in indignation at this honor done to Jesus.RH Mar 24, 1910RH Dec 3, 1867
The verse stands within the sequence that includes the resurrection of Lazarus, the last public discourse, the acknowledgment from heaven, the institution of the ordinance of humility, the pointing out of the betrayer, and the first two chapters of the farewell discourse to the disciples.ST May 26, 1909
Ointment and Its Value
The ointment was spikenard, the costliest anointing oil known.RH Aug 25, 1868ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 10, 1911 It was made from an Indian plant and sold throughout the Roman Empire at fabulous prices.ST Sep 20, 1899 Though it was common to anoint the heads of rabbis and special guests at marriage feasts with fragrant oil, this ointment surpassed anything in that line then known.ST Sep 20, 1899 A pound of it was worth more than three hundred denarii, the sum named as its selling price for the poor.RH Aug 25, 1868ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 10, 1911
The value is stated as three hundred pence, denarii, or shillings, and as more than three hundred pence.ST Apr 5, 1905RH Dec 10, 1867ST Jan 3, 1911RH Dec 3, 1867ST Apr 5, 1905 By one reckoning that sum was about forty dollars, and by the standard of that day it was more than ten pounds, about fifty dollars.RH Dec 10, 1867ST Sep 20, 1899 It was about three hundred days' wages for a laborer, about a laboring man's annual support.ST Jan 21, 1897ST Apr 5, 1905 It was put forward as enough to feed the hungry and clothe the unclothed poor in Bethany and Jerusalem.ST Jan 3, 1911
Mary had obtained the ointment through great personal sacrifice and self-denial, secretly saving to buy it as a token of love and honor for Jesus.RH Mar 24, 1910ST Dec 2, 1880ST Apr 5, 1905 Her gift was worth more than its price because giving it to her Lord deepened her experience more than keeping her property would have.ST Dec 2, 1880 The Spirit moved her to honor Him while He was alive, though she did not know His death was near.ST Apr 5, 1905
Judas's False Concern
The fault found with Mary and the question why the ointment was not sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor was spoken by Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, who would betray Jesus.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jan 21, 1897 He was treasurer and kept the disciples' money bag.ST Jul 29, 1889ST Jan 21, 1897 His apparent loyalty and trusted responsibility almost to the end did not prove present loyalty to God.ST Jun 1, 1904
His stated concern for the poor was not genuine and did not come from care for them.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 21, 1897 He said this because he was a thief who had the bag and stole what was put in it, taking money from the disciples' funds.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 21, 1897 His plea for the poor concealed meanness, covetousness, selfishness and greed.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Apr 24, 1893 His appeal to charity was a disguise and excuse for covetousness, for he wanted the proceeds for his own use and to have in his own hands to spend from the treasury.ST Oct 9, 1879ST May 6, 1889ST Dec 18, 1893ST May 25, 1882RH Nov 20, 1913 He felt the treasury had suffered great loss, and he objected because Mary's generous act contrasted with his selfishness and dishonesty.ST Oct 9, 1879RH Nov 20, 1913 His envy that Jesus should receive an offering fit for kings and his cherished greed corrupted his unselfish impulses, gained control of his character, and exposed him when he yielded to temptation rather than obeying Christ's words.RH Nov 20, 1913ST Jun 11, 1896
Had the ointment been sold the proceeds would have gone into his hands and the poor would not have benefited.RH Aug 7, 1900RH Aug 7, 1900 He lacked compassion for them and stole money meant for their relief, coveting and stealing what had been entrusted for them.RH Aug 7, 1900ST May 6, 1889ST Jun 3, 1897 His supposed concern did not match his actions, and treachery toward the poor was part of his betrayal of Christ.ST May 6, 1889RH May 6, 1902 Judas was the chief instigator of the indignation, and he wanted the money for himself because he was a thief.RH Dec 10, 1867 His insinuations made the other disciples distrust Mary's loving act of devotion, leaving her ashamed and afraid Jesus would condemn her.ST May 6, 1889ST Oct 9, 1879
The objection that the ointment was wasted and should have been sold for three hundred pence is also recorded as spoken by the disciples, who counted the broken alabaster box as lost.RH Mar 24, 1910RH Mar 24, 1910RH Mar 24, 1910 They are set forth as presuming to guard access to Christ and His gifts, obstructing one who came to Him directly.ST Apr 16, 1896 Jesus penetrated his hypocrisy and His rebuke exposed his covetousness while commending Mary's act.ST Jun 27, 1878RH Nov 20, 1913 At first He did not expose him, to avoid giving him an excuse for betrayal.ST May 6, 1889
The direct reproof rankled in Judas until in resentment and revenge he contemplated betrayal for money and retaliation.RH Nov 20, 1913ST Apr 19, 1905 He yielded to Satan and consented to betray and sell Jesus for silver, his love of money making him receptive to Satan's influence.ST Jun 27, 1878RH Nov 20, 1913ST Jun 11, 1896 His objection arose from covetousness and the reproof he received offended him, his concern for the poor masking his mercenary character since he was stealing from the money entrusted to him.ST Feb 14, 1906 His valuation of the ointment at three hundred pence contrasts with the thirty pence for which he plotted Christ's death.RH Nov 20, 1913 His apparently prudent, cautious question about the poor could make him seem virtuous and careful about expenditure, but character must not be judged by one apparently good act.RH Dec 4, 1860
Mary's Devotion Defended
Mary's anointing was not confined to the feet but embraced the head as well, for seeking to avoid observation she poured the precious ointment upon His head and His feet and then wiped His feet with her long, flowing hair.ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 12, 1914 Hearing many say that He would be elevated to kingly authority when He went to Jerusalem, she readily believed it and rejoiced that her Saviour would no longer be despised and rejected and obliged to flee for His life, and in love and gratitude she wished to be first to honor Him.ST Jul 22, 1886 The act carried a deeper meaning than royal honor, for it was the anointing of His body beforehand for burial, and with the words Let her alone Jesus defended her devotion and identified it as preparation for that burial.ST May 12, 1914ST Dec 20, 1905ST Feb 15, 1905RH Mar 24, 1910
Her offering honored the living Christ while He was still present and expressed gratitude for His blessing, showing how highly she prized the Saviour.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Dec 20, 1905 Its worth is not measured by outward cost but by the love that prompts it, whether the gift be great or small, for Christ looks upon that love rather than upon the sum expended.ST Dec 10, 1894 She considered nothing too good for Jesus and poured it all out upon Him rather than keeping it for her own enjoyment, and her act sprang from unselfish service without seeking praise or personal gain.RH Nov 11, 1915
Her offering to Jesus was not waste even though it was made from a very valuable treasure, for what honors God is never wasted.RH Aug 7, 1900RH May 29, 1855 The complaint measured devotion by utility and set relief of human wants against honoring Jesus, calling the broken box lost, but Jesus defended Mary and her so-called waste, commanding to let her alone because she had wrought a good work upon Him.RH Dec 3, 1867 His reproof met criticism that reproached Him for allowing the offering and stirred others to disaffection, and done for Christ's sake rather than for merely temporal satisfaction her devotion cheered and encouraged millions reading of it and of His tenderness, proving eternal where a gift for humanity's sake alone would have passed away.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Jul 15, 1886
The objection arose from selfishness and wanted the proceeds for selfish use, yet it made the other disciples distrust her loving act.ST May 6, 1889ST Oct 9, 1879 By reproaching Christ for allowing the offering it left her ashamed and afraid that He would condemn her.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Oct 9, 1879 The criticism expressed a cold, censorious spirit that would have restrained her loving act toward Jesus, which is why faultfinding must not be allowed to suppress sincere acts of love and gratitude.RH Dec 10, 1901
Christ First, Poor Remembered
Expense is not wasteful when it honors Christ, and the costly anointing therefore justifies spending means to bring people to a knowledge of the truth and salvation.ST Oct 6, 1881ST Jun 7, 1899ST Mar 27, 1901 Those whose affections are set on worldly things regard such personal sacrifices of true disciples as needless waste, while material things are more profitably used when spent in honor of Christ who gave His life for humanity.ST Oct 6, 1881ST Jun 7, 1899 No sacrifice made for Him is too great, and gifts to Christ do not prevent care for the poor despite appearances.ST Oct 6, 1881ST Jun 7, 1899ST Mar 27, 1901
Mary's offering honored the living Christ in gratitude for His blessing and did not prevent her from ministering to the poor after He was gone.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Mar 27, 1901ST Apr 5, 1905 Her gift was not wasted and was not taken from the poor, for the opportunity to honor Jesus directly would pass while the poor would remain to receive help afterward.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Mar 27, 1901ST Apr 5, 1905 Giving to Christ does not diminish care for the poor, and greater love for Christ strengthens benevolence toward them.ST Mar 27, 1901ST Apr 5, 1905
Christ first, the poor afterward: giving the money to the poor would have done well, but giving it to Christ did better.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Jul 15, 1886ST Apr 5, 1905 Given for humanity's sake it would have given only temporal satisfaction of a pennyworth of bread to three hundred souls and would have been transitory and passed away, but done for Christ's sake it cheered millions reading of her devotion and proved eternal.ST Jul 15, 1886 The objection about selling the ointment and giving to the poor stands against showing love and honoring people during their lifetime rather than waiting until they are gone.ST Dec 20, 1905STRH Jul 3, 1913ST Feb 15, 1905 Mary's anointing before His burial is an example of kindness offered in time to comfort and refresh its recipient, defended by the words Let her alone, teaching that love, comfort, sympathy and praise should be given while people are alive to hear and benefit from them rather than expressed too late after death.ST Dec 20, 1905STRH Jul 3, 1913ST Feb 15, 1905
Warning and Present Application
Judas spoke as the prudent, cautious one among the twelve, careful about expenditure, pale and flushed with distress at costly expense bestowed upon the Son of God.RH Nov 15, 1870 He is a type reaching to the present time of those who object to tangible, costly thank-offerings and sacrifices to God as wasteful and needless.RH Nov 15, 1870 He would have objected with horror and anger if he had seen Noah burn one-seventh of his priceless clean beasts and fowls on his altar, while Heaven smiled on that sacrifice.RH Nov 15, 1870
An unbeliever may treat money spent in God's service as waste, echoing the objection that the ointment should have been sold and given to the poor.RH Jan 13, 1863 Such concern for thrift can become a snare to a Christian who wants God's cause to prosper.RH Jan 13, 1863 The same charge of waste of time, money and life, counting the broken alabaster box and poured-out precious ointment as lost, is made against missionary work for black men in Africa.ST Jun 29, 1904
The appeal to the ointment's value shows greed and deceit under pretense of generosity, using concern for the poor as a pretext for seeking money for self, and stands as a warning for deacons who handle charitable funds.RH Sep 27, 1870 It illustrates the conflict between the old acquisitive nature and love for God, in which reluctance to give and fear of future poverty voice themselves as concern for the poor.RH Jan 1, 1861 A covetous person may in this way resent a costly act of gratitude and sacrifice to God, calling its use wasteful. Past service and trusted responsibility, even as treasurer almost to the end, do not prove present loyalty to God.ST Jun 1, 1904 Serving God with little is the way to make it more.RH Jan 1, 1861
The objection is a cold, censorious, unfeeling spirit that is not of heaven but comes from beneath, which freezes acts of love before they find expression and condemns an act prompted by love.RH Dec 10, 1901ST Sep 26, 1911RH Dec 10, 1901 Christ's answer, Let her alone, applies to all such criticism.RH Dec 10, 1901 Believers must let people alone to follow the good promptings of the Spirit, for God is able to guide them, whether a timid wife longing to invite a needy one to share her home or children longing to express childish love for Christ.RH Dec 10, 1901 Much more might be done for God if good deeds were not smothered by inward or outward faultfinding that would have restrained loving gratitude toward Jesus.RH Dec 10, 1901RH Dec 10, 1901 Mary's was the only precious box of ointment broken upon the Saviour while He was alive, and none should be sorry she broke it.RH Dec 10, 1901
The demand that the gift should have been sold treats loving devotion to the Lord as intolerable waste.ST Jun 16, 1887ST May 31, 1899 It misjudges motive, measuring service by money instead of love, while God knows the true motive.ST May 31, 1899 It is an objection ruled by mammon that seeks to restrict the working of love when it costs too much.ST May 31, 1899 It puts a plea for the poor against wholehearted devotion to Christ, setting relief of human wants and the cause of humanity against honoring Jesus, and refuses to break the alabaster box under pretense of spending it on the poor.ST Jun 16, 1887RH Dec 3, 1867 It puts man first while leaving Christ out of view, revealing want of appreciation of His excellence and want of love that leaves religion cold and lifeless, the opposite of a heart subdued by grace and broken by love.ST Jun 16, 1887RH Dec 3, 1867 A professed concern for philanthropy can thus mask covetousness, resentment, and a grudging refusal to support Christ's cause.ST May 25, 1882 By contrast, those who have received pardoning love do not stop to measure the value of their offering but regret that it is not richer and more precious, for love led the worshiper to pour it out and right conclusions come from love rather than finance.RH Feb 27, 1908ST Jan 10, 1906
Mary brought her best gift out of overflowing love because she had received richest blessings, bringing an alabaster box of very precious ointment, breaking the box and pouring it on His head, holding nothing too dear or too costly to bestow.RH Sep 17, 1901 Her gift was worth more than its price of three hundred pence because giving it to her Lord deepened her experience more than keeping her property would have.ST Dec 2, 1880 Though condemned as waste by an appeal to charity masking covetousness while a terrible deed was already meditated, her pouring it out in loving service made it a lasting blessing and remembrance throughout the world.RH Jun 24, 1902ST Jan 3, 1911 Her costly gift shows the value of giving oneself in loving service rather than carefully preserving one's life. All should bring their best to Christ because He gave the best He had, giving His life with a broken heart and poured-out precious blood, and from His throne of glory now lavishes the best gifts of His love, so He is owed the best of everything, the best affections with the warmest place in the heart, all the gems and jewels of love gathered like choicest perfume in a precious alabaster box.RH Sep 17, 1901 Loving service to Christ and deeds done for those in need, done to Christ, spread a grace beyond what price can measure, whose full worth may remain unseen until the final day.RH Nov 9, 1911
Sources