John 18:17
Then saith the damsel that kept the door unto Peter, Art not thou also one of this man’s disciples? He saith, I am not.
Translations
Then says the damsel that kept the door to Peter, Are not you also one of this man’s disciples? He says, I am not.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then saith the damsel that kept the door unto Peter, Art not thou also one of this man’s disciples? He saith, I am not.
Then saith the damsel that kept the door to Peter, Art not thou also one of this man's disciples? He saith, I am not.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
The maid therefore that kept the door saith unto Peter, Art thou also one of this man’s disciples? He saith, I am not.
Then said the maid keeping the door to Peter, 'Art thou also of the disciples of this man?' he saith, 'I am not;'
The maid therefore, who was porteress, says to Peter, Art thou also of the disciples of this man? He says, I am not.
The female servant, therefore, the portress, saith unto Peter—Art, thou also, from among the disciples of this man? He, saith—I am not!
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
At this, the servant girl watching the door said to Peter, “Aren’ t you also one of this man’s disciples?”“ I am not,” he answered.
Then the maid who kept the door said to Peter, “ Are you also one of this man’s disciples?”He said, “ I am not.”
Then the girl who was the door-keeper said to Peter, Are you not one of this man's disciples? In answer he said, I am not.
Then saide the maide that kept the doore, vnto Peter, Art not thou also one of this mans disciples? He sayd, I am not.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
The maid therefore that was portress, saith to Peter: Art not thou also one of this man’s disciples? He saith: I am not.
Pictures





Cross-references 20 of 23
- Luke 22:56-57
But a certain maid beheld him as he sat by the fire, and earnestly looked upon him, and said, This man was also with him.
Peter denies knowing Jesus when questioned by the maid.
- Matthew 26:69-70
Now Peter sat without in the palace: and a damsel came unto him, saying, Thou also wast with Jesus of Galilee.
Matthew recounts the servant’s question and Peter’s first denial.
- Mark 14:66-68
And as Peter was beneath in the palace, there cometh one of the maids of the high priest:
The servant girl questions Peter, and he denies knowing Jesus.
- Matthew 26:58
But Peter followed him afar off unto the high priest’s palace, and went in, and sat with the servants, to see the end.
Peter follows Jesus at a distance before denying him.
- Mark 14:54
And Peter followed him afar off, even into the palace of the high priest: and he sat with the servants, and warmed himself at the fire.
Peter follows Jesus at a distance before denying him.
- Luke 22:54
Then took they him, and led him, and brought him into the high priest’s house. And Peter followed afar off.
Peter follows Jesus at a distance before denying him.
- John 13:38
Jesus answered him, Wilt thou lay down thy life for my sake? Verily, verily, I say unto thee, The cock shall not crow, till thou hast denied me thrice.
Jesus foretells Peter’s threefold denial before the cock crows.
- John 21:15-17
So when they had dined, Jesus saith to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou me more than these? He saith unto him, Yea, Lord; thou knowest that I love thee. He saith unto him, Feed my lambs.
Jesus’ three questions recall Peter’s denial and restore him to service.
- Luke 22:31-32
And the Lord said, Simon, Simon, behold, Satan hath desired to have you, that he may sift you as wheat:
Jesus foretells Peter’s test, restoration, and strengthening of his brethren.
- Luke 22:61-62
And the Lord turned, and looked upon Peter. And Peter remembered the word of the Lord, how he had said unto him, Before the cock crow, thou shalt deny me thrice.
Jesus looks at Peter after his denial, and Peter goes out and weeps bitterly.
- John 18:25-27
And Simon Peter stood and warmed himself. They said therefore unto him, Art not thou also one of his disciples? He denied it, and said, I am not.
John continues Peter’s denials, followed by the cock’s crow.
- Matthew 10:33
But whosoever shall deny me before men, him will I also deny before my Father which is in heaven.
Hiding faith under pressure is denial of the Lord.
- Matthew 26:73
And after a while came unto him they that stood by, and said to Peter, Surely thou also art one of them; for thy speech bewrayeth thee.
Galilean speech marked him as disciple
- Matthew 26:34
Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, That this night, before the cock crow, thou shalt deny me thrice.
Jesus foretold that Peter would deny him three times.
- Matthew 26:33
Peter answered and said unto him, Though all men shall be offended because of thee, yet will I never be offended.
Peter’s earlier confidence that he would not fall is recalled.
- Matthew 26:74
Then began he to curse and to swear, saying, I know not the man. And immediately the cock crew.
denial repeated with oaths
- Matthew 26:75
And Peter remembered the word of Jesus, which said unto him, Before the cock crow, thou shalt deny me thrice. And he went out, and wept bitterly.
predicts the three denials this begins
- Mark 14:29
But Peter said unto him, Although all shall be offended, yet will not I.
Peter's confident boast contrasts with his later denial.
- Luke 22:33
And he said unto him, Lord, I am ready to go with thee, both into prison, and to death.
Peter’s boast of readiness contrasts with his denial.
- Mark 14:50
And they all forsook him, and fled.
Both texts record the disciples abandoning Jesus when he was arrested.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
20 sources
On a cold night in the high priest's palace during the trial before Annas and Caiaphas, Peter had followed Jesus inside and was warming himself with the servants and officers at a fire of coals when the servant girl who kept the door challenged him.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 91, 1909, par. 11–15Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22DA 698 Guessing from his face that he was a follower of Christ, she tauntingly asked if he too was one of this man's disciples and drew the eyes of the whole company upon him, and startled and confused, he first pretended not to understand and then angrily denied knowing Him, after which the cock crowed as the first of his repeated denials.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–223SP 107.2–3 It was the shameful, cowardly denial of one of Jesus' most zealous disciples from fear and a desire to hide his identity, thereby dishonoring and deserting his Lord in His humiliation, which pierced Jesus' heart more deeply than the insults of His enemies.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22 The denial came not from physical danger but from fear of scorn, ridicule and suffering, and concealing faith to avoid reproach is as truly a denial of the Lord as Peter's was, while lingering among Christ's enemies only exposes the disciple to temptation and shame.DA 710.2–711.15RED 28.1–2DA 711.2–35RED 32.23SP 112.2 Peter failed because he trusted in himself, yet Jesus' sorrowful look moved him to bitter repentance and conversion, which humbled him and prepared him to sympathize with the weak, warn the presumptuous, strengthen his brethren, and become a bold witness for Christ.Lt 54, 1874, par. 15–16EW 138.2Lt 35, 1891, par. 5–8
Scene of First Denial
The exchange belongs to the cold night in the palace of the high priest, while Jesus was on trial before Annas and the court of Caiaphas, when servants and officers and Peter stood together warming themselves at a fire of coals.Ms 91, 1909, par. 11–15DA 698 Peter had followed Jesus to the palace and had been brought inside by another disciple who was known to the high priest, and he was recognized as one who had entered with John.Ms 91, 1909, par. 11–153SP 108.1DA 710.2–711.15RED 27.2–3 The question came from the damsel who kept the door, a servant of the household of Caiaphas, who was curious about who Peter was.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22 With the light of the fire falling on his face, and with the dejected look on his face, she guessed that he was a follower of Christ.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22
She challenged him in a taunting manner, asking whether he too was one of this man's disciples, and the eyes of the whole company were at once fastened upon him.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22 He had mingled with the people by the fire and stood among the others, hoping to be taken for one of those who had brought Jesus to the hall, so that his loyalty would not be recognized.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–223SP 107.2–35RED 27.2–3 Startled and confused by her words, he first pretended not to understand her.ST Jun 6, 1878Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22 When she persisted and told those standing around that he had been with Jesus and had come in with John, he was compelled to answer, and angrily denied knowing Him, even with cursing and swearing.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–223SP 108.1DA 710.2–711.1
This was his first denial, the beginning of his repeated denial, and immediately afterward the cock crowed.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–223SP 108.1DA 710.2–711.1 It was made from fear and from a desire to hide his identity.3SP 108.15RED 28.1–2 So soon ashamed of his Master, one of Jesus' most zealous disciples cowardly denied his Lord.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–22 By that act he dishonored, abandoned, and deserted the Saviour in His humiliation, and that denial pierced Jesus' heart more deeply than the insults and accusations of His enemies.ST Jun 6, 187819MR 167.1–2Ms 104, 1897, par. 17–223SP 108.13SP 107.1
Lessons for Disciples Today
Peter's fall came not under threat of physical harm but under scorn, ridicule and reproach, when fear for his own safety and fear of suffering overcame one who had been willing to fight for Jesus.DA 710.2–711.15RED 28.1–25RED 32.23SP 112.2EW 138.2 Trying to hide his identity by blending in among Jesus' enemies, he left himself exposed to fear, shame, ridicule and temptation.DA 710.2–711.15RED 28.1–2DA 711.2–3 His first denial, born of that desire to conceal who he was, dishonored Jesus in the very hour of His humiliation and desertion.5RED 28.1–2
To disguise one's faith from fear of suffering or reproach is as truly a denial of the Lord as Peter's denial was, so disciples who conceal their faith to avoid suffering deny their Lord.DA 711.2–35RED 32.23SP 112.2 Yielding under such pressure can even bring upon the yielding one the contempt of those who tempted him.5RED 32.2 Keeping company with those who tempt a person to compromise leads to words and actions he would otherwise avoid.3SP 112.2 So it was in the wider setting when all His disciples forsook Him and fled.Ms 95, 1897, par. 10–12
Peter failed to witness when tested because he trusted in himself, denying his Lord.Lt 35, 1891, par. 5–8 He afterward became truly sorry and turned back to his Saviour, moved to bitter repentance and conversion by Jesus' sorrowful, reproving look as he remembered Jesus' warning and his own confident promise.Lt 54, 1874, par. 15–16EW 138.2Lt 35, 1891, par. 5–8 That repentance humbled him and fitted him to sympathize with the weak and erring, to warn the presumptuous, and to strengthen his brethren.Lt 54, 1874, par. 15–16EW 138.2 Thus restored, he became a bold witness for Christ.Lt 35, 1891, par. 5–8
The denial stands within the account of Christ's suffering and the ordeal He had prepared His faithful followers to face.4RED 102.2–103.1Lt 100, 1910, par. 16 That account is meant to strengthen those who suffer for their faith.Lt 100, 1910, par. 16 The earlier turning away of professed followers had already shown how fickle human support could be, so the disciples would not base their faith on the crowd's approval when Jesus was betrayed and condemned.4RED 102.2–103.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
33 sources
The damsel keeping the door asked Peter whether he too was one of Jesus' disciples, the also pointing to John whose conduct had already marked him as a disciple, and Peter answered that he was not, making his first denial.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Aug 9, 1899ST Mar 14, 1906ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909 He had been brought inside the high priest's court by another disciple known there, yet he lingered by the fire with servants and officers instead of standing by his bound Master.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Apr 29, 1897ST Aug 8, 1906ST Dec 30, 1889 He denied because he followed at a distance to avoid reproach and suffering, put himself among Christ's enemies in temptation's path, and failed to watch and pray, so fear and confusion overcame his love for Jesus.ST Mar 14, 1906ST May 7, 1902ST Aug 8, 1906ST Oct 24, 1911ST Dec 30, 1889 When discipleship must be drawn out by questioning it shows allegiance is hidden, and hesitation to confess openly makes further denial almost certain, so faithfulness requires staying close to Christ and declaring Him boldly even at cost of reputation or life.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Aug 9, 1899ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909ST Dec 30, 1889 His denial dishonored and deserted the Saviour in His humiliation, yet Jesus' grieving look awakened him to bitter sorrow and penitence, and after three denials his threefold avowal of love restored him to feed Christ's flock.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Jun 7, 1899ST Oct 24, 1911ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 19, 1885
Words and Setting
The verse stands at the beginning of the trials and persecution of Jesus before the high priest and Pilate, belonging in particular to the hearings before Annas and Caiaphas as steps in His sacrifice for fallen humanity.ST Sep 24, 1912 Peter had come inside the court of the high priest only through the help of another disciple who was known to the high priest and spoke to the woman keeping the door, while John had already entered with Jesus.ST Apr 29, 1897ST Dec 30, 1889
The doorkeeper's word also points to John, who had entered with Jesus and whose actions had already shown that he was Jesus' disciple, so that she asks whether Peter too is one of this man's disciples.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909 The need for discipleship to be established by such direct questioning shows conduct that did not make allegiance clear, for genuine discipleship should be evident in actions and not hidden until someone asks.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909
The verse records Peter's answer, I am not, denying that he was one of Jesus' disciples.ST Aug 9, 1899ST Mar 14, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 It was his first denial and the first step in compromise, beginning a course of repeated denials.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Mar 14, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906ST Dec 30, 1889 That denial added to the humiliation Jesus suffered when His own people rejected Him.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Jun 7, 1899 It came after Peter chose to stand among the servants and officers who opposed Jesus, which placed him in temptation and led toward further denial.ST May 7, 1902ST Dec 30, 1889
As light from the fire of coals made because it was cold fell on Peter's face, the doorkeeper who had seen him enter with John guessed he was a follower and challenged him in a taunting way, drawing the eyes of the whole company onto him.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 19, 1882 Startled and confused, he pretended not to understand and then answered angrily that he did not know Him, with a sharp repeated Nay.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 19, 1882ST Aug 12, 1880 He pressed through the crowd and crouched to warm his hands on a cold midnight, while Jesus stood nearby bound, stripped, mocked and forsaken, and immediately the cock crowed.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 19, 1882ST Aug 12, 1880 Afterward, rather than going to Jesus, Peter stayed and mingled with the servants, officers and soldiers warming himself at the fire.ST Apr 29, 1897ST Aug 8, 1906ST Dec 30, 1889
Why Peter Denied
Peter had followed at a distance instead of standing near his Master and risking sneers, persecution and suffering, holding back from open identification and waiting to see whether Jesus would use divine power against His enemies.ST Mar 14, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906ST Mar 14, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 He kept away from situations where he might be recognized as one of Jesus' friends.ST Jan 31, 1911 His physical and spiritual coldness reflected how far he was from the Master and showed that he did not know Him as he should.ST Feb 16, 1915
By choosing to avoid being identified and separating himself from Jesus, he stood and mingled with the servants, officers, soldiers and enemies who opposed Jesus.ST May 7, 1902RH Jul 13, 1911RH Dec 2, 1909 He had gone where he should not have gone, and standing with that company placed him in temptation's path.ST May 7, 1902ST Nov 1, 1910RH Jul 13, 1911 That association led toward further denial and even blasphemy.RH Dec 2, 1909ST Oct 1, 1885
His distance and failure to watch and pray left him vulnerable to temptation.ST Dec 30, 1889ST Dec 30, 1889ST Dec 30, 1889 Weakness and dissembling overcame him despite his continuing love and yearning for Jesus.RH Dec 2, 1909 Caught off guard, he was startled and confused and easily denied Him, and that distance helped make Satan's success possible.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906
The very fact that his discipleship had to be established by direct questioning shows his conduct did not make his allegiance clear.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909 Had he stayed close to Jesus, every word and act and look would have proclaimed that he loved the Man of Sorrows above all earthly flattery, praise or gain.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Dec 30, 1889ST Aug 8, 1906 Genuine discipleship should therefore be evident in actions, not hidden until someone asks, for discipleship recognized only after inquiry is not worthy of the name.ST Nov 11, 1897ST Dec 29, 1909ST Jun 2, 1909
That following afar off came because reproof had made him sensitive in selfishness, and brooding over it left the Master far in advance.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 Pride, ambition, avarice and pleasure standing between the soul and Christ is the secret of the denial.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906
Unlike John, who openly confessed his attachment to Jesus, Peter failed to confess at once when the maid's small but searching question tested his loyalty.ST Aug 9, 1899 That hesitation made further confession harder and let hostile circumstances weaken loyalty.ST Aug 9, 1899
One of Jesus' most zealous disciples was soon ashamed of his Master and cowardly denied his Lord from fear of people, with fear mixed with bravado and his blood running cold.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 24, 1911ST Jan 10, 1911ST Aug 12, 1880RH Jun 8, 1869 This exposes how the natural heart instinctively shrinks from suffering and faints and falters at the crosses and obstacles of the heavenward journey.RH Jun 8, 1869 Even disciples who had shared heavenly light and glory and had said it was good to be with Jesus, and who had been chosen to be with Him in His agony in Gethsemane yet slept through His anguish under the weight of sin and woe, proved the frailty of fallen human nature, so that no one could hope to be saved unless God were infinite in mercy.RH Jun 8, 1869
Warning and Restoration
Peter's answer was his first denial, and by it one of the most zealous disciples was soon ashamed of his Master and cowardly denied his Lord, dishonoring, deserting and abandoning the Saviour in His humiliation and adding to the humiliation Jesus suffered when His own people rejected Him.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 19, 1882ST Jun 7, 1899 As light fell on his face by the fire the doorkeeper who had seen him enter guessed he was a follower and challenged him in a taunting way that drew the eyes of the whole company onto him, and startled and confused he pretended not to understand but when pressed insisted angrily that he did not know Him, and immediately the cock crowed.ST Jun 6, 1878ST Oct 19, 1882 Unlike John, who openly confessed his attachment, Peter's failure to confess at once made further confession harder and let hostile circumstances weaken loyalty, showing that openly declaring oneself Christ's disciple helps one remain faithful under pressure while hesitation lets that loyalty fail.ST Aug 9, 1899RH Jul 13, 1911 Even small occasions can test devotion, for by choosing to avoid being identified, separating himself from Jesus and mingling with unbelievers, he put himself in temptation's path and his prior decision was brought into the open, warning that following at a distance and concealing Christian identity leads toward denying the Lord.ST Aug 9, 1899RH Jul 13, 1911
The same question still tests Christians now because they also follow afar off.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 When conduct does not make allegiance clear so that others must ask to ascertain whether a person is Christ's disciple, closeness to Jesus would have made it known by every word and act and look without asking, and there is no assurance that person will not deny the Lord even as Peter did, so that rebuke and humiliation must then come to that person as to him.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 That danger comes because reproof has made a person sensitive in selfishness and brooding over it has left the Master far in advance, with pride, ambition, avarice and pleasure standing between the soul and Christ.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 The call therefore is to stay with Jesus and follow faithfully by staying close to Him and living by His principles and by the principles He taught, even when doing so brings condemnation, loss of reputation or death, since distance leaves one vulnerable and makes denial easy and shows one does not know Him as one should.ST Dec 30, 1889ST Feb 16, 1915
Fear of people leads to denying the Lord not only by spoken words that repudiate Him but also by silence when He is attacked and by failing to oppose scoffing and wrongdoing.ST Oct 24, 1911 On a cold midnight Peter stood among mockers around the brazier fire while Jesus stood nearby bound, stripped, mocked and forsaken, his blood running cold with fear, and with a sharp repeated angry Nay he pressed through the crowd and crouched to warm his hands, a cowardly refusal to own Christ while Christ was betrayed, lurking afraid among His foes yet seeking comfort against the cold, a pattern still repeated when believers neither do the wrong nor dare the right.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Aug 12, 1880 That particular event could happen only once, but Christ is still on trial before the world and needs His followers' testimony, so love for Christ calls them to defend Him at personal cost and to confess Him boldly before others rather than seek comfort among His enemies.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Aug 12, 1880
Jesus' grieving look rebuked Peter, awakened him to his sin and led him to sorrow, and that sorrow helped make him strong.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Jan 10, 1911 His fear mixed with bravado began denials that bring bitter remorse when Jesus looks at him, and mingling with enemies by the fire in the palace yard leads toward further denial and blasphemy, while restoration comes through penitence and tears.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Jan 10, 1911ST Oct 1, 1885 The denial at the door belongs to Peter's three open and threefold denials, which Jesus later recalled when He three times asked Peter whether he loved him, drawing out his assurance of love and loyalty and showing his repentance was deep and his pride humbled.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 19, 1885 Peter was then entrusted with caring for Christ's flock, for without love for Christ he could not faithfully shepherd it, and love for Christ must be the motive for serving Him.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 19, 1885
Sources