John 12:4
Then saith one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, which should betray him,
Translations
Then says one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, which should betray him,
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then saith one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, which should betray him,
Then saith one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, who was to betray him,
But Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples, which should betray him, saith,
But Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples, that should betray him, saith,
Therefore saith one of his disciples — Judas Iscariot, of Simon, who is about to deliver him up —
One of his disciples therefore, Judas [son] of Simon, Iscariote, who was about to deliver him up, says,
[But] Judas Iscariot, one of his disciples, he that was about to deliver him up, saith—
But one of His disciples, Judas Iscariot, who was going to betray Him, asked,
But one of His disciples, Judas Iscariot, son of Simon, who was going to betray Him, asked,
Then Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, one of his disciples, who would betray him, said,
But one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot ( who was to give him up), said,
Then said one of his disciples, euen Iudas Iscariot Simons sonne, which should betray him:
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Then one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, he that was about to betray him, said:
Pictures


Cross-references 20 of 23
- Mark 14:10-11
And Judas Iscariot, one of the twelve, went unto the chief priests, to betray him unto them.
Judas’s objection to the anointing leads into his decision to betray Jesus.
- Matthew 26:6-13
Now when Jesus was in Bethany, in the house of Simon the leper,
A parallel account of the Bethany events that includes Judas’s response.
- Matthew 26:15
And said unto them, What will ye give me, and I will deliver him unto you? And they covenanted with him for thirty pieces of silver.
Judas agrees to betray Jesus for thirty pieces of silver.
- Luke 22:3-6
Then entered Satan into Judas surnamed Iscariot, being of the number of the twelve.
Describes Judas’s agreement to betray Jesus for money.
- Luke 7:38
And stood at his feet behind him weeping, and began to wash his feet with tears, and did wipe them with the hairs of her head, and kissed his feet, and anointed them with the ointment.
A woman anoints Jesus’ feet at a feast.
- Zechariah 11:12
And I said unto them, If ye think good, give me my price; and if not, forbear. So they weighed for my price thirty pieces of silver.
Foretells the thirty pieces of silver paid for Jesus’ betrayal.
- Matthew 27:3-5
Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders,
Judas regrets betraying Jesus and takes his own life.
- Mark 14:6
And Jesus said, Let her alone; why trouble ye her? she hath wrought a good work on me.
Jesus rebukes Judas’s criticism and defends Mary’s good work.
- Mark 14:3
And being in Bethany in the house of Simon the leper, as he sat at meat, there came a woman having an alabaster box of ointment of spikenard very precious; and she brake the box, and poured it on his head.
The verse describes the costly ointment poured on Jesus, which Judas criticized.
- Matthew 26:7
There came unto him a woman having an alabaster box of very precious ointment, and poured it on his head, as he sat at meat.
Describes Mary’s anointing, which Judas criticized.
- Mark 14:8
She hath done what she could: she is come aforehand to anoint my body to the burying.
Jesus commends Mary’s devotion in anointing him for burial.
- John 11:1-44
Now a certain man was sick, named Lazarus, of Bethany, the town of Mary and her sister Martha.
Jesus raises Lazarus, drawing people to Bethany and prompting Mary’s gratitude.
- John 6:70-71
Jesus answered them, Have not I chosen you twelve, and one of you is a devil?
Jesus identifies Judas as the disciple who would betray him.
- Acts 1:16-20
Men and brethren, this scripture must needs have been fulfilled, which the Holy Ghost by the mouth of David spake before concerning Judas, which was guide to them that took Jesus.
Judas’s betrayal and catastrophic end
- John 18:2-5
And Judas also, which betrayed him, knew the place: for Jesus ofttimes resorted thither with his disciples.
Judas comes to the garden to betray Jesus.
- John 13:21-30
When Jesus had thus said, he was troubled in spirit, and testified, and said, Verily, verily, I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me.
Jesus identifies Judas as his betrayer
- Matthew 27:6-8
And the chief priests took the silver pieces, and said, It is not lawful for to put them into the treasury, because it is the price of blood.
The priests use Judas’s blood money to buy a burial ground.
- Matthew 10:1-4
And when he had called unto him his twelve disciples, he gave them power against unclean spirits, to cast them out, and to heal all manner of sickness and all manner of disease.
Judas is included among the disciples sent out by Jesus.
- Matthew 26:10
When Jesus understood it, he said unto them, Why trouble ye the woman? for she hath wrought a good work upon me.
Jesus defends the woman’s good work upon him.
- John 12:8
For the poor always ye have with you; but me ye have not always.
Christ is to be honored before care for the poor.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
43 sources
The verse names the speaker at the supper in Simon's house in Bethany as Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, one of Christ's disciples who would betray Him.DA 557ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 175, 1905, par. 2DA 558.4–560.14T 41.1–42.1 After Mary anointed Jesus with costly ointment, he spoke out angrily that it was waste that should have been sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3ST Jul 22, 1886EW 134.2 His plea for the poor was false and covetous, for he cared nothing for them but as keeper of the bag stole what was put in and wanted the ointment money under his control for his own use.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.1SG1 44.1 Jesus' reproof of his greed wounded his pride and opened him to Satan, so his cherished love of money led him to sell his Lord to the priests and rulers for thirty pieces of silver.CET 172.2–173.14T 41.1–42.1SG1 44.1EW 134.2DA 720.1 His history stands as a warning to professed Christians today against the first deviation from righteousness, letting selfishness and covetousness shut the heart against Christ until it becomes a devouring passion.13MR 189.2–190.11T 192.16T 264.2–265.1Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20Ms 2, 1902, par. 7–8
Setting and Identification
The words belong to the feast at Simon's house in Bethany, six days before the Passover, when Jesus on His way from Jericho to Jerusalem to attend the Passover stopped for rest and refreshment, just before His betrayal and death.DA 557ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 175, 1905, par. 2 Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus had healed of leprosy, made a supper to show Jesus special honor and invited Jesus and His friends as guests.ST Jul 22, 1886 Jesus sat at the table with Simon, cured of loathsome disease, on one side and Lazarus, raised from the dead, on the other, while Martha served at the table and Mary earnestly listened to every word falling from His lips.ST Jul 22, 1886
Crowds gathered at Bethany because Lazarus had been raised from the dead, and his testimony about Jesus increased public excitement.ST Jul 22, 1886DA 557.3–558.1 That excitement alarmed the priests and rulers, who feared losing their influence and sought an opportunity to remove Jesus.DA 557.3–558.1 The supper held in Jesus' honor with His disciples shows that He accepted invited hospitality and social invitations and shared in the social life of His countrymen.Lt 2a, 1878, par. 8–1016MR 318.2–319.1Lt 2, 1878, par. 6–8 He used such gatherings to make His character and teachings known.16MR 318.2–319.1
The speaker is named as one of His disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, who would betray Him.DA 557DA 558.4–560.14T 41.1–42.1SG1 44.1ST May 20, 1897 At the feast he objected to Mary's costly gift, but his stated concern for the poor concealed selfishness and cultivated covetousness, for he was a thief who stole from the disciples' money bag and took for himself money entrusted to him for them.DA 558.4–560.1SG1 44.1RH Aug 7, 1900ST May 20, 1897 His complaint shamed Mary, stirred distrust of her devotion among the disciples and discontent among those present, and reproached Jesus for allowing the gift.DA 558.4–560.1RH Aug 7, 1900 Though he had witnessed Jesus' works and ministry, his heart was selfish and covetous, and Mary's gift rebuked his greed, while his presence among the twelve despite his faults shows his failure does not mean there were no genuine disciples who loved Christ and sought to follow Him.4T 41.1–42.1SG1 44.1
Objection and Covetousness
Mary had anointed Jesus with costly ointment of spikenard from an alabaster box, and its fragrance made the hidden act known to all present when Judas spoke out angrily that it was waste and should have been sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3ST Jul 22, 1886EW 134.2ST Jul 22, 18861T 192.1 He was named as one of the disciples who would betray Jesus, and though at first he did not appear notably wicked in speech, conduct, or appearance and had valuable qualities, he was not teachable and was vexed when Jesus defended her.EW 134.2Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7
His plea of concern for the poor was false and covetous, for he cared nothing for them and was a stranger to the deep devotion and homage that moved her deed of love.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.1ST May 20, 1897ST Jul 22, 1886 He regarded her gift as wasteful, grudged the offering, and judged it wasteful rather than an act of homage, with a selfish heart closed to others' needs and constantly planning to benefit self.CET 172.2–173.1EW 228.21T 192.1Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7 He hid his selfishness under a pious, conscientious regard for the poor, wishing the ointment had been in his own possession so it would not be lavished upon the Saviour but could be applied to his own use and sold for money.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 18861T 192.1
As holder of the disciples' united funds and treasurer of money for Christ's work, he dishonestly took for himself what was put in the bag, stealing small sums and gifts meant for God's service and the poor without recording them.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3DA 558.4–560.1SG1 44.1ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38 He had misused money entrusted to him for them and for the church's expenses, keeping some gifts from the account and idolizing the little treasure entrusted to his care to be used for the benefit of the church and to relieve the necessities of the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3SG1 44.1EW 134.213MR 189.2–190.1 At the time the other disciples did not know he was a thief, though they knew it afterward.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3
He justified his theft by deciding his work was not sufficiently valued and paying himself by his own selfish estimate, putting a price upon all his actions.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1 Acting on that reasoning corrupted his conscience and character, and had he submitted to the Holy Spirit he would have kept his integrity.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9 His covetousness was held fast as a precious treasure and became more and more confirmed, he treated saving money as evidence of godliness, Christ's lessons on unselfishness were unheeded, and his love of money and selfishness grew as he indulged them.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–34T 486.3–487.2Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7
His calculating of the ointment's value contrasts with the gratitude of those who have received saving love, who give generously rather than begrudge the offering.DA 558.4–560.14T 485.1 His complaint shamed Mary and stirred distrust of her devotion and discontent among those present and among the disciples.DA 558.4–560.1RH Aug 7, 1900 He reproached Jesus for allowing the gift and tried to instruct Jesus about what was proper, accusing Mary of extravagance, but Jesus defended her, for her deed was not to be reproved, and Christ's defense supplied evidence that would be needed later.RH Aug 7, 19004T 486.3–487.2Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7Lt 189, 1909, par. 4
Path to Betrayal
Mary's generous gift rebuked his greed, and Christ's reproof of his covetousness stirred wounded pride and revenge in him.SG1 44.1EW 134.2DA 720.1 Annoyed at the implied rebuke, he yielded to the tempter and gave Satan easy access to his mind.ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.25RED 45.2–46.1 Cherished selfishness, ambition, and unresisted sin leave a person open to Satan's temptation and captivity, and each accusing expression conforms character to Satan the great accuser.DA 720.1Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16
Indulged love of money perverted his nobler nature and led him to sell his Lord to wicked men and to the murderous priests and rulers.4T 41.1–42.11T 192.15RED 45.2–46.1 He valued Jesus only enough to betray Him for a few pieces of silver, for thirty pieces of silver.CET 172.2–173.14T 41.1–42.1EW 228.2SG1 181.1Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 Made by this course a fit agent for Satan, he stands as an example of abandoning good principles for earthly gain.SG1 181.15RED 45.2–46.1
Even in deciding to sell his Master he had no thought Jesus would permit Himself to be taken.ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.25RED 45.2–46.1 He expected Jesus to escape by divine power and to display divine power in deliverance, leaving the priests cheated of their purpose and Judas with the money to use for his own purpose.ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.25RED 45.2–46.1Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9 When he saw Jesus meekly submit to abuse and condemnation, he remembered His kindness, recognized the full extent of his crime, and was filled with remorse.ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.3
Though he had been with Christ through His ministry, witnessed His works, been included among those sent out with the apostles, and worked alongside them, association did not make him one with Christ.4T 41.1–42.1SG1 44.16T 264.2–265.1Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9 He had a divided heart, loved worldly praise and gain, never entrusted his eternal interests to Christ, maintained only superficial religion, and speculated for selfish profit.6T 264.2–265.1Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9 He was not teachable or willing to humble himself and submit to the Holy Spirit to keep his integrity.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 Christ loved him, freely received him, and sought to awaken his conscience and soften his heart so he would repent and be pardoned.Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 But his pride and stubbornness kept him from surrendering, he would not submit to counsel or reproof, and he went on in sin and thereby ruined himself, for forgiveness requires repentance.Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16Ms 4, 1875, par. 10–11
Warning for Believers
That one betrayer stood among the twelve does not erase the reality that the others were genuine disciples who loved Christ and sought to follow Him.4T 41.1–42.1 Judas stands as the type of a large class of professed Christians today, and his name has become the term for betrayal, unfaithfulness, and covetous opposition to Christ's work found even in churches and in sacred positions.6T 264.2–265.1Ms 91, 1899, par. 14–15Lt 189, 1909, par. 1Lt 28, 1888, par. 37–38 Though as near to Christ as anyone can be, he was ruined by Satan shutting his heart against practical sympathy, which is the test of purity and unselfishness of heart, and because association did not cultivate sincere sympathy for those for whom Christ gave His life he was left outside of Christ and the sport of temptation.6T 264.2–265.1 His case is therefore a warning to guard against the first deviation from righteousness and the first neglect to manifest the spirit of Christ, lest cultivated selfishness become a devouring passion which nothing but the power of Christ can subdue.6T 264.2–265.1 He is set forth as an example of a character opposed to the divine likeness, showing how covetousness can lead a disciple to oppose Christ's work and how those claiming faith and devotion can act against Christ by serving Satan and harming fellow believers.Ms 2, 1902, par. 7–8Lt 189, 1909, par. 1Lt 28, 1888, par. 37–38
He hid his selfishness under a pious, conscientious regard for the poor, wishing the ointment had been in his own possession so it would not be lavished upon the Saviour but could be applied to his own use and sold for money, prizing his Lord just enough to sell Him to wicked men for a few pieces of silver.1T 192.1 That bringing up of the poor as an excuse for selfishness is repeated by covetous professed Christians who hide their selfishness under put-on conscientiousness and oppose systematic benevolence.1T 192.1 His history warns that misusing the Lord's goods, keeping back gifts from the account and justifying it by deciding his work was underpaid, corrupts the conscience, and what is hidden from men costs the thief his soul.13MR 189.2–190.1 It warns that dishonest business practices and selfish speculation sacrifice Christ, for Judas with a divided heart loved worldly praise and gain, never entrusted his eternal interests to Christ, maintained only superficial religion, and betrayed his Master to the priests while wrongly assuming Jesus would not allow Himself to be taken, whereas genuine faith works through love and purifies the soul.Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9
Though he was with Jesus throughout His public ministry with opportunities to serve, and though Christ loved him, freely received him, and sought to awaken his conscience and soften his heart so he would repent and be pardoned, his pride and stubbornness kept him from surrendering and he went on in sin and thereby ruined himself, for forgiveness requires repentance.Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 After being reproved by the Lord before others he became provoked, resolved to take revenge, and sold his Lord for thirty pieces of silver, which warns against letting hatred and revenge take hold of the heart.Lt 12a, 1888, par. 14 His complaint about the woman who poured the ointment on Jesus displayed an accusing spirit revealing a heart unwilling to humble itself, and each such expression conforms character more closely to Satan, the great accuser.Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20 He shows that a person may remain connected with God for years, profess to keep God's law and be strict about some requirements while neglecting mercy and love, yet become more fixed in objectionable traits and be given over to a corrupt nature.Lt 6, 1880, par. 47
His call for the cheapest way and his question to what purpose is this waste reveal a narrow spirit that treats costly devotion to honor God as waste.5T 268.1–2 That same spirit objects when God's house is built well and furnished with costly materials.5T 268.1–2 God directed rich and careful work for the sanctuary in the wilderness to teach that He is a being of greatness and majesty to be worshiped with reverence and awe, not to be honored with cheapness.5T 268.1–2 When Judas objected to her act, Jesus defended Mary, and that defense supplied evidence that would be needed later that her deed was not to be reproved.Lt 189, 1909, par. 4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
55 sources
The verse names the speaker who objects to Mary's anointing at the Bethany supper as Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, the disciple who would betray Jesus.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 5, 1905ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899 He puts the ointment at three hundred pence and more, asks why it was not sold and given to the poor, and calls its pouring out waste.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889ST Oct 6, 1881 His plea is not care for the poor but the cover of a thief who carries the bag and takes from it, hiding covetousness, selfishness and desire to control the money for himself.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889 Christ vindicates Mary as having wrought a good work beforehand for His burial, and the rebuke offends Judas and turns him from that supper onward to bargain with the chief priests to deliver Jesus for thirty pieces of silver.ST Jun 16, 1887ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 10, 1911RH Nov 20, 1913ST Mar 27, 1901 Mary's costly gift from a heart broken by love stands opposite his spirit, showing that no sacrifice made for Christ is wasted and that knowingly cherished greed hardens the heart toward ruin.ST Jun 16, 1887ST Sep 20, 1899RH Oct 16, 1913ST
Supper at Bethany
The setting is Bethany six days before the Passover, as Jesus is on His way from Jericho to Jerusalem for the feast and has stopped for rest and refreshment, and this timing is used to date the events leading to the crucifixion.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Sep 20, 1899 The supper is made by Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus healed of leprosy, to show Jesus special honor, with Jesus and His friends invited as guests.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889 Jesus sits at the table with Simon, cured of a loathsome disease, on one side and Lazarus, raised from the dead, on the other, while Martha serves at the table and Mary earnestly listens to every word from His lips.ST Jul 22, 1886RH Oct 16, 1913 It is a gathering of trusted friends honoring Jesus shortly before His crucifixion, held in the house of Simon the leper.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889RH Mar 24, 1910
While Jesus reclines at meat, Mary brings an alabaster box of very precious ointment of spikenard, breaks the box and pours it upon His head and feet.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899RH Sep 17, 1901 She gives the best gift she has from a heart overflowing with love because she has received richest blessings from her Lord, in gratitude and deep devotion and homage moving her deed of love.ST Jul 22, 1886RH Sep 17, 1901 The fragrance of the ointment makes her hidden act known to all present, and her broken vase of stored nard poured out to touch her dearest Lord keeps spreading forever in its grace.ST Jul 22, 1886RH Nov 9, 1911 Her greatness is unseen now but will be shown in Christ's omniscient sight on the final day.RH Nov 9, 1911
The anointing is done before His burial and death, not afterward, for Mary honored the living Christ in gratitude for the great blessing He had given her.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Dec 20, 1905ST Feb 15, 1905 The costly ointment poured on Jesus before His burial illustrates the value of showing love and sympathy while a person is alive and able to be comforted, rather than waiting until after death.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Expressing love while He lived was better than waiting to place flowers on His tomb, and her offering did not keep her from ministering to the poor afterward.ST Jun 14, 1905
In its wider setting the verse stands within the section from John 11:30 through John 15, which contains the resurrection of Lazarus, the last public discourse, the acknowledgment from heaven, the institution of the ordinance of humility, the pointing out of the betrayer, and the first two chapters of the farewell discourse to the disciples.ST May 26, 1909 It stands in John's account of the triumphal entry and Christ's weeping over Jerusalem, one of four Gospel records of that scene with Matthew 21, Mark 11 and Luke 19, with Luke 19 giving the fullest account.ST
Judas Iscariot Identified
The one who speaks is one of Jesus' twelve disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon's son, who would betray Him.ST Apr 5, 1905ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899RH Dec 10, 1901 He is the disciple who speaks about Mary's act of anointing Jesus, the first to remark on her honoring of Jesus and the first to speak against it.ST Apr 5, 1905ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899ST Apr 5, 1905RH Dec 10, 1901 In that setting he criticized the use of the costly perfume because he coveted its value, objecting to the woman's costly gift and suggesting it be sold to give the money to the poor.ST Apr 5, 1905ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899RH Dec 10, 1901 His greed and yielding to temptation were already present before the Lord's Supper, for he was a thief.
The Simon who hosted the meal in Bethany was probably Judas's father.RH Dec 10, 1867 Judas was the chief instigator of the indignation over Mary's anointing, and his objection was driven by his desire to take the money for himself.RH Dec 10, 1867
Judas is treasurer of the united funds of the disciples, carrying the bag.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Oct 9, 1879ST Jul 22, 1886RH May 6, 1902 He is a capable man chosen to manage funds, called to be disciple and apostle, who served three years as treasurer and was considered loyal almost to the end, yet followed Jesus only outwardly and not in heart and truth.ST Jun 1, 1904RH May 6, 1902 He was a stranger to the deep devotion and homage that moved Mary's deed of love, and did not share it or care for the poor.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886RH May 6, 1902 As treasurer he had dishonestly taken for himself means meant for the service of God and intended for God's work, stealing money intended for others and for the poor.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Oct 9, 1879ST Jul 22, 1886RH May 6, 1902 He turned to the disciples to protest the use of the ointment and openly objected to it as wasteful, becoming the chief instigator of their displeasure, to hide his covetousness under apparent sympathy for the poor when in reality he cared nothing for them.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Oct 9, 1879ST Jul 22, 1886 His betrayal of Jesus was preceded by treachery toward the needy, and his greed culminated in selling Jesus for thirty pieces of silver, in which professing to follow Christ while greed and love of power consume him he becomes a prototype of the Man of Sin.RH May 6, 1902
Jesus knew his transgression and looked sorrowfully on him.ST Dec 18, 1893 Judas was given responsibility and the opportunity to learn from Jesus, but he cherished his sins, and covetousness cultivated over time had become the ruling trait in him and controlled him when temptation came.ST Dec 18, 1893ST Jun 3, 1897 Though he professed to follow Jesus, he was not a doer of Christ's words, stealing money intended for the poor and ultimately selling his Master.ST Dec 18, 1893ST Jun 3, 1897 His failure was his own choice, not a result of his circumstances, and Jesus' effort to help him fulfilled Scripture.ST Jun 3, 1897
Objection and Greed
Judas was the first of the disciples to remark upon Mary's act, and his was the chief voice that broke the peace at Bethany.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 5, 1905ST Mar 22, 1899RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 10, 1867 His complaint stirred indignation and murmuring against her among some of the other disciples, leading them to share his feeling and to distrust her devotion.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899 He valued the ointment at three hundred pence, or at more than three hundred pence, and asked why it had not been sold and given to the poor.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889ST Sep 20, 1899RH Dec 10, 1901 He called its use waste, treating costly honor shown to Christ as robbery of man.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Oct 6, 1881ST Sep 20, 1899
He spoke in this way not from care for the poor but as a thief who had the bag and took what was put into it.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889ST Sep 20, 1899 He dishonestly took means meant for God's service and the poor, stealing from the common store he carried.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 29, 1889ST Sep 20, 1899 His plea of apparent sympathy and prudent economy hid covetousness, selfishness and greed, with desire to control the proceeds for himself.ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 10, 1867 He coveted the value of the costly perfume and wanted the money for himself, and this showed him a stranger to Mary's devotion.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Oct 6, 1881RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 10, 1867 His objection over an ointment worth three hundred pence stands in contrast with his arranging Jesus' death for thirty pieces of silver.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jan 8, 1902
Rebuke Leads to Betrayal
Christ's answer to the complaint is Let her alone, vindicating Mary as having wrought a good work upon Him beforehand for His burial.ST Jun 16, 1887ST Sep 20, 1899RH Dec 3, 1867 No sacrifice made for Christ is wasted, and gifts given to Christ do not deprive the poor.ST Mar 27, 1901RH Dec 3, 1867 That vindication itself carries reproof for Judas, who had spoken against the offering.ST Jun 16, 1887ST Sep 20, 1899
The rebuke stings Judas because he feels slighted and wants recognition for his supposed wisdom and piety.ST Jan 10, 1911RH Nov 20, 1913ST Feb 14, 1906 Covetousness cultivated over time has become the ruling trait in him and controls him when temptation comes, and with it resentment of humiliation and reproof helps drive him toward grave wrongdoing.ST Jun 27, 1878ST Dec 18, 1893ST Feb 14, 1906 He begins contemplating betrayal from the Bethany supper onward where he was rebuked.ST Jan 10, 1911RH Nov 20, 1913ST Apr 19, 1905 After Lazarus is raised and the Jews determine to destroy Jesus, he sees opportunity both to gain money and to retaliate for his humiliation.ST Apr 19, 1905
From that time he goes to the chief priests to bargain to deliver Jesus for thirty pieces of silver and seeks opportunity to betray Him while still professing to be a disciple.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899 He is already preparing to sell Jesus even while criticizing Mary's gift from selfish desire for gain.ST Jan 21, 1897 He expects Jesus to escape His enemies by divine power, but seeing Him submit to abuse and condemnation makes him recognize the full extent of his crime and fills him with remorse.ST Jun 27, 1878
Cherishing covetousness leads him to betray his Lord for small financial gain and ultimately to ruin.STST Jun 11, 1896 His example shows how one knowingly cherished sin hardens the heart and opens the way to further sin.STST Jun 11, 1896 In professing to follow Christ outwardly but not in heart and truth while greed and love of power consume him, he becomes a prototype of the Man of Sin.
Mary's Gift Honored
Mary's offering stands in opposite spirit to Judas, for he does not tremble at God's word but chooses his own ways and finds no value in humble sacrifice, while hers is a heart subdued by grace and broken by love giving its costliest gift.ST Jun 16, 1887RH Oct 16, 1913 The worth of her Christian service lay in its motive rather than in any praise it might bring.ST Jun 16, 1887RH Oct 16, 1913 The anointing took place at the dinner given by Simon whom Jesus had cured of a loathsome disease, where Jesus sat at table with Simon on one side and Lazarus whom He had raised from the dead on the other to present saving truth to those gathered, and there Mary anointed His head and feet with precious ointment as a living example of His mighty power to set individuals free from the bondage of Satan.ST Jun 16, 1887RH Oct 16, 1913
Her act was Mary bringing an alabaster box of very precious ointment, breaking the box and pouring the stored nard out to touch her dearest Lord on His head from a heart overflowing with love because she had received richest blessings from Him.RH Oct 16, 1913RH Nov 9, 1911RH Sep 17, 1901 That act of love keeps spreading forever, unseen in its greatness now but to be shown in Christ's omniscient sight on the final day.RH Nov 9, 1911RH Sep 17, 1901 Because He gave the best He had for them, His life with a broken heart and poured-out precious blood, and from His throne of glory now lavishes the best gifts of His love upon them, all are called to bring their best things to Christ.RH Nov 9, 1911RH Sep 17, 1901
The lesson contrasts the sacrifices of Christ's true disciples with the worldly-minded view that honoring Christ is wasteful, for material spent in His honor is a profitable investment.ST Jun 7, 1899ST May 31, 1899 In that episode Mary's costly gift to Jesus was opposed as wasteful, showing how the rule of money can restrict loving deeds.ST Jun 7, 1899ST May 31, 1899 Christ's answer puts Christ first and the poor afterward, for Judas's plea to sell the ointment and give to the poor stands for humanity, giving for humanity's sake, which would have done well by giving three hundred people the temporal satisfaction of a pennyworth of bread each, while Mary's giving to Christ for Christ's sake did better, bringing eternal good by cheering and encouraging millions who read of her devotion and Christ's tenderness.ST Jun 7, 1899ST May 31, 1899ST Jul 15, 1886
Reason judged the costly gift poured out in love for Jesus to be misspent, but love moved the worshiper to give lavishly, and love — not financial calculation — must guide judgments and actions.ST Jan 10, 1906RH Feb 27, 1908 Judas was covetous when the costly ointment was offered, able only to calculate its value, unlike those who had received Christ's pardoning love, who would give freely and regret only that their offering was not richer.ST Jan 10, 1906RH Feb 27, 1908 His treating the generous act as waste is set against Noah's costly offering of gratitude, for he would have been unable to bear seeing Noah sacrifice a seventh of his remaining valuable animals.ST Jan 10, 1906RH Feb 27, 1908
Warning and Application
Judas spoke of selling the ointment and giving to the poor as a pretext while seeking to get the money for himself, and this warns deacons and all stewards against greed and dishonest concern for charity.RH Sep 27, 1870 His apparently prudent economy must not be taken as proof of good character, for judging a person by one seemingly good act of economy can mislead, as his later end revealed.RH Sep 27, 1870RH Dec 4, 1860
As one of the disciples who would betray Jesus, his criticism of Mary's costly gift shows how selfishness can wound and crush another person's loving act, and it stands as the counterpart to those who criticize generous gifts to God's cause.ST Dec 10, 1894ST Sep 26, 1911RH Dec 10, 1901 His suggestion that her only precious box broken on the living Saviour should have been sold and given to the poor is cold censure that freezes acts of love before they find expression, as when a timid wife is stopped from helping the needy or children are restrained from expressing childish love for Christ.RH Dec 10, 1901 That cold, unfeeling spirit is not of heaven but comes from beneath, while Jesus' answer, Let her alone, defends Mary's way of manifesting love and teaches in all such cases to let people alone to follow the good promptings of the Spirit, for God is able to guide them, and much more would be done for God if the rebuke were heeded.RH Dec 10, 1901
The voice that broke the peace at Bethany with the murmur about waste was his, though he was not the only one with indignation at this honor done to Jesus, valuing the ointment at more than three hundred pence that might have been sold and given to the poor and setting humanity and relief of human wants against devotion to Jesus.RH Dec 3, 1867 The same Judas-spirit speaks in an age that measures everything by utility and would call such honor waste better bestowed elsewhere, against which plea Jesus defends Mary with let her alone, declaring she hath wrought a good work upon him.RH Dec 3, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 His cry, Why this waste, treats costly honor paid to Christ, suffering for Christ, and anything laid on the altar of God as robbery of man, pleading that the ointment should be spent on the poor rather than broken to the Lord.RH Dec 3, 1867 It is spurious, Christless philanthropy, specious hypocrisy and essential self-seeking that hides the bag under a flowing robe, considering man and his interest only while leaving Christ himself out of view, and the same Judas-cry is raised whenever honor to Christ is in question.RH Dec 3, 1867 Failure to speak of what she hath done as a memorial of her reveals a radical defect of cold, mechanical religion wanting in appreciation of Christ and love to himself.RH Dec 3, 1867
The word waste spoken when the alabaster box was broken and the precious ointment poured out and condemned as waste is the same word of waste of time, money, and life spoken against missionary work for black men in Africa.ST Jun 29, 1904
His serving as treasurer among the disciples for three years and being considered loyal almost to the end shows that position and past service did not prove present loyalty.ST Jun 1, 1904 Though professing to follow Jesus he was not a doer of His words, for as a capable man chosen to manage the united funds he did not care for the poor, and his betrayal of Jesus was preceded by treachery toward the needy.RH May 6, 1902 As a thief who used the trust given him for personal gain, his criticism of Mary for anointing Jesus offended him when Jesus reproved him, and together with his covetousness this helped lead him to betray Jesus for money, showing how covetousness and resentment of reproof can lead to grave wrongdoing.ST Feb 14, 1906ST Jun 1, 1904RH May 6, 1902
The account of disciples trying to control access to Christ stands against those who claim exclusive authority to guard Christ and His grace rather than allowing souls to come directly to Him.ST Apr 16, 1896
Sources