Luke 13:9
And if it bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down.
Translations
And if it bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that you shall cut it down.
And if it bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down.
and if it bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down.
And if it shall bear fruit, well: and if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
and if it bear fruit thenceforth, well; but if not, thou shalt cut it down.
and if indeed it may bear fruit —;and if not so, thereafter thou shalt cut it off.'
and if it shall bear fruit — but if not, after that thou shalt cut it down.
and if it may bear fruit for the future; …but, otherwise, certainly, thou shalt cut it down.
If it bears fruit next year, fine. But if not, you can cut it down.’”
If it bears fruit, fine. But if not, you can cut it down next year.’”
If it bears fruit, fine; but if not, after that, you can cut it down.’”
And if, after that, it has fruit, it is well; if not, let it be cut down.
And if it beare fruite, well: if not, then after thou shalt cut it downe.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And if happily it bear fruit: but if not, then after that thou shalt cut it down.
Cross-references 20 of 22
- John 15:2
Every branch in me that beareth not fruit he taketh away: and every branch that beareth fruit, he purgeth it, that it may bring forth more fruit.
Unfruitful branches are removed, while fruitful ones are tended to bear more fruit.
- Matthew 21:19
And when he saw a fig tree in the way, he came to it, and found nothing thereon, but leaves only, and said unto it, Let no fruit grow on thee henceforward for ever. And presently the fig tree withered away.
The fruitless fig tree withers under judgment.
- Mark 11:13-14
And seeing a fig tree afar off having leaves, he came, if haply he might find any thing thereon: and when he came to it, he found nothing but leaves; for the time of figs was not yet.
The fruitless fig tree illustrates the warning and judgment against failing to bear fruit.
- Isaiah 5:4
What could have been done more to my vineyard, that I have not done in it? wherefore, when I looked that it should bring forth grapes, brought it forth wild grapes?
God’s carefully tended vineyard fails to bear the fruit he expected.
- John 15:8
Herein is my Father glorified, that ye bear much fruit; so shall ye be my disciples.
Both teach that God expects his disciples to bear fruit.
- Matthew 21:41-43
They say unto him, He will miserably destroy those wicked men, and will let out his vineyard unto other husbandmen, which shall render him the fruits in their seasons.
Those who withhold the vineyard’s expected fruit are judged and lose their place.
- Luke 13:3
I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.
Jesus warns that all must repent or perish, not infer guilt from calamity.
- Matthew 7:19
Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
Trees that fail to bear good fruit are cut down.
- Matthew 3:10
And now also the axe is laid unto the root of the trees: therefore every tree which bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
Both warn that an unfruitful tree is cut down.
- John 15:6
If a man abide not in me, he is cast forth as a branch, and is withered; and men gather them, and cast them into the fire, and they are burned.
Fruitless branches are removed and burned.
- Galatians 5:22-23
But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, longsuffering, gentleness, goodness, faith,
Names the graces expected to appear in a believer’s life.
- Mark 11:20-24
And in the morning, as they passed by, they saw the fig tree dried up from the roots.
The withered fig tree illustrates the lesson of the fruitless tree.
- Psalms 1:3
And he shall be like a tree planted by the rivers of water, that bringeth forth his fruit in his season; his leaf also shall not wither; and whatsoever he doeth shall prosper.
Delight in God’s law produces fruit in its season.
- Matthew 25:28-30
Take therefore the talent from him, and give it unto him which hath ten talents.
Both warn that the unfruitful will lose what they have.
- John 15:5
I am the vine, ye are the branches: He that abideth in me, and I in him, the same bringeth forth much fruit: for without me ye can do nothing.
Branches abiding in Christ bring forth much fruit.
- James 2:17
Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
Fruitless faith is dead and faces removal.
- Jeremiah 17:8
For he shall be as a tree planted by the waters, and that spreadeth out her roots by the river, and shall not see when heat cometh, but her leaf shall be green; and shall not be careful in the year of drought, neither shall cease from yielding fruit.
Trust in the Lord is pictured as a tree that continually bears fruit.
- Luke 13:5
I tell you, Nay: but, except ye repent, ye shall all likewise perish.
The warning of perishing unless one repents is repeated after the tower’s fall.
- Mark 4:19
And the cares of this world, and the deceitfulness of riches, and the lusts of other things entering in, choke the word, and it becometh unfruitful.
The deceitfulness of riches can make a response unfruitful.
- Isaiah 27:3
I the LORD do keep it; I will water it every moment: lest any hurt it, I will keep it night and day.
God promises to keep and water His vineyard continually.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
82 sources
In the parable the owner agrees that continued barrenness deserves cutting down, yet the gardener pleads for one more year to dig around the tree and fertilize it with every attention, and if it then bears fruit it is spared, but if not it is to be cut down.HSFM 180.2–37T 200.3–4COL 215.3–216.2ST Jan 6, 1909 The owner and the dresser being one in interest shows the Father and the Son united in love for the chosen people, putting every means of divine love into operation that they might become trees of righteousness bringing forth fruit for the blessing of the world.COL 212.1COL 215.3–216.2 The delay expresses God's patience and long forbearance, but probation is limited and not indefinite, marking one final added opportunity after which the fruitless tree as a cumberer of the ground is removed in ultimate separation from Christ.7T 200.3–4Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3Ms 11, 1902, par. 1–2 The fruitless fig tree is the Jewish nation richly blessed yet lacking righteousness, whose three years are Christ's own three-year personal ministry searching for fruit as their last trial, and whose continued rejection sealed its doom in terrible destruction.HSFM 180.2–3ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 18954SP 19.2–20.1GC88 20.1 The warning reaches beyond the Jews to all churches and Christians with great advantages who bear no fruit, for God expects returns proportionate to gifts and light in holy character and works that bless others, and mere profession, membership, or leaves without a living connection to Christ will not suffice.7T 200.3–4Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3HSFM 180.64SP 419.2HSFM 180.4
Parable Words and Plot
The dresser does not dispute the sentence that continued barrenness should end in cutting down, yet he pleads for one more year to dig about the tree and fertilize it.COL 215.3–216.2ST Jan 6, 1909 That plea is willingness to minister to a most unpromising plant with still greater care, making its surroundings most favorable and lavishing every attention upon it.COL 215.3–216.2ST Jan 6, 1909 There is no greater joy to him than its growth and fruitfulness, and he shares the owner's desire that it should bear fruit and provides every opportunity for growth.COL 215.3–216.2ST Jan 6, 1909ST Jan 6, 1909 The patience has a limit, for the tree is spared for a further time to receive care and bear fruit, but if it remains fruitless it will be cut down.ST Jan 6, 1909ST Jan 6, 1909
The owner and the dresser being one in interest means the Father and the Son were one in love for the chosen people.COL 215.3–216.2 Increased opportunities would therefore be given them, with every means that divine love could devise put in operation that they might become trees of righteousness bringing forth fruit for the blessing of the world.COL 215.3–216.2 The outcome is conditional: if the tree bears fruit during the additional time granted under special care, well, it is spared and may remain; if it still bears none after that time, it is to be cut down.HSFM 180.2–37T 200.3–4ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895Lt 74, 1897, par. 1 That final opportunity follows gracious renewal of mercy and tending, yet continued failure to bear fruit after such care brings judgment as a cumberer cut down.HSFM 180.2–3Lt 74, 1897, par. 1GC88 20.1
Jesus left the result of that work untold and placed the conclusion with the generation hearing Him.ST Jan 6, 1909COL 216.3 To them the warning was solemnly given that continued fruitlessness would bring cutting down, and it rested on them by their response whether the irrevocable sentence would fall and the warning of destruction be fulfilled.ST Jan 6, 1909COL 216.3 The verse thus links the warning of judgment with the invitation of mercy.COL 212.1 It illustrates the mission of mercy in its relation to justice and judgment, that He came not to destroy lives but to save them and not to condemn the world but to save it.COL 212.1
The verse belongs to the warning of the coming kingdom that sharply rebukes ignorance and indifference.COL 212.2 People were quick to read the signs in the sky that foretell the weather, but they did not discern the signs of the times that clearly pointed to His mission.COL 212.2 The image of a tree that bears no fruit is among the works of nature used to impress divine truths on hearers, so that seeing such things afterward could bring the lessons back to mind.RH Jul 25, 1871
Probation Ends in Judgment
Christ intercedes for the unfruitful person, asking that judgment be held back so more time may be given for truth to impress the heart and for light to reach the soul unto fruitfulness.Lt 10, 1881, par. 82T 421.14T 188.3–190.1 That added time with added care is granted to one who has received much light and many opportunities yet has neglected warnings and failed to change, as a further chance to heed the Spirit, reform, and become fruitful.Lt 10, 1881, par. 82T 421.14T 188.3–190.1 If the person still refuses and remains unfruitful, the opportunity ends and the tree is cut down.Lt 10, 1881, par. 82T 421.14T 188.3–190.1
The delay expresses divine patience and long forbearance, but it is not an indefinite exemption from judgment.7T 200.3–4Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3Lt 10, 1871, par. 2–3 The fruitless tree is given one final added period of care and testing, year after year, with continual encounters of such cases, and if it bears fruit during that time it may remain, while if it still bears none it is to be cut down as a cumberer of the ground.7T 200.3–4Ms 11, 1902, par. 1–2ST Nov 21, 1895Lt 10, 1871, par. 2–3DA 584.2 Continued patience is therefore opportunity to change, not reason for indifference.ST Nov 21, 1895Lt 10, 1871, par. 2–3 The words after that mark the close of forbearance and mean ultimate and complete separation from Christ, like a dead branch severed from the vine, a separation already begun in the heart years before.Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3 The outcome is not predetermined, but is decided by response to the care and blessings given, so that nothing can save from destruction one who fails to profit from them.Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3DA 584.2
If a heart keeps refusing to respond to divine agencies it becomes hardened until it can no longer be influenced by the Holy Spirit, and then the decision is made to remove the fruitless tree for uselessly occupying the ground.COL 218.2ST Jan 6, 1909 The tree is spared for a further time to receive care and bear fruit, showing mercy and labor for those who have not responded, but that patience has a limit and judgment follows hardened fruitlessness.COL 218.2ST Jan 6, 1909 God seeks to bring the unfruitful to repentance and to the Saviour through repeated warnings and through trouble, loss, misfortune and affliction.YGBCOEP 39.1–2STB 318.1–2Lt 124, 1902, par. 13–14 If these measures do not turn the wrongdoer to the Saviour, divine patience does not continue indefinitely and the fruitless tree is finally cut down.YGBCOEP 39.1–2STB 318.1–2Lt 124, 1902, par. 13–14
The mandate to cut down the unfruitful tree for cumbering the ground may go forth at any moment against a life that bears no fruit, especially one standing in rebellion in refusing to keep the commandments.Lt 15, 1899, par. 9–11 Such a life is uncertain, and disease or accident or death may suddenly cut it off while unready, leaving the soul lost.Lt 15, 1899, par. 9–11 Satan is the destroyer, and suffering and misery belong to his ranks.Lt 15, 1899, par. 9–11 God bears long with perversity and gives more than one test and trial, but if there is no repentance and confession to God and no restitution for robbery and neglect, the mandate will at last go forth.Lt 35, 1896, par. 8–11 The cutting down is a judgment in which all neglect, selfishness and cruelty toward a suffering wife, who is Christ's property bought with His blood, appears against the sinner in the books of heaven, because what is done to her is done to Christ.Lt 35, 1896, par. 8–11
Israel's Visitation and Fall
The fruitless fig tree is the Jewish nation, a people richly blessed and tested by God yet lacking the fruits of righteousness, given one final opportunity under special care and, if still fruitless, to be cut down.HSFM 180.2–3ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895Ms 13, 1892, par. 29–31GC88 20.1 The three years of seeking fruit are Christ's own three-year personal ministry among them, coming Himself after servants and prophets had been rejected.HSFM 180.2–3ST Nov 21, 18954SP 19.2–20.121MR 166.3–5Lt 317a, 1905, par. 14–18 That ministry worked unselfishly in teaching and healing and forgiving, in pleading for admittance and scattering blessings and calling people to Him.4SP 19.2–20.121MR 166.3–5Lt 317a, 1905, par. 14–18 It was their last trial and further period of mercy, with continued labor showing both the opportunity granted and the consequence of failing to respond.HSFM 180.2–3ST Nov 21, 18954SP 19.2–20.1
His presence among them was a day of opportunity and merciful visitation.ST Nov 21, 1895COL 216.3 But their unbelief and rejection were making them hardened and impenitent, and their fruitless religion hindered rather than helped.ST Nov 21, 1895 The day of wrath was near, and the calamities already fallen upon Israel were merciful forewarnings from the owner of the vineyard of the destruction coming upon the unfruitful tree.COL 216.3 If they continued to reject counsel and reproof they would perish through the results of their own choices.ST Nov 21, 1895COL 216.34SP 19.2–20.1
Continued refusal to respond ended the reprieve and brought judgment, fulfilled in the terrible destruction of the nation and the ending of its favored standing.HSFM 180.2–34SP 19.2–20.1GC88 20.1Lt 317a, 1905, par. 14–18 By rejecting light and warnings and entreaties and bringing dishonor to God, the city sealed its own doom and forged its own fetters and loaded its own cloud of wrath.21MR 166.3–5 So the things belonging to its peace became hid from its eyes and terrible retribution became inevitable.21MR 166.3–5 Refusal was willful, not inability, while waves of mercy beaten back by indifference and contempt and rejection returned again and again to break rocky hearts.21MR 166.3–5 After the Son had searched for fruit and found none, continued rejection of mercy and refusal of the light and evidence already given brought the sentence of removal and left it irrevocable.Ms 13, 1892, par. 29–31
The outcome was not predetermined, for the tree is the people addressed by Christ, whose response to the care and blessings given them determines their destiny.DA 584.2 Christ's later cursing of the barren fig tree showed that they had chosen destruction by failing to profit from those blessings, so that nothing could save it from destruction.DA 584.2 The same pattern is now the individual's day and opportunity to repent and obey before the irrevocable sentence is uttered.21MR 166.3–5
What Fruit Means
God expects fruit from those He has planted and tenderly cared for, with returns proportionate to gifts, care, light and sacred privilege, so that greater blessings require greater return.HSFM 180.4HSFM 180.57T 200.5–201.25T 423.1Lt 13, 1878, par. 9 Merely avoiding wrong acts is not enough, for people are accountable not only for wrong done but for good neglected, and neglected good makes them cumberers of the ground.4SP 419.2RH Jan 10, 1907 His searching gaze examines heart and life, and that inspection concerns both duty and destiny.5T 423.1 Even those who have slighted mercy and abused grace are not beyond hope while His long-suffering love still pleads with them.RH Jan 10, 1907
The fruit He claims is a pure and holy character shown in spiritual growth after Christ's perfect model, obedient to all the Father's requirements and to the precepts of the holy law.HSFM 180.45T 250.2 It is godliness, self-denial for others' good, meekness and loveliness of heart, with penitence, faith and obedience in saying and doing.HSFM 180.4ST Jul 21, 1909 It is the fruit of righteousness, with righteousness, peace and joy, and spiritual virtue in workers that contributes to saving souls for eternal life.5T 250.2Lt 71, 1903, par. 9–12Lt 73, 1903, par. 7–8Lt 120, 1907, par. 1–2 The disappointment of the parable is finding only leaves despite continued care.5T 250.2
Bearing fruit after years in the Lord's garden means bringing profit to the Master under God's inspecting eye.HSFM 181.1 It means increasing in reverence, love, humility, confidence in God and gratitude for His mercies, and seeking to bless those around.HSFM 181.1 It means manifesting the spirit of Jesus in the family, teaching His word to children and making known the wonderful works of God, and both being good and doing good.HSFM 181.1 Then a fragrance about the life and loveliness of character reveal a child of God and an heir of heaven.HSFM 181.1
The fruit expected is works corresponding to faith, for profession of faith alone will not suffice.Lt 13, 1878, par. 9 It is laboring for God and letting received light and truth shine to others.Lt 13, 1878, par. 9 It is caring for people around, warning them about sin, and praying and laboring to lead them to truth and righteousness, for the truly converted are not indifferent to others' salvation.Lt 13, 1878, par. 10 It is letting God's light reach others through good works and using time, influence, ability and money in His service to bring truth to people in darkness, with souls won as something to show for labor.Lt 218, 1901, par. 7
Fruit means a changed response rather than continued transgression.ST Nov 21, 1895 It is a heart surrendered to God, obedience to His will, love for the Saviour and for those for whom He died, and a life showing the restoring influence of the Redeemer.ST Sep 12, 1900 If the tree bears such fruit after added care it is spared, but persisting in refusal brings being cut down and perishing.ST Nov 21, 1895
Receiving the gospel, church membership, profession of faith including professed sanctification, and God's gifts and care do not suffice without a living connection to Christ and the fruits of the Spirit.RH Feb 18, 1909COL 216.4–217.14T 614.1Lt 50, 1878, par. 4 A claim to righteousness without a changed life is only leaves despite continued care.RH Feb 18, 19095T 250.2 The tide of His life does not flow through such a one, and the sweet graces of His character are not seen, so gifts that produce no good for others leave them without blessings and privileges they and others might otherwise receive, convey no blessing to the world, darken the ground so fruitful plants cannot flourish, and rob others of privileges.COL 216.4–217.1 A profession of truth without that living connection shows no practical godliness or love of God, and unless a thorough work is done, judgment comes as upon the fruitless tree.4T 614.1Lt 50, 1878, par. 45T 423.1 Hypocritical profession is more hopeless than open sin.ST Aug 22, 1878
Fruitlessness is living only for self, planning and studying to please self and gathering only for self, out of touch with humanity.ST Jul 21, 1909 It makes every pretension like the fig tree in full leaf, observing forms of worship and professing in words to honor God's law while obedience is lacking.ST Jul 21, 1909 No one can live God's law without ministering to others, and one who professes to serve God but bears no fruit to His glory is more guilty than the open sinner.ST Jul 21, 1909 Such are urged to become fruit bearers by doing duty and the works of Christ, denying self and taking up the cross daily.ST Aug 22, 1878
Fruitlessness keeps hoping to grow better someday without advancing a step.ST Oct 24, 1900Lt 16, 1879, par. 2–3 It dishonors Bible religion by lowering its standard to fit low attainments, receives mercies as a matter of course, and fails to prepare against Satan's assaults and to meet the attacks of the enemy.ST Oct 24, 1900ST Sep 12, 1900 It fails to engage in constant warfare against selfishness and pride of the heart and the inclinations of the natural heart, and fails to crucify self and deny self daily.ST Oct 24, 1900ST Sep 12, 1900 It fails to feed the hunger of the soul from God's Word and to search the Scriptures where Christ is testified of, leaving the soul weak, strengthless and unable to do God's will, changing nothing from consumer to provider.ST Jun 26, 1901Ms 148, 1899, par. 28 Its bitter and profitless fruit misrepresents Christ and gives no religious benefit to the world, presenting a distorted worldly religion that molds others to a low standard through self-love, pleasure-seeking, amusement, weakness and instability, so that the world is made no better by such living and they become unusable in His cause.Lt 12a, 1893, par. 35–36 Mere profession and passive hope do not constitute Christianity, for Christ's followers must grow, deny self, endure hardship, and resist sin and Satan while laboring to save others.Lt 16, 1879, par. 2–3
A show of leaves without fruit does not satisfy Christ when He finds no practical godliness or love of God.Lt 50, 1878, par. 4 The leaves picture people who have received much light, mercy, patience and care but do not produce what He seeks, and they are urged to trust Him and respond while He is still patient.Lt 36, 1876, par. 15Ms 9, 1880, par. 37–42 Christ searches institutions for spiritual virtue that saves souls, and leaves without fruit reflect the barren condition He found.Lt 120, 1907, par. 1–2 The unrepentant pretender so entreated and borne with yet remaining defiled is blighted and faces judgment as doomed, a sign of avenging wrath.Ms 9, 1880, par. 37–42
Warning and Call Today
The warning reaches beyond the Jews to all who neglect to improve Heaven's gifts, a warning for all time to all churches and to all Christians.HSFM 180.4ST Jul 21, 1909 It presses especially on those given great advantages and sacred responsibilities who still bear no fruit, who will be removed as unproductive burdens, for probation has an end and the delay expresses patience, not indefinite exemption.7T 200.3–4Ms 7, 1897, par. 2–3 Some are even now receiving the last trial, having been granted divine illumination, the example of perfect goodness, and new opportunities and lessons from time to time, and if they remain careless and neglectful they do not know how soon the word will be spoken against them to cut them down.HSFM 180.6 The fruit required is a pure and holy character — godliness, self-denial for others' good, meekness and loveliness of heart, with penitence, faith and obedience after a perfect model of obedience to all requirements.HSFM 180.4 Fruitlessness is living only for self, planning and studying to please self and gathering only for self, out of touch with humanity, making every pretension like the fig tree in full leaf while observing forms of worship and professing in words to honor the law while obedience is lacking, and no one can live that law without ministering to others, so that the professor who bears no fruit to His glory is more guilty than the open sinner.ST Jul 21, 1909
The fruitless one has long received His gifts, planted in His vineyard under the gardener's watchful care, with the tender gospel message thrilling the heart, taking Christ's name and outwardly a church member which is His body, yet with no living connection with the great heart of love. The tide of His life does not flow through such a one, and the sweet graces of His character, the fruits of the Spirit, are not seen in the life. Like the barren tree receiving rain and sunshine and care and drawing nourishment from the soil, yet with unproductive boughs only darkening the ground so fruitful plants cannot flourish in its shadow, the gifts lavished on the fruitless professor convey no blessing to the world and rob others of privileges that might otherwise be theirs.ST Aug 22, 1878RH Apr 30, 1901 Such do-nothings ignoring work and personal responsibility only cumber the ground, taking up ground and shade that could serve fruitful trees, and failing to show living faith with works stands as a mournful record, even a mournful blank, against their names in the book of heaven.ST Aug 22, 1878Lt 77a, 1897, par. 3Lt 93, 1892, par. 31 Christ has given a work to every church member, not to ministers and officials only, and bearing fruit is doing that assigned spiritual work, while indolent neglect leaves the record blank and brings the doom of being cut down after long watching and waiting for a return of love.Lt 93, 1892, par. 31
Church members who do no missionary work are the fruitless fig tree under sentence to be cut down.Ms 151, 1897, par. 19–20 Bearing fruit is voicing the truth from God's messengers, catching the first rays of light and diffusing the same, using talents in every way possible to make the ministry a power and get the knowledge of truth before thousands who would discern the evidence.Ms 151, 1897, par. 19–20 Failure is a do-nothing position of sinful neglect to use God-given talents, slothfulness and idleness that leaves His people years behind, with not one hundredth part done of what is required.Ms 151, 1897, par. 19–20Lt 35, 1895, par. 14–16 In the great day the unfruitful will be self-convicted and self-condemned for that slothfulness unless they see themselves as that tree, come to self-penitence, and seek forgiveness.Ms 151, 1897, par. 19–20STMW7 62.2Lt 35, 1895, par. 14–16
The figure applies to the Conferences, from which fruit had been looked for for more than two years, since He expects fruit from those He has planted and tenderly cared for, the fruit of righteousness shown in spiritual growth, with disappointment when only leaves are found despite continued care.5T 250.2 It applies to churches bearing no fruit, which face removal.Lt 82, 1895, par. 14 It applies to the church in its present condition when the love of God is lost and love for one another is absent, where self cherished and striving for supremacy bring selfishness and much human working with little pure grace in the heart, so that unless there is reconversion and repentance there will be lack of godliness and sure bearing of evil fruit, a name to live while virtually dead, and the candlestick removed because His Spirit will not always strive.Lt 80, 1901, par. 12 It applies to laborers in the Office and publishing work, who are called to consecrate themselves to Him and center their affections and hopes in Him lest the fruitless be cut down.3T 191.2TBC1872 20.2STPW 15.1
The image applies to ministers who stir interest in the truth but fail to complete their work: they are given a further test, and if unfaithful are set aside as cumberers of the ground, while those who accept the truth are to bear fruit to God's glory through daily self-sacrifice and obedience.4T 317.2 A gospel worker who wins no souls to Christ shows the fruitless tree, for fruit means souls won with something to show for labor, proved by looking after workers in different places to see the result.Lt 218, 1901, par. 7 Such a tree may need transplanting to another field, and if after proper labor it still bears nothing it is to be cut down by dismissal as an unprofitable servant in soul-saving.Lt 218, 1901, par. 7 The one removed should go into business to earn means to sustain successful laborers, persons of tact and wisdom who in the fear of God win souls, so the cost of working the vineyard is kept low while a large territory is worked.Lt 218, 1901, par. 7
The verse warns the covetous that opportunity to turn will not last without earnest repentance and decisive change, the unfruitful tree being given only a little more time before it is cut down.3T 544.3 It shows disobeyers of the commandments as cumberers of the ground who are not immediately destroyed, and whose religious lives can be reformed when enlightened and accepting the invitation to obey.Ms 52, 1900, par. 36 Pursuing worldly gain while neglecting God and spiritual life ends in being cut down, which is being lost eternally.1MR 218.2–219.2 A life destitute of spiritual fruit is like that tree and needs converting power with penitence and humility, or it will not enter the kingdom.Lt 37, 1879, par. 8 One given time to change who remains unproductive and faultfinding must bring good fruit into the home lest he be cut off, and the wrongdoer going on in heedless indifference will be cut down like a cumberer unless plain reproof and counsel warn him, for those who receive care and reproof yet fail to produce expected fruit defraud Him.Lt 49, 1905, par. 2Ms 174, 1897, par. 44
During the added probation Christ ministers with unwearied love, and with increased keeping and watering continually all that heaven can give is bestowed. Even those who have slighted mercy and abused grace are not beyond hope, because long-suffering love still pleads and invites return, healing of backsliding, growth, and fruit received from Him.RH Jan 10, 1907 The added time is opportunity to cherish received light, trust Him and respond while He is patient, turn from selfish pleasure to useful self-denying work for others' good and God's glory, and do the daily opportunities and assigned spiritual work given to every member.9T 129.3ST Jul 3, 1879Lt 46a, 1874, par. 31–34 Doing that work develops abilities and helps bear fruit, while neglect leaves withered fruitlessness; mere avoiding of wrong does not meet the expectation, for neglected good makes a cumberer and brings accountability.RH Jan 10, 19079T 129.3 Mere profession and passive hope are not Christianity: followers must grow, deny self, endure hardship, resist sin and Satan, search the Scriptures where Christ is testified of, seek the Lord earnestly and apply His promises, changing consumers into providers.Lt 16, 1879, par. 2–3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
78 sources
If it bears fruit after further care it is allowed to remain, and if it still bears nothing it is cut down.ST Jul 16, 1894ST Dec 25, 1901ST Dec 25, 1901 The added year of digging and fertilizing shows God's long-suffering in coming again and again seeking fruit, yet that mercy has a limit and must be improved before it ends.ST Nov 21, 1895RH May 16, 1912RH May 13, 1862RH Oct 7, 1902ST Mar 9, 1882 The tree is the Jewish nation tested by God and granted one last season of mercy in Christ's presence and work, required to bring forth repentance and faith but hardened in unbelief and rejection.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895 The fruit required is righteous living in return for blessing, obedience through grace, unselfish service to others, and a changed life bearing the works of Christ and the fruits of the Spirit.ST Oct 24, 1900ST Apr 18, 1878ST Jan 18, 1899RH Nov 30, 1911ST Jul 1, 1875 The present life is therefore granted time to turn from fruitless profession and neglect, to bear fruit and live, lest remaining fruitless bring destruction and removal.RH May 13, 1862RH May 16, 1912RH Mar 5, 1857RH Aug 21, 1900
Parable Words and Setting
The continued standing of the tree is made conditional on what happens next: if it bears fruit after further care it is allowed to remain, and if it remains fruitless it is to be cut down.ST Jul 16, 1894ST Dec 25, 1901ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jan 18, 1899RH Apr 2, 1908 Fruitfulness is the condition for preservation and barrenness the ground for removal, so that bearing fruit spares the tree while continued fruitlessness ends in its cutting down.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jan 18, 1899ST Jul 16, 1894 The final year of special care is a last period of respite before judgment, closing a longer period of cultivation and testing whether the tree will at last respond.RH Apr 2, 1908ST Jul 16, 1894
For that decision the tree is granted one more year, a further season of care in hope it will yet bear fruit.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Jul 16, 1894RH May 13, 1862RH Jul 25, 1871 That year brings digging around it and fertilizing it, the most favorable surroundings and every attention, with nothing giving greater joy than its growth and fruitfulness. The delay is not the end of judgment but a final opportunity, expressing patience and hope that leaves and strength alone will give place to fruit.ST Apr 18, 1878RH Jul 25, 1871 Continued opportunity of this kind is not unlimited, and calls for humble prayer and earnest effort to bring forth fruit before it ends.RH May 13, 1862
Within the parable the owner demands removal while the gardener pleads for delay, agreeing that continued fruitlessness deserves cutting down yet asking for more time.ST Apr 18, 1878 The Son pleads with anxious tenderness for the unfruitful to be spared another year, longing to replace even a dead heart with perfect soundness if the channel is opened for the life-giving stream of love to flow through to the perishing.RH Oct 22, 1872RH Oct 22, 1872RH Jul 1, 1902 Owner and gardener share the desire for fruit, and the gardener provides every opportunity for growth.ST Jan 6, 1909 Jesus left the result of that work untold, leaving the conclusion with the generation hearing him, so that it rested on them by their response whether the irrevocable sentence would fall.ST Jan 6, 1909
The three years of seeking fruit and the continued labor, with the additional year of care, form a period of special cultivation followed by a final year before judgment.ST Nov 21, 1895RH Apr 2, 1908 The later cursing of the fig tree and its immediate withering, shortly before the passion, declares that the year of respite has ended and its doom is fixed.RH Apr 2, 1908
The fruitless tree is a cumberer of the ground, occupying a valuable place that has been tended for years yet producing nothing in return.RH Oct 22, 1872 Like a barren tree receiving rain and sunshine and the gardener's care and drawing nourishment from the soil, its unproductive boughs only darken the ground so that fruit-bearing plants cannot flourish in its shadow.ST Aug 22, 1878RH Apr 30, 1901 It absorbs strength and sustenance of the soil that fruitful trees would otherwise use, conveying no blessing to the world and robbing others of privileges that might otherwise be theirs.ST Sep 12, 1900 Even the busiest and most stately and luxuriant growth is evil where it stands if it bears no fruit, since usefulness alone gives value to activity.ST Sep 12, 1900
Forbearance and Final Judgment
The delay before cutting down is God's long-suffering, for His mercy has continued in the past, continues in the present, and extends into the future to give time for fruit to appear.RH May 16, 1912RH Oct 7, 1902ST Mar 9, 1882ST Jul 22, 1886RH Aug 30, 1870 He comes again and again seeking fruit, waiting and pleading with Israel, with Judah, and with individuals before judgment falls, even when they have been unfaithful to light given and no fruit is found.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 22, 1886RH Aug 30, 1870 Stern justice demands that the fruitless be cut down, but mercy pleads for probation to be lengthened rather than bringing judgment at once.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 22, 1886RH Aug 30, 1870 That patience is reason to keep laboring and hoping for the restoration of one who has gone wrong.ST Mar 9, 1882
Every time life is spared it is grace giving more time, and the present life still possessed is that granted time.RH May 16, 1912 It is to be used to respond to the call of divine providence and to prove that the gospel has not been received in vain.RH May 16, 1912
That patience has a limit, for continued opportunity is not unlimited and does not mean the opportunity lasts forever.RH May 16, 1912RH May 13, 1862RH Aug 30, 1870 The tree is given a further season with special care so it may yet bear fruit, but if it remains fruitless after that care and further period of mercy it will be cut down, so the time granted must be improved before it ends.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Jan 6, 1909RH Feb 13, 1900RH May 16, 1912RH May 13, 1862 A heart that becomes hardened and no longer responds to the Holy Spirit brings that judgment upon itself, and profession of faith without good works does not avert it.ST Jan 6, 1909RH Feb 13, 1900ST Oct 4, 1899
To be cut down is to be cut off, removed, and destroyed, even by fire as a dead branch without fruit, picturing annihilation without remedy rather than torment.RH May 22, 1913RH Oct 18, 1864ST Jan 17, 1900 Fire is an emblem of destruction, not of continued torture in sin and misery, so the doom of the incorrigible is everlasting destruction and the perfected kingdom remains in undimmed glory.ST Jan 17, 1900 Mercy in granting time to repent is a plea for the sinner to change and bear fruit, not a promise of pardon without repentance, and those who refuse mercy and do not repent will finally perish.RH Oct 18, 1864
Unlike the wheat and tares left together until harvest, the barren fig tree warns that what bears no good fruit will be removed to make room for righteousness to grow and bear fruit.ST Dec 15, 1887
Israel and Prophetic Fulfillment
The barren tree is the Jewish nation, tested by God and granted a day of visitation and a final period of care and opportunity to bear fruit.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Feb 16, 1882ST Aug 4, 1881 That last mercy was the time of Jesus' presence and work among them, including three years of searching for fruit and continued labor in their behalf.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Feb 16, 1882ST Aug 4, 1881 The fruit required was repentance and faith expressed in a changed response instead of continued transgression.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Feb 16, 1882 But the nation lacked that fruit, rejected warnings, counsel and reproof, and its unbelief and rejection of him made it hardened and impenitent, with a fruitless religion that hindered rather than helped.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Feb 16, 1882
If the nation continued in sin and rejected him it would be destroyed as a people, perishing through the results of its own choices.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Nov 21, 1895ST Feb 16, 1882 After God had borne with the Jews for many years, the time had come when it was right to pronounce that judgment of sparing if fruitful and cutting down if still fruitless.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Oct 4, 1899 The day of wrath was near, and calamities already fallen on Israel were merciful forewarnings from the owner of the vineyard of the destruction awaiting the unfruitful tree.
During that added probation Christ ministers with unwearied love, with all that heaven can give bestowed and with care not lessened but increased in continual keeping and watering. A fruitful response preserves life, but a heart that does not respond to divine agencies becomes hardened until it is no longer susceptible to the influence of the Holy Spirit, and then the sentence of removal is pronounced. Even now return is still invited, with healing of backsliding, growth, and fruit received from God. The same warning applies to professed Christians who claim greater light and truth but do not fulfill the purpose for which they were made, for all who fail to live up to that purpose will ultimately be removed.ST Oct 4, 1899ST Oct 4, 1899
Meaning of Fruit
Fruit is the righteous life rightly expected in return for blessing, including righteous dealing with others, gratitude and obedience, and conduct worthy of repentance, for works in the judgment reveal whether there has been obedience through grace and mere profession without a changed life is not fruitful.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Jan 18, 1899ST Jul 1, 1875RH Jun 24, 1875 Obedience produced through grace, not profession alone, is what keeps the tree in its place, since continuance is conditional on bearing fruit and continued fruitlessness brings destruction.ST Apr 18, 1878ST Jul 1, 1875RH Jun 24, 1875
Fruit is unselfish service, living a merciful unselfish life and helping fellow men in every possible way, with repentance and faith and obedience to the law in word and deed.ST Jul 21, 1909 It is shown in returns for labor, in souls brought to God, churches established, multiplied conversions and a vigorous growing work, which should be even greater under the same commission and gospel with the promise of the Spirit and the added weight of fulfilled prophecy and nearness of coming.RH Nov 30, 1911 It is bringing others to Jesus by naming some person outside one's own relatives to win, uniting in prayer for those named, doing missionary work suited to age and place, and becoming better workers, in contrast to branches withered and dry.RH Nov 12, 1914 A Christian must of necessity bring forth much fruit by making other Christians through soul-winning, for a soul-winningless Christian is a contradiction like fire that does not warm or flame that does not light.
Fruit is a changed life of duty and the works of Christ, denying self and taking up the cross daily.ST Aug 22, 1878 It is a heart surrendered to God, obedience to His will, love for the Saviour and for those for whom He died, and a life showing the restoring influence of the Redeemer.ST Sep 12, 1900 It is letting light reach others through good works and using time, influence, ability and money in service to bring truth to those in darkness, with Christian love as the fruit expected. Mere profession is not Christianity, and claim to righteousness without such changed life does not suffice, for the gospel's saving power must be shown in fruit-bearing lives including the work of teaching and caring for others.RH Feb 18, 1909ST Oct 24, 1900
The tree pictures a life receiving light, blessings and care yet producing no good fruit, an aimless unproductive life of leaves alone, which cannot remain fruitless indefinitely.ST Apr 29, 1875RH Jan 6, 1874 Good works and blessings to others are the fruit intended, while leaves alone are aimlessness, and the extra season is opportunity to turn from aimless ways and through faith learn from Christ and bring forth fruit to God.ST Apr 29, 1875RH Jan 6, 1874
Fruitlessness is outward profession and leaves without fruit, an outwardly fair show, full leaf, forms of worship and words honoring the law while obedience is lacking.ST Jul 21, 1909RH Oct 22, 1872RH Oct 22, 1872 It is perfect fruit withheld, with earnest deeds replaced by idle words, unkept promises, hatred, strife and battle, a wasted misspent life of withered leaves sowing tares and weeds and reaping with toil and pain that grieves the Spirit and at last stands humble and mute to be spared if there is fruit or cut down if there is nothing but leaves.RH Sep 1, 1859 Fruit shows whether profession is living, and despite patient care and cultivation continued fruitlessness brings judgment and removal, for the Son pleads for more time yet grace is limited and a fair profession without a changed life ends in judgment.RH Oct 22, 1872RH Oct 22, 1872ST Jul 16, 1885 Such hypocritical profession is more hopeless than open sin, and cutting down a tree His own power had created shows how hateful vain pretense is.ST Aug 22, 1878ST Jul 21, 1909ST Jul 1, 1875
Fruitlessness is neglect of responsibility and work for God, producing no usefulness in His cause.ST Aug 22, 1878RH Apr 30, 1901 Even the busiest activity without usefulness is cumbering, for usefulness alone gives value to activity, and the fruitless tree however beautiful, stately and luxuriant absorbs strength and sustenance of soil that fruitful trees would otherwise use, so the humblest effort accomplishing some good outweighs the greatest show of energy serving no worthy purpose.ST Sep 12, 1900 Like a barren tree receiving rain, sunshine and the gardener's care and drawing nourishment from the soil yet with unproductive boughs only darkening ground so fruit-bearing plants cannot flourish in its shadow, gifts lavished on the fruitless professor convey no blessing to the world and rob others of privileges that might otherwise be theirs, after long watching and waiting for a return of love. It is hoarding for self what was freely given — the system of truth, this world's goods, and mental powers — keeping truth from mankind, using wealth selfishly and spending ability on own lusts instead of giving freely and being rich toward God, which brings just reward in loss of even what was kept.RH Jan 16, 1900
Merely avoiding wrong acts does not meet the expectation, for neglected good makes one a cumberer and brings accountability, though even those slighting mercy and abusing grace are not yet beyond hope while long-suffering love still pleads.RH Jan 10, 1907 Hoping to grow better someday without advancing a step, dishonoring Bible religion by lowering its standard to fit low attainments, receiving mercies as a matter of course, failing to crucify self and to wage constant warfare against selfishness, pride and inclinations of the natural heart, and failing to prepare against assaults of the enemy leaves the soul barren.ST Oct 24, 1900ST Sep 12, 1900 Being content with doing no wrong is a deadly peril, and a life lacking spiritual nourishment from the Word is left weak and unable to do God's will.ST Jun 26, 1901
Genuine faith bears fruit in works, though works themselves do not justify, and a life without the fruit of faith will not always be suffered to cumber the ground.ST May 13, 1897
Call to Fruitful Living
The present hour is a last call of mercy before each person's course is fixed, when the Lord hears those who humble and afflict themselves before Him, shows mercy, and brings them out of distress.RH Oct 30, 1856 Judgment for fruitlessness has not yet fallen, mercy is still extended, and there is time to heed counsel, turn from sin, and receive Christ.RH Feb 12, 1857 The opportunity to bear fruit will not last forever, for if there is no fruit the tree is cut down, so those resisting the Saviour's calls must turn to the Lord before patience ends and it is too late.
The church is a vineyard containing fruitless trees despite great labor, yet given a little more time and a final period of opportunity to repent, forsake sin, and faithfully serve God.RH Mar 5, 1857RH Aug 21, 1900 If it bears fruit it may live, but if it remains lukewarm and fruitless it will be cut off and lost.RH Mar 5, 1857 That warning of cutting down after care and waiting is meant to lead to repentance before it is too late.RH Aug 21, 1900
The warning is to be taken personally, for the further season and care are given so fruit may be brought forth, and continued opportunity is not unlimited.RH May 13, 1862 One who feared being cut down if he did not serve the Lord left his hindering business to begin serving God.RH Aug 11, 1903 The barren must examine whether Christ's love moves them to serve, deny self, and work to save others, because probation is passing and coming judgment will reveal whether fruit has been borne.ST Mar 24, 1887 Unfaithfulness spared for a time calls for renewed faithfulness and active labor, since continued unfaithfulness ends in being cut down. Those leaving undone the work given them in the vineyard are that fruitless fig tree, years behind and doing far less than required, and must come to penitence, confess being that tree, and seek forgiveness for not working.RH Apr 13, 1911
Bearing fruit is sharing God's word with hungry souls and doing God's will, made a prayer and pattern for life.ST Mar 10, 1914 It means working for Him by bringing others to Jesus, naming some person outside one's own relatives to win, uniting in prayer for those named, doing missionary work suited to age and place, and becoming better workers for Him, while failure leaves one barren and to be cut down.RH Nov 12, 1914
God expects fruit from those who receive His care, and a claim to righteousness without the fruit of a changed life does not suffice, for the gospel's saving power is to be shown through fruit-bearing lives including the work of those who teach and care for others.RH Feb 18, 1909 Those entrusted with care and opportunity, especially workers, must bear more fruit or be counted a cumberer of the ground facing being cut down.RH Nov 30, 1911 A ministry producing little or no fruit is not according to His mind, for fruit means returns for labor such as souls brought to God, churches established, multiplied conversions, and a growing vigorous work, and those sent with the same commission, the same gospel, the promise of the Holy Spirit, and the added weight of Christ's near coming and fulfilled prophecy should look for even greater results.RH Nov 30, 1911
God expects fruit from every tree planted in His vineyard.RH May 21, 1861 The tree bearing no fruit is among nature's works used to impress divine truths, so that seeing such things later recalls the lesson.RH Jul 25, 1871 A tree may be given time to prove whether it is still alive and capable of bearing fruit rather than being cut down on appearances alone, and its eventual fruitfulness shows the waiting worthwhile, though if it remains fruitless it may then be cut down as a cumberer.RH Apr 15, 1873
One whose past failures deserved being cut off as a cumberer may yet be spared rather than cut down immediately, receiving further opportunity to serve.RH Jan 14, 1858 What is needed from God is mercy, not justice, since justice would long ago have cut down fruitless trees cumbering the ground, and those forgiven a debt against God they could never pay must therefore forgive the small offenses of others against them.RH Sep 17, 1901
The barren life in God's service is called to prompt faithfulness to trust received rather than continuing to take up ground without bearing fruit, for time may be given but remaining fruitless ends in being cut down.ST Mar 20, 1901 Those living in disobedience to God's commandments are in danger of being cut down as cumberers of the ground, yet when enlightened and reformed in religious life they are spared that fate. Those whose lives produce no good works, with sickly faith and lack of heart-holiness despite great privileges and opportunities, must cherish the light received and make determined efforts to grow or face being cut down.ST Jul 3, 1879
Patience and Church Discipline
The delay of judgment is long-suffering that gives time for fruit to appear, and therefore those who have gone wrong are not to be given up too soon but to be hoped for still, dealt with by means and prayer rather than treated as incorrigible and abandoned.ST Mar 9, 1882RH Apr 25, 1871 Erring believers are to be labored with wisely for repentance and restoration, with prayer and renewed effort that may gain them more time to change, and with love, forbearance and humility that may lead them to repentance.RH Jun 24, 1873 Even when the end remains that the fruitless tree will be cut down if it still bears nothing, the further time and care first granted make patience the rule.ST Mar 9, 1882RH Apr 25, 1871RH Jun 24, 1873
Toward souls made suspicious by deceit, stranded in doubt, desponding, obstinate and wedded to sin, there is infinite patience that does not crush by imperious authority, exasperate by taunts, or at once fling aside as useless, but waits in long-suffering hope of conquering the soul.ST Mar 18, 1913 Time is given to recover and opportunity to know self, with nursing by gentleness, gaining of confidence, and finding of the secret of weakness and sorrow, because the soul may yet bear fruit next year.ST Mar 18, 1913 This patience rebukes cynical criticism and passionate haste, requiring that temperaments, troubles, habits, provocations and prejudices be taken into account in judging men, and it underlies patient cultivation of people in the Lord's vineyard until growth matures them and prepares them for service.ST Mar 18, 1913RH Aug 21, 1913
As a carefully tended tree may be spared when it bears even a little fruit, so people are patiently cultivated in order to bring forth fruit in them, while those who bear nothing will ultimately be cut down.ST Jul 16, 1894 Profession alone does not justify remaining as a fruitless member, for members showing no spiritual activity and no spiritual life are first to receive care, training, prayer, patient personal effort and seeking for restoration.ST Apr 16, 1885ST Apr 16, 1885ST Jul 16, 1885 If years bring no change or promise of fruit and those efforts fail, they should be removed from the roll as useless growth is removed from the vineyard, since leaving them in place may keep them deluded about their condition and contribute to the church's spiritual weakness.ST Apr 16, 1885ST Apr 16, 1885ST Jul 16, 1885
The additional year is opportunity for the beginnings of religious life to develop, and when those beginnings are destroyed another year is needed, so that receiving further opportunity is fortunate.RH May 13, 1875 Those who show outward growth but produce no useful fruit are urged to become fruitful before the time of patience ends, for the remaining days are the opportunity and the time granted may be short.RH Feb 16, 1911 Outward appearance is not enough, and what is expected is fruitfulness in righteousness, namely Christian love, on which the tree's future depends whether it bears fruit or is cut down.RH Feb 16, 1911
Sources