John 12:6
This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bare what was put therein.
Translations
This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bore what was put therein.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bare what was put therein.
This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bore what was put in it.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Now this he said, not because he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and having the bag took away what was put therein.
and he said this, not because he was caring for the poor, but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and what things were put in he was carrying.
But he said this, not that he cared for the poor, but because he was a thief and had the bag, and carried what was put into [ it].
Howbeit he said this, not that, for the destitute, he cared, but because, a thief, he was, and holding, the bag, used to carry away, what was cast therein.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Judas did not say this because he cared about the poor, but because he was a thief. As keeper of the money bag, he used to take from what was put into it.
Now he said this, not because he cared for the poor, but because he was a thief, and having the money box, used to steal what was put into it.
( He said this, not because he had any love for the poor; but because he was a thief, and, having the money-bag, took for himself what was put into it.)
Nowe he said this, not that he cared for the poore, but because hee was a theefe, and had the bagge, and bare that which was giuen.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Now he said this, not because he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and having the purse, carried the things that were put therein.
Pictures


Cross-references 20 of 22
- Matthew 26:8-16
But when his disciples saw it, they had indignation, saying, To what purpose is this waste?
Judas criticizes the costly anointing as wasted on the poor, then arranges to betray Jesus.
- Mark 14:4-5
And there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said, Why was this waste of the ointment made?
Judas objects that the perfume could have been sold to help the poor.
- Matthew 26:14-16
Then one of the twelve, called Judas Iscariot, went unto the chief priests,
Judas’s greed leads him to accept silver for betraying Jesus.
- Mark 14:8
She hath done what she could: she is come aforehand to anoint my body to the burying.
Mary did what she could, anointing Jesus beforehand for burial.
- Matthew 27:3-5
Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders,
Judas’s hidden dishonesty is followed by remorse and his death by hanging.
- John 13:29
For some of them thought, because Judas had the bag, that Jesus had said unto him, Buy those things that we have need of against the feast; or, that he should give something to the poor.
The disciples thought Judas might use the money bag to give to the poor.
- Mark 14:10-11
And Judas Iscariot, one of the twelve, went unto the chief priests, to betray him unto them.
Judas seeks an opportunity to hand Jesus over for payment.
- Luke 22:3-6
Then entered Satan into Judas surnamed Iscariot, being of the number of the twelve.
Judas agreed to betray Jesus for money.
- Matthew 26:12
For in that she hath poured this ointment on my body, she did it for my burial.
The anointing is linked to Jesus’ burial.
- John 13:27
And after the sop Satan entered into him. Then said Jesus unto him, That thou doest, do quickly.
Judas’s earlier theft precedes Satan’s entry and Jesus’ command at the supper.
- Matthew 26:9
For this ointment might have been sold for much, and given to the poor.
Both mention the plea to sell the ointment and give the money to the poor.
- John 13:26
Jesus answered, He it is, to whom I shall give a sop, when I have dipped it. And when he had dipped the sop, he gave it to Judas Iscariot, the son of Simon.
Jesus gave Judas the sop knowing his character.
- Exodus 20:15
Thou shalt not steal.
thief among disciples does not relax it
- John 6:70
Jesus answered them, Have not I chosen you twelve, and one of you is a devil?
Jesus identifies one of the twelve as a devil, foreshadowing Judas’s betrayal.
- John 6:11
And Jesus took the loaves; and when he had given thanks, he distributed to the disciples, and the disciples to them that were set down; and likewise of the fishes as much as they would.
Judas distributed the food whose value he later calculated.
- Matthew 26:48-49
Now he that betrayed him gave them a sign, saying, Whomsoever I shall kiss, that same is he: hold him fast.
Judas betrays Jesus with a kiss.
- Matthew 26:21-22
And as they did eat, he said, Verily I say unto you, that one of you shall betray me.
The disciples did not suspect Judas among them as the betrayer.
- John 13:5
After that he poureth water into a bason, and began to wash the disciples’ feet, and to wipe them with the towel wherewith he was girded.
Jesus washed Judas’s feet knowing he was a thief.
- Luke 7:36-50
And one of the Pharisees desired him that he would eat with him. And he went into the Pharisee’s house, and sat down to meat.
Luke’s account also mentions the anointing of Jesus’ feet.
- Luke 22:35-36
And he said unto them, When I sent you without purse, and scrip, and shoes, lacked ye any thing? And they said, Nothing.
shows later permission to carry a purse
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
53 sources
Judas protested Mary's pouring of costly ointment valued at three hundred pence at the Bethany supper six days before the Passover, claiming it should have been sold for the poor.ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3SG1 44.16T 310.1–2 His plea was pretense hiding covetousness and greed, for as keeper of the disciples' common purse he secretly stole what was put in it and wanted the price under his own control for his own use.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2Lt 167, 1897, par. 51T 192.14RED 108.2–109.2 Entrusted with the little fund to supply the company and relieve the poor, he yielded to continual temptation to take small sums, excused himself that his service was underpaid, and cherished avarice until it corrupted his character.ST Jul 22, 1886Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38ST Jul 22, 188613MR 189.2–190.1DA 717.2 His covetousness, unhealed by daily nearness to Christ's unselfish life and teaching, broke out at the rebuke over Mary's devotion and ripened into revenge and the betrayal of his Lord for thirty pieces of silver.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3DA 720.1DA 717.2ST Jun 27, 1878Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44 His course warns that secret misuse of entrusted means and professed care for the poor covering selfishness strengthens until it brings the whole man under Satan and leads to betrayal and loss of eternal life.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–386T 264.2–265.1Lt 110, 1897, par. 9–14Ms 91, 1899, par. 14–15
Setting at Bethany
The saying belongs to what happened six days before the Passover, when Jesus on His way from Jericho to Jerusalem to attend the feast stopped at the house of Lazarus in Bethany, choosing this retreat for rest and refreshment.ST Jul 22, 1886 The supper there was made by Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus had healed of leprosy, to show his Master special honor, with Jesus sitting at table with Simon on one side and Lazarus, whom He had raised from the dead, on the other.ST Jul 22, 1886 While Martha served at the table, Mary earnestly listened to every word that fell from the lips of Jesus.ST Jul 22, 1886
The words were spoken on an occasion just before His betrayal and death.Ms 175, 1905, par. 2 The verse itself names Judas as a thief in charge of the bag, while the surrounding narrative supplies only the setting of the Bethany feast.DA 557.1–2 The matter at issue was Mary's pouring of costly precious ointment upon Jesus from a broken alabaster box, an act of self-giving service that Judas in angry protest priced at three hundred pence and proposed should have been sold and given to the poor.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3SG1 44.16T 310.1–2
Plea and Theft
Judas's protest over Mary's anointing — asking why the ointment was not sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor — was not from care for the poor but a pretense hiding covetousness, greed and selfishness.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2Lt 167, 1897, par. 5DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.1 He was a thief who kept the disciples' common money bag and secretly took for himself what was put in it.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2Lt 167, 1897, par. 5DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.1 His objection to the costly gift reflected that thieving greed, and he valued Jesus himself only enough to betray Him for silver.DA 558.4–560.1CET 172.2–173.1
If the ointment had been sold and its price put into the purse, the poor would have received no benefit.DA 558.4–560.1RH Aug 7, 1900 He wanted the ointment in his own possession rather than lavished upon the Saviour, wanting the money placed under his control so he could apply it to his own use.1T 192.14RED 108.2–109.2Lt 189, 1909, par. 2–3 His heart coveted the ointment and was set upon earthly treasure, hiding selfishness under a pious, conscientious regard for the poor, desiring to sell it for money and use the proceeds for himself.1T 192.14RED 108.2–109.2Lt 189, 1909, par. 2–3
He put a price upon all his actions and paid himself according to his own selfish estimate, judging them by what he could gain for himself.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.1–2 In doing the little essential things connected with Christ and His brethren he exacted payment to the last penny for every act he did, doing some little service and then paying himself out of the treasury.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3Lt 167, 1897, par. 5Lt 166a, 1897, par. 5 Keeping money held in trust for oneself is theft, including contracting for work at one price, paying the poor worker less, and keeping the difference while already being paid wages for one's own time, which robs a poor man.Lt 166a, 1897, par. 5 Using entrusted money for self-payment is done with no right, like cutting down the wages of other men to keep them from getting more than one thinks they should have.Ms 94, 1901, par. 12 Heavenly courts keep faithful true accounts through an unseen bookkeeper, and each man will be judged by those figures, not by the estimate he places on his own work.Ms 94, 1901, par. 12
Covetous Heart Exposed
He had been made treasurer of the united funds of the disciples because of his financial ability, to provide for the needs of the little company and to meet the needs of Jesus and the disciples and to relieve the poor, a ministry to others that could have built an unselfish spirit in him.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886DA 717.2Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44 The small sums passing through his hands were a continual temptation, and he often took small sums for himself, secretly keeping sums off the account and concealing the amounts he appropriated.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1DA 717.2Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 He saw to it that all money received was placed in his hands, then felt free to use it when and where he pleased without consulting anyone, and he grumbled when asked to give from the bag for the poor.Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44 He excused the theft to himself by saying his work was not sufficiently appreciated and his labor was underpaid, paying himself out of the fund for little service done for Christ or time given to religious purposes and deciding he deserved more pay, yet in God's sight he was a thief and this self-serving reasoning perverted his conscience.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1DA 717.2Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 His covetousness was cherished and cultivated until avarice grew into a prominent feature of his character, and repeated indulgence of avarice turned small acts of selfishness into theft of a sacred trust, corrupting his conscience and character.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1ST Mar 5, 1912Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7
He was a stranger to the deep devotion and homage that moved Mary, with a carnal heart that was close and covetous and loved money, selfish and not attentive to the comforts and wants of Jesus.SG1 44.1ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886 He often referred to the poor to excuse his covetousness and often appropriated to his own use what was entrusted to his care to be given to the poor, hiding covetousness under apparent sympathy for them and in reality caring nothing for them.SG1 44.1ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886 That embezzling of money put in the bag appropriated to their relief showed utter want of feeling for the poor and oppression of the widow, the orphan, and the hireling.4RED 110.2 He was entrusted with the money bag despite his dishonesty and greed, and that responsibility tested his heart and exposed his true character, for when greed is cherished circumstances reveal the corruption within.20MR 146.4 His love of money led him to idolize the little treasure entrusted to his care, which was to be employed for the benefit of the church and to relieve the necessities of the poor, treating it as an object of devotion and holding his covetousness fast as a precious treasure.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.3
Road to Betrayal
Even after walking with Christ through His whole ministry, his covetousness was never cured but was held fast as a precious treasure and grew ever more confirmed, while Christ's lessons on unselfishness went unheeded.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3DA 717.220MR 146.3 Daily listening to Christ and seeing His unselfish life and unselfish example did not overcome him, and instead of heeding that teaching he worked against the principles continually set before the disciples.DA 717.2Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44Lt 110, 1897, par. 9–14 He excused his taking from the fund as pay for little service done for Christ or time given to religious purposes, excusing himself in his own eyes while in God's sight he was a thief.DA 717.2Ms 106, 1903, par. 43–44
His ruling sins of selfishness, ambition and love of money were what Jesus sought to bring home to his conscience to lead him to repent, but he persisted in justifying and hiding his wrong and refused to surrender.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–3Ms 2, 1883, par. 15–16 The other disciples did not know at the time that he was a thief, but they knew it afterward.Ms 47, 1897, par. 2–320MR 146.3 Jesus knew his true character and could have pointed him out to the disciples, exposed his hypocrisy and raised their indignation against him, yet He refrained from exposing him and reproached him in such a way as to leave him no excuse for his future betrayal.4RED 110.2
His covetousness came fully to the surface when Mary anointed Jesus, and Jesus' rebuke of that covetousness wounded his pride and fed his desire for revenge.DA 720.1ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.25RED 45.2–46.1 Provoked at being corrected before others and angered by the reproof, he yielded to Satan and chose revenge, and that rebuked covetousness helped make him willing to betray his Master for money.ST Jun 27, 18783SP 125.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 14 He would not submit to correction or counsel.Ms 4, 1875, par. 10–11
He prized his Lord only highly enough to sell Him to wicked men for a few pieces of silver, for thirty pieces of silver.CET 172.2–173.1EW 228.2SG1 181.11T 192.1 He reasoned that Christ would deliver Himself from His enemies and that he himself would make a shrewd gain, moved in part by revenge because Christ had not endorsed all his movements, and his satanic cupidity cost him his life.Ms 120a, 1901, par. 6–7 He robbed the treasury to enrich himself, appropriating what belonged to another contrary to the law of God, and his stealing led on to selling Jesus.Ms 120a, 1901, par. 6–7Lt 9, 1899, par. 1–8 His terrible end remains as a warning against covetousness till the close of time.Ms 120a, 1901, par. 6–7
Contrast With Mary
Mary's generous act from gratitude was a most cutting rebuke to his covetous disposition, and he condemned her for anointing Christ with precious ointment and became the cause of the severe judgment passed upon her.SG1 44.1Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.14RED 110.2 He complained in anger about the costly ointment poured upon Jesus, not from care for the poor but as an excuse for covetousness, hypocrisy and theft.SG1 44.1Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.14RED 110.2 His heart was carnal, close and covetous and loving money, selfish and not attentive to the comforts and wants of Jesus, though Satan deceived him to think himself a true disciple after seeing mighty works through his ministry and yielding to evidence that Jesus was the Messiah.SG1 44.1 He often referred to the poor to excuse his covetousness, while often appropriating to his own use what was entrusted to his care to be given to the poor, embezzling money put in the bag appropriated to their relief and showing utter want of feeling for the poor and oppression of the widow, the orphan, and the hireling.SG1 44.14RED 110.2 As carrier of the money bag containing gifts for Christ's work he stole from it, secretly keeping sums off the account, and excused his theft by telling himself his work was not sufficiently appreciated and that he deserved more pay, but dishonesty corrupted his conscience and character and self-justification did not excuse the theft.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–3813MR 189.2–190.1 Jesus knew his true character and could have pointed him out to the disciples, revealed his hypocrisy, and raised their indignation against him, but refrained from exposing him and reproached him in such a way as to give him no excuse for his future betrayal.4RED 110.2 Had he yielded to the Holy Spirit, he would have remained honest and would not have condemned Mary for anointing Christ with costly ointment.13MR 189.2–190.1
His plea against Mary's offering was a pretext arising from covetousness rather than sincere appeal on behalf of the poor, while Jesus defended her act as a good work and taught that Christ should be honored with the best of one's possessions and that caring for the poor should not lead to neglect of God's cause.4T 550.4 Her precious gift to the Saviour in the broken alabaster box was self-giving service led by the Holy Spirit and noted in the books of heaven.6T 310.1–2 Its influence has inspired many to loving service, and in the day of God she will be permitted to behold all that her life has wrought and will rejoice in it.6T 310.1–2 Her anointing was a demonstration of her love for Christ, and His words declare that her act joins her with Him and with the gospel throughout all time.Lt 135, 1897, par. 15–16
As covetous he could calculate the value of the costly ointment, unlike those who receive salvation and regret only that their offering was not richer and more valuable.4T 485.1
Warning for Today
Covetousness and secret misuse of what belongs to God's work eat away integrity and open the way to betrayal of His cause and loss of eternal life.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38 The thief who carried the bag with gifts for Christ's work and secretly kept sums off the account excused himself by feeling his labor was not appreciated and not sufficiently paid, yet that dishonesty corrupted conscience and character and led him to condemn Mary for anointing Christ.Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38 His course stands as an example of how covetousness and corruption contaminate workers placed in positions of trust in God's cause.Ms 91, 1899, par. 14–15 His complaint exposed an accusing spirit and a heart unwilling to humble itself, for even under Christ's lessons he was not converted.Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20 Refusing the meekness of a little child leaves one unfit for the kingdom of heaven, and repeated accusation shapes character after Satan's pattern.Ms 35, 1893, par. 18–20
He reveals the uncorrected natural tendency of man, professing care for the poor while stealing from the bag, at once deceiving and being deceived.Lt 65, 1897, par. 23 His course illustrates the deceptive influences that will continue until the close of time and the spiritual blindness of every soul in which Christ does not abide, showing the need for renewing of the mind to transform character.Lt 65, 1897, par. 23 Selfishness strengthened by exercise at last brings the whole man under the jurisdiction of Satan, as with Judas, whose profession of concern covered covetous selfishness and whose spirit, though privileged with connection to Christ as a disciple, did not agree with the principles continually set before the disciples but worked against them.Lt 110, 1897, par. 9–14 The same longing for personal advantage marks those who put self-interest first, refuse self-denying sacrifice, demand stipulated wages, and seek to buy below real value and sell for gain.Lt 110, 1897, par. 9–14 Those who like Judas set their hearts upon earthly treasure complain as he did, bringing forward the poor as an excuse for selfishness and hiding covetousness under put-on conscientiousness and pious regard for the poor, wishing the ointment in his own possession to apply to his own use and sell for money, and prizing his Lord only enough to sell Him for a few pieces of silver.1T 192.1 His conduct also stands as an example of the Judas-like influence that can arise in churches.Lt 189, 1909, par. 1
Outward place among the disciples did not mean practicing Christ's words or having true concern for others, for the claim to care for the poor concealed selfishness and covetousness and theft from the entrusted bag.Lt 28, 1888, par. 37–38Lt 63a, 1893, par. 18–21 That outward concern hid a heart far from God, an unsanctified heart devoid of mercy and justice and the love of God.Ms 2, 1902, par. 7–8Lt 28, 1888, par. 37–38 He is an example of one who can remain connected with God and profess to keep His law while becoming more firmly settled in objectionable traits, where exactness about some points does not make up for neglecting the weightier matters of mercy and love, until given over to a corrupt nature.Lt 6, 1880, par. 47 That same character is reproduced when men entrusted with human souls deal with them in a way God does not approve, placing a wrong mold upon those in their charge by acting as directors and judges and lawyers instead of fathers, molding character after Judas and Cain rather than after the divine similitude, so the Lord is not served or glorified in the work.Ms 2, 1902, par. 7–8 Men chosen to oversee caring for the poor and the proper distribution of means so that none among believers suffer for the necessaries of life must not work in a scheming, underhand manner for self, but faithfully and unselfishly for others as men of honest report, full of the Holy Ghost and wisdom, unlike him who robbed the treasury to enrich himself.Lt 9, 1899, par. 1–8 The verse thus exposes dishonest handling of shared funds, matching selfish financial speculation and betrayal.Lt 40, 1901, par. 7–9
Satan ruined him by closing his heart to the needs of others to prevent the expression of love and sympathy.6T 264.2–265.1 Practical sympathy is a test of purity and unselfishness of heart, while Satan works to make people unmoved by the sight of suffering.6T 264.2–265.1 He represents a large class of professed Christians today, so his case must be studied, for people now are as near to Christ as Judas was, yet if association with Christ does not make them one with Him and cultivate sincere sympathy for those for whom Christ gave His life, they are in the same danger as Judas of being outside Christ as the sport of Satan's temptations.6T 264.2–265.1 The first deviation from righteousness must be guarded, for one transgression and one neglect to manifest the spirit of Christ opens the way for another until the mind is overmastered by the principles of the enemy and cultivated selfishness becomes a devouring passion which nothing but the power of Christ can subdue.6T 264.2–265.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
84 sources
The verse lays bare that the protest over Mary's ointment did not spring from care for the poor but from theft, for the speaker kept the common money bag and took from what was put into it.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899 His talk of the poor was a false cover for covetousness and selfishness, wanting the worth of three hundred pence in his own hands for his own use.ST Oct 6, 1881ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jun 7, 1899RH Dec 10, 1867 Entrusted as treasurer of the funds of Jesus and the disciples, he repeatedly stole means meant for God's service and for relief of the poor, widows and orphans.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Oct 9, 1879ST May 6, 1889RH Apr 23, 1861RH Jun 25, 1901 That cherished greed hardened until it overpowered every good trait, and, stung by rebuke over Mary's selfless devotion, ripened into willingness to betray his Master for silver.ST Jun 27, 1878ST Nov 22, 1883RH Jan 6, 1910RH Nov 20, 1913ST Feb 14, 1906 Yet Jesus knew him to be a thief and a betrayer and still forbore to expose him, while nothing given to honor Christ is ever wasted, and turning mercy to the poor into an excuse for greed is a Christless philanthropy that withholds worship from the Lord.ST May 20, 1897ST Oct 9, 1879ST Mar 27, 1901RH Sep 17, 1914RH Nov 16, 1916
Setting at Bethany
Six days before the Passover Jesus stopped at the house of Lazarus in Bethany on His way from Jericho to Jerusalem to attend the feast, choosing this retreat for rest and refreshment.ST Jul 22, 1886 The supper was made by Simon of Bethany, whom Jesus had healed of leprosy, to show his Master special honor, with Jesus sitting at table with Simon on one side and Lazarus, whom He had raised from the dead, on the other, while Martha served at the table and Mary earnestly listened to every word that fell from His lips.ST Jul 22, 1886RH Oct 16, 1913
While Jesus reclined at dinner at Simon's house, Mary came unobserved from behind with a very precious alabaster box of ointment and broke it on Jesus' feet out of gratitude for the forgiveness of her great sins, wiping His feet with her long hair and kissing them with fast-falling tears.RH Dec 10, 1901RH Mar 24, 1910ST Nov 17, 1898 She hastened because she had heard rumors He might be taken away and feared she might have no other chance to show her love.RH Dec 10, 1901 The gathering gave Jesus opportunity to present saving truth and displayed His power to free people from Satan's bondage.RH Oct 16, 1913 The anointing harmonizes with the accounts in Luke and Matthew with different details, Luke and John mentioning the anointing of His feet and Matthew mentioning His head.ST May 12, 1914 It belongs to Mary anointing Jesus with costly spikenard before His burial a few days before the crucifixion, after which Jesus spoke in her defense.ST May 12, 1914STRH Mar 24, 1910
Words Exposing Motive
John's explanation strips away any idea that Judas spoke out of compassion when he complained that the ointment should have been sold and its value given to the poor, for he did not care for the poor at all but was a thief who carried the disciples' money bag and took for himself what was put into it.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 5, 1905ST Sep 24, 1912 The same exposure is repeated wherever the supper at Bethany is considered, that his objection to Mary's costly gift and his talk of selling it for the poor came from no concern for them but from thievery over the common store.ST Mar 22, 1899ST Mar 22, 1899ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 5, 1905ST Jul 29, 1889 His plea for the poor was hypocrisy and false pretense, a cover under which he hid covetousness, selfishness and meanness behind apparent sympathy while posing as liberal and virtuous.ST May 20, 1897ST Oct 6, 1881ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jun 7, 1899ST Apr 24, 1893 That professed sympathy was not genuine, but a selfish and covetous pretext by which he used concern for the poor to excuse greed.ST May 20, 1897RH Aug 7, 1900ST Oct 6, 1881ST Sep 20, 1899ST Apr 24, 1893
What moved him was desire to get the money himself for selfish use, coveting what was spent on the ointment and longing to bring its value, worth three hundred pence, into his own hands.ST May 6, 1889ST Oct 9, 1879ST Oct 9, 1879RH Dec 10, 1867 He did not want the ointment sold for the sake of the poor but wanted its proceeds for himself, hiding that covetousness behind a worthy-sounding motive while secretly taking funds intended for God's work.ST May 6, 1889ST Oct 9, 1879ST Oct 9, 1879RH Dec 10, 1867 His insinuations carried weight beyond himself, for as one who knew nothing of Mary's love and homage he deceived his fellow disciples by this pretense, becoming the prime instigator of disaffection and turning them to look distrustfully on her devotion.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889ST Oct 9, 1879 A stranger to the deep devotion and homage that moved her, he hid his own covetousness under apparent sympathy for the poor while caring nothing for them.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889
Even if the ointment had been sold, the poor would not have benefited from the proceeds, because his greed controlled the bag he held.RH Aug 7, 1900 Gifts given to Christ do not cause the poor to suffer, and a sacrifice made for Him is not wasteful nor does it prevent truly benevolent work afterward, as Mary's honoring of the living Christ out of gratitude did not prevent her from ministering to the poor after He was gone.ST Jun 14, 1905ST Mar 27, 1901 In this he turned the gospel principle of mercy to the poor into an excuse for greed, objecting to the anointing on the plea that it was waste.ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 That cry of waste is the pattern of a spurious, Christless philanthropy that treats anything suffered for Christ or laid on God's altar as robbery of man, leaving Christ Himself out of view and withholding direct honor, love and worship from the Lord under plea of spending it on the poor or using service for man or for the church as a guise to refuse Him the broken alabaster box.RH Dec 3, 1867
The contrast fixes his valuation in memory, for he who priced the ointment at three hundred pence devised Christ's death for thirty pence.ST Jan 8, 1902
Thief Keeping Bag
John 12:6 identifies Judas as the appointed treasurer of the united funds of Jesus and the disciples, entrusted with carrying the money bag and receiving and holding the offerings placed in it.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889ST Jun 5, 1884RH Apr 23, 1861 His office gave him charge of the shared purse and continual opportunity to practice the dishonesty rooted in his covetousness.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889ST Jun 5, 1884ST He dishonestly appropriated to himself means designed for the service of God, stealing for himself money meant for that service until avarice overpowered every good trait in him.ST Jul 22, 1886ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889ST Nov 22, 1883ST He repeatedly stole from the Lord's scanty common store to supply what he desired above his fellows, taking money entrusted to him instead of using it for its intended purpose.ST Jul 22, 1886ST May 6, 1889ST Nov 22, 1883RH Jan 6, 1910ST
He embezzled money placed in the common bag for relief of the poor, including funds given for the poor and meant to help widows, orphans, and hired workers.ST Oct 9, 1879ST Jun 5, 1884ST May 6, 1889STST Jun 3, 1897 In so doing he oppressed the widow, the orphan, and the hireling while professing care for them.ST Oct 9, 1879ST May 6, 1889ST Jun 3, 1897 The money in the bag shows that Jesus and the disciples received help for their needs.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Oct 30, 1913ST Jun 23, 1914 It was kept to purchase food and other needful articles for the Master and His fellow disciples, to carry the little money collected for the poor, and to meet the necessary expenses of Christ and the disciples in their preaching work and in advancing the light of the gospel.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Oct 30, 1913ST Jun 23, 1914
His trusted position stands in contrast with his sin and hypocrisy as a thief who stole from the bag.RH Dec 7, 1916ST Jun 1, 1904ST Nov 4, 1897 He served as treasurer among the disciples for three years and was considered loyal almost to the end, yet trusted position and past service did not prove present loyalty to God.RH Dec 7, 1916ST Jun 1, 1904ST Nov 4, 1897 Even one entrusted with the disciples' money and given opportunity to do good could prove false to Christ.RH Dec 7, 1916ST Jun 1, 1904ST Nov 4, 1897 His professed loyalty concealed selfish ambition and greed, for he followed while longing for position as treasurer so he could handle the kingdom's gold.ST Oct 4, 1910RH Jan 6, 1910ST Oct 4, 1910 He took pride in carrying the money bag and boasted of his supposed wisdom, even while stealing from its contents.ST Oct 4, 1910ST Oct 4, 1910
Covetousness Ripening to Betrayal
His stealing grew out of selfishness and greed cherished and cultivated through all his time with Jesus until avarice became the prominent feature of his character, overpowering every good trait and hardening into cruelty.ST Mar 5, 1912ST Nov 22, 1883RH Jan 6, 1910ST Jun 11, 1896RH Nov 23, 1916 He had no care for the poor but repeatedly took for himself from the Lord's scanty common store to supply what he desired above his fellows, and his plea for them was only deception and excuse for covetousness.ST Mar 5, 1912ST Dec 18, 1893ST Nov 22, 1883RH Jan 6, 1910ST Jun 11, 1896 While the other disciples were true in heart to Jesus, his heart was covetous for money, longing even as he watched rich gifts of gold cast into the temple treasury for wealth he could not touch and holding secret greedy thoughts he dared not speak aloud.RH Nov 23, 1916 His fall came despite three years of witnessing miracles and hearing teaching, ending in suicide, a warning against avarice.ST Nov 4, 1889
His trust as treasurer gave him opportunity to practice the dishonesty rooted in that covetousness and was a continual temptation to him.ST Jun 5, 1884RH Oct 30, 1913 From time to time when he did a little service for Christ or devoted a little time to religious purposes he paid himself out of the meager fund collected to advance the light of the gospel.RH Oct 30, 1913 When temptation came that ruling desire overcame his other traits, and he yielded to evil while professing to follow Jesus without doing what Jesus taught.ST Dec 18, 1893 He had some good qualities and, by listening to the discourses, a favorable opportunity to see his wrongs and become acquainted with his defects if he really desired to be a true disciple, placed where he could choose either to develop his covetous disposition or to see and correct it.RH Oct 30, 1913
What happened around Mary's gift began to reveal his real character through outward actions, for her selfless devotion shamed his selfishness.ST Mar 27, 1901 His covetousness, rebuked by Jesus, together with resentment at reproof and humiliation for being exposed, helped make him willing to betray his Master for silver.ST Jun 27, 1878RH Nov 20, 1913ST Feb 14, 1906 After the anointing at Bethany he saw opportunity to make money and retaliate for his humiliation, especially once the leaders had determined to destroy Jesus after the raising of Lazarus, so his betrayal was not sudden.ST Apr 19, 1905 His resentment at the rebuke grew into a decision to betray for money.RH Nov 20, 1913ST Feb 14, 1906
He was double-minded and seeking temporal advantage, wanting to stand in favor with both sides by keeping friendship with Jesus while gaining favor with the chief priests.RH Jan 6, 1910 He saw delivering Jesus to them as opportunity to reimburse himself for what he had lost by joining Jesus' cause.RH Jan 6, 1910 His betrayal of the poor revealed his character and prepared the way for his betrayal of Christ.RH May 6, 1902 His office as treasurer connects with his being chosen to betray Christ, and his interest in money even led him to reckon the value of the food Jesus supplied.ST Apr 13, 1882ST Oct 25, 1910
He is thief and traitor who betrayed Jesus with a kiss, and though he followed Jesus and heard His words he coveted money including the silver paid for his Master.ST Jan 31, 1911 His attachment to the bag held him down after his fall, for he could not rise while clinging to sin.RH Dec 16, 1909 A little of the world in the heart weighs heavily, and rising again requires repentance and giving up the sin.RH Dec 16, 1909
Jesus Knowing Yet Forbearing
Jesus knew all along that the keeper of the bag was a thief and knew he would betray Him, yet He washed his feet and handed him the sop at supper.RH Sep 17, 1914RH Nov 16, 1916 He disclosed nothing of that character to the other disciples and gave no hint to awaken their suspicion of dishonesty, so that when He said one of them would betray Him they all asked, Is it I.ST Oct 9, 1879ST May 6, 1889RH Oct 23, 1913RH Nov 16, 1916 By keeping back exposure He left Judas with no excuse for his later betrayal.ST Oct 9, 1879ST May 6, 1889
Though He saw the treason of one of His disciples ripening, He sat in silence and did not disclose the failures and weaknesses of the false disciple to the others.RH Nov 16, 1916 That restraint is a lesson for His followers in holding the tongue.RH Nov 16, 1916 He pitied Judas and did everything in His power for him.RH Sep 17, 1914 He deals with known sin by hiding it behind His back and casting it into the depths of the sea, and sends His Spirit to convince sinners to let Him take their sins away before others find them out, for which goodness the redeemed should praise Him instead of telling one another's faults.RH Sep 17, 1914
When Judas was chosen his case was not hopeless, for he had some good qualities.RH Oct 30, 1913 In association with Christ by listening to His discourses he had favorable opportunity to see his wrongs and become acquainted with his defects of character if he really desired to be a true disciple.RH Oct 30, 1913 He was placed where he could choose either to develop his covetous disposition or to see and correct it.RH Oct 30, 1913
Doctrine and Church Order
The fact that one of the twelve was a thief does not prove that Jesus relaxed the eighth commandment, and his presence among the chosen does not mean that Christ sanctioned robbery.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Feb 8, 1883 The absence of any record that Jesus and His disciples refrained from theft out of respect to the eighth commandment proves nothing, any more than the lack of a record of refraining from work on the seventh day proves that He relaxed the fourth commandment.RH Feb 3, 1852 The fact that one of the twelve served as treasurer, receiving money and keeping it in the bag to purchase food and other needful articles for the Master and His fellow disciples, proves that Christ's order to go out without gold, silver, brass, extra coats, or shoes was not a permanent and invariable rule for ministers under all circumstances, since His own company carried funds for its support.RH Jun 25, 1901
His example warns those entrusted with charitable funds against greed and dishonest handling of money, for his concern for the poor was a pretext while he controlled the money bag and took what was placed in it.RH Sep 27, 1870ST Mar 26, 1885 Handling funds entrusted by others can tempt a person to misuse them, so a deacon who handles church money must be free from greed and must not use the funds for personal benefit.ST Mar 26, 1885 Every man, woman, and child is put on honor as a treasurer for God, a carrier of the bag holding the first-fruits of increase, one tenth of it all.RH May 26, 1910 That carrier must be honest, deal truly with conscience, and hand God's part faithfully into His treasury rather than using it for self or family need, for withholding the tithe is robbing God and a reckoning day is coming when the unfaithful carrier will have to explain why God's portion was not paid in.RH May 26, 1910
His way of judging Christian service is a false measure, for he appeared concerned with the poor but his concern was not sincere.ST Apr 27, 1882 Counting charitable gifts and using totals to judge how much good has been done does not measure a gift's worth in Heaven, since a deed's worth depends on its motive, not its outward amount or appearance, as shown when Mary's act was commended because it was done from a Christian motive of service and not for praise.ST Apr 27, 1882 Even someone given opportunities and power to do good, including working miracles in Christ's name, and entrusted with the disciples' money, could prove false to Christ and act from selfishness for personal glory or material gain, for he did not truly care for the poor but controlled the money bag and stole from what was put into it.ST Nov 4, 1897
Call to Generous Love
Mary honored the living Christ with her offering out of gratitude for His blessing, and her act did not keep her from ministering to the poor after He was gone.ST Jun 14, 1905RH Jul 3, 1913 The lesson is to show love and encouragement and kindness to the living while they can still be comforted by it, rather than saving those acts until loved ones have died.ST Jun 14, 1905RH Jul 3, 1913ST Love for Christ brings Him the best of everything, especially the best of the affections with the warmest place in the heart.RH Sep 17, 1901 It gathers all the gems and jewels of love and the choicest of the heart into one precious alabaster box of perfume for Jesus, because He gave the best He had, His life with a broken heart and poured-out precious blood, and from His throne now lavishes the best gifts of His love.RH Sep 17, 1901 Her costly gift became a lasting blessing bringing her remembrance throughout the world and encourages millions who read of it, doing more than temporary relief.ST Jul 15, 1886
Nothing given to honor God is ever wasted, and serving God with little is the way to make it more.ST Mar 27, 1901RH May 29, 1855 A sacrifice made for Him is not wasteful, does not cause the poor to suffer, and does not prevent truly benevolent work afterward, for Christ comes first and the poor remain present afterward.ST Mar 27, 1901ST Jul 15, 1886 Judgments about such a gift should be made from the standpoint of love, not finance, for love moved the worshiper to give lavishly to the one she loved though financial reasoning called it misspent.ST Mar 27, 1901ST Jan 10, 1906 When money is master, love's work is restricted and loving deeds that cost too much are not allowed to be done.ST May 31, 1899 The plea for the poor covered love of money, the decision over the gift revealed whether love or money ruled, and though people mistake motives God knows them.ST May 31, 1899 The complaint that breaking the alabaster box and pouring out the precious ointment was waste treats costly devotion as lost resources.ST Jun 29, 1904 It is the same charge that missionary time, money, and life spent on Africans is waste.ST Jun 29, 1904
His talk about the poor was cold censure and criticism that freezes acts of love for Christ before they find expression.RH Dec 10, 1901RH Dec 10, 1901 That cold, unfeeling spirit is not from heaven but comes from beneath.RH Dec 10, 1901 Christ's answer, Let her alone, means Mary's act of love was to be left unhindered, coming as it did unobserved from behind while Jesus reclined at dinner, when she broke a very precious alabaster box upon His feet, wiped them with her long hair, and kissed them with fast-falling tears of gratitude for forgiveness of her great sins, hastening because she had heard rumors He might be taken away and feared she might have no other chance.RH Dec 10, 1901RH Dec 10, 1901 The same command applies now, when a timid wife longs to invite a needy one to share her home but meets objection, when children restrain their childish love for Christ for fear of censure, and when anyone follows a good prompting of the Spirit.RH Dec 10, 1901 People must be let alone to follow the Spirit, for God is able to guide them, and much more would be done for God if this were heeded, for hers was the only precious box broken upon the Saviour while He was alive and none should be sorry she broke it.RH Dec 10, 1901RH Dec 10, 1901
He is the example of those who criticize generous gifts to God's cause while claiming the money should be used for the poor, using that concern to hide their own selfishness.ST Apr 16, 1896ST Dec 10, 1894 He is also the example of disciples who selfishly obstructed people from coming to Christ.ST Apr 16, 1896 His apparently prudent conduct should not be mistaken for good character.ST Dec 10, 1894RH Dec 4, 1860 His example warns against calculating the value of a gift to Christ from a selfish heart driven by covetousness rather than care for the poor.RH Feb 27, 1908 Those who have received salvation should give generously and regret only that their offering is not greater.RH Feb 27, 1908 Genuine concern for the poor and the cause of God is shown through giving when money can help, for religion must reach a person's use of money and not remain mere profession or feeling.RH Feb 27, 1908RH Jun 5, 1866 His image as a dishonest bag-bearer stands as the contrast to faithful business management, as with a sanitarium's business manager.RH Aug 27, 1914
Sources