Mark 14:4
And there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said, Why was this waste of the ointment made?
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said, Why was this waste of the ointment made?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
But there were some that had indignation among themselves, saying, To what purpose hath this waste of the ointment been made?
and there were certain much displeased within themselves, and saying, 'For what hath this waste of the ointment been made?
And there were some indignant in themselves, and saying, Why has this waste been made of the ointment?
But there were some much displeased among themselves—To what end hath, this waste of the perfume happened?
Some of those present, however, expressed their indignation to one another: “ Why this waste of perfume?
Some of those present, however, expressed their indignation to one another and said, “ Why this waste of perfume?
But there were some who were indignant among themselves, saying, “ Why has this ointment been wasted?
But some of them were angry among themselves, saying, For what purpose has this oil been wasted?
Therefore some disdained among themselues, and sayde, To what ende is this waste of oyntment?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Now there were some that had indignation within themselves, and said: Why was this waste of the ointment made?
Pictures


Cross-references
- John 12:4-6
Then saith one of his disciples, Judas Iscariot, Simon’s son, which should betray him,
Judas objects to Mary’s costly ointment, invoking the poor while concealing his greed.
- Matthew 26:8-9
But when his disciples saw it, they had indignation, saying, To what purpose is this waste?
The disciples call the ointment a waste and suggest giving its value to the poor.
- Luke 7:37-38
And, behold, a woman in the city, which was a sinner, when she knew that Jesus sat at meat in the Pharisee’s house, brought an alabaster box of ointment,
The woman anoints Jesus in a loving act that honors him.
- John 12:3
Then took Mary a pound of ointment of spikenard, very costly, and anointed the feet of Jesus, and wiped his feet with her hair: and the house was filled with the odour of the ointment.
Mary anoints Jesus with costly ointment.
- Mark 14:8
She hath done what she could: she is come aforehand to anoint my body to the burying.
Jesus says Mary’s gift prepared his body for burial and commends what she could do.
- John 12:6
This he said, not that he cared for the poor; but because he was a thief, and had the bag, and bare what was put therein.
Judas’s concern for the poor was a pretense; he stole from the money bag.
- John 12:5
Why was not this ointment sold for three hundred pence, and given to the poor?
Both question why the ointment was not sold to help the poor.
- Mark 14:9
Verily I say unto you, Wheresoever this gospel shall be preached throughout the whole world, this also that she hath done shall be spoken of for a memorial of her.
Jesus promises that her deed will be told wherever the gospel is preached.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
21 sources
At Simon's house in Bethany Mary in gratitude for forgiveness and her brother's raising poured very costly oil on Jesus, and some present were indignant within themselves calling it a waste that should have been sold for three hundred pence and given to the poor.RH Aug 7, 1900EW 134.2DA 568.1–2ST Jul 22, 1886RH Aug 7, 1900 Judas spoke the complaint in anger and stirred the disciples and others to murmur against her devotion and reproach Jesus for allowing it.RH Aug 7, 1900DA 558.4–560.1DA 720.1 His plea for the poor only appeared compassionate, for he was a thief who stole from the poor fund and wanted the money for himself out of a covetous, selfish love of money.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.22SP 375.2–376.2ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 The offering was not waste, for nothing people could give is too costly for Jesus, and honoring Him with the best does not require neglecting the poor.RH Aug 7, 19004T 550.44T 485.1 The broken box became a lasting influence inspiring loving service through the centuries, warning that selfishness and covetousness can disguise themselves as care for others until the soul is led captive.DA 720.16T 310.1–2SG1 181.1ST Nov 30, 1915
Setting and Indignant Outcry
The outcry belongs to the feast at Simon's house in Bethany shortly before Passover, when Jesus' presence and the raising of Lazarus drew crowds and heightened public excitement about His mission.DA 557.1–2DA 557.3–558.1 Many Jews gathered and watched Him amid that growing attention, and some watched Him with unfriendly eyes.DA 557.1–2DA 557.3–558.1
It was Mary who poured precious anointing oil on His head and bathed His feet with her tears.DA 568.1–2 Though she had been regarded as a great sinner and had been controlled by demons, Christ lifted her from despair, and through His grace she overcame and became His close learner and servant.DA 568.1–2 She had bought the ointment to anoint His body after death, but hearing He would be raised to kingly authority she believed He would no longer be rejected and wanted to honor Him first.ST Jul 22, 1886 Her act was moved by love and gratitude.ST Jul 22, 1886
She anointed Him from love and gratitude because He had forgiven her many sins and had raised her brother from the dead.EW 134.2 She felt nothing was too dear to give Him, with the more precious ointment better expressing her gratitude.EW 134.2
Some present reacted with indignation within themselves at that costly anointing, regarding the ointment as wasted and asking why this waste was made.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Jul 22, 1886 Some of those present called the costly spikenard wasteful and objected that its value could have gone into the poor fund.RH Aug 7, 1900RH Aug 7, 1900 Judas regarded it as unnecessary waste, saying it could have been sold for three hundred pence and the money given to the poor.RH Aug 7, 1900RH Aug 7, 1900Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7
Judas spoke in anger against the offering poured on Jesus.RH Aug 7, 1900EW 134.2 His complaint stirred the others to murmur and to reproach Jesus for allowing the act.RH Aug 7, 1900 His insinuation led the disciples and others to distrust Mary's devotion.RH Aug 7, 1900DA 558.4–560.1 This was his first outward murmur and open opposition to Christ after long hidden disagreement.DA 720.1EW 134.2
Covetous Heart Behind Complaint
The cry of waste was compassion only in appearance, for Judas wanted the price for himself.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.22SP 375.2–376.2 He was a thief who habitually took for himself what had been entrusted to him for the poor, and had the ointment been sold the poor would not have benefited.EW 134.2RH Aug 7, 1900 His plea for the poor fund was therefore not care for the poor but a cover for greed, used to disguise his covetousness.4RED 108.2–109.22SP 375.2–376.2ST May 20, 1897RH Aug 7, 1900
His indignation grew from a carnal, close, covetous and selfish heart ruled by love of money and avarice.EW 134.2SG1 181.1Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7 He cherished covetousness, valued his Master only highly enough to betray Him for silver, and promoted saving as evidence of godliness.ST May 20, 1897SG1 181.1Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7 Inattentive to the comfort and wants of Jesus, he resented both the woman's gift and Christ's defense of her, and so turned the Gospel's call to mercy into an excuse for covetousness.ST Mar 5, 1912EW 134.2Ms 100, 1897, par. 6–7 By that false concern for the poor he stirred the others, leading them from misunderstanding of Mary's loving gratitude into distrust of her devotion and turning them against her act.DA 558.4–560.14RED 108.2–109.22SP 375.2–376.24RED 107.1–108.1
His covetous spirit had perverted his nobler nature and made him a fit agent for Satan to use in betraying Christ.3SP 125.2 Mary's generosity was a cutting rebuke to that disposition and prepared the way for Satan to find ready reception in his heart.EW 134.2 When Jesus implied a rebuke of that covetousness Judas was annoyed, yielded to the tempter, and gave Satan easy access to his mind, with wounded pride and desire for revenge breaking down restraint until greed held him in control.DA 720.13SP 125.2 Out of that yielding he decided to sell his Master to the murderous priests and rulers.3SP 125.2 Yet he had no thought Jesus would permit Himself to be taken, thinking the priests would be cheated of their bribe while he secured the money to use for some purpose of his own and Jesus would gain a new opportunity to display divine power in delivering Himself from His enemies.3SP 125.2
Costly Love Vindicated Forever
What was denounced as waste was no waste at all, for even the most valuable treasures human beings could produce would not be too great a gift for Jesus.RH Aug 7, 1900 Those who have received His pardoning love do not pause to calculate the cost of what they give Him, regretting only that the offering was not richer and more valuable.RH Aug 7, 19004T 485.1 The complaint measured the alabaster box of precious ointment by its sale price and treated its pouring out upon Christ as loss, but love does not weigh in that way.RH Aug 7, 19004T 485.1
Honoring Christ by giving the best of one's substance holds first place, while appealing to the needs of the poor against such giving misreads duty.4T 550.4 Rightly serving His cause does not require neglecting the poor, for faithful stewards can care for both.4T 550.4
The act of love that onlookers called waste did not end at Simon's feast, for the memory of the broken alabaster box became a lasting influence.6T 310.1–2ST Nov 30, 1915 That memory has inspired many people to loving service and has prompted countless loving deeds through the centuries.6T 310.1–2ST Nov 30, 1915
The outcry also stands as warning that selfishness can disguise itself as concern for others, as when covetousness pleaded that the ointment should have been sold for the poor.SG1 181.1 Covetous followers of Christ who value Him so lightly may abandon good principles for earthly gain, even to betray Him for silver.DA 720.1SG1 181.1 The first outward murmur and open opposition after long hidden disagreement exposed a long-indulged greed, and the reproof given turned wounded pride and desire for revenge into gall until greed held the man in control.DA 720.1 So it is with everyone who keeps tampering with sin, that elements of depravity not resisted and overcome respond to Satan's temptation and the soul is led captive at his will.DA 720.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
52 sources
At Bethany in Simon's house some present inwardly resented Mary's pouring of costly ointment on Jesus and broke into murmuring that it was a waste that should have been sold for more than three hundred pence for the poor.ST Sep 20, 1899RH Aug 28, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867ST Oct 5, 1882ST Dec 20, 1910 The disciples shared the complaint, but Judas prompted it and voiced it, drawing others after him once the fragrance made her act known.ST May 6, 1889RH Dec 10, 1867ST Sep 20, 1899 His plea for the poor hid covetousness, hypocrisy, theft, and indifference to the poor, for the poor would have gained nothing if the ointment had been sold.ST May 6, 1889ST May 6, 1889ST Jan 10, 1911 The gift was no waste, for its worth is measured not by price or usefulness but by the love and self-denial that gave it, and no sacrifice made for Christ however great is ever wasted or keeps the poor from help.RH Aug 7, 1900ST Dec 10, 1894RH Dec 3, 1867RH May 29, 1855ST Mar 27, 1901 What seemed loss became lasting blessing, comforting Jesus in facing death and leaving a memorial wherever the gospel is preached, teaching that love's best should be poured out while it can cheer the living rather than held back by cold calculation.ST May 17, 1905STRH Jun 24, 1902RH Jul 3, 1913ST Dec 2, 1880
Feast Setting and Timing
The anointing belongs at a feast in Bethany at Simon the leper's house six days before the Passover, not two days before it, with several days passing between the feast and the Passover.ST Oct 5, 1882 Lazarus's household was likely present where Jesus was expected as guest.ST Dec 20, 1910 The setting stands against the growing rage of the leaders and their desire to seize an opportunity to kill Jesus, while the people were absorbed in him and his works and the leaders feared he might avoid Jerusalem for the feast after discerning their plans.ST May 6, 1889 Matthew and Mark place the account after describing the betrayal to show the circumstances in which Satan took possession of Judas.ST Oct 5, 1882 Its setting precedes Judas leaving the table after welcoming thoughts of revenge and gold to go to the high priest and offer to betray Jesus, with the broken alabaster box and the scent of spikenard remaining at Jesus' feet at Simon's feast.ST Jan 10, 1911
Mary had bought the ointment to anoint Jesus' body after his death and kept it to anoint him for burial.ST Jul 22, 1886RH Dec 3, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 Having heard that he would be raised to kingly authority, she believed he would no longer be rejected and wanted to honor him first, moved by love and gratitude.ST Jul 22, 1886 She anticipated disapproval and kept her plan secret while saving to buy the ointment, because the costly gift was liable to be condemned as waste and she believed the disciples would not understand the sacrifice or the honor she meant to give Jesus.RH Mar 24, 1910 She understood his coming death and suffering with unusual sympathy and loving appreciation of the love he was about to show in dying, while the disciples seemed insensible to his suffering.RH Dec 3, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 Her keeping of the ointment was also to comfort him as he faced death, and the cost, worth about three hundred pence or roughly a year's wages, mattered because it expressed that love.RH Dec 3, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 The verse records indignation at the woman's costly anointing before his burial as part of the account of her loving act honored as service to Christ.RH Oct 4, 1870
The feast at Simon's house with Jesus expected and Lazarus's household likely present belongs to the verse even apart from describing the indignation about the ointment or explaining the objection.ST Dec 20, 1910
Indignation and Its Motives
Some at the table were inwardly indignant at Mary's use of the costly ointment for Jesus and broke out in murmuring against her.ST Sep 20, 1899RH Dec 10, 1867RH Mar 24, 1910 They called her act waste because the ointment could have been sold for more than three hundred pence and the money given to the poor.ST Sep 20, 1899RH Aug 28, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 In doing so they set practical usefulness above honoring Jesus and challenged the way she showed love for her Saviour.RH Aug 28, 1913RH Dec 3, 1867
The disciples shared in that indignation, but Judas was its chief instigator and the voice of the objection.RH Dec 10, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 His complaint, stirred by distrust and insinuation against her devotion, influenced some of the others to join him in calling the act wasteful.ST May 6, 1889RH Dec 10, 1867ST Sep 20, 1899 The criticism broke out after the fragrance revealed what she had done.ST Jan 3, 1911
His plea for the poor, for the temple treasury, or for the poor fund concealed greed, cold avarice, covetousness, hypocrisy, and indifference to the poor.ST May 6, 1889ST May 6, 1889ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912RH May 8, 1879 He was a thief who stole from the money entrusted to him and wanted the proceeds for himself, while seeking recognition for supposed piety and wisdom and harboring thoughts of revenge and gold.ST May 6, 1889RH Aug 7, 1900ST Jan 10, 1911 If the ointment had been sold the poor would not have benefited.RH Aug 7, 1900 Those who hold that his indignation arose after Jesus rebuked him for objecting place that rebuke before the charge of waste.ST Jan 10, 1911
His complaint stirred the others to murmur and even to reproach Jesus for allowing the act.RH Aug 7, 1900ST May 6, 1889 It showed a spirit that failed to value loving sacrifice, turning the gospel call to mercy into an excuse for covetousness.ST Mar 5, 1912ST Jun 16, 1887 Their reproach left Mary ashamed and afraid that her gift had been wrong.ST May 6, 1889 Jesus did not expose or reproach him at that moment, so that he would have no excuse for his later betrayal, yet the objection marked the beginning of his character becoming visible in action.ST Mar 27, 1901
That indignation exposed spiritual blindness, hardness of heart, and selfish thrift.ST Jul 6, 1915ST Jul 6, 1915 The witnesses failed to perceive the spiritual meaning and higher, lasting worth of generous devotion and consecration of life in love.ST Jul 6, 1915ST Jul 6, 1915 Their response to her beautiful act judged and condemned them for that lack of understanding.ST Jul 6, 1915
Cost and True Worth
The ointment poured out was worth about three hundred pence or three hundred denarii, roughly a year's wages.RH Dec 3, 1867ST Jan 10, 1911 By the standards of the time its value was more than ten pounds, or about fifty dollars.ST Sep 20, 1899 It was the costliest anointing oil known, made from an Indian plant and sold at fabulous prices throughout the Roman Empire.ST Sep 20, 1899 Although fragrant oil was commonly used to anoint rabbis and special guests at marriage feasts, Mary's offering surpassed anything then known.ST Sep 20, 1899
Its worth is not measured by human standards, outward cost, or financial calculation, but by the love, self-denial, and sacrifice that prompted it.ST Dec 10, 1894RH Dec 3, 1867ST Jan 10, 1906RH Nov 11, 1915 People see its price, but Christ sees the heart.ST Dec 10, 1894 Love rather than reason alone should guide judgments and actions.ST Jan 10, 1906 She thought nothing too good for Jesus and poured out the ointment rather than keeping it for her own enjoyment.RH Nov 11, 1915
The offering was not waste, and even the most valuable treasures people could produce would not be too great a gift for Jesus.RH Aug 7, 1900 No sacrifice made for Christ is waste, however great it may seem.ST Mar 27, 1901 Such gifts do not keep the poor from receiving help.ST Mar 27, 1901 What people call waste is not wasted when it honors God.RH May 29, 1855
Her costly gift was worth more than its price because giving it deepened her experience more than keeping the property would have.ST Dec 2, 1880 Its cost mattered because it expressed her love for Jesus and her appreciation of the love he was about to show in dying.RH Dec 3, 1867 She had kept it to anoint him for burial, to comfort him as he faced death and to meet his need as he faced suffering.RH Dec 3, 1867RH Dec 3, 1867 The broken vase and nard became a lasting picture of love's sacrifice whose full value would be seen beyond the moment.RH Nov 9, 1911
An offering made for the Savior is welcomed by God even when others object to its cost, in contrast to the complaint that murmured against it.ST Apr 11, 1906
Waste Rightly Understood
What was denounced as waste became loving service and lasting blessing to the world.ST May 17, 1905RH Jun 24, 1902 By breaking the vase and pouring out the ointment she spread its fragrance and secured the remembrance of her deed wherever the gospel is preached.ST May 17, 1905RH Jun 24, 1902 That act of love, though called waste, became a lasting influence that has prompted countless loving deeds through the centuries.ST Nov 30, 1915RH Jun 24, 1902 Had the ointment been kept unused it would have left no such remembrance, while a life poured out in loving service becomes a blessing and is remembered.RH Jun 24, 1902
Jesus called her loving act a good work because she did what she could in response to a present need.ST Jul 18, 1911 Her deed met his need as he faced suffering and death, and he promised it an enduring memorial in the gospel.ST Jul 18, 1911 Her faithfulness in doing what she could became an enduring inspiration.ST Jul 18, 1911
The cry of waste can disguise self-interest when what is offered to honor Christ is treated as a loss to humanity.RH Dec 3, 1867ST May 31, 1899 Service to people or the church can become self-seeking when Christ himself is left out of view, for love for others is not the fault but neglecting Christ's worth and failing to honor him.RH Dec 3, 1867 When money rules, love's work must be held back and a loving deed that costs much is judged as waste that cannot be allowed and condemned as too costly.RH Dec 3, 1867ST May 31, 1899 Generous giving to Christ is so condemned by hearts ruled by money, while God knows the true motive of love.RH Dec 3, 1867ST May 31, 1899
The indignation over the ointment's apparent waste shows how active service can take the place of worship and devotion. Worship is the soul's life, and service without it becomes dead. Judas's failure to value an offering made for Jesus stands in contrast to Noah's costly sacrifice of valuable animals in gratitude for preservation.
Present Lessons and Warnings
The objection that the ointment was wasted teaches that love and tenderness should be shown while a person is alive and can be comforted by them, rather than saved for a funeral when they can no longer bring cheer.STRH Jul 3, 1913RH Jun 15, 1916RH Mar 26, 1901 Honor is to be given to people while they are alive, rather than waiting until they have died when they can no longer hear words of praise or receive kindness.RH Jul 3, 1913RH Jun 15, 1916RH Mar 26, 1901 Love, sympathy, and kind words given to friends while they live can refresh and cheer them, rather than affection and honors being saved for after death.RH Jun 15, 1916RH Mar 26, 1901 Love and tenderness should not be saved for funeral flowers or praise after death, when they can no longer comfort or encourage the living.STRH Mar 26, 1901
What appeared to be loss in pouring out the costly ointment became a lasting blessing, for loving service was remembered throughout the world, while keeping the ointment unused would have left no such remembrance. A life carefully preserved for oneself bears no lasting honor, but a life poured out in loving service becomes a blessing to the world and is remembered. The fitting response set against the criticism is to think nothing too good for Jesus and to pour out the gift rather than keeping it for one's own enjoyment, with its value measured by the love and self-denial behind it.RH Nov 11, 1915RH Sep 17, 1901 Her gift was the best she had, offered from a heart overflowing with love, in answer to his giving his life, so that giving Christ our best stands as the true contrast to calling such devotion waste.RH Nov 11, 1915RH Sep 17, 1901
The indignation at the costly gift has a modern parallel in criticism of people who give generously to God's cause, since worth is measured by the love that prompts it while people see outward cost and Christ sees the heart.ST Dec 10, 1894 The same charge of waste is made against missionary work among Africans, calling it a waste of time, money, and life.ST Jun 29, 1904 That charge is mistaken, because the gospel is the power of God unto salvation and can make something of people even when they are very far down after centuries of sinking in sin and ignorance.ST Jun 29, 1904
The question about waste applies to spending money on tobacco while children lack bread, shoes, and books, for such spending defiles people and displeases the Lord.ST Nov 21, 1895 It also describes how the infidel regards devotion to God, seeing time and money spent in God's service as something thrown away in echo of the objection to the costly ointment.RH Jan 13, 1863
The words about waste warn against turning Christ away or begrudging a sacrifice made for his work and the salvation of others, since complaint about costly ointment can express greed and failure to value what is done for Christ.RH Jan 8, 1875 The broken box and its fragrance also provide an image for sincere confession, which brings a sweet blessing.RH May 30, 1912
Sources